Sarah kicks us off with a breakdown of the Lindsay Clancy trial unfolding in the US right now - who she is, what happened, the evidence we’ve heard in court and the reality of trial by TikTok. Hannah then talks through the latest developments in the Sydney Swans scandal, with multiple players now stood down from the club, plus the powerful show of support for the Swans women’s team over the weekend. Plus, the girls unpack the VMA nominations (Olivia Rodrigo snubbed?!), the latest changes to the NDIS, and finally… what the hell is going on with KATSEYE? Big Small Talk Instagram Sarah-Jane's Instagram Hannah's Instagram
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
A listener production. Hi, I'm Hannah. And I'm Sarah. And this is Big Small Talk. This is the podcast where we try and cover the entirety of the news cycle, from the serious to the frivolous, all in one place. Because loving pop culture doesn't mean you don't understand politics. Absolutely. And today we're going to be talking about the Lindsay Clancy trial, the Sydney Swans, Cat's Eye, the NDIS and the VMAs.
But before we begin today's episode, we would like to start by acknowledging the traditional owners of the land on which we're recording today, the Gadigal people, and pay our respect to elders past and present. But before we get into the actual news, Hannah, what is your personal headline for this week? Oh, look, actually nothing on last weekend, really. Bit of a sick boyfriend at home, so you know what happens when that happens. They are loud about their sickness. But this weekend we are going to my partner's older sister's wedding.
And yeah, it's going to be really exciting. So I'll have much more. I'll openly review the menu, the proceedings. Oh, good. Yeah, come back in gossip about it. Yeah, yeah. What I thought went right. No, it's going to be awesome. I'm really excited. And it's so funny. Like I get like MT's part of the groomsmen. I get to get ready with his mum and dad on the morning, which is hilarious. So it's going to be the three of us hanging out. It's going to be really nice. I really want to go to more weddings. None of my friends are even close to getting married. The only weddings I've gone to a family. Yes. I was going to say to you, actually, because I would seek your advice on all clothing help, all choices.
I said this to you this morning. I was like, come over. Come over. You can try stuff on. I actually have a story for you that I haven't told you is going to be part of my personal headline, but it's very funny now. We never keep things. No, we never keep things secret. I've saved it for the microphone. You're going to love this. So Puntus Politics, Conrad, friend of the pod. Oh, yes. Everyone loves. Yes, yes, yes. One of our best performing small talk episodes of the year. The man is a performer. He's a born performer. Anyway, last week on like Thursday afternoon, he just texted me that he's in Sydney. And I was like, I'll come to the office. Anyway, he comes over. We go and get some food. And he goes, you've got to work on your wardrobe for, you know, the campaign.
And he goes, you know who? Diva. And he's telling me that I've got to stop being so corporate. Like, he's like, you've got to chill out. You've got to wear T-shirts. And I'm like, I'm a woman. There's a different standard, right? You remember Julia Gillard punter. Anyway, you know what he says to me? Get Sarah to help you. Yes! Anyway, not only that, did he tell me that last Thursday. He then texts me again yesterday and goes, have you got Sarah to help you yet? One, how bitchy? I don't even know the brands that Sarah knows. It's so funny because our styles are different and I don't want to steal your clout, but I'm also like, imagine if you were trying to show me how to fix my wardrobe.
Also, how do I be myself in this environment? Why is this like... A political rom-com. Also, why is Punter... In the makeover scene of a political rom-com. Yeah, or in The Devil Wears Prada montage, but for a political film. And Punter's politics. Also, why the fuck do I have Punter being like, Oi, Hannah, I think you've got to fix some shit here. The guy that famously wore a t-shirt. To the Senate Inquiry. But that's why he thinks he's qualified. He's like, I'll tell you, I can give you some help here. You know, I actually bought a t-shirt the other day that I think could be funny for you to wear. It says, gentle until provoked.
But it's kind of sexy. It's like a little baby tee. Gentle until provoked is iconic. Anyway, sorry. What's your personal hand of the week besides that T-shirt? Well, it's about time someone was serious on this podcast. I wanted to talk about the big talk that's coming out tomorrow, which is a two-parter on Pauline Hanson. Our roles in this podcast are very clear. And you didn't even show for the record, kidding. That's actually funny. I didn't show for the record last week, Thursday. Sarah goes, can you do a big talk double header tomorrow?
Yeah, I thought we had an extra week of this month, but we didn't. And that's where I'm at mentally. The same. And I think I thought the same thing. So I thought we had an extra week. This is the sort of tight ship we run. Very tight ship. And big, small talk. So then we were like, oh my God, no, we have to record this actually on Friday. And thank God for producer Justine. Producer Justine, say hi. Hello, everybody. Producer Justine is qualified or if not far more qualified than me to talk about Pauline Hanson's appearance on Dancing with the Stars. Oh, producer Justine did an incredible job. I'm actually so excited for everyone to listen to this.
Justine came in with a Kindle. Oh, Justine, a born performer. With highlighted notes. And I said, you're nerd enough for this. You'll be fine. Justine, a born journalist and also a born performer in situations like these. Absolutely thrilling. I can't wait to listen to it. I'm going to be listening. I'm going to be a listener and join you both. But also, wow. So much I didn't know. Like, I did know when I was reading, but like... Holy shit. Oh, the way that Pauline Hanson actually was elected the first time is one of the most fascinating political stories in Australia's history, I think.
This is going to be a listen. And I say that as someone who's going to listen, even though I know a lot of this, I'm excited to find out some fun facts and bring it back to you and report my review. Hannah, in the comment sections on Spotify. I am going to comment. I often comment on Spotify from my own profile. You will see this. Don't look at my playlists. Should we get into the news? Let's get into the news. A breakdown on the Lindsay Clancy trial unfolding in the US, who she is, what has happened and the reality of trial by TikTok. This is a truly shocking trial that's in the US.
