Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Blockcast

Blockcast artwork

Is it Game Over for Web3 Gaming in 2024? TriliTech (Tezos Ecosystem) Global Head of Gaming Says No | Blockcast 25

May 10, 202442 minAudio

From Diablo to FIFA to Final Fantasy to Pokemon, here at Blockhead, we're big fans of gaming. But despite our love for gaming and our ardent passion for Web3, blockchain gaming has yet to convince us to abandon our Articunos for Axies. Join us as Jeremy Foo, who serves as the Global Head of Gaming for TrilliTech and Tezos, tells us how blockchain gaming is restoring its reputation from deafening backlash, and why we should delve into the vibrant Web3 worlds of Meta Pals, Battle Tabs, Stars Symphony, and Dogami. Jeremy Foo is an experienced gaming industry leader with deep experience in strategy, operations, and investment. Today, he leads the gaming vertical at TriliTech, and is responsible for the success of gaming on the Tezos blockchain. Previously, he has successfully guided senior management at Sea Group on key strategic initiatives. He also drove major investment deals, improved the monetization of Garena Free Fire, and led the League of Legends publishing team in Thailand. As a passionate gamer, he adopts a first principles understanding of gaming trends. More at Blockhead.co and join us on Telegram to stay up to date with the latest news. 🎙️ Hey there, Blockcast listeners! 🎙️ This podcast provides commentary and discussion on cryptocurrency and related topics. It is intended for informational and entertainment purposes only and should not be construed as financial advice. Guests appearing on this podcast may discuss companies or strategies, but these discussions are not recommendations to buy, sell, or hold any particular asset or pursue any specific strategy. The hosts and guests are not financial advisors, and listeners are urged to consult with a qualified professional before making any investment decisions. Investments in cryptocurrency are inherently risky, and you could lose money. Reach us at hello@blockhead.co.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hey there, Crypto Curious gang. It's time to plug in and play with the Blockheads at BlockCast. Strap in for a weekly whirlwind tour through the blockchain jungle, where NFTs, shiny coins, and crypto titans tango. Serve that with a side of spicy insights and the crunchiest bits of the digital sphere. Let's dive into the decentralized deep end. BlockCast is live in three, two, one.

SPEAKER_04Hi guys, welcome back to another episode of BLOCKLAST. I'm your host and producer at BLOCKHEAD, Jung. Today, alongside me, is our co-founder, Kohen.

SPEAKER_03Hey, guys.

SPEAKER_04Today, we have a special episode. You know, gaming has always been a big part of the Web3 ecosystem and industry. And it's not something we often discuss on broadcast, which is why we've invited someone special today to help us deep dive a little bit more into Web3 gaming and understand whether people actually play these games and do we actually need it. So let's welcome our guest, Jeremy. He's the global head of gaming at Trilitech. Welcome, Jeremy.

SPEAKER_01Hey, everyone. It's great to meet you. So yeah, I'll be happy to start off with a quick intro of myself. So I'm head of gaming at Trilotech. We are part of the Tezos ecosystem and I'm essentially responsible for the success of gaming on Tezos. Because Trilotech is essentially the adoption hub for the Tezos blockchain. So we have a head of arts and culture, a head of DeFi and a head of gaming seated at Trilotech to really advance the adoption of the Tezos blockchain.

SPEAKER_04Awesome. So we've heard that you are a hardcore gamer, played tons of hours of like WoW, Final Fantasy and League.

SPEAKER_01Is that why you got into gaming? Yeah, absolutely. So I started my career at McKinsey, the management consultancy. But then after a year and a half, I decided I wanted to really follow my passion and work in games since I've been gaming since I was five and old enough to hold a controller. So I spent around seven years after that working at Garena. I was a producer on League of Legends as well as strategy on Garena Free Fire. I also led around$70 million of gaming investments during that time as well. So yeah, after spending those times in the trenches, I've realized that there was a lot of potential for blockchain and Web3.

SPEAKER_01Actually, my boss at that time asked me to do a research project on that after the success of Axie Infinity. Maybe he shouldn't have because I ended up leaving and joining the Tesla ecosystem instead.

SPEAKER_03So what was it that you discovered during your research that made you jump to the dark side?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, I think we just saw the huge adoption and amount of users that were playing Axie Infinity as well as the monetization that was working at least at that time. And so there were a few key concepts that really resonated with me. I think one was player-driven economies. So having dabbled slightly in other games like RuneScape and EVE Online, I think having that player-driven economy aspect was really exciting. Other things I was excited about was around community as well. So again, my ex-boss at Garina keeps saying that games are really about community.

