Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Big Small Talk

Big Small Talk artwork

Why Does Australian Media Still Have The Same Problems? With Antoinette Lattouf

Jun 3, 202654 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Antoinette Lattouf is a journalist, author and co-founder of ETTE Media who knows a thing or two about winning. In her new book, Women Who Win, she explores what it means to win (why women often don't) and the Australian women who have changed the course of history. In this episode we chat about her legal victory against the ABC after she was removed from air over a social media post about Gaza, why it's so important to own your own work, and how difficult women who challenge the status quo are consistently targeted for doing so. Sarah-Jane Instagram Antoinette Instagram Women Who Win ETTE Media

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

A listener production. Women who have an opinion, women who are difficult, women who are challenging the status quo are often attacked and maligned and ridiculed and defamed in the media. Hi, I'm Sarah and this is Small Talk. It's not quite a news headline, but it is what the girls are talking about. And I am so thrilled to be here today with Antoinette Latouf. Welcome. Thank you for coming on. Oh, thank you for having me. I'm so excited to talk to you today.

You are the co-founder of Et Media. You have the podcast We Used To Be Journos. You are the co-founder of Media Diversity Australia, the author of now two books. And the most recent one being Women Who Win, who really just came out. When did this... Uh... Four or five weeks ago? Yeah. It's very new. And congrats on the writing festival being the most sold in Sydney. Yes. And Melbourne? Melbourne. Congratulations. Yes. It's been a wild month. That's a huge month.

I know we briefly met once before. I think my mum made us all take a selfie together outside of that. That's right. Outside of the, what was it, the opera house? In front of the opera house. Yes. Yeah, yeah. Which you went on stage for, I remember. Was that? Yes. Being pulled up there? I can't remember. Yes, I was on stage for that. Yes. Everything's a bit of a blur. The past two years of my life were a bit of a blur. Yeah. Tell us about how the book rollout's been. Should I tell you a little, should we start with what the book's about?

Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, we're going to get into all of them, please. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay. So it hasn't even been a year yet since I won the big court case against the ABC. And I had titled this book and started writing the book during the process. Yeah. And so I really wanted to sort of capture the raw emotions of what it takes to be a woman who wins, what it means to be a woman who wins, and how on earth throughout Australian history, women have taken on these huge lopsided battles, David versus Goliath style battles, and how on earth they found the strength, the perseverance, the clarity to keep going, and also how they were treated by society and media at the time.

And so I really started to write this book because I needed to figure out how the hell I'm going to keep going, what a win looks like for me, what it looks like for other women, what it means for Australian society. And in many ways, it was just an IV drip of courage. Each time I reached out to women or researched women who were no longer with us and spent hours and hours and hours and days and days and days deep into newspaper archives, looking at the way they were spoken about as well, because at the time of writing and even till now... Women who have an opinion, women who are difficult, women who are challenging the status quo are often attacked and maligned and ridiculed and defamed in the media.

So at the very time I was being all of those things, targeted in all of those ways, I was reading stuff about convict women settlers in the early 19th century and how they were being jailed and persecuted and treated because they dared to swear. Yeah. And I was like, oh, wow, how some things have changed and how few things have changed at the same time. So I really wanted to use the fact that a lot of people know about my case. A lot of people know about my win against the ABC. And I wanted to use my story as a way to tell the stories of other women because a lot of them aren't known and their wins aren't celebrated.

And there's a reason why history forgets. or conveniently fails to celebrate women who've won. Yeah. Well, not celebrating, but also if they are in the headlines, the media is awful. And we do the series on here, Big Talk, where we go back and revisit old news stories and sort of timeline it. And, you know, we've done Monica Lewinsky and, like, Dingo ate my baby and like all this different stuff. And it's the one consistent thing across every single big talk we've done that has a female protagonist in it is what the media said at the time versus what actually happened.

Yeah, exactly. And it's so interesting talking to our mums and to like my grandma or whatever people that were around during those news stories. Yeah. And hearing their version of events just based on the headlines they saw growing up versus me then explaining, well, no, actually, this is what happened. Right. And the disconnect is just, is huge. And so that was part of a big reason also why I wrote that story and why in real time I pushed back against the narratives about me. I was like, I'm going to do some counter-narrativing here. I know a thing or two about media. I know a thing or two about setting agendas.

So guess what? I'm not going to just lay down and cop it because that's the expectation for so many women that you're either you're shunned from public life, you're exiled, you're imprisoned, your reputation and career are ruined. And so understanding what this sort of process is, looks like and what has been used again and again, it was terrifying, but it also was instructive because I was like, hmm, I know how this is going to go. And so I'm going to do a counter narrative here and I'm going to tell my own story.

It's pretty incredible to do that in the thick of it as well, though, because- Yes, it's insane. That's insane. It's insane. But did that help you during that time to be able to have this to focus on and to draw inspiration from as well? Because to do this while having so much on your plate during that time is remarkable. I think it gave me agency and it gave me a sense of control when so many things were out of my control. Not only the things that were happening to me, but things that are happening to our democracy and our civil liberties at a time when we are criminalising dissent and we are not...

criminalising or using our diplomatic and legal tools against those who commit human rights atrocities in Gaza and in Lebanon. We are not using the tools we have to punish powerful actors doing horrible things. We're going after individuals who wear a T-shirt that says, from the river to the sea, or we're going after someone like me who shared a human rights watch post about starvation as a tool of war. And so there are so many people who felt overwhelmed by our lack of civil liberties, creeping authoritarianism. And obviously it was overwhelming and frightening for me.