It has gripped social media globally. And this is the case of Lindsay Clancy in Massachusetts. We started talking about this last week and I was like, have you seen this? It's now my entire feed. Yes, and I actually have algorithmically escaped this. I came across it because we received a few pitches for pieces on Cheek and we only wanted to take one from a clinical and forensic psychologist or someone in the legal space. Like our view was like we really want to be careful about how we cover this today, but also that we don't want to engage in this trial by TikTok and we want to be listening to experts and actually speaking to the evidence and what we know and the nuances here too.
I'm so glad that we were able to take the time to actually look at – the facts, the reports, and try and discern from misinformation. Also, what is just the valid conversation in this? And I think there's a few different things to talk about. But if you are not on TikTok or not online and you haven't seen this, Lindsay was a former labor and delivery nurse, and she is the center of a criminal trial for the murder of her three children. She's also filed a civil action against eight different healthcare providers for failing to diagnose her with bipolar and postpartum depression.
Instead of being properly diagnosed, Lindsay was given a grocery list of medications that made her worse and eventually led to her having a devastating psychotic break. And in the midst of psychosis, Lindsay strangled her three children. They were all younger than five years old. It was in the basement of her home. She then also attempted to take her own life, including throwing herself out of a window, resulting in a permanent paralysis from the waist down. And this happened about three years ago now. But the trial has been ongoing. As Lindsay's legal team has stated, the quote is, Lindsay now faces a lifetime of physical disability, psychological trauma, and the unbearable grief of waking up every day knowing she killed her children, all of which could have been prevented had the defendant, in her civil case, provided competent medical care.
Mm-hmm. As for her criminal trial, essentially Lindsay's lawyers are arguing that she should not be criminally liable for this as postpartum psychosis is an uncommon, misunderstood condition that has an incredible amount of stigma attached to it and that the medical system has failed her because she'd been crying out for help for months. Yeah, so that's what her lawyers are saying. And obviously there's... a raft of kind of armchair experts that have emerged throughout this trial by social media. This is kind of where we're going to have challenges when we're discussing this as well. So stay with us.
And we know that no matter how we speak about this, people are probably going to be unhappy with it because of the way this has unfolded. I think it's important to start with that Lindsay herself has acknowledged that she was the one to kill her children, as well as her lawyer, Kevin Reddington, in the criminal trial, which is the trial that is being live streamed online. But while she doesn't dispute that she killed her children, she is pleading not guilty on the grounds of insanity. Yeah. And just to be so clear, the reason that's a not guilty claim is because in criminal law to, you know, prove something like murder, you need to have the mens rea and actus rea.
So the act and the mental state. So that would be arguing then that on the grounds of insanity, there's not capacity for the mental state to have amounted to a murder conviction, if that makes sense as well. Yeah. And what's so fascinating about this trial, though, is that a lot of people on TikTok are convinced that not only did the medical system fail Lindsay, but also now that she is entirely innocent and that it was actually her husband, Patrick Clancy, who committed the murders. There have been thousands and thousands of TikToks, as we said, largely self-appointed crime experts who have turned their attention to blaming Patrick for being a, you know, and this is like taking from what TikTok is saying, a neglectful husband who should have done more like to help his clearly struggling wife.
Yeah. In his own testimony, Patrick was not always present at home. And that was even when Lindsay was in a particularly bad way and that he knew about her suicidal ideation and instead, you know, would go for brunch or took his daughter on a skiing trip and that he didn't give a lot of space. And again, this is what's coming out in these hearings to concerns about her being bipolar. Yeah. Lindsay also specifically told him that she was worried that she would hurt the kids. So she did sort of vocalize that. But the belief that he is a calculated criminal who committed the murders is...
I think it's quite a far-fetched idea, but it is a deeply popular online theory. And it's somehow, it's not the whole narrative online. I think there's definitely two sides and it really depends what your algorithm is feeding you. But it surprised me how confident everyone is in this. I think there's this obsession now online, but also in tabloids. There's been so much tabloid coverage of like reporting on his new life and his new his new wife and his new life in New York City and like people raising eyebrows about the fact that he's moved on.
Can I just say like the fact that we have to speak about this through the lens of like tabloid media combined with algorithmic conspiracy because I think I understand having a healthy level of skepticism and the nature of a lot of true crime is always being kind of open to like a conspiratorial kind of thought process. Mm-hmm. But I think it's really important to like continue to reiterate the facts here and to also say that the nature of what our algorithms have done to us is make us so kind of siloed. Yeah. And into this idea of like we are just fueled by views that we already agree with or the extremes of the other end.
And it often just means that we aren't even open to hearing alternate viewpoints that might still be possible. I think this story, I'll get to it in a bit. I'm just going to kind of run through what is the sentiment right now. But then I think I want to unpack a little bit more psychology of how we, the psychology of how we got here as well. I mean, what I'm seeing a lot is people assessing like the time of his emails, how long it took him to call 911. And if it makes sense that Lindsay confessed to him that she did it when she had like damaged her throat, why her body temperature was so low. And the fact that, you know, in psychosis, she doesn't fully remember what happened either.
Oh, God, one of the biggest theories is like these Bratz dolls that people are recreating the crime scene just to be able to prove where the blood could or couldn't be. And like it is quite compelling to watch. I'm not like taking away from that. It's gripping content. But to be clear, he is not on trial. He was cleared immediately. And if we zoom out even more, he has also endured the brutal death of his three children. Yeah. Something I thought of the other day was like, there's a lot of experts involved in this that would have been there on the scene.
This has been three years on. It's also showing not a lot of faith in people doing their job properly. But I think that also speaks to the fact that, you know, a lot of people have a major, this is more to the distrust that people have in our legal systems and in our I don't know, systems at large, medical, legal. The infrastructure that, you know, in many ways is there to supposedly support our safety. Yeah. He's also filed a wrongful death suit against two physicians and two facilities involved in his former wife's care, but there is no real concrete evidence that's coming up in these trials that suspect him or can see him as guilty at this stage.
In saying that, I think this has struck a nerve because we are seeing... a woman who was scared and who was asking for help and she should have received more. And I think that's why we're seeing two different conversations here. The first one being, you know, the impact of trial by TikTok again. I think although it's a really important global conversation right now, it is so hard to keep up with what's real and what's not. Like the misinformation is rife. I've seen AI enhanced security footage. I've seen extensive analysis of non-existent Instagram posts. But I also do understand why conspiracies and misinformation continue to travel so far.