SPEAKER_01When I was playing World of War Craft and Final Fantasy XIV. It was all about how you bonded with your guild, you did these incredible heart raids together, and I actually even ended up meeting a lot of them in real life and having dinner and drinks with them as well. So I felt like the way that Web3 was set up was actually very conducive to building these type of communities, and so I wanted to explore that more. Did Garena ever end up producing anything Web3

SPEAKER_04or blockchain related?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I think as most incumbents do, they are taking a more cautious approach which I believe is actually the right approach as well so they're not risking any of their top tier IPs or games again as I actually recommend it because it is a risky and nascent space instead they are taking and experimenting with a few smaller projects out of their innovation hub in Shanghai and also looking to investing into game studios that are experimenting with this technology.

SPEAKER_03Fast forward then why Tezos? What was it

SPEAKER_01about Tezos

SPEAKER_03and their blockchain that made it so enticing?

SPEAKER_01So I spoke to a a few chains before deciding on Tezos. I think what really resonated with me was the attitude of focusing on kind of real world use cases and real value to players. I think we've always been a very serious chain, maybe too serious in some regards, heavily focused on the technology and again, finding the real use cases for blockchain to make games better. So yeah, I think that philosophy was the one that really resonated the most with me. And also, quite frankly speaking, it was a senior role.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, I got to essentially define the strategy for how to grow gaming on Tezos and also build up a team to deliver on this vision.

SPEAKER_04We've actually covered quite a bit with Tezos on their art scene. We know that they have a strong community and we even did a video once with Catherine before. But as for gaming and for our listeners who aren't privy to Tezos, maybe you could just briefly explain what Tezos does and what does this blockchain provide in terms of the gaming aspect and the non-gaming aspect.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. So Tezos is a layer one blockchain where competing against other layer ones like Ethereum and Solana. I think what really sets us apart is our upgradability and the liquid proof of stake system. So our token holders vote on what technical upgrades to implement, which means that we are one of the few truly decentralized chains. On the other side, the liquid proof of stake allows our token holders to keep their tokens liquid and earn rewards and staking rewards while still using them in our dApps.

SPEAKER_01So I think what's really exciting that's coming up is our end enshrined optimistic roll-up strategy. So this enables us to scale while benefiting from the security of our L1. We're going to offer EVM compatibility through EtherLink, as well as working on a JavaScript smart contract, which now opens up smart contract development to a large number of developers across the world. And how does all these take place in terms of gaming in Tezos? I think we believe that blockchain as a technology, it's essentially a decentralized, publicly trusted ledger.

SPEAKER_01And so it doesn't necessarily need to focus on one specific industry. So we have three verticals that we're heavily focusing on. DeFi, arts and culture, and gaming. Right now, Tezos is super secure and it's fast and it's cheap to transact on it, which means that games can build their NFTs and their tokens on Tezos and enable all the things we've also spoken about around interoperability as well as being able to own and trade the items that you buy with an Now, if you're

SPEAKER_04going to get into the Tezos gaming, we know that there are quite a few like partnerships you guys have, some that you have mentioned, notably like Ubisoft and EVE Online, both of which are really like prominent in the gaming scene, right? EVE Online has been a huge MMORPG for a while and Ubisoft, if you're into gaming, they're basically creators of the Assassin's Creed franchise, which is like huge games. And they have been around for so long without blockchain. Why do you think like what has changed? Why are they getting you guys to now start the Web3

SPEAKER_01thing going on? Let me explain a bit more around like what the specifics of the partnerships were so for eve online you memorial you memorialized your kills on chain for one of the big battles so even today you can still see those results and you can also view those as nfts as well you know that was i would say quite a focused partnership it was essentially proof of concept that you could do that and and it so i can buy my kills on the blockchain the nfc so the nfts are minted on chain and you can see those results with the associated name of the player that killed them so it's minted every time someone does a kill close it was minted one time at the end of the battle to commemorate how many kills you did so if the top player that time you had maybe 100 kills during that war and so now you have that forever enshrined and memorialized on the blockchain are all

SPEAKER_03my deaths as well on the blockchain I don't want people to see that it wasn't but we should try to do that next time it's gonna up the stakes you mentioned Ubisoft right so Blockhead wrote a very well crafted article if I may say so a couple years ago about Ubisoft and their venture into Web3 according to Blockhead Ubisoft faced heavy criticism from the gaming community after announcing it would integrate NFTs into its game Ghost Recon Breakpoint Ubisoft's video announcing its NFT project received a 96% dislike rate with comments criticizing the publisher for milking its games so it seems like there's a backlash pretty strong backlash from gamers even again giants such as Ubisoft.

SPEAKER_03So how does that impact what you're doing with Ubisoft and

SPEAKER_01I don't know, have things changed since then? Yeah, so maybe let me explain a bit more around the Ubisoft partnership and then address what you just shared. So Ubisoft essentially worked with us to have Ubisoft Quartz, which was an NFT platform. And the first NFTs there were for a FPS, hardcore FPS game called Ghost Recon. We also acknowledged that, you know, the backlash was bad and even the ultimate success of it was also limited because we realized they were actually targeting the wrong type of users. We were targeting hardcore FPS users, you know, even with these NFTs. that were free and you could only earn them and not buy them, they were also the wrong kind of target audience.

