Lying on your resume when everyone else seems to be getting ahead? Struggling with reference dilemmas when your boss left on bad terms? Or maybe you've accidentally discovered your company's secret layoff plans and don't know whether to warn your colleagues? This week, we're diving into resume ethics, reference nightmares, and the ultimate workplace moral dilemma in our season finale. What you'll learn: • Resume Ethics Reality Check: Why changing your job title from "Marketing Intern" to "Marketing Coordinator" crosses the line from embellishment to lying, plus how to showcase expanded responsibilities without fabricating your actual role • Reference Dilemma Solutions: Navigating tricky reference situations when bosses leave badly, whether you can use junior colleagues as references, and how to politely decline being someone's reference when they weren't great at their job • The Ultimate Workplace Bombshell: What to do when you accidentally discover massive layoffs are coming while your colleagues are buying houses and planning weddings - should you warn them and risk your career, or stay silent? Plus: A follow-up on sick leave rights - why Australian employees are never legally required to find their own replacement when calling in sick, even if it's written into their contract. Welcome to BIZ Inbox, your go-to workplace advice podcast where awkward career questions get real-world solutions. Got office politics nightmares or boss-from-hell situations? Send us a voice note or email us at podcast@mamamia.com.au. You can remain completely anonymous! SHOW MENTIONS: BIZ: The Exact Script To Calling In Sick Get more Sarah Davidson in her sensational podcast Seize The Yay! Sign up to the BIZ newsletter here to get all our tips and tricks. THE END BITS Support independent women's media Follow the Biz Instagram and Sarah's very own podcast: Seize The Yay Podcast. HOSTS: Sarah Davidson and Em Vernem SENIOR PRODUCER: Sophie Campbell AUDIO PRODUCER: Leah Porges Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1You're listening to Amma mea podcast.
Speaker 2Hello, and welcome back to Biz Inbox.
Speaker 1I'm a Burnam and I'm Sarah Davidson, and today we're talking about resume ethics, specifically when everyone around you seems to be bending the truth and getting ahead because of it. Oh my god, that is an absolute toughye.
Speaker 2Plus, we are going to be solving some reference dilemmas. We've talked about references a few times in Biz Inbox. We've got a big one today because this one will make you a question everything you thought you knew about the process, including what to do when people who should vouch for you don't.
Speaker 1And we are finishing with an absolute bombshell. Somebody has accidentally stumbled onto information that could change their colleagues lives forever, but sharing it could destroy their own career. Oh my gosh, it's a biz Inbox puzzle and I can't wait to get into it.
Speaker 2So inducing this will be our best question for the whole season. But before we jump into the questions today, so we have a follow up from our episode about calling in sick. If you haven't listened to that episode, we'll put a link to it in our show notes. And this is what Fiona has responded with.
Speaker 3Hi, mamamir Biz, I have just listened to the episode about calling in sick, and I have another follow up question. My daughter works for a small business as a dance teacher, and the owner of the business enforces a rule that anybody who's sick must find a replacement for themselves, otherwise they need to come in and teach the class. And I'm just wondering about the legality or what the industry relations says in this regard. Is it the staff member's
Speaker 3responsibility if that's written into contract for themselves to find a replacement if they're unwell, or is it the business owner's responsibility?
Speaker 1Thank you?
Speaker 2Oh oh. I mean, if one person to us have to give Lee your advice, it's not going to be me, I'm telling you right now.
