Jesse’s 70-minute conversation with the man who uncovered* James Talarico’s hidey hole in an Ohio psych ward. Note: Listen to the episode first! *Did not uncover To hear more, visit www.blockedandreported.org
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Jesse, what the hell is this?
SPEAKER_02This is double bonus content. Well, I guess it's just bonus content. I interviewed earlier today, Thursday, October 15th. I interviewed a guy named Ryan Amaker. Ryan is the guy who basically set off this whole hoax about James Tallarico and a psychiatric hospital or clinic or whatever. I think it's an interesting conversation. It is a conversation that will benefit from some background knowledge about this. Lucky for you, we're releasing this the same time as we're releasing a media episode
SPEAKER_02about this whole controversy. So if you already know about the controversy, you can listen to this and you'll get it. But you might want to listen to our episode first. Anything else, Katie?
SPEAKER_00No, I haven't listened
SPEAKER_02to this.
SPEAKER_00I am. This is good. So this is like unfettered. Are you going to be honest? Am I going to listen to it?
SPEAKER_02Are you going to?
SPEAKER_00Honestly, no.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, that's a good advertisement for it. I think this is for the real freaks, the real telefreakos. It's getting inside the mind of a guy who's like a MAGA influencer who doesn't seem to really be able to lie. Like weirdly for a guy who spread a false rumor, he's pretty truthful about his motives and how he views the... Underlying moral issues to the extent he thinks there are moral issues, which he doesn't really. I found it interesting to talk to him. Hopefully you'll find it interesting too.
SPEAKER_02It's just the audio as is. I cut out where he works. He mentioned where he works, which we don't need to do that. And it's two calls. You'll hear me hang up and then explain that I'm about to get back on the phone with him.
SPEAKER_00Anything else, Katie? No, I think it's great that you have talked on the phone. Not to a girl, but Jesse has talked on the phone.
SPEAKER_02Well, you got to start by practicing with your guy friends, your guy mega influencer friends.
SPEAKER_00All right. Two bros just chatting. Enjoy.
SPEAKER_02Oh, wait. And also, are we doing a preview version of this too?
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. You should do a preview.
SPEAKER_02Well, okay. So first of all, I posted this to my Substack. So this will be duplicative for some of you. But this will cut off if you're not a Primo subscriber, if you want to hear the whole thing. Become a Primo subscriber. Bye.
SPEAKER_02I was just going to mention, you know, that she played a role in spreading this idea that Tyler Rico had been institutionalized. And I just keep circling back to the idea that I sort of feel like everyone is claiming that this was like your thing, that you were the guy. And I don't know, it just made me curious about like you said you got a tip from someone. I'm curious if you can tell me anything about that.
SPEAKER_01Well, it was off the tweet.
SPEAKER_02The tweet from who?
SPEAKER_01Caroline, I think. I posted on last Wednesday.
SPEAKER_02I reposted her. Yeah, that was it. And
SPEAKER_01I just went on a leap of faith and called the lender center. And I posted a statement this morning. I think I got it. I don't know. Well, I say that I didn't lie. I think what I'm trying to say is I didn't lie about the phone call. The phone call was real. Yeah. I think that they're talking about, like, oh, you misrepresented. You said your camera, you know, tolerate those cousins. Oh, yeah, of course. I'm talking about the phone call. The phone call was not mini-played or faked or... That's what I was talking about.
SPEAKER_01So a little confusing. I guess a little confusing on my part.
SPEAKER_02Gotcha. Did you... As this was all initially unfolding and you were planning to call them, did you have any interactions with Michelle?
SPEAKER_01No, I don't even have. I've talked to her a couple times on like a space, but I never know. And when I got it, I think I even told you that, you know, I'm originally from Portland. And when Nick and Kubel Daylor came down last fall, that's who I reached out to. I don't even have Michelle's number.
SPEAKER_02Gotcha. And what about, I'm just, I'm like curious, it seems like just in the normal course of American politics, this is the sort of thing campaigns do. They try to spread stuff like this. Do you think the Pakistan campaign added any role in that?
SPEAKER_01No, I don't think, I don't think they, well, because when Nick retweeted, retweeted, or excuse me, he posted original, and I made my own. I think he got like 7 million views, I got like one and a half.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So he's monetizing off of, I would say my work. I think you can agree to that, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. You're saying Nick is making money off your work.
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah, he's got, I mean, how many, this is his full-time job, but his post, which he never would have posted if I didn't get an audio, he's got like seven and a half or eight
SPEAKER_02million views on
SPEAKER_01now. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Are you making decent money from this stuff?
SPEAKER_01So I got, I just looked right now because they
SPEAKER_02pay every, I mean, the X creator poker thing. I know they
SPEAKER_01just changed it. I'm at 12.3 million impressions for the last two weeks.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And do you know what that's going to translate to Money Wise about?
SPEAKER_01I don't. The most I ever got was like $1200, which was like a
SPEAKER_02month ago. $1200 for how much time posting?
