Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Bobby Owsinski's Inner Circle Podcast

Bobby Owsinski's Inner Circle Podcast artwork

Mixerman REVEALS Exactly How to Make Musical Decisions First | Ep. 651

Nov 17, 202637 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Producers and engineers: Eric "Mixerman" Sarafin explains how Hurricane Helene stranded him in Asheville and pushed him to finally write his producing book. The book centers on one principle: get musical decisions right before touching the engineering. Arrangement choices shape the frequency landscape far more than EQ ever can. Bobby and Eric also cover selling his SSL bus compressor after 20-plus years, Dutch and Dutch cardioid monitors, and why he calls Atmos a failed bet for music listeners. You can also hear more from Eric on Episode 162. LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/eric-sarafin-8462ab17/ Twitter / X: https://x.com/mixerman Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/eric.sarafin/ Website: https://mixerman.net Audible Author Page: https://www.audible.com/author/Mixerman/B001QV42EW Book, Zen and the Art of Mixing (Tape Op Review): https://tapeop.com/reviews/gear/83/zen-and-the-art-of-mixing-book Resource, Dutch & Dutch Speakers: https://dutchanddutch.com #MusicProduction #RecordingEngineer #MusicProducerTips #MixermanProducingBook #BobbyOwsinski Chapters: 00:00:00 - Coming up... 00:01:01 - How Hurricane Helene devastated Asheville's music scene 00:03:30 - Asheville vs. Los Angeles: two completely different music cultures 00:05:52 - Building the best mixing room of his career 00:10:31 - Why he went 100% in the box and sold his analog gear 00:11:45 - Why sidechaining and gates create more problems than they solve 00:19:42 - His take on Dolby Atmos and why it will never work for music 00:24:15 - Where AI mixing tools actually help and where they fall short 00:27:09 - What his new producing book is really about 00:30:06 - Why musical decisions matter more than any engineering fix 00:34:03 - The best advice he ever received Thank you for tuning in to Bobby Owsinski’s Inner Circle, the podcast that takes you deep inside the music industry. Each week, Bobby shares insights, news, analysis, and conversations with the movers and shakers shaping today’s music world. 📌 Explore Bobby’s best-selling books: https://sholink.to/bobbyowsinskibooks 📘 The Mixing Engineer’s Handbook (6th Edition), the go-to guide for nailing that polished, pro mix sound: https://sholink.to/themixingengineershandbook 🎙️Nail that pro vocal sound: clear, upfront, and mix-ready. Learn how in Bobby’s Vocal Mixing Mini-Course: https://sholink.to/vocalmixingcourse 🎧 Discover more mixing and production courses: https://sholink.to/bobbyowsinski 📲 Follow Bobby for more tips, insights, and updates: • Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/BobbyOwsinskiBiz/ • LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/bobbyo/ • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bobbyowsinski/ • Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/bobbyowsinski.bsky.social 🎙️ New episodes release every Tuesday at 9AM Pacific on YouTube and your favorite podcast app. Music. Business. Creativity. Straight from the Inner Circle. Produced by APodcastGeek https://itl.ink/APodcastGeek Ad Link: Explore The Mixing Engineer's Answer Book, 50 Essential Questions About Mixing Answered. Ad link: Explore The Mixing Engineer’s Handbook (6th Edition), the go-to guide for modern mixing. Thank you for tuning in to Bobby Owsinski’s Inner Circle, the podcast that takes you deep inside the music industry. Each week, Bobby shares insights, news, analysis, and conversations with the movers and shakers shaping today’s music world. 📌 Explore Bobby’s best-selling books 🎙️ Nail that pro vocal sound: clear, upfront, and mix-ready. Learn how in Bobby’s Vocal Mixing Mini-Course 🎧 Discover more mixing and production courses 📲 Follow Bobby for more tips, insights, and updates: Facebook LinkedIn Instagram Bluesky 🎙️ New episodes release every Tuesday at 9AM Pacific on YouTube and your favorite podcast app. Music. Business. Creativity. Straight from the Inner Circle. Produced by APodcastGeek: https://itl.ink/APodcastGeek

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI'm known as an engineer. Uh I've always approached the engineering from the musical side, and just from doing it for 40 years you learn it. The more I learn it, the more useless I think of it.

