Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Brain Chatter

Brain Chatter artwork

A Giant Money Pit: Employee Turnover

Dec 9, 202052 minAudio

Kyle Roed is Global HR Manager for CPM Holdings, based in Waterloo, Iowa. He discusses the massive costs of team member turnover. How can you start to measure these often unrecognized, un-reported, and siloed costs, both financial and cultural? How can you minimize them? What are some top strategies to retain top human capital talent? Are you asking the basic questions? Do you conduct 'stay interviews' in addition to exit interviews? Does your human resources department have operational and business clout to help with solutions? EPISODE RESOURCES: Kyle's LinkedIn CPM Holdings Kyle's Rebel HR Podcast SHRM eLearning SHRM Article: “To Have and To Hold” Bill Conerly Article in Forbes: "Dollar Cost of Employee Turnover" US Bureau of Labor, Recent Data Gallup Article: "Fixable Problem Costs Businesses a Trillion" Brain Chatter, a podcast where we listen past the daily noise and explore topics at the intersection of leadership, workplace culture, profit, and sustainability.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Brain Chatter. Join us as we explore real life examples of leaders who listen past the daily noise, lead themselves and others with clarity, and make an effective difference on the front lines of leadership and life and work. I'm your host, Derek Brown. Today's episode is A Giant Money Pit, Employee Turnover. And our guest is Kyle Rhode, Global Human Resources Director of CPM Holdings in Waterloo, Iowa, and host of his own podcast, Rebel Human Resources Podcast.

SPEAKER_00I'll link to both Kyle's podcast, CPM Holdings, and Kyle's LinkedIn in the episode notes at BrainchatterPodcast.com, along with the other articles and resources we mention in this episode. Kyle, welcome to Brain Chatter.

SPEAKER_01Thanks for having me. Happy to be here.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. I'll loop back and do a deeper introduction of you, your company, and your podcast shortly. But to start us off, I thought I'd introduce today's topic about retention and turnover with some sobering information about the costs of turnover. First, from a 2019 article by the Gallup Organization, their estimate on voluntary turnover and replacement costs annually inside U.S. businesses is$1 trillion. And it identifies much of that as self-inflicted by many of these businesses.

SPEAKER_00The same article references 2017 numbers from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics showing that the average voluntary turnover inside U.S. businesses annually is 26.3%. The article further paints its stark picture by estimating that if there were a 100-employee company with an average annual salary of$50,000, the turnover and replacement costs would range between$660,000 and$2.6 million per year.

SPEAKER_00Kyle, I know this is no secret to the human resources world. What are your thoughts on the challenges of turnover and retention in general and from your personal observations in your years as an HR professional?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. Happy to share that. And some of those statistics are not surprising to me. In fact, most of my career has been uh highlighting some of those challenges and concerns and and um arguing that we need to take action on some of it. So uh as far as the challenges of turnover and retention, uh, they in my mind are the root cause of a lot of the challenges that that we face day in and day out in the world of HR. So uh, you know, you'll hear a lot about uh people who are trying to hire and can't find good talent.

SPEAKER_01Uh you'll you'll hear a lot about uh people who feel like uh there's quote job hopping and people don't stay at employers for a long time. But I I tend to flip the script on that a little bit and ask people, is it really a staffing problem or is it a turnover problem? Uh, because uh we all know that if we aren't retaining our top talent or we're not giving our team a reason to stick around, uh, then there's plenty of opportunity for them to go elsewhere.

SPEAKER_01And uh and that can hurt an organization. I think the one thing that I would argue, though, as it relates to the cost of turnover, is we're talking about human capital here, uh, which is the uh the sum total of all of the good and bad things that people bring into an organization. It's always kind of a mixed bag. And you you really can't put a true number on it in a financial capital lens.

SPEAKER_01You can do your best, uh, but I would argue that the organizations that have high turnover don't just have higher costs associated with replacing turnover, they have cultural costs. There's a cultural ripple effect uh to organizations uh are high turnover, and that leads to instability. Uh, when you have high turnover within your leadership ranks, it's going to be exacerbated. Uh, and ultimately uh you will start to degrade your product or your customer support uh within your organization if you don't address some of these things.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And in a different article, this one was in Forbes, and I'll link to this in the episode notes. Uh Bill Connorly, an economist and the author of Businomics from the headlines to your bottom line, provides a step-by-step guide for a company on estimating the cost and costliness of turnover in any given organization. Um, just like you said, it's there's there's a lot of places that you have to go out and discover where those costs exist. And as with a lot of costs, um management may not realize its actual size because the cost factors are scattered across different parts of the organization.

