#209 In this episode, Lisa discusses her thoughts on consequences not working. She covers her general approach when a child doesn’t care about consequences, inconsistency in consequences, parents over-explaining themselves, children refusing to complete the consequence, and how connection impacts discipline. Lastly, Lisa addresses five listener questions, discussing her general approach to a 5-year-old meltdowns over little things, strategies for handling challenging behaviour from a 4-year-old, what to do when a 6-year-old gets angry when they break a rule, how to respond to an almost 4-year-old not completing a consequence fully, and advice for dealing with a 4-year-old justice holder. Thank you for joining us! Courses: Toddler BratBusters Bootcamp (16-35 Months) BratBusters Bootcamp (Ages 3-12) Learn More: BratBusters Behaviour Board (Plus Toddler Basics) No-Cost Mini Course Private Coaching Podcast Questions: Have a question you'd like to submit for a chance to be featured in an upcoming podcast episode? Click Here to Submit 🎙️ Disclaimer: The information provided in this podcast is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as a substitute for professional advice. Lisa Bunnage is a Parenting Coach, mom and grandmother. Lisa is not a licensed psychologist or counsellor. Her services do not replace the care of psychologists or other healthcare professionals. For a full disclaimer, please visit bratbusters.com/disclaimer
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00When you feel good, you do good.
SPEAKER_01When you feel bad, you do bad.
SPEAKER_00I want to be a calm leader and enjoy my child, but I can't seem to break out of this cycle. Maybe you're overexplaining.
SPEAKER_01Maybe you're focusing too much on the negative.
SPEAKER_00When our six-year-old does something wrong or breaks a rule, he immediately flips the script and gets very angry at us, sometimes before we can even say a word.
SPEAKER_01Parents often believe that children act out because they don't understand right from wrong. They don't understand why they should be good. It's not a lack of understanding, it's a lack of correction and impulse control. Welcome to the Bratbusters Parenting Podcast. My name's Lisa Bunnage. I'm a parenting coach. I'm a mom. I'm also a grandmother.
SPEAKER_00And I'm Amy Bunnage, Lisa's daughter, and I handle the marketing and planning here at Bratbusters. While I don't have kids, each episode we'll dive into parenting topics and Lisa will answer your questions. Let's get started. Hello, sugar pie. What is today's parenting topic? Today's topic is consequences just don't work for my child. Yeah, they do. Okay.
SPEAKER_01Um, we're all done. Um, anyway, okay, I I'm gonna let you lead the way because you probably have some points. I've learned, I've learned the hard way that she's already got this figured out.
SPEAKER_00I think you hear from a lot of parents, and oftentimes it goes something like, you know, I just tried the behavior board, my child just doesn't care about consequences. I tell them they're gonna lose screen time or a favorite toy, and they just shrug and they go, okay, and they walk and they play with something else. What do you feel could be going on here?
SPEAKER_01There's two reasons for that. One is that you're not consistent or you don't have the right consequences, or the other one is you're not connected enough. If you're not connected, that's gonna happen each and every time. So your connection with them in their world is number one. None of this is gonna work if you're not connected with them, if you're not playing with them. Their love language is fun, laughter, play, joy, uh, positivity. Okay, if you're not providing that, none of the negative stuff's gonna work. And the discipline is the negative stuff. You always wanna make it like, you know, I don't want to set a percentage here. When you get good at it, the percentage will be like almost none negative.
SPEAKER_01But when you're learning, it, you know, it might be higher, but certainly it shouldn't be 50-50. It should be uh much more balanced towards the positivity.
SPEAKER_00When you talk about the inconsistency, what does that look like?
SPEAKER_01It means that parents um don't follow through correctly, or they're um, oh, there's lots of different things, ways of being inconsistent. One is that they just they help they have a good day, then they have a bad day. And they say, you know, yesterday I was doing really well, I was following through with consequences, but today I had a headache and I didn't. Kids don't really understand your headaches, like they don't understand the inconsistencies. It doesn't mean that you're not going to be inconsistent sometimes, but that's why it doesn't work, is what I'm telling you. I'm not saying you need to be 100% perfect all the time, but that is one of the main reasons is you're not consistent. So they figure, oh, well, what do you know?
