Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Chanticleer

Chanticleer artwork

World holds breath on Iran, $30b deal is test for govt & CEO pay secrets

Jun 20, 202536 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This week on the Chanticleer podcast, James and Anthony try to make sense of the conflict between Israel and Iran, explain why the biggest cash takeover in Australian history is a massive test for Jim Chalmers and ask - do our big CEOs ever miss out on a bonus? To ask a question, email chanticleer@afr.com This podcast is sponsored by Workday.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1The Australian Financial Review. Hello, I'm James Thompson, senior chantic clear columnist at the AFR. Welcome to our weekly news breakdown of all things business, finance and markets. With me today, as always is my chantapleer colleague, the hot air he producers will always be vital to the national interest. It's Anthony McDonald.

Speaker 2How are you, Anthony, feeling some fertile topics to discuss today, James, fantastic.

Speaker 1Well, this week we try and make sense of a conflict between Israel and Iran. Explain why the biggest cash takeover in Australian history is a massive test for Jim charmers, and we ask do our big CEOs ever miss out on a bonus? Well, Athony, let's start there. This week the Australian Council of Superinnuation Investors, which is sort of like a proxy advisory firm for the supersector, put out its annual review of CEO pay and it's safe to say the bosses are still doing all right, with the

Speaker 1median pay of CEOs and the ASX one hundred sitting at four point one five million, which I think is just above your wage, Anthony. But there's a sliver of solace for the ordinary Australian. That median CEO pay is now fifty five times the earnings of an average worker, which is down from seventy one times in twenty fourteen, and it's well below what's happening in the USA, where CEO pay is three hundred and forty eight times the average Gianni or Gina's wage, Anthony, are there any other

Speaker 1trends in this CEO pay survey that you'd like to point us to?

Speaker 2The Golden rules to the big bucks. James and I made the big big bucks. It's pretty simple, isn't it. You just have to run an ASX listed business that is big offshore. You can convince your board to compare your salary to peers or competitors in the US games you are laughing. So the top paid CEO is in order. There are all the companies that have these big US businesses. We've got Robert Thompson from News Limited. They've obviously got dar Jones over there, the publishing assets off Sure, Lavisa's Victor Herrero offshore expansion story, Macquary's Shamara Wick Ramayaka. You know,

Speaker 2a cool thirty million bucks realized pay this financial year. She's got a big global asset manager, big trading house, you know, competes with all the banks on Wall Street. You've got Goodman's Greg Goodman global logistics player, Mick Farrell from their RESMET he's even based in the US, Mike Henry from BHP and Yakov from Rio tinto big global miners. It's pretty simple, James, isn't it. You just got to have a company that competes globally where you can get compared to CEOs in the US and you make the big big bucks. But I think the thing that's worth looking at this year, James, is the amount of CEOs

Speaker 2is again bonuses. And you pointed this out to me. Of the one hundred and forty two CEOs eligible for bonuses, only five got a donut. Only five of one hundred and forty two got zero. So spare thought for them, James.

Speaker 1They must have really done something wrong. Now, Anthony, the first question that comes to my mind is do you happen to know what columnists are paid in America? Because that could help us on the second question is what do you have to do to get no bonus? I mean, were these really the laggards of the AX.

Speaker 2Yeah, laggards of the AX, or the ones that they had particularly troublesome years. I mean one that caught my eye was then Leasa's tiny Lombardo, poor bloke. I mean he had activists up his wazu or year as well. So yeah, I think you basically just have had to have had a shocker or I mean, all the criteria for their bonuses are laid out, investors can read them in the remuneration report. It's generally around total shold or return, you know, the earnings of the company and those sort of things. But James, honestly, I mean, CEOs get paid a lot compared to the ordinary person, don't they. And

Speaker 2I'm not sure you could ever say that one person's worth fifty five times than another. But I mean, i'll tell you why. I mean, most of the CEOs would come across. They do bloody hard. I mean, they are addicted to their jobs. They don't really get much time away, and they've all done years and years of dedicated service to get to where they are. But it's just astounding how those us sort of facing companies just continue to get paid so much more than the rest.

