
Is this your show? Claim this page
PodCred
The people behind this show
People get invited back because someone remembered they were great.
PodCred is the verified record of who made this show. A credit here means people who were there confirmed the work.
Hosts
Who is on this show?
Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.
Add a creditEpisodes
87 episodes#72: "Same Time, Next Year" with snotty esthete Dr. Jesse Rabinowitz
Fall is a lovely time of year for cozy things - sweaters, snuggling next to a fire, drinking hot chocolate. The comic love story, "Same Time, Next Year," is certainly cozy...but is it good? My favorite arbiter on the...
#47: Deathtrap with the insightful Nathan Whitmer
It is spoooky season, the perfect time of year to consider "Deathtrap." The popular post-modern murder thriller ran for 4 years on Broadway but, even more impressive, continues to get regularly produced all over the...
#59: The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas w/ Broadway cast member Susann Fletcher
We love Dolly. Everybody loves Dolly - it is, after all, the law. But that doesn't mean that everything she touched in her glorious life turned to gold. Exhibit A would be the movie version of "The Best Little...
#29-plus! The Producers bonus episode, with Jason Marks
"The Producers" was and is such a bountiful subject for conversation that Jason Marks and I couldn't stop talking about it. Here is a short-ish episode of bonus material that expands on a few of the topics we talked...
#29: The Producers with RVA's Max Bialystock, Jason Marks
There are ongoing conversations about how the most successful shows on Broadway have a certain "mid-brow" appeal. Sophisticated high-brow "arty" shows by folks like Sondheim are adored by some but don't get as many...
#52 (tie): "The Wiz" with Broadway veteran Jerold Solomon
"Chasing Phantom" is easing into its 4th season by easing down the road to "The Wiz!" Another show that host David Timberline has not seen live - shame on me! - but thanks to the podcast, has grown to appreciate and...
Season 4 starts on Wednesday!
Summertime is coming to a close and that means your favorite Broadway history podcast, "Chasing Phantom," is back! This season is going to be a doozy as we progress into the highest echelons of Broadway's longest...
"Mame" Q&A, TV adaptation, Patrick Dennis
Cool off with a breezy bit of bonus content from the Chasing Phantom live podcast event held in May of 2026. The absolute font of Broadway knowledge Phil Crosby and I continue our conversation about the musical "Mame,"...
#69: "Mame" live event with MVG Phil Crosby
The energy of a live show cannot be duplicated but listening to this episode is the next best thing to being in the room where the Chasing Phantom live event happened. Most Valuable Guest and dear friend of the program,...
#66: Barefoot in the Park with director Jan Guarino
My first guess for Neil Simon’s longest running show on Broadway would have been “The Odd Couple,” maybe followed by “Brighton Beach Memoirs” or “The Sunshine Boys.” But nope - the breezy romantic comedy “Barefoot in...
#74: Me and My Girl with RVA's Bill Snibson, Larry Cook
As has been chronicled extensively on this podcast already, many older Broadway shows do NOT hold up very well over time. The ones that do - your "Guys and Dolls" or "Oklahomas" - still regularly get produced. But "Me...
#71: "& Juliet" with national tour star Crystal Kellogg
You may think that a person in the midst of performing a role is too close to it to have insightful things to say about it. That's certainly not the case about Crystal Kellogg who at the time of this conversation was...
No Juliet...yet!
Just a quick scheduling note to let listeners know that the episode I had suggested (threatened?) might come out today will not actually come out until NEXT week, on Tuesday rather than Wednesday. In the meantime, be...
#72: Arsenic and Old Lace with monster-meister Dr. Jesse Rabinowitz
He is famous for playing the Frankenstein monster and voicing the Grinch but people often forget that Boris Karloff also made a big impact on the stage starting with "Arsenic and Old Lace." Not only did he steal the...
#61: Evita, exploring diva energy with the divine Melissa Chase
Don't cry for me, Chasing Phantom fans! I have brought back yet another one of your favorite guests, the diva-tastic Melissa Chase, host of the lifestyle television show, "Showcase." We discuss the diva-centric "Evita,"...
#78: The Music Man, the shiniest of the Golden Age with Dr. Kristin Stultz Pressley
Happy April Fool's Day! Sure, "The Music Man" included some incredible songs, featured one of the most career-defining performances in Broadway history, and captured a unique clash of squeaky-clean Midwestern living...