SPEAKER_00Those costs are often siloed and not fully comprehended in any sort of informal assessment. But as a reference point, he provides some generalized estimates for the cost of replacing a single lost team member in a company. He says, quote, off-the-shelf estimates are available, which might set the cost of an entry-level position turning over at 50% of salary, mid-level at 125% of salary, and a senior executive at over 200% of salary, end quote.

SPEAKER_00Obviously, those are very hefty numbers. That means if an entry-level position pays$30,000, then to replace that person would cost$15,000. And if you know the pay scale of an organization, you can quickly see how dramatically that scales up. How often do you think close to accurate accounting of these costs end up showing up on any kind of report or spreadsheet that is actually taken seriously by company executives and seen as something that's modifiable with effort?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think your your your question is very reflective and uh hits close to home. So, first of all, I would say I think that estimate that's probably pretty close. Um, you know, the uh 50% for an entry-level mid-level 125, senior executive over 200 uh percent. I think that's probably close. Um you know, my my answer to your question about having it on a report or a spreadsheet uh for me comes down to that specific organization.

SPEAKER_01The only time that I have seen that within my background, within an organization, has been when there's an organization with a really strong HR function that also has operational business clout and the ability to articulate uh the accurate accounting of those numbers. So I'll give you an example. Um at one of my uh companies, we actually had a uh project, a cross-functional project with accounting, and we took the various inputs from each of our individual locations that go into hiring and training a new hire.

SPEAKER_01Uh and that was the calculation that we then used to extrapolate the total cost to the business. When we did that, we found that we were costing the organization upwards of$15 million a year in turnover cost. And what that did is that actually prompted multiple projects within each location to start to address some of those issues and really do some root cause analysis on why.

SPEAKER_01So just by doing an accurate accounting project that was validated and supported by the finance team, we were able to articulate the problem, but then we also prompted additional insight into how do we go address it. So, I mean, I think that's in my world, we're a for-profit world, that's the only way to get momentum in my mind.

SPEAKER_00So one thing you mentioned just then was in organizations where the HR component of the business has operational and business clout. Can you talk a little bit more about that? How how you see that clout being developed and um what makes the difference there?

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I think, and this is my call to action that you know I I I get pretty passionate about it, but I view HR as a critical business function. Uh, and in order to be a true business partner, we have to know what our business is. And and ultimately uh we have to understand what the different business functions do and understand how our business works. And that's as simple for me as how do we make money?

SPEAKER_01Who are our customers, and how does that translate into the bottom line of the organization? So it's really what I would consider kind of like a fundamental analysis of how the business works. And once you get that building block and that foundational understanding of the organization that you work within, then you can start to align your HR strategy to the business strategy. And ultimately, you can go talk to any C-level executive.

SPEAKER_01That's what they want from HR. You know, the the the days of HR being the quote personnel department where you know you're just processing payroll and you're you're an admin function and you're you're overhead. Uh in my mind, I think those days are past. You know, HR is being called upon to be a true business partner, to help be a perspective on the business, to help the business A, be profitable through effective talent processes, but B also support that human capital and the people and and ensure that your processes are supportive of what they need as well.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. One of my coworkers is a former HR director at an industrial facility, and and she says, uh, her name is Kim McNanny. She says that one of the things she's seen over time is a lot of times the HR manager for a site will not go to maybe the the daily morning meeting or any of the shift meetings because they don't see that that there's any value in that. But she said there's a tremendous value in that just because you're at the table, then you're thought of more often, and then your input is more valued whenever decisions are being made and you can sort of get ahead and be proactive.

SPEAKER_00Have you seen that um before where it depends on whether or not the HR person is actually at the table?

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Um, you know, and and I think the term, you know, a seat at the table gets thrown around a lot, but I I don't think it's as big of a of a feat as a lot of people think. You know, at the end of the day, you just have to be there and show up and provide a perspective. And if you show up day in and day out to those types of meetings and you provide value, then people will rely on that and and and support, you know, some of the some of the initiatives that you uh know need to be done.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, an example I can use here. So uh this has been many years ago and a previous employer. Uh I came from a very progressive organization where HR was was kind of like the kind of like the town mayor, you know, going around making sure everybody was happy, checking in, seeing if we need to adjust things here or there to make people's experience better. And then I I transitioned in my career into a manufacturing environment. And uh it was a very different perspective of what HR was. It was, you know, you walk the floor and and people are like averting their eyes because they don't want you to, they don't want you to come over there because they feel like you're gonna get them in trouble.

SPEAKER_01So totally, you know, totally different environment and and something that uh I wasn't expecting, but uh as I walked into that, I realized really quickly I was gonna have to get my pulse on the organization somehow. And so I just started showing up uh every every morning to the uh standing uh meetings that the supervisors had, and then I would just make it a point to float around between daily huddles and just show up. And and what would end up happening is somebody would would say, Hey, Kyle's with us.

