China News and Analysis Beta - https://chinanewsupdate.com/ China Update provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. These podcasts are based on hundreds of articles, think tank reports, government statements and other resources in English and Chinese every week. The views and analysis are all my own and I produce the podcasts. My Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/chinaupdate Disclaimer: China Update is not a financial advisory channel. While I take great care in researching everything discussed in these podcasts, nothing I say should be taken as investment advice. Please speak to a professional before making any investment decisions. #China
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Heavy Saturday. Everybody, Welcome to another episode of China Updates, where we discuss leading political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on the world's in number two economy. My name is Tony. This is an extra Saturday episode. There's been a lot of episodes this week, but there's just been so much to cover. Today. We're going to begin with the US China story and then we'll move into the main story, which is on the Chinese economy, specifically a speech delivered by one of China's most prominent economists. There is a lot to cover, so let's jump in. US President Donald Trump has announced three billion US dollars and US backed
Speaker 1critical minerals investments as Washington accelerates efforts to reduce its dependence on supply chains dominated by China. Speaking alongside leading mining executives at the State Department on Friday, the US President said the projects would create thousands of jobs while strengthening American economic and national security. Quote we are putting our miners back to work, and we're reclaiming America's rightful place as the minerals superpower of the world. In quote, Trump said the investments include one point four billion US dollar loan agreement between the Pentagon's Office of Strategic Capital
Speaker 1and Nanotechnologies. The funding will expand production of silicon battery anodes and lithian ion battery cells. The Defense Department will also provide four hundred million US dollars to Sunrise Energy Metals to expand scandium production in Australia. Scandium is used in advanced aerospace and defense applications. Another one hundred and fifty million will be supporting Minnesota based euron Magnetics. The Export Import Bank is working to provide more than one billion US dollars for Ivanhoe Electrics Santa Cruz copper project
Speaker 1in Arizona. A further twenty five million will help launch a graphite mine in Alabama. Trump also highlighted more than one hundred and eighty million US dollars for mining education programs designed to train engineers, geologists, metallurgists, and other specialized workers the sector faces in aging workforce after decades of declining enrolled at American mining schools. The event brought together executives from Rio Tinto, b HP, MP Materials, USA, Rare Earths,
Speaker 1and other major resource companies. Became ahead of China's lead Regional Security Gymping's planned visit to Washington in September. Rare earths remain a major source of tension between the world's two largest economies. Although a trade truce eased some of China's export restrictions, Washington is seeking to establish an independent mind to magnet supply chain. The federal government has already pledged more than ten billion US dollars to emerging rare earth and permanent magnet industries. It is also supporting mining projects overseas, including a rare earth development in Madagascar. Mining
Speaker 1billionaire Robert Friedland said successive US administrations had been quote sleep walking in quote on the issue. Add in quote, this is critical to our national security end quote. Now we move into the main story for today. China's greatest economic challenge is not an increasingly u K shaped divergence, but rather a broader slow down that has persisted for three years. According to prominent Chinese economist Li dal Hui Le dean of the Academic Center for Chinese Economic Practice and Thinking at China's prestigious Tinhua University in Beijing and
Speaker 1a former member of the People's Bank of China's Monetary Policy Committee, delivered the assessment during the one hundred and twenty second China Macro Economy Forum Seminar in July. The online event examined the nature of China's uneven economic performance and possible policy responses. Lee argued that discussions of a K shaped economy where stronger industries and regions continue rising while others decline, risks creating excessive confidence that successful sectors can carry the rest of the country quote. The upper
Speaker 1arm of the K cannot pull up the entire economic base end quote. Li said China's economy as a whole is quote running cold end quote and operating below its potential growth rate. He warned as evident, lie present an alternative measure of unemployment that includes people who still want jobs but are no longer officially classified as members of the labour fall after extended periods without work. Including this discouraged labour force produces a broad unemployment rate of approximately ten point two percent. He estimated around twenty four million
Speaker 1people may fall into this category. Lead stress that these people have not simply decided to lie flat. They remain willing to work, but have become discouraged after reportedly failing to secure employment. Such a large population of long term unemployed people could have serious implications for household confidence, economic demand, and social stability. They also highlighted exceptionally weak investment, He said. Cumulative fixed asset investment fell four point one percent during the first five months of the year, while private and manufacturing investment both contracted week. Investment on the scale is