Speaker 1Well, firstly, I mean, we love an audio submission. I am so sad that it took until the season finale to get one of these, But guys, please send more of these in because we will be back at some point to answer them for you. Fiona, this is a really tough situation and very very common, I think for employees to feel a bit disempowered when it comes to businesses just enforcing rules and you feeling like you don't necessarily have the right to question it. But absolutely, in Australia, the legal responsibility to find a replacement when you call
Speaker 1in sick does not fall on the employee, even if her business, your daughter's business, sounds like they are trying to enforce that. This is governed by the Fair Work Act two thousand and nine. If you want to go and look further into the reference. When an employee is generally sick or injured, they're entitled to paid personal or cares leave and they do not have a legal obligation to find someone to cover their shift. And that's if they're a permanent employee. So of course, yes, you do have to notify your employer as soon as possible. They
Speaker 1can request reasonable evidence like a medical certificate, but you are not legally required to find a replacement. Now, it is the case that some workplaces have their own internal policies or informal expectations around finding replacements that they might communicate to you. For example, in a small business, if there's not very many of you, they kind of might suggest that you could help find or maybe contact someone else to cover the shift, especially if it's a more casual or roster based work, like I know in a lot of hospitality businesses, they might ask if you could
Speaker 1call around to some of your colleagues. But even if there are employment contracts that say otherwise or kind of have additional provisions that require that of you, they can't override the minimum standards in that fair work app So even if your employer expects it, they cannot legally require it as a condition for you getting your sick leave. So if you do need further help with that, you could, of course let them know. But if you need any further help, there are some amazing official sources like the Fair Work Ombitsman who can help you further to sort
Speaker 1of help you feel equipped to deal with going back to your boss.
Speaker 2Oh my god, what great advice, Fiona. What I want you to do right now is take this biz episode and just play it to your employer. Actually play it in front of the whole company.
Speaker 1Just play my voice to them, say here's my lawyer, here's my lawyer.
Speaker 2Take it away, Sarah, and then just.
Speaker 1Play literally this is a personal voice note that she sent me on her build time.
Speaker 2Oh I love love love that advice. Good luck, Fiona, and know you're right girl. Okay, speaking of workplace rules that make you question everything, I want to dive into our first question. It's all about the unspoken rules of resume writing and whether we should be playing by them. So Meg dm us this and it's literally got me questioning everything I know about resume honesty. So she says, I just finished a marketing internship where I was basically doing coordinator level work, running campaigns, presenting to clients everything.
Speaker 2My official title was marketing intern, but that sounds so junior compared to what I actually did. Job titles are completely made up anyway, And if recruiters are searching for marketing coordinator, not marketing intern, why should I miss out on opportunities because of some arbitrary label. My friends have definitely lied about their titles before and nothing happened. Isn't this just speaking the recruiters language, rather than being held back by a title I didn't even choose?
Speaker 1Great question, I want to say.
Speaker 2I feel like a lot of titles are basically just labels. I have seen people get away with like a little edit on their job title on a LinkedIn page or on a resume and they've gotten away with it. The only thing that I feel like might burn you is if you are applying for jobs at a new company and you change your title on it, but you have references from people at your current company who can vouch for you. I feel like that might go a bit left sided if you push that agenda and they call
Speaker 2your references and they're like, oh, she was an intern, she wasn't a coordinator. Like even though it's just something so small and minute, as someone who's like recruiting you, if you hear that and the first thing they hear is like a straight up lie, that will give a bad taste of them, and then you try and explain that to them after they find out, we'll just feel like you're just covering for yourself. So I feel like you just have to be really, really careful in those situations. If you're actively looking for a job.
Speaker 1Yeah, one hundred percent. I feel like it is expected that most people are embellishing to them maximum capacity that you have. Like, of course, the resume is putting your best foot forward, so you're going to be delivering it in the most positive light that you can. But I think there is a very clear delineation between embellishment and then actually editing the truth of the role that you had. Like I think in the description of what you do, you can drum up what you've been doing. But I
Speaker 1think downright, just changing the role that you had, like literally changing the title and position that you occupied in that role, strays into that's not true. Like there's a difference between the scale of what you did versus what it was actually called. And I think if it strays into yeah, like you said, if it's a strays into a lie, then it's unethical. Whereas if you're just talking up, you know, the responsibilities that you had and expressing them in the most positive language that you can, I think
Speaker 1that's different. Like I've been a serial resume patterer my entire life. I have always wanted to put my best foot forward and show the breadth of the different things that I've done. But if it came to actually changing the title of one of those opportunities or roles, that's where I would draw the line, particularly because you can get caught out. But even if you can't, I feel like it's just not the role you had.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's so true. And I also feel like if you're applying to roles and you're saying that you're a marketing intern but you're doing a coordinator level role, you can still apply for those marketing coordinator roles. Like, there are a lot of companies that want to invest in junior talent to help build them up so they can like learn on their job and then reach new heights. And I feel like you're still within your right to completely apply for those roles if you believe that you can do them. Don't feel like that your label as an intern is kind of like a red mark, Like it's not. In fact, it's like such a good way
Speaker 2to like show companies that you're willing to go above and beyond your job title, which is exactly what you did, and that you can show that off in your resume.
