From the seed of a tropical tree to creamy candies, it takes a lot of science to turn cacao into chocolate. Learn how cacao is farmed, fermented, and processed into cocoa products -- plus its history as a drink for 3,000 years -- in today's episode of BrainStuff, based on this article: https://science.howstuffworks.com/innovation/edible-innovations/chocolate.htm
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Welcome to BrainStuff, a production of iHeart Podcasts. Hey BrainStuff, Lauren Vogelbaum here. If you love chocolate, you're far from alone. The cocoa and chocolate industry boasts a stunning worldwide value of more than $ 178 billion a year, driven by farmers' production of some 4.7 million metric tons of beans. That's not shabby for a product that was local to a narrow band of the Americas for thousands of years and
Speaker 1really only existed in drink form until the late 1600s. As of 2026, Americans eat some 8.4 pounds of chocolate a year per capita. That's nearly four kilos. But they aren't the winners by far when it comes to chocolate consumption. That honor goes to the Germans at almost 18 pounds or eight kilos a year. So how did we get here? Today, let's talk about the history and science of chocolate. Nobody knows when the first person looked at the cacao tree
Speaker 1and decided to eat its seeds. But anthropologists have found evidence of theobromine, a chemical indicator of cacao, in ceramics in what's now Ecuador, in the northern part of the Amazon River Valley, dating back some 5,300 years. The delicate cacao tree grows no taller than 25 feet or 8 meters and will only grow in tropical rainforest-type conditions where it can get lots of warmth, rain, and shade. Unlike lots of more temperate trees that dangle fruit from their branches among their leaves, the cacao tree blossoms with clusters
Speaker 1of white to yellow to pink flowers directly on its trunks. Researchers think that prior to human cultivation, this might have plant spread by keeping the fruit in reach of large mammals that could have eaten it and dispersed its seeds. Cacao fruits, often called pods, are largish and oblong, sort of like a slightly deflated rib football. That's the American football, not a soccer football. They can be green or yellow or orange or red as they grow, and they'll shift to deeper colors as they ripen. Unlike many fruits, they
Speaker 1can grow year-round, and a single tree will usually have a bunch of pods at different stages of growth. Inside the pod, there's a sort of gooey white pulp surrounding some 20 to 50 seeds, the cocoa beans. The pulp is edible, and what I've had of it tasted really sweet and tropical. This was probably the first cacao product that people ate, either fresh or perhaps slightly fermented into a slightly alcoholic drink. But those seeds are what caught the world's attention. Fresh from the pod, the seeds are
Speaker 1light in color and don't have a lot of flavor. To get the chocolate we know today, they have to be fermented. Yes, chocolate is a fermented product. That fermentation generally happens right on the farms where cacao is grown. When the pods are ripe, the spotting of which is a job for experienced farmers, they're cut from the tree by the stem. Farmers then split open the hard pods and remove the beans plus some or all of the pulp. The workers lay out the pulpy beans in heaps or boxes and cover them to help keep them warm and moist.
