Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Caribbean Rhythms

Caribbean Rhythms artwork

EPISODE 214: SOVIET END

Apr 26, 202649 minAudio

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.bronzeagepervert.yoga The second of a three (or four) part series on the end of the Soviet Union and the rise of the oligarchs: in this part I talk Trump assassination attempt, and the coming apart of the Soviet economy, the subterranean black market economy, and just the beginnings of the oligarch era with special attention on the reformers to capitalism and political freed…

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Yes, welcome to Caribbean Rhythms. And it is April 25, Saturday, just a few moments ago. There was another attempt assassination on hegemon Trump at the White House correspondent dinner. And what is there to say? I don't know who it is. I guess in normal circumstance of, let's say, ancient Greek city, Mr. Trump would have the right to call. And I think he should do this. Why? Just reach for the brass ring, Mr. Trump.

SPEAKER_00Ask to become Commandator Trump. Come in front of the people. Do not worry about how your physique look. Just upper body. Lay bare your upper body to the nation. And maybe leather pant, but you come with oiled upper body in front, very confident of cameras. And you demand a 400-man bodyguard for your safe keep. Because of all these assassination attempts. And then you declare commandator.

SPEAKER_00Look, I don't have much more to say on this. I guess we find out in time what leftard it is. Actually, topic for this episode and the next couple of them I'm doing on not unrelated. It is on the transformation of Soviet Union into Russia and Russia. In the early oligarch so-called years, the transition phase of Russia in the 1990s, a wild time,

SPEAKER_00complete wild shift freedom time, anarchy, where when any, of course, full of assassinations. So any prominent businessman, a politician, journalist certainly would need own private army. Of course, journalists could never afford that. So many of them got offed during that time. But on this episode, I want to go back just a step prior to 1980s Soviet Union.

SPEAKER_00Explain for you situation then, life in Soviet Union, communist bloc, but especially the Russia, Russia-Soviet, to explain what was going on, how it transitioned to end of communist bloc system. And I want to maybe would you eat from Moscow, 1980s vegetable repository, green pepper, tomato special aged, you know, like now they have a nice steakhouse.

SPEAKER_00All the nice steakhouses proud display their aged meats, like in special refrigerator, dry aged and such. But when you eat green pepper, tomato aged in a Moscow vegetable warehouse where rat population out of control, ambient mold, at least a decade, you know, that's called terroir. I think in a cuisine aficionado called, look, I'll read for you. This is local color. This Moscow, Russia in 1980s. So you get good idea.

SPEAKER_00Wonders of centralized planned state economy. I'm reading if there wasn't if there if there was a nightmare of the late Soviet years. race that captured all the cumulative absurdity and folly of developed socialism. It was the reeking, rat-infested vegetable warehouses of Moscow. These 23 mammoth storehouses or monuments to the Bolsheviks peculiarly misguided distrust and cruel oppression of the Russian peasantry.

From Lenin's early battles with the peasants to Stalin's forced collectivization, much of Soviet history was a war against the countryside to feed the cities.

SPEAKER_00Although the mass violence ended after Stalin, the giant machine of central planning rolled on, confiscating the output of the peasant year after year and shipping it to the cities for storage until it was distributed. Huge quantities of vegetables and fruits, a year's supply, were brought from the farms into the Moscow warehouses just because the state's monumental distrust of the peasants. By the earliest days of perestroika in the mid-1980s, these vegetable bases had become an organizational monster.

SPEAKER_00The vegetables had to be brought in, sorted, stacked, packed, and preserved, sometimes for many months. The 23 warehouses, holding up to 1.5 million tons of fruits and vegetables, or enough provisions for a city of 10 million people, suffered all the symptoms of the shortage economy and all the underlying distortions of central planning. Terminal filth, stench, mold, rats, flies, cockroaches, there was nothing so vile that it did not find its home in these warehouses, recalled Yuri Luzhkov,

SPEAKER_00a seasoned Soviet industrial manager, after first visiting the warehouses. short break from reading to tell you this man, Yuri Luzhkov, was a kind of Soviet-era technocrat who was appointed, I think, first by Gorbachev or maybe Yeltsin, but one of them early on, I think Gorbachev, to reform These warehouses and he had some mild success doing this. And thereafter, Luzhkov became mayor of Moscow, which a post he held, I think,

