China News and Analysis Beta - https://chinanewsupdate.com/ China Update provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. These podcasts are based on hundreds of articles, think tank reports, government statements and other resources in English and Chinese every week. The views and analysis are all my own and I produce the podcasts. My Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/chinaupdate Disclaimer: China Update is not a financial advisory channel. While I take great care in researching everything discussed in these podcasts, nothing I say should be taken as investment advice. Please speak to a professional before making any investment decisions. #China
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Happy THURSDA everybody. Welcome to another episode of China Updates, where we discuss leading political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on the world's number two economy. My name is Tony in New Zealand. Here it is the middle of winter. It is a very cold and rainy day outside. It is good to be warm inside and with you for another day of China Updates. Let's jump in and first up, we begin with the Chinese economy. Beijing's land market remained under heavy pressure in the first half of the year, highlighting continued weakness of China's property sector despite targeted policy
Speaker 1easing and isolated pockets of demand land sales or more specifically land use sales or the auctions for these sales, and the Chinese capital totaled in US dollar terms four point seven billion dollars during the first six months of the year, down sixty six percent from a year earlier, according to data from the China Index Academy published today, and this is after several years of depreciation already. The average land price fell thirty five percent to the equivalent of four thousand, one hundred US dollars per square meter,
Speaker 1while the planned construction areas nearly halved to one point two two million square meters. This is significant Beijing is one of the most in demand housing markets in the country, along with Shanghai, Shanjin and Guangzhou. If Beijing land demand is this week, then the rest of the country is catastrophic, and of course we remember that land is an important source of extra budgetary revenue for local governments. Developers have also become increasingly cautious, with the average auction premium slipping
Speaker 1to three point six percent from seven point two percent a year earlier. Only seven of the twenty one land parcels sold above their reserve prices, while the majority attracted little competition and were purchased at the minimum asking price and les. Developers remain reluctant to commit capital as home by demand has yet to stage a meaningful recovery. Instead, they are focusing almost exclusively on premium sites in central locations, where stronger sales in higher profit margins are more likely.
Speaker 1This has created a two speed market, with most suburban land attracting limited interest while a handful of prime sites continue to generate competitive bidding. Analysts expect the broader market to remain subdued through the second half of the year with fierce competition limited to a small number of high quality urban sites. This crisis is now five years old, and even the capital is seeing plunging demand. It is fearful to think what the rest of the country looks like now. Next up and staying on the economy. Incredibly,
Speaker 1China's top auditor has accused some of the country's largest state backed financial institutions of tax evasion, weak governance, and in proper lending, signaling Bejing's continued efforts to strengthen oversight of its financial system as economic pressures mount, but also just how entrench the issue of tax evasion is in China. And its annual report released to TiO Tuesday, the National Audit Office alleged that the Bank of China avoided two point three seven billion yen three hundred and forty eight million US dollars in taxes by exploiting preferential tax policies
Speaker 1intended for public investment funds between April twenty twenty three and August twenty twenty five. The bank allegedly used two affiliated financial institutions and recruited large numbers of employees as nominal investors, contributing as little as one yan each to disguise eleven private investment funds as public funds eligible for corporate income tax exemptions. The report marks the first time in recent years that a major state owned bank has been explicitly accused of tax evasion by the National auditor.
Speaker 1Agricultural Bank of China was also criticized for inadequate loan screening. Auditors found the bank issued more than eleven billion yanin loans to projects that did not qualify as high standard farmland developments, with some funds later diverted into wealth management products and debt repays. Meanwhile, China Everbride Group was cited for governance failures, including weak oversight of subsidiary and improper use of the Everbright brand. The findings reflect Beijing's growing focus on reducing systemic financial risks as policymakers seek to
Speaker 1stabilize the economy amidst slowing domestic demand, ongoing property sector weakness, and heightened geopolitical tensions with the United States. Bank of China said it would implement the auditor's recommendations and strengthen its compliance. Fairly boiler plates stuff when one is caught with one's hand in the cookie jar. Now next up, we have one more very big development in quite interesting development actually to cover, but as quickly. If you're getting some value from today's episode, as always, as a huge HELPIAF units at the light budon subscribe and there is also a Patreon and buy mac coffee link in the
Speaker 1description below if you'd like to go the extra mild and help me keep China Update financially sustainable. Thank you so much, And finally for today, Europe's concerns about China's economic model are becoming harder to ignore. At last week's European Council Summit and Brussels, EU leaders devoted significant attention to the growing trade imbalance with China, raising concerns about industrial overcapacity and the impact of Chinese exports on European manufacturers. This is a space, of course, we've been following very closely on China Update for several months now, yet despite
Speaker 1increasingly forceful rhetoric, the summit ended with dialogue rather than action. The gap between concern and policy may reveal the central problem facing Europe's China strategy. While many European leaders recognize the scale of the challenge, there remains little appetite for the economic pain a tougher response would likely bring. One of the more striking proposals came from German Chancellor Frederick Mertz, who suggested that international discussions on exchange rates could help address the imbalance. Mertz argued that the Chinese yan is
Speaker 1substantially undervalued, claiming it may be undervalued by as much as thirty percent, and pointed to the nineteen eighty five Plaza record as a possible model. The reference is significant. The original Plaza accord saw the United States, Japan, West Germany, France, and the United Kingdom coordinate efforts to weaken the US dollar and strengthen other major currencies. Many analysts believe the resulting appreciation of the Japanese yin contributed to Japan's asset bubble and economic stagnation that followed. However, this is an