SPEAKER_01Two weeks. I think it was like $9.3 million for every two weeks period.
SPEAKER_02And then how many impressions did you say you have the last two weeks?
SPEAKER_01So right now I have 12.4.
SPEAKER_02Oh, so that could, so that's like, if you have, it's all a little bit unclear how they translate it, but you could be looking at like 15, potentially 1500 or $3,000. Potentially.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. Um, and if it's like premium or, you know, blue check mark that, you know, that,
SPEAKER_02So how does it work that Nick gets, like, is it just because he had the bigger platform going, and it sounds like he's going to get, like, six times what you got for your work?
SPEAKER_01Exactly. Exactly. Say again? Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Are you okay with that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Wait, what? I mean, are you, like, okay with that? Because you were the one who made the call.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, like, in hindsight, it's 20-20.
SPEAKER_02Like, I would say
SPEAKER_01there was, I didn't think, you know, go through the, you know, think about what was going to happen. You know, after they posted, was it the owner center posted the statement? Yeah. Like, it was like, okay, that's it, you know.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I still think he had a mental episode, but obviously it wasn't in Cincinnati, Ohio.
SPEAKER_01I just think, you know, there's still, there's something... This is my, it's not fact or anything, but
SPEAKER_02I think something happened. I don't know what, but obviously it wasn't in Ohio, but, you know. Yeah, so you think it wasn't at the Lindner Center?
SPEAKER_01Well, no, not now. Yeah. You know, I basically, like, you know, the term, like, high off opium, like, I was hoping, like, oh, this would stick, but I actually do have my two children's thinking through, so. Yeah. I mean, it was funny, too. I mean, I didn't sleep at all until Monday.
SPEAKER_02From when until when?
SPEAKER_01So I was driving back from Seattle. So I slept Saturday morning. So Friday night, I went to bed at like probably 1 or 2. Then I got up around 10. And then went for a hike. And then about 2 o'clock. No, probably like 1.30. Went to Seattle, man, so buddies. And then when I drove back, I was up all night and Sunday. I probably didn't go to sleep until Sunday night, probably around
SPEAKER_028 or 9. So you were up from like Saturday night to Sunday night?
SPEAKER_01Friday night.
SPEAKER_02You were up from Friday night to Sunday night?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, because I went to Seattle. I didn't sleep Saturday night. I didn't go to bed until Sunday night because of just everything that was going on.
SPEAKER_02Are you back? Are you back in Oregon now? Yeah. Yeah. Um, that's, uh, I'm so curious about the economics of this because it seems like the, like if you're an influencer, you just, I wasn't,
SPEAKER_01I'm not in like the next story.
SPEAKER_02No, I know. But you, it seems like there's like, you just, you need to keep posting basically for the money to be good. Right? Like you need to be diligent about it.
SPEAKER_01Oh, I mean, I mean, yeah, I mean, I post pretty regularly, you know, but I'm not, I wasn't, I get that post, well, first thing you nailed the election, I post more often, but, I mean, that's just close to the election, but, you know.
SPEAKER_02Was the, when you had the $1,500 payment, was that, like, a lot for you? Like, is it getting better as the election approaches?
SPEAKER_01Oh. Yeah. I mean, I usually, every two weeks, I get, like, 400 or 500 bucks, which is, like, extra income.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And is that, like, a decent chunk of your overall income, or is it just, like, a bonus on top, or what?
SPEAKER_01Oh, just a bonus.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Interesting. Yeah, I wish I better understood, like, this whole world. It's not just Trump supporters. It's, like, people on the left who do, who post a lot of stuff. Did, um... Is there anything you can tell me about what the lawyer said when he said you shouldn't comment more?
SPEAKER_01So I just put that comment out or that statement this morning. Yeah. And that was kind of it.
SPEAKER_02The lawyer has told you to do that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And you're back in Portland now? You're an ardent? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02All right. What do you... What do you, like, take from this whole experience? Like, just, because you, well, first of all, how did, it's interesting to me that Nick was the first person to post the audio, right?
SPEAKER_01Right, because the gift of it, you could get a larger audio and you could get a larger poll.
SPEAKER_02So did he pitch you that you should give him the audio to post?
SPEAKER_01Well, I sent it to him without him even knowing.
SPEAKER_02Without him even knowing what?
SPEAKER_01Well, no, I just sent it to him, I was like, hey, what do you think of this?
SPEAKER_02And then he posted it?
SPEAKER_01Well, no, I talked to him. Yeah. You know, a couple of times, yeah.
SPEAKER_02So you weren't surprised by him posting it. He said he was going to post it. Yes, correct. Okay. If you could do it.
SPEAKER_01If I had to do it, like, obviously that's not the same situation, but I'm like mixing my shake right now.
SPEAKER_02I would say there would be a different rollout.
SPEAKER_01It's not the situation with anything else. It was something, I mean, Who knows? If we had another political story, I probably wouldn't be in the position I'm in right now.
