Richard Nixon wins re-election in one of the biggest landslides in American history. Less than two years later, he becomes the first and only U.S. president to resign. So, how did it all fall apart? In Part Two, we get into Nixon’s growing paranoia, the creation of CREEP, the increasingly unhinged schemes of the people around him, and the break-in at the Watergate complex that started the unraveling. We take you inside what actually happened that night, before following the investigation, the secret White House tapes and the cover-up that ultimately reached all the way to the President. This is the break-in, the cover-up and the bitter end of Richard Nixon’s presidency.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
A listener production. Before we begin today's episode, we'd like to start by acknowledging the traditional owners on the land on which we're recording, the Gadigal people, and pay our respects to elders past and present. Hi, I'm Justine. And I'm Sarah. Welcome to Big Talk. Big talk deep dives into the big news stories that you've heard of but you don't know all the serious and salacious details about.
We revisit the most shocking headlines from the past that have shaped the world we know today. Across these two episodes, we are looking at Nixon's time as president and two of the United States' biggest scandals that unfurled under his leadership. The Pentagon Papers and the Watergate break-in. Now, if you have taken a break between part one and part two, we're going to do a little bit of a recap here so that you can get up to date. And even if you've just listened to part one, sometimes I do find it really helpful when someone just synthesizes all of that as quickly as possible.
Good little recap. There was a lot covered. So in our last episode, we looked at Richard Nixon's rise to power and the political playbook that he used to get there. Nixon didn't come from wealth and for a long time, he was sort of an underdog. But once he entered politics, Nixon became known for something else entirely, dirty politics. He was a ruthless political opponent. Again and again, he used the same strategy, find dirt on your opponent, blur the truth a little and make sure the public never forgets it.
He even earned a nickname for his tactics. Tricky Dick. But then, years into his presidency, Nixon grew afraid of people finding dirt on him, especially after the New York Times published classified government reports about the US's involvement in the Vietnam War. If people are willing to expose the lies of previous administrations, what might come out now about his time in office? Nixon became convinced that he needed to stop leaks by any means necessary. So he created a secret White House unit called the Plumbers, whose job was to go after the Pentagon Papers whistleblower.
And suddenly, Nixon has this crack team of burglars in the White House willing to go above and beyond the law for him. And that brings us to now, the end of Nixon's first term as president and the campaign for his re-election. Let's get into it, shall we? We are now in 1972 and Nixon is preparing to run for his re-election. Now, from the outside, he is in a pretty strong position. Like, not even a strong position. He pretty much has this one in the bag, I would say. Like, he is the incumbent president.
He has announced that the American troops are coming home from Vietnam. He was also the first sitting U.S. president to visit communist China. Up until this point, America and the People's Republic of China basically had no formal relationship. This is a bit of a weird side quest for me to go on, but this was a really big deal when I was reading about this. Yeah, hugely. So Nixon landed in Beijing and he's photographed walking across the Great Wall of China. It's this extraordinary moment. And there is a reason that people say that only Nixon could have gone to China.
Because as we mentioned in the first half of this, his political identity was so thawed fiercely anti-communist. He took down his opponents by saying they were, like, sympathetic to communism. Right. And that gave him this political cover, I suppose, to suddenly then open relations as one of the world's biggest communist powers without looking soft on communism. Yeah, he could go meet Mao Zedong without there being, like, concerns raised about him. He also then went on to go to Moscow and he met with the Soviet leader and that massively eased these Cold War tensions.
And I think... If President Nixon's legacy wasn't always going to be entirely overshadowed and tied to Watergate, I do wonder what would he otherwise have been remembered for. And I do think it would have been for his international relations. Yes, he was huge on foreign policy and building bridges from America to the rest of the world. But let's get back to his re-election. So his advisers, they're not too worried. But Nixon, he sees the election a little differently. And I think one of the reasons for this is because his other presidential elections had been incredibly close.
So in 1960, he lost to Kennedy by 0.17% of the popular vote. And then in 1968, he only won by just 0.7% of the popular vote. So from Nixon's perspective, I think it's fair to say based on his experience that you never know what can happen in an election. You never know what an opponent is going to surprise you with. And you definitely, definitely should never leave anything to chance. And in the spirit of not leaving anything up to chance, Nixon sets up a campaign organization called the Committee to Re-Elect the President, the CRP, which then became publicly quickly renamed as Creep.