Speaker 1The pulp will liquefy, and the beans soak in that broth for five to seven days, with workers stirring and draining them occasionally. During the first day, the seeds actually germinate and begin growing, and those wee baby plants' enzymes will convert all of the pulp's sucrose to glucose and fructose. With that high-energy food available, a bunch of friendly bacteria, yeasts, and other fungi go to town. Those microorganisms get in there thanks to contact with the workers' hands and all of the equipment that's used and reused. The microbes also
Speaker 1produce heat, which can reach 122 Fahrenheit or 50 Celsius, and is enough to kill the plant embryo and basically any unwanted microorganisms. Among the wanted microorganisms are Saccharomyces cerevisiae, which is the same species that brewers and bakers use for beer and bread. and various species of Lactobacillus, aka lactic acid bacteria. The yeasts help break down the pectin covering the seeds, which lets two bitter compounds leak out and allows the alcohol created by the yeasts to seep in,
Speaker 1along with all kinds of flavor compounds that are also excreted by the microbes. You want to stop the process before microbes begin growing in or on the beans instead of just the pulp. because those bacteria and fungi can break down some of the fats in the beans and cause weird, off flavors. So, next, you dry the beans out. This process, along with the subsequent roasting to kill off any remaining microbes and bring out a lot of chocolate's flavor and aroma compounds, is more or less what humans have been doing to process rock cow beans into something
Speaker 1we'd want to consume since about 1900 BCE. By then, pre-Omec peoples living in what's now Mexico were taking those roasted beans, grinding them, and mixing the resulting paste with water, and sometimes ground corn, to make bitter and invigorating beverages. Over 3,000 years later, when Europeans showed up in the area, the Nahua word for this drink was jocoa, thought to mean bitter water. The peoples of the Triple Alliance, sometimes called the Aztec Empire, still added ground corn, along with
Speaker 1spices like chili, vanilla, other herbs, and maybe a bit of honey for flavoring. By that time, this drink was out of reach for everyone except the upper classes and nobles, and associated with important events and ceremonies. The beans were one of the forms of currency of the day. They were also sometimes used in medicines. Spanish colonizers of the 1500s brought the drink back with them to Europe, where the aristocracy mixed it with another expensive import, sugar. By the early 1600s, drinking chocolate was fashionable among, again, the
Speaker 1wealthy and nobility all across the continent, which means that before coffee or even tea, chocolate was the original stimulant drink in Europe. More European countries planted cacao trees in their own territories around the equator. These plantations and those that provided sugar ran off of enslaved labor, the horrors of which allowed chocolate to become affordable to and popular with the everyday people of Europe and its colonies, especially in North America. But remember, this was still a drink,
Speaker 1and a gritty, unrefined one at that, until a series of inventions during the Industrial Revolution changed chocolate forever. And we're going to get into that, but first we're going to get into a quick break for a word from our sponsors. And we're back. Okay, so, in 1828, a Dutch chemist by the name of Conrad Johannes van Houten figured out how to press the cacao beans to separate the seeds' fats, cocoa butter, from the flavorful cocoa solids,
Speaker 1which is dry cocoa powder. He also treated the cocoa with alkali, making it smoother and less bitter. This Dutch-processed cocoa was later taken by Englishman Joseph Fry, mixed with sugar and some additional cocoa butter, and pressed into a mold to make the first solid chocolate bar in 1847. Then, in 1879, Swiss inventor Rudolf Lindt developed conching, a machine process that consistently created a smooth textured chocolate and made
Speaker 1chocolate more affordable to mass-produce. By the early 1900s, Nestle, Hershey, Cadbury, and other big names in chocolate were churning out candy for the masses. And the process hasn't changed a lot since then. Which isn't to say it's not complicated. It is. And it does vary depending on the company and how the chocolate will be used. But it always starts with those beans. Some companies rely on a single source for their beans or only buy them from a certain region. Experts compare the cacao bean to a wine grape. There
Speaker 1can be huge differences between beans depending on where they're grown and how they're treated. Big companies tend to use proprietary blends to create a consistent flavor. The first step when the beans show up at the chocolate factory is roasting, which removes bitterness, mellows the beans by evaporating some of the acids that they contain, and develops desired flavors. A part of this is through a chemical reaction called the Maillard reaction, which is also responsible for the roasty flavors in a lot of other foods, too. The Maillard reaction
Speaker 1happens when sugars and amino acids react with each other in the presence of heat. And in cacao beans, it helps create the distinctive flavor and smell of chocolate. After roasting, the beans are then winnowed from their hulls and crushed into nibs, little kernels of bean. Those kernels can be sold as is or ground into paste, sometimes called chocolate liquor, for further processing. The next step is grinding, which is done by a machine called a mélangeur, which has huge, traditionally granite rollers that mash the cacao nibs into a
Speaker 1paste called mass. The mass goes into a powerful press, which splits the cacao into its two components, powder and butter. If the powder is going to be used to make drinking chocolate or cocoa powder, it's pulverized very fine. If the confectioner is making solid chocolate, workers may make it straight from the mass or start with cocoa powder and add some cocoa butter back in. Good chocolate will use mostly or all cocoa butter as its fat. Cheaper chocolate will use other vegetable oils, too. Now's the time that they'll also add in sugar and any emulsifiers and other flavorings.