But I think if I did nothing, it would be more ruinous for me as a person. I would feel worse. not only about my own future, about the future of our democracy and the independence of public broadcasting, but also that I sat around and did nothing while an unprecedented amount of journalists had been killed by Israel in Lebanon and Palestine, whilst children are being starved in plain sight. So doing something for me was important. Otherwise, I think I would have spiralled. I think I wouldn't have been able to keep going. I think...

Pretty much everyone who listened to this podcast would already... Like, we followed on the podcast. I mean, we know it happened. But for anyone listening that doesn't, do you have a... Can you kind of summarize? A very summary, elevate a pitch of my trauma. It's so funny that you can never assume that people know. Even though most people do. I did have a look at... I mean, most people read reviews about their books. But I went on to Goodreads and the very first review of my book by a member of the public was like... I had never heard of this author or what she went through, but I really enjoyed learning about it and I really enjoyed the stories of all the other women and I really liked the book cover.

So my very first reviewer had no idea. It is funny. I think when you work in media and you're a journalist, you're like, everyone knows this, but there probably would be people. There are people. Yes. So very, very brief is that... I was presenting for ABC Radio in local radio in the lead up to Christmas. I was on a short-term contract. I am a journalist and an author. I am Lebanese-Australian and I have worked across many outlets in many different areas of journalism.

And at that point in my career, I was freelance, happily so, doing a bunch of different things at a bunch of different outlets. It wasn't uncommon for me to fill in as a presenter on the ABC. Yeah. I had shared a Human Rights Watch post on the third day while I was on air or after I was on air. I did nothing relating to geopolitics or whatever on the podcast because it was the lead up to Christmas. It was very conversational. Music, summer tips, talkback, all of those things. But I was targeted by the pro-Israel lobbyists because I am critical of Israel's conduct and because I was critical of the fact that Israel's using starvation as a weapon of war.

So merely In my Instagram stories, a post that the ABC had already reported on twice, a finding the ABC had already reported on twice, I was called into my manager's office, dismissed on the spot, told to get my bags and leave. And by the time I'd gotten home, there was already a defamatory, horrible hit piece about me in The Australian News. And it later surfaced a couple of weeks later. There were a couple of WhatsApp groups, Lawyers for Israel and other creatives and academics, Jewish creatives and academics who were targeting me, targeting the board and then celebrating my sacking.

And And then I had to fight it for almost two years in the federal court to prove that the ABC targeted me for my political opinion. Not that I did anything wrong because I had alleged that I didn't listen to my manager and that I breached editorial policy and I breached social media policy. I had done no such thing. I had done nothing wrong, literally nothing wrong. Yeah. So rarely is there a very clean victim. Like usually in court cases, they're like, yeah, but you kind of did this. You kind of did that. And, you know, no, like I literally did nothing. I literally did nothing wrong, but I still had to fight tooth and nail for my career, my reputation, my mental health, my safety.

Anyway, I won. It said employment law precedent because... testing political opinion under the, whatever, I'm not going to get into it. It's boring legalese, but it's at legal precedent in Australia because that section of the law had never been tested. And the ABC spent $2.6 million fighting me and they had denied it right to the very end that they had done anything wrong. And I won. It was... probably, like, I think the most engaged we've ever seen our audience when we were covering this. I think it just shocked everyone about how long it went on, how much taxpayer money was spent, what they tried to do.

But just the way you spoke throughout it was just... incredible. And I think reading your book and seeing, it was a good reminder of what actually would have been happening for you behind the scenes. Oh, it's so hard. That's why I wrote it in real time because people had this perception of me being invincible and stoic and had my shit together when I really didn't. I was terrified regularly. Yeah. I was self-doubting and spiralling often. But then so many other women I spoke to were, and they were courageous because they kept going, even though they were terrified and they were threatened and they were targeted.

They just knew what they were doing was necessary. It's probably one of the biggest benefits of writing this book because it's really honest and it's really raw. A moment in time, really. Yeah. Yeah. Can I take us all the way back for a second? I want to talk about when you first became a journalist. What was the media landscape like at the time when you first started this job? It was incredibly white, incredibly middle class, incredibly city-centric. But I really wanted to be part of storytelling and be part of such a powerful podcast.

lever or part of our democracy because I know it plays a really crucial role. Now that I look back, my first job was at SBS and it was where all good little ethnics go and start. But I look around, if I think back to all of my colleagues and the news directors and the presenters and the managers and stuff, and they were all, it's the multicultural broadcaster, but they were all white, which is sort of emblematic of how non-inclusive our industry is and what that trickle-down effect is. for a society and a democracy that is so culturally and linguistically diverse.

But it also gives you a taste of how and why certain issues about minoritised and marginalised communities are treated or ignored. Because you have a particular lens and a particular worldview that dominates newsrooms around the country. Was wanting to change that part of what made you want to become a journalist? Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, absolutely. So I grew up in the so-called War on Terror era. I grew up in Western Sydney. There was the Cronulla riots when I was still at school or university. I have distinct memories of September 11.

And the coverage and the narrative after that, the gaslighting and excuses to... go into Iraq and kill hundreds and hundreds of thousands of Iraqi people for so-called weapons of mass destruction. We just did a whole deep dive on the Iraq war. It is insane. And also how the media manufactures consent for outward racism, or in this case, genocide. And there was just so many things that were dangerous and unfair, whether it was the shock jocks or whether it was Murdoch press.

And perhaps... naively. I thought that I could contribute to it and change it if I joined. My voice would be part of a shift. And 10 years into working in the media, I was like, hey, things haven't changed. And so I started a not-for-profit, Media Diversity Australia, thinking, well, okay, we need other things to help structural change come about. And so we did things like academic research with university partners. We did internships and scholarships and mentorships for mid-range journalists of colour to go into management roles.