SPEAKER_00for almost 20 years from 1992, well into the Putin era up to 2010. And he also one of the founders of United Russia, currently ruling a party of Putin of Russia. And he deep involved with many of not just Putin and Russia deep state, but many of the oligarchs that I will talk on this or next episode. But I continue to read. Even the newer warehouses were stripped down and ruined by the workers,

SPEAKER_00Lushkov observed, brought to such a degree of negligence that you could explain it only by some crazy idea that the employees were obsessed with intentionally destroying everything like an army retreating in the face of an attacking foe. Nothing should be left standing for the enemy. The chain of rot began far away on the farms. Stripped of any incentives, the 120,000 growers who served Moscow had long since stopped caring about the quality of the vegetables and the fruits they shipped.

They reluctantly brought their vegetables to a collection point to be hauled away

SPEAKER_00in a truck carrying a bill of loading that read simply Moscow. You know, usually they attack my throat, look like on this episode they attack my brain, you know. But yeah, I have this problem repetition word, I think. I don't know. They're using Havana Ray. And I continue reading. But yeah, so they were loading it on a truck that suggested Moscow. By the time it got to the city, much of the cargo had begun to rot. The potatoes were infested with beetles.

SPEAKER_00The warehouses. became dungeons whose contents were destroyed, not preserved, recalled Lushkov. The rotting vegetables were then distributed to the state stores where customers could only curse at the black carrots, decaying greens and moldering potatoes. There was a well-worn refrain by the store clerks as they handed out the rotting vegetables. If you don't like it, don't eat it. The vegetable bases, as they were known, were a triumph of collectivist labor. Everyone worked there supposedly for the common good,

and yet the reality was that no one did.

SPEAKER_00The vegetable bases were run like army boot camp. Every day, 20,000 Muscovites were drafted to re-sort, re-pack, and re-sort. The whole system was so deeply and pervasively corrupt that it made absolutely no sense to bother with any investigations, Luzhkov said. This was because the police were in on the deal.

Financial controllers and inspectors just wrote off the losses and party officials

SPEAKER_00saw the mess as just another opportunity. They stole the best of what there was. The stealing was so common and pervasive as to defy definition as criminal. Here we are approaching the very core of socialism, Luzkov observed. To a certain degree, everybody was involved and everybody participated. And under socialism, this means nobody. That was the crucial point, the most corrupting effect of the developed socialism. Since everybody believed that they did not create this evil,

SPEAKER_00coming home with bags stuffed with stolen products was not wrong. In December 1985, Gorbachev brought a new boss to Moscow, the rugged Sverdlovsk regional party chief Boris Yeltsin. Sud Yeltsin began to take the city by storm in a very unconventional way, standing in line with average people. Anyway, I stop reading... And yes, Luzhkov was appointed during the reign of Gorbachev to try reform these bases and so forth. OK, welcome.

SPEAKER_00Yes, Caribbean Rhythms, episode 214, 214. And what I just read for you was from David Hoffman, The Oligarch, The Oligarchs, a good book you should read. But that was Moscow, Russia in the 1980s. And I guess what's odd to me... I'm from East Bloc myself, and I remember 1980s quite well. I lived in another part of East Bloc, and not even a very good part. There were shortages where I was also, but nothing like this.

SPEAKER_00And what the Russians people went through, the deprivation that you just heard of, and that's just starting it, the shortages under Marxist Leninism, what they went through seemed to be well beyond what East Europe went through. Even, as I say, the bad parts. Now, the good parts of East Europe... From a material, actually not only a material point of view, but just better over all parts in every way were Hungary, Budapest, Hungary, Yugoslavia, Czechoslovakia,

SPEAKER_00Poland, East Germany. And I don't know if in that order, but maybe Hungary was the best off by the late 1980s. They didn't really have to deal with shortages or food lines. chiefly because these nations had already somewhat opened up their economies. They had experimented with some limited free enterprise, for example, at the smallholder level, individual shops, farmers, you know, you couldn't own a big factory enterprise and with, you know, 200, 2,000 employees.

But you could have your own maybe small restaurant or shop, maybe a small farm, family farm.

SPEAKER_00I don't know if that's so. But furthermore, the repression that you read in between the lines already of what I just made for you now, what I said, that thing with the vegetable bases, with the drafting of the average citizen to work in those, Where I was from, something like that existed. I think the equivalent of medieval forced labor from the serfs, right? In other words, the citizens, excuse me, corvée.