Bobby OwsinskiThat's Eric Biksterman Steraphim, an engineer, mixer, and author with 40 years of experience. Sold the top board gear, moved entirely into the box, and rejected popular mixing techniques. After four decades, he's convinced that better records start with better musical decisions and not more processing.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI don't want to use anything that's an automatic process if I can avoid it in a mix, because it only causes me problems. I'd rather I don't use gates at all. Never use a gate.

Bobby OwsinskiAfter 40 years behind the console, he's learned that the biggest mixing problems often start with the music itself and not the equipment. In this episode, you hear why he abandoned analog mixing gear, why he believes popular mixing techniques can create more problems than they solve, and why getting the musical decisions right can make most engineering fixes unnecessary. Stick around, I'm Bobby Osinski, and this is my Inner Circle Podcast. What is the music scene like in Asheville? Especially these days, because Asheville, you know, went through some bad times there for a second.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinIt's in rough shape. If I had to depend on my income on Asheville, I would have moved because it was devastating, the hurricane. I was here alone during it. There was damage to my house, and I'm up. I'm up on a mountain. So I didn't have the flooding, thank God. But, you know, I'm surrounded by trees. There were a lot of trees that fell in the neighborhood. And the bars, like a lot of bars, a lot of restaurants, they had to close because there was no water for months, you know, tap water. So the ones that did stay in business were actually importing their water, and that was eating into their profits, and and the bars just a lot of the bars were closed, so now there was less opportunity for players to play, and it's still pretty bad.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinHelene happened, and I thought to myself, I'm not going to get any work from Asheville for the foreseeable future. And I knew it immediately when I saw the aftermath of it. And that's when I'm like, okay, I've been putting off my producing book for like four years now. So this is probably the time for me to do it because, you know, it's not an enormous chunk of my income, Asheville local stuff, but it's big enough, you know, where I knew I needed to make up that ground and make up that time.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI'd have time, more time available. So that's when I decided to write uh Richard Man's Ultimate Guide to Producing Records, Music, and Songs. So but yeah, it's still it's still, I don't think it's recovered yet.

Bobby OwsinskiWe'll get into the book in a second. So the music scene then really took a bad hit, I guess. And Asheville was pretty good before that.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinIt's a little weird. You know, there's a lot of venues for people to play, but it I don't pay a lot. So there's a lot of musicians in town. They're in like five, six, seven bands, and you know, that's the game. And the ones that successful musicians and artists in this town, generally, this is just a hub for them. You have a lot of access to a to like a lot of cities from here. Atlanta is close, Charlotte. Uh, it's not that far to get to Washington. You can get up to New York, you can get down to Florida, all you know.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinSo it's a very good location centrally if you want to tour and you want to just use this as your home base. So, you know, it didn't change for that, for those people.

Bobby OwsinskiCan you contrast it to Los Angeles? I mean, Los Angeles is a different animal completely, but I'm just curious how how different in your eyes.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI don't know. Los Angeles is such an enigma because the music business is there, and so everything's just completely distorted. Bands are basically being put together purely for getting a deal, and artists, you know, a lot of people are trying to get deals, so a lot of the shows are for that, and so it's it's just a completely different scene. It's a l- it's way more just down home regular people and uh performing. They're not trying to to get deals, and so it's considerably different in that way.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinMore for a tourism economy, you know?

Bobby OwsinskiHave you ever noticed that mixing vocals is often the hardest part of getting a track to sound right? You boost, you compress, you add effects, and it still doesn't feel professional. So to make it easier, I put together a simple mini course on vocal mixing that walks you through the exact steps to get the vocal sounding clear and upfront. If you're interested, scan the QR code on screen or click the link in the show notes. Now, back to today's conversation. There's a purity once you get outside of LA and New York for that matter, and Nashville even too. There's a purity in music.

Bobby OwsinskiAnd one of the things that I've seen is uh, you know, bands that talk about, well, we've been playing since we've been in grade school, you know, in high school, we've been playing together. Or, you know, it's one of these things where people people are good friends because they're friends and they play music and one of those things. And that you don't see in the bigger cities, unfortunately. And I think that that really is takes away a lot from the the vibe, the positive vibe from music.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinFor sure. Yeah, it's a whole other thing. It's like you I it's difficult to even explain to someone who's not in it. Because it just has a thing about it, LA does. And I don't know. You know, a lot of time LA is more about being seen, you know, just in general, no matter who you are, and that that's always present. And so, like, you know, you're at a show, okay, who's watching me? Whether I'm moving to this act right now, and it's just very contrived and weird and plastic.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinAll the things that people complain about LA, like, it's encapsulated in that experience, really.