Speaker 1Yeah, one hundred percent. You can also use the description. Often you will have a cover letter when you're applying, and that's the context where you can say, my position was technically intern, but I was given an extraordinary level of responsibility. And this you know, you can elaborate in other places, but I think just to assume that because your responsibilities were greater than your role, that you're allowed to just change the name of the role is probably where it becomes a little bit if he.
Speaker 2Our next question is about job references, which I feel like goes hand in hand with resumes, but I feel like it's one of the ones that we get most asked about, like actual references. So we got this email by Riley and it basically asks every single reference question you've ever had, So it's going to be a meaty one. She says, I have so many questions about references, and I'm honestly confused about the whole process. My boss left on really bad terms, and now I'm the only manager left. Everyone else is below me in the hierarchy. Should I
Speaker 2ask my old boss even though she left badly? Can I ask someone who's technically junior to me? Now? And when someone asks me to be their reference, how do I politely say no if they weren't actually good at their job? Also, what's the protocol? Do I send them the specific job description I'm applying for or just ask if they'll be a general reference? How will I even test if someone will be a good reference for me? Oh?
Speaker 1We need an episode on references for this question?
Speaker 2Oh my god, Raley, you're going through a reference spiral or.
Speaker 1Really good questions, though I think really common really.
Speaker 2Good questions are references are something that I haven't thought about in years. I'm also quite offended then no one's ever asked me to be a reference to them.
Speaker 1Look, I think to address the first part about your boss leaving on really bad terms, that's a really difficult one, but I think it really depends on whether they left on really bad terms with you or they left on really bad terms with the company.
Speaker 3Because I was going to.
Speaker 2Say the same thing.
Speaker 1If they left on really bad terms and it was nothing to do with your relationship, I think they can definitely still vouch for you, because the whole point is that they're speaking to your skill set, and if they're a reference on your resumes, usually because you're applying somewhere else that's not the company that they left. So I think that if they can still speak to your skill set and they still can vouch for all the things that you did do in the company, and that's got nothing to do with their relationship with that company, especially if you are applying for a third party company, there's
Speaker 1no reason why they can't still be a really good reference for you, especially if you trust it they won't go rogue and sort of start speaking badly about the actual business. I think that depends on the situation of what those bad terms are. And yes, you should absolutely still ask them if you do think they can keep that relationship with the business separate. As for asking someone who's junior to you, I probably wouldn't recommend that. I'm sure it's been done, but I think the more authority and breadth of what someone can speak to about the
Speaker 1way that you you performed your responsibilities, I don't think it's really the done thing to get that from someone underneath you. I think it's more to come from a leadership perspective, and that it would be much stronger if it did come from an old boss.
Speaker 2Yeah, and you also don't need to just get references from the company or currently working at yas like you could branch out and ask like a boss from a different company, or like a coworker who's now been promoted to a higher level at a different company that you previously worked at. I feel like so many people think that it has to be the exact company that you've come from and going to a new job, and that is completely untrue. It's just anyone who've ever worked with in your past who can vouch for you as a person as well as your work ethic.
Speaker 1Yeah. Absolutely, And that kind of links to the last part of the question about testing if someone will be a good reference for you. I think you can gauge that by the relationship that you have with them, and also by their general level of eloquence or attention to detail that they give to the work that they do. I think you get a sense of who will give you a really glowing reference who won't. And I would definitely go you don't want it to be too far into the past, because I think recruiters do want there to be some level of currency. But I would go for the strongest versus the most recent if they weren't
Speaker 1the same person.