#62: The Voice of the Turtle and its surprising relevance with Jordan Schildcrout, Ph.D.
Who could have known that this near-forgotten play from the 1940s would be so relevant in the 2020s? The title is from the Bible, a verse in the Song of Solomon that actually references a turtledove, not the shelled...
#73: The Sound of Music with the sublime Stacey Cabaj
With this episode, we reach an important milestone in "Chasing Phantom" history: this 64th episode marks the moment we pass the halfway point on the way up the list toward "Phantom of the Opera," still the longest...
#77: Hellzapoppin' and madcap comedy with August Hundley
Think "Blazing Saddles" but on Broadway and with 1930s era sensibilities. That's what "Hellzapoppin'" was and, honestly, for the times it was pretty cutting-edge stuff. Weird running gags, satirical songs lampooning...
#68: "Dreamgirls" with the dreamy Katrinah Carol Lewis
Valentine's Day is coming up, a time when the warmth of love takes our minds off the cold weather. So it's the perfect time for an episode about a show I love without reservation: "Dreamgirls." I'm not alone - critic...
#63: Matilda the Musical, and why it's not just a kid's show with Shannon Schilstra
It's weird how prescience can come from such unexpected places. When I recorded this episode about "Matilda the Musical" with the delightful Shannon Schilstra, I had no idea how relevant the show's themes about the bad...
#67: 42nd Street (2001 revival), celebrating the New Year with Phil Crosby
For this first episode of 2026, I expose perhaps the most embarrassing gap in my theater knowledge. I often say I'm not as devoted a theater nerd as you might expect from someone who's written about theater for more...
#60: Mary, Mary and the too-witty woman with Jordan Schildcrout
In the midst of your "Merry, Merry Christmas," let me interest you in a little "Mary, Mary" Broadway! Don't feel bad if you've never heard of this play -- I certainly hadn't -- but like so many other shows I've covered,...
#57: Ain't Misbehavin' with the incomparable Desirée Roots
Sure, you "Ain't Misbehavin'" at holiday time, but what about the rest of the year? For an expert on not misbehaving year-round, what person could I talk to that would be better than Desirée Roots? Roots has graced...
#76: How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying with Dr. Kristin Stultz Pressley
If you look down the list of Pulitzer Prize-winning musicals, past more recent capital "I" important musicals like "Hamilton" and "A Strange Loop," you eventually get to "How to Succeed in Business Without Really...
#81: Oh! Calcutta! with (a thankfully clothed) Dr. Jesse Rabinowitz
In approaching "Oh! Calcutta!" today, it's hard not to react with a "What! Really?!?" This is a show, that between the original production and its revival, had more than 7,200 performances on Broadway. Really? Full of...
#65: Jekyll & Hyde with literary authority Grace Todd
Happy Halloween! We have the perfect show to dig into for spooky season - mostly because it's downright scary how bad this musical is! Frank Wildhorn's "Jekyll & Hyde" is a musical that, if there was a just theater god,...
#70: Grease (1994 revival) with Broadway veteran, Patti D'Beck
It's one of the most famous and beloved titles in musical theater. Because of its iconic mismatched lovers storyline and nostalgia evocation of the 1950s, "Grease" has been performed in high schools, colleges and...
#83: School of Rock and non-traditional venues with Brian Baez
"School of Rock" opened on Broadway just a few years after "Billy Elliot" closed but, even though the shows have some surface-level similarities, it's hard to think of two more different stories. The earlier show was a...
#82: Billy Elliot: The Musical with David Leong, Broadway fight director & former VCU chair of theater
Fifteen years ago, "Billy Elliot: The Musical" was all the rage on Broadway. It was a show where hot button social issues -- from labor relations to social mobility to questions about gender expression -- mixed with a...
#84: Movin' Out with Tony Award nominee Elizabeth Parkinson
Welcome to season 3 of "Chasing Phantom!" If this episode is any indication, it's going to be the best season yet. At a time when debate about Billy Joel, his music and his legacy, has enjoyed a surge of attention...
Summer Bonus #2: Waiting for Godot
Hey there, Phantom Chasers! I've been a lax podcaster during the languid summer months but I'm prepping some very cool, very fun episodes for September. In the meantime, this is a conversation with my friend Grace Todd,...
Summer bonus #1: Funny Girl Q&A
Phil Crosby and I had such a good time talking about "Funny Girl" that we rambled on for another 15 minutes or so answering questions posed by our live audience at Richmond Triangle Players. You get some more background...