I did that for seven years while still working as a journalist. And then I left that in 2022, the not-for-profit is still going. And then after October 2023, And the way that story has been covered and the way journalists who are either Arab or Muslim or even journalists who call out the industry to be fairer and more ethical about the way we report on the unfolding genocide in Gaza, the way we've been treated and the way Arabs continue to be dehumanised and disregarded has made me think, well, I'm an idiot.

All those years I thought that we were making progress. Here we are back again to the early 2000s level of racism and division. I think that's part of why I was really wanting to talk to you today, because I think being sort of new to journalism in a way, part of me was like racking my brains about, is this what it was like 20 years ago? Or have I just become more media literate and I notice this more now? Well, it was really bad back then, but it's, I fear, worse now. I think it's worse now because we think we had gotten past things.

We thought we were better. We thought we had learnt lessons. The lessons are about the impact of ignoring blatant things breaches of international law and human rights atrocities, what that does to safety and security, you can't bomb your way into safety and security. Because there's a lot of evidence that shows that the treatment of Iraqis and the desecration of the Iraqi state led to the birth of ISIS and al-Qaeda and extremist organisations. And also when you demonise and dehumanise huge sections of the Australian community, that's not good for

Australia's democracy. When you impinge on civil liberties, like the freedom to protest or the freedom to say certain words, that doesn't make anybody safer. From a media perspective, I don't think we've gotten better, sadly. It's just, and perhaps that's why I fought so hard in the courts, because I wanted it to be public knowledge about the institutional failures in this moment in time. I wanted it to be aired. I wanted everybody to know just how easily the ABC capitulated to the looking at coverage and going, this is incongruent with what I know to be happening.

I don't know if you know, Sarah, but in the last 24 hours, Penny Wong sanctioned a bunch of Israeli settlers in the West Bank and also organisations for their violence against Palestinians. It's barely been covered. Did you know that? I didn't know. Exactly. I didn't know. It hasn't been covered. And so that raises questions. Absolutely. This is part of what, like, this reckoning I feel like I've had in the last few years of being, it's sort of like that, even when I wanted to join journalism, and I'm so proud of being in journalism, but so much of wanting to join it was like, you feel like you're part of this, like,

you're the good guy you're giving a voice to the voiceless you're speaking truth to power yada yada and there's like whole establishment um realization that you have of like who controls the media really and who's there and gas lobby and pro-israel lobby and yeah yeah And I think what's so, like speaking of media broadly, when I joined, I think there was such a rhetoric that you would hear from, you know, even our university lecturers being like, well, you know, media used to be tough, but thankfully, like we've had the Me Too movement and everything and everything's solved.

Yeah. we sort of walked in thinking, it's still tough, but like used to be worse and all the problems were solved because we had this movement or we had something. There was a bit of a sense between, and it's interesting because Me Too was 2017, I believe. And 2017 is when I launched the not-for-profit. I was like, okay, this is the era of inclusivity, guys. Yeah, there was like a real like hope to it. That was when I just finished high school and I was like, amazing guys, thanks for that. Yeah, yeah, yeah, thanks for the legwork, guys. Yeah, there was this sense and I think one of the things I highlight in the book, how shifts and changes and wins, they ebb and flow and nothing is static.

Like the book, if anything, is an examination of what it is to win. Yeah, Because, and I look at the Me Too movement and those so-called wins then were turned on their heads because of Australia's, we have some of the harshest defamation laws, people who came out against perpetrators, alleged perpetrators of sexual assault and sexual abuse, were then sued for defamation. And there's evidence, there's this data which shows the flow-on effect that had of people then no longer coming forward and reporting it. They were too scared that A, it's probably not going to get prosecuted by police, but you may be at risk of being prosecuted for defamation.

And it impacts journalism too. Even opinion pieces we have to be so careful of because the defamation laws are so intense here of like even just sounding like you've taken a side. And it's like, well, yeah, it's an opinion piece. Yeah, make it clear it's really tricky. I don't mean to sound like too much of a downer, but this is the trajectory I've been on and my shifting perspective and a bit of a sad and heartbreaking awakening, really, about the status quo.

There was something you wrote about in the book. Actually, I'm going to read out the little quotes so people can hear. But you said, As the first Arab woman to work as a reporter in Australian commercial television and the first woman in my extended working class family to graduate from university, I was too busy clinging to the doorframe of opportunity to question why I had to dislocate myself to squeeze in. That? So beautifully written, by the way. But really, I think, speaks to what I'm talking about of like, wow, we were so... willing to be there that we really wanted to, I think, in a way, believe that the worst of it was behind us.

Well, things are okay if you're blinkered by being grateful. You're so grateful. You're so grateful to have a seat at the table. You're so grateful to be there. And in some ways, if you continue to be grateful and not difficult, things will be okay for you. If you continue to be grateful and not go, oh, oh, I don't know if this is so good. I don't know how good it is for others. I don't know if we're really doing what our charter or our purpose is. Then you, A, wouldn't end up in this book. You also wouldn't end up being latoufed, as has become a word in the Urban Dictionary. And I was not one of those people who could stay eternally grateful and eternally silent and eternally compliant.

I think that is the shift, though. I think that is what you realise that... And it's not even... I mean, it's very particular to media, but I think it's a lot of women feel this in every... Yes, and I hear from women and people from minoritised communities all the time about that, that I thought I was safe, I thought things were okay, until I started asking why. And if I started asking if things could be better. Was there advice that you would have for women at the start of their career now? Like if they were joining media or they were joining something within this landscape, what would your advice to them be?