SPEAKER_01Kyle, do you have anything to share? And I would share, you know, whatever initiative was top of mind, or or maybe just you know recognition or what have you. But it's as simple as that. You build the relationship, you start to build uh the cloud. And then I also started to learn. And, you know, I did that for a good six months before I tried to roll out any sort of like brand new initiatives. And ultimately it the foundation of trust and understanding was really what in my mind allowed me to be successful in that role.

SPEAKER_00That makes a lot of sense. To loop back earlier to what we were talking about with the costs, there was in that same article I was talking about related to uh turnover and retention, the Forbes article, the Bill, the author, goes on to describe some of those costs that that he identifies scattered across the organization. And I'll I'll just run through these really fast. It'll be a little bit wordy, but I'd like to get your thoughts on this. He says among the costs, uh there's the time it takes for HR to conduct an exit interview, to process all the components of the termination and the benefits, the cost of advertising the new position wherever you do that, the time cost of reviewing resumes and holding interviews, of drawing up offers, the time and costs of leading and orientation and enrolling the replacement person or people into benefits.

SPEAKER_00And then while the position is open, that work is likely covered by other employees diverting attention from their normal workflow and lowering their own productivity inside their actual role, maybe even being paid at a higher rate for overtime, or work simply piles up and is not completed or is rushed, impacting quality, like you said. He mentions that open sales positions, that's a torpedo directly for the top line. And then there's the stress to other employees whose positions touch those open positions. And when the new person is finally on site, there's all the training, the time and cost of all that, the supervisor and manager's time, and then the coworkers who continue to help the new person and impact their own lower productivity or focus in their own role.

SPEAKER_00And then the mistakes that often come with being new in a position, not to mention the customer service interruption to the end clients, just the pile of costs go on. You even mentioned some others a few minutes ago, but uh if if an HR director's trying to make the case for all of these costs, um where do they start?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a long list. That is that is tough to understand uh where to start. I I would say it's relatively comprehensive. The only thing that I didn't see in there or didn't hear was um was cultural impact. And eventually what I have seen is you get one department that starts to see a little bit of turnover, the stress starts to build, you have a few more people leave. It's almost like this snowball rolling downhill where you can actually have a great performing department, and then one key person leaves, and 12 months later the department's on fire because it's it's just this kind of this cyclical issue.

SPEAKER_01And and when you have really key talent leave, there is a ripple, and it it really can it can be extremely disruptive. And if you don't if you don't address it or if you don't fill the position in a timely manner, the the cost and stress and pain of having that open position just continues to get worse and worse. So it's it's definitely a high urgency issue. Um and and a huge a huge pile of financial costs, but there's some intrinsic cost there that's that's not quantifiable through dollars and cents.

SPEAKER_01Um yeah, so so to circle back to the uh original question here, where do you start? Me, I'm a data guy. So, you know, if if I'm having if I'm having issues within a specific department, or if I start to see a turnover spike, the first thing is realizing that it happens either at the time it happens or having some sort of a leading indicator that there's a risk of it happening. A lot of times uh we we're too reactive to the point where we don't know that turnover is an issue until turnovers you know double digits and now and now we are are panicking because we're trying to, you know, we're trying to put the fire out, but then we're also trying to build the house at the same time and it just keeps catching on fire.

SPEAKER_01So you know, so I I uh I encourage people go do go do a deep dive into analytics. If you're not good at statistics or or data analytics, go find someone in your company that is uh in my current company. I have a fantastic uh financial planning and analysis director that helps me uh with some of those modeling, and you know, that's that's her thing. So I'm gonna let her do her thing, I'll do my thing, right? So leverage your internal expertise and and go in. And you know, a lot of people will tell me, well, I don't have that data.

SPEAKER_01I don't, I don't know that. Yeah, you do. You just don't know how to collect it. So uh an example of of uh uh something that we did, we we were having a significant issue with turnover in a manufacturing uh setting, uh, specifically with our female uh population at one of my uh employers. And we couldn't figure it out. And in the data, uh what we were seeing in that department is we were just having a huge spike of people getting terminated because they had too many attendance incidents, or we had people who are just job abandoning within the first few weeks of their job.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, obviously both of those things are bad. But ultimately, the way that we actually got the data and figured out there's something we can do about this is we actually just went out and started talking. We we went and talked to the coworkers on the line that were standing next to that person day in and day out and said, Hey, do you know why so-and-so left? You know, she she seemed to be doing really good. And what we found was as we went through and we started to have these conversations and understand some of the qualitative data is the fact that daycare was an issue.

SPEAKER_01And a lot of it had to do with the fact that the hours of that department were not conducive to the hours that most of the local daycare centers provided. So people were asking friends and family to watch their children until the daycare opened, or uh there wasn't enough available daycare within the area uh to provide it. So what we ended up doing is we went and partnered with our local child care resource and referral authority. We made sure that we we found an area uh that these individuals could go to to get referrals for you know qualified, uh safe uh daycare providers.