Bobby OwsinskiTell me about your studio. So when you moved there, you you basically had to start from scratch in in a way. What did you do?

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI had my clients, so you know, I'm not starting from scratch. My first room, the one I talked to you in last, was in a house that I was renting. I rented for quite a while after I moved here because I wanted to make sure I was going to stay and wanted to find the right house and all the all the things. And and the rent was so cheap compared to LA. I was like, why do I want to buy a place? I probably should have bought one sooner than than I did. But this iteration is my best iteration because we got a house on the mountain, and there was a big, enormous garage downstairs.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinThere's another garage for the cars, and so I took half this garage, and it's 26 feet to the back of the room behind me here, and it's like 16 feet across. And I realized, wow, that's like the ratio of the golden triangle. And so I I I kind of not the golden triangle, the golden um uh it's called the golden ratio for for room dimensions, whatever. So I always call it the golden triangle because there was a place in Redondo called that. I built the room, you know, I had a buddy who's a construction guy build the room for me, and I had a lot of the acoustic stuff, so I built bass traps in all the corners, and but the thing that really, you know, that really changed the game as far as like mixing in a regular, basically a rectangular room, no matter how you slice it, is uh my Dutch and Dutch HC monitor.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinThose use a technology called cardioid, and they have woofers on the back, and you use the wall to your advantage. So, you know, you s people say, oh, don't put the speakers too close to the wall. Well, in this case, you want to put them close to the wall because they basically couple with the wall. And so the the low end hits from the rear woofers, hits the back and comes up, and then it's you know, the app time aligns it so that that low end that's coming back is flipped out of phase with or the I never remember how this is done, or the front one of them's out of phase so that what you're getting from your listing position is a clean low end.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinAnd so basically they act like soft it mounted monitors without the build out. You know, I can go to another room and I've got them still, I can set them up in a new room. My buddy, he got a house and he had this very narrow, you know, not a lot of distance behind him room. And when I was building this one, I had a mix that I had to do. I'm like, hey, can I come over? And and he's like, yeah, and I walked in the room, like, oh my god, how am I gonna mix in here?

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinAnd all it translated, like it totally worked. Like these things, the guy who sold them to me, who's no longer with the company, he's like, Oh, you don't even need the the acoustic stuff. I don't believe that, but I'm telling you, these things can make a lot of rooms that have no business working actually work. And you use REW with it, you know, you I still have to do some EQ and stuff, and and getting the right distance between them and getting the right distance from the wall, that takes a little time. But once you get it set up, I'm telling you, Bobby, this is the best room I've ever mixed in, ever.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinBar none. Like, I can tell everything that's happening. I never get weird stuff. I sometimes I'll go, okay, well, it's maybe I should check this in the car. And I go and I check it in the car. I'm like, okay, I hear no issues here. So like I master my own mixes now. Like uh when I'm at the end of the mix, I put the limiter on, I put all I put the old mastering chain on, I'd make my adjustments. I don't mix with the limiter on. That's that's madness. You you get so exhausted just l mixing with a brick wall limiter.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinBut and people think that it changes the sound, and it doesn't really change the sound. It just really just levels the dynamics between the verses and the choruses. I did a thing YouTube video where I met level matched minus seven lufs to minus ten to minus fourteen, and then cut between them, and you don't even notice the cuts going past other than the distortion that comes in when you're get when you get up to minus seven. So like loudness doesn't do the thing that people think it does, but it does make it easier for clients to listen to it and not be completely confused.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinAnd they're like, you know, well, what is it going to be like after mastering? We get rid of that completely. And the notes are done with the loudness part as part of it. And then I may tweak the mastering at the very end, you know, the last thing, and send it for approval. But you know, those are always just minor little little things anyway. What do you do for vinyl? Has anybody asked for vinyl? I haven't done a vinyl product in I don't know, decades. So uh I mean I do know, like I've people ask me every now and then, there's a company that presses them here in in Asheville, so I just send them to them.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinBut I don't really f every now and then, actually, I do get someone who wants to put it on vinyl, but I don't have to do anything different with the master for that. They always seem to work out fine, and they always if there's a problem, they have an engineer that can deal with it, so I just let it go the way it is.