SPEAKER_00It's what same principle in medieval times. But the communist countries did the same where party demanded you come out whatever in the autumn to burn the leaves. I think I remember adults doing that. Or whatever bullshit thing like that. Not quite a harrowing work in a rat-infested vegetable distribution basis. But it was nothing like this thing in Russia. I don't...

It didn't matter if you were an engineer or a doctor or a physicist or whatever. You had to come out to work in these dreadful vegetable bases once a month or what.

SPEAKER_00Whereas, again, in East Bloc places where... Remember, there was Hungarian Revolution against the Soviets in 1956. And that was put down. And there was another one in Czechoslovakia in 1968. And that too, Soviet Warsaw Pact alleys invaded with tanks, and where in fact it was not a real revolution to throw out the Soviets. Dubček, that was the leader of Czechoslovakia at the time in 1968,

He was not attempting to defect from Soviet sphere so much as do socialism with a

SPEAKER_00human face, so-called, make certain reforms in terms of lessening censorship, loosening centralization of the economy. economy making a few concessions to the profit drive and such and although that was put down and by the way although it was yes it was put down but after 1968 the records of the presidio this was basically the junta that ruled the soviet union in some ways were they were even above the general secretary i shouldn't

qualified as not in some ways they were these uh soviet union was ruled by the presidio and then under that was general secretary and under that central committee i think but uh you can read their notes and they had decided after the czechoslovak revolution of 1968 that if there had been another one anywhere in the east in the warsaw pack they would not invade again of course they didn't publicize that and it

SPEAKER_00took until the 80s for these countries to peel themselves off from the Warsaw Pact system. But I think the decision was made in 1968 that it was no longer going to be enforced militarily, you know. And these types of reforms, especially the economic type, they returned creeping in the East European Warsaw Pact countries, where they didn't have to deal with these dreadful shortages by the 1980s.

SPEAKER_00And it was at most a kind of mild authoritarianism there. Think not like men in overcoats coming to take you away in the middle of night, maybe if you really made yourself huge nuisance, you know, but even then. It was more the type of tyranny you get good image from movies like Lives of Others, where you can... If you watch that, it's a bad living condition, but they're not living... Like rats, like the people in Moscow. I mean, Berlin, I guess it's in Berlin, right?

The lives of others takes place in Cold War Berlin in the 80s and is not quite...

SPEAKER_00It's not quite a terrible life that you're seeing. They were doing okay in the 1980s. It's not this level of absolute poverty deprivation. And that's what I want to emphasize you on. First, the segment of this show is the insane poverty that the Marxist system entirely on its own had degenerated into by the late 1970s. where again where i grew up my family for example had their own apartment i didn't know anyone who lived in communal apartment and i think there

were such things in in east europe okay you had these communist projects or living blocks okay by the way there's they sent mosquito i just saw one fly in front of me as i'm recording and i may have to stop show to i don't understand where these mosquito come

SPEAKER_00But it's a form of psychological torture warfare. There were two mosquitoes in my fridge the other day. I don't understand this. But look, in East Europe, you see everywhere you go, Slovakia, whatever, huge communist project blocks on the edge of cities. Maybe those had communal... Apartments, but I didn't know anyone who lived in those. But what was life in those like? It's not just like multifamily per apartment. More commonly,

there would be shared bathroom per floor or shared kitchen.

SPEAKER_00You'd be living in a disgusting college dorm, right? And again, I don't know people who live that way, but in Soviet Union, that was extreme common style. And even if you were, let's say, a PhD academic economist or whatever in your junior years, you'd be living that way. One of the men I talk on this or maybe actually next episode, Anatoly Chubais, and he's the man who led the economic reforms under Yeltsin, And became himself a kind of oligarch, but he lived like this well into the 1980s when he was a young

professor or

SPEAKER_00researcher or whatever. It was a huge feat for him to get a car, for example. Again, in East Bloc, it was rare to get a car, but not like in Soviet Union where... extreme luxury to have on just what got me reading these books. And I rely on three books for these episodes. The Oligarchs by David Hoffman, Casino Moscow by Matthew Brzezinski, who, yes, I think is that Brzezinski's son and was a journalist in Moscow in 1990s.