SPEAKER_01They just lose respect for you, okay? Or if they never had it, they just haven't got, they're not gaining it for you. So that's it. Usually you just have a really good run and then you'll sort of slack off a little bit because you think, oh, phew, okay, now I don't have to be as consistent. And then of course you start to slack off because you get tired or maybe it's stressful, whatever. That's why.
SPEAKER_00How about over-explaining consequences?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's all the talk about it, too, is like, well, you know, and the threatening, threatening doesn't work. You know, if you do that, you know you're gonna get a consequence. That's a threat. It's ridiculous. Makes you look weak. It makes you look like you're afraid of them. And it's kind of nasty. Just say, uh, you let them do whatever they're gonna do, unless it's dangerous. Let them do whatever they're gonna do, and then say, okay, uh, let's go to the board. And then you go to the board and you say, Okay, you broke this rule, here's your consequence, and then follow through with it. You see my tone, that little bit of a lilt in. I'm almost cheery all the time, even when I'm disciplining. So yeah, don't look like you're angry ever. If you show anger, disappointment, or frustration, that again can make it not work because they're gonna, it gets their backup.
SPEAKER_01And they think, yeah, you pee, you think I'm awful because you're showing anger, disappointment, and frustration. I'm gonna prove you right. That's what happens. So that's another small reason. I mean, there's lots of different reasons, but the two main are that you're inconsistent or you haven't balanced out the good times.
SPEAKER_00I think let's get into consequences. Now, if you want to learn more about my mom's approach, you can get access to the free Bratbusters behavior board mini course and then also the toddler basics mini course at Bratbusters.com when you join the newsletter. That'll kind of break down where my mom is going with all this. But let's just say you have a behavior board set up and your child refuses the first consequence, which is usually a chore, then the 24 media blackout is imposed. Do you still make them do that chore?
SPEAKER_01No. Uh, because the first one is uh canceled out now because they didn't do it. They get one or the other, so they don't get both. So let's say you say, okay, your consequence is you have to empty out the dishwasher and they won't do it. Just say, and you keep the timer going though. No matter what they say in that 15 minutes that you've given them to do it, you keep the timer going. If they say no, I'm not gonna do it, just ignore them. You're just a timekeeper. Soon as that bell goes and the 15 minutes is up, now you go over to the board and you impose the second consequence. That's when they often say, Well, I don't care. Fine, take it away for a whole week. They might challenge you like that.
SPEAKER_01That gets under a lot of parents' skin. I would just say, no, just 24 hours. And then in that 24 hours, every time they act out, then your hands are tied. You've already gone to the extreme consequence, you can't keep adding to it. So if they continue to break that exact same rule within that 24-hour media blackout, just say, Well, you might say this once or twice. Well, that's why you've got 24-hour media blackout. Like you don't give it, you don't do it again, you don't keep doing it. Um, another reason it fails too is that parents tend to hand out um consequences all day long. Okay, so they've got maybe they maybe they will do the chore.
SPEAKER_01So they might do it 20 times. On the third time, I would say, it might be the third time around them. I might say, I'll tell you what, that's the third time you've done this. We'll discuss it after dinner. Okay, so and make sure it's after dinner so you can group up the whole day. Don't do it during dinner, don't do it at bedtime. So after dinner, you say, Look, we kind of had a rough day. You know, you got a couple of consequences, then you kept doing, you kept hitting your little brother, whatever. So we're gonna go straight to three, uh, to 24 hour media blackout, and that starts now. And then just make it happen. Don't get into the discussions around it. Makes you look weak. There is no reason to have a discussion around it.
SPEAKER_01None. If you've been clear, they understand that. They understand that the behavior board, it's already been explained to them. They already understand it. It's all the but I forgot, but I did this. Say, oh well, you'll know next time, won't you? Do not get into the discussions. That's just them arguing.
SPEAKER_00I just envisioned the 24 media hour of media blackout. Someone's got it until their kid's 35.
SPEAKER_01The thing is that you're investing in tomorrow. That 24 hours is going to be ugly, okay? But you're investing in tomorrow. Uh, one of my favorite stories, I've told it a million times, but I I repeat all these same stories because they're the best ones. They're the gold ones. It's the one where that little boy was about seven or eight, and the mom said, I got permission to I got permission to tell this. Anyway, uh, it was a coaching client, and he was about seven or eight years old, and he'd had he'd lost his, I think it was a Switch or PlayStation, one of his gaming consoles. He loved that thing. He lost it for 24 hours. Now she'd already been working with me for two or three weeks, so the kid was starting to get this, right?
