Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Chanticleer

Chanticleer artwork

TACO theory rules markets, AI unleashes Telstra and inside Healthscope's collapse

May 30, 202538 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This week, James and Anthony reveal what the new strategy of one Australia’s biggest companies tells us about the coming AI boom, take you inside the biggest corporate collapse since the pandemic and explain the new theory moving the market - the TACO theory. To ask a question, email chanticleer@afr.com This podcast is sponsored by Aussie Broadband. Save 50% or more on unlimited access to the Australian Financial Review in our EOFY sale, ending June 30.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1The Australian Financial Review. Hello, I'm James Thompson, senior chanticleer columnist at the AFI. Welcome to our weekly news breakdown of all things business, finance and markets with me to day as always as my chanticleer colleague. He's worth more than all the shares in Australia's second biggest hospital company put together. It's Anthony McDonald. How are you, Anthony?

Speaker 2Yeah, Fortunately no one and a half billion dollar loan to here.

Speaker 1Jameson absolutely well. This week we reveal what the new strategy of one of Australia's biggest companies tells us about the coming AI boom. We take you inside the biggest corporate collapse since the pandemic, and we explain the new theory moving the market, the Taco theory. But Anthony, let's start with the government decision that's going to shape the country for I don't know forty years. The approval to extend the Northwest Shelf liquefied natural Gas project, which is

Speaker 1operated by Woodside up there in Western Australia. Now, Anthony, the Environment Minister Murray Waite, he was pretty open that this was going to make people unhappy. Whatever his decision, was Did he get it right though.

Speaker 3Well, there's definitely a spicy meat ball of a decision, and yeah, I think it's right. But I mean it's so controversial because it's gas, fossil fuels, climate change's big business. I mean, you're never going to make everyone happy. I mean, in a perfect world, the whole world would have already transitioned from gas and off all fossil fields. We wouldn't even be having this conversation, and would beyond the renewable energy, the extension of the Northwest Shelf would be a no brainer, wouldn't even be needed.

Speaker 2But James, we're just not there.

Speaker 3So we've come around to or realize we're not in this perfect world and the energy transition is not going to be a perfect thing. And the world needs gas. Australia has gas. Australia needs gas and we need it so badly that we're building an import terminal just south of Sydney here, James, which is quite unbelievable really, And there's another one in planning for Downagel Long. But I think this decision, James, was a pragmatic one. You know, the Labor government, they really changed their message on gas in the past year or so. It is the transition feel for the next few decades. And if you're okay

Speaker 3using it here in Australia, James, you've got to be okay extracting it, don't. I think that's what this comes down to. And it's something we do well at Northwest Shelf. It's been operating for decades. This an extension of it. It's a very very big extension. It's our third biggest export. It's good for the country in terms of the country's balance sheet. So yes, the right decision.

Speaker 2What do you think?

Speaker 1Yeah, Look, I think we've been talking for a while on the podcast about how inflation changes everything. It's changed the outcome of all these elections. Most of the incumbents got kicked out because of high inflation, Anthony Alben Easy being the notable exception. But the inflation story has changed the government's few on gas. In the last couple of years, it's become clear that because of inflation in the general populace, the cost of living going up, and because of particularly inflation and construction costs, the energy transition is not going

Speaker 1in the way we want it to or ultimately need it too. It's just going to be slower and tougher and more expensive than we thought. And when you've got affordability problem, you know you need a transition fuel, as you say, to try and get us from one point to the other. Gas has something we've got lots of and you can see in the last twelve months the government's really changed their tune on gas. And Meg O'Neil, the CEO of Woodside, she said exactly that the conversation has changed in the last couple of years as people

Speaker 1are looking at their power bills and going, hang on, why is this going up so far? Don't we have lots of energy here in Australia. So I think you're right pragmatic decision. Does the Northwest Shelf go for another forty years out to twenty seventy Well hopefully not, I guess, but you know that this gives Woodside the certainty it needs to invest certainly over the next couple of decades. So it's the one thing Anthony has taken six and a half years to get this approval in place. That can't be right, That can't be good for any business in Australia. That is something that we need to learn

Speaker 1out of this episode. We've got to move faster on this stuff.

Speaker 3Yeah, just quickly, James, for the Chuck hard Cares out there. Can you think of a busier company in Australia in the past five years? The mood Side, you know, it bought BHP's petroleum business in a really rare script deal I was worth tens of billions of dollars, tried to buy Santos, sold a half share in its plutou up there in the Northwest.

