Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Camp Code - Leadership & Staff Training Podcast for Camp Directors

Camp Code - Leadership & Staff Training Podcast for Camp Directors artwork

Why Are They Struggling so Much - Camp Code #175

Nov 3, 202649 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Have some feedback? A topic suggestion? Text us! Find full show notes and links at: https://www.gocamp.pro/campcode/strugglingsomuch From Counselor to Leader: Navigating the Transition Every camp director knows the whiplash: A brilliant counselor who is amazing with kids and handles chaos effortlessly gets promoted to a leadership role - only to struggle a few weeks into the summer. As explored in this episode of Camp Code, being a great counselor and being ready to lead are two entirely different things. We often promote people based on past performance without preparing them for what needs to change. To bridge that gap, new leaders need to master a few critical shifts: From Peer to Supervisor: You don’t have to stop being friendly, but you do have to become intentional about holding standards. You can laugh with your team and still address a problem. Stopping "I'll Just Do It Myself": Instead of jumping in to fix everything (which exhausts you and stunts their growth), ask: "How can I help this person learn to handle it?" Kind + Clear + Supportive Feedback: Redefine feedback as neutral information, not a personal attack. Combine empathy with clear expectations and active support. Ultimately, a new title doesn't automatically create new leadership skills. By providing a safe space to reflect, pre-empting tough conversations with a trusted "chat it out" buddy, and balancing care, standards, and staff development, we can help great counselors evolve into confident leaders. Best Practice for Leadership Training From Gabz, During week two or three of camp, ask your young leaders to look at the returning staff on their teams and reflect on this question: "If you weren't in the room, would they still be as great as what you see them doing right now?" Asking this early helps catch the staff members who only perform when the boss is watching before they get blindsided by missed promotions at the end of the season. It gives you the window needed to offer respectful, actionable feedback and build a real bridge for their future growth. Your Hosts: Beth Allison, Camp Consultant - Go Camp Pro Gabrielle Raill, Camp Director - Camp Ouareau Thanks to our sponsor… UltraCamp Imagine camp registration software that actually gives you MORE time for what you love - CAMP! With UltraCamp, you can effortlessly track attendance, manage staff, streamline registration, and more. Explore now at ultracampmanagemnent.com/campcode. Camptivities Well prepared staff deserve an intentionally curated schedule. Camptivities cuts hours of building schedules, helps prevent staff burnout, and makes sure campers get the activities you promised. You can schedule more confidently, use your staff and resources more effectively, and create a camper experience families want to come back to. Check out Camptivities.com and get back outside with your campers.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02You have a counselor who's absolutely fantastic. The campers love them. They're creative, energetic, responsible, and great at handling the day-to-day chaos of camp. So naturally, you promote them to a leadership role. And then a few weeks into the summer, you find yourself thinking, why are they struggling so much? They were such a great counselor. Here's the thing being a great counselor and being ready to lead are not the same thing. We often promote people because of what they've done well without preparing them for what they'll need to do differently.

SPEAKER_02Today we're talking about that transition and what we can do to help new leaders succeed. Running camp should be about people, not paperwork. Ultracamp helps you manage staff, registration, and communication in one place. So you spend less time on tasks and more on camp. Find out more at ultracampmanagement.com/slash campcoat.

SPEAKER_02Thanks to our friends at Camptivities for sponsoring Camp Code. Well-prepared staff deserve an intentionally curated schedule. Camptivities cuts hours of building schedules, helps prevent staff burnout, and makes sure campers get the activities you promised. You can schedule more confidently, use your staff and resources more effectively, and create a camper experience families want to come back to. Visit camptivities.com for 15% off fall implementations and see how Camptivities can get you back out with your campers sooner than you thought possible.

SPEAKER_02Welcome to another episode of Camp Code. We have really been enjoying this series based on all of our research of what camp directors found to be the most concerning issues last summer. But before we dive in today, I invite my dear friend and someone I get to see in person in Four More Sleeps to introduce herself.

SPEAKER_02Thanks, Gab. And I'm Beth Allison. My pronouns are she, her, and I've been part of the camp world for a very long time. I still love helping camp leaders think about how we can better prepare staff and support and develop them. And I'm one of those people behind Go Camp Pro. And of course, I co-host Camp Code with Gabrielle, where we talk about real life challenges and opportunities of leading at camp. So welcome back to the things we assumed they knew, our series about the skills we expect staff to have, even when we haven't necessarily taught them.

SPEAKER_02Today's episode is about the move from counselor to leader. And when we say leader today, we mean anybody moving into a role where they're responsible for supporting or supervising or developing other staff, whether that's a head counselor or a unit head or a program coordinator or any other leadership position. We all have different names for these sorts of things. So we're just gonna use leader and we're talking about that first year of being in that kind of position. So let's start here. Gab, I got a question for you. Have you ever seen someone who was brilliant as a counselor struggle when they first moved into that leadership role?

SPEAKER_02And what do you think made that transition? Yes, being my answer. Okay. So what do you think made that transition difficult?