Speaker 1Yeah, is it a surprise then that we don't see too many CEOs make the jump from Australian running Australian companies to US companies. I guess it's hard, probably hard to break into that US market. There's only so many CEO jobs, even in a big market like that.

Speaker 2Yeah, exactly. I don't think there's too many running US businesses, although there are a few. And likewise, James, it's interesting that you get the US CEOs that will come here and run businesses as well. We see them pop up from time to time, so there is a bit of border jumping that goes on. But one undred percent, if you were doing really well running in a strained business, surely you'd be looking at what's going on in the US and say hello, I'd like some of that.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, absolutely.

Speaker 2And James, speaking of Payer, I couldn't believe my eyes when I saw that Meta Platforms, which owns Facebook and WhatsApp and Instagram, is offering sign on bonuses of one hundred and fifty million dollars to AI engineers. Seriously, who should earn that sort of money?

Speaker 1Come on, Anthony, I mean, we see soccer players and baseball stars and basketball stars traded for that sort of coin all the time. I mean, hey, we're always saying that, you know, we undervalue science compared to sports. So here's an example where we're not doing that and never runs up in arms. It's a bit I reckon. There's a bit of double standards here. Look, look, it's a lot of money though, but why would you pay someone that sort of money. The reason you pay that someone that

Speaker 1sort of money, if you Meta Platforms, is because you think getting their skills on board is going to make you an extraordinary amount of money in return. You know. So if Meta Platforms is hiring AI engineers for one hundred and fifty million dollars, if they're looking to spend I think it's about one hundred billion dollars on AI infrastructure just this year alone. I mean, the pie that they're chasing has to be in the trillions of dollars, doesn't it.

Speaker 2It sure does, James. But it worries me as consumers of all these products, like how much are we going to be paying for them? If they can afford to be paying people one hundred and fifty million dollar sign on bonuses, what are they going to be selling their AI products for? They will be milking customers.

Speaker 1I think you're worried, is right. I mean, and I've said this before, if AI used to deliver these trillion dollar returns that everybody's betting they will, and everybody includes everyone who owns who has a super fund account. We're all up to the wazoo to use your phrase in AI stock through our super So how do those trillion dollar returns come through? They come through If the customers of these AO giants are prepared to pay big money to use the AI services. What are those services, Anthony? It's imagine AI agents replacing your entire call center, or

Speaker 1imagine AI agents that could inside a bank process loan documents and give loan approvals. Even now, why would the customers of the AI giants be prepared to pay to use these services because they know they can make more profit in turn? How do they make more profit in turn by reducing their biggest cost people, So, I think you've got to connect these two things. The reason someone is prepared to pay one hundred and fifty million dollars sign on bonus for an AI engineer is because somewhere

Speaker 1down the track, they think there's a big saving going to be had from taking out lots of people inside of business. I mean, the only I've said this before, the only way AI delivers returns is through unemployment. It is an ugly, ugly, ugly truth, but there it is. We can't sort of ignore it. Am I wrong, Anthony? Am I getting too doomy again?

Speaker 2Speed thought? Isn't it to think that one person collects one hundred and fifty million bucks and their job is to put how many other people have a job?

Speaker 1Yeah?

Speaker 2But I guess that's the way this is all going.

Speaker 1Yeah, absolutely, Okay, Anthony. Let's move to a look frankly equally glum first topic, and that's this week's news, which has been dominated by the latest tragic conflict in the Middle East between Israel and Iran, which appears to be turning well, really increasingly nasty, particularly for the civilians who are caught up in it, Anthony. As we record on Friday morning, things are sort of on a bit of a knife edge, with the world still waiting to see whether Donald Trump will lead America into the conflict. Now, Anthony,

Speaker 1Donald Trump initially sort of distanced himself from these Israeli attacks, but now he seems to want in on them. He's saying we could attack anytime in the next two weeks. What do you think has changed in the sort of American view of this conflict?

