Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Brain Chatter

Brain Chatter artwork

The Challenge of Change in the Workplace

Oct 29, 202030 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Debra Miller examines why change implemented in the workplace is often difficult, resisted, and costly. She provides a clear 7-step process for leading change management effectively, replete with examples. Where must a leader start? What must be done along the way? Deb is the Managing Principal and Chair of the Board of Ken Chapman & Associates, Inc. She has managed numerous large change initiatives throughout her career. She assists and advises clients on how to map and lead thoughtful change that is manageable, garners faster broad buy-in, and is cost-effective. EPISODE RESOURCES: Deb's Bio Connect with Deb on LinkedIn Ken Chapman & Associates, Inc. Brain Chatter, a podcast where we listen past the daily noise and explore topics at the intersection of leadership, workplace culture, profit, and sustainability.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01But as I learned more about human behavior and how we adapt to change, I've made adjustments in the way that I've approached change, and I've also developed just a little more patience with others as they adapt to change that I initiate.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Brain Chatter. Join us as we explore real life examples of leaders who listen past the daily noise, lead themselves and others with clarity, and make an effective difference on the front lines of leadership in life and work. I'm your host, Derek Brown. Today's guest is Deb Miller, the managing principal of Ken Chapman and Associates Incorporated. Prior to becoming an organizational consultant, Deb enjoyed a career with a large multilocation manufacturing company where she held roles in administration and human resources.

SPEAKER_00And at times, she was charged with leading significant changes within that organization. In our conversation today, we'll be exploring the challenge of change in the workplace. Welcome to Brainchatter, Deb.

SPEAKER_01Thanks, Derek. It's a pleasure to be here.

SPEAKER_00By the way, we will link to any resources mentioned in today's episode in our podcast episode notes, which can be found at BrainchatterPodcast.com. Deb, I think this is a topic that touches every single person listening to this podcast. There are a whole slew of adages in our English language we hear and use about change, such as change is inevitable and the only constant in life is change itself. We all face change in big or little ways every single day.

SPEAKER_00There are changes that I may decide for myself, as small as I'll switch toothpaste brands today. And then there's the change that in one way or another others press upon me without any particular buy-in from me. The famous fiasco on the consumer side is that of Coca-Cola in the late 1980s when they changed from original Coke to new Coke. Of course, it caused an uproar with the people who considered themselves the loyal consumers.

SPEAKER_00So when the newest Microsoft Word version comes out, it's also an example. They change the buttons around, even though the former locations seem to work just fine. And that annoys a lot of users, of course. We often experience change quite differently from change to change and from person to person. So that brings me to my question. Why is it that we experience change so differently? And why does this seem especially true of change in the workplace?

SPEAKER_01Well, Derek, most of us are very comfortable with change as long as it's change that we have initiated. It's those changes initiated by others, and specifically when those changes impact me, which give us some heartburn. You know, I can change the route for my drive to work, but when the Department of Transportation closes a road on my preferred route, I'm very frustrated by that. Human beings are trying to make sense out of things. It's one of those basic needs that we all share in common.

SPEAKER_01And we're trying to understand where we fit. Let's apply that to the workplace. You know, when you fundamentally change the way that people work, it's a big deal. We find safety and comfort in the routines and the normalcy of our work. Now I certainly realize that not all workplaces or all jobs are characterized by routine, and it's a fact that some people seek and even thrive in environments where there's a lot of flexibility and spontaneity each day.

SPEAKER_01However, even in those free-flowing environments, there are things that you can depend on. Things like the relationship that you have with your manager and your team members, uh the confidence you have in your own skill set, and in your ability to get the work done. When any of those things change, discomfort, vulnerability, and even insecurity can result. And most of us are more than a little bit unsettled by those feelings.

SPEAKER_00So what I hear you saying is that in a stress-free world, all change would only be the change I initiated. But on the other hand, in that world, we'd still be driving oxen wagons to work, installing new asbestos shingles with lead paint trim on our houses, and I guess I'd be recording this podcast on a thousand and fifty-seven floppy discs using a rotary phone. So another takeaway I hear from you is that even the change that I do not initiate that may make me uncomfortable can still get me to a much better place.

SPEAKER_00Is that correct?

SPEAKER_01Well, it certainly can, but you have to keep in mind that even positive change can create stress. You know, I'm doubtful anyone wants to return to rotary dial phones, but initially some people were convinced that they were just simply more reliable than touch tone. So not everyone switched at first.