SPEAKER_01So I think right now we've also evolved our thinking a lot to really truly understand who are the most likely players to accept and adopt this technology. And I'll talk a bit more about this throughout this, that we really want to focus on more, I would say, casual players that really are more open to understanding and trying out new things. And also some of the Web3 native folks. I think the hardcore gamer adoption at this stage will likely be quite muted but and of course in a few years down the line it could change the analog i like to use the most is around mobile free-to-play so when mobile free-to-play came out the top games were games like clash of clans and candy crush games that even today some hardcore gamers look at with disdain but these games have you know have hundreds of millions if not a billion players and they make billions of dollars every year and so you know and these things really necessitated that change but the more mobile free-to-play industry has also evolved, right?

SPEAKER_01So in my previous company, Garena, we had a hit game called Garena Free Fire. And so that game also hit hundreds of millions of players with billions of revenue. And that was a Battle Royale FPS built as a mobile-only game. So my takeaway from that is that the first wave of games will look markedly different from what you've seen in the existing gaming space. But then as the technology gets more and more accepted adopted, then all of these things that you've already seen successful in other platforms will move to this technology as well.

SPEAKER_03So how do you monetize a free-to-play game via the blockchain? How is that different to, like you said, like Clash of Clans or Cranny Crush or whatever?

SPEAKER_01Essentially, the first step is still selling the items as in-app purchases, exactly the same as you do it in a Web2 space. I think what is innovative here is that players can then take these items and sell it and resell it within themselves. So that results in two key things. One is that players value the items more, whether they are willing to spend more on it or maybe invest more time to upgrade and build it up. So players are invested into whatever they've bought and they're excited to own it and actually grow it.

SPEAKER_01The second part is an alternative monetization channel for the developers where they can start to monetize the royalties from the buying and selling of these items between players.

SPEAKER_04Besides the big games. You guys also worked on smaller independent studios or games. I've heard of games such as Dogami and Battletaps. Now these are a little bit more different than Ubisoft, for example. So what do these partnerships entail?

SPEAKER_01Our strategy now, we've pivoted heavily away from the esports sponsorships and we're looking much more towards content. Again, finding studios that are building things that resonate with their very focused target audience. So we're also very intentional in out approach so we only you know target 20 high potential partners every year that we want to work very closely with to succeed together so typically like in the case of Dogami and Battletaps you know they're building something as I shared before around relatively blue ocean that you know there are no major web 2 competitors fighting in this space and we feel that there's going to be possibility for widespread acceptance of what they're trying to do by integrating the blockchain and making their game which is also unique a even better.

SPEAKER_03Why do you think that there's such a negative perception of Web3 gaming?

SPEAKER_01So I think it primarily comes from maybe three areas. The first one is the general kind of crypto market. And, you know, when gamers are here to have fun and play games and they see kind of some of the meme coins and some of the, I'd say, like financial speculation going on in the broader crypto market, they get a bit wary because they say, look, I'm here to play games and then maybe I'm willing to pay$100 for a great game. And if it's a free-to-play mobile game, maybe$50 a month to enjoy it.

SPEAKER_01But then I look at this Bitcoin at$60,000 and are you going to start charging me this amount? Do I need to pay all of this? And then they also see the NFT prices, for example, to start playing Axie Infinity at one stage, you needed to invest$1,000,$300 for three NFTs. So in those cases, they immediately felt very threatened almost that this was kind of over-financialization and over-monetization of their favorite hobby. So I think that's the first one. The second one is around the onboarding as well.

SPEAKER_01So it's just incredibly challenging to onboard into WebTree. I think we're starting to make good headway to solving it. But in the past, you know, you had to write down your seed phrase, you had to sign every transaction. There was always a risk of signing a wrong one and getting hacked as well. So, you know, nowadays we have more like abstracted and custom little accounts that can actually smooth that journey out for you at the beginning. For example, like Kukai, a wallet on Tezos, we allow users to socially log in.

SPEAKER_01So the first time user experience feels exactly the same as if you were playing a Web2 game.

SPEAKER_03Playing Devil's Advocate a little bit, there are like 420 million over cryptocurrency users in the world. But yeah, even these guys are skeptical about Web3. gamers. How do you set it to people who are already bought into the whole cryptocurrency Web3 space?

SPEAKER_01So I think the cryptocurrency space with 420 million users, it's definitely an interesting space for us as well. So right now, our thesis is actually targeting two very distinct different types of audiences. Games like Battletabs and Star Symphony and MetaPals, which I'll talk a bit more about later. These games are targeting your existing Web2 fans and Web2 users with a very abstracted blockchain experience so that they can enjoy some of the benefits of the blockchain without the friction and the high cost involved.

