What does it actually take to spot the next big business before everyone else? In this episode of Biz, Lisa Lie sits down with Phoebe Pincus, CEO of Startmate, who spends her days surrounded by founders, investors and a LOT of startup ideas. Start up investing may sound intimidating, but Phoebe walks us through how to actually begin, where to find the right startups and what you need to know before putting your money behind them. We get into the reality of how many startups fail for every success story, how investors can account for that when spreading their bets, and why investing in founders whose vision creates a future you actually want to be part of can become a powerful motivator. In this episode you'll learn: The power law principle and why startup investing is fundamentally different from traditional investing Why getting a read on the founder trumps any other data points How to spot the patterns that keep appearing in successful startups The people skills that actually matter, and why successful startups are a much longer journey than they look from the outside How to invest in a future you actually want to help create Where to start if you've never invested in a startup before How to find and gain access to the right startups THE END BITS Support independent women's media. Got a work life dilemma? Send us all the questions you definitely can't ask your boss for our Biz Inbox episodes - send us a voice note or email us at podcast@mamamia.com.au. You can remain anon! HOST: Lisa Lie GUEST: Pheobe Pincus - Startmate EXECUTIVE PRODUCER: Courtney Ammenhauser SENIOR PRODUCER: Thom Lion VIDEO PRODUCER: Marlena Cacciotti Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present, and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures. Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Nobody knows if the stock is going to go up downside ways or in circles.
Speaker 2So when most people think about investing, they think shares, property, or maybe super But what if you could invest in the companies that might become the next canvas? Welcome to biz work life sorted. Today's question is how do you get started with investing when you're not a finance expert? And joining us is Phoebe Pinkus, who's the CEO of start Mate. Now, Phoebe's going to help us understand how startup investing actually works, what experienced investors look for before they back a company, the biggest mistakes beginners make, and
Speaker 2how to think more confidently about making your money work harder over time. So if you're not familiar with start Mate, they're Australia and New Zealand's leading startup accelerator and one of the region's most active early stage investors. Since they started, they've invested more than fifty million into over three hundred early stage startups through their highly competitive Startup Accelerator. Collectively, those companies are now worth more than four point five billion dollars. So when we wanted to talk about investing, Phoebe was one of the first people I thought of. She's the newly appointed CEO of start Mate and spends
Speaker 2every day surrounded by founders, investors, and people building some of the most exciting companies, which means Phoebe sees a lot of ideas. Some become incredible businesses and plenty don't, Which is why we're excited to have this conversation today because I think a lot of us hear the words startup investing and immediately think, yeah, that's not for me, or maybe we imagine shark tank or people just writing million dollar checks. Great to have you back, Phoebe.
Speaker 1Thank you so much for having me. Lisa, I am stoked to be here, so start meatee where I work. As you said, we invest in a lot of startups. One of the startups were lucky enough to back was line Up, the companies that founded.
Speaker 2Yeah, so we didn't touch on this, but you run one of the most highly competitive accelerators for early stage startups and it's definitely worth checking out if you are in that space. But before we even get into that, I'd love to ask you why should someone even care about startup investing?
Speaker 1Yes, I love this question. I think it's a really good place to start. I think, especially because there are a number of barriers to start up investing, it's good to at the front understand like why this is a journey that you want to learn about and pursue. So I think we see probably three main motivations of people who are interested in learning about startup investing. The first is obviously kind of the most obvious one, which is the sort of opportunity for outsized returns, and if done well, it can be an incredible investment opportunity. The second rough
Speaker 1bucket would be impact, and I think people when we think about investing in startups, we think about giving our money to founders who are building a future that we want to be a part of, and so it can be a really motivating, inspiring way to invest, rather than you know, maybe putting your money in property or stock market and all those things are important as well. Is like giving money to founders who you think of put in the future that you want. And then the final bucket would be personal development. I think when people are going on this journey of learning to invest in startups,
Speaker 1you learn a huge amount about how businesses work, how technology works, staying on kind of the cutting edge from that perspective, and so I think for a lot of people it's it's kind of a fun learning opportunity.
Speaker 2Yeah, totally. I think when I was coming into the startup world and getting to know it, investing seemed like it was all about predicting the future, like almost like crystal wall from the outside. But now I think it's actually the opposite. I think investing is more about getting comfortable making decisions when you don't know what the future would look like, but you want to help shape it. Am I anywhere near close?
Speaker 1No, one hundred percent. I think that it's helpful to have opinions and perspectives on where the world's going, But really you're looking to the founder to convince you about a possible future, and it's more up to them, I suppose to tell you about the future that they're building. But I think you're exactly right that it's much more useful to anchor on sort of past data points about that founder. They're going to give you more useful information in terms of helping you make a decision than trying to predict the future.