Bobby OwsinskiYou were talking a little bit about um your signal chain, your mastering signal chain. Which leads me to a question about a modern approach to mixing as compared to the approach that maybe we had or or have. Modern meaning there's lots of plugins everywhere. There's, you know, five plugins uh on every channel and whatever the case. Uh lots of of side chaining, lots of you know, just things that we wouldn't have when we didn't grow up with.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI call 'em fancy things.

Bobby OwsinskiOkay. Well let's go there then. Have you adopted any of that?

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinYou know, the side chaining thing is complete bullshit to me. Like that just like it's like an internet myth that just grew legs and like, oh, you if you're sidechaining, you're kicking your base. I mean, that's sidechain is great for an effect. But for solving mix issues, you're just complicating things more than you need to. So I I never adopted any of that. I do think that there's merit to using more plugins than we may have used in, you know, uh as far as analog gear is concerned, because, you know, it I can just think, like, uh if I take an 117, an analog 1176 and I turn up the input, you know, beyond 12 o'clock, then I'm gonna start getting or or turn up my output, actually, beyond 3 o'clock.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI'm gonna start to get distortion, right? But if I want to do that with a plug-in, I can use an 1176 model, but the distortion's never really the same to me. So like I start to break up things into parts, like there's the EQ, then the compressor, then I add my distortion. Everything's kind of in layers now. And it seems like it's more involved than I suppose it is to some degree, but you know, you don't have any limitations and instances, so what does it really matter? And it does allow me to really shape the distortion that I want on any particular thing.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI'm not stuck with whatever that particular 1176 has to offer or whatever the limited number of compressors in the room have to offer, you know, in a mixed room. I don't have to deal with these compromises of, well, I only have one LA2A, so I better use it on this. Uh, you know, and oh, I have an Innovanics, I'm gonna use that on the acoustic guitar because I'd be wasting it anywhere else. And, you know, that sort of thing. And so you get stuck into certain things, which is fine.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinYou're making a mix, it doesn't matter, nobody knows what you're using. But those decisions kind of go away and kind of frees you to use anything you want and try and you know shape the sound any way you want, which is, you know, it's different. And I'm not gonna say one's better than the other. They're just different processes and different ways of approaching it, is all. And if you know how to do both, then it doesn't really matter to me which one I'm in. I just have to shift my mentality of how I'm working between the two.

Bobby OwsinskiI totally agree with you about side chaining. I I always felt that, well, wait, if you got it right in the first place, you wouldn't need a sidechain. Just go back to the fundamentals and do it right, and you won't have to do that stuff.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinPlus, side chains are automatic processes. And so they're gonna be instances where, oh, that side chain's working great until here, right? And then until here. And then it's a problem, it's a real problem. So, like, I don't want to use anything that's an automatic process if I can avoid it in a mix, because it only causes me problems. I'd rather I'd I don't use gates at all, never use a gate. Like, I'll just strip silence the the toms, mix them in with the full toms, then I can get the bleed exactly where I want it, and then I get the hits exactly right every time.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI don't have mistriggers, I don't have anybody bumping a knob, not that I would bump a knob, but you know, like all that goes away. So I I want to get rid of anything that could change or that's has any kind of randomness at all if I can avoid it.

Bobby OwsinskiHow much are you in the box when you're mixing?

Eric "Mixerman" Sarafin100%. I don't I'm uh I I I even sold my SSL G384, which was dropped to my two bus for over 20 years. Because I was just like it was just sitting there. All the processing is done, everything that I did kind of changed. And it was like I you know, before I was doing a lot of heavy lifting with the SSL, and now it's like that's everything kind of internal, and I don't really I probably compressed the two bus maybe I don't know, 40% of the time, maybe less. It depends on if it's organic, I'm more much more likely to compress the two bus.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinBut but I just decided, you know, I'm sending people mixes. Sometimes I've got two or three projects or different songs from different people on my on my block, and I can't be fiddling with knobs and trying to get stuff in the exact same positions, and like I need exact perfect recalls so that when I send notes back, they're not like, well, this is better, but this is worse, you know? Like we just wanna so yeah, I I I'm not using any of the analog stuff anymore at all.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI've just switched to what works best within the within the box.