SPEAKER_01And so targeting them, these Web2 users, is the first tranche of our strategy. The second one we're exploring is exactly as you mentioned, targeting the existing crypto users. We realized that the players who actually like these games are more financially driven and they don't really want to play like an FPS game or a hardcore MMO that takes up the 30 hours, 40 hours a week. Instead, what they want is maybe a mixture, a little bit of gambling slash social wagering and also a lot around the community aspect and the social social status aspect as well so on that side of things we are still exploring some potential partners but we're particularly excited around like two key genres the first key genre is around slg simulation games so there are successful web 2 games like this such as rise of kingdoms and call of dragons all of which make you know a billion dollars a year in the web 2 space again these are very quite heavily will driven and they also a lot around building strong alliances and then fighting against other strong alliances so we feel that this and the gameplay is really a lot around resource allocation as well so which troops do you train and where do you send them into battle so we feel like this has a very good product market fit with the target audience of crypto users so that's the one area which we're excited about the other area we're excited about is kind of these like more farming games as well we've seen some success on other chains for farming games but we feel like those are extremely similar And if we could actually bring something, a good farming game like Stardew Valley or Hay Day and bring some of those mechanics to crypto, then we could also attract a large player base in that area.

SPEAKER_03But is it as simple as just because there's one in Web 2, just adding a blockchain component will automatically convert people who are already in Web 3 to play these games? Is it that simple?

SPEAKER_01I don't think so. So I think definitely there needs to be a lot of design from the ground up on how to design these games. So, so far, again, honestly, we've seen a lot of people taking, you know, SLG games, slapping on some web tree and hoping it works. And to me, that doesn't work. I think one of the key things that needs to be done is to simplify the complexity. So again, to draw back to the mobile free-to-play example, Clash of Clans is actually a RTS if you squint hard enough, right? The same way, so like StarCraft being a super hardcore and fun and I loved it and I was ranked in it at one stage, but then I couldn't spend seven hours a day watching my replays and playing it.

SPEAKER_01And so I ended up playing Clash of Clans because it gave me that 80% of the strategic depth, but 2% of the time invested and the complexity. And in the same way, I feel like the first successful farming blockchain game, sustainable farming blockchain game, will do the same, where they take away and strip away the need to play hundreds of hours to enjoy it, but there's still that core concept. And then having a little bit of the crypto, I would say the degen aspect as well, would be what serves the target audience the best.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, because I'd agree. I feel like the issue now, though, at least from us as casual gamers, I think that at the core, the game still needs to be really good, right? Because opportunity costs time, right? You can only dedicate a certain amount of time to play video games, and there's so many to choose from. So just because there's a blockchain part of it doesn't mean it's necessarily the key driver, right? So then with that in mind, do you think that maybe marketing it as a blockchain game or crypto game is... counterintuitive like can it not just be like a really good game that also you know has some sort of blockchain thing?

SPEAKER_03Why are these games being marketed as a blockchain game?

SPEAKER_01I think it really goes back to target audience again. So the first category, the Web2 gamers, we don't market those as blockchain games. Maybe to draw an example, so we have a partner called Metapels. What they do is AI pet companions that are also unique because of the blockchain, right? So in the same way, we felt like having a digital pet companion would be really valuable and people would love it. But, you know, having... just 1,000 of them that look exactly the same would not be great because then you lose that feeling of specialty because your pet is yours and it's unique.

SPEAKER_01So we use the blockchain to make each of these pets unique. And so I think that's one of the examples of the use case where it's quite abstracted from the user, but if they want to make sure that that pet they've been taking care of for the past year is theirs, they can always check and verify that it's theirs and it's unique. So in the first bucket, the games are not marketed as as blockchain, it's also very abstracted. So when you create an account and you buy an NFT on MetaPals, it's all abstracted from you. But when you want to take care and take over it and maybe trade some of the cosmetics that you've bought for your pet with your other friends, then you can take control of your account and then do the trading then.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think we're fairly familiar with MetaPals. We had Daryl, I think he co-founded MetaPals, if I'm not wrong. He spoke in Blockhouse about how it's going to help mental health and stuff and calm people down and everything. So it seems like it's a good game for sure. Are there any other mass market games that... on your horizon or that you feel breaking boundaries in this regard?

SPEAKER_01I think one other game would be Star Symphony. So this is a rhythm game where, you know, you're controlling some anime characters similar to that similar style to Genshin Impact, but it's more kind of a rhythm game similar to like Beat Star and Bang Dream from Japan. So what really sets it apart is focusing on the user generated content aspect, which I believe, you know, we've seen Web 2 on Web 2 side games like Roblox and even fortnite creative mode have done a great job there but on the music side of things you know we want musicians to make music for this game to you know add more content as well but also serve as a platform for discoverability and also get rewarded for creating content for this for this game so to that end star symphony essentially you can come in as a player or musician for a musician you can create music for star symphony those tracks will be minted as nfts you can you know decide on the number to be minted and you will also receive royalties whenever those tracks are being played, and players are spending money on those tracks.