This is so funny to me. this creep they're calling themselves creep this this i didn't know this before we were researching this episode that that was their nickname and i had a little giggle about it officially creep exists to raise money organize events buy ads and get nixon another four years in office Unofficially, though, it has another purpose, which is to gather intelligence on Democrats, spread misinformation, launder campaign cash through strange channels, and try and sabotage anyone who might stand in Nixon's way.
So I have a question here, which is that Nixon was clearly a competitive person, a dirty fighter, But why was he this paranoid? He was so paranoid. Like, everything in this story comes back to the fact that he is incredibly paranoid. And I do think the important context here is that his paranoia didn't come completely out of nowhere. Like, I do think it's pretty unhinged. But at the time, America is incredibly divided. And Nixon, along with his national security advisor and secretary of state, Henry Kissinger, just became obsessed with this idea that they were surrounded by enemies and people that they couldn't trust.
Yeah. Kissinger even wants his own staff to be bugged to find out who's leaking to the press. And in terms of Nixon, people have pointed out that this long-term deep resentment and distrust of the, quote, Eastern establishment, the media, liberal political opponents, people who went to Ivy League schools, and that dates all the way back to when he didn't get into Harvard or Yale for financial reasons. Yeah. And also, I was reading about Kissinger and Nixon. And- Something that was funny to me was just like the level of paranoia and distrust that they also seem to have for each other.
Like Kissinger apparently went around telling people that if the president, I have to do my American accent, sorry, if the president had his way, there would be a nuclear war a week. And Nixon apparently told his close allies that he thought Kissinger was psychotic. So, you know, they said they set up great. They talked about each other behind their backs. They're like, they're like high schoolers. Oh, it gets so much worse. Oh, yeah, it gets terrible. Okay, so they set up Creep, and the man that he puts in charge of Creep is a guy named John Mitchell. Now, Mitchell has just stepped down as Attorney General, which is the highest-ranking law enforcement office in the country, and he did so to run Nixon's re-election campaign.
Now, this is not illegal, but it's a big advantage for Nixon. Pretty much it means that a whole lot of people in government already know his campaign manager and they owe Mitchell favours and are used to taking his calls. So Creep, and we're going to keep calling it Creep, they raise a lot of money, more than $60 million towards Nixon's campaign. Now, at the time, campaign finance rules were still weak. Reporting was patchy and enforcement was like near non-existent. And some of the $60 million is handled legally. But approximately several million dollars of it is not.
And instead of being put into one neat account with a label on it, a lot of it is moved around in cash and through committees and through donors and through accounts that do not immediately appear connected to Nixon. And so you might be wondering, what is all this money going to be used for? Political espionage. Naturally. So in 1972, the Democratic frontrunner was Senator Edmund Muskie from Maine. And Muskie had already been the Democratic candidate for vice president in 1968. He was experienced, moderate, respected.
He also expected to do very well in the New Hampshire primary. where a lot of the voters were of French-Canadian backgrounds. That is until a few weeks before that primary, a local newspaper published a letter claiming that Muskie had insulted French-Canadians by laughing at someone who apparently called them Canucks. Yes, and I was trying to look this up. It was a derogatory term that people definitely weren't supposed to use or find funny at the time. It's not the kind of thing that would completely ruin a potential candidate's chances, but it does create some doubt and make people wonder, is he arrogant?
Is he out of touch? Does he respect us? And then the same newspaper ran an attack on Muskie's wife, alleging that she liked to smoke cigarettes, swear and tell dirty jokes. Oh my gosh, the height of impropriety. Can you imagine a woman? And Muskie is furious. He stands outside the newspaper office in the snow and delivers this emotional speech about the editor of the newspaper. You watched this clip, didn't you? I did watch this clip. And this moment becomes known as the crying incident because he allegedly cries, right?
And I say allegedly because at the time, Muskie insisted that it was just snow melting on his face. But either way, the footage makes him look emotional at exactly the moment that he probably needed to look steadier. Not the best footage, not the best audio. I wouldn't have picked up on that. I feel like this is unfair to him, but the media runs with it. And this is also all happening in the context of Nixon having had a very strong four-year term. Yes. I would say that this moment for Muskie doesn't entirely ruin his campaign.