SPEAKER_00And Godfather of the Kremlin is the other book by Paul Klebnikov, for which Klebnikov probably got whacked But who knows if it was for that book or something else. He had gotten on so many people's feet for just being a journalist in this era of Russia. You know, so many journalists murdered and just covering the things and people I'm telling you on this episode. I think it's quite unfair to...

Previously on Twitter and New York Times and something, they would show an empty press room.

SPEAKER_00You know, right now there is a press conference. This was where assassination of Trump took, excuse me, no jinx. Attempted assassination. They completely failed. But the latest attempted assassination of Mr. Trump, President Trump, took place at White House correspondent event. And they would show a press room like that with empty seats, whatever. 300 or 400 empty seats. I actually think more journalists than that got killed in the early 1990s.

But they would have a caption saying, these were the journalists killed by Putin. And I think that's really unfair because Putin say what you will about him.

SPEAKER_00He did not do that. It happened in the... late 80s and early 90s and it wasn't putin who did you know so um but it's the dreadful condition that got to me reading these books you know and me being from communist uh system i mean i remember it quite well as a small boy but uh the the dreadful condition of the African-Russian people that they live in. I'm sorry, allow me this joke.

SPEAKER_00For the Russians, anyone south of their border is Africa, you know, just a boorish, arrogant people where... I had a Russian girlfriend once, and she knew I was reading Mishima, and it was a Japan-loving weeb, and she's like, the Russians, you know that phrase you love so much from your Mishima books, Sonno Joy, write this Meiji-era Japanese unification slogan. It means, revere the emperor, expel the barbarian.

SPEAKER_00It's funny how the Japanese can say certain things so efficiently, like they say, revere the emperor, expel the barbarian is two short words, but if you want to say something like, I want milk, or something, it's like a two-line sentence, I don't know, but anyway, she's like she says yes that phrase is also the soul of the Russian people that sentiment so you will forgive me if as an East Euro I can call them Africans because of the way they lived is incredible to me even as I say being from

communist country myself and one of the worst ones but when it came to shortages and also repression even from such a place I was shocked to read about the ghastly African level poverty of the gypsy Russian people and the Soviet peoples during this time

SPEAKER_00I need to take a break to get some honey for energy and throat protect. I will be right back.

SPEAKER_00Yes, I'm back, but I was out of honey. Honey is great for the throat, so instead I used a kind of sugar. I don't know if sugar syrup is what's called. It's sugarcane juice reduction, where you reduce the actual liquid from the sugarcane. which on its own has a kind of refreshing citrusy flavor. It's quite nice when you drink cold, but when you reduce that, it becomes thick and dark and kind of honey-like, where you take a teaspoon and it's on

of my favorite products from tropical sugar growing regions but i think that it also exists in the american south i don't know what it's called like a louisiana it's called and i agree with ray pete ray pete lately has come under attack and he kind of a crank on many diet things i've attacked his ideas about you know i will

SPEAKER_00not stop eating fish for example or avocados but I think he's mostly right about healing qualities of sugar, although obviously you shouldn't do what the petards do, which is to take white sugar and mainline it and take teaspoons constantly. checking their temperature in the hope that their metabolism temperature will go up but what actually happened they go obese because the pounds of sugar per day I don't mean it that way but an occasional if you're not feeling

well like a teaspoon occasionally you know like once a few times a week maybe of this natural product especially sugarcane reduction I think has other things in it that are good for you

SPEAKER_00Oh, and here I give you more life advice. Because I have a special occasion record for you and I wanted not to think about mosquito, I used Terre d'Hermes perfume, cologne. And I doused it over the parts of my body exposed because I am recording this for you in a bathrobe. But where it's not covered, I put Terre d'Hermes and it works better than a mosquito

repellent.

SPEAKER_00Of course, I have citronella such mosquito repellent too, but... This terderm is made with vetiver and for whatever reason actually works better than any mosquito repellent. only a special occasion. It's an expensive cologne, but I wanted to feel motivated and refreshed for you for the record show. But I will tell you, Soviet Union crap plays on this episode.

Look, I leave the East Bloc communist shortages myself, and I remember it well.

SPEAKER_00But again, nothing like what the Russians went through, it looks like. Like, forgive to repeat if I've said this before, but the dictator where I was in an effort to pay off national debt and other such thing... He was, for example, turning off heat in winter, or I don't think he was just doing it to be cruel, but who knows. So I remember having to heat up in front of oven before going to school sometimes. Or you take meat, for example.