Speaker 2As well.

Speaker 3When Global LNG last year, when it brought into a US project called Driftwood, it now wants to develop that that's going to cost tens of billions of dollars. Yeah, it bought a clean ammonia project in the US that's another two and a half billion dollars US last year, and now it has this Northwest shelf extension and James I saw cities analysts saying that could be a twenty five billion dollar development. It's huge, huge maneuvering from a company that's supposed to be in a sunset industry, whose shareholders voted against this climate plan last year, who's some of whose sharhold has tried to kick the chairman, Richard Goiter out last year.

Speaker 2There's so much going on there.

Speaker 1True, but I think that's the nature of the beast. You know that this energy transition is happening, it needs to happen. It's it's all over the shop, and so Woodside is going to be here, there and everywhere. I think that's what you'll that's what will continue to see that they're going to be need to be very nimble as this as this plays out.

Speaker 3Okay, James has been killing me since the start of this episode. What the hell is the tarco theory?

Speaker 1The tarco theory? Anthony was introduced to me by Anthony Scaramucci, the Mooch, who was famously Donald Trump's press secretary for I think nine days in the first Trump administration. I spoke to him a couple of weeks ago and he said, everyone over here is talking about the taco theory. Trump always chickens out. And since since the Mooch told me about this a couple of weeks ago and I put it in there, He's right, it's everywhere. Because Trump suddenly backed out of these tariff threats against China and against

Speaker 1the EU, and investors just expect that he's going to back out on all these tariff and trade policies now. Interestingly enough, Anthony on Wednesday night, it's a very brave reporter in the Oval Office said Trump, excuse me, mister President, have you heard of the taco theory?

Speaker 2Really?

Speaker 1And he said, that's a nasty question. He said, it might look like chickening out to you, but it's just good negotiating. Well, I'm sorry, Donald, but the market doesn't believe you, mate. They have just decided that you are going to keep backing out of these big threats that you've made. Doge is dead. The restrictions on government spending they're gone, the tariffs they look like they're gone. And so here we are, the markets surging, We're back above the levels we were at Liberation Day. The Wall Street's

Speaker 1only off three percent from its all time highs. No, it's party time out there, Anthony. Does it feel quite right to you that it's party time?

Speaker 3Not really, But I do like your taco theory. Trump always chickens out. Tariffs are coming off, keep the taco is going. It's highly ententitating, isn't it.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's like a Goose Marti Gomez restaurant in here at the moment. Isn't it Alright, Anthony, let's get to our first big topic. And on Tuesday we've got a glimpse into the future when the telecommunications giant Telstra took the wraps off its new five year strategy. Now, Telstra, as we all know is it's a true giant of Australian business. There really wouldn't be too many of us who don't use its network or its digital infrastructure in one way, shape or another. And as we all become more connected, demand for that network and that infrastructure is

Speaker 1only going in one direction. The amount of data going across the network in the past five years has tripled. And if you think of all the stuff you do on your phone, you can understand that. But Anthony, Telstra's got a problem, doesn't It Demands through the roof, investments through the roof, but Telstra is barely getting a return above its cost of capital. Anthony, tell us a little bit about what the cost of capital means and why have Telstra's returns been so poor?

Speaker 2Well, James has been like this for years.

Speaker 3Like Telstra started out with a role gold network owned by the government, subsidized by the government, regulated, lots of political pressure to keep it roll gold service all parts of Australia, you know, the remote and rural stuff. It's a cost center, not a profit center for Telstra, and still is. I mean Telstra's problem is that it's had to keep investing in this network. You know, three G, four G, five G, all that Capex James. It means it's got a premium network, the biggest invest in Australia, and if allays fair in love and war, it should be able to charge premium prices and you know, really

Speaker 3really premium prices. But you know, the two b competitors opt in Vodaphone. While they're small competitive Telstra, they do keep it honest totally. They keep things pretty competitive in the sector. I mean their network works fine for most Australians for most jobs. They do their best to keep the prices low, keep the pressure on Telstra. So Telstra is this big, big gorilla, but the other two have got networks that are competitive at least and that sort of keeps a bit of a cap on Telstra's prices. So this constant reinvestment from Telstra, combined with the pricing pressure,

