
S14 E4: Peter Todd vs Sergej Kotliar on Full RBF
Full RBF is one of the most controversial topics in Bitcoin, so I sat down with both sides of the debate. Peter Todd, who proposed replace-by-fee and argues that every node should run full RBF, and Sergej Kotliar, the CEO of Bitrefill and a defender of zero-confirmation payments, go back and forth on how many merchants and users really rely on unconfirmed transactions, what wallet and payment processor data shows, and whether double-spend risk is real or only theoretical. They also debate fee rates, multi-party transactions and coinjoins, Lightning as the alternative, and whether changing mempool policy fixes Bitcoin or breaks something people use, and both agree to come back for a second round. This episode is sponsored by Wasabi Wallet, Cryptosteel, ShopInBit and Satodime. Timestamps 0:00 Intro and sponsors 1:10 Welcome: Peter Todd and Sergej Kotliar 3:02 Sergej on the RBF flag and zero-conf 6:18 Peter on what full RBF is 9:29 Who relies on unconfirmed transactions? 10:54 Testing merchants that accept zero-conf 13:22 Sponsor: Wasabi Wallet 14:15 How common are zero-conf purchases? 16:48 Bitrefill's fee rate requirements 18:28 On-chain zero-conf versus Lightning payments 19:20 How many users actually bump fees? 22:16 Sponsor: Cryptosteel 23:44 ATMs, KYC and services that wait for confirmations 25:20 Payment processors and merchant data 29:06 Exchanges, multi-party transactions and coinjoins 30:14 Standardness rules versus consensus 32:13 The Canadian ATM double-spend story 33:07 Sponsor: Satodime 33:59 Does zero-conf favor big companies? 34:42 Lightning as the alternative 35:50 Wallet usage data and ordinary users 38:30 Fixing one thing, breaking another? 40:45 Sponsor: ShopInBit 41:48 Is double-spend risk real? 45:14 Planning a part two 45:43 First-seen and how RBF changed the mempool
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