Speaker 2Yeah, James, big week for the world this week. I mean, it's not a market story, it's human stories, and it years of history, intentions boiling over. What changed this week, James, was the bombing obviously intensified. It's up to seven or eight days now. The israelis targeting key bits of infrastructure around Iran's nuclear program and key military officials. Iran seems to be doing what it can to stay in the game and say it won't surrender. But what changed. The US just beefing up its presence, beefing up its forces in the region, James, Like, It's sent a third US Navy destroyer into the eastern Mediterranean Sea. In a second

Speaker 2US carrier is heading over to the Arabian Seas. It's just emerged that President Trump has sort of privately approved these Israel's attack plans. It's raising the question of is the US about to join or not? You know, it's been a will he or won't he sort of story all week, James. I mean, Trump's playing a long He literally told reporters in the White House on Wednesday. I may do it, I may not do it. I mean, nobody knows what I'm going to do, right, and then this morning we wake up to this whole. I might do it in the next two weeks. I've got a

Speaker 2two weeks sort of timeframe thing, and it's pretty astonishing. I'm not sure we've seen too much like this, have we, James.

Speaker 1No, that's right. I think what Trump is probably sensing is that, you know, America and Iran have been at loggerhead's tension over the Iranian nuclear program for a long time. And I think Trump. Trump's good at seeing someone's weakness. You know, he loves this negotiating master negotiator stuff, and he can see is Iran is sort of down for the count. Here is this the chance to finally take that Iranian nuclear question off the table once and for all.

Speaker 1So I think that's where he's going. But yeah, the whole you know, I could do anything in the next two weeks. I mean, we know that Donald, you could do anything at any time. We've seen that in the last few months. So he's a master showman.

Speaker 2If nothing else, James, I wanted to bring a reader question in here, and we've got a marvelous one from Victori or Reid, who's the sister of our economics correspondent Mike Read. She'd send in a question, and the hope of going to the top of the family leaderboard for the most impressive red child, and the fact she's made it to the Chanticle podcast. I think she now is James. Her question also gets right to the heart of the market's response on this hijuks.

Speaker 3Oil markets have shot up off the back of the Iran is Ral conflict jud to Iran's role in global oil supply. If supply continues to be impeded, how can we expect global markets to respond? Can other OPEC nations and the US increase their supply easily? And what are the flow on effects of oil price increases into other markets and economies? Thanks?

Speaker 1Well, the first thing I've got to say is how good would Christmas that the Reeds be. I don't know if we'd be able to keep up with the conversation around the table, but it's a great question, Victoria. I mean, really, oil is at the heart of the market's response. We've seen oil's been funny this year. It's gone from about eighty bucks US a barrel in January down to fifty five dollars US of barrel in May, which we all saw at the petrol bowser some comparatively cheap fuel. After this,

Speaker 1it's shot back up to around between seventy five dollars and eighty dollars a barrel. So these aren't crazy prices. This isn't a massive spike. But I think the longer this drags on, the more worried we are that we could see the next set of actions that pushes oil up towards US one hundred and twenty bucks a barrel. What would need to happen, Well, it's not so much about the oil that Iran produces. That's only about one percent of world supply. What everybody's worried about is that Iran might close the Strait of Formuz, which is key

Speaker 1waterway in the Middle East through which about twenty percent of the world's oils flows. So you know, if we see attacks on ships in that strait, if we see a mining of the strait, you know c mines, if we see general sort of blockades of straight then that would take out a lot of oil and we could see oil go up to one hundred and twenty bucks, So you know, it's a possibility that would have big flow and effects from markets. There'd be a panic on Wall Street and probably on the AX. Those panics tend

Speaker 1to fade pretty quickly. Global economy is not as reliant on oil as it was, say, back in the nineteen seventies when we had a famous oil shock, So you know, it's not probably not the end of the world, but it would be a sort of nasty moment, particularly given that markets are stretched, they're expensive, they're overcrowded at the moment, so you know, you want to watch for that. So what we've got, though, Anthony, is a whole lot of armchair generals strategists trying to figure out how likely it

Speaker 1is that Iran takes that sort of action. You know, does Iran get pushed into a corner where they feel they need to do some real damage to the global energy complex to get everyone's attention and calm this down. Not sure, blocking that straight is something they hadn't tried in fifty years, And imagine the reaction if they do try and do that. Attacks on US ships in that area, for example, could be the trigger that really brings the US in to sort of wipe a run off the map.