He has other problems and he does perform badly in the primaries that follow. But the letter and the crying incident adds to the sense that he's rattled and it is enough to change the story around him. And it turns out that that Canuck letter was totally fabricated, and the FBI later linked it back to creep. But that letter isn't the only thing that they were doing. Yes. So let's talk again about G. Gordon Liddy. So we talked about him last step. He's the former FBI agent who Nixon put in the plumbers, that group of people whose job it was to kind of like...
get up... Prevent leaks. Yeah, prevent leaks, but also dig up dirt on people he didn't like. So he gets brought across from the Plumbers to Creep, where he is given the responsibility of campaign intelligence. And in 1972, Liddy presented a number of potential undercover operations to the broader Creep team, which were combined together and given the title of Operation Gemstone. So there's actually a book called Watergate, A New History, and it details all the different undercover operations that Liddy was talking about.
They're all named after gemstones. Lol. So I decided to pull out a couple of them and explain what they were. Okay. First, there was Operation Ruby. That one wanted to put spies in the Democratic campaigns. There was Operation Coal, which was about laundering money to the campaign of Shirley Chisholm to make her look bad. And Chisholm was the first black candidate for a major party's presidential nomination. There was Operation Crystal, which wanted to outfit, this one really tickled me, outfit a luxury houseboat at the Democratic National Convention in Miami with
be done in combination with Operation Sapphire, which wanted to hire sex workers to seduce party power brokers and lure them back to the houseboat's bedroom. Liddy even debated, apparently, over which women would be the most enticing to Democrats. It's so, this just goes on and on and on. It does. There was even an operation called Operation Turquoise, which was about sabotaging the air conditioning system at the Democratic Convention so that all the nominees would have to address the delegates in like 100 degree Miami heat, like all hot and sweaty.
Who was at this brainstorm session? Then there's Operation Diamond. So at this stage, there's an upcoming Republican National Convention where a number of anti-war protesters are planning on attending and disrupting the proceedings. Liddy's idea is to identify the protest leaders, kidnap them, drug them, take them into Mexico, and hold them there until after the convention to stop the protest from occurring. And you might be surprised by this, but if you remember last episode, that one of the plumber's plans was to take the whistleblower and like drug him with LSD at a Washington Post.
This is... It's on brand. Yeah. Yeah. And Liddy gives it the codename, I think this is German, Nacht und Nebel. Yeah, which does mean night and fog, which was a phrase associated with a Nazi policy designed to make political opponents disappear. Oh my gosh. On that Nazi policy, so before I mentioned that I was listening to The Rest is History, and they actually spoke a little bit about Liddy on that, and... And to quote them, they said, basically, he's a Nazi. He's dead now. And he explained that when the BBC filmed him for their Watergate documentary.
He had himself filmed in front of this huge collection of guns that he owned. And somebody who was involved with that said to me, well, you shouldn't think that's bad. In the next room, he had all these Nazi flags and pictures of Lenny Riefenstahl and stuff. They also go on to talk about like how pretty much he said in this documentary, like, if Nixon had told me to go assassinate someone, I would have done it kind of thing. And then also that at another point, he at the White House was showing footage of the Nuremberg rallies at the White House. Wow.
Like, what the... I don't even understand how this guy... Did this not confuse people? What were the people around him, like, doing? Exactly. They were like, ha, cool. Thanks for that contribution, Liddy. What the... And, like, apparently the others were all somewhat moderate, somewhat normal. I mean, they're not, but, like, comparatively. Comparatively moderate. But apparently everyone just thought he was a bit eccentric. Yeah. Like a kooky uncle. It's bizarre because the more I kind of was trying to look into this and understand, you would think that obviously people would hear all of those plans that you mentioned before and be like, this cannot be taken seriously, right?
Yes. But when you hear former Nixon officials talk about all of this in documentaries, you know, years on from this... they don't describe everyone laughing Liddy out of the room. Like, these schemes were actually entertained, and Liddy and Hunt were allowed to keep operating within Nixon's orbit despite coming up with these increasingly ridiculous ideas. Yeah, the combination of the ridiculous ideas paired with the fact that he was so, like, overtly... a Nazi, or at least a Nazi sympathetic, pandering to those ideologies.
I'm shocked that anyone... How? I don't get it. I mean, I'm shocked by the whole thing, though. Like, I'm shocked by the fact that the plumbers existed and the creeps existed. You need to start from the beginning because every layer builds on itself. So how do the other members of Creep respond to this proposal, though, in this instance? Okay, so the previous Attorney General John Mitchell, he's part of the creep team, he reportedly looks at the price tag of these plans and rejects them as too expensive. And again, we're talking about the plan to kidnap, drug and take to Mexico protesters.
