Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Biome

Biome artwork

S1 Int12 - September Editor's Desk

Sep 15, 20268 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

How does Biome pick the stories we publish? What's the value of prizes and recognition? Your host and Biome editor Alex Zoubine discusses the value of curation and prizes in Sci-Fi and literature more broadly Check out the Biome submissions portal here if you're curious: https://biomespec.wordpress.com/submissions/ Learn more about the Hugo Awards in Science Fiction: https://www.thehugoawards.org/hugo-history/2026-hugo-awards/ Learn More about the Nebula Awards here: https://nebulas.sfwa.org/award-year/2025/ And of course, check out the official Nobel Prize website here: https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/literature/ Check out our recent interviews with some of our Season 1 authors: Jordan Hirsch: https://www.patreon.com/BiomeSpec/posts/interlude-1-161200342/ M.D. Smith IV: https://www.patreon.com/BiomeSpec/posts/interlude-1-m-d-162930361/ Grigory Lukin: https://www.patreon.com/BiomeSpec/posts/interlude-1-165750671/ Toshiya Kamei: https://www.patreon.com/BiomeSpec/posts/interlude-1-161022506/ Have questions, comments or thoughts? I'd love to hear from you: biomespec@gmail.com Special thanks to our Biosphere Patreon supporter Shanella!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to Biome. This is Alex Zoubiner, your host, narrator, and the voice of the ghost in the machine. Dear listener, I'm so happy to have you join me today for another segment of The Editor's Desk. In this segment, I get to talk to you directly about what's going on at Biome and how that reflects what's going on in the world. Today, I will share some thoughts on how Biome picks the stories

that we publish, and that in turn ties into broader topics of competition, awards, and gatekeeping, all of which are worthy topics to consider. Before I jump in, I want to ask you personally to consider supporting this show on Patreon. At Biome, we pay authors for every story we publish because we believe good art and hard work are worth something. It warms my heart when we get a note from an author saying that the payment they got from Biome means finances are a little easier for them that month. I'd like to pay authors more for their work in the future, and with your help,

I will be able to. So check out the link in the description and sign up. Even $2 is a huge help, and I will be personally grateful for your support. So how do stories that appear on Biome get picked? For a publication like Biome, it almost always starts with the hopeful author. After they've written and polished a story that they put their heart and soul into, authors search for a home for that story. If they come across Biome and they feel their story aligns with the types of stories that Biome publishes, authors will submit their stories to us through our link on our website.

I'll include the submission link in the show notes so you can check it out and see it for yourself. Submissions are open to everybody, and we've been lucky enough to receive and accept stories from around the world. About a third of the stories in seasons 1 and 2 are from authors outside the U .S. At the time we read stories, we don't see where the authors are from, though, because we ask authors to remove all identifying information, even their names, from the submissions. This kind of blind reading helps us cut down on biases that could influence the way we think about the stories. Once a story is in our queue,

we give the story a read. The very best ones stand out from the very first line. Think of your favorite openings from other books and stories you may have read. In a hole in the ground, there lived a hobbit. Or, it was the best of times, it was the worst of times. These openings are confident and immediately give a sense that you're in skilled hands. A strong opening isn't all, though. At Biome, we look for stories with movement. Sometimes that means a more traditional story arc with a defined conflict and resolution. Sometimes it's a more subtle type of transformation. where

circumstances or mental states of characters have shifted and evolved often beautiful language and imagery help us make a decision over whether we want to publish a piece sometimes there is just a detail or two in a story that is so sublime we know we want to share it with our listeners above all we look for stories that will stay with you the Roman poet Horace explained in his masterful Ars Poetica that the purpose of stories and of any literary work more broadly is to entertain to educate, or to do both. So we hope that Biome

Stories can take you to far -off worlds, or let you see this world in a new light, giving you the chance to step away from the everyday. As a show that can only share a few stories each season, this also means we have to turn away a lot of stories. In that way, the editors at Biome are gatekeepers, a term that has acquired some serious pejorative inflections over the last couple of decades. It may be time for the term to get some rehabilitation. Today we live in a world that is overflowing with content. Pictures, stories, videos, and more. Now imagine

that podcasts and magazines don't exist. A world in which the only option anyone has for sharing their stories is on their own personal blogs or YouTube channels. What are the chances that you would dig through everything online to try and find a story that you enjoy? With shows like Biome, you don't have to dig. The authors and editors have done the work for you. When you come to Biome, you can be confident that we have selected some of the best new fantasy and science fiction and speculative stories from around the world. None of it is AI generated, and all of it has been carefully refined by authors who