Speaker 1So there's so many combinations and permutations here. But the question is, does Iran do something to disrupt the broader Middle East energy complex? We haven't seen it yet. I think if we avoid that then oil and markets will be okay. If we do see them take that step, then we could see a sort of short term shock to markets that would be pretty unpleasant. But Anthony, the other thing that was happening as all this was unfolding

Speaker 1was the G seven in Canada. Now, Anthony Albanize he trooped over there. He's not Australia, he's not in the G seven. We're on the periphery. We're a friend of the family, so to speak. And it was all set to have this big meeting with Donald Trump. But then, of course the Donald decided he had to leave the G seven early before Albaneze could meet with Trump. Who's the bigger loser here? Is Elbow upset that he's missed the Donald? Or is the Donald upset that he's missed Elbow.

Speaker 2I doubt Trump's thought about it again, James, Yeah, it's a blow for Anthony. Aberezi absolutely like him. Or lumping. President Trump is the most powerful leader in the world. He's the head of the worlds because the economy hugely important. You know, Australian Anthony Albanese don't have to necessarily like President Trump, don't have to like his politics, but I think it's pretty important we get in front of him, James. And since Trump's Trump was reinaugurated in late January, I mean he's been met with a procession of leaders who've been making their way to the White House to congratulate him and ask for stuff, and that stuff's usually to

Speaker 2go easy on Tariff's Albaneze hasn't made the trip and was hoping to get the job done with a meeting on the sidelines of this G seven summit, Like you said, James in Canada this week, you know they're both there was looking all good and then Donald walked out like Don Bradman, the overly nineteen forty eight James when he needed four runs to average one hundred and he got a duck. So Donald Trump, he was out of there, back home to deal with the Middle East. And he's he's clearly not a work from anywhere guy, Donald Trump, James, but out top reporter in Canberra, Phil Courry. I thought

Speaker 2he's been in Canada too on the trip, so you can imagine the disappointment if you're a reporter on that trip. But I thought he put it nicely, James. He said, meeting Trump has become the box that Alberanize needs to tick. And you know, sure, Albanize he got to meet a couple of other people while he was over there, including your man Scott Besson, who's the Treasury Secretary. But it's just not the same, is it. You know, you're you're running the country, you're representing Australia. It's your job to get in front of these leaders. And I think he's just got to get it done.

Speaker 1There is a sort of pressing issue. That great tariff pause ends on July eighth.

Speaker 2That's right, it's just around the corner. It best In has flagged the deadline will be extended for those nations currently negotiations. So Albin easy, he's got a little room to move. But James, like, I'm wondering, what doesn't Alberanisi just go and knock on the White House door.

Speaker 1Well maybe he's maybe Elbow's worried he's going to get a President Zelenski moment, you know he's going to have JD. Vance yelling at him. Or there was that South African president who also got the sort of rounds of the White House kitchen. So maybe Albo is a bit sensitive. He doesn't want to be yelled at by Trump and Vance.

Speaker 2Either way, James, I think Albo has just got to tear the band aid off and get this meeting done.

Speaker 1Yeah, but just quickly, James.

Speaker 2While Albo was in Canada, Federal Treasurer Jim Chalmers, he was in Canberra giving a big set speech on the government's economic agenda. What did you take from that?

Speaker 1It was a love letter to the AFR. How many times to reckon the word productivity was mentioned? How many twenty eight? What a beautiful thoodol no I could feel. Michael Stutchbury, our former editor in chief, great productivity campaigner, he would have been drooling over this one. Now have a read of the paper on Saturday. I'm sure he'll take some issue with Charmer's approach. But look, we're gearing up for this productivity round table which will be held around the apparently around the cabinet table. Anthony twenty five

Speaker 1seats around the cabinet table. So I'm not sure you and I will be invited, but I think we'd have a bit to contribute. Look, i mean, the headline here was about tax reform. Charmers has said, bring it on, I'm ready to discuss it. He even gave a little message to the media, gave a message to you, Anthony, he said, don't play the rule in this tax change and rule out that tax change. But then Charmers strangely went and said, I'm not going to touch the gsts.

Speaker 2Only one person can play.

