China News and Analysis Beta - https://chinanewsupdate.com/ China Update provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. These podcasts are based on hundreds of articles, think tank reports, government statements and other resources in English and Chinese every week. The views and analysis are all my own and I produce the podcasts. My Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/chinaupdate Disclaimer: China Update is not a financial advisory channel. While I take great care in researching everything discussed in these podcasts, nothing I say should be taken as investment advice. Please speak to a professional before making any investment decisions. #China
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Happy Tuesday, everybody. Welcome to another episode of China Updates, where we discuss leading political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on the world's number two economy. My name is Tony. I'm filming this in my hotel room. I'm currently on a short business trip. Please forgive the informality of the current environment, and if there are some audio issues, my apologies for this as well. Now there is a lot to cover. This is a very economics heavy episode. Let's jump in and first up, China's economy is expected to have lost momentum in the second quarter of twenty twenty six, highlighting the growing divide between a booming export sector driven by
Speaker 1artificial intelligence and a domestic economy still struggling with weak consumption, a prolonged property downturn, and falling investment. Economists surveyed by Bloomberg expect China's gross domestic product to have expanded four point five percent year on year in the April to June period, down from five percent in the first quarter. That would place growth at the bottom end of Beijing's official annual target of four point five percent to five percent, increasing pressure on policy makers to consider further stimulus later this year, quarter on quarter growth is forecast to slow to just zero point nine percent, the weakest paced since
Speaker 1twenty twenty three. The slowdown reflects several persistent structural challenges. Consumer spending remains subdued confidence as fragile. The country's housing market continues to contract despite years of government support measures. More on this later. Fixed asset investment is also expected to weaken further, with economists forecasting a five percent decline in investment during the first time of the year and real estate investment falling nearly seventeen percent. At the same time, fiscal tightening has weighed on infrastructure spending as local governments prioritize debt reduction over new projects. However, economists expect public
Speaker 1spending to increase in the second half of the year as Beijing accelerates the issuance of special local government bonds and rolls out an eight hundred billion yen one hundred and eighteen billion uiice dollar policy financing facility to support major infrastructure projects. Despite the domestic weakness, China's external sector continues to outperform expectations. Exports surged twenty seven percent in June compared with the year earlier. Whiles jumped to thirty six percent, both significantly exceeding market forecasts. The result was China's second largest monthly trade surplus on record, at one
Speaker 1hundred and twenty five point six billion U West dollars. The surge has been fueled by a global artificial intelligence investment boom. Exploding demand for semiconductors, AI servers, data center equipment, and advanced electronics has created shortages across global supply chains, boosting Chinese manufacturing of computer, telecommunications and electric equipment. However, the benefits have been uneven. High tech manufacturers are enjoying rapid growth, while more traditional sectors linked to domestic demand, including furniture, steel in the parts of the property supply chain, continue to strug. Retail sales or expected to remain weak
Speaker 1after months of declining consumer demand. Passenger vehicle sales have fallen by double digits for seven consecutive months, while consumer confidence remains near historic lows, liberty households willingness to spend despite lower energy prices. The strong export performance has also reduced immediate pressure on Beijing to launch aggressive stimulus, and less a resilient overseas demand allows policymakers to rely on targeted fiscal measures rather than introducing broad rescue packages. Looking ahead, much attention will focus on this month's POLYPI meeting, which
Speaker 1will be covering very closely when it happens, which China's top leadership is expected to outline its economic priorities for the second half of the year. The key question is where the policymakers can revive domestic demand and stabilize the property market before slowing global growth or weakening AI investment begins to erode the export boom that has become China's primary, indeed only real remaining economic engine. Next up, a Chinese born American scientist has been detained in China for nearly two years on espionage charges, according to a new report
Speaker 1published this week by UK based Reuter, In the latest case likely to further complicate already fragile relations between Washington and Beijing. Chan Yoden, a fifty four year old seismologist based in the United States, was arrested by Chinese state security officers at Beijing Capital International Airport on the fifth of November twenty twenty four, as he prepared to return to Boston after visiting family and delivering lectures at two Chinese universities. Chen has conducted research funded by the United States government on detecting North Korean nuclear tests through seismic monitoring.
Speaker 1According to Reuters, he has since been designated as quote wrongfully detained in quote by U Secretary of State Marco Rubio, making his release a priority for the Trump administration. Until now, Chan's family had chosen not to publicize the case, hoping quiet diplomatic efforts would secure his release. However, Reuters reported that those efforts have so far failed to produce a breakthrough, and Chen now reportedly faces trial on spying charges. The case marks at least the second known detention of a US citizen on espionage related allegations in China this year.