SPEAKER_01And then the other thing we did is we we looked at our shift start times and we said, well, this this shift isn't working for these folks. What if we just move the time back an hour? Would that, you know, would that shut down operations? And the initial reaction is, well, yeah, we can't do that. And then if you ask why, um, the the reason you'll find is well, it's because we've always done it this way, which is inherently part of the part of the challenge in a lot of uh uh environments. So we found out we could change the time. So we did. And and we saw the turnovers slow down.

SPEAKER_01Um and so it's one of those things where you've got to go a little bit deeper than, you know, I have X percent turnover. You've got to understand why. And ultimately, this is where HR adds value in my mind. Ultimately, you have to keep your pulse on it. You have to understand the real stories and the real implications, and then understand what you can do as an employer to help support success.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. What a great story and outcome. Um, I know that you mentioned that your current employer in in a previous correspondence, you mentioned that uh CPM Holdings has a lower turnover than many of the companies in the industry. Could you say some about how you attribute and manage that lower than average turnover and what sort of got you that way?

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. So um yeah, I I've been with my organization now um going on almost three years. And I'll be honest, the when I started here, um we weren't really doing a lot of the things I'm talking about. We weren't tracking it. Um, you know, we were uh relatively laissez faire in a lot of our management practices. Uh and so the first time that I went out and did a true deep dive of our data and put together a dashboard for, you know, kind of for HR results, I was shocked at the turnover number.

SPEAKER_01I was like, okay, this can't be right. And so I go back through and I I relooked at all the inputs and made sure that I didn't have a formula off somewhere. And sure enough, turnover was was low single digits. Like um, I want to say that first year I was looking at it, it was right around like 13, 14 percent. The industry average in my uh locations is usually anywhere from 35 to 45 percent. Wow. So significantly lower. So I'm like, okay, this something's wrong in the data. Uh but sure enough, uh it that it was accurate.

SPEAKER_01And you know, it was interesting. My perspective, I came from the world of retail, uh, which turnover was 80 to 90 percent on average. Annually. And then I was in a manufacturer that was what I would consider maybe a lower wage manufacturer. And that turnover rate was right around 30 to 35%. And then I came to my current role. And there were a couple inputs that I would attribute that to. I think the first very clear finding, and I know some employers will not like to hear this, but we pay our people appropriately.

SPEAKER_01You know, we um we look at the at the external market and wages are market comparable and they are livable. They're a livable wage. Um I think that that was one very clear finding uh and it just makes everything easier. Now it's not always an option for for an employer with razor-thin margins, but we we are fortunate at my current company to be able to do that. Um but I think if you go maybe uh away from wage uh and benefits, uh, because it's certainly an input, but it's not necessarily the primary reason that somebody stays.

SPEAKER_01Because the other comment I would say is, especially in manufacturing and skilled manufacturing jobs, you can go find a job pretty much anywhere for about the same, if not a little bit more, uh, money per hour. So there's there's other reasons outside of wage uh inflation or uh or or uh I would reach uh market wage paying. Um and and I I would actually say that through the course of my discussions and findings, people stick around for three primary reasons that are not related to wage.

SPEAKER_01The first one is they like the people they work with. And I was shocked at the number of people who were close friends outside of work. Um, they go hunting and fishing and drinking and go to their uh go to each other's kids, sporting events, you know, there's just that connection was there. And if you think about it from a human perspective, if I get to go to work and hang out with my friends all day, that's a great place to work.

SPEAKER_01And so if I want to leave an employer, I'm basically leaving my friends. So, you know, there's so I think that there's a ton of inertia that's built by just making sure that your employees are friends with each other. Now, a lot of HR people are gonna recoil at that and say, yeah, I don't want, you know, then you get this whole relationship in the workplace kind of thing. And I would tell you, yeah, I've got people who are married that work uh at my company that weren't married before they started there. They got to know each other at work, and guess what? Now they're married, you know, um, which isn't necessarily the HR goal, but it it happens.

SPEAKER_01And and I think it's a a a sign of being close knit. So I think number one, people like their coworkers. Number two, empowerment. And I would say this is such a buzzword right now. I kind of hate to use it, but but that's truly what we saw. So empowerment from the standpoint of people are not micromanaged. Uh, you know, there's not somebody flagging, okay, you've been offline for 15 minutes. That means you're you're loafing.

SPEAKER_01We, you know, you better go hit them up and say, you know, get your productivity back up. That's not how it is. It's it's much more laid back. The the goal setting is relatively informal and could be more formal, to be quite honest, but it's also very comfortable. People understand, okay, in my job, I have a goal of doing this. I'm gonna go figure out how to get there. Um, and we don't necessarily have all of the lean manufacturing processes.