Speaker 2Yeah, for sure, and definitely give them a heads up, like you don't want your recruited to be cold calling, like your coworkers going, hey, do you have fifteen minutes is spare to talk about this person?
Speaker 1Yeah? And when you give them that heads up, I would definitely send the specific job description because I would want them to be speaking to the skills that are relevant to that job and not just kind of going on about she's really good at looking after her dog, she's great at, you know, helping me keill my hair. Like, not that anyone would go that rogue, but I think it the more context they have, the better chance they have to help you in that specific application. And it could be different for I've got references who have been my reference for very different kinds of jobs, and them
Speaker 1knowing what the job is helps them tailor what they say to make it stronger for me as well, because usually reference wants you to do really well, so you've got to arm them with the most information that you can. In a flip situation, when you're asked to be a reference and you don't feel like you can give a really good reference, that is a very very difficult question. But I think it is probably best to say no rather than to accept and then not really know what to say, because the expectation is that you're going to
Speaker 1say something lovely. I don't know. I mean I would probably say something like as a policy, I don't really give references like. There's probably nice ways to say it other than I think you were really bad at your job. What would you do?
Speaker 2Oh, it's so so hard if it was someone that I was like, no, you were a horrible person, a horror like really really bad, I would say no, I don't think I'm the best person fit to give you a reference, and it would be a very hard conversation. And I feel like it has to be someone that you're okay with not being like your enemy, I guess for the rest of your life, like they'll probably hate you. But if it's someone that I felt like could do a good job, I'd say yes, and I'd do the reference,
Speaker 2but I'd still be quite honest, Like I wouldn't be overly glowing and overly enthusiastic about that person. I'll be like, I'll be quite honest with like the way they work. Because it's also your reputation on the line, right, Like it all comes back to you. Like if you give someone who was like I guess okay a reference, that's like they're the best person in the world, Like they're so good at their job, they're going to be amazing, Versus if you're like, they did their job, they were great. There were some issues, but overall, I'm glad that I was able to work with them. I think that is way better for both of you than lying.
Speaker 1Essentially, if I knew that they expected me to say something really, really positive and I wasn't able to genuinely say that and put my name to it, I think I would have to say no. I wouldn't just say yes and then not say a nice thing, yes, I'll do it.
Speaker 2They were horrible for me.
Speaker 1I personally I wouldn't be able to do that. But I also I'm not very good at saying no, so I know it's a really hard one.
Speaker 2It's really hard. Okay, I was complaining about no one asking me to be their reference, but maybe no. Okay, our final question, I feel like this is the wildest question we've had in biz inbox history, and I actually don't know what my advice would be for again, let's go. It's an anonymous one, so you just know already it's so wild. I found out my company is planning massive
Speaker 2layoffs in January, but I overheard this by accident in a meeting I wasn't supposed to be in. My entire team has no idea, and they're all making big financial decisions, buying houses, planning weddings. One person just had a baby. I'm dying inside watching them live their lives without knowing what's coming up. Do I warn them and risk getting fired myself? Do I stay quiet and let them get blindsided? And honestly, should I be job hunting right now even though I might not be on the list. I feel
Speaker 2like I'm sitting on a bomb and I don't know what to do with this information.
Speaker 1I am spiraling just hearing this scenario. I'm scared, and it's such a tough one. Like that is a dilemma, that is a serious.
Speaker 2Dilimma, actual dilemma. I want to know the like logistics of how you were in a meeting that you weren't supposed.
Speaker 1To be yeah, oh my gosh.
Speaker 2Like was it the situation where you were in the meeting and they suddenly realized that we shouldn't be discussing this with this person in the meeting or was it like you were on call, or like you overheard it through like another room or something like that. I think that can provide the ethics outline of what you should do next.