SPEAKER_01How much all the time, constantly, yes. No, I think I think that there's something that I mean, there's camp directors that have had that big struggle. They're they, you know, we we're great at what drew us to this passion, which it could be it could be the kids, it could be the community aspect, it could even be the staff, it could be the nature, it could be something there. And you have the opportunity to express that passion, bring people in, and you just tend to be great at it because you have an appreciation for whatever that is.

SPEAKER_01And because of that appreciation, and because of your skill sets and of course your experiences and mentors and et cetera, you're then put into a position of we want you to show others how to do what you do. And the truth is a lot of the times we don't reflect on our how, we just have the why and we're and and and people are great at it, you know, and they don't there's other skill sets that aren't always necessary, necessarily present to practice, especially once you get into a leadership role.

SPEAKER_01So I've seen this yes so many times.

SPEAKER_02And I think Gab and I always say start with the why, always, always, but then it has to be followed with the how. Yeah, like that's the important piece. Because I I find that they often struggle with maybe the work itself because it's different from when they were counseling, or they new leaders are sometimes afraid that their friends won't like them anymore if they're now in a supervisory role, you know, they can avoid conversations because of that, all that kind of thing. So that's that's what we want to talk about is preparing people for that shift before they get the promotion.

SPEAKER_02And I think that we sometimes assume that because somebody understands camp, they automatically understand leadership. But leadership isn't just doing your old job better, it's learning how to do a different job. One of the biggest changes is the relationship with your peers. So yesterday or last summer, you were sharing a cabin, you know, joking around at meals, complaining about the same things. And this summer, you may need to address someone who is late or disengaged or not doing their job properly. And you're still their friend, but you're also responsible for helping them meet expectations.

SPEAKER_02And I think that can feel really awkward, especially for somebody who has never had to give feedback or hold another person accountable. So, for me, a useful message for new leaders is you don't have to stop being friendly. You do have to become more intentional about your responsibility. So, like you can laugh with your team and still address a problem. You can care about someone and still tell them they need to change something. Being a leader doesn't mean becoming a different person, it means taking on a different responsibility. And one of the things I often saw, and I don't know if you did too, Gab, but new leadership staff would often fall into the I'll just do it myself trap.

SPEAKER_02So a new leader sees something that needs to be done. Maybe a counselor hasn't finished a task or a program's behind schedule or staff member's struggling. So the leader steps in and does it themselves, problem solved, right? Yes, maybe for the next 10 minutes. But if the leader keeps fixing everything, two things happen. The leader becomes exhausted, and then the rest of the team doesn't learn to take responsibility. And I find that this is especially tempting for people who were excellent counselors. They are used to jumping in and working hard and making things happen.

SPEAKER_02But leadership requires a different question. So instead of asking, how can I fix this, they need to ask themselves, how can I help this person learn to handle it? I mean, like imagine a counselor keeps forgetting to prepare the equipment for their activity. And the new leader could prepare it for them every day. They could complain about it to another leader. I've heard this many times, or they could have a conversation, clarify the expectation, and help the counselor develop that reliable system. And that last option takes longer at first, but it'll build the capacity.

SPEAKER_02So, Gab, my next question for you, I'm kind of interviewing you in this particular podcast, but you're still in the directing role. But how can a new leader tell the difference between stepping in because it's genuinely necessary and stepping in because it's easier than having a conversation?

SPEAKER_01I think I think one we have to understand within all industries, people get promoted and have have a hard time with this transition. This is that's a that's normal that happens in all industries. What yeah, different with camps, and I think when you're supervising, supporting, and training somebody is to know that an engineer that's moving. Okay, you guys, now I'm just like I'm making up what engineers do, but let's just say an engineer is in charge of bolt nuts and bolts, and now they are leaders of a team of people that are doing nuts and bolts.

SPEAKER_01Camp counselors that go into leadership roles were dealing with younger humans, and now they're gonna deal with a different age demographic of humans. So, as a camp director, just understanding that we're just trying to make that transition from they are actually good with people, they're good with campers, they're good with probably their co-cows. We can use that compared to maybe an engineer that's like nuts and bolts, and you're like, wait, now it's a it's a whole human that talks back to me and like has expectations. They can translate. So having your staff members understand first and foremost, before they walk into this role, what are some of the skill sets that they have with campers and starting to learn about their why or their how via something they're really good at already?

SPEAKER_01So then we can make that helpful transition for them on how do we do this with somebody that is your peer or same age or even older. Having them already have some of that confidence walking in and creating that trans translation is going to be really helpful for their confidence and and we don't do things for campers, do we? We don't, we we help them make the bed, but we don't make their bed for them. We help them, you know, we show them where the, you know, where swimming is, but we don't jump into the water and do their laps for them.

SPEAKER_01We're that's what makes a great camp counselor. And so showing those values that we have at our camp, that we have those same values with our staff members and and translating for them that they're trainers because somebody, this is a high, I mean it's not, I don't like saying that's a high turnaround turnaround rate with staff members, but the lifespan of a of a the head of canoeing in a lot of camps or the head of rock climbing in a lot of camps isn't many years. It's maybe two years or three maximum.