Like there is, as I was saying, a deep mistrust in our systems. And I also think beyond that, I wonder if it's partly because it is so difficult, I think, to believe that Lindsay, who is otherwise, you know, from reports, a good mom, a good person could do this at all. Like I think for everyone's sake, we want an alternative. outcome. But I also think that speaks to our lack of understanding of complex mental health conditions. Exactly. Because, you know, we're getting better at talking about things like depression and anxiety, but then there are, you know, the more sort of sophisticated illnesses that still have like deep stereotypes and issues attached.
So things like bipolar and postpartum psychosis in this particular case, you know, we're still not societally in a position to be openly discussing how they limit our capacity, our decision-making, our judgment. And, you know, And instead we go, oh, this makes her evil or bad. But actually, we're not culturally able to have the unpacked conversation because of the stigma. And that's a huge issue here. Yeah. And I think that is the second conversation here now. It's like women are now resonating with this story and they want to publicly support Lindsay because she has, in a way, become another devastating example of who is taken seriously, who is listened to and who isn't.
She asked for help months prior to this. She asked her mum to come stay with her. She told her husband what was going on. She went to numerous medical professionals. She was not diagnosed with bipolar when she should have been, especially knowing the link between bipolar and postpartum psychosis and how certain medications can dramatically worsen it. She checked herself into a psychiatric ward for a week. And when she left, she was practically left alone with the kids again. I read that in the New Yorker. Like it just... I think your heart breaks because you're like, wow, she was scared. And so what we've seen now is hundreds and hundreds of women wearing pink outside the courthouse to support her and raise awareness for postpartum depression and medical misogyny.
You know, I was reading different articles of like what the women were saying out front of the courthouse. Towards the end of their rally, they formed a circle. They prayed. They held their arms up. They formed hearts with their hand. They held flags from different countries to say that this conversation has gone global. I mean, I just think that I understand the conspiracy theorists and the interest on this case online. But I really think when talking about this, we have to be so careful not to detract now from the conversation about postpartum depression and psychosis being taken seriously, because it is an opportunity to talk about that.
Yeah. And it's a complex discussion, but I think it's one that demands to be had. And a lot of this sort of online content and AI and difficulty to limit our ability to openly actually advocate on the issue. Yeah. Yeah. Multiple Sydney Swans players have been stood down amid sexual assault allegations. Okay, so we're going to be really careful with this segment as well. When we started talking about this last Tuesday, we didn't want to kind of go into the subject too deeply because we knew how much information would evolve and emerge. It only just... It had only just broken last week.
We know this investigation involves several players from the Swans and that the team was staying in Melbourne that night after their game against Essendon. Now, as of Tuesday morning when we're recording this episode, we have no arrests that have been made, no charges have been laid. We are going to speak to the reporting from a number of media outlets, including the ABC, the SMH, the Herald Sun and the Guardian, who have been providing more details. But we're getting a bit careful into what we're willing to say here because a lot of these claims remain unverified as well. Yeah. Yeah. What we understand as of Tuesday morning is that some Sydney Swans players and their friends hired several adult entertainers to come to the Pullman Hotel.
One of the women alleges that she was sexually assaulted after being hired by the Sydney Swans players to perform lap dances. She is alleging that there were nine men in the hotel room. She also said that she didn't recognize them and that she provided them with a discount because they claimed they were carpenters and could not afford to pay the full rate. Ugh. Yes. Yes. She hasn't gone into detail about the incident, but the woman did tell the Herald Sun that the ordeal had left her fearing for her safety. The ABC also reported that there were drugs present in the room, but we are not going to speculate as to what those drugs were because we have no confirmation publicly from authorities on that matter.
The Age has also reported that there is a potential recording, again, a potential recording, that has been passed on to police via the AFL after a person contacted the club claiming to have information that could be relevant to this ongoing investigation. What we do know is there have been five players who have been stood down by the Sydney Swans. So Isaac Heaney, Chad Warner, Nick Blakey, Riley Bice, James Jordan. Yeah. They've been stood down for breaching the club's behavioural standards. So rules like drinking and staying out late after a match in Melbourne. So again, the reasoning behind this is not directly related to the investigation.
We should be clear on that too. Now, on Saturday, Victoria Police did provide a statement. They said the investigation is active and ongoing. The Swans have also released a statement saying that no member of staff is involved in the investigation. This includes being in the hotel room central to the police investigation. We've also come to know that the three women involved have engaged lawyers and that their lawyers are currently examining civil legal action options because the police investigation, just to be clear, is a criminal investigation. But separately, they are sort of considering their civil action options.
I actually think it's really important to go through this, though, because I feel like even in understanding this and being able to talk about it on a big small talk, I have missed so much of this information instead seeing awful different language used, different claims spread throughout the media. So I think it's also important that this is the core information that we have. We also publicly know that sponsors have suspended their partnerships with individual Swans players. So Colgate, Volkswagen, Telstra, the Australian Red Cross Lifeblood pulled out of a match day activation with the Swans during the doubleheader last weekend, which was both the men's and women's teams playing.
Isaac Keeney, we know, has a series of children's books called the Little Isaac Footy Fever Series. Glee Books, Readings, Big W have all removed them from bookstores around the country. Can I also say on Isaac Keeney... I know there's a lot of talk about the fact that he's engaged. And I find it pretty annoying how many people are chasing after and speculating how his girlfriend or fiance or whatever might feel and like ring watching her right now. That is awesome. awful. It is awful. It is awful. She's probably like, I've seen pictures that have floated across my algorithm.
I've seen so many headlines. And I think that it's interesting because obviously we want to protect the anonymity of the alleged victim survivors at the centre of this kind of allegation. But also it immediately we go to every woman surrounding, you know, and it's this just constant pursuit of like the women around them and how we can kind of find gossip and tabloid fodder to spread. And actually that they shouldn't be part of this discussion at all. They are private individuals. She wasn't there. Yeah. What I do want to say, though, actually, is getting back to the doublehead on the weekend, that there is actually a story of hope in the midst of all this.