Speaker 3combined with the regulatory and political pressure which is still there a couple of decades on from the privatization means it Telstra hasn't been able to really get the returns it should have on these really valuable assets. Now, the cost of capital is how much it costs Telstra to borrow how much it should cost capital to spend shareholders money, like what the return is that shareolders they expect, and the returns that shareholders makes the profit It just isn't enough to cover those numbers. Now, in the past, if you bought Telstra shares, you weren't really buying it for its profits, right, You're buying it for its dividend, right,

Speaker 3and you expected it to make normally twenty eight cents a year in dividends it would pay out. You didn't worry so much about the capital growth which would come from the earning scrace and everything, and you just milk the dividends for what they're worth own it for that. Now, if you've owned Telstra shares and lots of strains did, and I think more than one millions still do, it's been a pretty sluggish ride, which is ironic, James, isn't it Because the company at its heart it's about technology.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's technology.

Speaker 3Infrastructure, and what's been a better place to invest in the past decade than technology and tech infrastructure. So it's been a big problem for Telstra James. That leads to the obvious question, what's the CEO, VICKI Brady. What's she going to do about it?

Speaker 1Well, look, the first thing she's going to try and do is, over the next five years, get Telstra's return on invested capital from about eight percent at the moment, which is barely washing its face, up to about ten percent, and that would be absolutely industry leading in the telco sector around the world. How is she going to do it? Well, Anthony, I'm sorry to say, she's going to make you pay. You're going to make us all pay. Look, I mean, at the heart of this is exactly what you said. Telshra's got a premium network. All Telstra's customers tell it all day and all night that it's got a premium network.

Speaker 1It dominates the mobile business. Particularly. What Brady needs to do is extra track the right amount of return for that. So what we'll start to see over the next five years is Telstra sort of offering attributes of that network that people can buy if they need an extra premium service. I'll give you a couple of examples. Let's say you're a you know, you love streaming movies on the go, so you need a really good, really high quality, reliable service for that. Well, telstrall make you pay a little

Speaker 1bit extra for that extra reliability. You're a food vendor right at a big music festival. The one thing it can't go down is your payment system, so you might pay a little bit extra for a guaranteed spot on the network to make that work. You're a business that does artificial intelligence stuff. You need really low latency. You want the bits and the bytes going down the pipes really quickly, so you know you'll pay a bit of extra for that. The idea, Brady says, is to sort of have a good, better, best service and charge people appropriately.

Speaker 1Now that is done, and in every sector you can think of, there's a tiered pricing model. It hasn't been done in telcos. They haven't been good at it. Basically they've built the network and said, look how good this thing is. You know, we might change your data inclusions or your data speeds a little bit, but that's that's that's all. So this is a bit of a step change for Telstra, and as more and more data goes down these pipes, as more and more of us become reliant on the network, it wants to get a return for that, and its shareholders do too.

Speaker 2You know what Teestra could do, James, what's that?

Speaker 3For the ones that are into streaming and for the movies, they could make the first movie free and it could be Jerry maguire And you can sit there listen to someone saying, show me the money, Show me the money, and.

Speaker 2Then everyone can understand what Telstra's on about.

Speaker 1I think they'll have a much more subtle slogan than that.

Speaker 3Yes, but James, you promised us AI. Where does this new revolution come into for Telstra?

Speaker 1Well, look, I mean obviously it comes in through the demand they expect to see across its network that's going to be AI driven. But the message I got was that what Brady's saying is that AI is not some sort of experimental thing now is here. It's using AI to do all sorts of things on its network. So make sure that you know recognize patterns such that it if its network goes down, it can quickly do maintenance. It can do preventative maintenance. I mean one of the interesting things. One of the big costs for Telstra is

Speaker 1power and petrol. So yes, you know you need a lot of you need a lot of energy to keep the network going. But every time there's an outage somewhere on its infrastructure, someone gets in a truck and rolls out there and goes and fixes it. So if you can have AI monitoring and self healing they called it the network, then you can save a lot of money doing that. The other place you can save money is if you can deploy AI into your workforce. Now we're already seeing a little bit of that. When you ring

Speaker 1up Telstra and you get on the ring up the coll center and got an issue, you know, it's a pain in that pain bum No one likes that. Back in the day, they used to have used to have to manually enter the notes from that conversation. Now AI does that for them automatically. Only saves the call center person thirty or sixty seconds per episode, But when you're doing millions of these a year, that starts to add up. Brady was actually quite honest. She said, Look, in five years, the Telstra workforce will be smaller than it is now.