SPEAKER_00That's an interesting point and probably one long forgotten by many people who delayed making that change and now are carrying an iPhone in their pocket. During your career in HR and consulting, you've clearly witnessed a huge amount of change, change implemented by yourself and various others. Would you share some of your experience with both change implementation and change management?

SPEAKER_01Over the course of my career, I've seen an abundance of change. And, you know, some of it was so gradual that it was barely recognizable, and other changes happened immediately and were quite severe. As a leader, I've been responsible for a number of changes, and I've seen it done well and done poorly. I I have to admit that even changes that I initiated that impacted others did not always go well. I've been on both sides of the line. But as I learned more about human behavior and how we adapt to change, I've made adjustments in the way that I've approached change, and I've also developed just a little more patience with others as they adapt to change that I initiate.

SPEAKER_00Could you talk a little bit more about some examples and maybe some takeaways and strategies, both from the times in your career when you've managed change, but also from observations of others and other organizations uh implementing change management uh during your career? And maybe, if you don't mind, share some examples of both the good and the bad.

SPEAKER_01I've definitely seen both cases. Uh a number of years ago, my former company embarked on a comprehensive reorganization of the administrative staff. Uh senior management engaged a management consulting firm who came in and evaluated every function and every position in the organization, and then changes were made based on their recommendations. However, the the reasons for those changes were never appropriately communicated. And furthermore, management rejected some of the consultants' recommendations and either added to or changed others.

SPEAKER_01The result was just a hybrid of chaos. Many of the changes were simply nonsensical. We lost months of productivity while everyone tried to understand and navigate those changes. Plus, we lost some talent as a result. Some positions were eliminated, but other team members were so frustrated they simply left. In the end, a great harm was done to the organization. I still don't understand why an organization will pay for expert advice and then fail to take the recommendations.

SPEAKER_01You know, it's a little bit like going to a physician when you're ill and then refusing to take the prescribed medication. But that's what happened in this case.

SPEAKER_00That does sound like quite an interesting, very unfortunate and quite costly example for the reasons that you indicated. And unfortunately, I think we can all think of examples where a change was implemented without our buy-in and the communication was really awful to the point that people didn't understand why the change was being done in the first place. And as you indicated, people just want to make sense out of things. That's kind of a basic starting point, you would think, with any kind of changes. Here is why we're doing it, here's the purpose, here's what we want to get as a result, because as we know, so often change is not comfortable.

SPEAKER_00And if you're going to have to endure the discomfort you want it to be for a good reason, you also listed out all those costs, the lost talent, the degraded morale, the lost productivity, the lower competitiveness. So, how about an example on the flip side where you've seen change management done especially well, and what did they do to make it go especially well?

SPEAKER_01Well, sure, several years later, I saw the same organization implement a multi-year, multi-million dollar enterprise resource planning system, and they did it very successfully. But by this point in time, there was a different senior management team in place, a different consulting firm was engaged, and a very strategic effort was made to try to involve all team members in the process. The results were entirely different. The project was completed on time and within budget, but more importantly, you know, sales orders were entered, product was shipped, financial reporting was executed without any interruption to the business.

SPEAKER_01Based on the advice of our consulting partners, we had developed a comprehensive change management plan for every phase of the implementation. I can't say we did everything right, but we had a plan and we took into account the human element. We worked the plan and prepared for contingencies. Even though there were significant costs associated with the plan, uh the management team allocated those those costs and was willing to spend the money.

SPEAKER_01You know, when you discount the human beings in any effort, you do so with great peril and you risk the success of the initiative.

SPEAKER_00Well, definitely. As we know all too well, when managers ignore their employees or treat them like robots instead of human beings, or or just as though they can condescend and not include them in the buy-in, that never leads anywhere good. So, based on what you know, if you were talking with the decision maker preparing to implement something new to their team, maybe a new software implementation that you know the rollout's going to be disruptive, or a new reporting structure, whatever it may be, and you could give this decision maker some usable practical advice that would save them a lot of heartache later and maximize their probability of success.

SPEAKER_00Tell me what that advice looks like.

SPEAKER_01Well, sure. I have several suggestions, including some proven strategies that they should consider. Uh, first of all, you you need a change management plan. You you have to have a plan. And as part of that plan, you should be prepared to honor the past, uh, to account for individual receptivity, to over-communicate what you're doing, provide the tools for success, uh, celebrate success along the way, and then finally recognize and reward success when the change is completed.

SPEAKER_00Let's go through each one of those one at a time in more detail. First, say more about develop a plan as a strategy.