SPEAKER_01We could, we could have more of that, but I think people actually enjoy that because it's a creative process at times at work. So it's it's mentally stimulating and they don't feel micromanaged. Um and then I would say the the kind of the third commonality, the third criteria is really strong leadership. And when I say strong leadership, I don't mean like, you know, you're um a dictator that's like telling you thou shalt go and do this, you know, come hell or high water, you know.

SPEAKER_01I'm not talking like the Theory X leadership. I'm talking strong leaders that that care about their employees. And, you know, I think it comes, it circles back to the friends at work. My managers know their employees on a personal level. They understand that when COVID-19 hit, so-and-so has really little kids. They are really going to struggle during the hours that their children are awake.

SPEAKER_01We are fine being flexible with them, completing their work after the kids go to sleep, or being more productive after the kids go to sleep, rather. Uh, we're okay if somebody is on a corporate presentation with executives on the line and their kid busts in and is like yelling and asking for a snack. You know, it's funny. Um, and at one point, um, I remember this was back in like April, May, back when everything was quarantined.

SPEAKER_01You know, at one point I got onto a call and I think everybody had some sort of a giant beard going on because nobody was shaving at that point. So, you know, but it's it's like it's it's that kind of culture where, you know, my my leaders truly care about their employees as people and give them an opportunity to succeed as people. And I think if you boil that down into more of an analytical, you know, kind of a human capital lens, what that allows them to do is understand somebody's intrinsic strengths and opportunities.

SPEAKER_01And then they can modify the work instructions and the work expectations in order to fit that person's specific brand of execution and uh output. So uh long-winded example, but you know, those are kind of the three major findings.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And like you said, not things that can be captured in a spreadsheet as much as some people may wish they could be.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, sorry for all the bean counters out there, but it's some of this stuff is is a little touchy-feely.

SPEAKER_00Well, let me go back and do a better introduction of you now, Kyle. Kyle is the vice president of human resources for CPM Holdings Incorporated. In that role, he oversees the various aspects of human resources for their 27 domestic and international locations in 11 countries. Kyle previously held progressive HR roles for Fortune 500 organizations, and most recently was the senior manager of human resources for Omega Cabinetry. As I mentioned earlier, you can also listen to Kyle's views as the host of the Rebel Human Resources Podcast, which you can find on Apple Podcasts and other major podcast outlets.

SPEAKER_00I'll also put a link in the episode notes. Kyle is also a board member of the Cedar Valley Society for Human Resources Management and co-founder of Disrupt HR Cedar Valley. Additionally, Kyle serves his community as a board member of the Iowa State Rehabilitation Council, one Cedar Valley, and Cedar Valley Kids. Kyle earned his Bachelor's in Business Administration from the University of Iowa Tippy College of Business and holds the certificates of Professional and Human Resources from HRCI and the Society for Human Resources Certified Professional from SHERM.

SPEAKER_00Kal, I know as mentioned in your bio, you're very involved in your local chapter of the Society of Human Resource Management, often just called SHERM. That gives you a chance to regularly network and idea share with other HR professionals, and it gives you a chance to both hear about their successes and their challenges and even their horror stories and to learn more about how they approach and deal with all three. From those conversations, can you summarize what the conversation around employee retention and employee turnover are often like in in those kinds of settings?

SPEAKER_00And do you hear the same sorts of issues over and over, or do you hear issues that are all over the board?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a that's a great question. And I I am fortunate to get to network and and uh know a lot of uh really talented HR professionals through my through my networking. Um I would say that the approach is very drastically different depending upon the industry or the company that the person works at. So a lot of times the the topic of of turnover is a really big issue for for those that work in the healthcare, retail, uh, and manufacturing sectors.

SPEAKER_01That's uh that's just where my network feels the most pain. You know, some of the other industries are a little bit more insulated. Uh, typically the more you know professional industries uh don't deal with that. And so in the context of the higher turnover industries, I think the the conversation is usually uh complaining about people who are leaving for you know minimal dollar increases. So it's a it's a concern that you know somebody who is uh let's say they're an entry-level engineering in a manufacturing organization, maybe they're leaving for one or two thousand dollars more per year when you know an HR professional is like they would have gotten that in their raise had they just hung out for another few months.

SPEAKER_01You know, it's so it's some of those challenges that I hear. And then a lot of times the conversation revolves around not being able to find replacement employees for some of that turnover. That's the challenge. And so, you know, what I've seen, at least in my local community, is it's almost like there's just there's this talent churn, as I would call it, where employers are just um, you know, kind of taking one employee from another employer and that employer has to replace it. And so it's this kind of this constant cycle of hiring and replacing open positions.