Speaker 1That game exactly what a reverse ferret. So look, I mean, we'll see where all this goes. But you know, hey, Cutos to Charmers, they've got a mandate. We've said what are you going to do with this mandate? Can you do some big picture stuff? And Chalmers is you know, provided a speech that said, yeah, let's talk about it. Let's let's think about some big picture stuff. So look, I think if that discussions entered into in the right way, maybe even in a bipartisan way, you know, let's see that. Let's see the Libs and the Nationals throw up a

Speaker 1few good ideas and be prepared to have them kicked around. As well. I don't know. Look, I'm trying to be optimistic about this, Anthony. Let's have the discussion and let's let's have it in a try and have it in a normal, sensible way.

Speaker 2I reckon, Yeah, I agree, James. I mean there's always cynicism around, you know, around tables and discussions and reviews and talk of things like tax reform, and none of it matters at all until you get to the end of it and decide whether you're going to do something or not. But what else is the government supposed to do? Right, You've got to kick off these things somehow, and I think they're making the right noises, so you know, credit to them, and let's hope that something useful comes out of it. Yeah, well said, Let's get to our second topic, James. And this week we got the m and A deal of the year, a blocks bust, that thirty billion dollar

Speaker 2cash bit Frustralia's second biggest oil and gas company, Santos Now James, having been shopped to every oil major and sovereign wealth fund for years, the Emiratis took the bait, turning up with bids at eight dollars and eight dollars sixty share in March, before returning with a best and final offer of eight dollars eighty nine a share at the end of last week. James, the timing is stunning. I mean, we've just been talking about this Middle East conflict that could have a potentially huge impact on the oil price. Santos's board has acted pretty decisively and said, yep,

Speaker 2good bid. If you can stand it up, we'll recommend it to shareholders. So the bidder, which is calling itself the XRG Consortium, but really most of the money looks like it's the national oil company from the UAE, and then there's private equifirm Carlo as well. It's getting an exclusive look at Santos's books and if it can stand the offer up, Santos is basically it's for the taking. Now, James, were you surprised that Santosis board could act with so much certainty given all the uncertainty in energy mark It's yeah, good.

Speaker 1Question, Anthony. I mean I think so as you said, they've been shopping this business around for the best part of you know, two or three years. They finally find a bitter with enormously deep pockets willing to pay all cash willing to just take the whole business in one chunk, nothing, no funky sort of you know structuring to this deal. I mean, surely you've got to say, yep, yes, please, we want to put this to shareholders. This is a deal that we think stands up. I think that's totally understandable.

Speaker 1How does the Middle East conflict play into that? I think if you're on the Santos board, you'd be saying, look, there's plenty of conflict in the Middle East already hasn't really affected the oil price, and so they'll be you know, thinking, look, whatever happens here is probably a short term issue, and you know, we've got to run our business for the long term. So I get that, but it's a really difficult one for Santos. You know, they've tried so many things. They've tried, looked at a merge with Woodside, the other big oil and gas player in this country, sort of

Speaker 1fell over very quickly. They've had activists suggesting breakup plans come to nothing. So when you've got one bitter, as I say, with huge resources, ready to buy the whole thing from you in cash, I think that's pretty hard not to put that offer to shareholders even though there is uncertain in the world. There's always uncertain in the world. But Anthony, we've got a really good question from a reader, Cheryl cart right in Victoria, and I'd like you to like you to have a crack at answering it. She says,

Speaker 1why can't Santos unlock its own value? Why is it better to have Australian resources in foreign hands, particularly the hands of a foreign government. I think that's a really important point Cheryl makes here. Santos basically becomes a foreign government owned oil company if this still goes through.