And that's the AFLW team for the Swans. So we saw record turnout to support the women's team, which played, I think, 12.30pm on Sunday. This was a historic doubleheader game at the SCG. It was the first time, I believe, that the Sydney men's and women's team were both going to be playing. And what ended up happening was so many people turned out to see the women in support, given the week of media and attention and scrutiny. And what it meant was that 16 and more than 16 and a half thousand people came to watch the women's game.
I believe their previous record for an AFLW game in Sydney was around 7,000 or 8,000. So that's a doubling of that number. And we also saw a lot of Swans fans leave after the women's game in protest, right? Which is also interesting because I think there is a conversation to be had around, you know, I think the Swans statements that have, you know, followed in the last, like the tail end of last week, spoke to community, spoke to understanding, spoke to trying to rebuild trust. I mean, I was worried after they called it an incident this time last week.
After the Swans CEO sort of spoke about it being like a shock and disappointment that the players found themselves in that situation, I was deeply disappointed in that. But I also clearly saw a concerted effort to improve how the language from I saw the CEO of the AFL, Andrew Dillon, was a lot better when he released a statement. I thought the follow up from the Sydney Swans CEO was a lot better later in the week. And I think there's also a story to be told here about how we support the remaining team members and how we support the Swans as a club. But I do think action like that, the way people are protesting, is so tangible for all of these stakeholders within the business that is the AFL and the Swans.
Yeah. Of course they have to come out and take this seriously. If we kind of exercise, we're not putting up with that. Yeah, and I think that, you know, I don't want it to be that like sponsorship threats are the reason they, you know, that the hate viewers improved or standards are improved. But I think that this is a conversation to be had that this will impact your viability. And I think that's a strong message to the entire sporting culture as well. The nominations for my favourite award show, the VMAs, are out and I am kind of outraged.
Yes. I'm learning so much. Good. Yes. About time. It's only my fourth on the podcast, VMAs or something. You do love the VMAs. I do. You are putting me down. Okay. Remember when we watched it together? I remember the days. We've watched so many things together. The VMAs, the Grammys, the US election. So much. But the VMAs are fun because I think they're just, they're a little bit more chaotic, a bit more fun to watch, better outfits, better performances, more celebrity feuds.
Yeah. I mean, that's just in my personal opinion. But it's just a lot less polished. But it's still a huge achievement. And so it still gets the same like star power as any other award show. But let's take a little look at who got the honour for nomination this year. One of the biggest twists was for the first time since 1998, Madonna is actually leading the nominations. What? 11 nominations. He's learning so much. Including Artist and Song of the Year. Taylor Swift has the second most nominations with nine.
And then Ariana Grande and Sabrina Carpenter tie third with seven nominations each. But I can't help but fixate on the snubs here. Look, I don't know for sure. I think the VMAs you'll come to find in this story are a little vague on some of the information that they probably should give. I suppose... the eligibility period is a little unclear still. I know that last year's was from June 20th, 2024, to June 18th, 2025. So I assume this year's period was the same, but like, you know, the next year.
Best Pop, I think, is an extremely tight race. It always is. But I was surprised that Zara Larsson didn't make the cut. To be fair, her collaboration with Pink Panther, Stateside, I do love that song, has been recognized in other categories. But I thought Midnight Sun was a, you know, as a pop album, deserved more noise. BTS didn't make Artist of the Year. And look, I am new to K-pop, but I saw a really good Cosmo article talking about this and pointing out how kind of wild it is that they weren't nominated for Best Artists because they've just made this huge comeback.
They had all seven members had to go on hiatus to complete their South Korean military training service. Oh, yeah. I was Yeah. And so then they came back with this new album and their 37 million Spotify listeners were right there with them. And it is now the most streamed K-pop album in one day and the biggest debut album of 2026. So sure, they did get a song of the year nod and best K-pop, but still like an album that big, not getting a nomination, I thought was... As an artist, I thought that was interesting.
But I think that's actually a really interesting conversation broadly about how, and again, I don't want to draw too many assertions here, but there's actually been a consistent criticism of many award shows, especially in the music, in music and film especially, when films, when art, when soundtracks are not in English, often they are deterred to categories that are specific to region. rather than actually being able to sit. So, like, for example, like Bad Bunny winning, you know, Album of the Year, I think it was, that was the first time, like, you know. Thank you.
Yes. Thank you. Hey, hey, coming in. Coming in. Hey, I'm listening. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But... But, you know, it was actually something we talked about in the cheek office was like Varsha made the point that, you know, foreign albums that are not in English are often relegated based on category without actually being sought or considered for primary categories of awards. I mean, look, it made me sort of ponder like what goes into these nominations. And I think there is obviously a. a lot of lobbying involved for these to be considered in these categories and to get the nomination in the first place. And I think BTS is interesting because they're not necessarily trying to appease the industry.
They actually called out the Recording Academy and pulled themselves out of Grammy nomination for 2027. Olivia Rodrigo was also snubbed. Now, she received two nominations for Best Pop for Drop Dead and Best Alternative for The Cure. But I am confused why shooting at Literal Versailles did not get her a Video of the Year nomination, or like the Arts and Crafts of the Hospital set design for the song The Cure. I'm also confused why it was an album of the year or artist of the year.
It's like she was locked out of all the major categories. She shot that at Versailles. It's amazing. Have you not seen it? No. Yeah. I haven't watched a music video in years. I watched that Sabrina Carpenter. And yet the VMAs are my favorite. I love it. The Video Music Awards. I'm familiar. But, okay, the reason I think this is kind of shocking is because you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love, is one of the most critically acclaimed albums of this year. Like, across the board got rave reviews, more so than Madonna, Ariana, Sabrina, Bruno, Morgan Wallen.