#79: Funny Girl, live podcast event and season 2 finale
The highlight of "Chasing Phantom's" brief history happened in May 2025 with the recording of what I hope will be the first of many live podcast events. Phil Crosby, the executive director of Richmond Triangle Players,...
#96: Guys and Dolls, but mostly Dolls with Rachel Abrams & Rita Neidich
Is there a more iconic musical than “Guys and Dolls?” Probably not. That doesn’t mean it’s easy to do well and my guests for this episode are a testament to how to make a classic musical really sing. This is a show that...
#64: Waitress and modern relationships with Kylee Marquez-Downie
Both me and my guest in this episode had the chance to see "Waitress" on Broadway and we chose not to. And boy, were we both sorry! It's not often with this podcast that we talk about a show you can see right now. But...
#98: Amadeus, starlings and genius with Daniel Myssyk
Art about other art is fascinating to me, and only one of the many reasons I love "Amadeus," a play about music. Of course, it's also about envy of another man's genius: the play cemented the image of Salieri in popular...
#80: Mummenschanz and the human experience with Heidi Rugg
Is it mime? Is it puppetry? Is it augmented sketch comedy? Rather than try to categorize "Mummenschanz," it seems best to just wonder at the inventiveness and enjoy the fun of the experience. That was certainly what...
#97: In the Heights with RVA's Piragua Guy, Fernando Rivadeneira
Over the past 20 years or so, a handful of shows have revolutionized what can be done on Broadway. You could point to "Hamilton" as one of the biggest of those but that revolution actually started with "In the Heights,"...
#90: Cactus Flower and manic pixie dream girls with Jordan Schildcrout
Why is a conversation with Jordan Schildcrout always a good time? Because in the course of just 30 minutes chatting about the relatively obscure play “Cactus Flower,” you’ll hear about additionally fascinating plays...
#95: Sugar Babies and the history of vaudeville with Phil Crosby
Easter is this weekend and, while you might think I'm featuring the show "Sugar Babies" to make an allusion toward those sweet treats found in children's Easter baskets, well, you're right! BUT, thanks to my always...
#88: Promises, Promises and the cultural divide with Jesse Rabinowitz
"Promises, Promises" had a dream team of talent, both backstage and onstage. Neil Simon, Hal David, and Burt Bacharach are the big three, but it was also directed by Robert Moore ("The Boys in the Band" off-Broadway,...
#100 (tie): Memphis, "race records," and DJs with Melissa Chase
It's about music, it's about race relations, but it's NOT about how to be a good radio disc jockey. In giving a very loose account of the rise and fall of true-life music pioneer Dewey Phillips, the musical "Memphis"...
#92: 1776, alpha males, and optimism with Debra Clinton
Am I too on the nose here? Pretty much any time seems like a good time to reflect on the founding of the United States of America, but boy howdy, does this current time we're in seem like a specifically good time to do...
#99 (tie): Cabaret, the B Plot, and Meeskite with Doug Schneider
Nope - I am definitely NOT making any kind of political statement by doing an episode on "Cabaret" at this specific moment. Nope, not at all. My delightful conversation with actor and director Doug Schneider steers...
#98: Once, unexpected love, and the state of the American musical with Nathaniel Shaw
Valentine's Day has been commercialized to such an outrageous degree, pushing models of hetero-normative romantic commitment so hard that any other kind of love can end up seeming marginal or even invisible. That's one...
#81: MJ: The Musical with national tour star Jordan Markus
When you want to hear about Michael Jackson, it's best to talk to the man himself...or, given the impossibility of that, the man who's playing him. As of New Year's Eve 2024, the actor playing the title role in "MJ: The...
#92: "Sleuth," classism, misogyny and Sondheim with Grace Todd
Happy New Year to all! During these cold winter months, there's nothing as cozy as an old-timey murder mystery and "Sleuth" is one of the twisty-est. Helping me navigate the plot -- not to mention the embedded...
#85: Brighton Beach Memoirs, family dynamics and Jill Bari Steinberg
Happy Hanukkah! Oh, and Merry Christmas, but to be honest, this is more of a Hanukkah-forward episode, only because "Brighton Breach Memoirs" is very succinctly the story of a Jewish American family, the challenges,...
