Every U.S. election cycle, political campaigns bombard American televisions with advertisements for candidate X versus Y. But can these ads really make a difference, especially with shifts in the way we watch TV? Learn when they actually work in today's episode of BrainStuff, based on this article: https://people.howstuffworks.com/do-campaign-tv-ads-change-voters-minds.htm
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Welcome to BrainStuff, a production of iHeartRadio. Hey, BrainStuff. Lauren Vogelbaum here. The 2026 United States midterm elections are fast approaching. And if you live in a state with a hotly contested race, you're probably being blasted by political TV ads. As of late September, campaigns across the United States are projected to spend a total of $ 11. 6 billion on advertising on TV, in print, and online by Election Day in November,
Speaker 1according to the intelligence firm Ad Impact. That's far more than the 2022 midterms, which came in at just $ 8. 9 billion, and even the 2024 presidential cycle, which came in at $ 11. 2 billion. This year's record spending on television and other types of political ads reflects the high stakes of the 2026 midterms. The Republicans hold both chambers of Congress by slim majorities, the Senate by 53 versus 45 seats, and the House of Representatives by 218 versus 212. That means
Speaker 1that the Democratic Party needs to gain a net of only four seats in the Senate and three districts in the House to win majorities. Back in 2022, during the last and also blisteringly contested midterm cycle, HowStuffWorks spoke with Christopher Warshaw, now a political science professor at the McCourt School of Public Policy at Georgetown University. He said, campaigns hope that by buying a few extra thousand ads, they can put their candidates over the top and win control of the government for their party. the American public is
Speaker 1more polarized than ever before, but there's still this swath of independent voters in the middle who are trying to decide. And political ads, despite how annoying and even stressful they can be, have proven effective, especially in the tightest races. A bombardment of ads doesn't necessarily turn people off, but research has shown that the 1,000th ad is basically no less effective than the 10th. Take the 2016 and 2020 presidential elections, for example. The 2016 election was decided by
Speaker 1razor-thin margins of victory for Republican candidate Donald Trump in battleground states like Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. In 2020, Joe Biden and the Democrats spent heavily on political TV ads in those same battleground markets. As Election Day 2020 approached, pro-Biden TV ads outnumbered pro-Trump ads by the thousands in key markets, and Biden won the day. Back in 2022, Warshaw, along with two other researchers, published a study in the journal American Political Science Review that looked at data from
Speaker 1more than 2,250 U.S. elections from the years 2000 through 2016, not just presidential races. They found that for every additional thousand TV ads that a campaign runs compared to its opponent, it can capture 0.2 percentage points more of the vote. And the results of the 2020 presidential election seemed to bear this out, with small but significant swings happening in Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. However, it's a complicated equation. In the
Speaker 12024 presidential election, The volumes of ads that were pro-Harris versus pro-Trump were very close. Pro-Democrat groups spent more on advertising, nearly 1.8 billion versus pro-Republicans 1.4. But neither the numbers of ads nor the sheer money spent could win the election for Harris and the Democrats. Warshaw and colleagues did find that TV ads had a much greater effect on down-ballot races compared to presidential contests. three times greater for
Speaker 1Senate races, four times greater for gubernatorial races, and 12 times greater for the more obscure races like state treasurer. The reason may be that political TV ads function to convey some sort of new information to the voter. Warshaw said, At the presidential level, ads don't give you much new information that you didn't already have. We already knew so much about Donald Trump and Joe Biden. Whereas the races for the House or Governor or Senate people are following those a lot less closely. Voters might not know anything
Speaker 1about those candidates beyond their party affiliation. For that target demographic of undecided voters, any new information provided by a TV ad about a state or local race could swing them in the campaign's desired direction. This is also a lesson for political donors who want the most bang for their buck. A donation to a presidential campaign is a drop in the bucket, but that same donation to a down-ballot race could buy more ads that actually influenced the outcome. Television advertising has been part of the presidential election landscape
Speaker 1since 1952, when Dwight Eisenhower's team hired the Madison Avenue ad man who also came up with the Eminem's Melt-in-Your-Mouth, Not-in-Your-Hand campaign. At that time, only around 35% of American homes even had a television. And there was serious debate about whether it was appropriate for political candidates to run ads on TV at all. Eisenhower's opponent, Adlai Stevenson, felt that they should be above it. He said, Even TV
Speaker 1networks like NBC and CBS discouraged the campaigns from buying ad time in a move to maintain the dignity of the office. But Eisenhower and his TV-inclusive I Like Ike campaign wound up winning in a landslide, with the highest popular vote total since Franklin Roosevelt in 1936. It wasn't until the 1960 Kennedy-Nixon race that negative campaign ads debuted. The Kennedy team actually pulled a quote from Eisenhower slamming Nixon,
Speaker 1who was Eisenhower's vice president in that 1952 election. And it wasn't until the 2008 Obama-McCain race that complex data analytics entered the picture, with Obama's team pulling ahead with help from ad micro-targeting. Lots of studies have been done on the effectiveness of political TV ads over the years, and have shown mixed results. It seems that when you look at the big picture over time, these ads do have limited persuasive power. And the content doesn't necessarily matter.
