Have you been diagnosed with hEDS and have a variety of neurological symptoms and findings? Maybe you struggle with: chronic fatigue, brain fog, headaches/migraines, dizziness, light/noise sensitivity and more. Your imaging suggest chiari malformation or cranio-cervical instability. A recent research article is proposing for a new subtype to hEDS, known as Neuro-EDS. This is meant to better capture what is happening. To learn more about our approach to EDS: https://peakbrainandbody.com/conditions/eds/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Have you been diagnosed with hypermobile Ellers Danlow syndrome, but yet you notice you have a lot of neurological based symptoms and findings? Let's look at one of the newest research articles. This is actually still in preprint. This is a concept paper on Neuro EDS, which is proposed to be a subtype of hypermobile Ellers-Danlow syndrome. So we are going to dissect this research paper, explain what it means. We're going to go over what I consider the strengths of it, and it starts off with a lot of strengths, but then we're going to discuss where there's still a lot of questions that really need to be answered in this arena.
SPEAKER_00So when we start off, we look at this, right? There is a subgroup of those within the hypermobile Elders Damlo Syndrome who have neurological manifestations that go far beyond just hypermobility and musculoskeletal involvement, right? So some people, their predominant thing is, hey, I can dislocate stuff easily. I'm super hypermobile. But then there's others where there's things beyond that in the neurological spectrum, which we will get into what that looks like. But it's broken down into craniospinal findings, autonomic, neurovascular, inflammatory, and neuropathic disorders.
SPEAKER_00While these are all being recognized more frequently in those with hypermobile allergy and low syndrome, they point out something super important. They continue to be evaluated largely as isolated diagnoses, leaving a clinically meaningful subgroup embedded within broad and heterogeneous hypermobile allergy and lose syndrome populations. Now, one of the things you're going to see is they talk about interconnectedness and not doing things in isolation because one of the big things that I see in my clinic is people come in and like I've got diagnosed with this, I've got diagnosed with this and this.
SPEAKER_00And no one is really looking at the bigger picture of how these are connected. People are looking from a treatment perspective, each thing in isolation, versus how they all work together. So that's gonna be a big thing as we look at this. Now, what they do propose is neuro EDS actually has two interconnected clinical manifestations. They've got one that they call the cranial and spinal domain. This is gonna be more about findings on specific types of imaging, but we are going to look at what they talk about, the issues with imaging, and then they've got a broader that they call the neuroautonomic inflammatory domain, which we'll go into what they consider that as well.
SPEAKER_00So here's one of the big graphics, okay, um, that they have really well done. They talk about the overlapping features, they talk about the issues, right? Neurological manifestations are also often viewed as isolated diagnoses, and they include a wide variety of things in here, such as Arnold Chiari malformation, craniocervical instability, and much more.
SPEAKER_00So, what do we see here? And this part is really good in here, so I really need you to pay attention. This subgroup they develop complex neurological presentations instead of an isolated neurological diagnoses, right? So we already talked about don't do things in isolation, look at how things are connected together. Okay, now there are issues arising in the setting of interacting structural pathology, so there may be structural stuff, combined with dysregulation of your physiology, so the processes in the body, including the brain, and metabolic dysfunction, how well cells are producing and using energy.
SPEAKER_00Okay, these patients with this subgroup of hypermobile allergies download syndrome have a higher likelihood of having cranial, spinal, neurovascular disorders. And what's super important here is this appears disproportionate to the degree of generalized joint hypermobility, musculoskeletal improvement involvement alone. So, as we said at the beginning, some people have way more musculoskeletal issues, right?
SPEAKER_00And then there's those who are like, well, I mean, maybe I, you know, yeah, I mean, I've got hypermobility, but that's not my issue. My issue is my dizziness, my severe light noise sensitivity, and all that. Now, super important to understand this, okay? Um, many of these findings appear anatomically discordant, radiographically unexplained, or diagnostically fragmented through conventional imaging paradigms or disease-specific frameworks.
SPEAKER_00And this should provide you a lot of hope. Okay, it's gonna be frustrating, but it should be hopeful because it says radiographically unexplained, which they'll talk about more later. It's they know based off their observations that regular conventional imaging, the way that we are testing for stuff, the way we've been taught to step test for stuff, is not sufficient for this population and it's going to miss stuff.