Bonus Episode: #89: The King and I, spoiling the ending and more history with Phil Crosby
In the first ever bonus episode of Chasing Phantom, Phil Crosby and I talk about the ending of "The King and I," one that was a surprise to me so don't listen if you want it to be a surprise to you! We also get back...
#89: The King and I, family, and forgotten stars with Phil Crosby
We are hurtling towards the holidays and so, for this episode, I make the case for "The King and I" to be considered among your holiday viewing options. Even though it's a 70+ year show, it's a smart and sophisticated...
#9: Mamma Mia! Female friendships and communal effervescence with Grey Garrett
For this pre-Thanksgiving episode, we hurtle up the list of long-running productions to give everyone something to celebrate and lift our spirits. "Mamma Mia!" may be the longest-running jukebox musical ever to run on...
#102: Mister Roberts, humble heroes and thankfulness with Jesse Rabinowitz
On the week after Veteran's Day, my friend Jesse and I dig into "Mister Roberts," a play about sailors during World War II and humble hero who was an example of (mostly) passive resistance to a petty tyrant. When we...
#86: Angel Street, Gaslight and spooky season with Lindsey Zelli
What could be more terrifying than to think you’re going insane? That basic horror makes “Angel Street” the perfect show to talk about during spooky season. Originally produced in London as “Gas Light” and adapted for...
#103: Annie Get Your Gun and child stardom in the 1940s with Mary Ellen Ashley
When you want to know about a production, there's no better source than talking to someone who was in it. I never thought that would be possible with the original Broadway run of "Annie Get Your Gun" - I mean, it closed...
#91: Torch Song Trilogy, understudies and awards, with Keegan Ferrell
"Torch Song Trilogy" was a ground-breaking production and opened many doors for openly gay artists. It launched the career of Harvey Fierstein who would go on to write and perform in some additionally landmark shows on...
#94: Equus, sex, religion and Daniel Radcliffe with McLean Fletcher
We all know that sex sells, but is that the only thing that drove thousands of people to see "Equus" back in the mid-1970s? Listen in on my discussion with McLean Fletcher as we discuss the explosive intersection of...
#87: Lightnin' & the demise of long-running plays with Jordan Schildcrout
The chase is back on! Welcome to season 2 of the podcast dedicated to exploring...and sometimes explaining...Broadway's longest running shows! Today's episode features a true Broadway history whiz: author, dramaturg &...
Season Two starts Sept. 4th!
We're back - better than ever! The second season of "Chasing Phantom" will feature celebrity guests, unexpectedly popular productions, and a cavalcade of trivia, insights and lively conversation about the longest...
#109: Pins and Needles (End of Season 1)
For this very special episode, we welcome Barbra Streisand to "Chasing Phantom" to help us explore a show that was a monster hit in the 1930s. OK, it's more the spirit and definitely the Voice of Babs that highlights...
#106: The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
"The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee" is responsible for Mark Zuckerberg. Don't believe me? Listen as accomplished actor, director and video wizard Matt Polson and I wander around in nerd culture for a while,...
#107: Bring in 'da Noise, Bring in 'da Funk
Once again, the joy of this podcast for me is getting schooled on stuff I don't know about. In talking about "Bring in 'da Noise, Bring in 'da Funk," Dr. Julinda Lewis introduces me to a flurry of tap dance masters from...
#105: The Seven Year Itch
Before the iconic picture of Marilyn Monroe with her white dress billowing over a subway grate obliterated any other reference point, "The Seven Year Itch" was a long-running Broadway show. In fact, it was the longest...
#31: Annie
Leapin' Lizards, what is going on here? Chasing Phantom has been methodically working through the list of 1,000+ performances on Broadway from the bottom up but, this week, we take a radical leap into the higher realms...
#104: Guys and Dolls (1992 revival)
If you're reading this, I expect either you or someone you know has been in a production of "Guys and Dolls." There are so many reasons this show is a classic, from the colorful supporting characters to the silly...
#108: Butterflies Are Free
It's both a relief and a delight when a show that premiered on Broadway more than 50 years ago isn't a challenge or a slog to get through. "Butterflies Are Free" is a play about a young blind man out on his own for the...
#110: Plaza Suite
We start off 2024 with an old show that has surprising relevance today because of a very recent -- and somewhat confounding -- revival. "Plaza Suite" first premiered back in Neil Simon's imperial period when his shows...
#111: Fosse
What a perfect way to end the year in quintessential Broadway fashion! For this episode I'm talking about "Fosse," the 1999 musical dance revue that featured what may be considered the "greatest hits" of choreographer...