Yes, yes. also illegal, but in this instance, too expensive. So actually, there is a transcript of the conversation that was had. It's written out in Liddy's autobiography. They discuss how the plans would be executed. And the conversation is between Mitchell and Liddy. Sarah, do you want to take Mitchell? I'll take Liddy. Okay. Yeah, sure. Do I have to do an American? I don't know if I can do an American accent. We can do Australian accents. Okay. Where did you find men like that? They understand they're members of organised crime. And how much will their services cost? Like top professionals everywhere, sir. They don't come cheap.
Well, let's not contribute any more than we have to the coffers of organised crime. And apparently the Attorney General was like, had a pipe in his mouth the whole time while he's like saying this. You can imagine them in an armchair, just like slowly turning around. Yeah. So Lydia's told to scale it back, tone it down. And he does. The revised plan is cheaper. It's still wildly illegal, but not kidnapping illegal. Yeah. So he presents this plan to the team, and in March 1972, a version of it is authorised. Now, there are disputes later about who exactly approved it, because nobody involved wants to say that it was them.
But the important thing is this. Liddy now has money, a team, and a green light to collect, quote, intelligence on the Democrats. And what is that plan? One of the targets is the Democratic National Committee headquarters, which is located inside of a building complex in Washington, DC called Watergate. We got there! We got there! It's Watergate! For a story on Watergate, we are now one and a half episodes in, and we're finally talking about Watergate. The DNC is where the Democrats are organising their national campaign.
They have phone lists, strategy documents, schedules, contacts, and donor information laying around, all of which Creep would love to get their grubby little hands on. In May 1972, a team of men then broke into the DNC offices. And these men photograph documents, they install listening devices on phones, and they leave. Wow. The first break-in was successful, right? Except that the listening devices are not working properly. So a few weeks later, they decide they have to break back in. And that's where everything starts to unravel.
So it's midnight on June 17th, 1972. Frank Wills is working as a security guard at the Watergate complex when he notices a door leading from the underground car park has tape over its latch. And the tape means the door can swing shut and look locked, but doesn't actually lock. So Will removes the tape. He moves on. You know, maybe it's maintenance or something. He keeps doing his rounds. But then about half an hour later, he comes back and the tape is there again. So this time, he calls the police.
The police dispatch an undercover unit who are dressed to blend in with the surrounding late night drug activity. You know, so people won't notice that they're police. Yeah. And that really matters here because across the street in the Howard Johnson Motel, there's supposed to be a lookout. He's a former FBI agent. He's supposed to be watching the Watergate Complex and listening to police radio and warning the burglars if anything goes wrong. But apparently he's watching a low budget horror movie on hotel TV called Attack of the Puppet People. So either he doesn't see the plain clothed officers go in or, you know, he's distracted, doesn't paid any attention.
The officers enter the building. They search it floor by floor. And eventually they reach the Democratic National Committee headquarters where they find and arrest five men. Now, these men are all somehow related to the CIA. There's like a former CIA COVID operative, a former CIA informant. There's James McCord, who's a former CIA agent and security chief of CREEP. So these are all people who have ties to the CIA. Bit of a side question. here, but most of the actual burglars are Cuban exiles with connections to the CIA, as we were saying.
But several had worked for Howard Hunt. And I feel like we need to bring this up because we spoke about Liddy, but Howard Hunt is also a big figure in this. And he is an interesting character. He was one of the members of Nixon's plumber's team as well. And he also helped organize the Ellsberg psychiatrist break-in. But he was also part of the Bay of Pigs, which was basically this disastrous CIA-backed attempt to overthrow Fidel Castro in Cuba back in 1961. And the CIA trained all these Cuban exiles to invade the country and hopefully spark a rebellion against Castro.
But it completely collapsed within a few days, and Howard Hunt was the CIA officer involved in that operation. Yeah. So the reason that's important is because, understandably, that's now their connection point. So these people are fiercely anti-communist and see themselves as these true believers in the fight against communism. So when someone like Hunt, who they already know and trust, tells them that they're carrying out an operation connected to the White House and Nixon's re-election campaign, they are very willing to get involved. And that is how you end up with this bizarre group of former CIA operatives, Cuban exiles, and Nixon campaign figures carrying out the Watergate break-in.