Bobby OwsinskiIt's funny you should mention that yesterday I went to the uh Wednesday audio lunch, lunch bunch. You know about that, right? Yeah, the well it it started from Universal Audio.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinYeah, yeah, yeah. I used to go to that with Peter Dell and Pete Dell, right, exactly.

Bobby OwsinskiYeah. So I was sitting there with a a bunch of older engineers, and everybody was talking about all this analog outboard gear that they had that they haven't used for X amount of time, saying, I really should get rid of that. I love it, but I'm not using it or I haven't used it in such a long time. And it seems to be a theme where it's like, well, I got all the stuff, it's really cool, and it doesn't serve me anymore. So, yeah, I understand that completely.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinWell, the practicalities of it really dictate it more than anything else. And if I was doing one song at a time, then analog gear would would fit within that. That's just not how things are now. So like I can appreciate like for tracking, I I I love using analog gear. Like stuff that's tracked without it, like you could tell. It doesn't have the same punch, it's it's not contained, it's just it it's it doesn't have the same thing about it.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinAnd that doesn't mean that I can't make a great mix out of it, but I do have to work harder. But at the end of the day, with a mix, I'm trying to get across the song and the production and integrate them and and push the listener forward and cause a reaction. And like these are the things that I care about far more than oh, that snare drum just sounds amazing with that compressor. Like, who the fuck cares?

Bobby OwsinskiYeah.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinLike it doesn't matter. Nobody sings the snare drum, nobody sings the hi-hat, right? So like to me, it's not something to concern myself with. Those guys should sell their analog gear because I I'm telling you, we're probably at the peak of what it's gonna be. I mean, I'm making a prediction here, but things are gonna change dramatically. And I don't know, there'll always be a niche niche market for it, but I don't know how big that niche market's gonna remain, you know?

Bobby OwsinskiLast year I get rid of all my guitar amps. And I'm thinking the same thing. It's like, okay, this is the end. Everybody's going to modelers, and I can see why. Um do they sound better? Well, they're close enough. When I saw Metallica was uh touring with um whatever one they use, I thought, okay, well, it's all over.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinOh, they were touring with a modeler?

Bobby OwsinskiYeah.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinOh, yeah. I mean, it makes life so much easier. Like, you know, listen, if a guy comes in, like, I don't know, name famous guitar player and they have a sound with Joe Satriani. I'm not gonna go and tell, hey, Joe, put let's use my um Why can't I think of my favorite amp modeler? Oh well. And he's gonna be like, why? I've got my sound. So I'm gonna put a mic in front of him, right? But if a band member comes in and they've only got one amp and it's just this kind of amp, why am I gonna use that? I I have the ability to use any get any tone I want now.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinSo amplitude, that's the one I use the most. I really like that package.

Bobby OwsinskiOkay, speaking of which, are you tracking much?

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinNo, I've been mostly mixing lately. Anything I produce has been l uh local anyway, so and the producing is so time consuming and not as you know financially rewarding. So it's better for me to mix at this stage.

Bobby OwsinskiOkay, speaking of mixing, I was going through your book, your new book, which we'll talk about in a second, and I noticed um something about Atmos and your opinion of Atmos, which I totally agree with. So let's talk about that. I know you're not a big fan.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI'm not not a fan. Listen, surrounds amazing. That's what you get in these arguments with people, I don't even really argue about it anymore, but you know, they're like, but it sounds amazing. Yes, it sounds amazing. It's amazing in a in a movie theater when you or in a listening room where you're surrounded by the array, and that's fantastic. But it might even be cool for me to do that, but nobody's gonna listen to that. Nobody's gonna listen to music that way.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinWe already know they're not gonna listen to music that way. They listen to MP3s on streaming. Why are they gonna listen to Atmos? I don't even understand Apple's bet on the retail side. I don't get it. Like, why would they even think that this was gonna work? It's totally never gonna work.

Bobby OwsinskiWell, there's no no consumer demand for it.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinExactly.

Bobby OwsinskiI mean, zero.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinRight. And then they tried to like make everybody like put all of their music out in Atmos, and it's like, why? Nobody's gonna listen to it.

Bobby OwsinskiI get it from a label standpoint. Not that I agree with it, but I get it. They're they want a new copyright.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinOkay. And they want a new product.

Bobby OwsinskiA new product, a new copyright. So I can understand the labels.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinOf course.