Speaker 1area of huge controversy. While some do argue that, including many in Beijing, there are other analysts that argue that Japan's path had already been laid by its own domestic policy, and this simply quickened or exacerbated underlying structural realities to the stay. Economists and analysts still argue over whether the Plaza Accords really did throw Japan into its decades of stagnation. Indeed, for decades, Chinese policymakers have viewed the Plaza Accord not
Speaker 1as a success but a warning. Chinese state media frequently portrays it as an example of how external pressures can damage a country's long term economic development. That is why the notion that Beijing might voluntarily participate in a modern version of such an arrangement appears highly unrealistic. The response from China has been predictable. This week, state run The Global Times dismissed calls for a new Plaza Record, arguing that today's China bears little resemblance to Japan in the nineteen eighties. Quote Today's China is not the Japan of
Speaker 1the past, the newspaper wrote, adding quote the scale of China's economy, the depth of its market, the integrity of its industries. I guess they missed that first story on the tax evasion in their banks, and its policy autonomy are all on a different level. In quote, the nationalistic paper added, quote, China will not accept using exchange rates as a pretext for oppression, nor will it return to the old era of great powers. Coordinating the fate of a few countries in quote. This particular statement and complaints
Speaker 1about this being a colonial venture triggered a firm response from someone who we quote often on China Update, Peaking University Professor of Finance Michael Phittis, who yesterday made a long statement which is worth quoting at length. Quote. This is a rather bizarre argument to make, although it is one you often hear in the Chinese press. It assumes that the R and B exchange rate belongs to China, and that for the EU or anyone else to intervene in the RMB exchange rate is an act of colonial oppression. But this simply isn't true. An exchange rate belongs to
Speaker 1both countries involved. If China has intervened to devalue the R and B by twenty to thirty percent against the currency of its trade partners, this is exactly the same as if it had engineered a stealth Plaza accord in which it forced its trade partners to revalue their currencies by twenty five to forty three percent. There is no difference between the two, and so if one way isn't an act of colonial oppression, the other way isn't either. The Global Times also argues that China's trade surplus and its manufacturing competitiveness have nothing to do with an undervalued
Speaker 1R and B. If the People's Bank of China actually believed this, it is pretty obvious what it should do. It should revalue the R and B as quickly as it can. There would be no cost to doing so. Presumably Chinese manufacturers would be as globally competitive as ever, and it would immediately benefit Chinese households by raising the real value of their domestic income. Of course, the reason the People's Bank of China isn't doing this is because it knows, as most analysts know, including I suspect the editors of The Global Times, that this just isn't true.
Speaker 1The claim that currency values don't affect trade and balances is just silly. But to the extent that these kinds of editorials reflect actual positions among policymakers, we should expect a difficult and probably painful outcome. In history, there have been many large trade imbalances, especially ones associated with large increases in debt, in the past one hundred years, and they have usually ended very badly. The interesting question in retrospect has been why and under what conditions the brunt of the adjustment costs were ultimately borne by either the
Speaker 1surplus countries or the deficit com I worry that because there is clearly no appetite among surplus and deficit economies to reduce the imbalances in the least possible way possible for both sides, and because the imbalances may have already gone too far for any compromise, we may be moving towards an adjustment process in which the costs are magnified as each side tries to force the other to bear the brunt. Let me know what you think of Professor Pettis's comments in the common section below. Let's continue with
Speaker 1the main story, and indeed, European frustrations are becoming increasingly difficult to contain. European Commission President as Lavondleyan portally presented leaders with data showing a rapidly deteriorating trade relationship. The EU's goods trade deficit with China has reached roughly one billion euros per day, and some estimates suggest it could approach four hundred billion euros in twenty twenty six, surpassing previous records. The problem is no longer confined to a handful of industries, European officials increasingly argue that Chinese exports
Speaker 1are creating pressures across a broad range of sectors, from electric vehicles and batteries to chemicals, machinery and industrial goods. Germany, traditionally one of the strongest advocates of economic engagement with China, appears to be moving closer to this view. According to recent trade data, Germany accounted for roughly two thirds of the deterioration in the eused trade balance with China over the past year. That shift helps explain why Berlin's tone has become noticeably tougher. The European Commission is now exploring
Speaker 1additional tools to address what Brussels describes as quote global macroeconomic imbalances. Officials are reportedly considering new legal mechanisms that will allow faster action when European industries are suddenly flooded by imports. Wonder Lion has also indicated that the Commission is preparing legislation aimed at encouraging companies to diversify supply chains and reduce strategic dependencies. However, the summit also demonstrated the limits of European unity. While leaders approved further work
Speaker 1on trade defense instruments, they stop short of endorsing major new measures. Instead, they instructed the Commission to continue engaging in dialogue with key trading partners, including China. European Trade Commissioner is expected to meet Chinese Commerce Minister Wangmintau in Brussels later this month as part of those efforts. This reflects a broader reality. Many European governments are concerned about China's economic practices, but they are equally concerned about the consequences of a serious trade confrontation. European manufacturers remain deeply
Speaker 1connected to the Chinese market, while many industries continue to rely on Chinese supply chains. As a result, Europe finds itself in a familiar position. A sense of urgency is growing, the rhetoric is becoming tougher, and policy makers increasingly agree that the status quo is unsustainable. Yet when it comes to concrete action, caution continues to prevail. The idea of persuading Beijing to accept a major currency appreciation may therefore represent more wishful thinking then realistic policy, at least if
Speaker 1it's pushed by the Europeans. Europe's concerns about China are real and they are growing. But unless European leaders are willing to bear the costs of a more confrontational approach, hopes for a modern Plaza record are likely to remain just that hopes. Okay, that is to day's episode of China update to thank you so much everybody for watching, Have a good Thursday, and I hope to see you for the next episode, which will either be to morrow or on Saturday.
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...