Ah, that's very interesting. I was wondering how Cuban exiles with connections to the CIA were wrapped up in all of this. So anyway, the police search these five figures. They find lockpicks, cameras, tear gas pens, thousands of dollars in cash and electronic surveillance equipment. And very quickly, police find the first connection to the White House. One of the burglars has an address book with the name and White House phone number of Howard Hunt in it. Right.
See, it all comes back to Hunt. It all comes back to Hunt. So dumb. But then the FBI get involved. This is no longer just a local police matter. This is an FBI matter. And Nixon becomes very worried. Now, we don't know how much of the original Watergate plan Nixon knew about, but what we do know is that he wanted this story crushed as soon as possible. So Nixon meets with his chief of staff and they arrange for the CIA to deliver a message to the FBI, basically telling them to back off. They're told that if they keep digging, they're going to expose sensitive national security level operations.
But they're not the only ones investigating. There are two young reporters, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, who are working for the Washington Post and they've started following this story. These two start digging and in the course of this digging, they find a check linked to Nixon's re-election fundraising that had ended up in the account of one of the burglars. It's all tied together. Then a source from deep inside the FBI starts feeding Woodward and Bernstein little bits of information. Now, you might have heard of him. His code name is Deep Throat.
It's named after a porn star. It was named after a porn film. He needed an undercover name. So pick a name. I think it was from a porn film. And I think this is where that idea of the covert journalist source, you know, like the one in the trench coat and the hat in the basement that is parodied a lot. This is where it comes from in real life. This Deep Throat in the basement for the Watergate scandal. Yeah. So he tells these journalists that they're on the right track and, you know, they've got to keep looking. He's quite vague, actually, at points. But also, I'm pretty sure that he had leaked stuff to the press before.
Like, I don't think this is actually a particularly surprising element of the story. No, no. He was, like, already kind of like a guy on the inside for these guys. He'd leaked things before. So he's telling them they're on the right track. And pretty soon, Woodward and Bernstein start cracking the rest of the story right open. They're finding, like, more and more financial evidence to prove the connections here. and they start reporting on all of this. And yet, the public doesn't really react. Because it's 1972, Sarah, and there's an election coming up, and Nixon's pretty popular, and the Vietnam War appears to be winding down, and the economy is not in freefall.
So, you know... Why pull down a great candidate now? Plus, the Democratic opponent to Nixon is having a disaster of a campaign. And by the time of the election, George McGovern was Nixon's opponent. And McGovern is a very different kind of politician to Nixon. He's openly anti-war. He supports a faster withdrawal from Vietnam. He talks about cutting defense spending and putting more money into social programs. And so people start running this tagline to sum up his campaign, Amnesty, Abortion and Acid. It's a brutal line and it sticks.
It really sticks. Nixon starts using it too. And so perhaps unsurprisingly, on November 7th, 1972, Nixon wins in a landslide. He carries 49 out of the 50 states. It's one of the biggest presidential victories in American history. Can I say, this is a total side note, but I saw this in the research. When he had this big win, what do you think he went and did that night? Had a party? No, he took himself alone to the White House study to play kind of theatrical music and write down everything that he thought people would say that was bad about him.
Oh, he's such a theatre kid. I was like, wow, that's a lot happening there anyway. So Nixon is inaugurated for a second term in January 1973. But this is not the end of Watergate yet, because the men who broke into Watergate, they're about to go on trial for burglary. Now, this whole time, the media has been reporting on the evidence against Nixon, unravelling what really happened with Watergate.
The White House has been continuously denying involvement. In fact, Nixon even announces that White House counsel John Dean, he's a part of Creep, has investigated the Watergate bugging and found that nobody in the White House was involved. So it's all fine, guys. And at the trial, none of the burglars talk because Nixon's team are offering them all money, jobs, clemency, pardons, whatever it takes to make sure that nobody tells the full story. But then, one of the members, James McCord, knows how Nixon works.
And he's not buying the promises. Nuh-uh. So right at the end of the trial... He writes a letter to the judge. And James McCord says that perjury has been committed during this trial. He says that political pressure has been put on the defendants to plead guilty and to stay quiet. He says that there are people higher up who have not been held responsible. And shortly after McCord comes forward, so does the White House counsel, John Dean. And that's when things really start to come crashing down, because suddenly Nixon is facing two massive investigations.