Speaker 1highly unusual in modern Chinese economic history, he argued, and threatens Beijing's wider growth and development objectives. The fundamental problem is that China's traditiontional engines of economic expansion, property development, and infrastructure construction have faded before sufficiently powerful replacements have emerged. For much of the previous two decades, local government's powered activity through enormous spending on roads, railways, industrial parks, urban development, and other infrastructure. Lee estimated that local government investment and routine expenditure once equaled approximately forty one percent of GDP,
Speaker 1making local authorities a more important source of demand than household consumption. Real estate provided the second major engine, rising property prices and courage construction supported land sales and increased household well Today, however, both property development and infrastructure investment have stalled, Lee said, the housing downturn has produced significant economic damage, although the impact has been smaller than some economists previously fed. Chinese households hold approximately four hundred trillion Yan in net property assets and have absorbed the decline in housing values without widespread mortgage defaults. Although property must
Speaker 1be stabilized, Lee believes them a more immediate problem is local government. Local authorities are burdened by debt that Lee estimates exceeds one hundred percent of GDP when different forms of borrowing are included. Much of that debt was issued with relatively short maturities and high interest rates. Consequently, new bank lending and bond proceeds are frequently being used to repay old obligations rather than finance productive projects. After several years of debt resolution efforts, the outstanding burden has continued
Speaker 1growing because interest costs remain high. They describe local governments as economic quote heat absorbers in quote and financial quote black holes in quote that consume enormous resources without converting them into sufficient new activity. The consequences are visible across the economy. Households are reluctant to borrow and consume, companies are hesitant to invest, and local government borrowing circulates through the financial system as new debt is used to repay old debt. Local government expenditure has meanwhile fallen from approximately
Speaker 1four twenty one percent to thirty five percent of GDP. According to Lee, capital spending has contracted particularly sharply. Some cash trapped authorities have also sought to increase revenue by reclaiming previously promised tax concessions, collecting taxes early, and delaying payments to businesses. This creates a damaging cycle local government's withdraw demand from the economy while simultaneously placing greater financial pressure on private companies. The proposed a substantial expansion of central government borrowing to break the cycle. With central government
Speaker 1debt below thirty percent of GDP, Beijing his considerable room to borrow. He argues, planned bond issuance of approximately twelve trillion Yan should be doubled or increased even further. The proceeds could replace high interest local debt, provided local governments commit to more discipline borrowing in the future. The central government could also finance projects proposed by local authorities, allowing them to resume productive spending without worsening their existing debt burdens. Other potential uses include purchase using unsold homes and converting
Speaker 1them into affordable or rental housing, with the properties eventually packaged into real estate investment trusts. Additional borrowing could also fund migrant workers' access to urban public services, strength and social welfare programs, and support locally targeted consumption subsidies. Lee nevertheless ended on an optimistic note. China still possesses considerable growth potential, he said, but policymakers must directly confront the blockage created by local government debt. If central financing restores local government's capacity to support demand, stabilize property, and invest
Speaker 1in new sources of growth, Lee believes the economy could emerge relatively quickly from its prolonged period of cold operation, as he puts it, and returned to a stronger growth trajectory. Now it wouldn't be trying to update without a quote from Peaking University Professor of Finance Michael Pettis, who shared his thoughts on the speech yesterday. As we will see, he largely agrees with Lee's diagnosis of the issue, but Pettis has a much more pessimistic outlook in terms of what can be done will end Today's video with Pettis's observations quote. Many people are talking about this July speech
Speaker 1by Lee dol Qui not because his analysis is especially new. Many Chinese economists have been saying similar things privately, just as many foreign economists have been saying them publicly, but because he said it in such a public forum. Even as he insists several times that China's future is very bright, as he probably must, the speech nonetheless suggests that we may be seeing a gradual shift in the policy making consensus. To me, the most important part of the speech is his willingness to state clearly something that I don't think Beijing wants to hear. There is a hope among policy
Speaker 1makers that over the next few years Beijing will manage a transition in which the healthy part of the K shaped economy, advanced technology and high value added manufacturing, becomes sufficiently strong relative to the weak part everything else to pull the whole economy forward. In my opinion, this was always unlikely, even in a world willing to absorb China's attempt to expand its already large global share of advanced technology and high value added manufacturing. In today's world of rising trade tensions, However, I think it is all but impossible.