Speaker 1I kind of feel like it also depends on what your level of seniority is as well, because if you are in like er management, for example, and you were in the meeting where the layoffs were being planned, and you're part of that upper strategic management, it kind of is part of your role to not deliver that news before the company is going to deliver that news. There's strategy around that, and there's a reason why upper management is kept abreast of those plans and why everyone else isn't.
Speaker 1If you're a junior on the same level as everyone else who is sort of part of that layoff and who is going to be laid off, there's less of an expectation that A you're not supposed to know, but B it's not like a business strategy for you to keep it a secret. I think it's a little bit different, Like I think there are much higher expectations of secrecy on senior management versus everyone else. I personally would find it really really difficult to not share that information with
Speaker 1people who are making huge financial decisions around me. That's my internal moral compass. But I also feel like it's confidential, sort of very sensitive commercial information.
Speaker 2I'm the same, I'd find it really hard to not tell my coworkers, especially watching them go through massive financial planning like having a baby, buying houses, planning weddings like that's like life destroying news. For like those like life moments, I would almost.
Speaker 1Coffront the company first. I feel I would.
Speaker 2Almost say that, like I would go to that meaning you weren't supposed to be and like whoever was running it be like, hey, what the hell?
Speaker 1Yeah? I would almost Should I be looking for a new.
Speaker 2Job right now? Should I be telling other people?
Speaker 1Yeah? Should people know? Yeah? I kind of feel like the way to resolve the real tension between this could also really adversely affect the company and big financial interests on their level if I say something, and also it really affects everyone else. The middle ground is let the company know that you overheard, because you know, guys, that's your fault that you kind of I didn't keep a lid on the information, but I have it now and I don't know what to do. I haven't delivered the news to everyone else yet, but I feel like it's out of the bag. You know what's going on, and
Speaker 1then at least you can maybe get some guidance on how sensitive the information is. Maybe you can give them a chance to deliver it themselves so you don't have to be the messenger. But bring forward the timeline because they know that there's a ticking time bomb. Perhaps it is a situation where you go to HR and say, look, I've really I've become aware of this information, and I feel really conflicted. It's not a decision that you need to be making on your own. Also, I feel like this is such big financial interests on both sides on your shoulders. This is weighing down on just you in
Speaker 1this moment, and no one else knows you're going through it. I think I would go to the company and say, guys, I know, so what are you going to do about it?
Speaker 2And also just like tell them be like this person planning a wedding, this person just had a baby, this person is buying houses. You need to tell them right now before they invest all this money into these big things. I mean, the baby's like already happened.
Speaker 1So yeah, I think that's what I would do, because I think if you went straight to your colleagues and just let it out, you also might not have all the context of what the redundancy payouts might be. Like some people might be wanting a redundancy, It could be something that actually is a massive chunk of a payout. Some people might be being kept on, so you might go and deliver the news and saying everyone's being laid off, and then half of them aren't actually being laid off, and then you've gone and ruined everyone's lives before. I think it's probably yeah, best to just confront the company and clarify the exact facts before you go and deliver
Speaker 1life altering news on your own accord.
Speaker 2Oh my god, I am so interested to find out what happened. I want this person to email us again with what they decided to do, and then we can talk about it for the next season.
Speaker 1I know this is a cliff hanger, a.
Speaker 2Cliff we're leaving on a cliffhanger, but that is a wrap on our season of Biz Inbox. We wanted to do a thing I don't know, Sarah. Do you have your advice ready?
Speaker 1Yeah?