In February 1973, the U.S. Senate creates a special committee just to investigate Watergate, and they decide to broadcast these hearings live on television. And then the Justice Department appoints an independent special prosecutor named Archibald Cox to lead a criminal investigation. So for weeks, Americans are watching as government officials and campaign aides and lawyers and burglars and White House staff all sit under oath and explain what happened.
It's the first time that politics becomes like this national kind of reality TV event. Like in Nixon's life, you can imagine you've had the invention of television, the invention of colour of a television, and now the broadcast of this trial to the public through television. So John Dean testifies in June and Dean tells the committee that Nixon knew about and arranged the cover up. Massive. Throws him completely under the bus. Completely. And Nixon, of course, responds. He's like, no, Dean is lying. And it becomes his word against Dean's.
Except then a month later, a relatively routine question is asked. Huh. Did Nixon ever record conversations in the White House? Something you should know about Nixon is that when he moved to the White House, he installed a tape recorder in the Oval Office to record all of his conversations, as he wanted an exact private record of his presidency. Now, previous presidents had done similar, mainly Lyndon, but he thought it would be useful in the future for settling disputes and protecting himself against inaccurate memoirs or staff accounts.
The slightly ridiculous part of that system that he installed was that it was automatic and sound activated. So rather than something Nixon personally got to switch on or off for individual conversations, every conversation in the Oval Office was recorded. And it was activated by his presence. And it is fucking ridiculous, the sort of things that were recorded then. Okay, what were recorded? What was recorded? Okay. So him and his friends, his aides, his homeboys, are sitting around saying things like, do you think homosexuality brought down ancient Rome?
And then Nixon saying that he wouldn't shake hands with anyone from San Francisco. He wants to know, like... Do you think television or Socrates had more influence? This is what the boys talk about. Yeah, if you're ever wondering, apparently that's it. But he says racist and anti-Semitic things. It's interesting. I think a lot of people have tried to decode Nixon as well because he... As we said, a bit of an outsider. And a lot of people would be quite shocked by these comments. I think, interesting the time, he definitely presented as quite a normal guy most of the time.
And I think people have kind of assumed that in those conversations, he was trying to sound tougher than he was. Or trying to just like, I don't know, it's like a locker room chat he was trying to be a part of. Not to give him any excuse, but it doesn't feel like it just seemed weird to me. the whole thing. It's so bizarre. Of course, the Senate then requested copies of Nixon's Oval Office recordings, and Nixon refuses. And he says that private presidential conversations are protected by executive privilege.
But, you know, he doesn't give them nothing. He offers them summaries. He offers them edited transcripts. Yeah, but he only offered it if like one senator of his choosing was the one to listen to these and make notes. And that's really all he was offering. So he wasn't offering that they could have the tape. He was offering, okay, this one guy, my friend, can do it and he'll tell you what's in them. But that friend was incredibly racist and reactionary and was also deaf. Well, in any case, Archibald Cox, you know, the special prosecutor in the criminal investigation, he's not having a bar of this.
He says, no, I want the tapes. And for over three months, the two of them are in this like back and forth about whether or not they're going to release these tapes. And by October 1973, things reach a breaking point. So Nixon tells the Attorney General to fire Cox. The Attorney General refuses, he resigns instead. So then Nixon goes to the Deputy Attorney General and asks him to fire Cox, but he also refuses and resigns instead. But finally, Nixon does find someone who will fire Cox.
This all happens on a Saturday night, and it becomes known as the Saturday Night Massacre. And public opinion of Nixon changes almost instantly. And so Nixon, he's scared of what's about to happen. So he sends people from the White House to the office to seize any evidence that Cox may have. Congress is flooded with demands for his impeachment at this stage. And that makes sense. Like to fire the guy that's investigating you is very guilty looking, right? And not something that has happened at all in recent years under the American administration.
No, no, no. I don't understand why he didn't burn the tapes. Like, I don't understand how when this was first happening, he didn't immediately disregard this evidence. Like, it seems like a weird moral high ground for him to have, like, to be honest about that. He respects the preservation of evidence, clearly. Apparently. That's where the line is drawn. But at this stage now, his approval rating has plummeted to 17% and he is flooded with angry messages, telegrams. And at the same time, the world is imploding. If we were to zoom out to the rest of the world, there's wars breaking out.