SPEAKER_01Well, you have to really think through what you want success to look like and develop a plan that's going to support and lead to that success and allocate the resources to implement it. You know, whatever it costs, it's going to be money well spent. The plan will guide the change to your desired outcome. The change is going to happen anyway, but if you have a plan, if you know where you want to go, the plan can increase the probability of a successful change.

SPEAKER_01And without one, as I said earlier, you risk any anticipated return on your overall investment.

SPEAKER_00The next item on your list is honoring the past. And this does sound a little peculiar on the surface. How does it help people to accept change if you're honoring the past?

SPEAKER_01Well, you don't want to make team members feel like everything they've achieved in the past is now worthless. You want to let them know that you value the past contributions and you look forward to their uh continuing contributions. It's it's their efforts, it's your team's efforts which has brought the organization to where it is and positioned it to leap forward. In the case of a new implementation, you know, it's scary to think about all my skills are now being negated and I'm no longer able to provide value.

SPEAKER_01Uh so you have to acknowledge past efforts and assure them that you're going to help them regain the skills if that's what's necessary in order for them to move forward and continue to be successful.

SPEAKER_00That's logical. The next item you mentioned was account for individual receptivity. Can you explain what you mean by that?

SPEAKER_01Sure. Not not everyone embraces change at the same speed. Uh, just keep in mind that there's there's no system, no process, no organizational structure that is so screwed up that somebody doesn't love it just the way it is. Uh they don't know they love it until you try to change it, and then you find out how very dear it is to them. Uh at the onset of any change initiative, about 20% of your team will be anxious, excited even, and they're ready to go.

SPEAKER_01They they are already with you. In fact, they may have been waiting on you to catch up. Uh, another 20% is at the other end of that spectrum. Uh they don't want to go, and they will stonewall. Not only will they not cooperate with you, they they may really work at trying to undermine whatever it is that the change represents to them. Uh, you may never get their buy-in, no matter what you do. But the remainder of your folks, the majority in the middle of these two extremes, they're gonna most likely develop a wait and see posture.

SPEAKER_01They may be open to the idea of the change, but they need to be convinced. And these are the team members you need to direct your change management efforts toward. You want to communicate with them, explain to them uh everything you can about the change, involve them in the process, and by all means listen to what they tell you because it's it's this group of people that will ultimately determine whether or not the change is going to be successful.

SPEAKER_00I can definitely visualize people I've known during change processes in each of those three categories. I suspect everybody who is listening can also do that. So the next strategy you mentioned is overcommunicate. What do you mean by overcommunicate?

SPEAKER_01Well, a couple of things. Uh, first of all, it it's not enough to tell me what it means for the company. People need to understand their the reasons for the change, how will it affect them, and what exactly is expected of them. You know, the new processor system may be the greatest thing since sliced bread for the company, but I want to know what it means for me, including what I'm going to need to do to be successful after the change. What's that gonna look like? Uh second, don't think that you can say what you're communicating only once.

SPEAKER_01In the ERP project I referenced earlier, for example, part of the communication plan was to produce a video message from the company president that would be shown to every employee at every location. And he wrote his own script for that message and he did a terrific job delivering it. But the communication plan called for that message, or at least a portion of it, to be communicated periodically through a variety of mediums. So in month two, I went to him with a memo that I had drafted for his signature to go in the company newsletter, and he flatly refused.

SPEAKER_01He said, I've already told him that, and and that was the end of the story with him. He was not going to do it again.

SPEAKER_00This does not seem logical to me, especially since there was already a plan to have multiple touches over time. What do you believe was his rationale for responding in that way where he basically said, I did it once and that's enough?

SPEAKER_01You know, I think he fell into the trap that a lot of senior leaders fall into, and they think because they're the president or the CEO and that they've said something once, it it should be enough. Uh, but it's simply not. Uh think of the average commercial spot on television or radio. They are designed to run multiple times because we simply don't hear them the first time. We don't really begin to listen until we've heard something the second or third time.

SPEAKER_01And it may be the fourth or fifth time before I assimilate what I've heard and it actually changes my behavior. Think about it this way: when you've heard that commercial for the 20th time, finally you've got to have that Big Mac, or maybe I do want to go look at a new car. It's it's the repetition that kind of anchors it in your mind.

SPEAKER_00Well, sure. This is especially interesting because anyone acquainted with sales and marketing knows that best practices state that for all products and services, a multi-touch approach with the buyer is imperative. It speaks simply to how human nature is wired and the way our brains work. And that's why when I Google six-foot ladder or I click on an ad for an air fryer, I see ladder ads and air fryer ads on every website I visit for the next four weeks or so.