Speaker 1Now We don't know how much smaller? Is it ten percent? Is at five percent? Is it forty five percent? I don't know when Vicky Brady doesn't know, which is fair enough because the tech is developing very quickly here. But we've got a big AI summit coming up next week, Anthony, And to me, this is more proof that this stuff's becoming very real, very quickly, isn't it. I mean, you talked to one of our big data center leaders, Greg Goodman, this week. Where does he think we are in this sort of whole AI revolution.

Speaker 3Ye, our data center leaders Greg Goodman. Now, James, that's a sentence you wouldn't have said like a year ago, let alone two years ago. It's amazing how much this this space, to use Goodman Group's word, is changing. You know, like this is a logistics company that develops warehouses, logistics parks, that sort of stuff. Now it's really leap left into data centers. And he says, it's hot, hot hot, you know, red hot.

Speaker 2You know what, while while we.

Speaker 3Might think that the data centers stories come off the boiler bit, he says, like on the ground, it's still red hot.

Speaker 2It's as hot as ever.

Speaker 3And why it's just it's just the simple message we've been hearing for a while now, James. It's that generative AI, which is the AI that can create new content like text, images, music, and video. And the data demand is going through the roof the big software companies Amazon, Microsoft, Google, Meta, et cetera. They're investing huge sums into AI, tens of billions of dollars a quarter some of them, and they need data centers to make that growth come true. Yeah, So, like I said, he's gone from logistics parks to jump over into data centers and he reckons He's going to have

Speaker 3five hundred megawat's worth a data center started by June next year.

Speaker 2Five hundred megawats is a lot.

Speaker 3He's got one in Sydney at Artaman, just up the road from North Sydney here.

Speaker 2James got one down there for you in Melbourne. Take out of Paris. Back of the envelope.

Speaker 3Five hundred megawats is about five billion dollars worth of development, right, so Goodman Group will find some of that itself. It'll also bring in some capital partners. The names that it brings in James's capital partners and the price at which they come in or the return expectations at which they come in in a I mean, that's the bit that really shows you how hot this sector is.

Speaker 2We don't really have that data yet, but.

Speaker 3If Greg Goodman's to be believed, there's plenty of capital there. It's just a matter of getting the timing right. But for him, he says, for Goodman Group, they've got all these developments. They've been working away at them in the background for a bit, he said, You've got but they're trying to do that prep work as fast as they can, you know, securing the power, securing the approvals, getting all the equipment. He said, there's not many holidays at Goodman Group at the moment because there's this big opportunity there and they're all rushing to get it out. Basically saying, look, don't forget about the data centers theme. It is definitely

Speaker 3not dead. Yeah, fair enough, now, James, speaking of AI, we had inn videos result this week. Can you tell us about it quickly?

Speaker 1Oh? Well, you and your generative AI Anthony, that's so old hat. That's last week, mate. I'm onto agentic AI now, which sounds even cooler, doesn't it. This is all about AI agents now, AI agents they're the ones that they can basically think for themselves. This is where you get an AI agent that can reason, work through a problem, and then take action. So you know, you might have an AI agent that does summarizes the call center transcripts or does some other role in videos. Ideas that we're

Speaker 1going to have a sort of virtual workforce of these that you can just sort of pull off the shelf and say, yep, take that one, Take that one, take that one, And that's where we're moving now. To be fair, that's where AO needs to move because the money is not in mum and Dad sitting at home doing chap GPT searchers on their next holiday. There's no cash in that. The cash is going to come from businesses replacing human workers with virtual workers. It's that simple. Well, it is that simple, and it's that scary, and it's that exciting.

Speaker 1That's where Invidio says we are now and that's the next part of this revolution. So watch out. I think we're going to have a lot of fun at the AI Summit next week chewing through some of what that means for austrained society, because I'm going to have some implications.

Speaker 2Oh yeah, there's a lot going on for our second to be James.

Speaker 3Let's look at Astralia's biggest corporate collapse since virgin This week Hospitals Group Healthscapes lenders finally called in the receivers and when it's sold as soon as possible to try and recoup as much of their loans as they can.

Speaker 2James.

Speaker 3This collapse has been a while in the making, own a brook Field by one of its private equity funds, pay too much and lumped Healthscape with too much debt and rent to survive any longer. Brookfield invested in June twenty nineteen and officially loses control this week. It will dust all of its investment, estimated it to be about two billion dollars, and likely cause Healthscapes, banks and landlords to.

Speaker 2Dust some cash as well. James.