Speaker 1Only the United States, the European Union, and Japan are large enough and advanced enough to support China's manufacturing ambitions through their net demand, and all three are increasingly closing their markets. Lie seems to agree that this K shaped dream is unrealistic. While I agree strongly with Lee's analysis of the problem, I disagree with his solution, which is to use the central government balance sheet to clean up local government balance sheets so that they can return to their old mission of pumping up economic activity. My problem with this proposal is that it assumes local governments invested
Speaker 1badly for reasons that can be corrected. It further assumes that future behavior can be changed, perhaps by requiring local governments to promise to reform. But that is not what happened, nor is it what will happen. Beijing has set excessively high GDP growth targets for decades because it could not get consumption growth to accelerate sufficiently. This meant that it also could not allow investment growth to decelerate. With the highest investments rates in history, achieving these growth targets required an enormous pipeline of economically viable investment projects. The problem
Speaker 1is that, unlike the period before the end of the two thousands, China is no longer sufficiently under invested across the board for huge increases in investment to generate enough viable projects and sustain real growth. China has had excess capacity in property, infrastructure, and manufacturing for many years. That necessarily means that the returns on new investment have been very low or even negative, and because investment remained so high, debt had to surge, which, of course it did not. Only has this problem not improved in recent years, it
Speaker 1has become progressively worse. That is why local government debt has risen so much faster since the early twenty tens than the real value of provincial economies. That is why so many provinces are struggling under their debt burdens. It is not that local governments were careless or irresponsible when they made those investments. Rather, the GDP growth targets themselves forced them to continue investing, whether or not additional investment was economically justified. The inevitable result was an ever growing volume of non productive investment. Because provinces are now burdened
Speaker 1by these debts, Lie proposals cleaning up their balance sheets by transferring the debt onto the central government balance sheet. He is right that the central government still has a relatively clean balance sheet. It is, in fact the last clean balance sheet left in China. But that is precisely why I think it should not be compromised in an effort to sustain GDP growth targets that have become increasingly unrealistic foreign economy facing the kinds of structural problems Lie himself describes. As long as Majin continues to set excessively
Speaker 1high GDP growth targets, there is no way to prevent debt from continuing to searge. My concern is that Lee's proposal would simply cause China to lose the last clean balnce sheet it still possesses, and with it its ability to moderate and manage the pace of which is likely to be an inevitable and inevitably difficult adjustment. End quote. Okay, that is today's episode of China Update. Thank you so much everybody for watching. I hope you got some value from today's episode. Very economy focused with that second story
Speaker 1is the major story. If you've got some value from today's episode Don't forget to the light button, subscribe and there is also Patreon and buy me a Coffee links in the description below. If you'd like to go to the Extra madle and help me keep China update financially sustainable. Thank you for watching, Have a good Saturday, have a risk for weekend, and I hope to see you for a new week of updates on Monday.
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...
China Update by Tony Fiddis provides listeners with the most up to date political, economic, and geostrategic analysis on China - so that you are on top of the world's number 2 economy. My name is Tony Fiddis - these...