Speaker 2As you say, for sure, as the way that you think about investing change since you got exposed to start mate. Yeah, massively.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean I think it's funny yet you said this in the introduction, Like my background is I studied psychology. I do not have a finance background. And I think I definitely I had a lot of preconceptions about what kind of skill set you would need coming into the space in order to be a good startup investor, and I would say almost all of those are wrong. I can maybe talk to some of the broad misconceptions that I have or where they were wrong, if that's helpful. The first one is really that misconception that to be a good startup investor you need to have, like, you know,
Speaker 1the skill set of being a rigorous financial model and be able to really unpack a business and its mechanisms, Whereas the reality and like very early stage investing is we're often backing a founder pre revenue. You know, there is no there is nothing to model, and it's so much more about the founder and getting a really good read on the founder. And so I think that's like at a very high level, the biggest misconception is that are the data points? Any data point is more important than the data point of the founder.
Speaker 2Themselves. Yeah, so that's the very first place you start.
Speaker 1Yeah, I think in terms of where to start, I think there are some really helpful sort of foundational principles about startup investing that can help guide people's thinking if they're.
Speaker 2If they're interested in engaging in this.
Speaker 1So one thing that I would talk about from an investment perspective is the power or principle. I'm not sure how much founders think about this.
Speaker 2Absolutely nothing, but maybe I did and I didn't know the principal's name.
Speaker 1Tell me investing in startups is it's really different from other asset classes, where if you're investing in property or stocks, you're kind of hoping that everything does pretty well. When you're investing in startups, we think about the power law, which is essentially that probably a very small percentage of your investments will return, you know, will give the outsize returns that justify all your investments. So you know, if you invest in twenty companies, you're really you're probably expecting that nineteen of them may not do that well. Just
Speaker 1to like oversimplify things, nineteen of them may not do that well, but one you're betting on the at least one will be kind of give exceptional returns.
Speaker 2And so I think I think when you're thinking.
Speaker 1About startup investing, just really from first principles, like there is an element of investing in enough companies that you're likely that you're you know, putting yourself in a position that where one of them may be a power or company that returns. You mentioned Canva before, like they're a great example that you might need to invest in a number of companies before you you kind of find that Canva. So I think power is one really important principle to have in mind when you're thinking about starting this journey. Another one would be the timelines of the startup journey.
Speaker 1This is something you'd be more familiar with as a founder. So it's not these aren't investments that you make and then hope to make money off them kind of in the next few years. It's really a tenure journey and that you're going on. And so I think that's important first of all to consider in terms of like how much how long this money will be locked away for one of a better word, and for two to think about like the length of time that you're going on that journey with the founder essentially is like it is a ten year journey. That's a generation. You know, that's
Speaker 1a long time, and so that should inform how you're thinking about the investments you want to make. And then maybe the final thing I would think about is is probably access when you think about canvas as being a great investor, or when you think about even the power I was talking about before, Like, so much of successfully investing in startups is about can you get access to the best startups? And so there's a lot that goes into that. But you basically, if I was approaching this for the first time, I'd be thinking about how can
Speaker 1I basically be in a position where I can get access to those startups?
Speaker 2Okay, so when I kind of got connected to the startup investing community, I found it was like learning another language. There are so many acronyms flying around. If I was starting from scratch today, what do I need to know and what are the steps I need to take? Because what we're talking about with startup investing is different to investing in a publicly listed company that once was a startup?