SPEAKER_00There was money around, but the shelves were empty, so... You couldn't buy anything. So to get meat, unless you had access to special privileged government stores, which my parents did not, they would have to go into abandoned subway stations at night where the peasants came from countryside to trade meat on the black market. But, you know, they wouldn't take money. So... You'd have to trade barter, you'd have to bring like a canister of gasoline to get meat. So, you know, my parents had to do this too, even they were white collar,

like scientists working scientific institutes was supposedly the most prestigious

SPEAKER_00thing you could do both. soviet and east bloc but they had to do this like everyone else so actually for full disclosure in what i say and so you know more about me you should know my grandfather was one of founders of one of these east european communist governments set up after world war ii And in fact, it's funny, he ran, I think he ran the propaganda for them at first. I think that's what he did. But then he retired by 1970 or so. So we did not get access to government stores nor had any

privileges to travel

SPEAKER_00abroad or such things. The only kind of legacy benefit we got, while a child, I could use the special party hospital and I went to the same school that dictator's grandson went to. And he was in neighboring class to mine, and now I hear he's schizophrenic, which is unfortunate. But I tell you all this for a reason, and some may be of what I tell you, who knows, family law, I don't know. But my grandfather, a hardcore believing communist,

maybe less so toward the end of his life,

SPEAKER_00but for sure back to the 1930s and then into the 1950s and so on. And he was incorruptible, as were many of his colleagues, and very intelligent. And the reason I take tangent and tell you this is because a widespread attitude among American left and leftist self-styled communists and such in United States, incredible chauvinism, parochialism actually, to where they want to attribute the Soviet Union's collapse and sorry state for much of its existence to to fact that they were stupid Slavs or,

you know, they're hairy Slavic apes. They don't say that funnily, but that's the underlying assumption of many American...

SPEAKER_00that those people must be dumb thieves and the like. I mean, look at Putin. And so, you know, so the belief is all, well, if we smart, we ethical American communists do the same, it will work here. You know, we're not like retrograde, reactionary, racist Russian communists, you know. So it's just stupid, OK, because first of all, leaving aside the fact that many of the founders of these regimes were Jewish, which I'm not saying that's better than Slavic or whatever,

SPEAKER_00but from point of view of these American leftoids, who are often of Jewish origin themselves, it is. Or at least they know it's something quite different. So they're kind of obfuscating over that. But leaving aside the question of origins, which in my view is actually not as relevant as some think, a lot of these men... I'm telling you were incorruptible. They were well-meaning and extreme intelligent. And actually they did make a good faith effort to apply Marxist theory.

SPEAKER_00The terror that was applied is part of that. You have to apply... Terror to get rid of the bourgeois classes and so forth. So after World War II, by the way, in many parts of like Czechia and so on, also it was highly industrialized with industrial traditions of some decades. The part about how it was an inappropriate application by Lenin to an agrarian economy, that is also false. In fact, Leninism,

SPEAKER_00Stalinism made great strides industrializing the former Russian Empire, although I've seen figures that it was already industrializing before and the rate actually slowed during Soviet times, but I haven't studied that myself, whatever. I can tell you also that many of the people in the beginning of these regimes were gladly went along with the reform because of a sincere belief in principles of Marxism. And even quite late, many of the older people, even a boomer generation,

which had in many ways turned against these governments by the 1980s for sure,

SPEAKER_00nevertheless, the older people felt gratitude, some gratitude to the rather sincere efforts these places made to upraise the general run of the people, especially in regards to education. So the Soviet and East Bloc educational program is the reason these places still shoot, I think, way above the demographic weight still when it comes to math and science. And then they easily transition to computers and so forth. Anyway, I could say much more on this, but it's just the worst kind of parochialism for fat,

SPEAKER_00disgusting, masturbated, Bernie, Bernie leftists and woke so-called whatever trany fine United States to pretend that East Bloc. And Soviet communism did not work because of some very special Slavic retrograde corruption or deficiency. In fact, the Soviet Union, the application was especially faithful and intelligent. There was a place called Gosplan, a huge government institute employing untold numbers of technocrats, scientists, mathematicians,

SPEAKER_00economists. Their job was to centrally plan every part of a gigantic Soviet economy. Thank you. In that same building, I mean, every tomato, every nut and bolt, literally, every nut and bolt of the economy,

every steel pipe was centrally logged and centrally determined where it would go,

SPEAKER_00how it would be used. Right. The prices were set by the government. So the economy did not function in any way that you're familiar with. Every item, every production was centrally dictated and there were quotas and centrally planned. So in a normal economy. Money prices communicate information to producers. They want to make a profit. You know, price goes up and down. They can calibrate. And then they find financing through debt and so, et cetera. But this was more like it worked very different.