SPEAKER_00Now, it does ask that we view these issues through the lens of connective tissue biology, not just cranial and spinal biomechanics, cerebral spinal fluid issues, venous outflow, right? So arteries bring blood to the brain, veins bring it out, peripheral nerve issues, autonomic regulation, these seemingly separate manifestations are understood as interconnected expressions of a common underlying disease process versus treating everything in isolation.
SPEAKER_00Because when you do, you end up with fragmented multidisciplinary care and inconsistent referral patterns. So we need this because it promotes you know it's going to help with these issues they're talking about, right? Because not doing this appropriately, it's going to promote inatten inappropriate attribution of systems to functional or psychiatric disorders, under recognition of treatable craniospinal pathology, and missed opportunities for patient stratification.
SPEAKER_00So basically, hey, here's where you really need to go. Instead of saying all hyperimobile elder standow syndrome patients go here, they're saying, no, no, no. If you have certain subtype, right, if you have the neuro EDS subtype, here's actually things that should be considered. So you're actually gonna be better suited with this type of referral. And we all know the biggest issues, not just in the Ellers Danlos community, but it's also in the pots, the myogic encephalomyelitis, it's the overattribution of your symptoms to mental health.
SPEAKER_00So, oh well, you've just got anxiety, you've got depression, you have FND. It's like, well, yeah, I may be depressed, but I'm depressed because no one's listening to me, or I may have anxiety because I'm not sure if I'm ever gonna get my life back. Also, my medical bills are picking up, you know, and I'm trying to figure out how I'm gonna live. So, yes, but let's not gaslight people. And then it talks about how medicine advances, medicine advances through observation, right? Once you observe enough, you start saying, Oh, let's piece this together, right?
SPEAKER_00So, and they even acknowledge that we may not understand it all up front, right? So you have to observe something first, and then it's like that's interesting that it's clustered that way. Now we need to understand why it's clustered that way, right? So you first cluster it, then you seek to understand why it's clustered that way.
SPEAKER_00And then from there you can progress. Now, what they've noticed, okay, um, you know, that there are you know, many things here in this arena, okay? There's increased understanding of biodynamic effects of hypermobility on the nervous system, emerging molecular and cellular insights to really look at this.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Um, we've already talked about it. It's important to have a subset because this subset is going to allow people to really get the help they need in a way that they're not going to. And as they say, by examining how these features cluster and interact, network medicine offers an approach to understanding complex multi-system disorders beyond traditional diagnosis. And we should look at all these as a whole. So now, when we look at neuroeds, right, they basically break it down and they start saying, What are we seeing, right?
SPEAKER_00So, one of the first things they're going to look at is the craniospinal issues. We know based off some of the research that there is a higher prevalence of type 1 QR malformation, craniocervical instability, tethered cord syndrome, styloid hypertrophy, cerebrospinal fluid links, dysotonomia, MCAS, and others in those with hypermobile Ellers-Danlow syndrome. And then they state that there is a frequent co-occurrence of cranial cervical instability and teller tethered cord syndrome, which they say is unified craniospinal phenotype characterized by overlapping cervical medullary, so up at the top, versus lumbosacral down at your low back.
SPEAKER_00And then it's important when they look at the tethered cord, radiographically occult, tethered cord syndrome and dynamic cranial cervical instability may evade detection using conventional static supine imaging, so that's laying down, underscoring the limitations of traditional structural diagnostic paradigms in this population. And this is where you'll see a lot of people like hey, if you think you have chiari malformation, you may actually have to do it standing up. But even then, right, there needs to be even positional dependent.
SPEAKER_00Because one of the big things a lot of people tell me is, sure, I was fine when you did my testing, but that also isn't the position I have my issues in. So, like, if I'm bending down and if you can capture that, you now are gonna get a representation of maybe what I feel and see if it matches, not a hey, let's just have you laid down and see if everything looks good. Because you can't test people in an ideal environment. You have to test people in a place where they say the weakness and the symptoms occur.
SPEAKER_00Now, what do we know? Um, compared to a general population, individuals with hypermobile allergic download syndrome have disproportionately increased rates of likely chiari malformation. Now, once again, it is important to understand that Chiari type 1 is the most common type. It's usually considered benign, which means it's not going to impact most people. So we need to understand that having this finding does not mean it's your issue. Okay, it does not automatically make it your issue.
SPEAKER_00Now, it doesn't make it not your issue, but this is where you have to take imaging findings in conjunction with symptoms, history, etc. Don't take anything in isolation. If you do, you're likely going to be frustrated. They also talk about cerebral spinal fluid leaks, tether cord, intracranial hypotension, trigeminal neuralgia, peripheral neuropathic, and more. So, how does you know this stuff work?