Speaker 1Right, Yeah, so maybe that's a good place to start. Like foundationally is that this is obviously this not obviously I shouldn't say none of this was obvious to me before getting involved in this space. But investing in privately owned companies that startups are is very different from investing in publicly listed companies. I think a good example we spoke about Canva before is Canva currently is still a privately listed company. Canvas obviously this incredible growth story. Hopefully people will have of Canva on this podcast. Canvas is
Speaker 1an incredible growth story and it is at the moment. You can't invest in Canva through the public market. So this same way that you can invest in any other stock, you can't get access to Canva that way. The only way to invest in Canber is basically to look at how do we invest in privately owned companies? And so there's a few different important things to understand there. One is that is kind of like an eligibility piece which is called the Sophisticated Investor Test in Australia, which basically
Speaker 1means you do need to meet a threshold from an income or assets perspective. And I think if this is you know, a journey that anyone is thinking about going on, it's worth chatting to your accountant and understanding do you qualify for that or is that something that you could qualify for in the next couple of years. And then the second piece is, as you say, like, okay, let's say you do qualify or you think you will qualify soon and this is a journey that you want to go down. Is then basically like how do we demystify this like incredibly like where do you start? How do
Speaker 1you do mystify this incredibly complex landscape that is investing in startups? And I think to that point, like my best advice is that it's going to be a really hard thing to learn purely on your own, and there are really great programs and resources out there for you to get started with. I think the best example is a program called First Believers, which a startmate runs this program. I will say, however, we specifically created it for this exact person that we're speaking about now, who is someone
Speaker 1who wants to get started on their startup investing journey but has literally no idea where to start. They might never have, you know, never been Plenty of the people who do this program have never been involved in the space before. And the way that we have set this up is truefold. We have a theory component, which is really important to basically understand how do you make good investment decisions? Like how do you create a strategy year around the way you're thinking about investment, How do you decide how much money to allocate? Like all those really practical decisions. And then the second part of the program
Speaker 1is getting the reps in is basically like you get access to the say a thousand companies that apply to our accelerator, you get access to basically helping make investment recommendations for those companies. So much of good startup investing is pattern recognition. And if I can guarantee that even if at the start of the program you have no idea what kind of company you think you'd like to invest in, after you've reviewed a couple hundred of them, you know you can review as many as you like, But you start to form a really good idea of
Speaker 1like what does it mean to have good traction, What does it mean to have like an amazing vision for the future. What does a truly exceptional founder with no experience look like? Kind of the only way to learn those things is through like practically looking and meeting enough founders and enough startups.
Speaker 2And let's be real. You don't have to start with one hundred thousand dollars, right, You can start with two thousand or five thousand, and when you're investing in these kind of companies.
Speaker 1Absolutely. I think that's another misconception is people think that to invest in startups you need like millions of dollars in spare cash, whereas we see a lot of angel investors start off with kind of fight to ten K checks. When you're willing to take bets on founders early, when you're willing to lend a hand and help be kind of an advisor for those founders, help go on that journey with them, if you're able to offer strategic introductions. There are so many other ways that you can add value outside of just that money. And so there are some really good ways to get your foot in the
Speaker 1door that don't necessarily mean you need to be, you know, have hundreds of thousands of dollars of disposable income.
Speaker 2Totally and if you don't meet that sophisticated invested test, I think a really good way to get into the startup community is offer a bit of sweat equity and start working within a startup as well. Absolutely, investment in that space.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's like a whole different a whole different channel here is basically, Yeah, if you work for a startup and you're able to get equity in that startup as part of it, like that, it's effectively investing in that startup because you own a portion of it, and then you know, assuming it does go on to do well, you're able to basically you know, translate that into capital.
Speaker 2And maybe become part of their team.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah, they're from the starts. There's a lot of ways to invest in startup time and money, yeah, being two of the most obvious.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, we see that a lot with mentors. They end up being you know, mentors and advisors can be given you know, equity as part of that, and so I think that's a good that's especially if you feel like, you know, you've got strategic value to add, then that's a great pathway to go down.
Speaker 2So you've looked at maybe hundreds thousands, I don't know, I don't know if you count now of startup pitches over the years. I imagine that changes the way that you look at almost everything. Like what's the biggest lesson investing has really taught you about making decisions, and it can be in work or in life.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, that's that's such a good question. And yeah we get we get two thousand companies applying per year now for the ACCEL, so you.
Speaker 2Do two thousands get yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1Across the two cohorts, So you do get to do some good pattern matching. I guess the same with any with any decision. It's useful to be able to come back to first principles for something, even for something that seems like incredibly complex. And I know that startup investing can be full of so much jargon, it can be so opaque. It's so much more simple than I would have appreciated coming in, And I think I've appreciated the simplicity of it more and more as I've gone on. So I think at the end of the day, it
Speaker 1comes back to how good is that? How impressed are you by the founder? Are they solving a real problem? Who is their customer? How are they solving the problem in a differentiated way? Like they have really simple questions that again, I don't think you need a finance background to understand. I think anyone can sit down with a founder and it helps to you in pattern match, the more founders you speak to, but I think being able to come back to those first principles of this is this person solving a real problem? Do I think this
Speaker 1person is capable of being the person to solve this problem? That's going to be much more helpful in terms of driving a good decision than any other of the thousands of data points you could get caught up in.