Speaker 3This is a sad corporate story. I mean, it's a very important company, second biggest private hospital's owner in Australia, huge part of the elective surgery production line in particular. It's gone under. Its future is now up in the air. Australia is probably a little bit poorer for it now. It's a tempting to blame Healthscape's private equity owned Brookfield for pushing it too hard on this investment. Do you think this was Brookfield's fault?

Speaker 1Well, Anthony, you put him in the private equity Hall of shame a few weeks ago, so I'd find that hard to argue with. I mean, I think you said it right. They paid too much, They loaded up with too much debt, and they change the sort of nature of the cost base where they got stung by a big shift instructural costs around rent and also wages. Now, did Brookfield see the pandemic coming which unleashed all this inflation? No, you know, fair enough, But things happen in business. You

Speaker 1need to have a business that can withstand a little bit of change or a lot of change. Actually, and this business just hasn't been out of cope with it. Other businesses have. But the debt and the rent agreements, particularly of just hamstrung this business. So look, I think Brookfield has to take the line and share of the blame here. There are some big structural changes in healthcare. We don't like going to have overnight stays in hospital anymore. We like going for day days, and they are eight times cheaper than staying in overnight, and so Brookfield suffered

Speaker 1a bit from that. There's a question about whether the private health insurers are sharing enough of their profits to support the sector. I think that's a legitimate question that we'll see debated. But look, I mean, the company that signs the check has to be the one that bears alts responsibility, I think, and Brookfield's in that position. It's not comfortable, but that's the way it goes. I guess we can keep doing the post mortem forever. But what matters now for you know, the people who are booked in for surgery in the next few weeks. What matters

Speaker 1now is what happens next. So are there potential bidders ready to come forward? They've had months to get ready. Are they going to suddenly step forward and pay a price, make a half decent bid and keep this thing going.

Speaker 3Receiverships should help James, like it really does. I mean, it puts a timeframe on it, puts certain around the outcome. You know, receivers there to sell it. This is for sale. This is not Brookfield flying kites, which we've seen in the past. You know, this gets the lenders together, gets the landlords together, gets Brookfield out of the way, gets Healthscope out of the way, gets Healthscope board out of the way, and says we're doing something like deals like this really are like hurting cats. You need to get everyone on the same page at the same time, and it's so hard to do. Sometimes it's just easy when

Speaker 3you've got an outsider and outsider with sort of legal responsibilities and someone that the court will back if they have to, to take a side here and get something done.

Speaker 2And that's what's happened with the receiver James.

Speaker 3Healthscope CEO this week Tino, who's been He told both of us if Healthscope has three problems, receivership is the best way to fix two of them, too much debt and too much rent. The third one, which you just said, then the structural issues in the healthcare system. Basically, we have more private hospital beds than we need for now at least, which is quite amazing if you think about our aging population total and the demands and you hear hospitals are overrun. All that sort of stuff that can't be fixed by receivership. The fact that, like you said, the models of care, the people not doing as many

Speaker 3nights in hospital that can't be fixed by receivership. The fact that private hospitals are getting less of the private money that goes into the private health sector than they used to, about a billion dollars less according to Ramsey Healthcare. That can't be fixed by receivership either. So there's still some problems there that whoever it is that ends up owning these hospitals is going to have to deal with. Receivership won't change any of those, but it should act as a lightning rod, perhaps for the industry, but most importantly, it'll bring all the parties together.

Speaker 2In terms of this actual deal.

Speaker 3Now, James, perhaps a surprising thing, given what we've seen in some other situations in the past year or two, is that the government has pretty much stayed out of this one. You know, he sat back and it's let a business fail here. Yeah, yeah, Do you think that's a good thing or not?

Speaker 1Well, Look, I mean we've been critical of the government stepping into buy a crappy steel plant in Wuyela and a pretty crappy regional airline called Rex, so you know we shouldn't. We can't slam the government for staying out here. Look, it was very deliberate. The health Minister Mark Butler. He made it clear that there was no way he was going to step in and use taxpayer money to fund a private equity back to business, and he was very clear about that. I think he even said a foreign private equity back to business. So the government wants Brookfield

Speaker 1out of the way too. And so now they've cleared the decks. So the opportunity is there at least for the government to come in and start fixing some of these big problems. But they're going to need to. You know, this isn't just going to heal itself. Butler called I didn't get this. But Butler called health scope and outlier. It's not an outliner. Yeah, private hospitals are struggling big time. And so unless there's a bit of industry reform, unless they sort of use this as the lightning rod, as you say, then we could have another hospital back in

Speaker 1the Sick Bay in the not too distant future. So which brings us, Anthony to what are the lessons here? What are the lessons for the country, for investors, even for the health system.