#112: They're Playing Our Song
For the first of several Neil Simon creations that this series will consider, we start off with one that may be a "meh" to listen to but is still fun to talk about if only for the speculation about what could have...
#43: SIX
With this episode, Chasing Phantom inaugurates an intermittent series on shows that haven't technically made it over the 1,000 performance mark but are on the fast track to getting there. SIX was the answer to Broadway...
#114: Spider-Man: Turn Off The Dark
Look, everyone knows this show was bonkers and, even after running more than 1,000 performances, was possibly the biggest money loser in Broadway's history. It'd be easy to just rag on "Spider-Man: Turn Off The Dark" --...
#113: Kiss Me Kate
Marrying slices of Shakespeare with perhaps Cole Porter's finest score, "Kiss Me Kate" is one of the ultimate old Broadway hits. Fashioned as a response to "Oklahoma" and built with sturdy story beats that have allowed...
#115: Don't Bother Me, I Can't Cope
"It transformed my life." That's the kind of statement you want from someone talking about a cultural experience. "Don't Bother Me, I Can't Cope" broke all sorts of barriers on Broadway in 1972 but it is not well known...
#117: Shenandoah
For better or worse, the song "Freedom" is one of the most persistent earworms around but what do we think about the show that spawned such a tenacious tune? "Shenandoah" used to be a regional favorite but hardly ever...
#116: The Pajama Game
Watch out -- it's the 50s! The romantic dynamics, not to mention the workplace politics and the capitalistic shenanigans, might seem like artifacts from ancient history in the plucky musical, "The Pajama Game." The show...
#118: Annie Get Your Gun (1999 revival)
It's a show that you wish was just about the songs -- "There's No Business Like Show Business," "I've Got the Sun in the Morning," etc. -- but, for better or worse, it's set in a time (late 19th century) and place (the...
New podcast alert! Didn't Read It - a podcast about books
Hey there, Chasing Phantom phans! We're taking a little break this week from chasing after all that theater-related historical yumminess in order to introduce you to a brand spanking new podcast, Didn't Read It! Grace...
#119: The Teahouse of the August Moon
Welcome back to the wacky 1950s! It may be a little mind-boggling that a show so prominently featuring an actor in yellowface ran longer on Broadway than beloved classics like "Grand Hotel" and "Damn Yankees!" But the...
#120: Les Miserables (2014 revival)
The first revival on the list also happens to be my personal favorite show of all time. In honor of the occasion, I have invited a panel of Les Mis experts to talk about the differences between the stage production and...
#121: Damn Yankees
In honor of Independence Day, we talk about a show that is as All-American as apple pie, featuring America's favorite pastime: selling your soul to the devil. No, no, no -- I mean, baseball! Through the magic of Zoom,...
#122: Grand Hotel
It is classic, quintessential Broadway: the Tommy Tune directed musical, "Grand Hotel." Strangers intersect in a hotel in 1930s Berlin with passion, crime and redemption the natural results, not to mention some snappy...
#123: Contact
"Contact" was such an anomaly on Broadway that it inspired a new Tony Award category: Best Special Theatrical Event. It was a musical with pre-recorded music and a play with almost no dialogue. The producers called it a...
#124: Never Too Late
How do you avoid talking about a dreadful show? You invite on a delightful guest! The so-called comedy, "Never Too Late," was a play that ran for an unbelievable 1,007 performances back in the early 1960s, remarkable...
#125: Beatlemania
How the hell did they get away with this? Join me with a only slightly legalistic consideration of what they were thinking when they made "Beatlemania." It opened in 1977 when sadness about the supergroup's breakup was...
#126: Big River
Join Chasing Phantom for a rollicking ride down "Big River," the 1985 musical based on Mark Twain's "The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn" that ran for 1,005 performances. My buddy, Christopher Haushalter, and I rave...
Posts
No posts yet. Posts Chasing Phantom shares on PodSubs, and what it publishes on Substack, YouTube and its own site, will show here.

Subscribe
Be on the front line of the show
Everything Chasing Phantom sends its own people, first. Resources, announcements, behind the scenes, events, and giveaways, straight from the host. No account needed.
- The resources the host shares with subscribers
- Announcements before anyone else hears
- Behind the scenes from the team
- Events, invitations, and giveaways
- Only what the host sends, nothing else
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
