SPEAKER_01So it's it's definitely in the context of disruption. For those HR professionals that are in organizations where the turnover rate's a little bit lower, a lot of times I'll hear more conversation related to cultural improvements. And it's not so much a focus on preventing turnover, but the focus is more on optimizing uh their organization so that they can leverage the team that they have in a more effective way. So uh it it it's drastically different depending upon how good or bad your turnover is within your your uh company.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. For a lot of those entry-level positions, do you do you hear a lot of conversation about um the lack of certain basic skills? And uh and by that uh I mean like the basic skills that an employee needs to come to work, uh knowing like that uh that you actually have to come every day that you're scheduled, um, or that um you ought to treat your fellow employees with respect, the the those very kind of basic human skills.

SPEAKER_00Do you hear that across the board as a challenge or not so much?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean it it that is one that transcends the industry. Um, you know, I think there's a general challenge with what we would call the soft skills. Um, and you mentioned many of them, you know, it's the attendance, uh, it's the having the appropriate attitude, uh, being willing to learn, following directions. Um I hear a lot of concerns about people who question authority, uh, to the point of, you know, being almost insubordinate because they think that their way is better than their, you know, the the way that they're being told to do it.

SPEAKER_01So I think that I hear that though, a lot of that's cultural, you know, just cultural clashes of people who just have differing perspectives towards work. Um, but yeah, that's a lot of the work in the community that I've done has been with some of those local uh education institutions to help them understand, you know, what are some of the some what are some of the challenges that we see? And then, you know, my perspective is position-based training and work-based training uh is a really great way to overcome that hurdle and ensure that people are set up with great training up front, uh, but also in ensuring that some of that workplace training includes some of the cultural training within your organization, because every organization has this like like these unwritten rules of you know what you're what you're supposed to do.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, like for instance, when I started with my current company, uh my my shift always started really early at my last company. So I scheduled a meeting at like 7:30 in the morning, and uh I got so much grief and people are like, don't schedule any meetings until after 8:30. Nobody's had their coffee yet, don't do it. You know, but it's like one of those things, well, that wasn't in the handbook, and I didn't know that, so you know, sorry about that. Thanks for the feedback. It's stuff like that, right?

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Well, from your experience, are there any really low-hanging fruit, as the saying goes, when it comes to addressing common causes of employee turnover that are the very basics that every organization ought to be addressing, but that you notice plenty of organizations uh just being oblivious to or or not prioritizing?

SPEAKER_01That's a great question. Um, you know, I think the universal agreement is make sure your communication protocols are in place. Just be good at communicating. If you even if you just open up the channels of communication, have a good open communication policy, uh, listen, learn, provide feedback, provide transparency to some of the uh things that you do or some of the decisions that are being made, that's just that's gonna help not just with turnover, but just in general.

SPEAKER_01Um so you know, I would say focus on communication. I think the other thing that's maybe a little bit more tactical is very simple, and that is do exit interviews if people leave. Make sure you actually facilitate that discussion so that you actually get the real feedback. But then I would take that up a notch and say uh the next level up is something called a stay interview. And a stay interview is much more proactive than an exit interview.

SPEAKER_01At the point of an exit interview, you're not gonna save anybody's job. They've already made the decision. Uh, that even if they're conflicted about it, typically an exit interview, you're not gonna convince someone to stick around. You're just gathering data. A stay interview is an opportunity to actually go to somebody, ask them very similar questions to an exit interview, but you're asking them why do they stay? What keeps them there? What are some things that keep them up at night? And then the the key point here is, and then you take action on it and and improve.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, I would say that the the actions that are are gonna need to be taken off of some of that data are gonna be completely um different depending upon the company. But if you enact some of those things, uh you will be able to have some data, you'll be able to have some actions, you'll be able to leverage your employees' feedback in order to make it a better place to work.

SPEAKER_00Great, great insight. Well, just as a hundred percent employee turnover might be a horrible issue, um and and obviously also an indicator of uh of a broken company culture, so of course, too can a hundred percent retention be a sign of broken company culture. And I'm sure we've both seen examples of that. Can you speak to that and expound on what healthy turnover is and why you want it?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a great point. You know, there is there is a healthy turnover number. Um, and you know, I think it's pretty simple. It's it's the fact that, you know, as people grow and mature, their lives change, their goals change, uh, and it's not always going to align with the company that they work with. So um, you know, I would argue at those companies where there's 0% turnover, there's probably a number of people that are still showing up to work, but quit many years ago.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01And are just there because either they're paid too high and they they don't want to leave the money. Um, and so they're just kind of kind of phoning in as so that you know they fly under the radar. Um, maybe there are people that are are actively uh you know searching for a job, but nobody's hiring them for whatever reason. Um, you know, and then I think there are people who um I there are actually people who are like actively disengaged and are like their job is to make uh their work uh worse for everybody else.