SPEAKER_00It just makes total sense that when you're selling a team on a needed change, it would also require multiple touches of the message. People don't leave their human nature in the parking lot at work before they come in the door. So, anyway, thank you for sharing that. And the next strategy you mentioned is provide the tools for success. Tell me more about what you mean by tools for success.

SPEAKER_01Well, whether it's training or equipment or providing feedback, uh, you need to be prepared to uh provide for the team what is needed for their continued success. You want to let them know that you're willing to invest in their success and then follow through with that promise. Remember, whatever the change is, it it was your idea, not their idea. So they will be a lot more comfortable with the change if you commit to them that you will provide whatever it is that they need in order to adapt and continue to be successful.

SPEAKER_00I can certainly see how implementing change could quickly be undermined by not making sure that everybody has what they need to access success, not to mention that it would just simply be unfair. Okay, the next strategy is celebrate success along the way. And again, on the surface, this one sounds a little perplexing. Why would you not simply wait until the end after you have gotten everybody fully on board and the change has been fully successfully adopted and then celebrate?

SPEAKER_01You can't wait for the moment that the change is fully implemented, especially if it's a year-long or an 18-month-long process. People simply get discouraged. If if it's a large system implementation, for example, uh people are already doing extra work trying to keep the existing systems running and take care of the business while at the same time they're doing the things that are needed to implement the new system. It can just simply be overwhelming, and after a while, fatigue sets in.

SPEAKER_01So if you want to boost enthusiasm and encourage continued commitment along the way, you need to look for milestones that you can celebrate. You don't want to lose that your momentum before you get to the finish line.

SPEAKER_00I see what you're saying now, and this leads into the last strategy that you mentioned, which is recognize and reward success. Is this not the same as celebrating success along the way, though?

SPEAKER_01Well, it it is and it isn't. Celebrations are for everyone, everybody that's on the team. But rewards should be directed to those who've actually created the success. And you've asked them for some extraordinary effort. So you should look for some ways to recognize that effort. And it doesn't have to be a monetary award, but certainly if your business plan can accommodate a financial incentive plan, it's not a bad idea. I do suggest some caution when implementing a financial reward system.

SPEAKER_01However, again, it does not have to be financial. My experience, rather, is people. People want to know they are valued and appreciated. It's the other basic human need that we all share in common. We we simply want to know that we have value. So if you acknowledge the team member's role in the success, it goes a long way. Uh a team member told me recently, you know, we don't need a parade or even a steak dinner. I just like to hear I'm doing a good job occasionally.

SPEAKER_01Sad, isn't it? Uh leaders are too quick to point out a person's shortcomings, but not always equally generous with positive feedback. I often hear from leaders that say something like, Well, that's what they're paying to do, and yes, it is what they're being paid to do. But we all want to know that someone has noticed that we're doing a good job and appreciates our effort.

SPEAKER_00Well, sure. So why does change management often go so poorly? It's not like change itself is anything new to any of us, and it's not like we haven't all seen change fail very badly at various points, probably close to us and from a distance. So why don't more people follow some sort of logical protocol like you just outlined instead of just plowing into it and crashing?

SPEAKER_01It's baffling, I know. Organizations spend millions of dollars implementing changes from technology to organizational restruction to even branding, and never consider the human impacts. The best answer I have is it it's work. And leaders are so often focused on the change, whatever the change is, that they forget it's the humans who will determine whether or not the initiative will be successful. Dealing with all of the human aspects, well, you know, it's just really work.

SPEAKER_01It requires emotionally intelligent leadership. And as any HR professional will tell you, the soft stuff really is the hard stuff.

SPEAKER_00Uh yeah, for sure. Here's a scenario. What about someone who is in an organization and they've been tapped to be part of some sort of change rollout, and yet they see their manager about to make a big mistake? Maybe their manager is prepared to surprise the organization with the change because the manager thinks, well, that way it'll get less resistance, there'll be less whining, and I really don't need the impact. Um I'm sorry, I really don't need the feedback from the people on the front lines anyway.

SPEAKER_00I know how this business works. I have seen some change rolled out this way. I know you have as well, and as we both know, it is cringe worthy for all involved from day one. So if this, let's say it's a good willed, uh good and well-intentioned team member, and they're in this situation, they can foresee what's going to happen with this kind of strategy or lack of strategy, and they want to help their manager understand the pitfalls, uh, avoid the pitfalls and the costs that come with that by having a change rollout done so poorly.