Bobby OwsinskiAnd Apple, I think it's more um it was another way to make more money for them because they're kind of forcing you to go to the higher tier, both as a consumer and as as a uh a label where you have to pay more money in order to do this. Or you don't pay more money, but you get uh fewer features. So I I I can see it from their standpoint as well. But I think it's failed bet at this point.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI'm surprised they're still even trying to I mean it i it's it's fine for movies and and for you know for certain things. I'm not saying Atmos should go away completely. I'm just saying like I'm actually doing a revision of the mixing book, Sending the Art of Mixing, right now. Like and I'm just removing all the whoops, all the timeless, all the stuff that's gonna make it that dates it, basically. Because every time I do a Revision, I'm like, ah, this changed four years ago. It's completely different. And it's like, and I'm like, but I have all this timeless stuff in it that no matter how technology changes, that's going to stay the same.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinSo I've stripped it of all the stuff that's going to cause me problems later and made it just the timeless volume that I originally actually wanted it to be. And there was a reason why I went down this road. Well, oh, we were talking about the Atmos. And so I'm looking at it, I'm like, you know, I got to the section where in the last revision I talked about Atmos. And I'm like, shh, gone. I don't need to talk about any of that because it's never going to happen. And so this book is completely written about stereo techniques.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinAnd I can promise you, 20 years from now, 30 years from now, the things that are in this book will apply regardless of all technological changes, no matter how different things are with how we work, these principles will stand. And so, you know, stereo mixing is it. The stereo is playing in a room, right? So it's bouncing off the walls as it is. You're all over the room. You're rarely sitting in the stereo field. Most people don't even have a stereo field to speak of because they're listening on a Bluetooth brick or whatever.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinAnd like, it's about the music. You see the guy going down the street on his bicycle with the little transistor thing, and he's listening to it and he's rocking out. Like it's the music, man. They don't care about the sound.

Bobby OwsinskiI've been invited to a lot of uh Atmos music playbacks. I'm not going to name the names, but there'd be some really popular album, you know, from a legendary album from our past that they'd be redoing in Atmos. And started playing and I go, but wait, where's where's the glue? Where's the punch? Where where's all the stuff that I remember?

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinThat's the other thing. I think it just fails miserably at that because when you have shit coming from behind you and stuff, like I don't even it's very confusing. Like it's like it's not, it's all disconnected. And it's like if it's all in front of you and it's coming out, and depending on where you're in the room, it's acoustic mono. It makes a lot more sense.

Bobby OwsinskiAll right. So let's touch on AI for a second. You mentioned before that you don't like anything that's automatic happening in your mixes. So I would assume from that that uh you're not a big fan of any AI-assisted tools, mixing tools either.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI mean, well, how many are there really? There's ozone. Um I I use every now and then, actually almost never now, but when I was first you know getting used to the room and stuff, I would run the mix through ozone just to see what its EQ suggestion was. And the problem was like I'd put it in Ozone 9. I have 910 and 11. I put it in nine, it'd give me one EQ curve. I'd put it in 10, it'd give me a new EQ curve, it was brighter. I put it in 11, it was even brighter.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinAnd I'm just like, wait a second, like what is it making decisions on? And then you'd go into 11 and they have like, I don't know, eight, nine different plugins that are within the module, right? And if I'm like, oh, it's too bright, I'll just cut the EQ. Wrong, because everything's like integrated. So you can't even just remove one or the other, really. It's like you're kind of stuck with it. And so yeah, I find that pretty useless. If you can't, the thing is about AI, if you can get the AI to revise for you, then AI becomes very useful.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinIf you can't revise, AI is purely hit or miss, and you'll never actually hit the bullseye. Which is exactly the way it is, yes. Except for occasionally, right? Yes. So everything that I do with AI, first of all, I don't do anything that I can already do myself with AI. I mean, I have processes on processes. I don't need AI to help me with mixing music, right? That doesn't mean I don't want AI to help me be more efficient, right? I would love for a product to allow me to not have to deal with the DAW, that all the functions of the DAW are available through the AI just by talking to it.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI would love to have so that I don't have to learn the DAW. I could switch any DAW. The AI helps me through it, right? I would love to be able to uh have the AI process something for me and not have me choose first my EQ, then my compressor, then my distortion. Oh, let me move the EQ between the three, which is the best spot. Have it just take it holistically and use feel words and say, yeah, I want this, you know, to be aggressive and I want it to be distorted like a fuzz, fuzzy kind of distortion and see what it spits out and then revise from there.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinAs long as I can revise, we're good. I'm gonna use the AI. But if I can't be in control and be the arbiter of what's good, and I just gotta take whatever it spits out, then it's useless to me.