SPEAKER_02The position you're in now meaning what?
SPEAKER_01Well, I'm meaning death threats. I mean, I'm afraid to look at my inbox on X. It's always a request. I don't want to look at them, so. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, that's basically it. Just, you know, um, it, you know, again, I think I've told you for, I'm not a journalist, so I don't know, like, you know, check your sources. I just like, oh shit, this is big. I'm gonna run with it. That's it.
SPEAKER_02Well, what do you think, what do you think happened with the woman who said that, yeah, he was discharged if you had to guess? Cause like it appears now that was not accurate information.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I don't, I don't, I honestly, I don't know. Um, I just, when I heard, when I said James
SPEAKER_02Tallarico, and she like,
SPEAKER_01it registered in her head, and I don't think she even knows, well, she does now, but at that time, I don't think she even knew who James Tallarico is. Like, that's still the mystery why she said, because she said that name right there, so I don't say I don't know at this point. Yeah. I mean, she could be, she's old. You know, it would have been a mistake.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that, I think maybe she thought, I can't find this guy, I'll just tell him, he's not a patient here, I'll just tell this guy on the phone, the cousin, he was
SPEAKER_01just... She had other ample opportunities to just hang up or get rid of me or, you know, push me to the side and say, I don't want to deal with you anymore. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Could you, I, I, I, you, you have been honest in our interactions and I appreciate that. Could you send me a screenshot just of that 1500 check just so I can, I'm, I am curious about the money side of that. If you're willing to share that.
SPEAKER_01Oh, the, on that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Oh, okay. I don't, I don't need any personal info. You can black out whenever you want. I just want to see the amount of the dates. What would you say if, like, if a James Salarico family member, you know, if that was one of the people in their inbox and they were like, you know, you spread this damaging rumor about my, I don't know, brother, father, whatever?
SPEAKER_01Oh, they contact me?
SPEAKER_02If they did, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, I have to probably at this point, I have to learn.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but what do you feel like as a human being, if lawyers weren't involved, how would you respond to that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I would probably apologize. Yeah, I mean, you know, I would say I take, you know, full responsibility, but yeah, Yeah, I think it was more out of my depth and like how this blew up or how it was released and how it, you know, because I don't have any media training.
SPEAKER_01And so, you know, I, yeah, I didn't, when I, obviously when I, when I got posted, I didn't think what was, what was going to happen next was going to happen. I, you know, I don't know if anybody said, so.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I mean, I think, yeah, And then just because people were yelling at you about this, what was the deal with the video game clip and the reference to Somalis and Ilhan Omar? What was that about?
SPEAKER_01Oh, to support him? Yeah. Well, I never mentioned Ilhan Omar.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. But people were claiming you were making a violent threat. You're saying you weren't?
SPEAKER_01No. It was a video game that just got released.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I do troll, yeah. Everyone trolls is 2026. The only other thing that jumped out at me was after you said your lawyer told you not to talk about this stuff, you posted that image of Tallarico with a drag queen. Are you at all worried about future legal issues?
SPEAKER_01You mean the meme?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01No, I think that was after, or that was before.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it was after, but are you worried that, like, posting fake images could get you in more trouble?
SPEAKER_01Well, if I say that they're real, yeah, I mean, as it said, I don't know if you read it, it said allegedly these are not being confirmed or verified.
SPEAKER_02Gotcha. So you think that that'll shield you from defamation?
SPEAKER_01Well, I don't know. I'm not supposed to, I'm not going to post anything, like anything that would, other than like, I don't know, like whatever the debate, or last night, just like straight, nothing that could potentially give me any hot water, like, you know, I don't know.
SPEAKER_02That's it. That's all you get if you want to hear the rest of my interview with Ryan Amaker, become a premium subscriber, which will also give you access to the episode that forms the basis of this whole thing. Thank you for listening. Hope you enjoyed the preview. Bye.
This week on the Primo show, three stories. First, Jesse and Katie discuss the transformation of a former child star into a radical Catholic internet beggar. Then, the boycott of a Vancouver Island brewery over an...
This week on Blocked and Reported, Jesse and Katie dig into attempts to thwart the voter-approved initiative that will bar trans girls from girls’ school sports in Washington state. Will trans activists and allies...
This week on Blocked and Reported: hockey. First, Jessica the ‘80s Baby investigates the NHL’s ill-advised attempts to harness hockey’s thirstiest online fans. Then, Katie explains the AI scandal tearing apart the...
This week on the Primo show, the blue tsunami. Featuring: socialists versus normies, trans issues on the ballot, how the online right is coping, and how and when the Dems mess this one up (sorry). To hear more, visit...
This week on Blocked and Reported, Jesse and Katie discuss how RuPaul made drag mainstream, the legend of problematic queen Sharon Needles, and the Pittsburgh drag bar caught in an accidental blackface scandal. Plus, a...