Speaker 2Right, Yeah, absolutely, In terms of the first part of the question, James, I mean, yeah, Santos could in theory unlock its own value. It's one of those companies whether some of the parts is worth more than the whole on paper. And Santos has been talking for years about doing stuff to unlock that value. James, asset sales, infrastructure sales, farm downs, joint ventures, everything. It's had more reviews than the Phantom of the Opera would have had over the years. It honestly is always just flooded with bankers trying different things. You know, whether it's heart's been in actually doing something

Speaker 2or not. I mean, that's sort of another question. And why, James, why haven't they been able to do anything? What turns out that all those various assets that it's got, they've worth more on paper when you look at them by themselves, but they're actually not that valuable to other parties on their own. You know, they might be a bit small on their own, they might be subject to preemptive rights, or only attractive to a small player who doesn't have the cash flows to develop them, you know. And oil and gas, James, it's all about scale, the big companies getting bigger. Santos is a big fish here. It's relatively bite size compared to the other places globally. And it's portfolio,

Speaker 2it's it's quite separated, right, you know, Like it's got a big stake in an LNG plant in p and G. It's got g LNG, which is l and G up in Gladston, it's got other assets in Australia, the center of Australia and WA. Like they're quite sort of separate now, each of those things on their own. You know, sure, sure they're big enough, but they're not that big, they're not that not that meaningful. So that portfolio being all over the place. It's those assets are too small for a big bit of like XIG just to pick off

Speaker 2one or two. You know, wants it wants the whole thing. So so I'd say Eryl, like Santos has been trying and the method it's ended up with basically is just trying to get a bid for the whole thing. I mean, that's what they think is the cleanest. That's the value realization strategy here. It's the one they've got from the Emiratis, and the Santos board locked it in last weekend. I mean, as for the second part of the question, why is it better to have Australian resources in foreign hands, particularly of a foreign government? I mean, Cheryl, I mean, she has hit the nail on the head with this one.

Speaker 2This is the question for the takeover. I think everything's going to live or die on this. James Hu you picked it up straight away in your first Take column on Monday morning when this came out the Foreign Investment Review Board. It's going to come down to ERB, It's going to come down to the treasurer. Countries globally, they're turning inwards. Governments are getting protectionists. This is an energy company. We still haven't worked out what our energy system looks like for the long term, where you know, how we're going to transition from the fossil fhels to the renewables. What's the likelihood do you think the government says go

Speaker 2for it?

Speaker 1Ye're not great, probably, but I think there's one caveat to that. And just to explain the process, So the Foreign Investment Review Board, it gets first crack at reviewing a deal like this, and then it passes a bunch of advice onto the Treasurer Jim Charmers, who has the final sort of veto, right, I guess you'd call it so often the Treasurer would just say thanks, ferb, you've done a great job.

Speaker 3Tick.

Speaker 1But I think this one, it really is going to come down to It's going to be a decision Charmers has to make. So the sort of immediate response is no, we don't want these critical Australian assets in foreign hands, not only for national economic reasons and national security reasons, but for political reasons. Jim Chalmers won't expect too many high fives for a decision like that. The one caveat I've got, Anthony, is that we do need to get more gas out of the ground. Yeah, like it or not,

Speaker 1it's the transition fuel that is the practical answer at the moment. So we're going to need more gas, and there is a question as to whether who's better to pay for the development of that new gas. Is it Santos as a standalone listed company that has all those challenges attracting capital, or is it Abu Dhabi Inc. With deep pockets and lots of oil money that it's more than happy to spend. So maybe there's a compromise where

Speaker 1for chalmershe does a deal where he gives approval conditional on the new owners investing a certain amout out in unlocking new gas supply. That might be a way he can have his cake and eat it too. He can say, hey, look, you know, I know how important energy and affordability and energy security is. I've just guaranteed that this mob is going to spend thirty billion dollars on gas. I'm picking a number at random, thirty billion dollars on gas investment

Speaker 1over the next thirty years. That might be one way through it, but it's going to be a hugely tough decision. Anthony. The other thing. I mean, as you said, this is the third, the third set of takeover talks on Santos in three in that you and I have covered in the past decade. I mean, what is it about this thing that it keeps attracting bids and what if this one falls over? Is there a bit of last chance saloon about this?

Speaker 3Oh?

Speaker 2There definitely is. But he's so unique, James, for top fifty companies have two bids in a decode let alone three rupt you now, I mean, there's something quite magical about santa And like, there's a few things going on, a big a few global forces and a few sens or specific things. I mean, the first one is the cost of doing business in oil and gas James. It's through the roof. You've got a rising environmental regulations, your planning approvals, construction costs, it's just way more expensive to get a project up and running now than it used to be. That's making developers and producers like Santos's lives harder.