SPEAKER_01He started starting to understand. It's all up to him. If he break, if he never breaks the rule, he never loses his his PlayStation, right? But he was starting to put it together. So, anyway, he didn't know that she could see hear him. And he sits down in front of it after the 24 hours and he's holding the beloved uh controller in his hand and he says to himself, Phew, I won't be doing that again. I thought that was the cutest thing. He didn't, he wasn't mad at his mom. He got that it was his his issue. He understood that it was his responsibility. It was all up to him, right? That that was what was so good about that.
SPEAKER_00I think it's so cute because it almost sounds like an adult would say that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, phew, I won't be doing that again. Yeah, she thought it was adorable. She it was the first thing she told me when I during our next session. It was so cute. And that's why I said, and I often I forget to ask permission for really great stories like that. That time I asked right away, can I tell this? No names. Can I tell? She goes, Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00So and then I think just before we get into the parenting questions on consequences, I want you to go into why connection makes consequences work from your perspective.
SPEAKER_01Okay, because it's based on such a simple theory I have, and and it's the theory for life, basically. When you feel good, you do good. When you feel bad, you do bad. When they feel good, they do good. When they feel bad, they they do bad. Okay, they're like us, we're all like that. If you feel like a million bucks about yourself and about life, you tend to everything around you is positive, everything smells like roses. It's not perfect all the time, but that's the basic idea. But when you feel bad about yourself, maybe someone's put you down or someone's been really mean to you or rotten to you, nothing's going your way, you've got no laughter, no joy in your life.
SPEAKER_01You kind of want to share that with other people, don't you? You kind of want to put that on other people too. Like you kind of want to bring the room down if you feel like crap. So it's that's based on that. When you feel good, you do good. When you feel bad, you do bad. My goal with kids is never to make them feel bad. It's okay that they're mad and they could be sad, maybe, about you know, getting a consequence. That's okay. All they have to do is not break a rule. That's up to them. It's okay if they feel mad at you or sad that they have this consequence, that's okay. But you never want them to feel bad about themselves. I always want kids to feel good about themselves.
SPEAKER_01I'm always focused on increasing their self-esteem and keeping it up there. That's what the connection does, makes them feel good.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Was that explanatory? I felt like that explained it. Good. Do you have anything else before we get into the questions? Nope, nothing. Okay, the first one here is Hannah from the United States. I have a three-month-old, three-year-old, and 5.5-year-old. All girls. The oldest has always had these huge meltdowns over little things. Swift consequences don't seem to make a difference. It's like a nuclear reaction, just instant huge meltdown. I know I can't fix my kid, and in your 200th episode, you talked about enjoying your child. How do you reset your relationship? I feel like we've gotten into a cycle of correction and reaction.
SPEAKER_00Some tantrums, some meltdowns, but also I have other responsibilities. So when she takes forever to listen, then she has used up our playtime. I want to be a calm leader and enjoy my child, but I can't seem to break out of this cycle.
SPEAKER_01Two things I couldn't write fast enough. Were the old was the oldest one five? What what do you mean by she takes forever to listen? Did I miss something there? I don't was that explained more? She takes forever to listen. Maybe you're overexplaining. Maybe you're focusing too much on the negative. Okay. And also if you want her to do something, like if you want her to have a chore, um, write it down on a board and put down uh make your bed before 10 every morning so you don't have to explain it. Okay. Sounds like you're overexplaining, you're focused too much on the negative. Um, yeah, I I'm guessing that that was the first thing that came to mind is that you're focused, you're explaining yourself too much.
SPEAKER_01Um, and and it's okay to explain positivity, but the negativity, the only reason parents think they have to explain it is they truly believe this. And I took me a long time to figure out why. I still don't know why. Parents often believe that children act out because they don't understand right from wrong. They don't understand why they should be good. That has nothing to do with anything. It's it's not a lack of understanding, it's a lack of correction and impulse control. It's like everything. We all understand we should never speed. Why would we do it? If it's understanding is the problem, why would we ever speed?