SPEAKER_01So we can show that even that CIT that's coming in. What are you doing to show them how to do your job? We need to make you no longer the boss. We we want somebody else to take your role. How do we do that? And putting that into your frame of mind from the beginning, but also for you yourself, make it not making it hard on yourself as a camp director or camp pro. So like this person already has the some of the human sides of of what we already do. That's why they're getting promoted. I think is a helpful lens to look at.

SPEAKER_02A phrase I like is like, I can help you figure this out, but I don't need to do it for you. Yeah. And that's leadership to me. You're offering support without taking away responsibility.

SPEAKER_01Well, it's it's a, you know, one of our our one of my leadership team members who moved into an a leadership support role this this summer, which we which we have, because they're very good at what they're doing, they were ending up doing the job. They're like, it's there's too much work for me to do. And and we have a we have somebody that comes in throughout the summer to meet with our leadership team to give a little reflection space and realign their goals and also what needs to get done at camp. So the Natasha came in to speak to this leadership team support person who is brilliant, brilliant, by the way.

SPEAKER_01And she said, Oh, I see what's happening. You think you need to do those tasks for those people. No, you need to help them figure out when's the best time for them to do the task, what kind of support they need, and let them do it. That's what, and she was like, Oh, like it was a huge light bulb moment. I think sometimes we also say those things during staff training, but they need to be reiterated. Yes. Once I once everything's going, once the machine is is running, you actually have to show them this is the okay, this is one of those moments where you're helping somebody do their job, you're not doing it for them.

SPEAKER_02Absolutely. And before we take our quick break, I just want to let you folks know that co-cows at Warrow is co-counselors, and that we in Canada do not actually have bovine who helped to supervise our children.

SPEAKER_01I use that.

SPEAKER_02Just to just to make sure you know. I'm tipping my hat to you, Beth. I appreciate that. Or my two. All right, there we go. So we're gonna take a quick break, and when we come back, we're gonna talk about one of the new skills, one of the skills new leaders often find most uncomfortable, and that's giving feedback and why being kind doesn't mean avoiding the conversation. So we'll be right back. For camp code listeners, unlock UltraCamp's operations checklist for new directors, a free download to help you prepare for a smooth season.

SPEAKER_02Find it at ultracampmanagement.com slash campcode. Running camp comes with countless moving parts. Ultracamp helps you stay on top of them. Organize activities and daily schedules, manage wait lists and cabin assignments, automate billing and payments, centralize all camper and staff info in one place. With UltraCamp, camp operations run smoother so directors can lead with confidence. Book your free customized demo at ultracampmanagement.com slash campcode.

SPEAKER_02Thanks to our friends at Camptivities for sponsoring Camp Code. What if your technology could help you lead more intentionally? Think about what you're trying to be intentional about at camp. Reducing staff burnout, managing operational overhead, making sure campers get the activities you promised their parents, feeling confident you can enroll more campers with the staff and activities you have. Camptivities can become part of your tech stack to simplify these complex challenges. Camptivity Scheduling Engine 8 handles more variables, solves more complex scheduling challenges, and makes the entire schedule easier to manage.

SPEAKER_02With more data and clear insights along the way, you can see what's happening, understand why, and build better schedules faster. And when the weather changes, you can pivot without starting over. So your team spends less time rebuilding schedules and more time in camp with campers and staff. Camptivities. Smarter scheduling, more insight, less work. Visit camptivities.com to get started. All right, welcome back everybody.

SPEAKER_02We have talked about the temptation to do everything yourself. Now let's look at what a new leader can do instead. So coaching. It doesn't mean standing back and letting someone fail. It means supporting them while leaving them with an appropriate level of responsibility. So a new leader might ask, what do you think is happening? Or what have you tried already? Or what's your next step? Or what support would you have would help you handle this? These questions encourage problem solving rather than creating dependence on the leader.

SPEAKER_02And of course, some situations require immediate action. So if there's a safety concern or a serious behavior issue or something beyond the counselor's role, yes, that new leader needs to step in and follow camp procedures. The goal, however, it's not to make every situation a teaching moment. It's to recognize when coaching is appropriate and when direct intervention is needed. So, Gabwin, I just want to know what it looks like. What does good support look like when a new leader is helping a struggling counselor?

SPEAKER_02How do we avoid either abandoning the person or sort of taking over completely? Are there other things that you would add in there?

SPEAKER_01So are you you're saying like there's a staff member that's putting in effort but they're struggling and a new leader wants to support them in that struggle? Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So, but how do they do that without just sort of abandoning that person or taking over the task completely, right? Because I've seen both.

SPEAKER_01So it's I think both are avoided tactics. And I think that's important to acknowledge. When we just take over, typically we're avoiding something. We're avoiding a conversation or we're avoiding I, you know, the feeling of I don't know how to teach somebody, or or if you just let them sink, it's also a type of like avoidance tactic. I the third piece is is perhaps that leaders also overwhelmed themselves and they're not like paying attention. Yep. But but there's something askew. I think that's what's important to pay attention to.

SPEAKER_01If we're if we're doing it for somebody or we're completely avoiding, there's something that's off. And and first is to tap into that leader, what is going on here. And my experience is nine times out of 10, it is avoidance of a tough conversation with somebody. And typically there's signs that are happening earlier before somebody's starting to sink that we're avoiding those conversations for. And I think that what you were saying at the beginning of our podcast, you know, you don't need to stop being friendly.

SPEAKER_01You can still be yourself when you're giving somebody feedback, is remembering we want you to approach that person as soon as possible. Your job as a leader is to notice and acknowledge if something is there's a little hiccup, there's a little resistance, is to notice it and to act upon it. And act upon it can be come to your camp pro support person, that could be the camp director or another teammate. How do I approach this person? Or it is to just genuinely go and ask and say, hey, I've noticed, I've noticed that when everybody's participating, you seem a little frozen and you're standing back.

SPEAKER_01I'd I'd I'd love to hear more. But typically what happens is we avoid those little pieces that we see at the beginning because we don't know what to do, and then it becomes a big issue. So it's it's teaching leadership tactics to your young leaders right when you notice something. When you notice something, say something. I think that's some sort of that's for another campaign. But you want that for your leaders at camp. If you've noticed something's off, and a lot of the times our young leaders that could again be ahead of an activity or or whatnot, but our young leaders are nervous to get somebody in trouble.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And that's that goes that goes into that piece saying, I'm not here. We're here to train. We're here, we do everything to make somebody successful within our organization. And we don't want it to get too down the road where it's it's a it's a big turnaround. We want to do micro shifts along the way.

SPEAKER_02I love that. So, yes, one of everybody's favorite F-words is feedback. Um, and I kind of say that a bit sarcastically because it tends to make people very nervous on either end of it, giving it or receiving it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02But for a first-time leader, giving feedback can feel incredibly uncomfortable, as Gab said. So they might worry about hurting somebody's feelings or damaging a friendship or being seen as bossy. So they'll often hint or make jokes or again complain to somebody else, or they wait until they're so frustrated that the conversation comes out badly. And obviously, none of these approaches are very helpful. So we need to teach these new leaders that feedback can be kind and clear and respectful.

SPEAKER_02So I used to use a very simple structure that and and would front load that feedback is information. It is not a personal attack, it's information. So young people, young leadership team members, they often avoid feedback because they think it means you're in trouble. So we need to redefine it. Feedback is information. So exactly as Gab said, I noticed. And if you want to know more about noticing, go back a few podcasts. We talked about it for a long time. Or they might say, here's the impact, or here's what needs to change, or how can I help?

SPEAKER_02That's leadership. And of course, I'm sure many of you have heard this before, but we always talked about you can be kind while being clear. So I liked to use the formula kind plus clear plus supportive. So, you know, kind, I know you've had a long day. Clear. You still need to be on time for your responsibilities and supportive. What can we do to make that easier tomorrow? It's not harsh, it's just leadership. All right, Gab. So why do you think giving feedback feels so personal for new leaders and what can help them become more comfortable with it?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you just like tugged a little bit of my heartstrings because I I think it's because it's so fresh to them. We're also working in a in an age demographic where things are very, very sensitive and new. And they're also working in a place that they typically care about. And, you know, Beth and I often talk about there's nobody that comes onto your camp or your property and they put their you know foot on the ground once they get out of the bus or the car and say, I can't wait to slack off here. You know, they their image of themselves is doing a great job, their image of themselves is ha having fun and making sure other kids are having fun.

SPEAKER_01So it it it it it taps on that and it taps on their self-esteem, and nobody wants to bring somebody's self-esteem down. So, my my thing with any stuff, any leader that's going to give anybody feedback, and this is a policy within my organization, is you never give feedback alone, metaphorically speaking. It doesn't mean that there's another human in the room or in the space with you, um, but it means you've talked it out with somebody else beforehand. So the so if there's ever if you notice that somebody is late, you can always ask them, hey, oh, I noticed.

SPEAKER_01You're late. Is everything okay? Like, is everything all right? Or what's up, you know? And they tell you the information that's not the time to necessarily give feedback. If somebody says, Yeah, I slept through my alarm, you're like, Oh, that really that really sucks. That we've all done that. Oh, that's horrible. Now, if they do this like a second time or a third time, then we need to problem solve. There's something that's going on here. We need to figure out. So, my team is never to go to that person on the second or third time and say, Hey, this has happened a couple of times. I'd I'd love to chat about how we can problem solve.

SPEAKER_01That would be a great way to approach, but my expectation is that you go to a teammate that's of amongst your peers that that you trust and say, I want to talk to Beth, classic Beth being late all the time. Classic Beth sleeps through her alarms. Spoiler alert, that is not Beth. She wakes up before her alarm. Due to anxiety, I don't want to be a whole other podcast. Whole other podcast. But even if you're feeling confident about it, you might have a spot that you haven't thought through about that person or even about you.

SPEAKER_01So, so what we always have a pre-conversation with somebody else before you give that feedback. And that could be for a first-year leadership team member, that could be for a fifth-year CNEO instructor, that could be for a 10th year assistant director. I don't even go and talk to somebody, even though I know my tactics are sound and I feel fully confident. Because what happens is maybe on the one case, I'm just going out of frustration and my energy is wrong. Or I am nervous to talk to this person.