SPEAKER_01And as a player, you get a wide access to a wide variety of musicians, many of them local, and you can support your local musicians as well, while at the same time enjoying a really fun game.

SPEAKER_04So for these kind of games, do you guys actually build them, develop them with their team, or are you just providing a level of support for them to be on your blockchain and platform?

SPEAKER_01We work very closely with them. We provide maybe four key levels of support. One is strategy, one is marketing and then technical. And then finally, we provide some funding as well. So in the strategy side, for example, for Battletabs, they were deciding what to do for the NFT launch and also whether or not to do a token. So we have been closely advising them on how exactly to set this up and what the NFT should and should not be able to do. Similarly, on the technical side, being a Web2 studio, they were with obviously Web3 aspirations, they needed some help on the technical side on how to mint those NFTs and also navigates some of the legal complexities around it.

SPEAKER_01So we have also really sat down closely with them and worked closely to work through these issues. On the marketing side of things, we also want to make sure that our projects get initial influx of players. So recently, last week, we did an influencer mega space with two big influencers with hundreds of thousands of followers each and brought on three of our good partners, Metapel, Sugar Gaming, BattleRise, which is a RPG, match-free PVP, and digital AI company. So during the AMA, we had 15,000 listeners and we managed to draw a lot of attention to our partners in our ecosystem as well.

SPEAKER_01Finally, on the funding side, we do provide investments and grants to our partners as well. We believe game making is expensive. We want to help there. At the same time, we are not there to provide all the funds from beginning to the end. So we typically work with studios that have either already raised funding as well or have a very high likelihood of finding funding from the external capital markets as well.

SPEAKER_04So when these games release, they will be pushed to the normal retail crowd from now onwards? That's the strategy that you were talking about earlier, right?

SPEAKER_01So I'd say specifically for MetaPals and Star Symphony, they will be pushed towards the retail crowd, so people who love IPs like Hello Kitty and Teletubbies, which MetaPals is working with officially, and also for Star Symphony, people who love music rhythm games but want to have more local music and not just play your big hits, but also what your local musicians.

SPEAKER_03They play it on my browser, right?

SPEAKER_01So, Better Pals right now is browser. They are... likely to expand over the next year as they grow traction, but it's a good fit because the MetaPals themselves are something that you interact with throughout your work day. You can feed them, pet them, play with them, and they will be able to jump around your screen and point out certain things if you want to allow them to do that as well. For Star Symphony, it's a mobile game. It will be a mobile first launch because I think that's where the majority of their target audience is.

SPEAKER_03Like the App Store and the

SPEAKER_01Google

SPEAKER_03Play Store. Is there any adventure into console gaming from the Web3 gaming

SPEAKER_01space? So it's not an area which we're looking into deeply right now. I think, again, for two reasons. One is the hardcore players are not our target audience as of this time. When you say

SPEAKER_03hardcore, how do you define hardcore?

SPEAKER_01So I'd say, you know, people who are, there are certain genres like FPS, FPS primarily, where we don't see it as a super strong fit for the blockchain at this moment. You know, there are obviously some adjacent use cases like skin trading, which we are excited about. But to like integrate it deeply into the FPS is something that's a bit less exciting for us at the moment.

SPEAKER_03Because there's a lot of like casual gamers. I feel like casual gamers actually make up the majority of console games. games, right?

SPEAKER_01So I think right now, and I got to take a bit of a closer look at the statistics, my... Yeah, I might be wrong. I'm just... Yeah, impression. I

SPEAKER_03just, just like on an anecdotal note, right? Everyone that I know has a PlayStation or Xbox or whatever, you kind of play like games casually, right? I know what you mean by hardcore, but I guess my point is that there's not just hardcore gamers that are playing console games, there's a wide breadth of gamers as well that you could have access to, right? So I'm wondering why there's no venture into the console side or, you know, even like PC games on like the Microsoft Xbox store or whatever, right? There's no interest there from the Web3 gamers point of view?

SPEAKER_01I haven't thought too deeply about this. My initial view was that firstly, I think console games tend to be more single player. And when you're single player games, the blockchain has vastly reduced use cases. And then for the top games there, you know, again, I think it is mainly quite hardcore in the sense that, you know, you're sitting there and you're playing for hours at a time. And it's typically quite hardcore. I would say that, again, it's not something I've looked into too deeply. I think it's worth exploring for sure. It could be a cool new idea.