SPEAKER_01Ever. Right? Now, it's not the understanding that makes us do right from wrong necessarily, it's the consequences. So, and I don't mean the big stuff, but you know, let's say you were never penalized for not paying your personal taxes on time. Never penalized for it, no penalty. But they say to you, you understand why you should pay on time. Would that make you pay on time every single time? No penalty if you don't. Think about it. And yet you expect that from kids. You expect them if they understand what they should do and what they shouldn't do, then they'll always do the right thing and they'll never do the wrong thing.
SPEAKER_01It's all this over-explaining. I know it's trendy. I I know people teach it out there from what I've heard, but it's kind of crap. No, it's not kind of crap. It's absolute crap. They know right from wrong, okay? Because you've already said don't hit. That's it. That's all they need to know. Don't hit. They intuitively understand hitting probably isn't a nice thing to do past the age of two, two and a half, right? So yeah, they already understand it.
SPEAKER_00Do you find that that often impacts the meltdowns?
SPEAKER_01Oh, 100%. The more you focus on the negativity, the more likely they are to have meltdowns. Um, because it's negative. It it's feeding, you know, you get more of what you put out there. You're where you put your energy and your focus is where it grows. So if you put it into positivity, you're, you should get more of that. If you're putting so much focus on teaching her right from wrong and discussing it and, you know, like all these discussions around it, and then you look stern and you look upset, disappointed, or frustrated at her, which I'm assuming is part of it too, it's gonna make her worse.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Just say, well, you did that. Here's your consequence, and then you want to go read a book. It's all over.
SPEAKER_00It's all over. Do you find, I mean, three children, five and under, like that's a lot to deal with as well. Like, how do you navigate that when you're trying to do consequences, but then you have a little one?
SPEAKER_01Like, yeah, but there's some age there between, like, there's two years between the first two, maybe a year and a half or two years. So you're you're kind of done with that now, right? So, but you then you've got a three-month-old. That's a three-year split because the three-year-old, I think you said was three and a half. So you've got a three-year split between. So that's enough of a split that it shouldn't be that real crazy physical time now, you know. And also, they usually stop tantrums by three to three and a half because if they don't work, if they continue to work, do they still get attention? Um, yeah, are you not connecting enough or do they still get attention for it?
SPEAKER_01Like, do they if they don't get enough positive attention, they'll go for the negative attention. And also your reaction is huge. You know, if you look frustrated, angry, it's working. She's getting under your skin and she knows it, and it must break you down. I it's a learned behavior past a certain age, past about three and a half. Tantrums, they only do what works at that age. So it means it must work. There must be a payoff for it. There has to be. Even if it's just confirming her own self-esteem that I'm difficult, she might have that that label for herself.
SPEAKER_01Maybe she's overheard. She's the difficult one. So she's just sort of validating that too. That could be part, that's deeper stuff, that's more coaching stuff. But yeah, that could be part of it too. They what they just intuitively validate um their identity, um, good or bad.
SPEAKER_00I think also with this question, because it says like, how do I reset the relationship? I could imagine this feels like you're doing like a big 180. And then it's like you're trying to deal with the behavior, but then you're also trying to deal with the connection. Like, how do you go about focusing on that connection when maybe you as a parent have some frustration on your end and you're feeling just like.
SPEAKER_01Well, I already sort of I already sort of explained that because I said, okay, so here's your you broke a rule, here's your consequence now. Do you want to go read a book? See how quick I ricochet? I get in there fast before they can get cemented in that mode. Um, yeah, so here's your consequence. And she's, and while that's 15 minutes is going, let's say she did the right thing. She emptied the dishwasher, whatever it is, that whatever the chore is, and then say, oh, okay, all done. Let's go read a book. Let's go. You want to connect after this stuff, especially if you've got a kid who is more squirmy like this emotionally. So yeah, you want to connect pretty quick after a scene.
SPEAKER_01Soon as she's done with a scene, oh, y'all done? Okay, let's go. You want to go to the park? Do you want to help me do the dishes? Doesn't even have to be like you're going out and doing something fun. It can just be connecting. Hey, do you want to come help me do the dishes? Do you want to come help me fold the laundry? In other words, do you want to connect with me? I still love you. You're not a bad kid. You want to come come help me with something? See my tone though. It's the tone. It's really important. And then you were going on a little bit, you and I interrupted you, and you were starting to say, well, the mom does get frustrated. Yeah, I know that. And I can't help you with that. Like I literally can't help you with your own emotional reaction.
