Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

BrainStuff

BrainStuff artwork

What Really Happened at the 'Amityville Horror' House?

Oct 30, 202614 minAudio

After a tragic set of murders in 1974, the next residents at a grand old house in Amityville, New York, claimed the home was demonically haunted. Their story spawned a horror sensation. But was the whole thing a money-making hoax? Did the murderer really hear voices there? Learn what we know (and still don’t know) about what happened in Amityville in today’s episode of BrainStuff, based on this article: https://history.howstuffworks.com/history-vs-myth/amityville-horror-house.htm

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Welcome to BrainStuff, a production of iHeart Podcasts. Hey, BrainStuff. Lauren Vogelbaum here. Amityville. Even the name may send chills down your spine. This sleepy suburb on Long Island, New York, was the site of what may be the world's most famous tale of a haunting. The story goes that in 1975, a family of five moved into their dream home, a stately five-bedroom Dutch colonial at 112 Ocean Avenue. The house

Speaker 1came with the name High Hopes, and a grisly recent history. The family knew that the house had been the scene of a horrific mass murder just a year before. They were immediately besieged by dreadful apparitions, bubbling green slime, red-eyed pig heads, levitating beds— and sinister cries to get out. 28 days later, that's exactly what they did, abandoning their belongings. They'd go on to tell and sell their terrifying story to the world. They collaborated on a book titled The

Speaker 1Amityville Horror, A True Story, which came out in 1977 and catapulted to the top of the bestseller list. Hollywood bought the rights and released a fictionalized film, The Amityville Horror, in 1979, which, despite tepid initial reviews, was a box office smash and grew into a franchise of 10 studio official films to date, plus dozens of other movie riffs and copycats and parodies, all based on a true story. Like so many movies that Fangoria magazine once held a

Speaker 1special category in their annual Chainsaw Awards, the best Amityville of 2022. But how much of the Amityville horror story is fact, and how much is fiction? Is the world's most famous haunting nothing more than a hoax? Today, let's attempt to untangle the story behind the Amityville horror. For the article this episode is based on, HowStuffWorks spoke with Robert Bartholomew, a New Zealand sociologist who specializes in mass hysteria,

Speaker 1and who has strong opinions about this one. He said, The Amityville myth persists in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary. It's starkly obvious that it's a hoax, but people still want to believe. Whatever you think about the haunting of Amityville, what happened in the house in 1974 is truly horrific. On the night of November 13th of that year, six members of the DeFeo family were found shot to death in their beds. Parents Ronald Sr.

Speaker 1and Louise, both in their early 40s, and four of their five children, ranging in age from 18 to just seven years old. The murders happened early that morning, and the remaining child, 23-year-old Ronald Jr., better known as Butch, was implicated and eventually convicted. In a mess of a trial the following year, Butch's court-appointed lawyer, one William Weber, claimed that his client was driven mad by a satanic presence in the house, that Butch had heard voices in

Speaker 1the house telling him to kill, and entered a plea of not guilty by reason of insanity. The jury didn't buy this devil-made-me-do-it defense, and the judge sentenced DeFeo to six consecutive terms of 25 years to life in prison for six counts of second-degree murder. The case rocked the affluent suburb of Amityville, and it was breathlessly reported in the press. the home at 112 Ocean Avenue became notorious as the murder house. But less than a month after

Speaker 1DeFeo's conviction, in December of 1975, George and Kathy Lutz moved in with their three kids and a dog. They'd later say that they knew about the murders, but weren't particularly bothered. It was a really nice place. In addition to the three-story, 5,000-square-foot home that's around 450 square meters, There was also a heated pool and a boathouse on the Amityville River. For that much house, the property was underpriced at $ 80, 000. The mortgage was still a bit of

Speaker 1a stretch for the Lutzes, but they said it was their dream home. The following summer, reports began appearing in the press of a family dream home haunted. What happened to the Lutz family over the course of 28 days in December of 1975 to January of 76 has been retold many times and morphed slightly with every telling. In all versions, there's a local Catholic priest whom the Lutzes ask to bless the house due to its earlier events.