She outperformed all of them critically and commercially. And that's not any hate to the others. It's just saying, like, who's... What is the metrics for this then? Great question. Some speculate that MTV is giving her the, like, we'll see you next year treatment. Like, maybe it is, like, it was too close to the cutoff or something like that. But if it's not the cutoff, like... I know, but we just don't know. No. That's what I was saying before. It's a bit vague on what the eligibility period was for this year. But also... Sorry to jump in. But also, big Olivia Rodrigo fan here declaring my bias...
the do you want to put a disclaimer at the top of the segment yeah just jump in at the top what um no but also her other songs were nominated for other categories from this album yeah but they were singles so i wonder if the singles came out a little bit earlier sorry there's no formal criteria that we found anywhere no in our investigations let me get into it a little bit sorry sorry sorry Because ultimately, history shows that fan-voted VMA metrics don't always align with critical success.
So the snub is, I would say, still highly unlikely to impact her trajectory when the Grammys come around. But again, I was like, how the fuck are the VMA nominations chosen? Like, it's actually kind of hard to know. MTV really sells that the VMAs are in the hands of the public and it's a public vote. But ultimately, even though the public chooses who wins the category, they are only picking out of a short list of nominations that have been selected by MTV as their favorites. The only thing I could really find on this, and if people know more, please let me know, but I found Bustle did an investigation into this back in 2015.
So a while ago. The ancient text. We were in school. I was in year 11. And they found that the voting rules for the winner were ultimately at the decision of the sponsor. So technically, I believe the sponsor could decide who the winner was regardless of the votes. And we just kind of wouldn't know because, I mean, to be fair, that should only happen, it says, if the results are interfered with or tampered with or there is a reason for them to have to step in and just decide a winner. But the language is vague enough, right? So like, call me a cynic.
But I do think a lot of this is just like who's in favor of the industry for whatever reason. Sounds like a veto power at the United Nations. I'm going to get a defamation case for the PMAs. We should check this. Bustle said, bustle said. But like, again, it was just vague. It's interesting to read the voting requirements because it's vague. Then the big category, which is usually my favourite category every year, is best new artist, right? Tight race. Very competitive category. Serious range this year.
We had Bella Kay, who I hadn't actually heard much about. Can I say that's funny? Yeah. Because you know Bella Kay. No, no, no. Of course not. Come on. Let's be serious. Sorry. Have you been on this podcast before? Is it your first day on Earth? You know, someone actually wrote... Sometimes you surprise me, though. Someone actually wrote into us recently and said they listened to the pod for the first time and was surprised by how funny it was. No, we get that a lot. Guys, I know that we have to cut down clips that are kind of depressive. But the foundation of this podcast is humour.
Is humour. Anyway, please take it seriously. It's so funny for you to go in with like, this is my favourite category. It's a tight race this year. First one, haven't heard of it. Well, no, I'm saying historically. Yeah, of course. So please go on. Okay. Next one is Cortis, which is a K-pop band. Then we have Magnus Ferrell, Will Ferrell's son. Have you heard about Magnus Ferrell? I have. So Magnus Ferrell released a song, I think it was in April, and it went viral because his dad, Will Ferrell, played a snippet of it on Michelle Obama's podcast.
Genius. I must say, though, he's good about the whole Nepo Baby thing. Oh, I saw the clip. I'm going to play a little bit. There's some privilege I do have to acknowledge. Like, you know, some people don't get the opportunity to pursue a dream, and I do. That's the biggest thing, is just like recognizing it and showing the hard work that I've put on. When he plays your music, when he shows it to people, he is so proud, he's so excited. It means a lot. I think it's cool to see him as a dad, and for people to see him just as a dad, I don't think many people have seen that.
side of him. I've just been so lucky to grow up with him being so in my corner. I genuinely do love Will Ferrell. No, same. And also, I think he's green flags for me. Like, he's absolutely green flags in my mind. Because I think Will Ferrell doesn't try too hard to be like ally, like some men who I question. But back to it. But he is a... Can I just say, I love that when... a Nepo baby is just like up front and is like, there's privileges, there's advantage. I want to acknowledge that. We're like, you're trained. And I'm actually like, maybe he's just a really good person. Like maybe he's just like... The joke is, is that there are so many Nepo babies in Hollywood now and a lot of them for a long time there were refusing to acknowledge that maybe...
The space and time and opportunity that they had to pursue these dreams in the contacts might have played a hand. Correct. But his response is perfect. But I also think that might speak to having a good upbringing and just being a solid person. Like, I hope that's the outcome. I'll play a little snippet of his song. He's like if Will Ferrell was sexy. Oh, Will. But I also think that that's more my vibe than Cat's Eye.
I mean, see them live though. See them live first. I mean, I would think I'd change my personality the day after. Malcolm Todd also, who's actually Audrey Herbert's brother. You would have heard Audrey. Sue me, I want to be Will. Sue me. I didn't know we were going to be doing that. You don't know that song? Maybe. Come on. It was everywhere. Sorry. She's Gracie Abrams' best friend. Sorry that just from your five seconds little... Say you, I want to be one. Miles Smith.
Stargazing was a viral song. Do Love His Voice. Sienna Spiro. My girl. Oh, my God. I think she should win this category. I have been rinsing her song, Great Expectations. Rinsing. Rinsing it. Hold on. Rinse and repeat. I'm having too much fun with this segment now. Hold on. This is her singing live. Just to have you in the way I want. Oh, I sing just to know I'm alive. And I cried all the tears I could cry.
If happiness is just an illusion, you are the best I ever had. Wow. Isn't that amazing? Wow, that's so... Wow. She's got a very Amy Winehouse look about her as well. And that is even better. We also have Stella Lefty, who had the viral song Boston. On a train back to Boston and we're jumping the gun and I'm telling you baby. Idiot. Finally. Did you know, though, that her dad is a billionaire? Businessman Eric Leftoski?
Best known as the co-founder of Groupon and the founder and CEO of a health tech company, Tempest AI. Oh, I do know that. So, you know... What a lineup. Yeah. Then, of course, the bigger water of the night is the best music video. We have Hate That I Made You Love Me by Aaron Agrande, Bruno Mars, I Just Might, Generation Storm, Madonna Confessions 2, the film, Sabrina Carpenter Tears, and Taylor Swift, Fate of Othelia. Who do you think? Yeah.