There's confrontation between the US and the USSR. And pretty much Nixon is distracted with Watergate. So eventually, Nixon is forced to submit the subpoenaed tapes. However, interesting, when investigators listen to a crucial recording from June 30, which is just three days after that Watergate break-in, they realise that 18.5 minutes of the tape is missing. It's just like dead air right in the middle of Nixon's conversation with his chief of staff. And Nixon's secretary, Rosemary Woods, she says the gap is,
She's like, it happened accidentally, like while she was transcribing the tape. She claims like, you know, she was answering the phone. She pressed the wrong pedal. She erased the tape while stretching awkwardly across her desk. This became known as the Rosemary Stretch. And prosecutors made her try and recreate the stretch to prove that it was pretty much impossible for her to have naturally done this unless she was like really intending to. So that kind of unravels this explanation for why the tape is missing. So funny. Nixon looks guilty. Yeah, the rosemary stretch.
That's hilarious. So then at this stage, Nixon decides, okay, fine. Like, you can have more. And he seems to think that maybe if he tries an entirely different tactic, if he won 80s and gives them so much content, floods the zone, they'll be so bamboozled and unable to make sense of it all. So he gives them 1,200 pages worth of his conversations, but has all of the swear words redacted, including words like damn. And that is the Quaker in him. Ah, yes. This is where he draws the line. Yes. So by 1974, the question was no longer whether Watergate was a scandal.
The question was, could Nixon survive this? And the House of Representatives begins formal impeachment proceedings. He isn't impeached yet, but he is going to be put on trial in the Senate. And there are still more tapes that Nixon is refusing to hand over. So the case went all the way up to the Supreme Court. And on July 24th, 1974, the Supreme Court rules unanimously against Nixon. The court says that executive privilege is not absolute. A president cannot use it to hide evidence needed for a criminal trial.
This is an explosive and damning finding for Nixon. And as a result, Nixon releases all the unedited audio. And in that audio... There are two very important conversations. One was known as the smoking gun tape. It was a conversation between Nixon and his chief of staff where he approves a plan to get the CIA to block the FBI from digging into Watergate. is known as the cancer on the presidency tape. So in this one, Nixon met with John Dean, his White House counsel, and discussed how different administration officials had been blackmailed in relation to Watergate.
He said that up to $1 million could be needed to pay the original Watergate burglars to keep them silent in court. These are damning admissions. And both of these tapes would prove that even if Nixon wasn't originally aware of the Watergate break-in, he was illegally involved in their cover-ups. And the Republican support that kept him afloat completely disappeared. Senior Republican leaders go to the White House and tell Nixon that if he is impeached, he no longer has enough votes in the Senate to survive and that he's going to be removed.
And again, the rest is history did share this, but there's this extraordinary story from the final days of Nixon's presidency that gives you a sense of where he was at emotionally. So according to Henry Kissinger's account, Nixon calls Kissinger to the White House late at night and they sit together and they drink brandy. And Nixon breaks down crying and asks Kissinger to pray with him. And the two of them apparently get down on their knees together and Nixon is sobbing, right? And the detail that I think says so much about Nixon is that afterwards, he apparently starts begging Kissinger not to tell anyone that he cried because he doesn't want anyone to think that he wasn't strong, which is particularly unfortunate because Kissinger did go on to tell everyone about it.
He's such a messy, messy bitch. And we're talking about it now. Anyway, on August 8th, 1974, Nixon goes on television and he announces that he will resign the next day. This is where the melodrama really reaches a fever pitch. So what he does is he gathers the White House staff and his family together for his farewell speech. And he's clearly exhausted and emotional and he hasn't slept properly for days. And he keeps breaking down and the speech sort of starts becoming incredible.
incredibly personal, right? He talks about his father, he talks about his mother, about how she lost two sons. He calls his mother a saint. And at one point, he starts reading Theodore Roosevelt's writing about losing his wife. And then he ends on this incredibly dramatic reflection about how you only really understand life's highest moments when you've experienced its lowest ones. And then he walks out of the White House, gets onto a helicopter, gives a double peace sign and flies away. Did we expect anything different though from our cinematic king?
And that was that. So you might be asking, what happened next? Gerald Ford, Nixon's vice president, becomes the president. And a month later, he makes one more decision that becomes honestly, maybe almost as controversial as Watergate itself. He grants Nixon a full, free and absolute pardon for any federal crimes he may have committed as president. So Ford says that he's trying to help the country move forward. But, you know, there's a huge question here of like, is he actually helping out his former president?