SPEAKER_00How can that person help the manager uh counsel the manager in in a respectful way about the wisdom of doing it more along the lines that you've discussed instead of sort of a uh just barreling out like a a surprise tank or something?

SPEAKER_01Well, I I think that's going to depend on whether or not there is mutual trust between that team member and his or her manager. You know, do they have the kind of relationship where they freely exchange information on a give and take basis? Uh if not, uh chances are they're not going to build that relationship in this instance. But if they've built the speed of trust into their relationship, it certainly provides the platform for sharing helpful information, even when maybe it's difficult to say what needs to be said.

SPEAKER_00You just mentioned the speed of trust. Would you mind defining that, please?

SPEAKER_01Well, sure. The speed of trust exists when I've assumed responsibility for earning your trust. And you've also assumed responsibility for earning my trust. And when we've built the speed of trust together, we're able to meet challenges with ease and efficiency. In those circumstances, we don't waste any time trying to decide whether or not you're looking out for my best interest or whether you've got some sort of hidden agenda.

SPEAKER_01We simply move forward and address the issue, we tackle the problem head on, and when we're able to do that, everything takes less time, it costs less money, and morale is usually higher. And morale is higher because I don't have to spend my time and energy watching my back. I I know that you and I trust each other, we have each other's best interest at heart, we're both interested in doing what's best for the team and for the organization.

SPEAKER_00It sounds like what you're saying is that how well change management occurs and how likely a team member is to reach up to a leader to successfully prevent failure of change management has more than a little to do with the organization's culture. Would you like to speak to that for a moment?

SPEAKER_01Oh, you're absolutely right, Derek. You know, almost everything comes down to the organization's culture. But a culture that's based on mutual respect and trust really is a competitive advantage. And the best organizations understand that and they invest in creating it. That type of culture is also a great foundation for any change process. You know, when team members believe that they are valued, that their input matters, that they are respected as individuals as well as for the work they do, they are much more likely to buy into the initiative.

SPEAKER_01In that kind of culture, the change initiative will be viewed as a partnership between the team members and leadership. And ideally, the change is not seen as something that's being imposed on me. It's something we're doing together for the good of the team and for the sustainability of the business.

SPEAKER_00Deb, you've shared a lot of great and practical information. So now, what have I forgotten to ask you? What else can you leave us with?

SPEAKER_01Well, we've covered the basics. Uh, change is inevitable in all aspects of life and work, just as we we said at the beginning of the conversation. Much of it is beyond our immediate control. However, we can always control our response to it. The best leaders build the kind of relationships with their team that makes it easy for team members to choose a response that is in their own best interest and in the best interest of the organization.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for your time on the podcast, Deb. For the convenience of those listening, we're going to post a link to your bio and to your LinkedIn account where they can connect with you if they like. And we'll also post information on any other resources mentioned during today's podcast at BrainchatterPodcast.com. Brainchatter is a production of Ken Chapman and Associates, Inc. We assist clients across North America and beyond with leadership development, corporate culture transformation initiatives, behavior based professional development for health and safety issues, individual and team assessments, conflict and performance management, succession planning, and team building, making a difference in organizations and individuals' lives for almost 40 years.

SPEAKER_00Learn more at Leaderscode.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Psychology Behind Loneliness in the Emerging Workforce

    Oct 23, 202616 minAudio

    Loneliness and Anxiety: Are they a key root cause of employee turnover among your younger employees? What do studies show about this? How can this be addressed? In this 16-minute episode, Delcia Petersen explores...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Trust In Two Languages: Leading A Multilingual Workforce

    Jul 27, 202618 minAudio

    What is the connection between being able to communicate with someone and being able to build and maintain trust with that person? How do you overcome or mitigate the challenges related to trust, best effort, safety,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Engage & Retain: What Can You Do?

    May 4, 202625 minAudio

    How can our organization retain our most valuable team members? The costs of turnover are startling and the benefits of key person retention are exponential. In this 23-minute episode, Ryan McShane explores what you or...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How To Get Promoted At Work

    Apr 14, 202628 minAudio

    Getting promoted at work is not always straightforward. In this 28-minute episode, Alisa Patel, a VP of HR, talks candidly about what you need to do in order to be promotable, to learn about opportunities inside your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Effective Workplace Feedback

    Mar 12, 202640 minAudio

    The Effective Workplace Feedback episode of Brain Chatter explores the role of effective feedback in building strong workplace cultures and improving leadership. Organizational psychologist Dr. Ken Chapman, founder of...

    Credit the people on this episode