Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Buzzing About HR

Buzzing About HR artwork

Fair Pay or Favoritism

Mar 4, 202513 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Have you ever given a quick pay rise to keep someone from leaving, only to watch it snowball into resentment across your team? That knee-jerk decision might be costing you far more than you realize. With International Women's Day approaching and the National Living Wage set to increase next month, pay fairness questions are unavoidable for small business leaders. This episode dives deep into the real-world challenges of handling counter offers and pay decisions when margins are tight and good people are getting poached. We walk through a practical decision framework that helps you navigate these difficult moments with clarity and consistency. You'll learn how to choose the right mechanism for each situation - whether that's a retention bonus, market adjustment, or progression increase - while protecting your business from equal pay risks that affect companies of all sizes. The legal lowdown section demystifies equal pay law in plain English, addressing common misconceptions head-on. Contrary to popular belief, equal pay applies to businesses of all sizes, not just those required to report. Jobs don't need to be identical for comparisons to be valid, and "market rate" isn't a magic defence unless you can prove it with solid evidence. Through mini-dramas illustrating common pay scenarios gone wrong, we demonstrate how seemingly small decisions can trigger costly spirals of resentment, claims, and turnover. The episode closes with a rapid-fire Q&A addressing your most pressing questions about comparators, job evaluation, and time limits for claims. Pay decisions are well-being decisions that directly impact both your people and performance. Which approach will cost your business less: creating a fair structure that withstands scrutiny, or constantly firefighting departures and rebuilding teams? Download our free one-page Paym Rise Decision Flow and share it with your busiest manager today. If you’re not 100% sure how your HR is really holding up, take our free HR Health Check. It’s short, jargon-free, and gives you a clear score on what’s working - and what needs a bit of love. And if you do it before 30th October 2026 you’ll get a bonus 7 Pillar Strategy-on-a-Page, tailored to help you manage HR brilliantly for the year ahead. That’s it for today, but if you fancy a bit of friendly HR advice in your inbox (with zero waffle), come and join our newsletter. We send out bite-sized tips, plain-English updates, and handy things you’ll actually use - no spam, no fluff. You can sign up here If you're not sure how your HR is really holding up, take the free HR Health Check. It's short, jargon-free, and gives you a clear score on what's working and what could do with a bit of love. Enjoyed this episode? Subscribe so you never miss one, and leave a review if you've got thirty seconds. It honestly does help more small business owners find the show, and it's the cheapest good deed you'll do all week. Got a question or need actual HR support? Find Kate at kateunderwoodhr.co.uk, email buzz@kateunderwoodhr.co.uk, or follow along on social. Until next time, keep buzzing, and take care of your people.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

KatePicture this it's Tuesday, the 4th of March 2025. Small logistics office in Portsmouth. Phones ringing, vans, late, costs rising. Everyone's a bit on edge. Jasmine steps in, eyes, tired, determined. I pivot my chair. Kate, I've had an offer Two quid an hour more. If you can match it, I'll stay. I'm thinking that'd make her the third picker we could lose this week. What is going on? Just bump her now.

KateWe don't want to lose another key member. We'll sort the rest later. Quick raise or slow wildfire? Hi, kate, same role as Jasmine. Why is she on more than me? Handing in my notes Feels like favourites. Here's the heart of it. Does paying one person more keep stability or spark resentment and turnover? Which one will cost us most? Hello, you lovely lot. I'm Kate. This is Buzzing about HR Today.

KateFair pay or favouritism, counter offers and quick pay bumps. Smart retention or slow burn chaos. Plain English UK law only. If you've got a live case, get help early. Let's get practical. Kettle on Cake. Optional for morale, not policy. Part one setting the scene Across small businesses. Right now, margins are tight. International Women's Day is this weekend. Fair pay is in the air and on LinkedIn everywhere.

KateNational living wage goes up. Next month your lower bands will shift. Good people are getting offers. Managers feel cornered. The fastest lever is pay. But pay, the squeaky wheel, has a cost. Counter offers aren't evil. Unmanaged counter offers become patterns. Patterns become perceived unfairness. Perceived unfairness becomes churn or claims. And that, my friends, is how your diary gets eaten alive.

KatePart two Benefits versus headaches. Handle pay well and you get retention with fairness and trust. Clarity, a playbook, not panic. Defensibility if challenged. Budget control Fewer, ad hoc bumps Wing it and you get the favourites narrative. Equal pay risk if gaps skew by sex Turnover spirals. After one counter offer, cost creep, bands bent out of shape.

KateIt's like spaghetti, but less tasty. Part three the legal lowdown. Legal in one cup of tea. Equal pay basics Men and women must get equal pay for equal work. That means like work, work rated equivalent or work of equal value. Every contract has a sex equality clause baked in value. Every contract has a sex equality clause baked in. If you pay differently, you need a material factor that isn't sex.

KateIf the difference indirectly disadvantages one sex, you'll need objective justification. Time limits exist. Tribunal equal pay claims usually six months from leaving. Civil claims can run for years. Don't sit on problems. Fix what you can now. This week's context matters. Iwd is days away. Expect fairness questions. National living wage rises next month. Pressure is coming for lower bands.

KatePlan. Don't panic. Then plan two touchstones, one line each, as the v briley store staff could compare to depot staff. Comparators aren't always in the same building. Samira ahmed v bbc. Equal work needs equal pay. Market isn't a magic wand. Without evidence, common, common traps, market rate as your only reason, weak if unproven or if it bakes in bias. We're under 250, so we're fine.

KateReporting might not apply. Equal pay law still does. Part four, step-by-step process. Walkthrough Pay rise decision flow. Use this when someone Thank you. Define the ask Is this a retention counter, offer A market adjustment for the role, progression, a temporary responsibility allowance?