Speaker 1In June, Menzen, a prominent MIAMA scholar and head of a think tank focused on MIAMA, was detained after arriving in Kunming in southwestern China. According to NPR, Menzen had traveled to China at the invitation of a Chinese academic institution to give election. Two cases are likely to heighten concerns among academics, researchers, and business people, and perhaps even youtrobers traveling between the United States and China. Experts have warned that fears of arbitrary detention are already discouraging exchanges
Speaker 1between the two countries. The director of the Penn Project on the Future of US China Relations told Singapore based The Straits Times that even if such incidents involve only a small number of people, they have an outsized psychological impact on students and researchers considering travel to China. The latest attention also comes as U S President Donald Trump has sought to stabilize relations with Beijing following last year's trade disputes. Whilthough governments have worked to prevent further deterioration and ties, espionage cases have repeatedly emerged as a major
Speaker 1source of tension. China has not publicly released detailed evidence supporting the allegations against Chan, consistent with the country's handling of many national security investigations. Beijing has frequently defended such arrests as legitimate law enforcement actions, while Washington has increasingly ugus that some detentions lack transparency and raise concerns about due process. With two American citizens now facing espionage related accusations, the cases are likely to become another sensitive issue in the already complex US China relationship. Now, next up, we
Speaker 1have one more quite big development to cover, but it's quickly. If you're getting some value from today's episode of China Update, as always, it's a big help if you can just hit that like button. Consider subscribing if you haven't already, if you want to be on top of all updates as they're released, and if you'd like to go to the extra mile and help me keep China Update financially sustainable. I rely on your support to keep going. Patreon and by Mere Coffee links are in the description below for everyone who helps keep me going and make China Update possible every day, Thank you so much. Next up, and finally,
Speaker 1for today, we are going to examine two prominent voices discussing China's ongoing housing crisis. China's economy may have avoided the dramatic financial collapse that many analysts predicted following the implosion of its property market, but it did not escape the economic crash altogether. According to economist and commentator Noah Smith in his recent piece, no China did not manage to avoid a crash. Smith argues that while Beijing successfully prevented a banking crisis, and maintained positive official GDP growth. Smith argues the country's economy still experienced a significant downturn,
Speaker 1was masked by government intervention and quieshtable official statistics. For years, China appeared remarkedly resilient during global downturns. Of course, for folks watching China Update, they would have seen the devil in the details. Unlike many advanced economies, it avoided prolonged recessions through an economic model that relied heavily on state directed bank lender Rather than relying solely on traditional monetary policy such as interest rate cuts or fiscal stimulus through government spending, Beijing employed a third toll, directing state controlled banks to dramatically increase lending to targeted sectors during the
Speaker 1aftermath of the two thousand and eight global financial crisis and again following the twenty fifteen stock market turmoil. The strategy fuelled a massive real estate boom. However, when the property bubble burst in twenty twenty one with the collapse of Evergrand, authorities shifted their focus instructing banks to poor credit into manufacturing instead of housing. This will be very familiar to regular viewers of China Update. Supporters of China's economic model argue this demonstrates the strength of state directed markets, noting that the country avoided the kind of financial crisis many on Wall Street had forecast. Official GDP growth never
Speaker 1fell below zero on an annual basis, leading some commentators to claim Beijing had successfully deflated one of the world's largest property bubbles without triggering a recession. Smith disputes that conclusion. He points out that China's own quarterly data showed the economy contracted during the second quarter of twenty twenty two. More importantly, he argues the broader economic indicators painted a much weaker picture than headline GDP figure suggest Youth unemployment surged following the property downturn, forcing authorities to revise how the statistic was calculated after the figure became politically uncomfortable.
