A bigger mortgage can impact your ability to invest, change careers, travel, start a business, survive a layoff, retire early, or create the lifestyle you actually want. In this episode, I'll walk you through the framework I use to evaluate a home purchase, including the hidden costs most buyers overlook and the tradeoffs that rarely get discussed. In this episode, you'll learn: Why "Can I afford the payment?" is the wrong question The true cost of homeownership beyond the mortgage How much of your take-home pay should go toward housing The hidden expenses that catch many homeowners off guard How a house can impact your flexibility, retirement timeline, and future choices Questions to ask before buying a home Why the bank's approval amount isn't necessarily your budget How to determine whether a house supports the life you want to build đź’° Need help making a major financial decision with confidence? In a 90-Minute Money Clarity & Decision Support Session, we'll look at your full financial picture alongside your goals to understand the real tradeoffs of your options and what the numbers actually mean for your life, so you can move forward with total confidence. Book Your Session here: Build Wealth with Katie
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
the best house purchase isn't necessarily the biggest house that you can qualify for. It's the house that still leaves room for investing and vacations, career changes, or taking time off, raising your kids the way you want, and all the things that make life rich outside of a house. Welcome to the Build Wealth Podcast, where ambitious women get real about money, wealth, and what it means to fund a life that's truly
free. I'm your host, Katie Viola, personal finance coach and founder of Build Wealth with Katie. This show isn't about budgeting hacks or guilt trips. It's about unlearning outdated money rules that never served us, rewriting our internal money stories, and building real wealth for a life that you actually want. We're here to help you make clear, confident money moves that gives you real freedom, time, choice, and peace of mind. Now, let's turn your ambition into freedom. What's up, dolls? Welcome back to Build Wealth.
I hope you're having an amazing week. I'm happy to be home from our trip visiting family. I'm coming at you from another nap time podcast session. My husband was kind enough to give me our home office for like an hour so I can record this instead of recording in our bedroom closet. What a guy, what a guy, so nice of him. So today I'm excited because I wanna talk about one of the biggest purchasing decisions we ever make in our lifetime, and that is buying a house. For
most people, there is truly no bigger financial decision than that. And I think a lot of times we get kind of caught up with the big purchase, and a lot of times we're asking ourselves the wrong questions and zooming in a little bit too much and not looking at the big picture. And then when we do that, We may be accidentally giving up the opportunity to reach other goals of ours or accomplish other dreams that we might have or come up with later in our life that then we actually don't have the chance to have. So today I want to walk you through how I think
about running the numbers on a house purchase. I think a lot of people mainly ask, can we afford the payment? But that's really not the right question. Because almost everybody can find a house payment that they can technically squeeze into their budget. But the question that's getting left out is, what is this house going to cost me? And it's not just in dollars. It's also in future wealth, in career flexibility, in stress, in years until work becomes optional, and other
opportunities for yourself or your family. Because a house doesn't just cost the mortgage payment. It can cost the ability to take a career risk because you're tied down to this big payment every month. Or it could cost you the ability for one parent to stay home or to survive a layoff comfortably or take bigger vacations that you wanted or invest more or just have flexibility in your life and in your future for different decisions. And I think a lot of people kind of just go with the number that the bank gives them
when they get approved for a mortgage, and they don't actually run the numbers in their own scenario and how that payment is going to affect their actual life that they're living alongside their other expenses and their other goals. And before we dive in, if you're trying to decide whether a house, a move, career change, your retirement date, or some other major life decision really fits into your financial picture, that's exactly what we can look at together in a 90 minute money clarity session. We look at your numbers together, identify the real trade -offs that you'd be making
in your life and help you make a confident decision without second guessing yourself. You can learn more at the link in the show notes. All right. When it comes to running the numbers, before we even touch a calculator, let's make sure we're solving the right problem. I think people love blanket statements about homeownership. Like a house is always a great investment and rent is throwing away money. and just buy as much house as the bank approves you for. But a house is literally the biggest purchase that you ever make, and it's really hard to change your mind once you buy in. It's a tough one to sell and
get rid of if you decide that's not really what you wanted. So these blanket statements just aren't enough for a purchase like that. When people are buying a house, the thing that they often want the most is not a good investment. There are lots of ways that you can invest your money that's going to give you a better average return on investment than... your primary residence. When people buy a home, what they really want is often stability, a specific neighborhood that they get to live in, a school district that they get to send their kids to, maybe a safe place
to raise their family, a place to host holidays and make memories, or freedom to design their own space. And all of those things absolutely have value as well. But lifestyle value and investment returns are not the same thing. So if you're thinking about buying a home, And you're starting to think, am I doing this because everybody around me is doing it? And I'm at an age where I feel like I should be. And I want to prove that I'm financially well off. And by doing that, I need to buy a house. Ask these questions instead. Would I be happy living here for 10 years or
more? And yes, I know the guideline they tell you is often five years or more, but I would argue that it takes at least 10 years for it to be worth owning a home between the expenses, the closing costs, and actually getting that equity back in your home when you look at an amortization chart. And we can go into that another day. But would I be happy here for at least 10 years? Am I buying because I genuinely want a house or because I feel like I should own one? And last, if housing prices remained flat for the next 10 years, would I still want this house?