Would it be to own your own work or to figure out how to advocate for yourself? Like where do you even begin right now? Yeah, it's a tricky time because there is increasing casualisation of the workforce. So the people who are in most precarious positions are usually women or people, again, from minority backgrounds. People with disabilities, people who are First Nations, people of colour. And so already you're at a bit of a disadvantage. I guess the fact that I was a casual, I was on a casual contract, probably speaks to why the ABC was so arrogant in their mistreatment of me, probably thinking, what is she going to do?

Like she's on a one-week contract. We're the largest broadcaster in the country. What is she really going to do? And so, yes, you probably do start off in a position of less power. I guess my main thing that I can say, because I don't know everybody's circumstances, is to be really clear about what your North Star is, why it is you do what you do. And as cliche as it sounds, my North Star has always been to give a voice to communities and to people who don't have a voice and the equal cliche in journalism of speaking truth to power.

And every time I've come up against something and I'm like, okay. Am I doing this? And to work towards a community and a democracy that is more inclusive and functions better. Anytime I come across a barrier or something that feels off or a challenge, I question, how does this sit with my North Star? Is it relevant? Is it worth the fight? Is it worth pushing back against? And throughout the entire process, even though they were sometimes going, I'm insane for thinking that I can take on the ABC, take on the Murdoch press who are attacking me, take on the pro-Israel lobby who were doing everything in their power to see my demise from public life.

I was like, what's my North Star? And my North Star was very clear and I continued focusing on it and my behaviour and my ethics never wavered from what I believe in. That and also surround yourself with people who you can lean on and you can trust, even if it's only a few people, because in times of adversity, you're often, there are many people who step away from you. With those two things, I think no matter what comes your way, that will help you navigate it and help you determine if you should persist or what it is your course of action is, particularly in a landscape that is changing so much.

It's impossible for me to really dish out career advice in a landscape that is changing so fast and at the same time will never change as slow. In that moving forward. The attitude's the same, but the mediums are different sort of thing. But also the rate of change with technology and with AI is something that I can't even prepare for. Oh, terrifying. So even though throughout my career, I can look back and go, wow, it's changed so much. The next 10 years are going to change even faster. And it's those sort of ethics and what ends up becoming your brand that you can take wherever you go.

And I think if your brand then goes to books or to podcasting or to not-for-profits or to government, whatever it is that you do, I think that that being really cemented is your most powerful asset. What I find really fascinating about your story and the insights that you now have is that you have been on both sides of the coin of Australian media. Like you've been the one chasing the story and now you've been the story. How has being on both sides of that influenced sort of your perception of media in Australia and journalism and tabloid fodder and just the way we operate in Australia?

Yeah, it's interesting because I have been the court reporter chasing people down the street as they come out of court. I have thankfully never worked for any of the Murdoch tabloids, so I don't empathise with some of the crap that they put out. I think what it gave me was a unique insight in how to use it to the best of my ability. I know I was better placed than other people to withstand a livestream trial. I knew that I could represent myself properly under pressure in a way that other people who don't have as much privilege or practice could.

But in that moment, immediately I went to feelings of empathy and anger for other women and other people who don't have that training, who get cross-examined and who get slut-shamed and who get treated in all sorts of horrible, unjust ways on the stand. Because I don't want to get into it, but in the book I detail two horrible, horrible techniques the ABC used on The justice system isn't necessarily a justice system. It's a legal system. Oh, yeah. And sometimes it's justice for whoever can afford it, whoever can represent themselves the best.

But it also enabled me to do things like hold a press conference on my own grounds at the end of the... because I knew how it would work. I worded up the journos that I was coming out to speak. I didn't take questions. I then said what I wanted to say on my own podcast when I launched media a week later. So it actually, in some ways, I had the tools to navigate the situation as best as possible and to counter some of the attacks that were coming my way. Yeah. How did you find trust again in institutions and in staying within the media landscape in Australia?

Well, I think trust is something that has to be earned. The entire time I have said and continue to say, I want the ABC to be strong and independent and robust and fearless and all of the things. I've heard you say this and I go, I agree. But I find it so hard to fathom not feeling so let down by the fact that they are meant to be our North Star. I know. I know at one point when I walked in, I was being, and here's the other thing, like half of the journos or the camera people I know who were standing outside of court coming up.

So some would give me encouraging winks and things like that. So there was a lot of unspoken solidarity. And I remember one time when I was walking into court and I rarely gave comments, but one time I did and I said, well, the ABC are meant to be the good guys. And if the good guys are behaving this appallingly, what hope do we have? Like what are the bad guys doing? And so I think that was what's really heartbreaking for me, but I think for a lot of the Australian public, they were really heartbroken because as so many things in our democracy are under threat with the rise of populism politics with One Nation, with the criminalisation of protests, infringement on civil liberties, we really do need our media to hold power to account and not cower and bow to power.

Yeah. So how do we trust? Trust is earned. We have to see repeated behaviour and repeated instances of when the ABC can withstand lobbying. At the moment, Grace Tame is under attack. Again, yep. We have to see them back their staff. We have to see them shrug off or ignore attacks by the Australian. Part of the federal court judgment actually said that, in his words, Justice Range, the ABC went into, to quote, a state of panic because the Australian were wanting to write an article about me because they'd been briefed or they already been chatting to the lawyers for Israel WhatsApp group.

