This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.thebulwark.com Sarah sits down with Congresswoman Lizzie Fletcher to break down the Texas redistricting ruling and why a Trump-appointed judge delivered a major surprise. They dig into what this means for 2026 and why the fight over fair maps is far from over. As always: Watch, listen, and leave a comment. Bulwark+ Takes is home to short videos, livestreams, and event archives exclusively for Bulwark+ members. Don’t care for video? Use the controls on the left side of the player to toggle to audio. Add Bulwark+ Takes feed to your player of choice, here.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hey everyone, Sarah Longwell here, publisher of The Bulwark, and I have the fantastic Lizzie Fletcher, Congresswoman from Texas, here to explain all that's happening with this Texas redistricting case to me. Lizzie, thanks for being here. Glad to be here. Always glad to be with you, Sarah. I can't believe I just called you Lizzie. I should call you Congresswoman Fletcher, like a grown-up. The problem is... Congresswoman Fletcher and I know each other because we both went to Kenyon and she was five years older than I was.
SPEAKER_00And so we were at reunion together and we were on a panel.
SPEAKER_01So that's how it started. And honestly, most people call me Lizzie because I put it on everything. You know, fun fact, I put it on the ballot, even though I was a practicing lawyer, putting Elizabeth on everything, because I was like, but everybody knows me as Lizzie. So, you know, you're welcome. There's a lot of like Team Lizzie merch. I can get you seeing that. And it's all good. So I'm perfectly happy for you to call me Lizzie.
SPEAKER_00Please do. Okay. I just, I sometimes forget decorum is still an important part of our system. And you are a congresswoman and a... I know, I know. It's all so sad and depressing. Well, you know what? It looks like to some degree there are still rules. There are still courts. And one of them just ruled there in Texas that the new congressional map for 2026 that... The president of the United States pushed on Texas as mid-cycle
redistricting in
SPEAKER_00order to procure more Republican House seats, squeeze them out of Texas. The court said no. They said that they have to stick to the lines passed in 2021. So three judge panel that ruled that. Can you just unpack sort of because we talked about this going back when this first broke and now a lot of stuff has happened since then. But what does this ruling mean and will it stick?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay. So huge questions. I'm going to try to break it down a little, but I want to start where you started, because I do think it is really important to take a minute and think about this opinion that this panel just issued. It was a two to one ruling. And I think that there are many things about it substantively that are hugely important to talk about. But I also think, you know, when it came down, first of all, I was So excited to see the court reaching the right result,
SPEAKER_01especially after I know how much hard work the team put into this. So when I say the legal team, I mean the lawyers. And as a lawyer, I can say these lawyers cannot get enough shout outs. They did an incredible, incredible job. They were ready to go. As soon as the map was signed, they'd been working on this and pouring their heart and souls into this for years. There's a big legal team and I'm so grateful to them. And I'm also really grateful that the judge who issued this 160 page opinion, it ran in Texas. You know, we elect our judges.
SPEAKER_01He was on the Texas Supreme Court for many years as a Republican judge. He was appointed to the bench by President Trump and he. issued this opinion that found that Texas Republicans, Governor Abbott, and all of those who were involved in this process discriminated against Black and Hispanic Texans, not only in what they said about the map, but in the map itself. And so it really gives me not only the substantive understanding
SPEAKER_01appreciation for the result that it brings us, but also a lot of hope that we don't need to give up hope. There are still really good people out there who are doing the right thing, who are looking at the facts and the law and reaching the conclusions. Everything is not a foregone conclusion. And as we head into 2026 and we think about the elections and all the stuff that we're working on, It just gives me a lot of hope we can get there. Like we can we can turn this stuff around. Obviously, the elections gave us a lot of that hope, a lot of other things. But I just want to point out kind of starting with,
SPEAKER_01you know, the judge that issued this opinion, this is a real profile in courage. And we don't see that many of those around here these days. And so I think that that is important. Now, substantively, what it does. is the plaintiffs, there are five different plaintiff groups that all work together and ask the court to temporarily stop the map that Governor Abbott signed earlier this year, the 2025 map, from going into effect for the 2026 elections and basically asked for a preliminary injunction requiring the 2026 elections to go forward on the
existing congressional
SPEAKER_01map, which they were already in court arguing was discriminatory, but that we would use that map for the next election and have the court look at and redraw potentially the 2021 map. But that which is the status quo would stay in effect for the 2026 elections. And then the court will take up the substance and look at the map overall for a permanent remedy. So that's where we are. The state of Texas immediately appealed. It will have a direct appeal to the United States Supreme Court.