SPEAKER_00So, when we look at craniospinal, I'm just gonna quickly work through these. You can have craniocervical instability, so you've got ligaments that are a little bit more lax, and so your ligaments they act as a safety check, right? So anytime you move, the primary stabilizers of a joint, it is your muscles. But if your muscles are not activating in the way they should, to prevent too much movement, your ligaments are there as that safety. Now, if those don't develop appropriately, they've been impacted because of trauma, immune, or whatever, then now of a sudden you're doing certain movements, your vertebrae are gonna slide further than they should, creating issues.
SPEAKER_00CR malformation, we talked about already, stringomyelia. This is something that can occur in the spinal cord, causes pain syndrome, tethered cord, intracranial hypertension. So a lot of people are diagnosed with idiopathic intracranial hypertension. Um, then they have intracranial hypotension and spontaneous CSF leaks, jugular outflow, styloid that could compress, and then eagle syndrome.
SPEAKER_00Now they say there's different reasons why this stuff could develop, okay? Part of it, there's new evidence um implicating extracellular matrix organization. So extracellular matrix is basically scaffolding for cells, organization remodeling, the cell matrix interactions, fibroblast behavior, part of the immune response, inflammatory immune signaling. This can all influence all of us. Now, once again, um, tethered cord, there's classic and occult, occult presentations characterized by compatible clinical features, despite a normal position, conus medularis on conventional imaging.
SPEAKER_00So you may still have this despite having normal imaging, and this is why they talk about it's important to understand the biomechanical properties and how to really evaluate that. Cranial cervical instability, they consider a central component of the cranial and spinal domain. Now it is important when we look at cranial cervical instability. I found a couple research papers. One was looking at, you know, how much this one person was seeing in their clinic. Basically, everyone had it, but they didn't publish on the here's the outcomes of treatment.
SPEAKER_00And then there was someone else that did craniocervical instability and actually went and did surgery. When you look at the outcomes of that, let's say the average person, and it was about this, you know, they were like an eight out of ten for pain and many of their other symptoms, they came down on average to a six out of ten. So I don't want to knock the improvement because it definitely existed, but this means you're gonna have people who saw really good results, you're gonna have people who saw no results, and you may even have people who it made worse.
SPEAKER_00Um, but I think that's also why we look at the interconnectedness of these diagnoses, and we don't say, hey, craniocervical instability or chiari on its own has to explain it all. This is part of a bigger interconnected picture that if we address this more completely, maybe getting craniocervical instability allows something else to work. We're already talking about chiari, we've talked about all of those, okay. Um, now what I do want to point out is one of the weaknesses in here is a lot of these are going to be some of these are case studies where it's just isolated individuals.
SPEAKER_00The other thing is observations of hey, you know what, we saw this in our clinic, but what we don't have a lot of is treatment outcomes, right? So if someone has Eagle syndrome, then what's the outcome if they have this surgically addressed? Or if someone has a venous outflow issue, what's the outcome, right? There's there's a lot of thoughts about what is happening in this community, but we don't have the research that shows us the outcome of the treatments, and that is actually the most important thing that we really need.
SPEAKER_00Because if we really want to say these are meaningful findings in those with neuro EDS, then we have to know that when it gets addressed, they are going to see improvement. Because what's happening is because there's a lack of awareness, there's not enough money behind it, we are grabbing things diagnostically, and we're like, hey, here's what we're finding. And then people are like, Oh, this is what they found in me.
SPEAKER_00Awesome, I have an answer, but then when people go and get it treated, the outcomes of treatment are just all over the place, and we need to get to a place where we can understand if this is found, what is the probability someone improves? I know no surgeries are perfect, I know no treatments I do are perfect, right? I don't claim to help 100% of people either, but I can satisfy my patient and say, hey, this is the likelihood something's gonna improve based upon the findings I'm seeing.
SPEAKER_00And how am I picking out who's likely gonna improve versus not? And we need to be there with this stuff too, not just say, hey, you know what, it's off. Um, it's worth doing surgery or another procedure. Now, on the other side, you have the neuroautonomic inflammatory domain. They don't really talk about this a lot, but basically they say neuroautonomic inflammatory. This includes any types of dysautonomia. So this may include POTS, orthostatic intolerance. You may have the results of dysautonomia that causes gastrointestinal dysmotility.