Speaker 3Oh, James, you know me, and my mind goes straight to deals, the way deals are done, the way these private equity bids sort of work. Yeah, Australia has this thing for assets with infrastructure like properties. All these businesses, they're operating businesses. But anything with a government contract earnings that can be called defensive. The financial engineers can't help themselves, but look at this and say, it's infrastructure like that means we can pay a lot for it. We can load it up with debt, we can run it on a shoe string budget. We can get earnings going up

Speaker 3and then float it back on the ax the suckers out the other side and make some easy money. James, this one makes you think twice. You know that such a defensive business could go bust is almost unimaginable. If you're talking about an investment grade type structure industry player coming in with industry player like debt to equity ratios, it just wouldn't go bust, right, But it's completely understandable when you get your head around the financial engineering the Brookfield had to do just to get this deal done in the first place, and then pile on what happened

Speaker 3in the industry soon after, like you said, COVID, the structural change, etc. So I think it should provide a bit of pose thought really, like what is infrastructure? What sort of businesses should you load up with? Fixed costs like rent and interest payments? How defensive are hospital earnings? You know?

Speaker 2What comes with being the government.

Speaker 3Back sector like private hospitals which wouldn't exist at such scale if we're not for the government mandated and funded private health insurance system and not medicare. What responsibilities come with that in tough times? Like can you just cut costs? Can you get your way through things like you might normally do for a less important business?

Speaker 2For me, that's one of the lessons.

Speaker 3I mean.

Speaker 2The other thing we've.

Speaker 3Heard a little bit this week people saying about FERB, the Foreign Investment Review Board, which looks at all foreign investment in Australia or big ones and property at least, and perhaps they should have a good hard look at themselves. Why did they let such a big deal on a systemically important business like Healthscope happen in the first place in twenty nineteen. It's a good question, right, because first jobs protect the national interest, but normally we see that along security lines. Yeah, you know, Chinese buyers have been

Speaker 3ruled out of buying electricity networks for example, or pockets of national interes. We normally think like the farmers graincop wasn't allowed to be brought by the Canadians because they were worried about the farmers and what it would do to grain supply and the way the grain was moved around in regional areas. But what about bitters blowing themselves up financially on important assets?

Speaker 2Should that be a category?

Speaker 1I don't know. I mean, how does FERB look into the future and say, what if there was a pandemic that sent inflation up to nine percent? Is that realistic?

Speaker 2Anthony? I don't think it is. No, I don't think it's realistic at all.

Speaker 3And if we're getting FERB to be a ruler over financial structures like that, I think the country's lost the plot personally.

Speaker 1Can I give you one lesson?

Speaker 3Yep.

Speaker 1So every year the government, the health minister comes out and sits tells us how much private health insurance premiums are going to rise by Now that health minister likes his job, he wants to be voted in back next time. He never puts through an increase that's probably what it should be. He always tries to get that increase as low as possible. But the problem is, as with lots of things in Australia, we sort of never want to pay for what something's actually worth or actually required, and so we strangle the amount of funding at the sort of top of the funnel, and then we set the

Speaker 1insurers and the private hospitals against each other to try and fight as hard as they can for that artificially constrained pool. I think we've just got to figure out we are getting older, we will get sicker, it is going to cost more, and we've sort of got to cop that. And at the moment we've got this system where we don't let that price signal flow through to the market. We let a bloke who wants to get reelected or a person who wants to get reelected, we let them control where the prices are set. So I

Speaker 1think that's an issue too. Mark Fitzgibbon, who used to run the health insurer NB, he says, get an independent umpire to do that job, take it out of the hands of the politicians. I reckon that's a good start to Yeah, well said, all right, we'll be back after the break, Anthony. We're getting a very important health check for the Australian economy next week back in a second, Well,

Speaker 1welcome back. If you want to know more about what we're talking about today, and a whole lot more. AFR subscribers can sign up to the Chanticleer newsletter at join dot AFI dot com forward slash Chanticleia. Every Saturday morning, the newsletter pulls together the best Chanticleer columns from the week and delivers them straight to your inbox. All right, Anthony, we mentioned on Tuesday where we will be up in Sydney for the AI Summit. I think it's sold out. It is going to be really good. Isn't it a really good sense check of where we're actually at?

