Stop Playing HR Cluedo: How to Run an Investigation Properly
14 minAudio
If someone says “Can I have a quick word?” and your stomach drops, last week was about grievances. This week is what comes next. Investigations. And this is where most small businesses wobble a bit. Not because you’re doing anything wrong. Because you’re trying to figure it out on the spot, while everyone else is already feeling stressed. In this episode of Buzzing About HR, I walk you through how to run a workplace investigation properly. No drama. No overcomplicating it. And definitely no “corridor justice.” At its core, an investigation is simple. It’s a fact-finding exercise. Not a disciplinary. Not a verdict. You are gathering information so you can make a fair decision later. We go step by step through what that actually looks like in real life. How to pause and steady things first if emotions are high How to write a clear scope so it doesn’t spiral into “and another thing…” How to focus on the right evidence without dragging half the team into it And how to keep a simple log so you are not relying on memory later We also talk about the bit people find hardest. The conversations. You will get simple ways to open meetings so people feel calmer, and questions that get to the facts without putting words in someone’s mouth. Because “everyone knows” is not evidence. It’s gossip in a nice outfit. Then we bring it back to what really protects you. Not a perfect process. Just a fair one. Clear steps. Consistent approach. Short, factual notes. And giving people a proper chance to respond. If you run a small business or manage people, this is one of those moments where a bit of structure makes everything feel more manageable. Press play, take what you need, and next time something lands on your desk, you will know exactly where to start. If you’re not 100% sure how your HR is really holding up, take our free HR Health Check. It’s short, jargon-free, and gives you a clear score on what’s working - and what needs a bit of love. And if you do it before 30th October 2026 you’ll get a bonus 7 Pillar Strategy-on-a-Page, tailored to help you manage HR brilliantly for the year ahead. That’s it for today, but if you fancy a bit of friendly HR advice in your inbox (with zero waffle), come and join our newsletter. We send out bite-sized tips, plain-English updates, and handy things you’ll actually use - no spam, no fluff. You can sign up here Making AI Work for Small Business Secure AI for SMEs: streamline processes, cut costs, train teams to work smarter. Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you. If you're not sure how your HR is really holding up, take the free HR Health Check. It's short, jargon-free, and gives you a clear score on what's working and what could do with a bit of love. Enjoyed this episode? Subscribe so you never miss one, and leave a review if you've got thirty seconds. It honestly does help more small business owners find the show, and it's the cheapest good deed you'll do all week. Got a question or need actual HR support? Find Kate at kateunderwoodhr.co.uk, email buzz@kateunderwoodhr.co.uk, or follow along on social. Until next time, keep buzzing, and take care of your people.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
KateIt's Tuesday, the 17th of March. So happy St Patrick's Day. If you're celebrating, I hope it involves something green, something fizzy, and absolutely nothing that ends with a sorry I slept through my alarm message tomorrow. If you listened to last week's episode, you'll remember we talked about that dreaded sentence. Can I have a quick word? And how? Nine times out of ten, it's the start of a grievance conversation.
KateWell, this week is what happens next. Because once someone's raised a complaint and you've acknowledged it properly, the next step is often an investigation. And this is where small businesses panic, wing it, and accidentally turn one issue into three. Hazel is doing her morning patrol. She's walked into the room, sighed like she pays the mortgage, and parked herself behind me like a tiny furry supervisor. She's basically here to make sure I don't do anything silly.
KateFrankly, she's doing the Lord's work. This is Buzzing About HR, and today we're talking stop playing HR Cludo. How to run an investigation properly, without drama, without corridor justice, and without accidentally making it worse. Hello and welcome back. It's Kate. If you've never run an investigation before, you're not behind. Most people haven't. You're running a business, not a courtroom.
KateBut when something lands on your desk, you do need a process. Not because you want to be corporate, because you want to be fair, consistent, and able to sleep at night without replaying the conversation at 2 a.m. So I'm going to give you a simple step-by-step plan today. You can follow it like a checklist, and it will stop you doing corridor justice, which is where most businesses come unstuck.
KateThe Hive Brief. Let's start with what an investigation actually is. An investigation is a fact-finding exercise. That's it. It's not disciplinary. It's not a verdict. It's not I've decided and now I'm collecting proof. It's you gathering information so you can make a fair decision later. If you remember nothing else, remember this. Investigation first.
KateDecision later. Because the minute you decide first, your questions get leading, your brain gets selective, and the whole thing becomes shaky. And if you're thinking, Kate, we're only small, yes. That's why you need this. You don't have HR sitting in the background tidying it all up afterwards. The sting. Right. Here's the step-by-step plan. Step one.
KatePause. Do a quick risk check. Before you rush into meetings, ask yourself, is anyone at risk right now? Is there a safety issue? Is this something that could escalate quickly? Is evidence likely to disappear? Are people so wound up they can't even be in the same room? If the answer is yes, you stabilize things first. Calm, practical steps.
KateThat might be separating people temporarily. Adjusting shifts, changing reporting lines, removing access to systems, and in serious cases, considering suspension. But suspension is neutral. It's not punishment. It's basically you saying we need space to look into this properly. Hazel has just sighed at the word suspension. She hates unnecessary drama. Same Hazel.
KateStep two. This is what people skip. And then the investigation turns into chaos. Write one paragraph that says what is being alleged, roughly when it happened. Who is involved? What you are trying to establish. And what is not part of this investigation. If you don't do this, it becomes an another thing.
KateAnd suddenly, you're investigating five years of workplace history and someone's tone of voice in 2019. Step 3. Make a simple plan for evidence and people. This is where we stop playing HR Cluedo. List what you need to look at emails, Teams messages, WhatsApp, CCTV, rotors and timesheets, policies, training records, anything else that actually proves what happened.
KateThen list who you need to speak to. The person raising the concern. Any witnesses with direct knowledge. The person being investigated. And here's the rule: you are not interviewing everyone. You are interviewing the people who actually know something. Otherwise, you create gossip and stress for no reason. And if you're wondering how you spot what's relevant, you don't need to become CSI, Small Business Edition.
KateHazel can hear a cheese packet open from three rooms away. That's the energy you want for evidence. Notice what matters, follow the trail, ignore the noise. Step four, start an evidence log. I know. A log, another document, but hear me out. This is what saves you later when someone says, Where did you get that from? Or you've ignored my evidence. Your log is simple. Date, what it is, who provided it, where it's stored, why it's relevant, that's it.
KateStep 5. Do meetings in an order that makes sense. Generally, complainant first, then witnesses. Then the person being investigated. Because you need to understand the allegation properly before you put it to the employee. At each meeting, say the same opener so it stays calm. Thanks for coming in. This is a fact-finding meeting. No decisions are being made today.
KateI'm here to understand what happened. I'll take notes and you'll be able to review them afterwards. That one opener reduces a lot of tension. Step six. Ask questions that don't put words in someone's mouth. This is the biggest difference between a good investigation and a messy one. Avoid questions like why did you do that? So you admit you were rude? Do you accept you breached policy?
KateThose are leading. They're accusatory. Instead use talk me through what happened. What did you see or hear? What was said? What happened next? Who else was there? What evidence do you have? And if someone says everyone knows they do this, you respond with who has seen it and when. Because everyone knows is not evidence.
KateIt's gossip in a nice outfit. Step seven. Keep it confidential and manage the vibe in the workplace. Investigations make people anxious. Rumours start. People pick sides. It's like year nine with payroll. So you keep it tight. You tell people This is confidential, please don't discuss it. If the wider team needs a line, keep it minimal.
KateWe're dealing with a matter through the correct process. Please focus on work and speak to your manager if you have concerns. Step 8. Write a neutral report. Your report should say what the allegation is, what you reviewed, who you spoke to, what the key facts are, where there are gaps, and whether there's a case to answer. It's not a rant, it's not a character assessment. It's a summary of what you found.
KateUse neutral wording. It is alleged. It was stated. The evidence shows the witness recalled avoid. They lied. They're always like this. They were obviously guilty. Keep it boring. Boring is good. Boring stands up. Step nine. Decide next steps and communicate calmly. Once the report is done, the outcome could be no case to answer, close it.
KateInformal action or training. A case to answer, proceed to disciplinary. Then you communicate next steps properly, keeping confidentiality. Legal angel. Here's the ACAS friendly bit in plain English. A fair investigation is about being reasonable. Reasonable steps, reasonable timescales, reasonable impartiality, reasonable chance for the employee to respond.
KateYou don't need a gold plated process. You need something you can defend as fair. Two warnings don't ask leading questions and don't delay. Delay makes everything worse. Memories fade, evidence disappears, people get stressed and start talking. And if it's serious or involves discrimination, harassment, whistleblowing, safeguarding, or anything criminal, get support early.
KateDon't wing it. Small business actions. Here's your checklist, risk check, scope paragraph, evidence plan, evidence log, meetings in order, neutral questions, confidentiality, neutral report. Clear next step. If you do those nine things, you'll be ahead of most employers and you'll massively reduce your risk. This week's challenge. This week, create three templates and save them somewhere sensible.
KateAn investigation invite email. An evidence log. An investigation notes template. So when something happens, you're not starting from scratch while stressed. And if you're already mid-in investigation, do one thing today. Write your scope paragraph. What you're investigating and what you're not. It instantly calms the chaos. Investigations don't need to be dramatic, they need to be structured.
KateStop playing HR Cluedo. Stop doing corridor justice. Stop deciding first and investigating second. Be fair. Be calm. Follow a process. Hazel is now sitting in the doorway. Like nightclub security. Which I'm taking as her way of saying, this meeting is over, please exit politely. And because it's St. Patrick's Day, she's also doing that hopeful little head tilt that says, any chance of a green biscuit?
KateSpoiler, there is no green biscuit. There is, however, a strong chance she'll accept cheese as legal tender. It's also properly sunny today. Spring is in the air. Let's hope it lasts because I need to dry out my webbed feet after the last few months of British weather. Kettle on, standards up, see you next time.
The harassment duty steps up on Friday 30 October. Employers must now take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment, a higher, more active bar, and a new third-party harassment duty means protecting your team...
There's a surge in AI-generated job applications, and it's broken the old signals, polished cover letters and CVs now tell you almost nothing, while burying employers in volume. Kate explains why the answer isn't an...
World Menopause Day is the way into a bigger subject: retention. Kate looks at how good, well-meaning workplaces quietly push out their most experienced people, often women going through the menopause at the peak of...
National Work Life Week and World Mental Health Day, and what wellbeing actually means in a small business once you take away the fruit bowl. Kate makes the case that wellbeing lives in your systems and your managers'...
October isn’t a single HR deadline, it’s a cluster of dates that can catch even well-run businesses out if you diarise the wrong one. We put every change in one place, in the right order, with the real dates attached,...