Speaker 1Alternative labour market indicators also pointed to deteriorating employment conditions, particularly among migrant workers and young graduates. Independent research groups have also questioned China's official growth data. Analysts at Rhodium Group estimated the Chinese economy likely contracted in twenty twenty two and grew far more slowly in twenty twenty three than official figures suggested. We covered this report at the time on China Update. Two other institutions, including the Bank of Finland and Capital Economics, have similarly concluded that China's post property boom recovery has been considerably weaker than Beijing's
Speaker 1reported numbers indicate. Smith acknowledges that China's financial stabilization model has proven effective at preventing systemic financial panic and deserves serious study by other countries. However, he warns that repeatedly using state directed lending to support growth risks creating inefficient zombie companies and weaker long term productivity. Has broader conclusion is that while China succeeded in preventing a financial meltdown, it did not escape the economic consequences of its property crisis. It merely managed them in a less visible way. Now,
Speaker 1the second voice that we will examine for this piece is Surprise Surprise, Peaking University professor Financed Michael Pettis, who took the time to write a response to Smith's arguments. It is a long quote, but I think it is worth examining at length as it gives a brilliantly succinct overview of the entire situation quote. Noah Smith gets much right in his argument is how China managed the huge property bubble deflation in a painless way, and why it's a little silly to say that Beijing managed to deflate a massive housing bubble at no cost. The key point,
Speaker 1as he notes, is that whenever China faces an economic shock, Beijing uses its direct control over the banking system to push banks to lend more. What's more, contrary to some of the more dizzy comments to which this essay is a response, China is not the first country to have figured out how to manage adverse economic shocks by setting off compensating investment bubbles. Many investment driven economies have done the same, most notably the US in the mid nineteen twenties, Latin America in the early and mid nineteen seventies to the ore shocks, and Japan in the mid nineteen eighties.
Speaker 1What this means in practice is that the system is not allowed to adjust. Each economic shock is counted by setting off a new investment bubble. For example, the post two thousand and nine collapse in China's current account surplus from ten percent of GDP to three percent of GDP was balanced by inflating an infrastructure bubble. At the time, this was hailed as a brilliant move by Chinese and especially foreign economists, although today many Chinese economists will tell you, mostly in private, but occasionally even in public, that this was a mistake and was the beginning of China's debt problem.
Speaker 1The reason is that if China had been severely underinvested in infrastructure, balancing the intraction and trade with an explosion in infrastructure investment would have been both clever and sustainable. But by two thousand and nine, China already had almost as much infrastructure as it could productively absorb, and so the surgeon infrastructure investment was decided on not because China needed more infrastructure, but because a slowdown would have been more disruptive than China could absorb. Consider what happened next. As China trying to bring infrastructure investment levels down in
Speaker 1the mid at twenty tens, it could only do so without pain by setting off what turned out to be the last stage of the property bubble. It did this in twenty fifteen through sixteen by eliminating many property purchase restrictions, lowering minimum payments, reducing mortgage rates and forcing banks to expand mortgage lending, often in spite of growing concerns among banks. These policies not surprisingly set off a new wave of surging home prices and expanding property development. But this couldn't last long, and when the property sector gorged on almost unimaginable levels of debt began its sharp contraction in twenty
Speaker 1one through twenty two, Beijing once again responded by setting off an investment bubble in any other sector. This time, as Smith notes, it set it off in the manufacturing sector, with a decline in property investment matched almost dollar for dollar with an increase in manufacturing investment. Once again, if China had been severely under invested in manufacturing, this would have been a great move. But because at the time it was already over aliant on a large mans manufacturing sector, even larger than the property sector at its height, and suffering from excess manufacturing capacity, the result within two to three years was massive increases in excess capacity, severe involution,
Speaker 1and an uncontrollable surge in the trade surplus. So what some of the less historically literate might wonder if every time an investment bubble contracts and the authorities can negate the economic impact by setting off an investment bubble in another sector. Shouldn't they keep doing it forever? Yes, if they can, But for what should be obvious reasons, they cannot, and the longer they postpone the adjustment, the more costly it is likely to be. The problem, of course, is that each bubble has to be bigger than the last to keep the economic activity from slowing. We can see
Speaker 1this most obviously in the acceleration in the growth of the country's debt burden, already the second highest in the world after Japan's and the fastest growing in history, to the extent that debt funds a productive investment. Of course, rising debt should not translate into a rising debt to GDP ratio, But in an economy in which nearly all debt funds investment and very little funds consumption or transfers, many years of rapidly rising debt to GDP ratio is pretty strong evidence that the investment is increasingly unproductive. Among other things, this means that a bubble replacement strategy can
Speaker 1look very clever in the short term, but it can only run on as long as growth in the debt burden can accelerate. End quote. I said it was a long quote, but I do think it was worth letting Professor Pettis unpackers ideas in full. Let me know what you think of the updates we cover today, including these final views from Smith and Pettis in the comments below. That is today's episode. Thank you so much everybody for watching. Have a good Tuesday, and I hope to see you for the next episode, which will either be tomorrow or on Thursday.
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...