Speaker 2How do you combat that, Well, one of the ways is to chase scale. So the bigger you are, you should be able to do things more efficiently. So we've got a situation where the bigger just hoovering up assets and trying to get that scale to protect their margins. And then the smaller are sort of disappearing. At the same time, James, you've also got less capital around it. It's that green sort of discount over these companies is really hurting. So some capital has fled the sector or it's much more choosy. Right, So companies they now need to be able to fund their own developments rather than tapping equity markets to do them do it for them,

Speaker 2or getting banks or a new investor whatever. So you have to be big in order to be able to become the next big thing to beause you need to be able to big to have the cash flows now to fund the developments that will be your next project. So the small end of the sector, it's just capital starved and it's all about it's all about being big now, James. If you want to get big and you're an acquirer, there's not that many opportunities of scale around in good jurisdictions, and Australia is still one of them. There's just not that many assets up for the taking. And here you've got Santos, You've got a board that is repeatedly engaged

Speaker 2with bidders, so it's clearly up up for a deal with decent assets, large enough for someone like an XIG to take the whole lot and to make a difference. So there's few targets. Santos is one of them. And then overlaying all this, James is a life on the ASEX. It's not been that easy for Santos. Like I said, Santos has tried a few things to create value. Most recently it committed to return more cash to investors and be disciplined about production growth. I mean, that's something that I've heard fund managers talking about for fifteen years. On Santos,

Speaker 2it finally commits to do it. The shep ross go up, not really, I mean this thing just bounces around with the oil price steal. So I think I think there's a few factors there. But Santos's board, i think it was about eight years ago, got a bid from private equity and at the time, yeah, you know, the bid was good, was good enough price. But at the time they had this new CEO, Kevin Gallagher, that had just come in and the board kind of said, well, yeah, why should we take this private equity mob's money. Let's just back this Kevin Gallagher bloke to do his turnaround plan and make money for shelters for us, and sure

Speaker 2enough they so they turned down the bid and they went with Gallagher. You know, fast forward to today, James and Gallagher is probably closer to the finish than the end total, and they don't really have that next that next executive up with the turnaround plan that could make them maybe want to reject something like this on evaluation grounds. So it's pretty eavenly poised. What's your gut feeling, James, what's the probability of success do you think in terms of this deal getting over the line?

Speaker 1A great question. Fifty to fifty for me, I really don't know, but I reckon fifty to fifty, and I reckon there's we'll still be talking about this in six months. What's your what are your numbers?

Speaker 2My gut pheel James says that he's easier to block this thing than it is to accept it. I mean every few years, for the past fifteen years, we've had a big deal like this go to the treasurer and get knocked back. We had Asex Limited, we had Grand Court, we had APA Group, we had Osgrid. They're rejected for various reasons, could be security, national interest, but it's basically a combination of those two things. This thing, James, that it's energy policy, energy security. We know that Australia's not been good at that. Like you say, perhaps there's a

Speaker 2way forward for the Adnock, the UAE company to offer something to the government and the government to take it. And there are a few things that could offer. Like you say, it could commit to invest capital needed to unlock the be Toloo Basin, which could be Australia's biggest ever gas reserve. Santos is a big player there. It could do that. It could commit to not take so much money domestic gas to feed into GLNG, which is their nextplorider offshore. So there are things that it could offer. But without offering those things, James, I just reckon. My gut's telling me that this one will struggle.

Speaker 1Yeah, all right, lots to play out. We'll come back after the break and discuss a deal that is happening and it's one of the most exciting of the year. On the ASEX back in a second, welcome back. If you want to know more about what we're talking about today and a whole lot more. AFR subscribers can sign up to the Chanticlear newsletter at join dot afi dot

Speaker 1com forward slash Chanticleer. Every Saturday morning, the newsletter pulls together the best hnticle columns from the week and delivers them straight to your inbox. Very exciting day on Tuesday, Anthony, and not just because you're hosting the afr's first insurance forum. It would be good, yeah, sector at the moment, but on Tuesday we have the first big IPO in a while. Really, Virgin Australia is going to retake to the public boards by listing on the AX now, Anthony issue price two

Speaker 1dollars ninety been very well supported this thing. Is it going to fly or stay grounded? Will the shares finish the day higher or will they be lower on their first day?