Speaker 2I love those questions because I think a lot of people think it's about spreadsheets and numbers and analysis, and there's an element of that, But the questions you shared around is this a problem worth solving? And who is this founder and what's their experience and who's the customer? That's a really good place to start to think about start off investing when you meet someone with a brilliant idea, because you've talked a little bit about like the founder and who you're backing. When it comes to start off investing, how much of your decision is actually about the idea
Speaker 2and how much is about the person behind it. I love that question.
Speaker 1I would say at this stage that where investing it's like ninety percent founder really ten percent?
Speaker 2Really?
Speaker 1Yeah, Like ideas are cheap and any almost any idea that anyone has, there will be ten other people working on that same idea, especially right now where with AI, like the ability to build has essentially been democratized and anyone can sort of build anything to an extent, And so it's so much more about that founder. And obviously you need them to have clarity on the idea front, like you need to be persuaded by that. It's a
Speaker 1burning pain point that they have identified a real customer group who will be willing to pay for that, that they have some sort of like unique vision as to like the world that they're building, Like that's almost a given, But the rest of it is all in.
Speaker 2It's all in.
Speaker 1Do you think this founder is the person who is going to solve this and who's going to be the person who can build a billion dollar company out of it?
Speaker 2What are those kind of like attributes I wouldn't say skills, like maybe attributes that are common across those founders.
Speaker 1Yeah, the one that is almost like universal, because sorry, I would say as a whole, like these founders could look so different. You would have noticed that the cohort you came through, So Lisa came through a cohort with you know, fifteen other companies, and there's a lot more different about the founders than there are similar like incredibly different range of like ages, experiences, backgrounds, you know, areas that you're building in. I think the common thread behind successful founders is we would say it's probably something to do with like I'm going to call it hustle. It's
Speaker 1like a customer session within their hustle, a customer brand of hustle. So someone who cares so deeply and relentlessly about about solving a problem for a real customer, and who is not afraid to be speaking to their customers and learning from their customers and continuously iterating on what they're doing in order to better serve those customers. Like it's it's they won't figure it out on the first go, they may not figure out the second go, but it's the fiftieth conversation, it's like the continued iteration and then eventually they can land on something. And it's seeing that's
Speaker 1a skill set that if you see it in someone, you see that like relentless customer obsession, true obsession, that you can have a lot higher conviction that like, yeah, they haven't figured everything out now no one has, but give them time and they will work their way to the right answer.
Speaker 2It sounds like tenacity pointed in the right direction. Yeah, you can have hustle but be spinning your wheels on something else and not even have spoken to the person who's going to buy this product a thousand percent.
Speaker 1I think something we see all the time is and this is useful to keep in mind from an investment perspective. You can come up with a really cool idea, yeah, really cool, kind of like solution. But if you're too obsessed with that solution and that idea and not obsessed enough with the problem that you're solving, then you could spend all your time doing the complete wrong thing. And I think that's an easy mistake to make. Yeah, or investors starting out on their startup investing journey is falling in love with the solution and the idea rather than
Speaker 1the founder and the problem. It's very compelling. It's really easy to get excited by an idea. But again, anyone can kind of have that idea, so you've got to kind of you have to be able to like strip that away. Actually, there's a good question you can ask yourself if you're not sure if you're just excited by the idea or not, which is like if inevitably, in you know, the next ten years or the next year, ten people start to build this exact same thing, would you still be excited about investing in this person this startup? And that kind of helps tease out like are you just excited about what they're building or excited by this person?
Speaker 2That is a great question. Is there other resources that you recommend or questions like that for beginners who are wanting to get their foot in the door but have that understanding of how they should assess startup investing.
Speaker 1Yeah, I think I think in terms of where to start, I would really recommend I would really recommend looking at like maybe joining a community of people who are also interested in learning about it is. It is a journey, and I think having people around you who are also on that journey. I think resource that I would point to would be First Believers, which is an angel investing program that start where I work runs.
Speaker 2Explain what are because a lot of people won't know what angels are.
Speaker 1Angel Yeah, angels are investors who direct who invest directly into startups and so you know, so I spoke very briefly at the start that you can kind of have a strategy of investing directly into startups, or you can invest in funds like a start Maid or another bench capital fund that then does sort of the investing for you. And so angel investors are people who they invest in startups. They also generally will help like mentor and advise those startups. And so I think for a lot of people that's like an incredibly rewarding path to go down because you get to work directly with the founders, you kind of
Speaker 1go on that journey with them. You've obviously got skin in the game because you're invested in them.
Speaker 2And you don't have to create a business yourself. Then no, yeah, you get to be part of the startup journey. Yeah, you get to be part of the journey.