SPEAKER_01That is your challenge, though. I can tell you what how you should look like you feel, which is like doesn't bother you a bit, but that is your challenge with all this. I can't help you control your emotions. That is the challenge. You know, um, it's like anything. You learn something, and then you, you know, you've still got to do the work. And um, yeah, I really can't help you with that. The only thing I can say that might help is I've dealt with hundreds of people in coaching who have turned the corner and they go, I get it now. Fake it till you make it, and then life gets easier.
SPEAKER_00Do you find, oh gosh, I'm gonna try and do an analogy month.
SPEAKER_01So we're terrible at analogies, terrible.
SPEAKER_00Is it almost as if you're like, I get so frustrated when I hit the ball in the net at tennis? And it's like you are focusing on the actions to help you not to get the ball over the net so that you don't have to get frustrated anymore. Is that kind of where you're going?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's it's a whole bunch of things that I I'm I kind of hesitant to have an analogy here because we're so bad at it. But it's like anything, it's the actions, not the emotions behind it that you want to focus on. It's like they say about um a self-discipline or motivation, it starts with actions, not with emotions. Okay. So it's like that. The problem with this is when you're working and you're procrastinating on something, you know that the first step is just to take small actions, small wins, right? Start small. But the problem is that you can show emotions even though you're working.
SPEAKER_01But when you're parenting, you want to you want to control your emotions, at least on the outside. I'm not telling you not to be stressed. I'm telling you try not to show it. You know, you might want to take an acting class or something. I do this a lot in coaching. We do role-playing, and I'll say, now show me how you're gonna say it. And they always roll their eyes. They just always show disgust, disappointment, anger, frustration. They just do. And I say, okay, you you showed it, you know, let's work on it again. So I say to practice in a mirror if you have to.
SPEAKER_00Okay, the next one is things have been going really well at home for us. So good leadership, happy, calm, sweet children. But there's a combination of three things. So hot summer nights, summer holidays being almost over, and an upcoming birthday. Our son is now so tired and tense that he is expressing it through a lot of impulsive, challenging behavior. For example, spitting on the floor, hitting the younger sister, and getting extremely angry when we say no. Normally we work on these, but at the moment, the behavior doesn't seem to be improving at all. He's very angry, not forgiving, and the difficult behavior just seems to continue.
SPEAKER_00I see a consequence as a kind of fine where as a naughty chair, something we don't use, feels like more of an escalation towards prison, so to speak. But if the fines are not having an effect anymore, would you move on to the prison like the naughty chair? Or would you approach this differently? Where's the age? I don't think there was an age there. Oh, sorry. Uh um four years old, almost turning five.
SPEAKER_01He's four. Okay, I'll I'll just put down four. Okay, the naughty chair and all that. That uh I'm not gonna use the analogy with prison and that because it's just not not not something I'm comfortable talking about. Not to say it's wrong, but it's just not my way. Um, okay, so the naughty chair, um, I was just gonna say it's like putting them in prison. We both knew that was gonna happen, didn't we? It was funny because because I could see her body language, she knew I was gonna mess up somehow. Were the shoulders going up? Oh, it was so funny. Anyway, okay. So now you see here's what doesn't make any sense to me.
SPEAKER_01The heat and a birthday and summer holidays has nothing to do with their behavior. Uh, they could be a little bit more excitable or a little bit more uncomfortable and not sleeping as well, but their behavior usually isn't affected by any of those things. And then you said all of a sudden he was perfect all summer, and now he's spitting on the floor hitting sister. You know what I'm thinking? This is my gut reaction, is he was being spoiled and everything was going his own way, and now it's not. You've pulled in a little bit because you've got a you got a birthday coming up, maybe you're busy planning it.
SPEAKER_01Um, maybe on the summer holidays are coming to an end, you're probably busier. Things aren't going his way as much. That's what I'm assuming you were a pleaser and um not maybe follow, not maybe um having challenges for him. Does he have chores? He should have chores. At three years old, they should have chores. Uh make your bed four and a half. Number one. He's I know that's why I said at three, they should have chores. So he's old enough for chores. And my kids had three chores uh every day. They had to make their bed, put their laundry away, and put their dirty clothes in the hamper. That was it. That was just non-negotiable, and they never questioned it, they just did it.