Bobby OwsinskiLet's talk about your book, your new book. There's a lot of information in it. Boy, it must have taken you a long time because it's packed.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinYou know, it's technically a revision of uh Zen in the Art of Producing, a blown way out from that. So there were some core parts to it that I already had, but I mean it's significantly blown out from that book. So that's why I gave it a new title. You know, Zen in the Art of Producing was written for people who wanted to produce others, and this one's designed for anybody who wants to produce, no matter where the what their position is, you know.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinAnd I wouldn't say no matter what knowledge base they're at, I mean it'd be pretty tough to just decide you're gonna make records and then pick up the book and use it that way. But I mean, there is certain amount of front leg work that's required. But you know, usually by the time someone's buying a book, they've already done that. They're frustrated. They're like, I need something to get me past this point. And so I I read it wrote it for that, really.

Bobby OwsinskiHow long did it take you?

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinSix months. I started the day after Helene or the week after Helene, once my family got back, because they were in Spain and I was here alone with the two pups, and it started immediately, and I was done by April or something, so October through April.

Bobby OwsinskiWell, considering that's pretty fast.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinYeah, I don't know. I don't know if I'm fast, slow, what when it comes to writing a book, it's just it's done when it's done. You know what I mean? So uh I only care about its quality. I don't care how long it takes me. I can mix in between, you know, I can if I have mix comes in, I can just put it down for the day. It doesn't matter.

Bobby OwsinskiSo you were writing every day?

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinIf I wasn't mixing, I was writing, yeah. I try to take weekends off no matter what I'm doing, because it's very easy to to just get in the haze. And if the weekends really if you just force I if I if I force myself to just step away for two days, it really helps a lot. There's a very good reason for weekends. We should use them, so I I do.

Bobby OwsinskiI go kind of the other way. I go on a a cruise, uh usually a transatlantic cruise or Trans-Pacific a couple times a year, and and that I I work on it. I still work, but you know, instead of ten hours a day, it's maybe six.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinSo the thing is for me, like, I gotta be doing something all the time. Like, uh I'm not smoking weed anymore, so like I don't just sit around and and veg out anymore. And so like after I quit weed, I was like, I'm always doing something, right? So but that's why I have to absolutely force the the time off. You know, I'm gonna step away. I'm not gonna work today.

Bobby OwsinskiLet's come back to your book for a second. So is there one one thing that you want people to get out of it more than anything else?

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI just I want them to get out of it that the musical decisions are the most important decisions and that music is sound, and if you approach sound from the perspective of sound, you're not uh approaching it from the perspective of the music. And I have way more control with my musical decisions on the on the frequency landscape of of a track than I do with my uh EQ decisions, right?

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinBecause I mean, uh a part takes up the space that it takes up and if it's I can't put something that's taking up an upper mid-range space down into the lower mid-range. I don't have that capability, none of us do. So your arrangement and musical decisions are way more important than any engineering decisions that you make. And if you get the musical decisions right, the engineering decisions go away for the most part.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinAnd so if you're not an engineer, then that's the way you want to think about things. Because you don't want to anytime you're in the engineering side, you're doing shit you don't know how to do. And you'll learn it over time, but like you already know how to make music, so just become better at that, first and foremost.

Bobby OwsinskiI couldn't agree more, and I think one of the things that most musicians never learn, and it should be the first thing, is how to arrange things. And if nothing else, just sonically, where things ought to go. Because that would make a huge difference for every engineer and every mixer out there, if just sonically everything fit together well. Exactly. But it doesn't. More times than not, that's the problem. Eric, what's one thing that people don't know about you that you wish they did?

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI don't know that there's a lot that people don't know about me. I'm pretty forward-facing.

Bobby OwsinskiYou have exposed a lot about yourself, yes, in your writing for sure.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinOh no. If there's things that people don't know about me, I don't know that I want to reveal them.