Speaker 2Five percent high? As my guest James, look, this is a coming home party for Virgin Australia. The AX is where it belongs. It's where it would have been if it hadn't gone broke. That's where it used to be. So yeah, I think I think most investors are looking forward to seeing it back. It doesn't mean everyone's going to buy it. In fact, a lot more people won't buy it than will. But I think we get an okay reception. What about you?

Speaker 1Yeah, I think it's going to get a good reception that the only I think five percent up is a good guess. It could get trumped though, if the Donald goes into Iran oil price go through the roof. Airline stocks are very sensitive to very sensitive to oil prices. Maybe that's the only thing that holds it back on day one. But the reception for this has been good and it is great to see a big new business joining the AX or rejoining the AX. And then on Wednesday, Anthony,

Speaker 1we'll get monthly inflation numbers. Inflation is looking pretty good around the world, so hopefully the good story continues.

Speaker 2Right, yeah, absolutely, well.

Speaker 1We loved answering your questions during the episode today. If you've got a question you want to ask us, email us at Chanticleer at afar dot com and you can also send us a question in audio form. Just record a voice memo on your phone, include your name and where you're from, and email it to us. And of course the widget on the on the Chanticleer articles at afar dot com is always there as well. And I must say, Anthony, you don't need to be a family member of one of our journalists to get your question on you.

Speaker 2Absolutely.

Speaker 1All right, Well, it's been an the big week. We'll see where Virgin goes next week. We'll see where where the Iran Israel conflict goes next week, and we'll see how markets do. It's a nervous time out there, I reckon, Anthony.

Speaker 2Yeah, I agree with you, James. Like you said, valuations are still high. Everyone's sort of holding on, just hoping that nothing too too bad from the market's perspective sort of spills over. Yeah.

Speaker 1Absolutely, it's going to be another big week. We'll see you next week. Thanks for listening. If you like the podcast and you want to hear more, consider sharing or giving the podcast a review, as it helps other listeners find us, and don't forget to follow wherever you get your podcasts. At The Financial Review, we investigate the big stories about markets, business and power. For more, go to afar dot com and you could subscribe to The Financial Review. The daily Habit of successful People at afar dot com

Speaker 1slash subscribe Chanticle was hosted by me James Thompson and Anthony McDonald, and it was produced by Alex Gau assistance from Mandy corn. A theme is by Alex Gou. Head of Premium content is Fiona Baffinia The Australian Financial Review

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Anthropic duds Aussies, recession risk rising & General Pants joins retail bloodbath

    Nov 20, 202631 minAudio

    This week deputy editor Anthony Macdonald and new Chanticleer columnist, Joyce Moullakis dive deep into the deal of the year and the pinnacle of the AI trade, they worry about the big short on Australia and what it says...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Jensen Huang scandal rocks AI, Qantas shows job threat & banks’ wealth comeback

    Nov 13, 202637 minAudio

    This week Chanticleer columnist James Thomson and business editor Anthony Macdonald examine the incredible spy and sex scandal that’s engulfed Nvidia chief executive Jensen Huang, they look at how Qantas ripped the lid...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Midterms spark AI bloodbath, Rate hike reckoning & why Canva cut hard

    Nov 6, 202644 minAudio

    This week, Chanticleer columnist James Thomson and deputy editor of business Anthony Macdonald dissect what might prove to be the biggest news week of the year. They get into troubled Australian companies Canva and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Rates pain puts mince on the menu, Coles serves up a stinker & Anthropic's big moment

    Oct 30, 202643 minAudio

    This week, Chanticleer columnist James Thomson and deputy editor of business Anthony Macdonald reveal why you’ve never seen anything remotely like the $3 trillion float of Anthropic, they explain what more bad news on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. NextDC's electric shock, NAB says 2500 jobs must go & Musk’s $5trn move

    Oct 23, 202644 minAudio

    This week, Chanticleer columnist James Thomson and deputy editor of business Anthony Macdonald jump into a couple of corporate story crackers on NextDC and NAB, preview the piece of data that will make or break...

    Credit the people on this episode