SPEAKER_00They built a factory. We need cars. We need steel plates or whatever. We need still plates and we're going to build a gigantic, awesome factory for that. I mean awesome in the awe-inducing sense. I mean, these are gigantic structures. I think they have artistic merit as unintentional, as barbaric, gargantuan, you know, Mordor structures built by the government. And then that factory, once built, it had to meet the production quota.

SPEAKER_00And to reach that quota, it got subsidies from the government, and it asked for raw input materials, which also then the government sent it from other factories, other producers. So it was economy geared toward industry and production, not the needs of the consumer. So in many ways, it was designed to function on shortage insofar as the average man's needs were concerned. So the problem is that although this system kind of worked, maybe not well, But relative to later,

it functioned, let's say, rickety or whatever for some decades.

SPEAKER_00And I say this following without endorsing any other economic system, least of all, whatever hybrid fake capitalism that had developed in United States by the time Trump came along in 2016. And it's still largely the situation. Let's see if you can change it. But What I will say now is, you know, I'm not endorsing, I'm not saying therefore, whatever. But by the late 1970s, the centrally planned Soviet economy breaking down on its own and leading to kind

SPEAKER_00of situations that I say above with vegetables baking. Or this book begins with a story, again, of some type of scientist woman who is trying desperately to escape the crowded, disgusting African heat and filth of the Moscow summer. She's trying to go to the Dacha on an overcrowded crap train, right? These are the summer houses in these birch forests outside Moscow where Russians try to find

SPEAKER_00Yeah. as much toilet paper as she can. So think like toilet paper, COVID craze, but those kinds of shortages permanent where you'd have to stock up on whatever you can find on your way to anywhere like this, you know, and go back to, you know, you want to talk about Bugman apartment.

SPEAKER_00I mean, that's what these collective Soviet blocs were. You know, this one would probably have to share public bathroom in her apartment building with a bunch of drunk, right? Because vodka was the only thing widely available to be sold in Russian stores. You know, they didn't skimp on that. Vodka was widely available. And the real breakdown, however, it wasn't only the increasing shortages and breakdown of production lines, which the mathematicians and economists of Gosplan,

SPEAKER_00again, the Central Planning Authority, they would be constantly trying to correct these distortions of the economy with adjustments similar to planetary epicycles in the pre-Copernican, right? The model didn't work, so they constantly had to rejigger the numbers, but they'd never be able to catch up in the long run. So by 1979, the problem was, and it was spread actually first, it was the mathematicians and economists working at Gosplan who

noticed this,

SPEAKER_00through their studies, and they met in secret to discuss, hey, this model is not working anymore. The numbers will never add up ever by now. And then some of them produced samizdat. These are self-published, unauthorized, illegal literature again. You could not take it to a Xerox machine, by the way, because the Xerox machines were all... This was actually... Listen, I would still... I have this residual...

SPEAKER_00I think when you use Xerox machine, even in the United States today, there are backdoor signatures that make it traceable. But certainly in communist times... forget traceable, they were under lock and key. You could not use Xerox machines. They're like special state technology. But somehow they self-published some samis that made copies. To make public some of earliest criticisms of this economic system, I'm saying, came from scientists working at the Central Planning Institute of the Communist

SPEAKER_00Economy. And Naishul, this guy, his name Naishul, was one of them. And it's not just, you know, mild... the usual run-of-the-mill crappy life that I knew in East Bloc and that you think can go on for decades. But actually, the Soviet Union is becoming critical by 1979. And by 1980s, there were absolutely frightening shortages, drastically collapsing quality of life, such of whatever it had been anyway. So... Another aspect as well, which is maybe more important to realize,

SPEAKER_00is declining state power, okay? Some of these economists at Gosplan, when they went out in the field to see how factory managers... This is from Naishul's Samizdat in the early 1980s, one of the mathematicians of the planning authority. He, of course, published under his frog Avatar, and it is an anonymously published pseudonym. And... So he go out and he look in factory directors,

how they actually behaved in practice.

