The Fat and Protein Imbalance, Why Rebuild Isn't Happening, and a Soft Soybean Market
7 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail Today we start with a look at the imbalance between fat and protein in the dairy market, thanks mostly to the increase in cows and production. We also look at why the beef herd isn't rebuilding and probably won't anytime soon, and how soybeans took it in the pants recently and what that might mean going forward.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hey everybody, welcome to Chat BDC. For today, here's the stop Top Stories from Black Dirt Daily, which is Wednesday, November 4th, 2026. We're trying a new format today. Try some video. So if you're watching this on YouTube, you get to see my lovely face, which we've always been told is a face made for radio. So we'll see how this goes. If you're on the regular podcast, obviously you're just lucky enough to just hear my silky voice this morning. So today we're going to talk about the imbalance between fat and protein in the dairy market, why the beef herd isn't rebuilding and a sell-off in soybean markets.
SPEAKER_00So let's get to it. Starting off with dairy in an article on dairyherd.com, butter production has been trending higher every year over the last five years, with 2026 well above the rest. Latest dairy products report released earlier this month had butter production at 187 million pounds of butter, which is up 6.3% from last year for the month of August, although slightly less than July's production. Seasonally, August butter production is lower than the first half of the year, with a rebound of higher production in the winter months.
SPEAKER_00Cheese production has a similar story, coming in at 1.245 billion pounds of total cheese production in August. That's 1.4% higher than August 2025 and 1.4% below July 2026 production. Parmesan blue and gorgonzola cheese had the biggest percentage increases in production year over year. Reason for increases in production is directly related to the increasing number of cows and the milk that they produce. Large amount of milk brings a surplus of supplies for each component, with butter and cheese seeing some of the biggest increases.
SPEAKER_00Production of these products has been optimized as manufacturers push production capacity to keep up with the overabundance of milk available. Inventories tell a little bit more of the story. Butter inventory, while it's been lower the last month, on the latest cold storage report shows an increase of 16% more on hand than a year ago. Cheese inventories increased 2% year over year while also down slightly from last month. Butter and cheese prices have helped the imp have felt the impact of increased supply.
SPEAKER_00Butter prices have fallen 29% this September when compared to last September. Using the AMS class price announcements, cheese prices have fallen 14%. However, uh non-fat dry milk and dry whey have benefited from the protein growth and have rallied over the last year. From here, all eyes are on cow numbers and coal and as coal prices are high, but calf prices are even higher. So the question is how much longer can producers maintain these cow numbers and this production, especially with increasing feed costs.
SPEAKER_00So that's something that we're going to keep an eye on. Switching over to cattle markets article on drovers multi-year liquidation of the U.S. beef cow herd has finally hit bottom, we think. But producers waiting for a full-scale rebuild phase will probably have to wait longer. Cold cow slaughter has plunged to historic lows. In the second half, the rebuilding equation, heifer retention remains stuck in neutral. And as worsening fall drought grips key southeastern cow calf inventory, forage deficits are giving producers little choice but to keep replacement plans on ice.
SPEAKER_00According to Darrow Peel, who's at Oklahoma State livestock marketing specialist in a recent newsletter, said cyclical herd growth requires two distinct biological phases. First, decreased cow culling is mostly about slowing herd liquidation and stabilizing cow inventory at the cyclical low. From that point, you got to replace them. Increased heifer retention provides the means to expand on those cow inventories. Inventory has successfully checked the first box. The industry has successfully checked the first box.
SPEAKER_00Beef cow culling dropped from a record high of 13.19% in 2022 to a projected record low of 7.35% this year. Full year projections indicate 2026 beef cow slaughter will finish down more than 48% compared to the aggressive liquidation pace seen four years ago. However, though, the replacement replacement pipeline has been remarkably slow to fill. USDA semi-annual cattle reports revealed only modest upticks.
SPEAKER_00January data showed a minor increase of 41,700 head of beef replacement heifers, followed by a hundred thousand head year over year increase in July. Compounding the issue is herd demographics. After four consecutive years of reduced culling, producers are managing an increasingly aged cow base that can't stay on pasture forever. Daryl Peel says that four years of decreased cow culling means that more old cows in the herd will have to be replaced relatively soon.
SPEAKER_00He says that it looks like that a minimum of 200,000 head of beef replacement heifers are likely to be needed in the next year just to maintain the current herd. Neither inventory increases is enough to indicate herd rebuilding. Soybeans made new lows for the move with January down 17.5 cents. Chip Nellinger of Blue Reef Agri Marketing on an agweb article says the soybean complex saw technical selling of funds still holding a sizable long in soybeans and meal.
SPEAKER_00December soybean meal ended below the 200-day moving average, and so did soybean oil, which could open the door to more selling, according to Nellinger. January soybeans are still holding above the 200-day mark moving average, which is around 12 bucks, but will it hold longer term? Or do the funds push the market through those support areas as they exit longs? Ellinger says it wouldn't shock him one bit if we hold it ahead of the WASDA report that comes out next Tuesday. That's going to be a major report.
SPEAKER_00The fear is based on farmers' results from the field and the combine seat that they can maybe raise yields just a little bit. I think that's the fear of the market, maybe driving some of that fund liquidation, Nellinger says. Well, that's all for now. Thanks for tuning in to ChatBDC. If you like what you heard, drop me a comment. Check out the full articles behind these stories on BlackDertDaily.com. I'll be back tomorrow with more business news across Tag and Financial Markets. Until then, I'm Mike Hopperman, and goodbye for now.
Send us Fan Mail In today's Chat BDC, we're covering four stories shaping agriculture and business. December milk prices edge higher, record-heavy beef carcasses create new challenges for cattle producers, and corn...
Send us Fan Mail Today we've looked at the importance of developing agriculture's next generation of leaders, the changing dynamics of consumer meat purchases, the potential impact of declining government payments, and...
Send us Fan Mail Today we check in on October uniform milk prices, and the battles cattlemen face in Washington going forward. We also look at what we can expect in 2027 from a grain market standpoint, and how Wall...
Send us Fan Mail Today we start in dairy with a look at an Uplevel Dairy podcast that talks about the economic realities on dairy farms. Then we switch to a Tyson rebound, and the changing agriculture economy. We wrap...
Send us Fan Mail Today we look at how producers can deal with a slide to beef-on-dairy calf prices, and a look at how beef demand has evolved over time. Then we look at risk management and taxes, and how farmers can...