SPEAKER_01I mean I I've ran into those people too, you know. You don't want those people sticking around. So um yeah, it it can be unhealthy. Um as far as what a healthy level is, that's gonna depend on the organization. I think that um I think that on a in a really small team with really close-knit relationships, um, you know, small business, maybe a you know, family-run business, something like that, you know, having an annual turnover goal may not be appropriate.

SPEAKER_01You know, it might be like you might expect to see healthy turnover, uh, maybe one person quits every few years. Um so I I would I would I would argue that it's not necessarily applicable uh to look at it on an annual level. In a larger employer, um, you know, I think it it really depends on um on the the situation there. So it you can look at studies. I mean, you know, I've I've had I've seen research studies that say, you know, you should just assume that 10% of your workforce is a bottom performer, and 10% just needs to go, and you just need to, you know, um uh force rank everybody and then the bottom 10% gets gets removed.

SPEAKER_01Um I don't necessarily prescribe to that thinking. I I think that's a little bit uh Machiavellian. And uh, you know, I would I would argue that you know healthy is relative to the organization. But if but if you have people who have already quit and just haven't given you notice yet, uh then you need to facilitate an opportunity for them to go somewhere else in whatever shape that takes.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Have you witnessed examples of where when a broken company culture is being adjusted and transformed, that turnover actually increases during the process before later decreasing?

SPEAKER_01Yes, I have.

SPEAKER_01And so, you know, if I could use an example here, so one of the strategies that we employed uh was an immigrant uh hiring uh approach where we brought in uh we brought in individuals that uh did not speak English as a first language. And so in order to ensure that we could bring people in, train them appropriately, do that in a safe manner, we brought in our local community college to teach English language learning classes on site. Uh, we brought in some trainers that were multilingual that could help uh facilitate the training.

SPEAKER_01You know, we we we layered in this structure to help support these individuals. Um and what we saw was that there was some initial turnover as we started to bring some of these individuals in. And, you know, had you just looked at that on the surface, you would have thought, oh no, this isn't working. We need to abandon this. But what we found out was the root cause of the reason that they were leaving was not the fact that the program was bad. It was the fact that our selection process was off.

SPEAKER_01We weren't giving them a realistic job preview and then giving them an opportunity to either accept or decline. They basically thought that, oh, they just they had to take. Take it because they because we weren't going to listen to them or accept any feedback. Ultimately, by letting them self-select and say, oh, you know what, this isn't for me, we were able to find the individuals that actually stuck around and saw a huge improvement in turnover, but it was a selection process issue. It had nothing to do with the project to impact turnover. And so, you know, before you look at a surface level uh data point, you have to, again, you have to dig a little bit deeper and truly understand, okay, what's the root cause here?

SPEAKER_01I like to use the five Y analysis. It's, you know, it's maybe an overused tool, but it it helps break down that barrier between what's actually happening and what do I think is happening.

SPEAKER_00Uh, yes. In a recent Brain Chatter podcast episode, um, our my guest, our guest was Kelly Caruso, CEO of Shipped. And she, in conversation, told me her most useful question of insight that she asks her direct reports. And her question is, are we solving for the same problem? And of course, her point is that makes everyone define the problem that they're working on uh to make sure that it is in fact the right the same problem. Do you have a most insightful sort of go-to question that you like to ask your team and and the other managers in the organization?

SPEAKER_01Um I do. I don't it's probably not that insightful. Uh I love that question, by the way, because defining the problem is the the first rule and you know fixing a problem. So it makes perfect sense. But I would say, you know, I I maybe I wish I had a better question than this, but the question that people will tell you that I always ask is help me understand. Oh, yes. And it's and it's a lot of times that's in the context of of understanding why a decision was made, um and and then kind of backing into understanding somebody's reasoning and logic.

SPEAKER_01And so um, but help me understand is it's an opportunity to open up the lines of communication and get and and it's you know an active listening technique to actually get to the root of of what the appropriate conversational uh direction is, as opposed to going in and saying, why did you do that? Um you know, it's a very different, different approach. So help me understand would be my would be my approach.

SPEAKER_00That's that's great. And I know you're probably not as uh well, you're not as accustomed to being on the side of the podcast interview that you are today, because you are a podcast host. And thank you so much for changing seats and letting me interview you. Um what made you decide to start your podcast about human resources and are there any great insights you've gained from it already?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, um, yeah, I appreciate you asking the question. And, you know, so the the podcast was really my effort to fill the void uh that that hit me and my extroverted self during uh the quarantine. You know, I I I was missing my my HR network, you know, we weren't having in-person meetings, we were doing some virtual Zoom happy hours, but it just wasn't the same. The the depth of conversation wasn't there. And so this was really a way for for me uh and and some of our local Sherm chapter members to to put our thinking hats on and and facilitate some of that networking in a more structured manner.