Speaker 1So I think that the challenges to that is that to come back to the power or piece, you would obviously want to sort of be diversifying your direct investments across a number of startups. That becomes incredibly time consuming, so I think you really want to make sure that you've got time set aside. But to come back to the question of yeah, where to start, and first believers like I think doing a program like First Believers, essentially, there are two things you want to get. You kind of want to understand the theory of startup investing. And
Speaker 1I don't just mean like the frameworks in terms of making good decisions, but also just like, well legalities around it and make sure that.
Speaker 2That's all sound.
Speaker 1But then the community piece is really important, and getting to speak to other people on that journey and learning about startups as well, Like, that's one of the ways that you can accelerate your learning and growth the most. And there are a number of these kind of programs out there, but I think it's really worth looking into because it's a really hard journey to go on on your own.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, that is a grow resource. Okayabes, we're going to do no overthinking now, we're just going to go into some rapid fire and maybe one sentence, Max, don't throw in heaps of commas, Like one short, sharp sentence. I want you to give me the first thing that comes to mind when I say this word diversification.
Speaker 1Critical strategy within startup investing. WHOA is that what you mean by one sentence?
Speaker 2Yeah, that's one sentence. So a critical strategy taking the free, very serious that it is. You are taking this homework and you're running with it.
Speaker 1Risk risk should be a part, should form a part of your investment strategy. I unbelievably exciting opportunity. Property feels like it's getting to be less of an exciting opportunity timing the market. I wouldn't get too caught up with.
Speaker 2This, Okay, Fomo.
Speaker 1Pomo should be a big motivator in terms of should you should feel a sense of fomo of like not wanting to miss out on investing in the next can. But I think that that is a powerful motivator and failure all part of the fun.
Speaker 2So good. So I want you to imagine you've saved a bit of money, you're interested in investing, you've heard everything that's been shared today, but you're worried you've started too late. What's one belief about money you're investing? You'd love people let go of.
Speaker 1I think the fear that you need to have an incredible amount of technical knowledge to invest in startups and financial knowledge to invest in startups. Again, I come from a background of studying psychology, working more in the people space.
Speaker 2I have almost no.
Speaker 1Hard skills, and I have found an interesting people to be far more helpful in terms of building out my investment decision making skills than having a like strong financial background, And so I would be I would be reflecting on, like, what is what fear is maybe stopping me from exploring this further? And is it that I don't think I have the kind of technical financial skill set? Because if so, then it's still it's still worth pursuing. It shouldn't be the barrier.
Speaker 2Awesome. I love that. So when we wrap up these episodes, we try and share one useful thing. It's out out yeah, and normally EM and I share that, but today we love to get you to share something. Okay, So what's one thing everyone could do this week that would make them a better investor? This is very practical.
Speaker 1Start a WhatsApp group with three friends who are interested in learning about startup investing and commit to kind of like sharing one resource with each other every day. Could be something you read. It could be something like a piece of advice you've been given. It could be a startup you're looking into. I think so much of this is about baby steps and not be being overwhelmed by it. And I think a if you can break that down, so feel that learning journey feels really achievable. But be like doing it with friends so that you have people
Speaker 1around you, Like I think that would be a really a really fun way to start.
Speaker 2I love that that is a very very practical and easy thing to do. Off the back of listening to.
Speaker 1This, I hope some people do it.
Speaker 2Yes, Thank you so much for sharing your time today and sharing all your insights into what can be often seen as a mystery industry or something that people might not know that much about. It's been great to learn a bit more with you.
Speaker 1Thank you for having me on.
Speaker 2Thanks for listening to today's episode of Biers. If you've got someone in your life who's always said I'd love to invest, but I just don't know where to start, send them this episode. Follow the show, leave us a review, and come and say hello on Socials. We'll catch you next week on Biers.
Starting her career as a beauty therapist before branching into sales, co-founding a dance school, and pivoting into PR via an internship, Jessy Marshall knows a thing or two about taking non-linear paths to success....
Growing up, Jane Lu followed the immigrant dream playbook to the letter - graduating from high school straight into a cadetship at a major accounting firm. But once she secured the corporate life she thought she was...
What started as a lockdown passion project to cure personal isolation has quickly turned into a $100M robotics company. In this episode, host Lisa Lie chats with Grace Brown, the visionary founder and CEO behind...
When Sandy Li-Truong and Justin Truong started PUSHAS in 2017, they were sneakerheads solving a problem inside a subculture they knew intimately: buying rare sneakers required immense trust, but the market was plagued...
As a student midwife, Remy Tucker worked with vulnerable new mothers and saw women forced to make impossible choices around basic essentials, including period products. She was eventually told that if she wanted to...