Bobby OwsinskiAnd the reason why I ask is uh uh sometimes there there's something that no one would ever talk about, but the you know, like uh gee, I I was undefeated as a tennis champ or something like that, you know. And that things like that come up occasionally.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinSo all right. Well, how about this? Uh I mean I I mention it, and people should know it, but I come from a musical background. Like I started playing piano at six, I was playing Chopin in high school, Rach Manonov. I studied jazz piano. I switched to jazz piano, I studied jazz piano with Kenny Barron at Mason Gross School of the Arts. I went to Berkeley, I studied arranging and songwriting, and and uh I changed my major like four times because I wanted to be a voice major for one semester just so I could get the voice classes and you know, and get some tips and tricks on that.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinAnd I never was going to be a singer, I just wanted to know how to do it. I just wanted to get better at it, you know. I was playing trumpet at eight through high school, was top in my band, first chair. So, like uh when I went to my first studio, was you know, I was songwriting all the time and recording my songs, and so you know, I I do come from a musical background. I'm known as an engineer, but I've always approached the engineering from the musical side. I kind of learned it begrudgingly in a way.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinUm and just from doing it for 40 years, you learn it. But like the more I learn it, the more useless I think it is.

Bobby OwsinskiBut yes, I understand that completely. Coming from a musical background. Makes perfect sense. Okay, last question, Eric. I asked you this the last time you were on, but a lot has changed since then. So what's the best piece of advice that you've ever been someone imparted to you, or maybe you learned yourself along the way?

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinFor some reason, Prof. Fielder is in my head. Prof. Mason Gross where I was studying with Kenny Barron, and um he was Winston Winston Marcellus was his protege. You know, he played in the Chicago Symphony, and he played jazz. He was the first crossover classical jazz guy. I just hope I can remember the three things. He said the three evils in life are I can't, passing the blame. Oh my god, I can't remember the third one. So I just blew this one. What was the first two?

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinI can't and passing the blame. He was a trip, that guy. I remember like the first day, he's like, played all the two five ones, and you'd go on the piano and you're gonna play all the two five ones up the keyboard, and I played, and he goes, What are you doing? And like, because I did just four notes, I didn't have any like he's like, no, and he's like, John, jun, jun, jun, jun, jun, jun. And he's had all these color tones in it. I'm like, well, show me, show me how you do that. And then that week I practiced, like I and I could do it just as good as him, all the way up the up the scale and the chromatic scale.

Eric "Mixerman" SarafinAnd um, so that was that was kind of eye-opening.

Bobby OwsinskiThanks for listening and being in my inner circle. Remember, if you have any questions or comments, you can send them to questions at bobbyosinski.com. You can also learn all about the latest in music, audio, and production news, and find out about openings for my latest online classes at Bobbyosinski.com. This is Bobby Osinski. I will see you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Matt O'Neil REVEALS Exactly How to Spot Music's Next Hollywood | Ep. 650

    Nov 10, 202632 minAudio

    Producer-engineers learn how Matt O'Neil bet on Houston early and built 42 plugins with AI instead of waiting on costly developers. Matt explains how he spotted Houston as an underserved music market in 2015 and worked...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Tamar Kaprelian REVEALS Exactly How to Survive Getting Dropped | Ep. 649

    Nov 3, 202628 minAudio

    Artists and music industry newcomers: how Tamar Kaprelian got dropped by Clive Davis, burned out at 24, and built the support she never had. She refused a Lindsay Lohan recut Davis pitched her and lost the deal. She...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Robina Ritchie-Barker REVEALS Exactly How to Never Miss a Sync | Ep. 648

    Oct 27, 202637 minAudio

    Sync composers: Robina Ritchie-Barker explains why finishing catalog admin early is what keeps your music ready when a brief arrives. Robina co-founded TrackStage after missing a sync opportunity because a piano track...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Gil Weinberg UNCOVERS What AI Could Really Mean for Musicians | Ep. 647

    Oct 20, 202637 minAudio

    Musicians curious about AI robots: Georgia Tech's Gil Weinberg shows how technology expands what players can do without replacing the act of playing. Weinberg built Shimon, a marimba robot with eight arms hitting 20...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The AI Copyright Battle Every Independent Artist Needs to Understand | Ep. 646

    Oct 13, 202618 minAudio

    The latest music business and production news. For independent musicians: AI copyright lawsuits, royalty disputes, and changing listener habits are reshaping the music industry right now. Bobby covers US recorded music...

    Credit the people on this episode