This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit bigbiology.substack.com What was distinctive about Bob Ricklefs’ mentorship style, and how did he influence his students and collaborators? What were Bob’s major contributions to biology, and how did these ideas leave a lasting legacy on the field? In this episode, we commemorate the life and work of Bob Ricklefs, who passed away recently. Bob was a giant in the fields of ecolo…
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_03Hopefully, you've had the fortune in your life to meet a great mentor. Of course, parents, older siblings, grandparents, other family members can positively change the course of your life.
SPEAKER_02But in academia, you often have the chance to meet people that change your thinking, accidentally or unintentionally shape your career, and outright affect you for good and forever through the guidance and example they offer you.
SPEAKER_03Most biology graduate programs in the US Inherently foster these mentor-mentee relationships because prospective graduate students usually pick a major professor based on having shared research interests when they apply for a master's or a PhD program.
SPEAKER_02Depending on the people involved, these relationships can be very formal and professional. They can be nurturing and supportive, and sometimes they can even be negative and unlucky cases. Students can end up with neglectful or outright nasty mentors. It happens. We have all heard such stories.
SPEAKER_03On this first episode of season nine for Big Biology, though, we don't want to dwell on the negative cases. What we want to do is start the season with gratitude and a memorial to a couple of the best mentors we've known, both of whom passed away this last year.
SPEAKER_02If we had more time, we'd record an entirely different podcast celebrating the lives and contributions of biologists lost recently. We don't have the capacity for that approach, but we have been of the mindset to speak with senior scientists whose voices probably haven't been heard by enough people.
SPEAKER_03Which is why we'll continue hosting senior scientists on the podcast and why today's episode is dedicated to a few people who had huge impacts on ecology and evolution, but especially on the students that they taught.
SPEAKER_02So sure, it's great to read the writings of our intellectual heroes, but isn't it equally, if not more, interesting to hear them share their ideas directly? Haven't you wondered about the backstories, the motivations, and the struggles that led to their contributions?
SPEAKER_03Last year alone, we lost an enormous number of influential biologists before they had a chance to share their stories with us, including Jane Goodall, Peter Raven, Bob Trivers, Paul Ehrlich, Jay Savage, Madhav Gadgil, Herbert Sukup, William Bond, Mark Elgar, John Rapol, and many others. These people had a lasting influence on their fields, their colleagues, collaborators, and especially their trainees. For me, one of those mentors was Michaela
SPEAKER_02Howe, Ayla to most of us. Ayla was a group leader at the Max Planck Institute for Biological Intelligence in Sevilla, Germany, but she was also a good friend and a mentor during my PhD. Her contributions were diverse and deep. From the regulation of biorhythms, which she began at her own PhD with Abel Gwinner, working of all things on house sparrows, to the evolution of hormone regulation. Most of Ayla's work involved birds, including a lot of research on neotropical species with past guests of the show and her postdoc advisor, John Wingfield.
SPEAKER_02She spent years on the faculty at Princeton before moving to the Max Planck.
SPEAKER_03I only met Ayla a few times, and she had all the characteristics you hoped for in a mentor or a collaborator. She was curious and tireless. But she was also candid and serious. She rarely conceded an argument just to be nice or because the topic was fraught. She did science because she sought understanding, and she expected the same from everyone she met, students especially. She was also fiercely committed to bringing women into science, and a lot of the field's best young researchers are in it because of her.
SPEAKER_02Personally, Ayla had more influence on me as a scientist and mentor than almost anyone else. In particular, she taught me how to be nicer, which I'm still working on, But she succeeded in helping me straddle the line between support and criticism. Tough love was her superpower, which is probably why so many of her trainees say their time with Ayla was the most rewarding they ever had.
SPEAKER_03This past January, Integrative and Comparative Biology published a memorial to her. The memorial was organized by Jim Adelman from the University of Memphis and Jenny Oyang from the University of Nevada, Reno. Check it out for yourself and learn more about who Ayla was and many of the things she contributed to biology.
SPEAKER_02The other person we want to celebrate today is Bob Rickles, one of the most influential ecologists of the past half century. Probably everyone who listens to the show knows of Bob's contributions, even if you don't think you do. He wrote one of the most used textbooks in ecology, 860 pages of it in his early 30s, even before he had tenure, and it's still in print 53 years later.
SPEAKER_03On the off chance you haven't heard about Bob's contributions, there's a fantastic piece in the American Naturalist that summarizes it. Written by dozens of his former students, trainees, and collaborators, it's available online now.
SPEAKER_02Cam and I both knew Bob a bit, but not that well. I met him when my PhD advisor and he and a bunch of others were awarded an NSF grant to investigate what they call the life history physiology nexus. I won't dig into what that was right now, but the series of ideas that it included was the instigation for my PhD and arguably a big part of what became integrative biology.