SPEAKER_00A lot of people have issues with temperature regulation. While most people are not gonna like warm weather, there's also those who do not like cold weather. Basically, anything that causes your system to have to better regulate is going to demand more energy. And if you have autonomic dysfunction, that's gonna be harder to do. There's also plenty of people who do have urinary dysfunction, some people have interstitial cystitis, there are those who get frequent UTIs, and the list goes on and on. You also see a decent overlap between hypermobile allergic dancelose syndrome and those with immune system issues, such as mast cell activation syndrome.
SPEAKER_00You may have an increase of neuropathy and neuropathic pain, whether this is autoimmune or not. We do see increased headache prevalence in the allergy dance community, sleep, cognitive issues, so brain fog, word finding, attention concentration. There's some links between ADHD, autism, what's happening in the brain, and EDS as well, chronic fatigue, exercise intolerance, even to the level that it's post-exertional malaise, and you may meet criteria for myelgic encephalomyelitis.
SPEAKER_00Now, these things can coexist together, and it's important to understand that there's an overlap, right? What they say is you can have the autonomic issues as a result of the craniospinal pathology, which is true, okay, but not all craniospinal pathology is going to cause it, and this is where I really do caution about latching on to a single diagnostic, okay, because I can't tell you how often I see patients, they come into my clinic, they've been diagnosed with all sorts of stuff, they've done all sorts of stuff, and I'm always like, Well, what's helping you?
SPEAKER_00It's where I talk to other experts. I'm like, look, what's the outcomes when some of these procedures are done? Because people are desperate, they want answers, they want solutions, they're willing to undergo any procedure necessary, but we do owe them, and we need to get to that point in the next hopefully five years, um, ten years tops, hopefully. We'll see. But we need to get to the point where we can truly stratify and say, hey, based upon your exam findings, this is the type of imaging you need, and the based upon your history and everything else, this is actually worth going after and surgically doing.
SPEAKER_00And this is not worth surgically doing. Because right now, what is it? You've got certain clinics are like, boom, I'm all things, you know, cranial cervical instability from an injection standpoint. I'm all things cranial cervical instability from a chiropractic standpoint, I'm all things chiari from a cervical, you know, from a surgical standpoint, I'm all things spinal fluid leaks, right? And then you have those who rave about those clinics, and then you have those who are like, I went there and it did nothing.
SPEAKER_00And we also have to be careful about unnecessary surgeries until we can truly say who benefits. We know that surgeries act as a trigger for dysautonomia, and there's a lot of people who developed it after surgery, so that is the ultimate progression that we need to, and the whole purpose of this is to give a new framework, not to create a new disease that didn't exist, and to allow people to not only be better understood, but to get sent to the right places and ultimately get the right treatment.
SPEAKER_00So I hope this paper helps you understand a little bit more about the neuroeds framework, why it matters, who it applies to, because this is not meant to apply to everyone with hypermobile Eller's Danlow syndrome. Um, there was a spot in the research paper where I believe it was about 10 to 15 percent of those with hypermobile. So you're not trying to fit, you're fitting because you fit, not because you need a place that resonates, and that's another thing important to understand because that's also creating a too much frustration in this community.
SPEAKER_00It's wanting to have an answer, so sometimes we're we're really stretching to give someone a diagnosis that they shouldn't necessarily be getting. So I hope you found this useful. Um, please comment, like, and share this with other people. That is the way we grow, that's the way we continue to help more people and provide education. And lastly, if you'd like to work with me, my clinic is Peak Brain and Body, located near Tampa. I'm Dr. Zimmerman, I'm a dual licensed nurse practitioner and doctor of chiropractic.
Post-exertional malaise is the hallmark feature of myalgic encephalomyelitis. It can occur for a variety of reasons, including infections such as COVID. While we are still trying to understand exactly what's driving...
Unexplained symptoms across multiple body systems, normal labs, and a doctor who says you look fine? Mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS) may be part of the answer, and most clinicians were never taught to look for it....
Mast Cell Activation Syndrome, while still relatively unknown, is likely massively underdiagnosed. In this episode, I explore: What Mast Cell Activation Syndrome is The diagnostic criteria of Consensus 1 vs 2 Natural...
What happens when a physician develops long COVID and finds herself struggling to get the medical system to understand what she’s experiencing? In this episode of Brain Body Reset, I’m joined by internal medicine...
If you have POTS, you’ve probably heard conflicting explanations for your symptoms, each presented as the answer. How do you sort through the noise and figure out what actually applies to you? In this episode of Brain...