Speaker 2We wanted to do a thing where we want to give you a final piece of advice that we want to leave you with. Mine's more like life advice rather than yeah, workplace advice, but it developed from the workplace. And I stole this from Jemima Kirk, who is like an A List actress. She was in girls, she was in sex education. She's absolutely brilliant at like advice, it's do the next thing. And I've used this so much in my life. I feel like if you have like mental health issues, if you are a deprocrastinator, I am
Speaker 2both of those things. Doing the next thing has helped me so much. Like There'll be times where I'm just sitting at my desk and I'm like, I physically can't type out a word on my email, and I'll just be like, Okay, do the next thing. Just read the email, do the next thing, write the intro to the email, do the next thing, finish the email, send it. Like there are so many times, and I feel like this goes hand in hand when you feel like you're starting to get burnout in the workplace, When you feel like that everything just becomes so so hard. Even just taking
Speaker 2lunch break walking outside becomes like the hardest task in the world. Like do the next thing, Like just get up from your desk and see what happens. I think so many people, especially now in today's work climate. We talked about it on last week's episode, that we're all job hugging and we're all just trying to go above and beyond f our jobs because we're so scared to leave them. At the same time, there are people who have been struggling to find a job for the longest time, and it's just this really scary environment that we're in right now, and I think just taking the next little
Speaker 2step just makes the biggest difference and stops you from just completely spiraling that I know so many people are going through right now.
Speaker 1Oh, that's excellent advice, Am, That's such a good one. Mine's probably more workplace focused. It's been a recurring theme through every episode we've done, both A and B, and I think it's just that no matter what dilemma or quandary you're facing, you're not alone. We have had so many of people feeling like it's there alone in their workplace, that they're the only one who's kind of facing this situation. Often it's a situation where they feel a bit disempowered in that workplace. So I think my big message to
Speaker 1everyone would be, you're not alone. So many other people have faced and overcome the situation that you're in. You're not expected to deal with this on your own either. There is so much help and support and resources out there, and I think particularly as employees, there's often a big power imbalance between you and your bosses, which makes you feel like you have to tolerate everything that they throw you away. And that's not the case. You're not meant to just suffer through every single thing that someone decides they want to inflict on you. Of course, there are rules,
Speaker 1and you know, things that do come with authority, but there are a lot of situations that have been submitted where you have a lot more power to set boundaries, a lot more power to demand that you are treated well and rewarded and appreciated and supported in your workplace. So there is support out there and none of you are alone.
Speaker 2That's such good advice. That makes me so motion.
Speaker 1We are here for you.
Speaker 2We're here for you all the time. But that is a season wrap on our biz Inbox. We haven't covered everything from lying about job titles to navigating reference etiquette and ending with some very serious heavy workplace ethics.
Speaker 1Thank you guys so much for sending us your messiest worked lemmons all season long and trusting us with those situations. As I said, we are here for you. Keep them coming through our show notes link. We will be back soon with more career chaos to solve for you.
Speaker 2Okay, so before you go, Yes, Biz Inbox may be done for this season, but we still have two more biz apps for you that are coming next week, and honestly, I'm pretty sure we are going out with our two biggest, most jam packed episodes. Yes, So on Tuesday, we're diving into how to give feedback without making everyone want to crawl under their desk, And on Thursday is our final Biz Main Show episode where we're unpacking pivot because let's be real, most of us are going to switch careers multiple times in our life anyway, so we might as
Speaker 2well figure out how to do it properly. These are going to be our last episodes for this season, so do not miss these episodes next week. Bye bye, Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters that this podcast is recorded on
Starting her career as a beauty therapist before branching into sales, co-founding a dance school, and pivoting into PR via an internship, Jessy Marshall knows a thing or two about taking non-linear paths to success....
Growing up, Jane Lu followed the immigrant dream playbook to the letter - graduating from high school straight into a cadetship at a major accounting firm. But once she secured the corporate life she thought she was...
What started as a lockdown passion project to cure personal isolation has quickly turned into a $100M robotics company. In this episode, host Lisa Lie chats with Grace Brown, the visionary founder and CEO behind...
When Sandy Li-Truong and Justin Truong started PUSHAS in 2017, they were sneakerheads solving a problem inside a subculture they knew intimately: buying rare sneakers required immense trust, but the market was plagued...
As a student midwife, Remy Tucker worked with vulnerable new mothers and saw women forced to make impossible choices around basic essentials, including period products. She was eventually told that if she wanted to...