SPEAKER_01Now,

SPEAKER_04you mentioned like skin, trading skins and ownership over items, which is something that we often hear a lot when we talk to like Web3 gamers. But like most of the traditional gamers or their opinion, casual gamers, like they don't really because they can already trade the items, but it's not on the blockchain. So they're just trading it with like in-game money and in-game cash, I guess. But what does the blockchain actually bring to the table that the Web2 aspect doesn't actually. Do you have any opinions or thoughts on that?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, definitely. So I think one part is really around being able to sell what you've earned and what you've paid for and earned in a secondary market in a safe manner. So for me, I played again World of Warcraft and two examples. One is I did some of the auction house trading based on data mining to try to play and that part was really fun but at the end of the day it was just all within the game and the second part was you know i had a very strong warlock with a lot a couple of legendary equipments you know when i quit the game you know i was thinking yeah what can i actually do with this right it's i still have it and although it's obsolete now but yeah so so you know actually being able to to trade and sell these characters to other other players i think would be quite valuable i think to me that's the main case of the of it and the second one probably is around the community building as well so i think there's this idea that you know if Essentially, there are limited editions of NFTs.

SPEAKER_01In the same way, there are certain skins today within League of Legends, for example, Black Alistar skin, which was, I think, only 10,000 people in the world or 10,000 accounts in the world own. So having these limited amounts, again, verified and ensured by the blockchain to make sure that no other new ones can be minted for the series, I think it's something that's quite powerful in creating viscosity and high-value goods.

SPEAKER_04I guess as a casual game or a traditional game, most of the time we don't hear much about like these blockchain games is that a reason why or is this going to change or what are we

SPEAKER_01expecting so as a now strategy is to abstract a blockchain so essentially you know making it really easy for them to to get started 20 20 seconds to create account and and actually start playing the game the strategy here is to you know you know get them to play and then if they're spending the game they accrue some value into their account and then eventually stepping in and taking control and custody of their assets once they realize how valuable it is. And I think that's really our strategy right now.

SPEAKER_01Is play to earn dead? Is it dead? I have a lot of thoughts on this. I feel like your traditional play to earn is dead because it's unsustainable. Ultimately, you need someone to actually pay money, right? There are a few paths forward, and maybe I'll just draw a few key points in a not particularly structured way. First one, I think, is in the case of Axie Infinity, there was a certain use case where there were managers who were buying these Axies, and you could argue that they were actually quite willing to pay money in order for the fund of managing scholars, right?

SPEAKER_01And I would say, you know, in case of play-to-earn, football players are play-to-earn. Cristiano Ronaldo plays football and earns money, right? And then there's your Alex Ferguson's and your football team managers so there's an argument here that you know there might be players who are willing to spend money in order to buy these NFTs and rent them out and have that management game management feeling which again they are willing to pay for and that creates a sustainable ecosystem because these players are willing to spend obviously if they do really well they have an upside but net net each of them is is paying for the privilege and then they play to earn users who are enjoying the game and earning money and then the developers who are getting a cut of those transactions So I think that is one sustainable model.

SPEAKER_01The other one is more like the win to earn side of things, where essentially it's a bit of wagering on your own capabilities and skill. And so that creates a sustainable economy because the rewards will never outstrip whatever players put into the game. Are these being worked on? Yeah, absolutely. So we have one project called Coin Blast. It's essentially focused on social wagering. So we're starting out with trivia, but we have games like Bingo and Solitaire coming as well. Taken reference from the big US public company called Skills.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, they essentially do something similar, but on Web2. But we feel the Web3 version essentially allows greater liquidity of players across the globe. Also slightly easier, lower friction in terms of transactions. And then finally, we can also implement unique things like NFTs as membership passes, et cetera, to add further value.

SPEAKER_04Now that we are talking about Web3, we know that there are a lot of hacks and scams going around in the industry. So if you're going to bring Web3 into gaming, how do we prevent these sort of things from happening? Is there some sort of precautions developers are creating to prevent all these hacks and scams?

SPEAKER_01I think I'll make three points here. One is quite straightforward, is to keep it simple. When you're having a token that can be used to upgrade your NFTs. I think that's quite straightforward. When you start doing multi-tokens and all these sort of things, then it opens up your game to a lot more risks. If you are trying something new and, you know, we always encourage innovation as well, then you just get an audit, right? It's expensive, but you should get an audit. The final part I'd say is if you look at like Ruonan's previous hack, for example, is to keep it truly decentralized.

SPEAKER_01And again, shilling a bit for Tezos, but, you know, the foundation itself only owns 10% of the tokens and it's liquid proof of stake. So at the end of the day, you know, if you're holding so much funds like, you know, Axie Infinity was, you know, you shouldn't have it behind a multi-sig with, you know, only a few signatories with a lot of contagion risk. So keep it decentralized, keep it simple and audit it if you don't.