Speaker 1In the book, the priest senses a sinister presence in the bedroom that belonged to the two youngest siblings and warns the Lutzes not to let anyone sleep in that room. Some versions say the priest felt a sharp slap on his face and heard a groaning voice scream, get out. In the movie, he's attacked by a swarm of flies. Then, allegedly, the really weird stuff began. Doors slamming open and shut at all hours. A persistent coldness in the house despite roaring fires in the fireplace. Drops of gelatinous goo, red

Speaker 1in some versions or green or black in others, appearing on the walls and carpet. One night, Kathy transformed into an aged crone. Another, the face of a demon-eyed pig appeared in a bedroom window. On their final night in the house, George reported that Kathy levitated and slid off the bed, and that he was kept awake all night by the sound of the children's beds slamming against the floor above him, along with flickering lights and an unseen presence lurking in the room. The next day, the kids

Speaker 1awoke traumatized, saying they were unable to move or leave their rooms. The Lutzes, terrified and exhausted, said they couldn't take it anymore. On January 14th of 1976, they left just about everything behind at 112 Ocean Avenue, never to return. Soon after the Lutzes abandoned the house, they met with William Weber, the lawyer who had represented Butch DeFeo. Exactly what happened next is difficult to suss out, because there

Speaker 1was the promise of money involved. Later, Weber would say that he and the Lutzes had a creative brainstorming session that January over, quote, many bottles of wine. Apparently, the Lutzes shared the story of the unsettling things that they had felt and seen at the house, and Weber shared details about the DeFeos and the killings that only he knew. Weber claims that several of these details were spun into events in the book and film. For example, Weber says that he told the Lutzes that a neighbor's cat would

Speaker 1peer into the DeFeo's window at night. That became the red-eyed pig. And he said that Ronald DeFeo Sr. had once hit his wife while she held a plate of red-sauced spaghetti. That became the mysterious red goo on the wall that then morphed into green slime bubbling from keyholes. Weber said in 1988, we took real-life incidents and transposed them. In other words, it was a hoax. At the time, Weber and the Lutzes talked about a book contract, and

Speaker 1they even held a press conference about the phenomena the Lutzes supposedly experienced that February of 1976. Around that time, Weber corresponded with Butch DeFeo and worked out a royalty agreement with him. But Weber and the Lutzes soon parted ways after a fight about how money from the book deal would be split. Over the next few years, the Lutzes sued Weber and a few of his collaborators for publishing articles about their experiences. Weber and company countersued for breach of contract and for fraud. They all eventually settled

Speaker 1out of court. Perhaps conveniently, Weber and his co-defendants settled the day after the judge in the case proposed referring the entire situation to the New York State Bar Association because, and here I quote said judge, one Jack B. Weinstein, there is a very serious ethical question when lawyers become literary agents. Meanwhile, the Lutzes took their story to Jay Anson, a journalist and filmmaker who had previously done a short documentary on the making of The Exorcist. Our sociologist, Bartholomew, said,

Speaker 1Anson listened to 35 hours of taped interviews with the Lutzes. Then he sat down and wrote the book. The best way to describe Jay Anson is a writer who didn't let the facts get in the way of a good story. The book was published in September of 1977, and pretty immediately optioned for film. The movie came out in the summer of 1979, by which point the book had already sold some two and a half million copies. The movie turned out to be the highest-grossing independent film ever up

Speaker 1until that point, a position it would hold for a decade. Remember that by the late 70s, both real and fictional accounts of satanic cults were whipping into what would become the full-blown satanic panic of the 80s and 90s. While the film was still in production, in March of 79, Writer's Digest published an excellent profile about Anson and the book and movie deal that had made him retireably wealthy. He was elusive about the truthfulness of his account of

Speaker 1what had happened in Amityville. He said in that profile, It's funny. Almost nobody ever says to me, Hey, that book of yours is a bunch of bull. I didn't believe a word of it. Instead, they ask if I think what the Lutzes told me is true. I tell them that I have no idea whether the book is true or not, but I'm sure that the Lutzes believe. what they told me to be true. Bartholomew is convinced that the Lutzes abandoned the house because they couldn't keep up with the mortgage and tax payments, and created the