The next thing I would do is calculate the real cost of the house. And this is the real cost in numbers. So most people compare something like, oh, if I could rent for $2 ,500 or get a mortgage for $25, they're basically equal. So I may as well buy a house and start building equity. The thing is that those two payments are not equal. When you're renting, The rent that you owe is the max amount that you are going to owe every month. If something breaks, you do not have to pay for it when you're renting.
You submit a ticket or you email your landlord and you say, hey, this is broken, and it is their responsibility to fix it and cover the cost of that. When you're buying a house, you have to add up everything to get the total cost of the house. That's going to include your principal mortgage payment, the interest that you owe on the mortgage, property taxes, homeowners insurance, an HOA if there is one, plus maintenance. Most people forget about the maintenance. and a simple rule that i like to use is planning for roughly
one percent of the home's value every year in maintenance you can think of maintenance as what it costs to maintain your home and the utilities in it so that includes like the roof repair that you might need seven years from now from there you can get a pretty good idea of what that housing payment would truly cost you month to month Then when you have the real cost of your housing every month, that includes the principal, interest, taxes, insurance, any HOA, maintenance, and utilities,
you want to see what percentage of your take -home pay that housing is going to cost you. Some general guidelines to see how comfortable you would be with that housing payment. If it's less than 25 % of your take -home pay, that leaves you a lot of flexibility for other things. If it's somewhere between 25 and 35%, that's pretty stable. It would be pretty comfortable to do that and cover all of your other expenses and investments. If it's 35 % or more, that's where
you're going to start to feel really stretched. Like every month, most of your money is going to your housing payment, and it might be really hard to leave room for things like vacations, going out to eat, investing to the amount that you wanted to. And ultimately, that could end up limiting your optionality down the road. That could mean delaying your retirement date or one partner not being able to pull back from work because you both need both of your incomes to make that housing payment and still live comfortably every month. I think the thing that a lot of people miss here is that they get approved for
a mortgage amount, but all the bank really cares about is that you're going to be able to cover that housing cost every month. They don't really care if you're putting other expenses on credit cards and getting into debt. They don't care if you have to take out a personal loan or you've ended up reducing your contributions to your retirement or other investments or not able to reach other goals. They know that the last thing that you are going to fail to pay is going to be your housing. So they're going to prove you up to a bigger loan because... That makes them
more money on the interest that you're paying. So it's really important not to just take what they give you. You have to calculate for yourself with your own goals and your own financial picture what you would feel comfortable with in that house. So the next thing you want to look at is your savings rate. After you buy the house, can you still save and invest the amount you need to reach your goals? A good rule of thumb for saving and investing each month is somewhere around 15 to 20 % of your income. And if you can save more than that, that's going to give
you more flexibility down the road, maybe an early retirement or a sabbatical or changing careers or taking a pay cut. And it's really common that after buying the house, if you find that you're getting squeezed with your expenses going up and your housing costs tighter than you realized, the part that gets squeezed is your savings and investing. They end up dropping their retirement contributions or their emergency fund stops growing or they start dipping into the emergency fund and your future flexibility is totally getting squeezed by the house. And that's where you really have to be honest with
yourself and think, would I rather have a slightly smaller house and still continue building that wealth and flexibility or would I rather have my dream house and potentially feel house poor and squeezed every month and every year? And that's the part that I feel like almost nobody calculates is the flexibility that that house is costing you. Now the time is to ask yourself, if we buy this house, can one of us stop working? Could we survive a layoff? Could we take a lower
paying but more fulfilling job if we want it? Can we still travel the way we love? Can we afford a season of childcare for not just one kid, but multiple kids at the same time? Could we choose private school for our kids someday? How do I want to spend my weekends? Is this house going to make me end up spending time doing fixer uppers and runs to Home Depot when I'd much rather be planning hikes and backpacking and snowboarding on the weekends? Those are the parts of buying a house that I think people often forget to calculate. And to me, that is the real cost of housing.
