Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

CAP Chat Live!

CAP Chat Live! artwork

NAIA Moves to Five Years of Eligibility

Nov 6, 202626 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The conversation discusses recent changes in NAIA eligibility rules, particularly the shift to five years of eligibility without age restrictions. It also covers the implications for recruitment, highlight video best practices, and post-season strategies for college coaches. Takeaways NAIA now offers five-year eligibility Highlight videos are crucial for recruitment Chapters 00:00 NAIA Eligibility Changes 12:00 Differences Between NAIA and NCAA 15:43 Highlight Video Tips for Recruitment 23:22 Post-Season Reflections and Next Steps

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

Josh Tyler: Hey. November. I can say it's November because we got an NAIA ruling update that just passed. hot news, hot take. so yeah, hot stuff coming up. That's right, Peter Griffin. But so yeah, so it is it is it is November. We have NAIA rule that that just passed. We hear the NAIA expert of Canton, Missouri, Tyler Tomlinson Tyler.

Tyler: I think that's on my resume. It

Josh Tyler: Himletsen.

Tyler: says N A I A expert guy.

Josh Tyler: You know what I think is weird? Do you think it's weird that when you see emails you see it more on club coaches, but and you see email and it lists like all their licenses and and like the different things they've they've done on like I think it's

Tyler: Should are you saying I should do that?

Josh Tyler: No, I think it's kinda odd.

Tyler: okay.

Josh Tyler: I I I know people are like, Well, you should be pri I am prior your license, but I I don't know. Like it it it it it I you just

Tyler: I don't think I I don't think I would put it in my signature, no. It's on my resume.

Josh Tyler: Right. I I

Tyler: It's on my resume.

Josh Tyler: Right, but your signature not like who you trying to pr we're emailing back and forth. I I see that and go, He pr

Tyler: Maybe some people's emails are their resume, you know, like 'cause they have to work in like getting people to hire them

Josh Tyler: Guess.

Tyler: to do stuff. I don't know.

Josh Tyler: I I guess. Now I get I get your title of the club, like I'm a DOC. I get that, but I don't need your licenses or I've seen one of their club record like it was Heartland League champion. Like I think

Tyler: You think I should put that on there? Saint Louis St. Louis Youth Soccer Association Division V champ? We got promoted. Let's go.

Josh Tyler: You should for sure. Yeah. You absolutely. Absolut Yeah. Just just just just have your entire resume on there. Tyler lives

Tyler: All every game I've won for wreck through college.

Josh Tyler: that's terrible. We're gonna get some bad reviews on that one. All right. Well,

Tyler: Yep, sorry.

Josh Tyler: this is let's stop in. This is we're gonna go right into it. This is CapChat Live, everyone, in November. Alright, well let's let's start, Tyler. Let's get right into it. we've talked about this a lot, but now it's now it's official. and actually Tyler, when NAIA has gone the five year resibility. You brought that up at Nike headquarters back in I lose track of when it was July?

Tyler: Yeah. Yeah.

Josh Tyler: July Tyler is all over this. I I I I'm gonna attach this clip to it too, 'cause I've been I still have that. But so you were all over this one in in July. So tell us what what is official I know we talked about kind of the possibilities, what what what is the official ruling happening here with with NAI eligibility?

Tyler: Yeah, I think I think the global big news here is that all four year athletic awarded divisions are now five year eligibility. Okay. So that means division one, division two, and AIA. All the ones that are four years that can provide you athletic scholarships, all of those divisions are now five year eligibility. And AIA was the last to jump in the pool. that happened yesterday. And so with that, the main difference that NAIA provided that the other two did not was NAIA did not have an age restriction on their five years of eligibility. What their setup is, you get ten semesters to play your sport. That's it. As long as you remain academically eligible and are progressing, you are allowed to play your 10 semesters, no matter your age, or no matter if you started at another division. so that is something that is the big separator here. So the big news is everybody's five years to play their sport now. The big difference between NAIA and NCAA, as we predicted here on CAP, is that the NAIA will not restrict your age.

Josh Tyler: I like that this this is directly from the NAI here and it's it's worth noting 'cause it's a little different verbiage, but it's tied to academic progress, not age. Unlike models that strictly count consecutive calendar years from high school graduation, the NAI's fifth year links directly to academic progress and terms of attendance, meaning you could take two years off and come back and still play.

Tyler: Mm-hmm. Yeah, so and and and there will be some and same thing I think with NCAA. So if you're a current student athlete in the NAIA in your senior year, you will be allowed to participate next year in in this. So if you graduated in May and you fulfilled your four years of eligibility, then you are not eligible to come back. So not grandfathering in anyone.

Josh Tyler: And this is what causes lawsuits. Now I I think i I

Tyler: Yeah.

Josh Tyler: think I think NAI has less we have less lawsuits because there's less in a amount of yeah, correct.

Tyler: NIL's not as prevalent. It's not as prevalent. So kids aren't really losing money as much. And not that NAI doesn't have NIL, they do as well. But it's just not as prevalent, I agree. So they're they're probably not gonna have as many lawsuits. That's correct. But you know what you what you could have is situation in soccer, it because it's a fall sport, right? Someone could have done their ninth semester in the fall and played four years. in that time and then not take classes in the spring, and then come back again the next fall for semester ten, because, you know, they get ten semesters. And so there will be some gaps and things like that for some players, for NAIA that they'll take advantage of for sure.

Josh Tyler: Yeah. Yeah, interesting dude. What is this? So you're an AI coach, w how does this are you changing anything as you as you're moving forward?

Tyler: I think what it changes is the root recruitment process, just making sure that we educate the players that we're recruiting, that they have five years of eligibility. and that we tie that to what our school can provide. my school, for instance, has several master's programs that may be more enticing to a player that wants to play five years. So I would say at the route there is that. Maybe it increases my ability to recruit some masters students, some grad students, some transfer students, things like that, just without the age restriction. I think you're gonna see a big migration. Not that the NAIA hasn't always been kind of like a front runner when it comes to older kids and international kids. It's always kind of been the place for those athletes. I think this really solidifies it that, you know, clientele wise, they're gonna have a lot more of these types of players. So the international players that are older, et cetera, are are gonna be coming over and they're probably looking more at NAIA schools for those scholarships.

Josh Tyler: Yeah. Well and let me talk about the so the key differences. And let me actually ask you this though. And you said it very carefully is the four year schools that give athletic aid have all changed. W you you so that leaves out NC NCAA division three. What what what's your feelings? What's your feelings for division th three here?

Tyler: Yeah. two or three months ago, just some feedback I was getting from division three coaches and some, just articles I was reading, it seemed like maybe they were gonna go the way of everybody else. what I'm reading lately is that there may be NCAA division three may be the outlier here and they may dig their heels in in a four and this is a four year process. academics is still the priority of NCAA Division Three. We're not gonna jeopardize and try to prioritize athletics over academics. We're gonna dig our heels in on what we truly believe in. And so if I had to predict at this moment, I don't think NCAA Division III will go the five year route here. I mean, I think someone could logically say, like, well, you could get a master's degree and play five years, and wouldn't that be considered an academic advancement? I think there's that side of the argument. but I don't think right now, if I had to predict, I would say NCAA Division III will not follow suit as a

Josh Tyler: I yeah, I I agree. Th there's I know we're all this has been can this is consumed well, probably me and you more than the average human being, but

Tyler: Yeah.

Josh Tyler: yeah, it it's they pump the brakes. I I I one of the things I've I've read I've I got it right here is the fear of eroding the division th three identity.

Tyler: Yeah, their ideals and principles of that's what I'm saying. That that's why I think

Josh Tyler: Yep, you're

Tyler: that they'll they'll and the more I read, the more they're like, Well, I I just don't think it's gonna happen. if those kids want to go play a fifth year and get a master's degree somewhere else, the good thing is they still have those pathways available to them. No, it's not division three, but they can still pursue their fifth year and now in pretty much all cases, as long as they stay on their normal calendars or they're not too old. Even if they're too old and then go to NAIA. So it there's there's There's always opportunities now.

Josh Tyler: There there's an article that it's called Inside Higher Ed and one of the things they also point out is the cost concern is allowing or or encouraging or allowing students to stick out if you're creates an unnecessary financial burden. It forces families to pay out of pocket for the extra yeah.

Tyler: Yeah, look, can yeah. Can I can I talk about that real quick? Because I've heard about I've heard this this

Josh Tyler: Perfect.

Tyler: a lot, okay? And so in in this in an administrative sense, and some things I heard was, well, the a reason why we shouldn't do the fifth year is, you know, ethically having those kids pay for that fifth year, you know, that's gonna be a big burden on them. Those are some of the words you just used. And look, Josh, I'm gonna say this. That's absolute BS, okay? This is not the time for administrators to all of a sudden care how much college costs. College is too expensive in this country. And so for you to say, like, I'm gonna say no to a fifth year because the fifth year costs too much. The first four years cost too much for everyone. So this is

Josh Tyler: Mm.

Tyler: not a time to all of a sudden to be ethical because you're gonna care now about how much something costs. Like, no, dude. Like, that's not a reason why. that you should say no to a fifth year. If a kid wants to play their sport, they're all you're already paying a ton of money. Let them pay a fifth year if they want to. Like, especially if there's an advancements and and postgraduate degrees that are b being brought into this. Like not the time to dig our heels in on freaking costs. So I think that's really dumb. And I've said that in a few bigger meetings than this. So

Josh Tyler: I'm gonna move on to the comparing because that is is that's good. I can't can't say anything different. so let's look at the key comparisons. So this is NAI versus division one, division two eligibility. So so the seasons of competitions, so NAI is gonna have five seasons of actual competition, division one, five seasons within the window. They're an age group, age-based. Division two is the same thing five seasons in the five-year window. It now you look at the clock and the time limit. In the AI has no calendar clock. It's it's governed by 10 semesters of terms. The clock for division one is a continuous five-year window, and division two is a continuous five-year condu. When does the clock start? NAI terms only starts when full-time enrollment. happens, not part time. The division one and division two triggers at first time full enrollment or the start of the academic year following your nineteenth birthday. So that's that's the key thing but real fast is following your nineteenth birthday. If you turn nineteen in November, the academic year is not to the next year. That was one of the questions that people are having of when do you turn nineteen?

Tyler: Correct. Yeah.

Josh Tyler: 'Cause some people graduate. So if you turn nineteen in in May, that that fall, so if you let's look at twenty twenty seven, you turn nineteen in May. Tw fall twenty twenty seven is when your clock starts.

Tyler: Hm, interesting.

Josh Tyler: Yeah. Does this run while you're inactive? An AI does not. If you take a gap, you're drop off. It does not. division one, division two, yes, it continuously runs because your age, and

Tyler: Because of your age. Yep.

Josh Tyler: then this is age limit. There's no age limit for an AI. Nineteen is the trigger for division one, division two. Red shirt, no red shirts, no waivers, anything like that. So that is the Those are the main differences that that that there are. we're actually in these show notes. I don't normally do this, but I'll I'll put this, we'll create like a little PDF you can download in the show notes. It'll be nice for you. So yeah.

Tyler: Wow. More Financy.

Josh Tyler: Here we're getting there. So I learned that from another podcast. Yeah. So that's that's the that's the deal with the with the eligibility. A lot of things. A lot of things going. So with that. We have a long gap here that we've been missing, but Tyler, let's you wanna say hello to Ruthie?

Tyler: Ruthie.

Josh Tyler: I'm just gonna pa I'm not gonna say I'm gonna give you through her due credit. I know you wait for. Yeah.

Tyler: You're not gonna give me a Yahtzee? You gotta give me a Yahtzee or I can't do the segment.

Josh Tyler: Tomato soup We had that for dinner the other night. All right.

Tyler: You got a okay, that's good enough. All right, so hey okay, weird thing here. If so for highlight videos, this is this is good. Okay, for highlight videos, if you're bringing in a highlight video from your YouTube shorts or TikTok, okay, and you've put together your highlight video, you got your phone, you're on portrait mode, it looks good, and you go through the YouTube app on your phone and you upload it to that to YouTube. Okay, so when you do that, it's going to upload it as a short. Okay. So when it uploads it as a short, that means it's only going to be in portrait mode. All right. And so when I as a college coach want to consume this highlight video on my computer, it's going to take the computer screen and it's going to shrink it. So your highlight looks like this on the computer screen. Okay. I just worked with a kid on this. and I think it was a recruiter. I don't even think it was a one of our one of our rush kids. And I said, just stop everything. Can you take what you've done and go to your computer and upload it to your normal YouTube page on the computer and let's just see what happens? And she's like, Actually, no, I haven't tried. I've done everything on my phone. So, okay. So she went back, she did it on her computer, she resent it to me, and now it was the full screen and I could actually tell. How good or or bad of a player she was. And so a trend right now is they think they're doing it because they're doing everything on their phone. But a lot of college coaches don't, they don't want to watch highlight videos on their phone. It's not, they might, if they have to, hey, Josh sends me a player, hey, watch this player real quick. Sure, I'm gonna watch it on my phone. But if I'm gonna take it serious and I might offer this kid a scholarship, I really need to evaluate. I need to see it on my computer. Okay. And so

Josh Tyler: And and and and to your point there, it needs to be in sixteen by nine. I know they're getting ratio. So sixteen by nine is your phone is sideways. So even if I'm watching on my phone, I'm gonna turn my phone sideways so I can see the full play. Where all is is on shoe your point there. Yeah. Sorry, I cut you off on Tyler's trends. I'm sorry. That's a

Tyler: So just yeah, that's that's I know that's a little tip. I know Josh will clip this into an Instagram reel and you will we'll see it this way. But it it's I'm just trying to help you guys with your highlight videos and and put out the best product you can for college code.

Josh Tyler: Yeah. Well and and we've long you've long said this, Tyler, too. This is not like you people use YouTube and and your Instagram a as like, hey, look at all my clips and you gotta clip through it. So it it it it's not a good

Tyler: Yeah, so what yeah, what Josh is saying is you sending me eight twelve second clips is gonna make me go insane. Okay. Put them together in one two minute reel, please, and then it's easier to consume.

Josh Tyler: Yep. I I still think to this day we we there's such a problem with highlight videos. I I it I think I think it's the the biggest problem we have with recruitment. And I I I think it's I think people are still trying to make it their own on their own. Like they're like, I'm gonna save myself three hundred bucks and I I can appreciate that. I don't like to spend money either. But you're talking a th you're talking thousands of dollars in investment here, right? If you have a bad

Tyler: Yeah, yeah.

Josh Tyler: highlight video, I hate to say this out loud. The only people that probably watch a bad highlight video are are me, you, and some other coaches because we're going, look at this bad highlight video. But it's like it it it kill it can kill your recruitment chances instantly. It like instantly it's done. And we're still making these videos. I just got one the other day. It it from the sideline and in the message he said, I'm number nineteen. I immediately knew Jackson was sitting in on my in my office couch. I immediately I go, This highlight video's not gonna be good. He says, How do you know? I go, Because he had to tell me what number he is. I mean he did Right.

Tyler: Right now he's not he's not circled, you gotta look for nineteen every time you're looking for it?

Josh Tyler: And halfway during the play, I lost him. I was like, Where did he go? Like I I and like I was even trying, I like even trying to follow nineteen. And it is such a problem. if you're making your own life videos, stop especially young men, stop making your own highlight video. I I just I've never seen one that's prolific. When you're talking thousands upon thousands of dollars on the line, thousands.

Tyler: Yep. Yeah. You just you just put out a reel from Nike headquarters when that was me talking about it. And

Josh Tyler: Yes. Yes.

Tyler: and for our boys, you're competing with international players that are paying money to get highlight videos done, and all of them are sending those highlight videos to college coaches. And if you're not doing that, you're behind. And let me tell you, girls on the girls side. The internationals are coming. it's just without a doubt, an influx of players have started to come to the United States. Guess what? They all have film too. And so we have to have film in America with our players, and it has to be good. And that's what we're helping you with.

Josh Tyler: And and not just compete against internationals though. If if

Tyler: No, d you're I'm talking about competing for scholarships. Yeah, period. Yeah, if you don't have one another

Josh Tyler: Yeah. Yeah.

Tyler: girl does, bye bye. Another boy does, bye bye, and you don't have it. Absolutely.

Josh Tyler: One thing I'll give the I'll I'll give the current leagues is and platforms is that you they're all recording their game. and so they have correct. To to good but it's w it's again. Yeah. You you got your dream spot.

Tyler: So you have access. Or you may have to pay for access. It's still there. You're saying Josh is saying make the investment.

Josh Tyler: Yes. It it is a no-brainer to make this investment. I I just don't. Yeah. I'm not even gonna say we have the service because people are like, you're just trying to get our money. So don't even use our service. I I just it's such a it's such a I don't know, man.

Tyler: Well well that that was the first question Josh and I were looped in on a transfer, from college. yeah, we'll help you out. Josh was like Where's your film? Like you here in college, you film all your games. Where's your film? Put your highlight reel together before you start move trying to move on to a transfer to different school. Like still it's still highlight film. It's still reel based.

Josh Tyler: Yep. It's the number one thing they ask. We'll reach out we'll reach out to to a coach. you know, and hey, I got this player. Where's the highlight video? Okay. And it's and and to for for me, and I know Tyler, you do the same thing, is if it's a bad highlight video, I'm not sharing it. I'm like, no, you gotta fix this. Like it it I and I

Tyler: And we'll help you.

Josh Tyler: don't know what it is. I I I don't I I I don't know if it's stubbornness. I I it's always those people like, I can make my own. Why why risk A 10 actually more than that. Let's say you get a scholarship at $5,000 a year, okay, times by four. That's a $20,000 risk you're willing to take to save $300. That I'm taking that risk all day. I'm taking that $300 all day long without question. Like not even you would write that right now. If Tyler, if I said, hey, you got a chance to make $20,000 to $20,000 and it's gonna triple your likelihood. Or without it you you have no chance of twenty thousand dollars.

Tyler: And all it cost me was three hundred bucks? Yeah, that's the easy one.

Josh Tyler: Yeah, I'm in. I I'm in. Yeah, I yeah, I'm with you. So I I don't know, man. I I know there's gonna be people commenting like I can make my own and you can, and you certainly can. so anyway, man, that's that's what I got this early early November. Hey, final question for you is what do you guys do when seasons are finishing up for college coaches? What what's your what's what's your next step? do you do you take a deep breath and pause and I'm done for a couple of weeks, did you immediately hit the recruitment trail? 'Cause I know college seasons, postseasons are ending. What do you do as a

Tyler: Yeah.

Josh Tyler: college coach?

Tyler: Yeah. for us, you know, when y yeah, making playoffs and things like that, everything gets really I push a lot of things off. So I, you know, I I kinda dipped real quickly back into some communication with recruitment on some kids that were important to us. and then it's midweek now. Probably by the end of next week we will have all of our individual meetings done with all of our players. So we don't want to wait too long on those. We wanna give feedback what How did they reflect on the season? What can they do to get better? Where do I see them fitting into the team next year? What role will they play? So they're very clear on our expectations of them and and you know, hopefully their expectations of themselves within the program. and then we'll probably do like a a a team banquet to celebrate the year. I think that at the college level that's really important that every team recognizes their own players. and celebrates those things together. I think that brings I I think that's one of the the core values of belonging, right? Is recognition.

Josh Tyler: Yeah.

Tyler: and so I think that every team in the country at at the college level, high school level, club level should probably have some sort of recognition thing in place. So we'll do that. And then yeah, we we give them time off after that. Josh, like I think rest and and recovery and refocusing is is important and and That'll lead us probably into the Christmas break and then we'll we'll really hit it with you know, all our training and strength and conditioning when we start second semester.

Josh Tyler: week dude. Well enjoy your time. Enjoy enjoy some downtime. It's always this I

Tyler: Yeah. I'd rather be playing.

Josh Tyler: yeah I know that that is true. That that that is that is true. I it was always like this postseason hangover, right? You I remember always walking around for a week of going, I'm supposed to be somewhere like

Tyler: Yeah, then my my wife's like, Okay, so she's like, I I won't be able to pick you up, says my to my daughter. I won't be able to pick you

Josh Tyler: Yeah.

Tyler: up after your basketball game, 'cause I gotta go back to work, but you can ride with and and my daughter goes, Dad will be there. They lost. And I was like, Yeah, I don't have practice now at at four thirty or five o'clock. I I can be at my daughter's basketball game, so yeah, she's like,

Josh Tyler: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's a nice break.

Tyler: yeah, yeah, your dad's I'm not a widow anymore. Your dad's back in the house. He can actually pull his weight around here.

Josh Tyler: I normally made it about a month and a half and I was like, I'm ready to to to to do. yeah, I had a coach text me today. I I think people know where I'm at, so I don't want to give the name away, but he texts me and 'cause our club practices is there and he texts me, he's like, Hey, I I missed the field already. Can I come out and and and help train one of your teams? I'm like I was like, Yeah, Mick. Yeah, yeah.

Tyler: I'm I'm not doing they're okay, I'm not doing anything. Can I I'm gonna swing by.

Josh Tyler: Coup come on out, man. Yeah, it it is a I took a I we took a week.

Tyler: It's a weird f it's a weird feeling when like you're practicing every day and then it just ends.

Josh Tyler: I know.

Tyler: Yeah.

Josh Tyler: It does. It's like it it's quick. It's like Christmas morning, it's over. You're like, now I gotta put stuff away and yeah, it's

Tyler: Yeah, right.

Josh Tyler: yeah. Re reach out to a coach if you know has just finished her season and check on them to make sure they're alcoholism goes way up this time of year for All

Tyler: Check this, check their well being, yeah.

Josh Tyler: right guys. This is so NAI changes everything. This has been this has been big stuff happening here in in November. So the the NI expert of Canton, Missouri, Tyler Tomlinson, who also likes candy corn.

Tyler: Yeah, why not? Mix it up.

Josh Tyler: Did c candy corn. So this is this, my friends, have been has been CapChat Live.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Big Changes coming to NAIA

    Oct 2, 202626 minAudio

    The conversation covers recent changes in NAIA eligibility rules, the implications for institutions, and the impact of new legislation on college sports. The hosts discuss how these changes may affect student-athletes...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. College Coach Panel: ID CAMPS

    Sep 18, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    summary In this episode, college coaches discuss the ins and outs of ID camps, including misconceptions, evaluation criteria, and effective follow-up strategies. Perfect for aspiring college athletes and their families,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Big Youth Soccer Shakeup – U.S. Soccer & USYS Unify

    Sep 12, 202651 minAudio

    We sit down with Neil McNab - President and Executive Director at Georgia Soccer and Executive Director for Rush Union. Drawing on his experience as a former professional player (Manchester City youth, Portsmouth F.C.,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Live from Nike HQ: Today's College Landscape

    Aug 24, 202636 minAudio

    Live from the Nike HQ for the Rush Summit annual meeting. Josh Tyler moderates a college coaches panel to discuss the Current College Landscape PANELIST JACOB LISSEK: DENVER UNIVERSITY: MEN'S SOCCER AND RUSH SELECT...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Implications of the Five and Five Rule

    Aug 13, 202646 minAudio

    The conversation covers the impact of the five and five rule in college athletics, the challenges of load management in preseason, and the implications of the rule change on high school seniors and gap year programs....

    Credit the people on this episode