Speaker 1The next step is the aforementioned conching, so named because of the shell-shaped cylindrical grinding machine that Lindt created for the process. The machines that companies use for conching these days are proprietary, guarded secrets, but they're all designed to do a few of the same things— A continual grinding action evenly distributes the cocoa butter within the chocolate mass, creating a smoother mixture. The friction polishes the cocoa particles and makes them smoother. It also generates heat in the cocoa mass, releasing volatile oils and flavor compounds. If the
Speaker 1mass contains milk powder, which is often the case when making milk chocolate, heat will also encourage the Maillard reaction. Finally, the rotation introduces air into the mass, removing more acids and bitter compounds. The result is a smooth, even mixture of liquid chocolate that's easy to pour into molds. But before it hits the molds, the chocolate is tempered. This is a process of heating and cooling the chocolate to basically mitigate the size and shape of the cocoa butter crystals within it. Yes, cocoa butter molecules stack themselves in
Speaker 1crystal structures. The issue is that they'll form different structures depending on the temperatures and length of time at which they're allowed to solidify. Too cold and quick, and the resulting chocolate will be soft, and after it's finished, some fats may bloom to the surface, making it feel oily and crumbly. A warmer, but still too quickly, and the chocolate will be firmer, but still bloom fats. The magic temperature is right around 93 degrees Fahrenheit, or 34 Celsius. And letting it cool very slowly will produce the correct
Speaker 1type of cocoa butter crystals that results in a chocolate so hard that it snaps when you break it, with a nice shine to the surface and a smooth, melt-in-your-mouth texture. The tempering process can require multiple steps of heating and cooling to get most of the crystals on the same page. In factories, there are machines that do it automatically to take out the possibility of error. So if you've ever had trouble with it in your own kitchen, you're doing just fine. Although cacao is originally from Mesoamerica, today most
Speaker 1of the world's supply comes from West Africa, namely Ghana and the Ivory Coast. As of 2025, about 69% of cacao was produced in Africa, but only 23% of it is processed there. Europe leads with about 36% of cacao processing. Usually, cacao is grown on small family-owned farms of less than 10 acres or 4 hectares. Mass agricultural production just isn't possible because cacao farming is so intensive. Again, the pods are selected and harvested by hand. There's no other way
Speaker 1to remove them without damaging the bud from which additional pods will grow. Unfortunately, as global demand for chocolate has increased, the labor issues surrounding it haven't magically gone away. For the hundreds of billions of dollars the industry is worth, many cacao farmers live in poverty. And child labor and even trafficking and enslaved labor are still serious issues. Demand for cacao has also meant destruction of rainforest to plant more of it. To help as a consumer, look for the fair trademark on chocolate products. These companies have agreed
Speaker 1to pay an above-market price for cacao to help the farmers. And they support international programs to help communities where cacao is grown. It's not a perfect system, though. If you want to dig a little deeper, look up resources like the Chocolate Scorecard and the Food is Power Chocolate List to learn how different companies shape up. Treats are nice, and buying them from companies that care about their workers is even better. Today's episode is based on the article,
Speaker 1How That Creamy Chocolate is Made, on HowStuffWorks.com, written by Shanna Friedman and Aliyah Hoyt. BrainStuff is a production of iHeart Podcasts in partnership with HowStuffWorks.com and is produced by Tyler Klang. For more shows from iHeart Podcasts, visit the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.
Deep frying anything is a science -- but perhaps especially a whole turkey. Learn how to do it (and why it works) in this classic episode of BrainStuff, based on this article:...
DM Me with Doug Melville” is a direct, practical self-help podcast in which Doug Melville answers real questions with clear guidance to help listeners grow and take action on their careers, reputation, culture and life....
Cranberries evolved to grow best in bogs: acidic, nutrient-poor wetlands where most other plants can't survive. Learn how bogs came to be and how cranberries wind up on your table in today's episode of BrainStuff, based...
Most of Sparta's ancient history was written by its enemies, so it's hard to separate sometimes harsh facts from lurid fictions. Learn how historians think Sparta actually differed from other Ancient Greek city-states...
No one had ever seen a fossil of a feather until one Bavarian dig site gave us Archaeopteryx, a winged theropod with teeth, clawed fingers, a bony tail, and shaggy feather trousers. Learn what we know (and still don't...