And the ABC panicked. They're going to have to beat the story, was one of one of the middle management had said in a text message, which we'd subpoenaed. And so I think we need repeated examples where they can withstand pressure, whether that's pressure from the government, pressure from the gas lobby, pressure from whoever. Yeah. And protect your staff. And defend your staff. Because we also saw in subpoenaed emails, Aita Buttrous say, referred to me as, we owe her nothing. Can't you come down with COVID? We need to get her out. Like, it's essentially like get rid of her and speaking about me like I was, you know, a dirty dishcloth that needed to be thrown out.

Yeah, the cowering to The Australian was probably one of the most shocking parts of this. And I have to ask you about The Australian's recent reach out with you. See, now I just clap back. That was incredible. Yeah. So the context is they reached out when they saw that you had made a business in Yeah, name for Women Who Win. So in the past couple of weeks, they've just written as many articles as they can about me. They don't like my book, which I mean, I'd be a bit worried if they did. They don't like my book.

They came into defense of Ida Bartros in another article. I don't know how they tracked. I don't even know how you keep tabs on. I registered the business name Women Who Win because I just wanted to keep it. It's a catchy title. I want to own it. That's a business move. That makes complete sense. Yeah. Which these uber capitalists over at the Australian you would think would love, right? You know? How would you even know? How many business names get registered? It's another thing I wanted to talk about with you. It's like a bit of a sidestep. We'll come back to it. But I think the amount of people...

especially in the Murdoch media that seems committed to key women just tracking them, staying on them. We've seen it with Abby Chatfield. We've seen it with Grace Tame. We've seen it with you. With Randall Fattah. I know Hannah's face. It happens over and over again. Honestly, I feel like there is a board somewhere. A whiteboard with a hit list. 100%. With a hit list and just be like, monitor whatever they do. Yeah. And whether that is walk your dog, own a business, cry. Oh, yeah, they wrote an article about me.

Anyway, they wrote so many articles. But this one was they had registered, they noted that I had registered Women Who Win Mm-hmm. And then I trademarked it and, because how dare I? And they put questions to me and it was like questions of urgency. Like they needed me to respond right away. Like, why have I done this? Yeah. Firstly, none of your fucking business. But also I knew that they weren't asking in good faith. They were not here to celebrate a woman entrepreneur. And so I wrote back knowing that they weren't going to publish my response, but also publishing my response before they published their article.

I can't remember the exact words, but words to the effect is, I'm inspired by Rupert Murdoch and I would like to build a business on targeting and harassing women, not paying tax, denying climate change and manufacturing consent for genocide. And that is why I did this. Anyway, so they published the article. And they say, you know, Antoinette Latouf did not respond in time. I did respond in time, but I was just like, well, but I bet my response got more traction and more reads than their stupid piece of we are stalking Antoinette.

The whole concept of smear campaigns that we're seeing again and again in the media. What I find the most frustrating about it is they paint women out, these particular women that they go after and write a dozen articles a week about, as controversial. Yes. And we're all progressive. We're all progressive as well. There's a clear whiteboard. And then the people that are controversial... Get promotions? Yep. And again, this is what I'm linking back when I'm thinking about this was sort of when I joined journalism, told we'd sorted this one out.

Exactly. You're like, hold a second, guys. Yeah, why are we back here? Yeah. Yeah. We even saw the Grace Tame comment, the Charlie Pickering comment as well. Yep. Yep. The fact that this is happening. Yeah. And now there's another last time I checked like 30 to 40 articles about this. And you'll see the selection of the photographs selected by certain outlets of grace. They get you when you're angry or when you're pulling it. Like these are good deliberate choices to choose these women to make them look menacing or problematic or highly emotional and...

Despite the fact that the bottom line in this story is that Grace Tame is guest hosting a podcast about autism as a woman who has autism, is sexual abuse survivor and advocate. How that relates to anything... I also don't even really understand what's in it for them. Like, except that clearly, does it just drive a lot of clicks once people decide, like, maybe that's the universal truth that we like to just team up and hate on a woman? I think there's a couple of things. There's a bit of like, there's a bit of...

misogyny, internalised misogyny about women who are too outspoken, too public. I see it with Abbey Chatfield. They're like, well, she, even women, boomer women in the comments, not only boomer women being like, oh, well, she asks for it. Why doesn't she get off social media? Like victim blaming. I think with Grace Tame, it's a bit more sinister. I think it is trying to conflate the criticism of Israel's actions with anti-Semitism at a time when there's an anti-Semitism royal commission. It's trying to paint anybody who has a problem with human rights atrocities being committed daily, continually in plain sight.

with anti-Semitism and trying to send a warning shot to other people with public profiles, don't say anything about Israel's conduct. We know Rupert Murdoch is a huge supporter of Israel. There are also reports that came out of the Washington Post that he called Trump himself and urged him to bomb Iran. So we have a media owner who has vested interest in the industrial military complex. And so those who criticise that, they're smeared. Their characters are smeared. And if you try and what Grace Tame did in one interview, in one sentence where people didn't like her certain choice of words about claims of sexual abuse on October 7th,

then all of a sudden she's a rape denier, she hates Israeli women, she's anti-Semitic, she's X, Y and Z. When, if I listened to the interview, what she was trying to, and I'm not here to be an interpreter for somebody, Grace Tame was speaking to the... New York Times report about sexual abuse on October 7, that was rolled back. Parts of it were rolled back. And parts of the sources were questionable. And parts of the information had, according to the New York Times itself, been inflated or inaccurate or shared by vested interests.

Anyway. But you see this in the media. They're not taking the full context. They're taking... three lines and then running 50 articles on it. And then for the general public, I don't know how anyone's meant to know that that's not fair. And that's the other thing. I'm constantly aware of the fact that everything I say is being closely monitored, a misplaced explanation. Like things can be so egregious and there can be so much overwhelming evidence, but then there'll be something by Abby or by Hannah, I think with Charlie Kirk. Yeah, those are a huge ones. A couple of lines.