SPEAKER_00The economic sector, the provincial directors, how they... acted in real life, and he was shocked to see that at times they would just tell the party heads and the central committee people, well, not the... They tell their party, even department heads, you know, to fuck off. You know, and that would have gotten you shot some decades prior, even after Stalin. It was unheard of to be that open. And I was taken aback myself to read this, open insubordination to what central authorities in the communist system were

SPEAKER_00saying. It's not that it was a free society, but that the regional manager felt, and this is well before the collapse of the Soviet Union formally, okay, by early 1980s, you'd get concurrently three major related developments, the inability... of the centrally scientifically planned economy to provide its supply lines. Second, collapsing ability to enforce by these central powers of the Soviet state. And finally, outright thievery, banditry, pillage of the state property because the black market informal

economy began to

SPEAKER_00overtake the overt, whatever you want to call it, communist socialist one. You know, it's supposed to work one way. During the entirety of the Soviet times, because the communist economic or socialist, pure socialist economic system like that makes assumptions about human nature that are too elevated regarding its selflessness. And that aspect, the selfish aspect, of course, does not disappear. It just goes underground. So everything from backscratching to special favors to forms of barter,

SPEAKER_00actually, that's what greased the wheels of action in this economy, too. It was just informal and behind the formal robot space communism image it was kind of barter and connections based shadow economy that powered the overt one in a much milder healthier form you would find the same thing in ancient greece you know to where right in sparta there was formerly no currency okay so in that case yeah it was quite strict in sparta no currency and A Spartan citizen was not ever supposed to engage in

money-making activity.

SPEAKER_00This too had been one of the dreams of the early Leninists, that you would get rid of money entirely, eventually. Well, Sparta did that. The Spartan currency was basically impossible to use. It was as heavy as an anvil and so forth. But it didn't stop the Spartan citizens from engaging in secret capitalism. Except in that case, it wasn't really punished. Like it actually was very punished in Soviet Union. But look, forget Sparta. This is actually well documented in essence.

SPEAKER_00where the gentlemen, especially the aristocracy of Athens, was not allowed by the rules of honor to engage in commerce, really. So it just went underground, and they had, like, not quite a company, but actually, yeah, proto-corporation even, or ancient factories or shops. workshops I mean I don't mean just like but like mini factories and they were run by their wives or slaves informally except in Athens on this side on so many other

things you know people know about the gay thing but the law or honor said one thing and then in practice people learn to look the other way and to tolerate a lot of

SPEAKER_00inconsistency So there was in fact a burgeoning capitalist or proto-capitalist economy in ancient Athens with financing of overseas commercial voyages, enterprise and the like, with words for things like capital and interest and so on. Athenian economy and society, a banking perspective. This is a book from Princeton University Press by Edward Cohen, I think in early 1990s. Athenian economy and society, a banking perspective saying that They had complex private banking,

SPEAKER_00deposit taking, lending, maritime finance, creditor and tax avoidance techniques, and many legal grey zone practices. All of these involved METICs. These were resident foreigners, you know. So they wouldn't do the business themselves. They would get the local foreigner, whatever, the same way European aristocrats did business with their court resident Jews or whatever as intermediaries. But in ancient Athens, they delegated to not just foreigners,

SPEAKER_00but also chosen smart slaves and women, you know, their wives or, you know, cousin or whatever, an unmarried woman cousin or whatever. And he... This author and others show there were private banks and basically a market economy functioning, but it was informally in that case, half legally. whereas the overt economy or life in ancient Athens was based on notions of honor that looked down on all this. So, you know, some same ethos as the Hidalgo, the Spanish gentleman,

SPEAKER_00labor and commerce are dishonorable. Well, in a much more dysfunctional way, the Soviet system, because of its far greater ideological enforcement against anything resembling capitalism or private property, drove all this underground rather than extirpating... To where the selfish material drive in man, right, you wouldn't have stuff like ancient Athens. You'd just be like essentially mafia economy in a proto sense. These elements,

blood, it was called blood, the Russian word blood, basically bribery.