I am the last one of all of my friends and family to buy a house. We rent and I still love renting. But I think there was a time where people started looking at us like, did you guys do something wrong? Like you've traveled too much and now you can't afford a house. Do you guys need help? Like, you know, buying a house is a really important investment. And it used to drive me crazy because there I had been investing like 30 to 40 % of my income and doing very well in the stock market. But knowing that the reason that I didn't want
a house was because it did not at all align with the lifestyle that I wanted. I wanted flexibility. I wanted to be able to move easily. I wanted to change states. I thought about living in another country sometimes. I was a freelance artist and I had so much opportunity where I got to work in all different cities. And I knew that owning a house was just going to hold me down from that. I also loved spending my weekends hiking and backpacking and being outside. And the last thing that I wanted to do was... deal with things breaking
in my house. I felt like everybody I knew needed a $10 ,000 hot water heater and their roof was leaking. And I was like, I would be so angry if I had to deal with that on the weekend instead of doing this LA peak hike that I really have been wanting to do for a really long time. I literally hated putting gas in my car. I was like, I would be miserable if I had to fix up a house all the time. Just on a whim, something just broke unexpectedly. It would drive me crazy. So there absolutely were seasons where it was
hard to feel like I was going against the grain of literally everybody around me and being looked at as like maybe she's like financially irresponsible. And they don't really know what they're doing and they don't have their priorities straight. Meanwhile, I knew deep down we were crushing it with our finances intentionally. And I didn't need a forced savings by a house because I knew I was investing more than I needed to every single month and living very happily with the flexibility of the lifestyle that I really wanted. Now the
last part when you look at the numbers is you have to remember the phantom housing costs. Those are the costs of housing that nobody really thinks about, but they come up all the time. I know when I first started learning about buying a house, I thought that once you were locked into your mortgage payment, it could not change or go up over time. And while that is true for the mortgage and interest payment it's not true for the taxes and insurance so while people are like oh rent always goes up and you want to lock in
that mortgage payment rent does go up and down over time and it fluctuates with the market and housing costs can also go up over time as the value of your property goes up the insurance and the taxes on your property are also going to go up so that housing payment is going to change over time. And I think that's something that we often don't realize until you're already locked into the payment and you've bought the house. And then all of a sudden you owe more this month than you did last month. And you're like, uh, what the heck? I wasn't expecting that.
Other phantom costs that you might not see in the beginning, but have to pay for over time is remembering the maintenance and repairs on things like a roof. a furnace, a hot water heater, plumbing leaks. Another phantom cost is the closing cost on the transaction when you buy and sell the house. It's often 2 % to 5 % of the purchase price when you buy it, and then you pay costs again after you sell the house down the line. There's also transaction costs like realtor commissions,
transfer taxes, moving expenses, staging the house when you're ready to sell it. And even things like the cost of landscaping and the driveway, the garage, the garage door opener, things that you might not think about paying for or breaking or having to fix, especially if you're coming from being a renter. Like I think to me, sometimes when I think about buying a house, I'm like, oh yeah, then we need like... We need to shovel our walkway by ourselves. Like we don't have to do that right now. It's so nice. And they just take care of the grounds here by our apartment.