SPEAKER_04cool how are you guys like intending to let's say educate casual gamers who are perhaps you know the first thing they see is like oh this game has like web 3 or blockchain aspects it's probably not something i want to dabble into because of like security risk and all that how do you guys intend to overcome like these sort of problems

SPEAKER_01back back to the target audience if you're targeting the web 2 users who are not as familiar with this typically we our strategy is to is to keep it keep the prices low right again this is not something that you go in as a crypto investor and you know put a$10,000 on the first day, you're saying, look, Metapels, the min price is likely to be$15 to$50, right? So easily affordable for most people. And so, you know, the utilities is apparent on day one, right? You're not selling a promise like many crypto projects are.

SPEAKER_01They actually have a digital pad that already works. And so the moment you buy it, you can use it. And it's just like buying a web2 product almost. In those cases, by keeping the volumes low or the cost low, and then just onboarding the in a streamlined way. I think that helps a lot. And of course, you know, as they love this more, they might end up, you know, buying lots of cosmetics at$10 a pop. They will start trading and the company will earn royalties as well. And so once all of this is in place, they actually might end up having accounts that are worth quite a lot in the same way that, you know, some of my mobile game accounts are probably worth like$1,000, which I spent there.

SPEAKER_01So in those cases, then you start realizing, oh, hey, actually there's something here and maybe I better start, you know, taking control and custody of my account because especially if I want to trade them.

SPEAKER_04Awesome. Is MetaPals out now?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so you can actually download and get the basic pets. There's a Shiba, a cute cat, and a rabbit. But the Teletubbies one is still... I have it right now actually on my computer because I have early access. So it's in your background right now? It's on my browser, yeah. So you open the browser and it's just hopping around in the browser? Yeah, I can feed it, I can pet it, play with it, and I can bring it to a sanctuary where I can meet other... other people's pets as well I

SPEAKER_04see sounds like a good game to play at work because

SPEAKER_01you're not actually playing you're just running it on the browser yeah yeah you know whenever I feel stressed and I see this little thing running around and making stupid faces I feel quite happy awesome man

SPEAKER_04alright I guess we can sort of like wrap things up so we got like perhaps one last one for you where do you see like web 3 gaming in the current future like is it something that you think has the potential to replace web 2 gaming or you know like is it meant to like work together

SPEAKER_03yeah we can see triple a Web3 games? Is that going to happen?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I think in the very short term, again, the innovation will be driven mostly from new genres, maybe genres we can't even have a name for today, just like social deduction was among us, and before among us there was no term for it, right? So the short-term innovation will be driven by new genres and new ideas. In the longer term, I think it will work together in a way that the blockchain will start to replace some key parts and enable some player use cases, like again, the player trading and maybe interoperability, being able to use your items across different gaming experiences.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, definitely working together. At the end of the day, blockchain is a technology. And so in the same way that companies use AI or they use distributed servers, they will use blockchain as a technology to make their games.

SPEAKER_03Is there a correlation between the cryptocurrency market with gamers, yeah, like with the amount of people engaging and downloading and playing the games? Is there a correlation there?

SPEAKER_01So, yeah, I think I said this five times, but I think it's a really important question. So it's a target audience, right? So your Web2 gamers are maybe not as closely linked to the crypto market, so they care about the use case. When you see a Teletubby that's cute, they want to buy it,$15, they buy it, right? And there's nothing to do with the crypto market. For the Web3 games, as I mentioned, around the SLG and the farming games, absolutely, right? I think when they see the uptake and they get excited, more retail investors come in, Bitcoin halving news, and then Bitcoin price goes up, which means people have a bit more money to try and degen into other things as well.

SPEAKER_01Then for those type of Web3 games, definitely it's highly dependent on the state of the market.

SPEAKER_04Will you guys be scared or afraid the crypto market will affect the adoption of your games like Star Symphony, Metapulse? For example, if the market is bad, do you think it's going to affect you guys and how you guys, is

SPEAKER_01there some sort of strategy or... thought behind this? So I think for Metapels and Star Symphony, I think we're quite comfortable because again, these target audiences, Web2 users, who again are not really affected by the crypto prices when they make a purchasing decision. For the Web3 games, a couple of which we're exploring, maybe even the social wagering game where you're essentially wagering with Tez, then in those cases, yes, we are worried. The biggest risk is if the prices crash too quickly, then it kind of sets into a death spiral, right?

SPEAKER_01So when time are good we encourage our partners to set aside even like some form of stability fund so that in case where the price of their tokens crash too quickly they're able to at least maintain some level for some time and that tends to prevent projects from completely failing in a span of days.

SPEAKER_03So then the skins or assets or whatever that I've minted on the blockchain through the game that I've paid for are those prices reflected in the cryptocurrency market as well?

SPEAKER_01So the prices of the NFT that you have bought. For some cases, yes. So like if you look at Dogami, which is kind of the hybrid, the middle ground, where, you know, each of the NFTs is$100. So it's slightly more expensive than, you know, a typical gamer would spend. Like for me, you know,$100 is like a AAA game. So we always think of it from that lens. But at the same time, it's not like your$10,000 NFTs as well. So in those cases, the crypto market prices have caused the NFT prices to decrease.