Speaker 3Oh? Totally, such good timing for it, James. There's lots and lots happening, as we've spoken about earlier.

Speaker 1Absolutely, on Wednesday we get GDP growth figures here in Australia. Now, we saw the inflation number monthly inflation read during the week. It came in a little bit hotter than we expected. Does that mean a July the rate cut is off the table, Anthony?

Speaker 2Do you think potentially?

Speaker 3I mean, as for this GDP number, I saw a JP Morgan, we're expecting point three percent quarter on quarter growth, which sounds all right, James, But remember the RBA is expecting two point one percent for this calendar year. So yeah, if we are going to hit two point one percent for twenty twenty five, sounds like we're going to need it to pick up in the second half. Yeah.

Speaker 1Well, I mean Paul Bloxham, who's the former RBA economist now at HSBC. He says the maximum, the maximum the economy can grow is two percent now and he reckons where we've really got an issue. So this GDP number is going to be really interesting to see. All Right, on Friday night, we're going to get us job numbers, which leads us into our question for the week. We love questions here at the podcast. Our question this week is from inz Zine from Wollongong. You've got a question you want to send in, you can email us at chanticleer at afi dot com. You can also send us

Speaker 1a question in audio form by recording a voice memo on your phone. Just include your name and where you're from and email.

Speaker 2It to us.

Speaker 1And of course some of you will have noticed that there's now a widget that allows you to ask questions on every chant of clear article on AFI dot com. We're getting great questions through there. Please keep them coming and we'll get to as many as we can. Let's hear from an.

Speaker 4As Anthony and James. I was wondering with the whole US situation. Could you outline the best in worst case scenarios what would happen if US became debt free? And conversely, what would happen if the US government went bankrupt? How did this effict Australia? Thanks, and he's from Wollongong and A.

Speaker 1That's a great big picture question, Anthony.

Speaker 3You want to start all right, let's sing about the US being debt free. The US's debt was worth one hundred and twenty four percent of GDP last year, one point twenty four times GDP, so it had US thirty six trillion dollars in debt and the GDP so that economic activity of the country was worth US twenty nine trillion.

Speaker 2That's a lot of debt, James.

Speaker 3Now that debt would take a lot of repay just to pay the interest on that debt. Don't even worry about paying off the debt. Just to pay the interest on that debt. They're looking at close to a trillion dollars. Yeah a year now, James. Remember the US budget deficit is running close to US two trillion dollars a year, so the debt's actually getting bigger. The interest costs are going up so unfortunately. As I just I find it really hard to see how that debt's.

Speaker 2Going to be paid off in full.

Speaker 3If it does happen, it's going to take It's hard to see it happening in our lifetime. It's going to take a while unless they've got an inheritance from a richar in Saudi Arabia or something. It's just so hard to see it paid down via repayments. I mean the way it could get debt free then via some sort of restructure where the lenders get wiped out like yacks. That is, take your cash out and hide it under the mattress type bad. That is end of day stuff

Speaker 3in terms of financial markets.

Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, I think the best scenario it ads is that the government doesn't have to pay down its debt immediately or even in a hurry, or even entirely. Like a bit of debt for like any household or business, a bit of debt is actually a bit useful. Let's you do things. So the best scenario I think at the moment would be if the government recognized the problem and sort of committed to tackling it over the long term. If it does that, then the people, the bond holders, the people who lend the US government money every ten minutes,

Speaker 1they would say, look, okay, we get it. You know, the US is a responsible borrower. They're doing the right thing. They get the problem, They're going to attack it. That would be the best situation because the cost of money would fall. But at the moment we've got the cost of money rising. It's quite high, and that's because the bondholders don't believe that the government wants to be responsible. They're just seeing them spend like a drunken sailor and cut taxes. So could the US government go bankrupt. It's possible, again,

Speaker 1extraordinarily unlikely. I've seen countries go bankrupt before where they can't meet their debt repayments, and as Anthony says, that is just crazy for the bondholders. They would push the price of money through the roof, and that would come back to bite Australia because all of our banks, for example, they have to go into international bond markets to raise money, and they would need to pay a higher prevailing price for that money. And guess what, the banks just wouldn't eat that cost. They would pass it through to borrowers

Speaker 1down here, and so the cost of money would go up for the entire world. So I mean, that's why the bond market matters, Anthony. That's why when we hear these stories about people becoming worried about the American debt situation, it actually does matter to Australia eventually, and so we want it to get We want them to get it sorted out as well.