That's so nice. I'll never forget a friend of mine being like, do you have any idea what a front door costs? I was like, no, I do not have any idea. But it sounds like it was a lot more than you ever expected. So there's so many parts of a house that I think we often forget about that requires maintenance, upkeep, and then either your time or hiring it out and paying for somebody else's time to take care of it for you. And actually probably the happiest time that I ever had that I was a renter was a couple of years ago when our freezer was leaking all over the kitchen.
It was soaking wet and no matter what we did, it wouldn't stop leaking. So we have a huge puddle in the kitchen and of course I go into labor that day with my first baby. So we're like, okay, well, I guess we're going to leave this puddle here and like hit the hospital. Let's go. So my husband submits a maintenance request. We go to the hospital. Don't even think about our freezer anymore. Obviously a little bit preoccupied. A couple of days later, we come home with our newborn. There was a brand new refrigerator already installed in our kitchen. The old one was gone. We didn't have a bill. We didn't have to deal with a contractor. We didn't have to research
new appliances. We didn't dip into any emergency funds. It costs us nothing. No time spent researching anything. And everything was totally handled by our apartment. I seriously have never been happier to be a renter in my entire life. So if you're thinking about buying a house, I encourage you to run the numbers yourself against your own financial situation. The bank can approve you for a certain amount, but that doesn't necessarily mean that buying the biggest house or the best
house that maxes out what you're able to borrow from the bank is the right move for you. It could be costing you flexibility. It could be costing you peace of mind. It could be costing you retirement. goals, other dreams that you have for yourself or your family or your kids. Buying a house can be a really great investment, but remember on the lifestyle side, what you really want. Are you looking for stability and a neighborhood, maybe a school district, maybe a place that you
can design on your own, and then run the numbers on what your options are and really think about what is this going to cost me, not just in money, but in life options and flexibility. and is this house worth it to me or can i still get that same stability school district and freedom to design my home in something smaller that's still going to leave me more options later remember that the best house purchase isn't necessarily the biggest house that you can qualify for it's the house that still leaves room for investing
and vacations career changes or taking time off raising your kids the way you want, and all the things that make life rich outside of a house. Next week, we're going to tackle the question that everybody gets wrong. They love to think, I bought my house for $400 ,000 and I sold it for $700 ,000, so I made $300 ,000 profit, right? Not so fast. We are going to run the actual numbers and see what your house really earned in ROI and compare it. to the ROI of renting and investing
the difference. So that if you are back and forth between renting and buying, you can make an informed financial choice after running the numbers with both. If you're facing a big financial decision right now, whether it's a house purchase, understanding when you can retire, maybe a career change, a business idea, a big move, or simply wondering if you're on track. I can help you. In my 90 -minute money clarity and decision support session, we'll look at your investments, savings, income, and your goals and translate the numbers into something that's much more useful, what they
actually mean for your life. Together, we'll identify the trade -offs, explore your options, and help you move forward with confidence instead of second -guessing yourself. You can learn more at the link in the show notes. If you've been finding these episodes helpful, I would love if you would leave me a review and share this with a friend so that I can reach more women and help them feel confident in their finances and their future. I hope you have a wonderful rest of your week and I will see you next Tuesday.
Between political uncertainty, rising costs, layoffs, and scary economic headlines, it's hard not to wonder: Should I be doing something differently with my money right now? Especially when you've spent years working...
✨ FREE THIS TIME ONLY: ARE YOU ON TRACK? MASTERCLASS You’ve mastered the hard part - earning and investing. The next step is figuring out how much freedom, time, and LIFE it can actually buy you. Could you work less...
If you’re wondering whether you can work less, change careers, buy the house, spend more, or make a big life move without screwing up your financial future, this episode is for you. What happens when the “smart”...
What happens when the life you want starts asking for something different? A lower-paying job. More time with your kids. A move closer to family. A career change. And suddenly you’re wondering: Can I actually afford to...
If you’ve ever opened your 401(k), seen only a few investments, and thought… Wait. Is this really enough? Investing has a reputation for being complicated, which can make a simple portfolio feel almost too simple....