And if you say those words, and maybe they are a little bit inaccurate, maybe they are a little bit insensitive. Mm-hmm. Sure. Like sometimes people make mistakes, but we're not allowed to have misplaced syntax. We're not allowed to, even if the sentiment of our argument is the same and accurate and correct, that's how closely we're watched. And we see all manner of absolute lies, absolute racist dog whistle, absolute propaganda. Yeah.

just said proudly and loudly by other people in the media and they get applauded and they get promoted and they don't get prosecuted in the way that women do. But I also wonder if it creates kind of a feeling of fear within the media as well, because like when you go through something as public as you did or if you are being publicly taken down... You also look to who is your friend in those moments too. And I can only imagine that would have been part of it is, I don't know, for you as well.

I know I've spoken to others and you're like, wait, who's defending this? Part of the reckoning. And that's why I was, and it's really, really clear those who feel the freedom to support you. It was people like Grace Tame supported me, Hannah. You've supported me. Abby Chatfield supported me. Yumi Stein supported me. And if I think about the women, but one thing that these women all have in common, Narelda Jacobs supported me, Vanessa Turnbull Roberts, these two Indigenous fabulous women. What they all have in common is they're not tethered to, actually Narelda Jacobs is, but most aren't tethered to institutions.

Most are either freelance or independent. Yeah, they can. They're not at fear. They're not. And don't get me wrong. You could still have... your podcast network or the network you belong to approached. And I've seen many others have their podcasts taken or advertising revenue go. I know Abby Chatfield lost a lot of advertising revenue by having Voices Critical of Israel on her podcast. Remember our first ever sponsorship for this podcast when it was so new? Because podcasts came out just before October 7 happened. And our first sponsorship was pulled as well.

Yeah. So you have to take a risk. And that's the thing. And you have to be willing to risk something. But that's what solidarity is, particularly at times that are really dystopian and unfair. You have to be willing to risk something. And I know not everyone will be willing to risk everything. Like I risked everything to take this to the federal court. Yeah. And I don't expect everybody to do that, but you have to be able, you have to be willing to risk something. Otherwise, this is how creeping authoritarianism happens. It happens slowly. It happens gradually. It happens because people are silenced. People are worried about their hip pockets. People start to turn on one each other.

This is how it happens. And then in a few decades' time, our children or grandchildren will be studying it going, how did you let this fuckery happen? It's like, well, this is how we let it happen because we allowed fear to dictate. We allowed our civil liberties to be slowly stripped away. We allowed fear of being labelled a certain thing to override what we knew was wrong or action against something that we knew was wrong. Yeah. But, I mean, I don't blame people for being scared. Like, even just the latest attacks on Grace Tame now, I'm just like, oh, this poor woman, how much can one woman withstand?

Exactly. And I think as well, it sounds like you've just come back that the antidote to this in a lot of ways, especially when media is consolidating as fast as it is in Australia, is independent media. It's things like Ed. It's things like Cheek. Is that where you hope the future for Australian media is going then? Well, I don't know that we can all together. We are an antidote. We are an alternative. But we're also up against... The Gina Reinhart, who's buying parts, more media, were also up against the second most concentrated media environment in the world, second to Brazil.

It suffocates independent media. It does. Because you can't, it's not commercially viable to survive in a lot of ways. So that's why we're really, like I'm really, my faith really goes into audiences and the people. And I think one example of that was recently at the Sydney Writers Festival. It was its largest ever turnout. in its 37-year history. More books were sold, more people turned up, and a third of the people who turned up were under 25. Really? So it broke all records. You got the Gen Zs out to get to them.

It broke all records. And look, in part, I mean, there were a lot of Gen Zs who came along to the panel that Jan, Fran, and I did, and some of the other events, and my one on my book, but I can't claim it all. There were also like school excursions and stuff like that. And so school groups and high school groups come through as well. But that's so cool that They're being taken to that. They are. But it was a notable difference in the attendance rates of Sydney Writers' Festival. And my book was the biggest seller at the festival, which again, to me, like I have been attacked in so many different ways and...

And the festival was attacked for platforming, platforming, daring to have Randa Abdul-Fattah in there. Her book was, I think, the number four seller. And so for me, it's audiences. Like I'm hoping that audiences decide and the public decides with their feet and with their money, what it is that they're going to be Like, are we really going to be in a world where the premier can tell us who can and can't be at a writers' festival? Because Chris Minns, the New South Wales premier, was like, I think it's crazy that they would have Randa Abdul-Fattah five or six months after the Bondi terror attack.

The Bondi terror attack is absolutely horrible. It was committed by a father and son psychotic duo. What the hell does that have to do with Rwanda? Also, the father and son, the son is Italian Indian. The dad is Indian. What the hell has this got to do with people who care about a genocide? I know. So much has been conflated. That is so dangerous. It is nonsense. You can hold two truths. There was at the Writers' Festival also a panel about After Bondi, which is a really important panel to have. It's like we can have these conversations and we can have empathy and concern for people without...

having our premiers telling us which books we could read and which authors we can listen to. Yeah, you'd hope so. But it's so interesting looking at this media debate as well. I remember it was like, maybe it was like this time last year, that it was genuinely a debate and a lot of people were talking about even... our podcast, but in the conversation of new media. And like, it was a lot of legacy media coming down really hard on anyone that had used Instagram or podcasts or whatever else to get media out there. And it was like back and forth of like, well, no, I think people, there is a trust thing that we're trying to build in other ways.