I reckon Ariana's going to get it. Really? I think it's... Sabrina Carpenter Tears was a good music video, though. I agree with that. See, I have seen a music video in the last three years. It's exciting. So you're a liar. Yeah, that's court. No one can make a joke these days. No one wants to have a laugh on their news podcast these days. One was crazy. Labour has teamed up with the coalition to pass controversial national disability insurance scheme changes and people are deeply distressed.
I want to start at the top of this segment by saying this is an Australian political segment and I want to declare that I am intending to run as an independent candidate. What? You're intending to what? This is how you tell me. What? People get really tired of this. Just to finalise that, I'm intending to write as an independent candidate in the seat of Graindler at the next federal election, which is the Prime Minister's current seat. Thank you for that, Sarah, though, because it's going to get really old really fast, but I'm going to do it every single time.
I'll come up with lots of different reactions. Okay. So now we've got our bias out of the way. You know what the thing is? It's one of those hard things where I'm constantly asked, like, oh, you know, how are you going to navigate? I'm like, well, I was telling the truth before. Like, I'm just telling my opinion exactly as I would have anyway. But... What we know so far that's happened over the last week is that Labor and the coalition teamed up to pass a controversial bill that will make significant cuts to the NDIS. And there's obviously so much anger and concern from, you know, people in the Greens, the independents, and from so many members of the public that will be impacted by this.
Whether you're someone from the disabled community, you might be a family member, a support person, a carer, like there are so many people that will feel the impacts of this reform. Yeah, we're not covering the story because we just discovered it. Like this has been a huge conversation. A lot of people have been outraged. And I think part of the reason it's been quite difficult to navigate is because we've been seeing, you know, Senate discussions. We've been seeing Senate reports about it. We've been seeing a lot of changing information since the budget when this was kind of formally announced. It was hinted at before the budget. But the detail matters here.
And so much of that has been quite clouded. So we're going to get to kind of the grit of what we do know. Yeah. Just actually going back, I think for a lot of people in Australia who might not know about the NDIS, we need to go back to basics too. This is an opportunity to explain what it is. So the NDIS is a national government funded scheme that provides funding to registered eligible people with disability that they can use and access for supports and services. It's a really, it was really an ambitious social scheme. It was created by Julia Gillard's Labour government back in 2013.
And my understanding is it supports more than 770,000 Australians who experience a disability. So why is this bill happening? Like, what are the concerns with the NDIS? Yeah, so there's been in the last couple of years, like a big conversation being had around the cost of the NDIS. And, you know, originally the Productivity Commission in 2011 thought the NDIS would support around 410,000 people and cost around $13.5 billion annually. But in reality, it's costing the government more than $50 billion a year.
And I just want to say, like, when we're speaking about this, this is a really clinical assessment that we're providing these facts. But these are human lives, human experiences, and this is a social scheme that is designed to support people in Australia who require additional services. So there is concern that the scheme is too large, too expensive. But one of the major assessments here... is that the NDIS is plagued by fraud. So, for example, in July of this year, the ABC reported that 4,000 NDIS service providers had been profiting from incorrect billing practices.
So you've probably heard about like NDIS rorts has been like a massive headline conversation. Yeah. But a lot of people don't know enough about the NDIS to understand what that actually means. And we've actually gone and done an explainer on Cheek as well about this and how a lot of the wrought claims started from a false claim made in a 60 Minutes episode back in 2022. And that actually there was an inflated statistic given that claimed how many providers were acting in fraudulent ways. And actually the stat was much lower. So the ABC is reporting of 4,000 providers.
That's... That's still a very large number engaging in fraudulent or incorrect billing practices. But we need to look at the detail as well of what this actually means, how it plays out and how the cuts might be impacting vulnerable Australians, but not actually necessarily solving the issues as well. So what happened last week? So Labor was trying to get this bill passed in the Senate. So what they're aiming to do is cut the NDIS by removing 241,000 current participants from the scheme and stopping an expected additional 105,000 people from entering the scheme in that time as well.
So over the next four years. And they're aiming to save $37.8 billion by tightening the eligibility criteria to be on the NDIS and then requiring all participants to undergo independent functional assessments from 2028. It will also have individual budgets for social, civic and community participation. So supports for like attending social events, for voting assistant, public transit travel. communication coaching, really cutting the opportunity for so many people on the NDIS to engage in recreational, social, civic life outside of their home, which is a really significant and damaging change.
It also gives the NDIS minister, currently that's Mark Butler, the power to reduce a category of funding by up to 99% across all participants. But this hasn't been supported by the Greens or the Cross French, right? No, so it hasn't. There's been a lot of pushback. There was a Senate committee, which is just essentially a group of senators, which I referred to earlier, who reviewed the bill and handed down a report earlier this month. And what Senator David Pocock said in his report is that, you know, this is like a, which I completely agree with, is a vital safeguard against social isolation.
I also want to mention the amazing work of Green Senator Jordan Steele-John, who has been fighting and advocating for such significant amendments and to be constantly, like we interviewed him at Cheek after the budget and he is such an amazing advocate and communicator. I think that night where he basically said it's a really hard day to be the only physically disabled person in the Senate. And it's not just politicians, obviously, that have been raising the alarm.
There are so many organisations, not-for-profits. There are so many pig bodies as well that are advocating against these changes. Greg Jericho from the Australia Institute, their chief economist, said the cuts were deep and brutal, and it will simply force care needs of Australians onto the families of those whose coverage has been lost. Yeah. There were 63 amendments rushed through across both houses as part of the backroom deal to get the coalition and Labor to agree to team up on this. The coalition also secured amendments to create new criminal and civil penalties against people, anyone, offering or providing kickbacks using NDIS funding.
And, you know, there were some things that have been made better through those amendments. So, for example, there's a change that allows vulnerable participants with high support needs to apply for more funding if they are impacted by these ministerial expansions under Mark Butler. Yeah, OK. And this wasn't the only bill. We also saw, I just want to briefly mention, we've been talking a lot about gambling reform in the media. The NDIS has got a lot less media, which is, I think, one of the reasons that we've decided to kind of focus in on that bill. But gambling reforms passed last week as well that do not actually take on the public health lens and the 31 recommendations of the Murphy Inquiry, which was delivered more than three years ago.