SPEAKER_00or bribery through some kind of barter or favor. And this other word, I don't know how to pronounce this barbaric language, Svyazi, I don't know, Svyazi, if I pronounce it, meaning your private trusted network of acquaintances and off the books business partners. You know, in other words, yes, what I mean is proto-mafia, like this is definition of low trust society, you know, where you cannot... Nothing happens through the formal channels and you cannot trust the state. So it's a collapse to your family and your trusted network of friends.

SPEAKER_00And it works through mutual back scratching and so on. And although on paper it was socialist in practice. Everything ran on Svyazi and blood, connections and bribes. And as the shortages got ever more desperate and people's survival was at stake, this informal economy basically overtook the real one by the late 1980s through just outright insubordinations to state authorities, including... At times, yes, exceptional cases, just economic department heads disobeying, provincial, regional managers,

SPEAKER_00whatever, disobeying. But more generally, what happened, and here's how Nyshul, again, one of the economist mathematicians from Gosplan, Hear how this book, The Oligarchs, describes this Samizdat work by Nyshul explaining breakdown of Soviet economic system by 1981 now. This is well before fall of Soviet Union, years and years before, 1981, even before Gorbachev. I'm reading now. Just the industrial supply and distribution plans created by

Gosplan totaled 70

SPEAKER_00volumes of nearly 12,000 pages and dealt with over 30,000 commodities. The Gosplan mathematicians toiled over their models, but after a while, Nyshul saw that his bosses took his mathematical work, and to his horror, they just changed the answers to fit whatever outcome they wanted or needed that day. Nyshul had a sudden insight. The system no longer was really commanded from the top. There was no dictator. Instead, the whole bureaucratic planning system had become a strange,

SPEAKER_00never-ending, undisciplined bazaar. At the core, there were no firm commands but bargaining. From below, factory directors made demands on the ministries and the ministries made demands on the central planners. All the tugging and pulling went up the ladder and then came tumbling back down again in the form of a cascade of decisions that never matched the initial demands. If the decision was to take away from one factory and give to another, the loser did not accept the decision and began to lobby others

for what it wanted,

SPEAKER_00sometimes not up the ladder but sideways, from other factories. The key players in these transactions were often not the central planners at all, but the factory managers who gained more and more power as the system weakened. Everyone, not just factories, was engaged in a wild crisscrossing web of demand. Demands, permissions, secret hordes, trade-offs and shortages, and the planning system could hardly keep up, much less control it. Naishul liked to tell of a communist party boss in a faraway region.

SPEAKER_00The people in Moscow thought he was busily building socialism. But, the boss told Naishul, my business, the first half of my day, is to exchange chickens from my region for eggs produced in another. The growth of these side deals meant that Gosplan gradually controlled less and less. Right, I stopped reading, but the steering wheel turned, force applied, and nothing happened. There was no central authority anymore, really, by 1981 even. I mean, there was... In terms of foreign policy and in terms of,

SPEAKER_00if you made yourself annoying through speech, but in terms of controlling this vast imperial economy, no. And as you can get from all these hints, the looting... Looting began and began hard already before 1981, before the fall of Soviet Union formally. I'll be back to talk brief this coming apart of state and society and just the beginning of oligarch pirate era during this period.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. EPISODE 228: CLAUDE LEVI-STRAUSS

    Nov 19, 202652 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.bronzeagepervert.yoga I talk the problem of India, the innate slum in all civilization, Claude Levi-Strauss amazing book Tristes Tropiques and the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. EPISODE 227: POLITICAL MIX

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.bronzeagepervert.yoga I return to political mix show to discuss midterm elections only in part but more so the sorry state and future of the right and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. EPISODE 226: BAHIA

    Oct 19, 202657 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.bronzeagepervert.yoga I talk matrilineal and matriarchal societies, primitive depth human evolution, Claude Levi Strauss and the inauthenticity of modern...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. EPISODE 225: NEALL ELLIS

    Sep 28, 202645 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.bronzeagepervert.yoga I talk to legendary condottiere and military helicopter pilot Neall Ellis, hero of the battle of Freetown (where in January 1999 he...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. EPISODE 224: FREEDOM AND SEX

    Sep 17, 20261 hr 15 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.bronzeagepervert.yoga I talk Brazil election and constitutional crisis, Iran war developments and possibility of new path for Trump administration,...

    Credit the people on this episode