Yeah, look, I think you guys copped it more. Like Jan and I have been in legacy media for a long time. And we've moved over. I think people like you and Toilet Paper Australia and Puntis Politics, people who are literally building almost entirely from new media, social media, news influences, whatever you want to call it, were spoken about patronisingly and spoken about. I think we are a bit harder to flick aside. We're a bit harder to dismiss. You guys have earned your stripes. You genuinely... Well, I mean, I'm sure they're still dismissing us in other ways, but I think we're a harder target because we've ticked all the boxes.

I've worked in commercial media, won awards, done this, that and the other. My only thing about the lack of trust in the media and people turning to social media... It also is a breeding ground. It can be a breeding ground for misinformation and disinformation to go rife. Yeah. And for anybody, I've seen all of these pages which look like pseudo news pages. I don't know who's behind them. Actually, we did a story a few months ago that we broke where there's an entirely AI generated newsroom that looks like a newsroom. It's so scary.

And all of the reporters are made up. And it has Instagram page and social page. And it's run by one guy who's not a journo. He's just interested in AI. He's a tech dude. And he puts out content that looks like it's indiscernible. It's really scary. And so that to me, while there's a big distrust in institutions, that worries me because there are these phonies or there's Advance Australia, the far right group that are getting well-funded. There's this, I don't even want to name it, but there's this website which I'm pretty sure is connected to Advance, which again looks like a news.

It is the most white supremacist, sexist, awful thing page of so-called news, but it looks like a news page and it gets shared widely. No, it's really scary. And I think when we, even when we started, that was sort of like, it felt like that really blew up even after we'd already started the podcast. But especially when TikTok took over and there was so many other things that it was, I'm sort of looking both ways and I'm going, well, I understand the problem. There's some serious problems with legacy media.

But I also don't want to be contributing to a problem over here either. I know. It's really... One of the things Jan and I often talk about is being beholden to social media platforms and algorithms is a problem. Like I know a lot of our following and a lot of what you guys do and what we do is amplified on social media and that communication and that, I guess, community. I also know that... Those algorithms can change at any time. And I know we get shadow banned when we talk about certain topics.

I see it. I see it in our engagement. And so I think that there's a real need to develop direct relationships, more direct relationship with audiences via subscriptions, via newsletters. That's annoying because I subscribe to so many newsletters and sometimes you get a very full inbox. But I think that's the only way out because we're seeing more billionaires buy up social media outfits, like TikTok being bought from the US, TikTok also being a place where a lot of young people share things about climate change. They see a lot of things about the genocide.

I don't think it's any secret as to why they don't want... a social media platform that is influencing young people against the very real dangers of society. Yeah. And that worries me as well. So I just think we need to cultivate that relationship directly with audiences and build that trust. Yeah, I think that completely makes sense. The algorithms and the echo chambers and how to reach people beyond that. I know. That really scares me as well on how do we reach people. And there's a lot of conversation that we've had recently on this podcast as well about how to reach people beyond

that are, you know, One Nation supporters. Yeah, which are growing and including among young people and not just in the regions. Yeah, look, sometimes there's a bit of a social experiment. I go to the most vile media person I can think of and I'm not going to say who they are. Actually, there are a few of them, but I just go to their page as a social experiment and I have a look at the engagement and I look at the comments and... And I feel like it is the upside down because almost all of the engagement in uniformity is glowing and you are the truth teller and thank you for your bravery. And I agree with everything you say.

oh, damn, we're in trouble. Yeah. Because then if you go to my page, so much of the comments could be almost the same. We love you, we trust you, blah, blah, blah. And I'm like, oh, dear. Oh, dear. Yeah. I'm like, oh, no. It is. I think the way we're reaching, I mean, the YouTube element to everything, what we're seeing is the bigger the personality, the more pool they have with audiences and it doesn't like – I think that was part of it. I was like, all right, what's the future of Australia's media looking like?

And I have so much hope in what you and Jan are doing. But then at the same time, I look and I go, Carl started a YouTube. Yeah, I know. No, but you know what? It's so hard when so many people are looking at us smaller players and there is a lot of hope. It's why people are listening. It's why they're coming to our events. But I'll just, like, I'll be honest with you, Sarah, and with your listeners, this morning I couldn't get out of bed. I was just like, this is too overwhelming. The fascists and the fuckwits are winning. Oh, I don't know.

They're having a big week. They're having a big week. I'm like, how do we counter this? How do you, it's just so hard. I was like, no, no, no, but people are hoping we can do something. And I'm like, get up, Antoinette. You know, I'm like, get up. Get up and get on the podcast. Like, I'm like, you've got to get up. You know, I think there's reason to feel overwhelmed. There's reason to feel concerned. And, you know, there are fewer and fewer powerful people with growing resources having too much control over our democracy.

And that is... That's terrifying. When you have mornings like that where you're like, this is tough today, is there a particular story or part of the book that you've written that you go back to? Yeah. Oh, yes, a couple. So one is Wendy McCarthy. She is in her 80s. She is the best. She has long been a women's rights advocate. She helped decriminalise abortion in New South Wales in the 70s. She was also actually former deputy chair of the ABC, I think, in the 80s.

And she's been a big sort of supporter of mine. And even though she was part of a group of women who helped decriminalise abortion, and they did one of the most baller things at the time, they all took out together a full-page advertisement in the local, not the local paper, in the daily newspaper, announcing that they'd all had abortions and taunting the police to come and arrest them. Because they were like, well, if they come and arrest us, we've got the cameras ready. Yeah. So that was part of their campaign to be like, it's ludicrous that we can't do what we're... It's unsafe because women will find ways to have abortions.