I mean, I wasn't surprised to read that at all. No. Right? Like, surely he was always going to pardon him. Like, I think partly it might have been a loyalty. I don't know. I mean, ethically dubious, obvious, but... I think also if he now is president and he wants to continue potentially being president in the next run, the last thing he wants is a complicated trial hanging over his head. And knowing that he would definitely appeal as well. Like it would just go on and on. And knowing that any damning findings against Nixon would probably be damning findings that would rub off somewhat on the Republican Party.
Yeah, I think so. And also, I don't think Nixon's health was in a particularly great way, either physically or mentally. I think people were really worried about his mental health at this stage. But at the end of all of this, what that means is that Nixon was never really brought to any kind of formal justice for his role in the Watergate scandal. I mean, you know... I mean, he got kicked out. Well, he resigned under the threat of being kicked out. But he never faced criminal or legal proceedings against him. So that kind of brings us to the end of the story.
But I think there's still this lingering question of why is this the scandal that is referenced so much in popular culture, has embedded itself in, you know, political and journalistic history, gone down as one of the biggest stories of the 20th century? Why do you think that this moment in history was so infamous? And I say that especially because, you know... We've seen, not worse since, but like, you compare this to like Reagan or Trump storming the Capitol or... Or Bush.
Yeah. George Bush in the Iraq War. Like, this is not the only political scandal that we've had. And yet it is one, I think, that sticks in the minds of people a lot. I wonder if it's because it went on for so long or because it was such a layered incremental story to unravel. I also wonder if it's because the cover-up was almost more ridiculous than the scandal. Yes, I was going to say the cover-up, I think, is a big part of it. The cover-up is the story, really. Also, the details that come out of this, Operation Gemstones, the lengths that people were willing to go are great.
Crazy. We can say that. They're crazy. I also think it came at a time that there was a massive distrust in the world. And I think this felt like a symptom of what was going to be the problem and has continued to be the problem in politics. I also wonder if this was just it was a different time. And I think we've become desensitized. We have become desensitized in a way. And I think there is something so funny to us because we have seen politics get so much more ridiculous since this. But it wasn't funny at the time, right? No one was laughing when this happened.
No one saw the ridiculousness in it in the way that we can do retrospectively or even when we compare it to current politics. And I think this was because maybe at a time this was when politics was still seen in a higher regard. These were offices of integrity. Yeah, and I think this was the beginning of that changing. And playing down into these kind of almost fantastical caricatures of politicians. It was the beginning... Can you say it's the beginning of the dirty politician to this extent? I don't know if you can, but I think you can say that it's maybe when...
the dirty politician and the tactics of a dirty politician became so explicit, so public, and also just so fanciful. Like the kind of game of politics I don't think had to that point ever looked so ridiculous, but also so serious at the same time. So serious. And yet all of the got such a weird frat boy energy. It's like a film. Yeah. The theatre kid at heart.
That's my takeaway from this story, is that Nixon was a theatre kid at heart and he had a almost like Greek tragedy style rise and fall. And to be clear, this story is horrific. People's lives were ruined. As you said, not a laughing matter at the time, but looking back on it, it almost And that's Big Talk for the month. That is Big Talk for the month. Thank you so much for having me back on this month. Thank you for coming on. Thank you for researching this with me.
Thank you to Grace for helping to research. Thank you to Grace for all her amazing research on this story. We couldn't have done it without her. And we will see you next month. Bye.
There’s a lot no one tells you when you start working. Luckily, this week Sarah is joined by someone who has made all the mistakes so you don’t have to: Sophie Hirst (aka Soph Workbaby). With a career spanning Nylon,...
We are coming to you with some breaking news: Robert Pattinson has been named as the next James Bond, and Sarah has thoughts. Is he the reinvention 007 needs, or a safe studio pick? Then, Justine unpacks how one of the...
If you're in your late twenties and feel like your entire life is being turned upside down, you might just be in your Saturn Return. Breakups, career changes, friendship shifts and existential crises. According to...
Well well well. It’s a new week and a whole new world that we’ve woken up to. First up, Hannah explains what happened in the U.S. mid-terms. The Democrats won BIG and we want to know why. What does this mean for the...
From WitchTok and tarot cards to manifestation and etsy witches - it seems women are embracing their witchy side more than ever. But whats the darker history of witches? For centuries, women accused of witchcraft were...