SPEAKER_01But at the end of the day, there are people still... coming in to play those games because the auto racing game is fun and they're earning a little bit of money from there as well so yeah the prices do fall kind of in conjunction with the market but maybe not as much and also because people are just using it day to day yeah

SPEAKER_03because then I guess the counter argument is that web 2 games the stuff that you could buy and the platforms that they have that they can sell skins or whatever on they're not subject to anything right other than supply and demand in that sense and irrespective if it's on the blockchain or not then the asset is still more significant to cure. because it's not vulnerable to the crypto market.

SPEAKER_01I think enabling, you know, truly player-driven economies is very difficult for isolated system. So if you think about Diablo 3, for example, the real money auction house, they tried and experimented. I think firstly, there were some game core mechanic kind of mistakes around implementation, but also, you know, not really opening it up and allowing free flow of people to buy and sell these items was one of the weaknesses of this. So yeah, I think, you know, it needs to be obviously designed well and secure, but enabling players to buy and sell these items on a blockchain, on a public trusted blockchain is actually a net benefit to the gamers.

SPEAKER_04All right. What is Tezos booking on next?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I think, you know, we're continuing our focus. We're finding innovative games, meaningful, innovative games that are integrating blockchain in a meaningful way. We're providing, you know, full support for them across strategy, marketing, technical and funding. You know, we have exciting games coming up coming out soon. We have MetaPals, so they're Teletubbies NFTs in the next couple of months. We have BattleRise, which is an innovative roguelike RPG. The token launch is coming in a couple of months as well. And of course, like Star Symphony and BattleTabs, which we've spoken about already.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you know, I think we'll have more and more top quality games coming. And I think the hope and the goal for us is to make sure that any game you play on Tezos, especially those that are, you know, that we work closely with is enjoyable and fun experience. And And yeah, I think you can learn more. You can follow us on at Tezos and myself at Foo for Fun. And we hope to bring you more exciting

SPEAKER_03things. Have you got a game that's got a bigger horizon that you're really excited about? What's your GTA 6?

SPEAKER_01So I don't think we will see a GTTA 6 equivalent, but I feel, again, talking about MetaPals, that with their partnerships with Hello Kitty and Teletubbies and a few more that are very close to signing, there's so much audience that would love it, right? And so this could be the Candy Crush of Web3 in the same way that was, and so this really opens it up to the 60 million Hello Kitty fans in the world. Yeah, Hello Kitty is huge. And so I think that's the one that could be our Candy Crush. crash.

SPEAKER_01We don't have a GTA, but we have a Candy Crush. Good enough. Okay, man. That's it for today.

SPEAKER_04Thanks, everyone, for listening. And thanks again, Jeremy, for hopping on to our episode of Blogcast. Thanks, everyone. Bye. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Licensed to Shill: AI Agents Will Need Their Own Court System | Albert Castellana, GenLayer Labs

    Nov 20, 202632 minAudio

    Albert Castellana, co-founder and CEO of GenLayer Labs, joins Licensed to Shill to argue that the agentic economy needs a neutral way to settle disputes. As AI agents get wallets, passwords and spending authority, he...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Licensed to Shill: Thailand's New Wave of Crypto Beyond Its Beaches | Didi Wiboonma, Bitazza

    Nov 10, 202653 minAudio

    Didi Wiboonma, Chief Communications Officer and founding team member at Thai exchange Bitazza, joins the show to discuss how crypto took hold in Thailand. Her argument is that the industry’s next phase depends on people...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Licensed to Shill: There Is No Tokenized Finance Without Tokenized Liquidity | Emma Pecenicic, Fidelity International

    Oct 30, 202639 minAudio

    Emma Pecenicic leads digital assets at Fidelity International, where she oversees crypto ETP distribution and the firm’s tokenization work. In this episode, she argues that tokenized liquidity is the first layer of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Licensed to Shill: Tokenised Stocks, Stonks and the Case for Self-Custody | Alvin Kan, Bitget Wallet and Renna Ba, Morph

    Oct 23, 202635 minAudio

    Alvin Kan of Bitget Wallet and Renna Ba of Morph join the show during TOKEN2049 week to talk through the boom in tokenised stocks. Their argument is that tokenised equities have grown from synthetic experiments into...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Licensed to Shill: Taiwan's Banks and AI Hardware Makers Could Fuel Asia's Largest Stablecoin Corridor | Justin Wang, Capital Layer

    Sep 2, 202635 minAudio

    Justin Wang, CEO of Capital Layer, a Taiwan-based stablecoin infrastructure provider helping banks integrate stablecoin rails into their existing systems, joins the show this week, arguing that the next wave of...

    Credit the people on this episode