Now, we can't get into the detail now, but that's just it's been a massive couple of weeks in sitting weeks in Parliament. And I think the NDIS bill is something we really wanted to speak about today. Girl group Cat's Eye's new EP, Wild, has debuted atop of Billboard 200 and is the biggest release of a girl group in the streaming era. It is by all measures a commercial success. Why am I so baffled by this? So interesting. They've also just released a new documentary called Wild Hearts. I mean, you saw them live. I did see them live.
Look, okay, don't get me wrong. I love Cat's Eye. I love the girls. I didn't know how much I felt strongly about them until I did see them live. I saw them live earlier this year at an event, quite an intimate event, I'll say as well. And my jaw hit the floor. Those girls can move. They are incredibly talented. I was mesmerized watching them on stage. But if you don't know who I'm talking about, I'm going to run it back and give a little bit of an insight into who these girls are, where they came from. So they're a group that formed in 2023 on a competitive reality series called the debut Dream Academy.
They beat out 100,000 contestants. I actually haven't seen this yet. I've seen parts of it. But essentially, the play here was to take the recipe of like K-pop success and make an international band and like make this TV show away. It's kind of like One Direction-esque meets K-pop. Industry giants backing this, right? Had the best choreographers, labels in both the US and Korea. They had the best stylists, the best songwriters.
They had every major brand wanting to work with these girls straight away. I don't know if you remember the milkshake ad that they did for Gap that went really viral. Yes, I do. Iconic, right? They got Grammy noms right off the bat. By all means... They are huge, but they haven't had the easiest ride since their formation. Like one of the girls, Manon, left indefinitely back in February and she said she needed to focus on her health. I think we did touch on this briefly at the time, but it was a bit of a weird. Actually, we spoke about it when Coachella was on because there was like this confusion about Cat's Eye got their big Coachella stage moment and Manon was in the crowd watching with Billie Eilish.
cool. I've told you this before. I'm not sure what my reaction was at the time. My natural instinct is to say, oh, I hope she's okay. That one was also interesting as well, because she also on the series, from what I've heard, got a lot of slack for being like lazy or whatever else. And they were quite hard on her, but she was the fan favorite then. Dare I say the fan favorite. So it was a big deal when she stepped back. And it also had a lot of people speculating
Then just this month, another member, I believe it was the group leader, Sophia, has also announced that she will be leaving due to vague health concerns. Not for good, on hiatus, which is technically what Madden is as well. So the original six girls are now down to a quartet. And then just 10 days after that announcement, another group member, Megan, has also been under the weather and also took a step back from promotional activities, even though this EP has just come out. leaving just a trio doing promotional activities.
I think she has since returned. But everyone's just kind of watching this going, what the fuck is going on over there? And, you know, part of this conversation is like, all of these girls have such impressive range. But their music is experimental, to say the least. Their lyrics are like memes. Maybe I should play a snippet. Please. Maybe... That's fine.
That'll do. The reason I'm playing this is because I think part of the conversation online now is, is like, is this genuine experimentation? Like, is, you know, they've even in interviews, I've heard them be like, you know, Lady Gaga went through, there's not comparing ourselves to Lady Gaga, but like, you know, when you're doing something different. And I'm like, is it that? Is it they're trying to find their sonic voice? Or is it a sort of gimmick to play to online audiences and marketing and the fact that they have this Gen Z audience? So they're trying to put like... La Boo Boo Dubai Chocolate, like everything in these lyrics that don't necessarily make sense.
And I also think it's because, you know, when we're talking about these girls were created by the industry in a way, their music videos are also sort of notorious for like overt product placement. You know, like a Bobo T mention matching the lyrics to Gnarly or like significantly more baffling, a TikTok and a slime promo placement on that song, which is called Hooty Fruity, which I played a little snippet of earlier. I tried Hooty Fruit Fruit Fruit. Wow. Right? It makes me feel like I'm 70 years old listening to that stuff.
Yeah. But like, I mean, they had this song Gnarly that was quite a big hit. I think it's their biggest hit so far. That was in this style. And it was the first time they sort of came out with that. And I do think it was intentionally ironic at the start. Like it kind of warms on you and it's kind of a bit ironic. But for everything out since to be in a similar vein, I think the reason, and I know some people are going to come for me for this because I'm sure there are huge Cat's Eye fans that like, you just don't get it. It's not for you. That's fine. Totally. And they're not. So fair. So fair. Great comeback. I've sat down. Great comeback.
I think these girls are capable of more. I think they're capable of more. They are so insanely talented. I think Adela, bona fide superstar. I can't wait to see what she does next. She was also part of this reality TV show, but she didn't make the cut. And so she's been able to go do her own thing. And she's having incredible success in her own individual career. And I'm wondering, speculating, if that's what's maybe going to happen with these other Cat's Eye members. Will they break off? Will they break off? Or is this going to have the lasting cultural impact when they are this big?
Like, I'm not denying how big they are, but like in a week that we also saw things like, and it's so different to compare. I know this is a bit of a stretch, but like, you know, we're seeing things like Phoebe Bridges come out with her album that also, you know, is a number one album. And it's like, I think Cat's Eye was the biggest album technically, but would it have the same lasting cultural impact as something like Phoebe Bridges? Probably not. Yeah. You've introduced me to this idea of the industry plant. And it's serious speculation happening here, but I'm enjoying. You're basically making a prediction they potentially don't have it to last, right? Well, not if the behind the scenes isn't super supportive as well.
Or I don't know. I'm like, who's making these decisions? Do these girls want to be doing this? That's a crazy call. Now I'm just riffing. I'm just riffing now. We've gone from really careful. Let's be really careful and not speculate to, are the girls and cats I happy in this? And do they know I love them and one of them waved at me? Thing is, they're not going to reply. You should check, though. Okay, we are now at the Q&A for this week. Thank you so much to people of Messenger sent in. This was from the link that we put in our Besties chat.