SPEAKER_01But they I'm very organized, I'm a minimalist, so uh I did laundry every day, and they had like the all, and I rolled up all the socks already and everything, and then they went in a certain spot. I made it very easy for them. And um, and also that it was like two minutes and that was all done. And making their bed, just pull out the duvet, it was no big deal, right? And I'd go back and make it nicer. But yeah, that responsibilities uh lead to pride. Where's his pride? All of a sudden things aren't going his way, and he's spitting, he's hitting his sister. Yeah, I'm just I'm guessing that's what it is.
SPEAKER_01You've been catering to him over the summer, and now that's starting to come to an end, and he doesn't like it. So he needs and the way you combat that is have some responsibility and pride for this kid. Where are his chores? Where's his responsibility? Have you had him help you get ready for school? Like, has he been helping you shop and sort for all the school supplies and helping his little sister? Um, you said he's been hitting his sister. I'm assuming she's younger. Um, so yeah, maybe he and set him up as the hero for her. Can you help her? She's gonna, we're gonna get her some school supplies too.
SPEAKER_01He needs more pride. He needs more chores, he needs more uh responsibility. And yeah, I think you're catering to him. That's my gut reaction. I could be wrong. I don't with the information you've given me, that would be my assessment.
SPEAKER_00Okay, the next one's Jack from the United States. When our six-year-old does something wrong or breaks a rule, he immediately flips the script and gets very angry at us, sometimes before we can even say a word. Shame seems to be a big trigger for him. It feels like he uses this intense preemptive anger to control the situation and deflect any consequences. How should my husband and I handle this reaction going forward without getting sucked into a power struggle or escalating his anger?
SPEAKER_01Well, this one's easy. Um, you make sure you're on the board too. And when you act out, or not act out, when you yell or whatever you're doing wrong, that's on the board, your rule, and then just say, Oh, I messed up. Let's go to the board. Like there's no shame in making mistakes. Okay, so that's an easy one. And then just when he acts out or does something, just say, okay, let's go to the board. See, there's no shaming, blaming, or um you never show anger, disappointment, or frustration. Because you said he goes into the shame thing right away. That's because you're shaming him. Yeah. So, and also, yeah, you've got to be accountable and show them that we all mess up.
SPEAKER_01Everybody does. You do, I do, everybody does. Adults, kids, everybody messes up. There's no shame in making mistakes, it's just shame in not being accountable for them. So, but yeah, but don't put that on him. You put that on yourself, though. Okay. But he's just a kid. You want to teach him this and you lead by example.
SPEAKER_00Speak for yourself. I never mess up.
SPEAKER_01We all do. We all do. It's funny. Um, I'm, I mean, I've made a sort of a lifetime, I'm very self-deprecating the humor. This brings up something really embarrassing. I just want to say this. So such an offshoot of this podcast. Years ago, I was speaking to about 600 people. I used to do public speaking back in the day. And um, and I I always say, someone commented on how I always make fun of myself. And they said, Oh, and I said, Yeah, I've always been into self deprecating humor, but I didn't use the word deprecating. I'll let you fill that in.
SPEAKER_01Self-pooping humor. So yeah, and and I couldn't figure out why they all just froze and then they all just cracked up. I had no idea. And the the the host had to come over and say you said this. Well, I thought that was hilarious. But anyway, yeah, I'm really into self-deprecating humor. And and that makes it okay for other people to make mistakes too. That's why it's so important. Like with my kids, I was always messing up. It was just a joke. It was no big deal, right? But just little things like I forgot something or I dropped something. Uh, you know, you want to make fun of yourself so that it's okay to make mistakes.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it sounds like there's a lot of uh yeah, a lot of judgment there. That's why he feels shame and he gets his back up and he gets mad.
SPEAKER_00Okay, the next one is Michelle from Canada. My son's almost four, and when he gets a consequence to clean something, I'm explicit in detail of what the task is he needs to do. So for example, your consequence is to clean this square of the wall outside siding so I can visibly see that he does it. I point to it, I wipe a square where you can see the clear outline. He'll do one swipe, say all done, and joyfully wipe down another thing nearby. All the while I have to bite my tongue not to say anything, then I'll say five minutes left. Turns out most times it moves down to the negative deprivation because he doesn't clean the actual spot that I asked.