SPEAKER_01So it's headed to the Supreme Court. It is fully anticipated that the governor and the state of Texas will ask the Supreme Court, if the district court doesn't do it, to stay the judge's order. So that's the next thing we're looking for, is to see whether the order enjoining use of the new map and requiring use of the 2021 map, the existing congressional districts we have now, will get stayed or will continue as the Supreme Court takes up the case.
SPEAKER_00Are we optimistic about the Supreme Court? I mean, you're a lawyer, so you know the ruling that came out from two out of the three judges. Did it make the kind of compelling case that the Supreme Court might be unlikely to overrule? Or does it seem like there are flaws in it or something that the Supreme Court could just any little thing they could use to sort of procedurally or technically give Trump what he wants? so my read on it is this is an incredibly thorough well researched well thought out
well articulated opinion like i said it's 160 pages replete with maps and other
SPEAKER_01things but it really is kind of a brutal um review of what the Texas Republican leaders did in this case. It really systematically exposes how race was used illegally to configure the map and how Governor Abbott and Texas Republicans illegally used race to describe it, to promote it, to justify adopting it. And so I think that it's It's a really important, clear roadmap as to why this injunction was issued and why it
should stay in place. And I think that the other thing about it is that there was a dissent and the
SPEAKER_01dissenting opinion is very passionate, but it is not a clear articulation of what's wrong with the evidence. You know, the injunction really lays out all of the evidence and shows why the court reached this result. And the other important thing to know, because there's so many things about voting rights and voting cases, and we can talk about it a lot more, but basically this case was brought on constitutional grounds. And they only had to reach one finding, which was that the state of Texas discriminated against
minority voters in Texas with this map and violating the 14th and 15th amendments of the Constitution.
SPEAKER_01And so it's not a voting rights case. There's no VRA claim that's going to get mixed up with the other VRA case that the Supreme Court's currently considering. So in that sense, it's pretty straightforward. And I am optimistic. I mean, I think The court reached the right result, and the Supreme Court should allow this injunction to stand. Because we are seeing the Supreme Court kind of got the Voting Rights Act.
SPEAKER_00So that's an interesting point that I had not considered, which is that you're saying the lawyers specifically tried to stay out of that framework because they know the Supreme Court is... can get funny about that and instead focus narrowly on the law there in Texas. Actually, I want to remind you of something you told me when we talked last about this case, because it stuck with me and it seems even truer today than it was when we talked about it, which was even if the Supreme Court were to,
SPEAKER_00you know, overturn, overrule the ruling, which I hope it doesn't. But if it if it did, The Republicans can't feel as great about Texas, even with the new maps, because Hispanics, more than just about any other demographic, are just the bottom is dropping out of them for Trump. And so... To the extent that the new maps were redrawn with a little bit of a bullish read on
SPEAKER_00the political realignment that Hispanics could be giving to Republicans, that seems not to be true anymore. And so you told me at the time, hey, Sarah, even if this happens, I still think we can do better than they think we can. Do you still feel that way?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I still feel that way. And when you look at what they did, they essentially made two of the districts that Democrats currently hold in South Texas much more difficult based on the assumptions they made coming out of 2024 and the election results in 2024. I think that that was an overestimation and certainly what we saw in the elections in New Jersey and Virginia and across the country, you know, local elections in Texas, too. You saw a shift back in terms of Democrats winning and picking up ground everywhere.
But also they took those two districts and thought they made them more Republican.
SPEAKER_01We've always thought we could compete. They'll be hard. You know, they're not easy races. These are frontline races either way. We feel very optimistic that we can pick up the other district in the Valley, which is currently held by a Republican. But under either map, we feel really good about our chances of actually picking that up. And then in the new map, they had drawn another district kind of outside of San Antonio. We feel very strong about that one. But certainly we know that the efforts that they've undertaken
to disenfranchise
SPEAKER_01voters are also going to backfire. People are mad and everybody in Texas should be mad because ultimately what they're doing and ultimately the reason people hate gerrymandering is because you want it to matter when you go to the ballot box, right? You want to be able to say, throw the bums out or you're doing a great job.
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.thebulwark.com House Republicans have apparently decided to stop showing up for work, leaving Mike Johnson begging his members to return as a government...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.thebulwark.com Rep. Jamie Raskin joins Catherine Rampell to discuss the growing investigation into Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick’s financial ties to...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.thebulwark.com Full transparency: this was not a good press conference from the president. For the true sickos among you, upgrade to a Bulwark membership...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.thebulwark.com Andrew Egger and Ben Parker give their takes on Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s surprise trip to Venezuela, where he announced a new...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.thebulwark.com Sam Stein and Andrew Egger look at Elon Musk’s embarrassing attempt to distance himself from MAGA after spending hundreds of millions of...