have been practicing their craft for years. This also means that there are a lot of stories that we decide not to publish. I'm proud to say that Biome is one of the few publications that responds to every single story that authors submit with a personal note sharing what elements of the story did and didn't work for us. At Biome, we believe that listeners and audiences will get the best stories if the entire ecosystem of authors and storytellers is thriving. So we try and make sure our comments are helpful and kind. We try

and give back to the authors, even when we have to say no to a story. The ultimate form of editorializing or gatekeeping probably comes in the form of prizes and awards. The most widely recognized speculative fiction awards in English today are probably the Hugo, Nebula, Locus, and Shirley Jackson awards, and each of these gives out just one top prize in each of their respective categories. Each prize has different criteria for how stories are entered for consideration, and each one chooses its top winners in different ways. whether it's

the Hugos, where winners are chosen by a popular vote at a WorldCon, or whether through a jury composed of distinguished writers and academics, such as for the Shirley Jackson Awards. The process of selecting and awarding these prizes tells its own kind of story. What do the public and jury value? What do they enjoy? What do they want to draw attention to? When these prizes are awarded, we can't say that they always mark the very best story in any specific sense. A chosen story might not have the best dialogue. It might not have the most riveting plot. Its

word choice might not be the most original or its characters the most likable. But these prizes do say that at a specific time, in a specific place, a certain group of people decided that a story was notable enough that it was worth elevating to a wider audience. You might not agree with the story or the author who gets the top prize, and that's okay. Just like you might not love every single story Biome releases, although I hope you do. But I think that rather than debating whether a grand prize was awarded correctly or

not, it's actually more interesting to have a discussion about why a certain jury or audience chose to highlight the stories and authors that it did. Can we try and understand that value for ourselves? Can we use that to enrich our own understanding of the world? At the time of recording, Worldcon 2026 has just wrapped up. and the Nobel Prize in Literature is scheduled to be announced in about a month. If you decide you want to check out the winners, I invite you to approach them from a place of curiosity and discovery. I'll include links to recent Hugo

and Nebula awards for you to check out in the show notes if you so choose. Next week, I will be sharing the final author interview before the start of Season 2. I will be chatting with JMJ Brewer, author of our seventh story from Season 1, titled Anemone, a haunting and unique story. If you have a moment, I invite you to go back and give that story another listen before the interview for an even deeper appreciation of that conversation. After our interview, Biome Season 2 starts on Tuesday, September 29th, featuring

Homecoming by Proxy by Erin Cullen. I absolutely cannot wait to share this story with you, so mark your calendar. And if you can't wait until the 29th, Patreon supporters get early access, in addition to supporting the authors and the writing community more broadly. As always, Shanella, our Biosphere -level Patron, I am especially grateful for your support. Well, dear listener, that's all I have for you today. Tune in to next week's interview, and until then, farewell, wherever the days take you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 8 - Spectrum

    Nov 18, 202633 minAudio

    They came to build a new world. Instead, the crew of the Accra is stranded, their technology fried. Their bodies, broken. They have just one chance to warn the next colony ship of the danger, assuming it's coming at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 7 - Morning, Noon, and Night: A Portrait of Mars

    Nov 11, 202628 minAudio

    Earth is dying and humans have reached Mars. But is this a step into the future? Or will these dreams be dashed like so many before them? Morning, Noon, and Night: A Portrait of Mars is by J. M. Williams J. M. Williams...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 6 - Green Up in Aisle Thirteen

    Nov 4, 202620 minAudio

    When a petroglyph goes missing, Julie feels powerless to help. But when she comes across a Chepi desperately trying to get by in a world that has brushed aside Native spirits, Julie must choose whether she is ready to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep 5- The Box Born Wraith

    Oct 27, 202625 minAudio

    In a fate worse than death, Benny is buried alive by his gang on Halloween night. What happens next is stranger and more chilling than he could have dreamed. The Box Born Wraith is by Kevin David Anderson Kevin David...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep 4 - The Glasshouse

    Oct 20, 202619 minAudio

    When they die, they go to the Glasshouse. Sofia cares for the dead - those with loved ones and those without, cultivating beauty in the soft, slow decay. The Glasshouse is by Thane Hespera ​Thane Hespera is a Vietnamese...

    Credit the people on this episode