Speaker 3Right, absolutely, if the US goes broke, that's like hellscope times are gazillion.

Speaker 1Yeah, well said Anthony. Well, Anthony, before we go today, we wanted to take a moment to pay tribute to an integral member of the Chanticleer podcast team, and indeed, Anthony, the leader of the AFRs podcast division, lap Fan, who is our super producer and the head of podcast here at the Finn, is very sadly leaving us to start a new chapter with his beautiful family in Vietnam. Now, Laps just a brilliant guy. He's calm, he's enthusiastic, he's energetic, and he's relentlessly positive. He's just a great guy to

Speaker 1work with. But I think it's really important to recognize the role he's played in building up the Finns podcasts. From the very first podcast we did, which was an award winning series called The Sure Thing. Go and check it out if you haven't listened, Lap's been the champion of the format inside the finn Now. He's held the hands of countless reporters like us trying to make the format work for the first time. He's worked tirelessly with advertising and marketing and editorial. He's experimented with different formats and ideas, and he's helped bring tens of thousands of

Speaker 1new listeners and read into the AFAR fold. I think Anthony being first through the door, being a pioneer of something is often really hard work and it's sometimes thankless. But Lap, your contribution to the AFR is mighty, and the fact that you've done it with a big, passionate smile on your face is what we'll remember most.

Speaker 2Here, James.

Speaker 3I mean the Seant Clear pod. It wouldn't be here, wouldn't have done as well without Lap. Of all the things that the financial reviews tried in.

Speaker 2The past decade.

Speaker 3I Reckon podcast is right up there in terms of the success and a lot of that credit has to go with LAP is endless energy, enthusiasm, ideas and pursuit of what is a really good form and something that our readers and our listeners have really responded to. So yeah, On, behalf of you, James On, behalf of our other super producer Alex Goer and myself. We'll really miss you, Lap, and we can't wait to come and record a live pod in Vietnam on our next world tour.

Speaker 1Well, we'll see you later, Lap, and we'll see you all next week. Thanks a lot for listening. If you like the podcast and you want to hear more, consider sharing or giving the podcast a review, as it helps other listeners find us, and don't forget to follow wherever you get your podcasts. At The Financial Review, we investigate the big stories about markets, business and power. For more, go to afar dot com and you can subscribe to The Financial Review The daily Habit of successful people at afar dot com slash subscribe. Chanticleer was hosted by me,

Speaker 1James Thompson and Anthony McDonald and it's produced by Alex Gau and lap Fan. A theme is by Alex Gou, head of podcast is lap Fan and the head of premium content is Fiona Buffini. The Australian Financial Review

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Anthropic duds Aussies, recession risk rising & General Pants joins retail bloodbath

    Nov 20, 202631 minAudio

    This week deputy editor Anthony Macdonald and new Chanticleer columnist, Joyce Moullakis dive deep into the deal of the year and the pinnacle of the AI trade, they worry about the big short on Australia and what it says...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Jensen Huang scandal rocks AI, Qantas shows job threat & banks’ wealth comeback

    Nov 13, 202637 minAudio

    This week Chanticleer columnist James Thomson and business editor Anthony Macdonald examine the incredible spy and sex scandal that’s engulfed Nvidia chief executive Jensen Huang, they look at how Qantas ripped the lid...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Midterms spark AI bloodbath, Rate hike reckoning & why Canva cut hard

    Nov 6, 202644 minAudio

    This week, Chanticleer columnist James Thomson and deputy editor of business Anthony Macdonald dissect what might prove to be the biggest news week of the year. They get into troubled Australian companies Canva and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Rates pain puts mince on the menu, Coles serves up a stinker & Anthropic's big moment

    Oct 30, 202643 minAudio

    This week, Chanticleer columnist James Thomson and deputy editor of business Anthony Macdonald reveal why you’ve never seen anything remotely like the $3 trillion float of Anthropic, they explain what more bad news on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. NextDC's electric shock, NAB says 2500 jobs must go & Musk’s $5trn move

    Oct 23, 202644 minAudio

    This week, Chanticleer columnist James Thomson and deputy editor of business Anthony Macdonald jump into a couple of corporate story crackers on NextDC and NAB, preview the piece of data that will make or break...

    Credit the people on this episode