SPEAKER_00I'm baffled that he does this. Is he testing me? Is taking away a toy not affecting him as we don't do enough screen time to utilize it. Any thoughts about this? Part of me wonders if we need to start doing more screen time just so I can take it away. Ha ha.
SPEAKER_01Um, yeah, no, that's a good one. My gut reaction, I have something else in mind, but I would have to ask questions, but I don't think it's the other thing. That's more rare. Um, but I'm just guessing he's just playing you like a fiddle. Okay. So if he says, there I'm all done, you do you already sound like you're doing the right thing, but maybe you look annoyed. Um, but if he does say, I'm all done, I wouldn't say anything. I'm just keep looking at the timer, but I'm doing something sort of like washing the dishes at the same time. So, but I'm looking, my focus is the timer and also watching what he's supposed to be doing. So if he says all done, I might look over, just glance, not at him, but at the the wherever he's supposed to clean.
SPEAKER_01I just look over casually and then I might say, Oh, five more minutes or nothing. Okay, so it sounds like you're doing the right thing. And then the timer goes off. Say, now let me see. Okay, that wasn't done within the 15 minutes. Okay, let's go to the board. See my tone? See how I stay on that high road. I'm just focused on the timer and the job, was it done within 15 minutes or not? You're you obviously make it very clear. So that's not the problem. The problem is I think he's playing you. That's my gut reaction. Like I said, anything could be other things, but with the basic information I get, I just go with the basic answer too.
SPEAKER_00Okay, we have one final question. Alyssa from the United States. Hi, Lisa, you've talked about how you were a major justice holder as a kid, and I believe my daughter, who's four, is too. We've been following your advice for about six months, and things are going great, except for playing with her sister, who's two years old. They antagonize each other and they usually end up in a hitting or screening match. The four-year-old asks why the little sister doesn't get a consequence after hitting like she does. We've tried to explain that she's not old enough yet to understand, but we do correct the little one with saying no and removing her from the fun. I'm at a loss on what to do, and I'm tired of playing referee in these moments.
SPEAKER_00I make sure the four-year-old has her own space and that she needs it in her own room, and we started the library system with toys except the special ones that stay in their own rooms. Should we give a consequence to the two-year-old so it seems fair, or is this just a phase?
SPEAKER_01Okay, she's not a justice holder, she's a fairdom holder. Is it fair to me? She's not obviously fair to others. So it's it's more of a me-me-me thing. Justice holder, like I used to organize lineups for the slide, but I'd never get a turn on it. Okay. I just wanted justice for all. Now, if she's hitting her little sister, um, that's not justice for all. That's justice for me, fairness for me. Yeah. Um, so yeah. Um, now, use my uh fighting. I have all sorts of videos on fighting, and it's like sibling rivalry stuff.
SPEAKER_01But base the basis for this is if they're fighting, you've got to be a detective. You've got to figure out who started it. Often or almost always, parents go after the hitter. They usually don't hit for no reason. Some of them do, but that's another issue. But let's say usually, almost, almost always, there's a reason why they hit. You want to figure out. Now, did a two-year-old come over and knock down her tower? If she was a justice fighter, if a two-year-old came over and did that, she would go to you and you would figure it out if you're a leader. Okay, she would go to you and say, Look, she knocked down my tower. I don't want to hit her.
SPEAKER_01She's four years old, she can handle this. The reason why she lashes out is she doesn't feel that you are gonna take charge, too. So, yeah, that so you want her to trust you to take charge. Figure out what's going on. Is there a reason for the hitting? If not, then you say, I'll tell you what, you hit. But then if she's saying, but it's not fair, it's not fair, sounds like it isn't fair. I'm guessing. Otherwise, she wouldn't say that as much. But yeah, sounds like you got to get to the bottom of it. What did the two-year-old do? And then you say to the four-year-old, look, if you want to play uninterrupted, you have a choice.
SPEAKER_01You can go into your room or into our room, take the toy that you want to play with. It can't be the one that everyone wants to play with, okay? You have to figure that out. But say, look, you can go in your, if you don't want to be interrupted, you can take a toy and we'll choose which one it is, and you can go in our room or in your room if they share a room. And so you can play uninterrupted. If you come out here, you know she's gonna disrupt things, but you come to me and tell me, and I'll fix it. So then you can remove the two-year-old and have her do something else in another room with you, potentially. But yeah, you got to get to the bottom of it. They don't usually hit for no reason. And also a justice fighter.