And then when I go to interview her for this book, she's just come back from eye surgery and she's like, oh, well, they've wound back rights to abortion. And we saw just on the weekend an anti-abortion rally, but in parts of regional Australia and the parts that she's from, doctors can conscientiously object to giving an abortion on religious or whatever grounds. And so she's like, there are women who have to travel hundreds and hundreds of kilometres to find a doctor.

So she's pointing out that even in her 80s... Yeah, I was going to say she's only like 85 or something, right? Yeah, about 85. She's still, she's like, my work hasn't stopped. Yeah. And so for me, it was a reminder that... Changes can be won. They can be wound back or threatened in some ways and that there has to be eternal vigilance and that we can't be complacent. And so that's one woman I go to. The other is probably Marwa Johnson. She's a First Nations woman. And she, in her early 20s, led a campaign against a billionaire coal miner to stop a coal mine in her community because of the impact it was going to have, not only on the environment, but to her tribe's connection to land and country and their ancestry.

And it was the first time the court upheld that it was an attack on the human rights of Indigenous people, not just an environmental right, but an actual human rights. They invoked the Human Rights Act in Queensland to stop this coal mine. But after that win, she was like, what's next? When I interviewed her in the book, we were both feeling exhausted and we're both feeling overwhelmed. And I said to her, look, I was hoping to speak to you because I'm tired. And I was hoping to get a bit of, you know,

She's like, but my ancestors, First Nations women have never stopped fighting, even in the most dire of circumstances with the most dire indicators. First Nations women have never stopped resisting. And even if I'm tired, I have to go on because they go on. And I was like, well, if you go on, I go on. So they're two women that I often think about. Oh, it's a really incredible book and I have loved reading it. And for anyone listening, please go read it. I'm just so thankful that you came on the podcast today.

Thank you. Thank you for carving out the space, for asking the questions, for sharing my existential threat. I think it's important to be honest when you feel weary or when you feel overwhelmed, when you feel... that the forces of evil are just so overwhelming. And to rest and to recalibrate. I was actually out on a book tour and a lady came up to me and I don't know her. She's like, I'm speaking to you as a woman, as a mother. You are tired. Get some rest.

She's like, I can see you. You're tired. You're crying. You're going to burn out. Just rest. Just rest. There's so much talk around brave women and stoic women and always being on women. And it's actually just really nice to be open and talk about the fact that, yeah, it's fucking exhausting sometimes. It's exhausting and sometimes I have moments where I'm like, it's just too hard. And it doesn't make you any less brave or stoic or any of the other things. But I think there's this shield that we put up because you don't want to show any weakness.

And that kind of gives people opportunity to call you weak. You'll never give them that. But it's missing a lot of the nuance to what it's actually like to go through these things. And I think the reality is that we have to find comforting and determine our own narratives or our own array of emotions is if you cry... you will be called a drama queen or a bit dramatic, was the Sky News segment did. I walked back into the ABC and they were like, oh, she was a bit dramatic because I cried. If you don't cry or if you're too tough or whatever, you're a bitch.

It's impossible. It's impossible. So I think you just, you have to be comfortable with not tone policing yourself because you were never going to satisfy the detractors. They will always find an emotion that they find unsettling. And it's not the emotion. It's the fact that you're effective or that you have a voice, that power doesn't like to be challenged, that they would much rather you be gratitude or shut the hell up. Like show gratitude and be grateful or shut the hell up. They're your options. Frankly, if you don't have any enemies, I don't think you're doing enough. Right. Especially if you're in the media or you're in the public sphere.

And in this field, if everybody likes you, then I think there's a problem. You're probably like a plant or something. You're just there and some people glance over you and you're not offensive, but you're not particularly noteworthy. And I don't want to be that person. But also no women of note in Australian history have been that person. No. And... So today's a day of feeling a bit weary. Tomorrow I hope will be better, but it's okay. It's okay. All those formations are okay. Thank you so much. Is there anything else? I mean, obviously go listen to used to be journos.

Yeah. Follow App Media. Sure. Read the book. Substack. Read the book. Do it all. We're really relying. People are relying on us, but we guys are like, we're relying on you. We're relying on the audience to reinforce to us and to others that, that we're not going to be okay with this. We want different perspectives. We want a more robust and brave democracy. Thank you for coming on. Thank you. Thanks so much.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Should I Quit My Job?

    Nov 18, 202651 minAudio

    There’s a lot no one tells you when you start working. Luckily, this week Sarah is joined by someone who has made all the mistakes so you don’t have to: Sophie Hirst (aka Soph Workbaby). With a career spanning Nylon,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. James Bond, Chinese Spy & Daddy Issues

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    We are coming to you with some breaking news: Robert Pattinson has been named as the next James Bond, and Sarah has thoughts. Is he the reinvention 007 needs, or a safe studio pick? Then, Justine unpacks how one of the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Blame It on Saturn Return

    Nov 11, 202637 minAudio

    If you're in your late twenties and feel like your entire life is being turned upside down, you might just be in your Saturn Return. Breakups, career changes, friendship shifts and existential crises. According to...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Democrats Win, Russell Brand Jailed & Taylor and Karlie Are Back?

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Well well well. It’s a new week and a whole new world that we’ve woken up to. First up, Hannah explains what happened in the U.S. mid-terms. The Democrats won BIG and we want to know why. What does this mean for the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Feminine Urge to Become a Witch

    Nov 4, 202639 minAudio

    From WitchTok and tarot cards to manifestation and etsy witches - it seems women are embracing their witchy side more than ever. But whats the darker history of witches? For centuries, women accused of witchcraft were...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode