Ever opened a simple holiday request and felt your stomach tighten? It is just time off. It should be straightforward. But in small businesses, annual leave can turn into one of the biggest sources of tension. School holiday clashes. “I booked first” debates. Quiet swaps that no one tells you about. And suddenly what should restore energy is quietly draining trust. In this episode of Buzzing About HR, we break down why leave becomes such a flashpoint and how to fix it with clarity, fairness, and speed. We start by stripping policy back to what actually matters. Short rules that people can find and understand. Naming peak weeks upfront instead of pretending they do not exist. Being honest about how many people can realistically be off at once. And choosing a fairness method that actually fits your team. That might mean rotating priority year to year. Capping peak-season leave. Or running a genuine first-come-first-served system that everyone can see is fair. We also talk about speed. Nothing fuels anxiety like silence. A simple rule such as deciding within five working days, or setting a clear decision date, removes so much drama. And when you do have to say no, we cover language that keeps it about capacity, not character, and offers workable alternatives instead of a blunt refusal. Then we get into the messy middle. Manager inconsistency. Swaps happening in the shadows. Hero culture where one person never takes leave and everything collapses the moment they finally do. We talk about making swaps visible, aligning managers so everyone applies the same approach, and creating simple cover plans that spell out what continues, what can pause, who is backing up, and where instructions live. Most importantly, we talk about real switch off. Defining what counts as an emergency. Stopping the habit of pinging people while they are away. And modelling boundaries from the top so rest feels safe, not risky. If you are tired of rota jigsaws, guilt trips, and last-minute tension, this episode gives you a calmer, fairer way to handle leave in a small team. Subscribe, share it with a fellow manager, and leave a quick review telling us the one change that would make time off feel fair in your workplace. If you’re not 100% sure how your HR is really holding up, take our free HR Health Check. It’s short, jargon-free, and gives you a clear score on what’s working - and what needs a bit of love. And if you do it before 30th October 2026 you’ll get a bonus 7 Pillar Strategy-on-a-Page, tailored to help you manage HR brilliantly for the year ahead. That’s it for today, but if you fancy a bit of friendly HR advice in your inbox (with zero waffle), come and join our newsletter. We send out bite-sized tips, plain-English updates, and handy things you’ll actually use - no spam, no fluff. You can sign up here If you're not sure how your HR is really holding up, take the free HR Health Check. It's short, jargon-free, and gives you a clear score on what's working and what could do with a bit of love. Enjoyed this episode? Subscribe so you never miss one, and leave a review if you've got thirty seconds. It honestly does help more small business owners find the show, and it's the cheapest good deed you'll do all week. Got a question or need actual HR support? Find Kate at kateunderwoodhr.co.uk, email buzz@kateunderwoodhr.co.uk, or follow along on social. Until next time, keep buzzing, and take care of your people.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
KateIf you've ever had a holiday request land in your inbox and you've instantly thought this is going to cause drama, you are not alone. Because time off should be the easy bit. People rest, recharge, come back nicer, everyone wins. And yet, in small businesses, holidays can cause more tension than a leaky roof. Especially when you've got peak seasons, skeleton staffing, school holidays, and someone who always seems to book the same two weeks every year like it's been carved into stone tablets.
KateThis is Buzzing About HR, and today we're talking time off, tension on. Sorting holidays without falling out. Hello and welcome back. It's Kate. Hazel is here too, my well-being officer. She sat nearby doing her best I support well-being face, which mainly involves pretending she hasn't been fed in at least 12 years. Hazel size, translation, less talking.
KateMore treats. Right, let's get into why holidays get so spicy. It's rarely about the actual holiday. It's about fairness. It's about feeling overlooked. It's about someone thinking, why do they always get what they want and I never do? It's about people feeling like they can't switch off, or like the business falls apart without them. It's about managers dreading the rotor jigsaw.
KateAnd it's about the business owner sitting there thinking, I cannot have the whole team off at once, or we'll all be living here. So when holiday goes wrong, what you're really dealing with is emotion, perception, and trust. Let's talk about the common flashpoints. One, last minute requests. Someone asks for next week off and you've already got two people away. They're disappointed when it's a no. You feel guilty.
KateThey feel resentful. Then you're in a SOLK situation. 2. School holidays. If you've got parents in the team, those weeks matter. But if the same people always get priority, everyone else starts feeling like they're second class. 3. The I booked it first argument. Someone submits a request six months in advance and thinks they've won. Someone else asks later and is told no.
KateAnd now you've got a fairness debate. 4. The favorite manager effect. If requests get approved, based on who asked nicely or who the manager likes, you'll create tension, even if you don't mean to. 5. The unofficial swapping and side deals. Don't worry, I'll just swap with Jamie. Except Jamie didn't agree and the manager didn't know. And now the rotor is wrong and everyone's annoyed.
Kate6. People not taking holidays. This sounds like the opposite problem, but it causes the same tension. Because if someone never takes time off, they become a bottleneck, they get resentful, they hoard knowledge, they burn out, and then when they finally take leave, everything is chaos because nobody's covered. Now the goal here is simple. You want a system that feels fair, is easy to manage, and doesn't rely on the manager's mood that day.
KateSo here are the practical fixes. First, set clear rules that everyone understands. You don't need a long policy, you need clear basics. How much notice is required? How many people can be off at once? What are the peak periods? What's the process for requesting? Who approves? And what happens if two people want the same time. If those rules are not written down and shared, you'll end up with the manager being the policy.
KateAnd that's when people start saying, Well, you said yes to them last time. It becomes personal, and that's where the falling out begins. Second, decide how you'll handle peak weeks. This is where most businesses come unstuck. If you have periods where you simply can't have multiple people off, name them. Be honest. For example, if December is your busiest month, say so. If summer Saturdays are non-negotiable, say so.
KateIf end of month is crunch time, say so. People can cope with boundaries. What they can't cope with is surprise boundaries that appear only when they ask. Third, build in a fairness system. There are a few ways to do this, and you can pick what suits your business. You can rotate priority. So if someone got Christmas week last year, they go lower priority this year. You can use a cap on peak leave. For example, everyone can request one week in peak season, and additional requests are only approved if there's capacity.
KateYou can have a first-come, first served rule, but only if the system is genuinely accessible and consistent. That means people know when the holiday calendar opens and managers approve within a set time frame, so it's not a waiting game. The key is this.
KateApprove or decline within five working days. If you can't decide yet, tell them when you will decide. That reduces anxiety and stops rumours. Fifth, separate the person from the decision. When you decline leave, don't make it feel like a judgment on them. Make it about capacity. Try something like, I can't approve that week because we already have two people off and we won't have safe cover.
KateIf you can flex the dates, I can approve the week before or the week after. That keeps it practical. It also shows you're trying to help, not just saying no. Sixth, don't rely on informal swaps without oversight. Swapping can work brilliantly, but it must be visible. The manager still needs to approve it, and the calendar needs updating. Otherwise you'll end up with cover gaps and arguments about who agreed what.
KateSeventh, blank cover, not heroics. In small businesses, holidays often fail because the business relies on one hero who holds everything in their head. Then when they're off, everyone panics. Build simple cover plans. What tasks need covering? What can pause? Who is the backup? Where are the instructions? You don't need a perfect manual.
KateYou need enough that the business doesn't fall over when someone takes a week off. Eighth, encourage people to actually take their holiday. This is a culture piece. If people feel guilty taking time off, they won't rest properly. They'll stay half on, checking emails, putting out fires, and they'll come back more tired than when they left. Set the tone. Holidays are for switching off. If you message people on holiday, you're telling everyone that time off isn't real.
KateUnless it's a genuine emergency, leave them alone. And define what counts as a genuine emergency. Because some managers think everything is an emergency. Now, a quick word on manager behaviour because this is where things get messy. Managers need consistency. If one manager is relaxed and says yes to everything, and another is strict and says no to everything, you'll create fairness issues across the business.
KateSo align your managers on a shared approach. Also, please don't approve leave in the moment just to avoid an awkward conversation. That is how you end up with three people off, no cover, and a business owner quietly crying into their tea. Be kind but be clear. Now let's do a quick check to stop the tension before it starts. Do people know the rules? Do they know how far ahead they should request?
KateDo you have a shared holiday calendar everyone can see? Do managers approve quickly? Do you have a fairness method for peak weeks? Do you plan cover in advance? And do people feel safe taking their holiday without being made to feel guilty? If you've got a couple of no's in there, that's your starting point. This week, here's what I want you to do. One simple action. Put your holiday rules into a short plain English message, five lines max, share it with a team, then open a shared holiday calendar and make it visible.
KateAnd if you don't have one, even a basic system will do. The point is transparency. If you want to go one step further, look at last year's peak leave, who got what? Is there a pattern where the same people always get the best weeks? If yes, you found the root of the tension. If you're a manager listening, your job isn't to make everyone happy all the time. Your job is to be fair, consistent, and clear. People can cope with a no when it's explained properly.
KateWhat they can't cope with is feeling like the rules change depending on who's asking. And if you're the business owner, remember this. Holiday tension is rarely about entitlement. It's usually about trust. When people trust the system, they accept the outcome. When they don't trust the system, every decision feels personal. Hazel sighs again. Translation. Time off means naps. I support this message.
The harassment duty steps up on Friday 30 October. Employers must now take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment, a higher, more active bar, and a new third-party harassment duty means protecting your team...
There's a surge in AI-generated job applications, and it's broken the old signals, polished cover letters and CVs now tell you almost nothing, while burying employers in volume. Kate explains why the answer isn't an...
World Menopause Day is the way into a bigger subject: retention. Kate looks at how good, well-meaning workplaces quietly push out their most experienced people, often women going through the menopause at the peak of...
National Work Life Week and World Mental Health Day, and what wellbeing actually means in a small business once you take away the fruit bowl. Kate makes the case that wellbeing lives in your systems and your managers'...
October isn’t a single HR deadline, it’s a cluster of dates that can catch even well-run businesses out if you diarise the wrong one. We put every change in one place, in the right order, with the real dates attached,...