Speaker 1All types of ads— positive, negative, partisan, nonpartisan— seem to have the same small effect on voting outcomes. Warshaw and colleagues' research showed that the largest plausible effect of TV ads influencing people to vote for a certain candidate is only one to two percentage points. So, if he was consulting a campaign on how to spend its money, he said he wouldn't automatically recommend pouring millions of dollars into television. It would depend on the market you're pitching to. A solidly
Speaker 1red or blue state isn't going to be swung by such a small amount. But as we've seen in the past few election cycles, there are plenty of contests that have been decided by less than one percentage point. Your vote always counts, even if you feel like you're shouting into a red or blue void. But okay, it's 2026. The way that we consume media is changing fast, so is the influence of TV ads changing too? We're going
Speaker 1to get into that, but first we're going to get into a quick word from our sponsors. The research from Warshaw and colleagues that we've been talking about looked at data from the years 2000 to 2016, a time when most American voters watched hours of cable television every day. But subscriptions to cable or other paid live TV services peaked in 2011, with some 82% of Americans subscribing. Between
Speaker 1then and now, 46% of Americans have cut the cord, and the number is growing every year. As of 2025, according to a Pew Research Center report, only 36% of Americans subscribed to cable or satellite TV at home. Compare that to 83% who watched streaming services. There's obviously some overlap there, but 55% of people said that they only watched streaming at home. Nevertheless, broadcast TV ads are still
Speaker 1the single biggest spending category in 2026's campaign advertising, estimated to make up some 48% of the aforementioned $ 11. 6 billion that's projected to be spent. A rising category of ad spending is in the relatively new market for connected television, which encompasses ads on streaming services like Netflix and apps like YouTube. A relatively small 23% of 2026 campaign ad budgets are estimated to be going to connected TV ads. However,
Speaker 1the increase in spending that we're seeing over the 2024 election cycle is expected to be almost exclusively in this category. Digital ads in general have been found to have an even smaller effect on voters than traditional TV ads, but political advertisers are getting smarter. On ad-supported apps and streaming services, campaigns can run hyper-targeted ads based on the subscriber's personal data. Not all streaming platforms currently allow political ads, but for
Speaker 1those that do, two people who live on the same block and watch the same show could be served different campaign ads based on all kinds of household data, including the resident's age, sex, race or ethnicity, voting record, party affiliation, or even the home's estimated market value. This might be key because research has shown that campaign ads tend to reinforce or confirm viewers' existing biases. That, for example, showing a pro-Republican ad to self-identified Republicans will mobilize them to
Speaker 1vote Republican. But that showing the same ad to self-identified Democrats will backlash, mobilizing them to vote against the Republican. So ad targeting could come really in handy for maximizing mobilization, minimizing backlash, and perhaps most importantly, reaching those undecided voters. And campaigns are getting really granular. Obviously, not every ad is going to resonate with every audience, but it's not just preferences for positive versus negative campaigning or issues versus
Speaker 1personality anymore. Research has shown that as of the past decade, a lot of traditional wisdom about what makes a campaign successful has gone out the window. Instead, it increasingly seems that every demographic of voters going into every race has its own priorities and preferences. Big money is now going into experimentation with different iterations of campaign ads. In such a fractured and contested political environment, you can run from
Speaker 1campaign ads, but you can't hide. Of course, all of the ads in the world won't make a difference if you don't actually vote. Look up your state or local elections office and make sure that you're registered and know how to vote, either via a mail-in ballot or in person during early voting or on election day. There are a few scams out there right now, so be sure that the website you check has an address that ends in. gov.
Speaker 1Today's episode is based on the article, Do Campaign TV Ads Really Change Voters' Minds? on HowStuffWorks.com, written by Dave Ruse. BrainStuff is a production of iHeart Podcasts in partnership with HowStuffWorks.com and is produced by Tyler Klang. For more shows from iHeart Podcasts, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.
Deep frying anything is a science -- but perhaps especially a whole turkey. Learn how to do it (and why it works) in this classic episode of BrainStuff, based on this article:...
DM Me with Doug Melville” is a direct, practical self-help podcast in which Doug Melville answers real questions with clear guidance to help listeners grow and take action on their careers, reputation, culture and life....
Cranberries evolved to grow best in bogs: acidic, nutrient-poor wetlands where most other plants can't survive. Learn how bogs came to be and how cranberries wind up on your table in today's episode of BrainStuff, based...
Most of Sparta's ancient history was written by its enemies, so it's hard to separate sometimes harsh facts from lurid fictions. Learn how historians think Sparta actually differed from other Ancient Greek city-states...
No one had ever seen a fossil of a feather until one Bavarian dig site gave us Archaeopteryx, a winged theropod with teeth, clawed fingers, a bony tail, and shaggy feather trousers. Learn what we know (and still don't...