KateFind comparators. Same role, same band, ideally same site. Note pay service skills performance. Scan for risk. Would a rise create or widen a sex-based gap? If yes, consider a band review, not a one-off bump. Pick the right mechanism Retention, bonus, time bound, market adjustment Applies to all in role Progression, increase Against a framework, responsibility allowance, temporary duties.

KateWrite a short business case. Why now? Which mechanism Cost versus turnover risk, fit with your framework? Decide consistently. Apply the same tests as last month. If you diverge, write down why. Communicate clearly To the employee decision reason, review date To managers the principle behind it. Document and diarise File comparators and sign off. Set a review point three to six months. Zoom out quarterly.

KateRun a quick fairness check by role or band. If you fix one, fix the pattern. Golden threads, fairness, consistency, transparent criteria and solid material factor thinking. When differences remain, also breathe. Then document Part 5. Mithbuster Parade Myth Equal pay only applies if jobs are identical. Truth it also covers equivalent and equal value work.

KateMyth we're tiny, the law won't look at us. Truth reporting is for big employers. The law covers everyone. Myth market rate always wins. Truth not if it bakes in bias or you can't evidence it. Prove it or lose it. Myth a quick counter offer is cheaper. Truth it can be the most expensive move. If it triggers churn or claims. Myth we'll keep it secret.

KateTruth pay secrecy rarely holds Plan for daylight. If you'd be proud to explain it out loud, you're on safer ground. Part six mini dramas three tiny scenes. Then fixes the counter offer spiral Manager we matched her offer. She's staying Colleague. So I must threaten to leave to be valued colleague, so I must threaten to leave to be valued.

KateFix set rules. Retention payments are rare and time bound. If the roll rate moved, adjust the band and all incumbents, not just the squeaky wheel. Document the logic. Explain the principle Same roll, same range is a very useful sentence. The market rate fig leaf Director. Engineers are scarce. That's why the men earn more. Not a defence if it disadvantages women and isn't backed by evidence. Fix. Use objective factors.

KateProven scarcity, skills responsibilities. Test for indirect bias. If a factor hits one sex more, you need objective justification. Unexplained gaps erode trust and mental health. The band bender Owner let's bump just this one person Quietly. Finance, then three more will ask tomorrow. Fix If the roll rate moved, move the band and bring others along. Announce the rationale in plain English.

KateConsistency beats secrecy. Whispers cost more than clarity. Part seven Practical takeaways. Five quick actions Map rolls into bands with ranges. Log comparators before any increase. Choose the right tool retention, market progression allowance, review patterns quarterly for equal pay risk. Explain decisions clearly in writing. If you can't explain it to a new starter in one minute, rethink it.

KateAnd yes, a slice of cake can help the meeting, not the pay gap. Part 8. Listener Q&A. Seven quick questions straight answers. Question 1. One-off raise to keep someone and leave others, as is Answer. You can, but check comparators. If it creates a sex-based gap without a strong objective reason, you're at risk. Write down your material factor. Question two Do comparators have to be in the same building?

KateAnswer Not always. With common terms across sites, comparisons can reach further. Think Asda v Briley. Question three Do we need formal job evaluation? Answer Not mandatory. A simple banding or light job evaluation grid makes consistency easier and cheaper than a claim. Question four Is market scarcity enough to defend a difference? Is market scarcity enough to defend a difference? Answer Maybe, if it's real, evidenced and not indirectly discriminatory without justification.

KateKeep your evidence, review it regularly . Question 5 how long to bring an equal pay claim? Answer Tribunal Usually six months from leaving Civil claims Years. Don't wait to fix gaps. Question six we already pay national living wage. Anything else to do? Answer yes, plan the April rise, adjust bans so the uplift doesn't squash lower grades and create new fairness issues.

KateQuestion seven Should we publish or pay? Answer you don't have to. But clearer ranges and criteria Reduce suspicion and make conversations easier. Think salary bands what's on the table. Outro and call to action. Back to that opening scene. We saved Jasmine with a quick raise. Then we spent the week handling resentment and resignations.

KatePay decisions are well-being decisions. Fairness protects performance and people. What's cheaper for your business? A fair structure that stands up to daylight or firefighting Pay Rise departures and rebuilding teams? Grab my free one page PayRise Decision Flow Link in the show notes. Share this with your busiest manager. I'm Kate. This is Buzzing About HR. Kettle On Standards Up. See you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What Employers Must Do Before 30 October To Prevent Sexual Harassment

    Oct 27, 202619 minAudio

    The harassment duty steps up on Friday 30 October. Employers must now take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment, a higher, more active bar, and a new third-party harassment duty means protecting your team...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How To Hire Well When AI Writes The Applications

    Oct 20, 202619 minAudio

    There's a surge in AI-generated job applications, and it's broken the old signals, polished cover letters and CVs now tell you almost nothing, while burying employers in volume. Kate explains why the answer isn't an...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Menopause Support That Protects Retention

    Oct 13, 202618 minAudio

    World Menopause Day is the way into a bigger subject: retention. Kate looks at how good, well-meaning workplaces quietly push out their most experienced people, often women going through the menopause at the peak of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How Small Businesses Build Real Workplace Wellbeing

    Oct 6, 202619 minAudio

    National Work Life Week and World Mental Health Day, and what wellbeing actually means in a small business once you take away the fruit bowl. Kate makes the case that wellbeing lives in your systems and your managers'...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The October Employment Law Changes With The Right Dates

    Sep 29, 202628 minAudio

    October isn’t a single HR deadline, it’s a cluster of dates that can catch even well-run businesses out if you diarise the wrong one. We put every change in one place, in the right order, with the real dates attached,...

    Credit the people on this episode