SPEAKER_01And really the the intent is to provide a different perspective on the lens of HR, talk to innovators within the space, and just understand uh, you know, how can we all you know kind of find our tribe and continue to support each other uh in a really volatile and disruptive world uh where HR is being asked to step up and do more uh with less. So, you know, that was really the the reason for the podcast.

SPEAKER_01As far as what I've taken away from it, I'll be honest, I feel like I'm learning uh learning more than um than uh than anybody else because I get to have these great conversations with these really great professionals. And I listen to it once when we have the conversation, and then I listen to it twice when I do the editing. So I'm actually retaining some of this uh some of this knowledge. So it's it's been great. It's I feel like I'm back in school.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. I completely understand. And uh just two more questions. Um over the years of your career, are there any resources, whether they're books or periodicals, blogs? Uh obviously, I I know your podcast will it certainly will be one of these. Any other resources that you think are would be really useful to someone who wants to learn more about what we've discussed today?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so um I am uh a Sherm member, and uh Sherm is the uh largest professional network in the world for HR professionals, I think 300,000 plus uh members. They have a lot of great content. Um it's not free, but they do have you know a certain number of free articles uh before you become a member. So you could just you know simply Google uh Google Sherm and Google the topic, and you can typically find an article uh at low cost. I think the other thing too, uh there's a ton of free content out there right now.

SPEAKER_01Um and I I actually uh encourage uh folks to go get connected on LinkedIn with other with HR practitioners and professionals, Twitter. Uh, there's like a whole HR Twitter group uh that I get a lot from. I get I get about just as much from the comments in a LinkedIn post as I do on an on an article uh because I'm hearing somebody else's perspective. So there's a ton out there, um, depending on what you're looking for. Uh and feel free to connect connect with me on LinkedIn and you know, I I connect with anybody.

SPEAKER_01I always I always like to build that network and connect.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And I'll link to your LinkedIn in our episode notes as well. What else should I have asked you but did not? Is there anything else you'd like to offer uh before we go?

SPEAKER_01Hmm. That's a great question. Uh I you know, I think the the only thing that I might add is the fact that while it is very difficult to capture some of the financial ripple effects of turnover, I do think for many organizations, they still need that. They need the dollars and cents, black and white, uh, actuarial value of turnover. And so if you're struggling or you're thinking, well, my organization isn't going to want to do this, um, I would I would challenge you to not ask, just do, and then share your findings.

SPEAKER_01And if they tell you they don't want you to do that anymore, then you can stop then. But I guarantee you, if you go to a a uh a motivated accounting professional and say, hey, I want to try to figure out how much turnover costs, they're gonna love it. It's a fun, it's gonna be a fun project for them, right? Yeah, and uh and a good opportunity to collaborate. So that would be the you know, maybe a call to action for those that are thinking, where do I start?

SPEAKER_00Thank you for your time on the podcast, Kyle. For the convenience of those listening, we're gonna post a link to Kyle's bio, to his LinkedIn, and to more information about Rebel Human Resources Podcast, as well as links to the articles and other resources we discussed. Those can be found online at BrainchatterPodcast.com. Brainchatter is a production of Ken Chapman and Associates Incorporated. We assist clients across North America and beyond with leadership development, corporate culture transformation initiatives, behavior based professional development for health and safety issues, individual and team assessments, conflict and performance management, secession planning, and team building, making a difference in organizations and individuals' lives for almost 40 years.

SPEAKER_00Learn more at leaderscode.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Psychology Behind Loneliness in the Emerging Workforce

    Oct 23, 202616 minAudio

    Loneliness and Anxiety: Are they a key root cause of employee turnover among your younger employees? What do studies show about this? How can this be addressed? In this 16-minute episode, Delcia Petersen explores...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Trust In Two Languages: Leading A Multilingual Workforce

    Jul 27, 202618 minAudio

    What is the connection between being able to communicate with someone and being able to build and maintain trust with that person? How do you overcome or mitigate the challenges related to trust, best effort, safety,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Engage & Retain: What Can You Do?

    May 4, 202625 minAudio

    How can our organization retain our most valuable team members? The costs of turnover are startling and the benefits of key person retention are exponential. In this 23-minute episode, Ryan McShane explores what you or...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How To Get Promoted At Work

    Apr 14, 202628 minAudio

    Getting promoted at work is not always straightforward. In this 28-minute episode, Alisa Patel, a VP of HR, talks candidly about what you need to do in order to be promotable, to learn about opportunities inside your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Effective Workplace Feedback

    Mar 12, 202640 minAudio

    The Effective Workplace Feedback episode of Brain Chatter explores the role of effective feedback in building strong workplace cultures and improving leadership. Organizational psychologist Dr. Ken Chapman, founder of...

    Credit the people on this episode