This is the Depth Dossier: the South Florida Bulls, Week 11.
South Florida put up 41 points, out-gained Memphis, held the ball for nearly twice as long, and still walked out of a 52 to 41 loss wondering how that's possible.
The Bulls dug themselves a 21 to nothing hole early, then played nearly even football the rest of the way behind quarterback Luke Kromenhoek's career day. He threw for and ran for four total touchdowns, piling up 416 total yards with 146 of those on the ground. Running back Jason Collins Junior, starting in place of an injured D.J. Crowther, broke off a 75-yard touchdown run and caught a scoring pass too. Wide receiver Mudia Reuben set career highs with six catches for 98 yards and two touchdowns. USF even took a 41 to 38 lead with just over eight minutes left. But Memphis answered right back with a 76-yard touchdown pass, and USF's final chance died on a failed fourth and two at the Memphis four-yard line with under four minutes to go.
So how do you out-gain a team by that much and still lose? That's really the whole story of this game. USF held the ball for over 37 minutes, ran 90 plays to Memphis' 68, and racked up 552 yards of offense. None of it mattered because Memphis didn't need long drives. It needed big plays, and it got them, including that back-breaking 76-yard touchdown that erased USF's first lead of the game.
The number that's going to stick from this one is Kromenhoek's workload. Thirty carries from a quarterback is the most by a USF player since running back Marlon Mack ran 31 times back in 2014. It's a stat line that usually belongs to a running back, not a passer, and while it helped keep the comeback alive, it came with seven sacks and 44 rushing yards lost behind the line. That's worth watching if this becomes a regular workload instead of a one-time thing.
Special teams played a real role too. A 36-yard punt return from Joshua Porter helped spark the comeback, and a missed 61-yard field goal by Memphis handed USF the ball at its own 42, which USF turned into points. Kicker Nico Gramatica made both his field goals when it counted, including a 38-yarder that gave USF its only lead of the game.
USF actually converted five of eight fourth downs, including a fourth and one that kept the comeback going. But the one they didn't convert, that fourth and two at the Memphis four, was the only one that actually decided the game. Head coach Alex Golesh's postgame comments about players smiling for pictures after the loss, which he called a "loser mentality," are worth filing away as something to watch about this team's culture rather than just a one-game reaction.
Now to the depth chart, and the biggest question is still Crowther's health. He was a pregame scratch after being listed as questionable, with no diagnosis reported, and whether he's back next week is the most important thing to track on this roster. In his absence, Collins Jr. didn't just fill in, he was explosive, going for 108 yards on just 12 carries with that 75-yard touchdown and a receiving score on top of it. That's a performance that's going to be hard to bury in a committee backfield even once Crowther's healthy.
Reuben's six-catch, 98-yard, two-touchdown game, capped by a 44-yard catch on the final drive, makes him look like Kromenhoek's clear top target, a role that wasn't settled coming into the week. And Kromenhoek's big day keeps validating the staff's decision to build the offense around him. The question now is how much longer a 30-carry, seven-sack workload is sustainable before it turns into an injury risk instead of a weapon.
Nothing is official yet on the offensive or defensive lines, but with USF again unable to hold a fourth-quarter lead, the protection in front of Kromenhoek and the pass rush that gave up that 76-yard touchdown are both things worth watching as the staff sorts out personnel heading into next week.
This was the depth dossier. For everything college football, be it depth charts, data or dossiers, head over to C F B Depth dot com. We will be back next week. This was an AI-generated podcast from content developed by real human beings passionate about college football.