SPEAKER_01There's two reasons. I guess she sort of could still be a justice fighter, but she just doesn't trust you to take care of it. I would have got frustrated too, if I had no one to take care of stuff, but I still wasn't likely to lash out. So um, yeah, I would just sort of back off um physically. But I didn't have a little sister, so maybe I would have hit. Who knows? I don't I don't think so. Um, but yeah, there it's just you got to figure out who's starting it though. Parents do this all the time. They go after the hitter, not the starter. And the starter's often like, ooh, got away with that one. So yeah, they often get and they know what they're doing from the age of two, they can catch on.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Well, that was it for the questions.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so uh consequences don't work for my child. I've never met a kid that I couldn't get respect with. The consequences didn't work. Never. And I've worked with troubled teens, young kids, toddlers. Um, I've worked with them all, and I babysat them all when I was a teenager. I've never not been able to hand out a consequence and have it some have some effect. I'm just pretty good at figuring out what's going to work for each kid. So that's what you've got to do. And you already know your kids. You've got to figure out what would work with them. So, and keep it simple. It's not about what the consequence is, it's about how you how you how you set that out, how you set up the behavior board with toddlers, how you follow through.
SPEAKER_01Your body language, tone of voice, and facial expressions are everything. When I'm disciplining, I get real quiet and I talk slow and there's no emotions. I just like, oh, tell you what, here's what we're gonna do. That's how I talk when I'm disciplining. Tell you what, here's what we're gonna do. See my tone? It's it's almost it calms them down almost. Right? But also, if I mess up, I'm in trouble too. I'd say, oops, I messed up, didn't I? What do you want me to do? You see, it's it's mutual. So it's very calming.
SPEAKER_01And and that's what parents get wrong all the time. And I don't blame you. I know it's hard, but I was doing this when I was a kid. I was babysitting kids, and I never, you know, there's lots of kids that were really difficult. So I never showed any anger. And I was 11 when I started babysitting, I'd say, oh, that was that was something else. What do you think we should do? I know. So I'd come up with a consequence, and they they like that tone. You can see it like, oh, what's this is weird. I wasn't yelled at, right? It's a different way of approaching this, and it it's a positive way of approaching it. And and they're drawn in almost by your con by your calm control.
SPEAKER_01They're almost pulled into it, and it also doesn't get their backup. They don't tend to resent you for it. They tend to just learn a lesson and go, ooh, yeah, I did make a mistake. But because I'm so accountable too, it's a two-way street. And that makes them the justice fighter, like you said. My parents were very were my mom was a leader for sure. I felt like I had a say on how my life was going. And I think that's a big part of it too. I think that's a great place to end. Okay, so we'll be back again soon talking about another parenting topic. Happy parenting.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for tuning in. If you're ready to dive deeper, check out Bratbusters.com to learn more about the behavior board, parenting courses, and private 101 coaching with Lisa. If you've enjoyed the show so far, we'd love it if you could take a moment to follow, rate, and review us on your favorite podcast platform. Your feedback helps us reach more parents just like you. The information provided in this podcast is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as a substitute for professional advice. Lisa is a parenting coach, mom, and grandmother. She is not a licensed psychologist or counselor.
SPEAKER_00Her services do not replace the care of psychologists or other healthcare professionals. For a full disclaimer, please visit Bratbusters.com forward slash disclaimer.
#227 In this episode, Lisa shares her thoughts on holding boundaries and parenting in public. She covers the pressures of parenting when an audience is watching, navigating situations when a child doesn't want to leave...
#226 In this episode, Lisa shares her thoughts on listening like a calm leader. She covers the parental urge to want to fix everything, using mindful body language when listening to your children, discussing bad...
#225 In this episode, Lisa shares her thoughts on defiance from children. She covers the effects of showing anger or frustration, managing inconsistent boundaries, why lecturing and over-explaining can backfire, a...
#224 In this episode, Lisa shares her thoughts on bedtime battles. She covers why parents often lose their cool at night and what bedtime battles look like, navigating feelings of guilt when holding firm boundaries,...
#223 In this episode, Lisa shares her thoughts on children not listening. She covers why this connects back to parenting approach, using the BratBusters Behaviour Board, the habit of repeating yourself, practical...