So thank you to everyone who has been sending voice memos in there. So if you go on our Instagram page, you'll see at the very top, there's like a little chat function and you can join in there and you can send in a voice memo if you want to be included. But we have one here. I'm going to play it out. From Anonymous. I don't know what I feel about adults saying they don't need any more friends. It's really confusing to me. And as somebody who has moved to a new city and is trying to make not only friends, but like a community of people, it's really frustrating the attitude that, oh, I don't need any more friends.
And also just confusing because... like what are you going to do with your life? You're just going to stay friends with the same people and never meet anybody else, never let anybody into your life. It doesn't make sense because nobody ever really says that about like romantic relationships. Like if you broke up with somebody, the expectation is that you're eventually going to get into another relationship. So why do we not have the same sort of belief around friendships about like you're eventually going to get another friend and all of that?
I love you so much, listener. I kind of disagree with parts of this. Interesting. Well, not because I think the romantic partnership thing is a wrong comparison because for most people, it's either you want to be single, you want to date multiple people, or you want to be in a monogamous relationship. But for most people, it's a lot of maybe single people wanting to be in a relationship. That's one person. Friendship capacity is kind of different because also, I think it comes back to the expectations of every friendship. Like, I might say, like, I have in my inner circle, like, five close, close friends that I see X amount of time a week.
But I might absolutely be like, I'd love to make five new friends who are my, like, once a month, you know, get a coffee and go for a walk friends. Like, I actually think it neglects the layers and different roles and space that friendships can take up. Like, sometimes I might be like, I'm looking for a really new close, close, close, close friend. We actually did a really interesting interview recently with Anna Goldfarb, who is a journalist and a columnist and author specifically on friendships, because we get so many DMs like this. She had a really good way of speaking about the different tiers of friendships and how we can have different types of friends.
I'm not even going to try and go into it because the way she explained it was so much better. So I'm just going to leave it for that. But I will say I understand this because I... I'm constantly surprised at how much I hear people say they're not looking for friends in any capacity. I think to move to somewhere, and I know it's particularly a Sydney thing, we have had the same friends from high school. Oh, well, see, this is actually the interest because I would agree with this speak pipe anonymous because I would say I've been someone who's moved high schools. I've moved to a new city for university where I didn't know a single person.
And then I've moved to Sydney three and a half years ago. So there's been multiple points in my life where I've kind of gone to zero and then looked to make the first friend. And I've looked to make a hundred friends and I'm an extrovert. So I really enjoy always having capacity. Like I actually do agree with this person. Like I think there's always capacity for a new friend. Mm-hmm. I'm even someone that only became a little bit hesitant to date and meet friends because of my job. And I sometimes feel a bit weird about meeting new friends because of it. But I even was in the UK earlier this year and I met someone who was like, you know, at Oxford studying and who was an Australian and I hung out with them in a group of 20.
And I was like, I'm going to text them afterwards. I'd really like to be their friend when they move back to Australia. And I was so embarrassing. I was like, hey, I'm just wondering when you move home, like, would you like to get coffee and become adult friends? And I was so excited to, do that? I haven't done that in ages. I just think it's finding the right people. I think people that are really closed off and genuinely don't want to make a new friend, that's their loss. I don't understand that. I think you don't need to make a new best friend immediately, but I don't understand being rude to people, especially when they're new to a city. I don't get it. I don't know why that's so entrenched.
I also find some of my most introverted friends are the best at actively seeking new friendships. I think sometimes think that extroverts find it so easy. They're just like, oh, whatever to everyone on the periphery. Yeah. Whereas I think my introverted friends are really particular about how they spend their energy and how they invest in someone. And the boundary lines feel far clearer to me because of that. So I think also there's assumptions about who's friendly, who's not that we actually need to ignore as well, because my most active social friends can be like massive introverted people. I also think when you're cutting yourself off from new friendships, you are really isolating yourself.
I mean, I'm so lucky that I have incredible friends from high school or friends that I've had since I was a kid. And like, that's really special. But it's also, I wouldn't want that to be my only friendships because you can't be expected to grow at the exact same rate as people that you've known since 10 years old. You enter different stages. You need single friends. You need relationship friends. You need work friends. You know, like... Yeah, I don't get it. The only other thing I'll add to this is like, sometimes I think that when someone says they're not looking for new friends, it might be because they're genuinely at capacity and they can't give you what you need.
Yeah. And that's true. I think that you're going to be able to discern where they're coming from. It's more that like, I can imagine myself doing that in a scenario where like someone might want to see me like twice a week. And I just know, like, it's like committing to a social sport. You're like, I just... don't think I can. Yeah. Yeah. And I happily would like go for a walk on a Saturday morning once a month, but like the capacity is different. So I think there's sometimes rejection on the basis of frequency and intensity rather than actual friendship as well. Agreed. Wow. Nuance. And I hope that was helpful. I hope that might've been helpful. Yeah. Thank you so much for listening again this week.
Please remember to follow us on Instagram. Join the Besties Chat. Leave a review. Tap the bell. Leave a comment on Spotify. There are so many things to do. It all really helps. So thank you so much. And we will see you this week for Big Talk. See you Wednesday and Thursday and next Tuesday. See you next week. It's a big week. It's a big week.
There’s a lot no one tells you when you start working. Luckily, this week Sarah is joined by someone who has made all the mistakes so you don’t have to: Sophie Hirst (aka Soph Workbaby). With a career spanning Nylon,...
We are coming to you with some breaking news: Robert Pattinson has been named as the next James Bond, and Sarah has thoughts. Is he the reinvention 007 needs, or a safe studio pick? Then, Justine unpacks how one of the...
If you're in your late twenties and feel like your entire life is being turned upside down, you might just be in your Saturn Return. Breakups, career changes, friendship shifts and existential crises. According to...
Well well well. It’s a new week and a whole new world that we’ve woken up to. First up, Hannah explains what happened in the U.S. mid-terms. The Democrats won BIG and we want to know why. What does this mean for the...
From WitchTok and tarot cards to manifestation and etsy witches - it seems women are embracing their witchy side more than ever. But whats the darker history of witches? For centuries, women accused of witchcraft were...