SPEAKER_01And when I talk to somebody else, it helps me calm my nerves. Or somebody says, We've already had that conversation with that person. They actually, we just, you know, and then you're like, oh good. I didn't just tell them again, you know, something they already heard. So the first step and make it and we make it a policy is that they you need to chat it out and say, This is my plan, this is what I want to do. Is there anything that I'm missing? And typically the conversation is like, no, when are you gonna do it? Lunchtime, perfect. Let's make sure they don't have a duty. Okay, great. There we go. So chatting with somebody first, and then that provides you with the on in the moment training opportunities with your young first-time leaders, and it allows for returning leaders to impart some of their wisdom and it builds trust and it builds a teamwork, but we're all on the same page that way.

SPEAKER_01And I'll tell you, as somebody that is getting close to her 50s, everybody this year I was working in the kitchen quite a bit because we lost our head chef and our sous chef got promoted into that role, but she needs support. So I I was really there quite a bit. And for for those of you that know me, I like to be with the kids. But I this is what was needed of me at camp this summer. And there's a couple of times where I we got really, really frustrated.

SPEAKER_01And thank goodness I you I kept to my own policy. And before I went to go talk to whoever, I went and chat and say, This is what I've noticed. Am I off? You know, and I had one leadership team who is 21 years old who said to me, You know what, Gab, I think there's a lot of pressure on you right now, and it might make sense to wait a day, take a beat, and then see how you feel tomorrow. And I was irritated and I did, and she was right.

SPEAKER_01So even for us old, old goats, that little piece I think is really helpful.

SPEAKER_02I love that. That is a brilliant, brilliant, brilliant idea. Also, I like to remind new leaders that they don't need to turn every piece of feedback into a huge formal conversation.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02You know, sometimes it's a quick, respectful check-in. The key is not to let those small concerns accumulate until they become big ones. And if the concern is serious, repeated, or beyond their authority as a new leader, they involve the appropriate supervisor. And there's another challenge here that I often see first-year leaders run into is they want everyone to like them. And that is understandable, especially if they have built their identity around at camp, around being fun and helpful and well-liked.

SPEAKER_02But sometimes leadership means making a decision that somebody won't love. And you might need to enforce a policy or address a performance issue or redistribute responsibilities or tell somebody that a particular behavior isn't acceptable. It doesn't mean that you have failed as a leader. The goal, and this is a hard piece for to you know, to get into your head when you're that age, or any age really, isn't to be the most popular person on the team. It's to be somebody people can trust. And trust grows when people know you will listen and you will treat them fairly, follow through, and address problems rather than ignoring them.

SPEAKER_02So, Gab, I want to know from you how a new leader, how can they remain approachable and connected to their team while also being willing to make those unpopular decisions sometimes?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's gross. I think that's one of the gross parts of being in charge. Yep. Yep. We all want to be liked. I think there's few people that I do know in our industry that is quite confidently okay with not being liked. They're far and few in between, and they just they they walk through their camp and they're just like, meh, their problem, not mine. And I'm thriving to get closer to that. I want to be liked too. So I think it's emulging it from the beginning. We want that.

SPEAKER_01Of course we do, and it is hard to do. I think an open conversation of what is difficult for certain people to approach others when we need to give feedback, having that conversation in a safe space before camp is wonderful. And you will see on your team who are like, meh, it needs to be said. So I'm fine with saying it. That may be a really good person to be your person when you do have to go tell people, but making it first explicitly clear that we do need to do this.

SPEAKER_01Second, if we didn't do this, what would happen? And what would happen is certain people won't get hired back. So letting them know on the reality, just the transparent reality, we're doing this so that people can be not only well, one, we don't want to fire anybody, but it will happen. Two, if somebody is applying to come back and we're saying, sorry, no, we have to give them as many chances and option opportunities throughout the summer to shift their behavior, shift their way of doing things.

SPEAKER_01So what we're doing is we're we're rendering a service. So holding on to that feels really good. And then three, learning your language, learning your style of giving feedback takes practice and we're gonna fumble through it and you're gonna fumble through it. But the more you do it, the more you're gonna learn to center yourself in that conversation. I don't mean center myself, my story. I mean center as how would I present information to a person. And when you start to do that, then it's kind of cool because you're also thinking of the other person and how what's the right way to approach them.

SPEAKER_01But it it's it's I I we always talk about the beginnings, but it's so important to address that before TAMP happens. And then, yes, I would provide space throughout the summer with your young leaders and first-time leaders. Who do you feel you need to you're concerned about? And and and let's let's let's start planning how we have those chats. So at Warrow, one of the things that we don't do is during check-ins, which is every other week, we don't give feedback to staff members that haven't received that feedback already.

SPEAKER_01The check-ins are a place for them to share the learnings that they've received from their leaders. So we don't want to surprise anybody in check-ins because they're already so anxious and nervous. We don't want that surprise. So our leadership team members have to provide feedback before these check-ins happen to our staff members. That's obviously constructive feedback, that's positive feedback, but you have to provide feedback. So giving them the space to reflect and and why are they avoiding talking to those people?

SPEAKER_01Typically, you just need space to talk it out and then they can then we can do it. But that first part and then providing them space, I think is essential. Great. Yeah, absolutely.

SPEAKER_02And I think it helps to separate being liked in that moment from being respected over. Yeah. So a counselor might not enjoy hearing that they need to change something, but if the leader speaks respectfully, respectfully, explains the expectation, offers support, that conversation can strengthen trust rather than damage it. And of course, as always, directors need to model this. So if we want emerging leaders to have clear, respectful conversations, they need to see us doing that as well.

SPEAKER_02And if I could give new leaders one simple framework, it would be this. Their job has three parts. So, one, care for people. Yeah. Know your team, notice when someone's struggling, listen, help people feel supported and included. And I think if you're moving an outstanding counselor into this type of role, they're already great at that part. Yeah. Like they're already great at that. Number two is hold the standard. This is where it becomes a bit more difficult when you're talking about supervising friends, but make expectations clear, address problems, follow camp policies and procedures, and take concerns seriously and then escalate them when it's needed, right?

SPEAKER_02You know, you bump it up the chain. And that's all something you front load with them at leadership training, what decisions need to get bumped up. And number three is develop people. So you want to help counselors learn, build confidence, solve problems, and become more capable. And the challenge is that new leaders can become very good at one of these while neglecting the others. And they may care so much about their friends, they avoid accountability. They may focus so much on standards, and I've seen this too, that they become controlling.

SPEAKER_02Or they may get everything done themselves without developing anybody else. So good leadership requires all three of these. And I would encourage directors to use these responsibilities in your check-ins. Like you can ask them, who have you supported this week? What expectation have you clarified? Who have you helped become more capable? So those questions reinforce that leadership is not just about keeping things running, it's about helping people and program succeed. So let's just bring this back to the camp directors for a second.

SPEAKER_02We often promote somebody because they're capable, committed, and ready for more responsibility. And that may be exactly the right decision. But the promotion, I think this is the whole point of this podcast for us, is it shouldn't be the entire preparation plan. So we need to identify what that new leader already does well, what their new role will require, and which skills they need to practice before they're responsible for other people. So it could include giving feedback and addressing concerns or delegating rather than taking over, or managing relationships with former peers, or understanding the limits of their responsibility, whatever it happens to be.

SPEAKER_02And then we need to let them practice those skills. So, you know, using role play, giving them realistic scenarios, letting them rehearse conversations and make decisions in a setting where somebody can offer some guidance. So you've touched on this, Gab, a couple of times already, but I'd like maybe some more specifics. But how can directors continue supporting new leaders once camp is underway? Is there anything else besides some of the stuff that you've already shared with us? How do you support them through the summer?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think so. I mentioned Natasha already. I've mentioned her before. I really do believe in, you know, and I just talked about me being in the kitchen this summer. Y'all, I have my own apron. It I look cute in it. But but camp directors can get pulled away for and and then we can't do some of the leadership stuff. And having somebody to come in where you've already built a relationship with your leadership team, with this individual, and they can come in sporadically throughout your summer can really help realign those values that Beth is was highlighting earlier.

SPEAKER_01So having somebody in place to do that, and we know a lot of camp pros who have become teachers, it seems like, or a lot of camp pros are married to teachers. That's another, that's a whole other podcast, but that's a whole other podcast. Yes, a lot of people are are are in relationships with educators, and they never see each other. They don't, they just take night shifts with the kids, you know, or the fur babies. But listen, we're we're raising the children, okay? That's what's happening. But but so we have within or perhaps within your community, there are teachers that would, you know, have some time during the summer, summer.

SPEAKER_01Maybe they can make a little extra money because we want to say thank you to that work. And even if they come in for a day every other week so that they can meet with those leaders and they can have resets and and check-ins and chats. And or perhaps you are completely available, but having that other person coming in can just changes a little bit the energy and the reflection. So I do find having that helpful. I'm a big fan of cue cards personally, and I do give my leadership team members cue cards with questions on them.

SPEAKER_01I pre-make them, I have them on my desk in a cue card box. That's something that Trav has taught me about with games. I shifted it to questions that I want to ask my leadership team that I typically know are important for them to be paying attention, especially in the first week or two of camp, where everything seems to go sideways. And I mean that not from the camper's point of view, but the anxiety of a new leader who have all those thoughts like, who am I to be in this role? Who am I to tell this person they shouldn't be late?

SPEAKER_01I was late two years ago all the time. I was that punk staff, and now I'm telling somebody not to be late. Like we have all of those inner monologue thoughts, that type of sideways internal, and have those questions about who's who is your support person in your team to you? Who is somebody that if other staff members, you know, tried to be like would make your job easier? Who's somebody you need to have some question you're concerned about and you don't know how to address? Like having those cue cards and them reflecting and giving them back to you allows you on when I have those little spare moments and I see that person, I say, okay, quick, let's talk about that.

SPEAKER_01Because if I'm if I'm just talking to them like as a group, or they need, you know, it's it's hard to to think about it, but when you have that cue card, you have to write it down. You sort of reflected on it. So providing that space. And then, and then secondly or thirdly, I would make sure that yourself or somebody is present with that person who is leading in the first time near the beginning, if possible, to provide them with feedback and a lot of that good supportive feedback that is, oh wow, how you got their attention.

SPEAKER_01That was amazing. And you know, this sort of piece. Can you have uh a fellow peer that's a returner that's present during certain moments to give them a little bit of that confidence and that comfort? But also if there is things that they see they can address from the beginning. Beautiful, beautiful.

SPEAKER_02So the important point here is that the director still has a responsibility once they that someone has been promoted. So we just can't promote them, hand them a title, and assume they're gonna figure it all out. Yeah. We need to clarify expectations and provide appropriate authority, make support accessible, and check in regularly. Developing leaders, the same as with campers, is not a one-time training session. It's an ongoing process and they will get things wrong.

SPEAKER_02We all do. So they may avoid a conversation for too long. They may be too direct, they may step in when they should have just coached or coached when they should have stepped in. And that's all part of the learning. The question is whether they have a safe and constructive way to reflect, get feedback, and try again. So, you know, what happened? What were you trying to achieve? What would you do differently next time? What support would help you? These questions hold our staff accountable without turning every mistake into a verdict on their ability to lead.

SPEAKER_02And of course, mistakes involving safety or serious misconduct or camp policy need to be addressed appropriately. Supporting a new leader doesn't mean lowering expectations or ignoring risk. It just means helping them learn while ensuring that campers and staff are properly supported. And I think one of the best things that we can do is make support visible before somebody needs it. So new leaders need to know who they turn to, what they should handle themselves, what they have to bring to a supervisor.

SPEAKER_02And that's one of those let me make this perfectly clear conversations. Yes. And then they, you know, check in before they reach that point of feeling overwhelmed. So they come to you first. And we want leaders who are willing to take responsibility, not leaders who feel they have to manage everything alone. All right, Gabrielle. We have covered a lot today. So let's pull it all together.

SPEAKER_01Recap, recap, recap, recap. Like new leaders. That's everybody, that's kind of it gets my heart pumping because I think that's what a lot of camp pros are excited about. Whether they're a camper that's coming to camp for a first time and is making a friend or a staff member that's been with us for a couple of years, who definitely merits that transition into a new role and passing on the great knowledge. It's exciting when we are gifted with the opportunity to train and give confidence to new leaders.

SPEAKER_01And one of the biggest, biggest issues that new leaders have and anxiety is that how do I lead my peers? How do I manage up? How do I manage across? How do I manage down? It is very, very scary. It's quite a big difference when you're a camp counselor and you're in charge of kids versus when you're in charge of people that are your own age or even older, and you just want to be liked at the end of the day. And what Beth is saying is guess what? You can be liked at the end of the day, but feedback is part of that trajectory in this new role.

SPEAKER_01You're there to help other staff members become better at what they already love doing. And that is a lot to do with camp work and being around people. Now, you do have to remember this is a job. You do have to remember that we're in charge of young individuals and that feedback is part of making sure everybody's safe and feels happy and good. So, one of the things that Beth is talking about is I love this one, kind, clear, supportive. When we are talking to young and new leaders at the beginning of the summer, we want to let them know that their role is to care, hold the standard, which is why we're hiring them in the first place.

SPEAKER_01They know what the standard is, and to develop people because there is a very short trend, there's a very short period of life for somebody that is ahead of canoeing or ahead of rock climbing. And we need to make sure that the next generation, just that is just a year younger than you, is going to know how to do your job. So getting in that mindset that you're a trainer throughout the summer is super important. But while you're in the summer, you're like, how do I do this by myself? Well, Gab says, don't do it by yourself, ever, ever, ever. Right before you like, I need to talk to this person.

SPEAKER_01Chances are you can take a moment, go talk to somebody else, run through what you would like to say, when you would like to say it, how you would like to say it, go through all the possibilities that make you nervous and scared. And then once that is all done, you're like, now I'm ready and feeling more confident to go talk to this person. There's less fumbles. You have a buddy system that's put in place and there's learning and there is some support/slash mentoring that happens within there. You can also use key cards, have somebody come in. You don't have to do it all, everybody. Even if you just do one thing that Beth and I are talking about, what we love to hear is that you care and that you're passing on your great knowledge to other people that will pass on their great knowledge.

SPEAKER_02Thanks, Gab. I think that is a great place to land. And if today's conversation gave you something to think about, we would love to hear from you. You can find camp code at go camppro or gocamp.pro. And if you can, you can also find us wherever you listen to your podcasts. And Gab, where can they find you if they wanted to get in touch?

SPEAKER_01Well, you can check out where we work at warro.com or you can reach out to me at info at warro.com. Waro is spelt O-U-A-R-E-A-U.

SPEAKER_02Thank you. You can email me directly at Beth at GoCamp.pro or find me on threads at topaz underscore fayfa. So join us in our next podcast when we delve deeper into kind doesn't mean avoiding the con or conversation. I don't know. We'll see if we keep that title. But anyway, as always, we end with the best practice. And today that is going to come from Gabrielle.

SPEAKER_01Hey everybody, it's Gab from the podcast right now. And my best practice has to do with the same subject. But we're going to start almost at the beginningslash end. Here I'll explain how. When you're talking to your young leaders in that first or second week, and we're looking at their team and how everybody's doing, ask them to look at the staff members that are returners and ask them to reflect on the question if you weren't in the room, would they still be as great as what you see them doing right now?

SPEAKER_01So, meaning, are they still cleaning up the mess that's on the ground that nobody asked them to? Do? Are they still, you know, when kids are kind of bored starting a game or a song? Are they acting the way we want them to act when the camp director walks in or a parent walks in, whether they're there or not, or themselves as the boss? So the reason why I like doing this is that sometimes we overlook those returning staff members. And some of them are great when there is the boss in the room.

SPEAKER_01But when the boss isn't in the room, they they can maybe not be that great staff member. And we all know who those people are. And those are the leaders that camps are missing out on for next generations. We either say no to them, but we didn't know when to give them the feedback because they typically are great when we see them, but we know when we're not around, you know, stuff happens or gossip happens or et cetera. They're not hitting our big picture, our mission, whatever that might be.

SPEAKER_01And it's a shock to them when we don't offer them a leadership team position and they're frustrated when other people get it. And so we lose that staff member. Or we say yes to them, and then we have a heck of a time when we're trying to get them to give that feedback specifically. They don't want to talk, be un what they think is maybe unkind to their friends and rather just keep besties on staff. So asking that question in week two or week three gives us enough time throughout the summer to approach that that person with kindness and respect and let them know, hey, we see a lot of great stuff from you.

SPEAKER_01These are the stuff that we see. However, this sort of tapers when there isn't somebody around. And we know this because of X, Y, and Z. And you don't always have to be on. But if you're ever interested in being a leader on the leadership team or a leader moving forward, here are the things we'd love for you to work on. And and you know, phrase it however you want to phrase it. But but having your leadership team or young leaders think about that so that we can keep some of those people that unfortunately some camps lose because we didn't give them that specific feedback, having that reflection piece at the beginning of the summer.

SPEAKER_01And I've seen some great turnarounds. So I'm I'm saying this actually this works, and we can approach them as people that we care about and that we believe in, but this is what we need from them is this X, Y, and Z, whatever that is. Love it, love it, love it.

SPEAKER_02All right. A new leadership title doesn't automatically create new leadership skills. So we need to help people make that shift from doing the work to coaching others, from being a peer to taking responsibility for the team, from solving every problem to developing problem solvers, from trying to be like to building trust, from avoiding difficult conversations to being clear and kind. And if you are a camp director, don't just ask whether somebody is ready for a promotion. Ask what they'll need to learn to succeed in it and how you're gonna help them to learn it.

SPEAKER_02Because we don't want to promote great counselors and then wonder why they're struggling. We want to help great counselors become great leaders. So thanks for joining us for another episode of Camp Code and the things we assume they knew. Next time, we're gonna cover a whole bunch of other kinds of things in detail about kind conversations. So until then, keep asking good questions, keep supporting your people. And remember, when somebody struggles with a skill we never taught them, that's an opportunity for us to do better. Camp Code is brought to you by GoCamp Pro.

SPEAKER_02Have a listen to all our other podcasts. There's a lot of learning to be had there. And we will see you next time, folks. Thanks for the listening, friends.

SPEAKER_00Please remember, no other industry shares their best practices the way summer camps do. If you use an idea you heard on a GoCamp Pro podcast, please be professional and remember to give credit where credit is due. The Camp Code is brought to you by GoCamp Pro. Thanks for listening, friends.

SPEAKER_02Camp Hacker.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Did You Not See That? Teaching Staff to Notice What Matters - Camp Code #174

    Oct 27, 202638 minAudio

    Have some feedback? A topic suggestion? Text us! Find full show notes and links at: https://www.gocamp.pro/campcode/howdidyounotseethat The Art of "Camp Radar": Teaching Staff How to Notice In the high-stakes...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Why Do I Have to Tell You - Camp Code #173

    Oct 8, 202648 minAudio

    Have some feedback? A topic suggestion? Text us! Find full show notes and links at: https://www.gocamp.pro/campcode/whydoihavetotellyou Moving Beyond the "Answer Key": Cultivating Staff Initiative In the high-stakes...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Small Interactions That Shape Camp Culture - Camp Code #172

    Jun 9, 202636 minAudio

    Have some feedback? A topic suggestion? Text us! Find full show notes and links at: https://www.gocamp.pro/campcode/the-little-moments The Little Moments That Shape Camp Culture On this Camp Code episode, our hosts Gabz...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How to Recover When You Mess up - Camp Code #171

    May 26, 202630 minAudio

    Have some feedback? A topic suggestion? Text us! Find full show notes and links at: https://www.gocamp.pro/campcode/recoverwhenmessingup Repair, Reflect, Reenter: Teaching Staff How to Recover From Mistakes On this Camp...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Teaching Professionalism - Camp Code #170

    May 12, 202644 minAudio

    Have some feedback? A topic suggestion? Text us! Find full show notes and links at: https://www.gocamp.pro/campcode/professionalism Teaching Professionalism at Camp Without Losing the Fun On this episode of camp code...

    Credit the people on this episode