Speaker 1haunting story as an excuse and a lucrative side hustle. For their part, the Lutzes never retracted their story. Amidst controversy over their claims, George told the Washington Post in 1979, Our critics are people who have never been in the house, just people who read a book. No one who was ever in the house, who investigated it, ever called it a hoax. No one with any credentials who was personally involved ever called it a hoax. No one who helped

Speaker 1us there, with the auction, with getting stuff to the Salvation Army, ever called it a hoax. All I know is what happened to me. But the veracity of the Lutzes' claims aren't the only mystery at hand here. Over 50 years after the murders that started the Amityville legacy, we still don't know what really happened that terrible morning in November of 1974. There have been wild and contradictory stories from various people connected to the case over the years,

Speaker 1including Butch DeFeo himself. There have been rumors of mafia connections, and of Ronald Sr. being physically abusive to his family, and of drugs being involved, and of family fights about money, and of up to two accomplices, one of whom may have been Don DeFeo, Butch's 18-year-old sister, who he killed that morning. It's the opinion of Rick Asuna, who published a book about the murders in 2002 called The Night the DeFeos Died, that the judicial system seriously mishandled the case.

Speaker 1He basically alleges that the district attorney and prosecution and judges involved didn't care to look beyond Butch as a suspect, basically forcing the court-appointed lawyer, William Weber, to enter an insanity plea for his client, and thus inadvertently kicking off the entire myth of a demonically haunted house. On the flip side, there have been accusations that Weber was angling for a book deal before the trial even began. Butch DeFeo's own story changed several times over the decades. He

Speaker 1died in prison in 2021 at the age of 69. Through it all, the Amityville house itself persists. The next family that bought the property at 112 Ocean Avenue after the Lutz's bank foreclosed were so harassed by horror fans and vandals that they had to move out. Apparently, people rang the doorbell at all hours asking for butch, stole roof shingles, and ripped out chunks of the lawn. The house now has a different street number to discourage fans, and its iconic quarter-circle upper windows, which gave it the

Speaker 1appearance of having eyes, were remodeled to less creepy rectangles. The house has been sold four more times, and none of the newer owners have reported seeing any paranormal phenomena. It last went for $ 605, 000 in 2017. The house where the original movie was filmed, out in New Jersey, has been completely renovated and last sold for a smidge under $ 1. 5 million in 2023. The listing agent said that the previous owners really did it up for Halloween and also

Speaker 1reported that the new buyers were aware of the film, but not really fans. Today's episode is based on the article, The real story behind the Amityville Horror House on HowStuffWorks.com, written by Dave Ruse. BrainStuff is a production of iHeart Podcasts in partnership with HowStuffWorks.com and is produced by Tyler Klang. For more shows from iHeart Podcasts, visit the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. BrainStuff Classics: How Do You Deep Fry a Turkey?

    Nov 21, 20269 minAudio

    Deep frying anything is a science -- but perhaps especially a whole turkey. Learn how to do it (and why it works) in this classic episode of BrainStuff, based on this article:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Introducing: DM Me with Doug Melville

    Nov 21, 20261 minAudio

    DM Me with Doug Melville” is a direct, practical self-help podcast in which Doug Melville answers real questions with clear guidance to help listeners grow and take action on their careers, reputation, culture and life....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How Do Cranberries Grow in Bogs?

    Nov 20, 202612 minAudio

    Cranberries evolved to grow best in bogs: acidic, nutrient-poor wetlands where most other plants can't survive. Learn how bogs came to be and how cranberries wind up on your table in today's episode of BrainStuff, based...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Did Sparta Really Only Care About Producing Super-Soldiers?

    Nov 18, 202612 minAudio

    Most of Sparta's ancient history was written by its enemies, so it's hard to separate sometimes harsh facts from lurid fictions. Learn how historians think Sparta actually differed from other Ancient Greek city-states...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Dinosaur Archaeopteryx Had Wings, But Could It Fly?

    Nov 16, 202610 minAudio

    No one had ever seen a fossil of a feather until one Bavarian dig site gave us Archaeopteryx, a winged theropod with teeth, clawed fingers, a bony tail, and shaggy feather trousers. Learn what we know (and still don't...

    Credit the people on this episode