SPEAKER_03The nexus work was inspiring to me too, but my appreciation of Bob started with his textbook as an undergraduate. And dozens and dozens of his papers when I was a PhD student with Tom Martin at the University of Montana. My research interests revolved around life history evolution, community ecology, and physiology of birds. And every time I started to read about these topics, Bob's papers were always the most influential ones that shaped my thinking.
SPEAKER_02But here's the thing about Bob that we want to drive home. He took very few graduate students, a choice he made on purpose. He also wasn't much of a grant chaser either. He'd raise money when he needed it, like for his malaria work, which you'll hear more about later, but grants were a tool to do more science, never the point.
SPEAKER_03Today on Big Biology, we'll talk about Bob's work, but especially his personality, philosophy, and approach to mentorship and collaboration with his closest collaborator, his wife, and eminent botanist in her own right, Suzanne Renner. Suzanne is an emeritus professor at the University of Munich and an honorary professor of biology at Washington University in St. Louis. And years before that, a full professor at the University of Missouri-St. Louis, where she and Bob overlapped. Among many projects with Bob,
SPEAKER_03she challenged the notion that neutral processes are important in explaining biodiversity, particularly for trees.
SPEAKER_02Along with Suzanne, we'll be joined by Alan Cohen, Associate Professor of Environmental Health Sciences at Columbia's Mailman School, where Alan holds the Chair in Biological Complexity and Healthy Longevity. Alan's research with Bob had nothing to do with plants or even biodiversity. Alan studied aging, predominantly the role of antioxidants in the aging process in birds, which attests to Bob's unbelievably broad interests. These days, Alan still works on aging, but more on people than wildlife. Also, be sure to check out his excellent Substack, Dynamic Entropy.
SPEAKER_03So before we answer your burning question, what about Bob? A few things. Bigbiology continues to be a top rising science publication on Substack. We've just hit 10,000 subscribers and 20,000 others follow us on Spotify. Thank you so much for taking an interest in what we do. Tell your friends, family, colleagues, and students about us because the best way to keep us going is to make sure everyone knows about what we do. We're on Instagram, Blue Sky, LinkedIn, X, and most other platforms.
SPEAKER_03So share our next post with your circle Or do it the old fashioned way. Send them an email or just tell them about us.
SPEAKER_02Last year, as you might recall, we installed a paywall on Substack because we needed help to keep producing shows and for Clayton, Brianna, Cass and Caroline to contribute as interns. Well, we decided to tear down that wall because too many people were frustrated to hear just the first part of an episode. If you're nice enough to want to listen to us, why should we stop you?
SPEAKER_03Don't get us wrong. We really need and very much appreciate your support because only about 5% of our listeners actually support the program by paying. And to be honest, that's really not enough to keep the lights on. But for now, everyone will get whole episodes for free. We're investigating other ways to support production. And if you want to help, it's $5 monthly or $50 annually. Just go to bigbiology.substack.com and sign up.
SPEAKER_02And while we're on the subject of who gets heard, junior voices in science are hugely important to us. The focus on senior scientists we mentioned earlier does not mean that we don't want to platform students, postdocs, and new professors. We know how hard it is for people new to the field to be seen. It's for exactly this reason that we're holding a student spotlight to help share these new voices. Check out bigbiology.substack.com for details on how to take part in that initiative.
SPEAKER_03In fact, if you really want to get involved with Big Biology, get in touch with us. We're always looking for new interns.
SPEAKER_02And moreover, I'm in the process for looking for new graduate students as well. Many members of my group have worked on this show during their MS and PhD degrees. If you're interested to learn more about that or our grad programs here at USF, shoot me an email.
SPEAKER_03Two last things before we start with Bob. First, unfortunately, we lost most of Suzanne's audio because of technical difficulties. There were other stories she shared But didn't survive during the recording. Second, this season, you're going to hear two newish voices that are going to join us on a few episodes. One is Fran Bonnier from Queen's University in Canada, who joined us last season to talk with John Winkfield.
SPEAKER_02The other new host is John Drake from the University of Georgia, who also joined us a few times last year. John and I will co-host the upcoming episode with David Lodge of Cornell University. And fittingly, given today's theme, John did his PhD with David at Notre Dame. Welcome to John and Fran.
SPEAKER_03Now on to the show.
SPEAKER_02I'm Marty Martin.
SPEAKER_03And I'm Cameron Gallenbor.
SPEAKER_02And this is Big Biology. Suzanne Renner and Alan Cohen, welcome to Big Biology.
SPEAKER_00Such a pleasure to be here.
SPEAKER_02So we invited you on the show today for a bit of a different kind of conversation to talk about a major figure in biology that was very important to both of you, Bob Rickles. Bob was a giant in ecology, but he passed away on June 7th of this year before we got to interview him directly. We really appreciate that you both agreed to join us, especially you, Suzanne, being a scientist yourself, but having been married to Bob for more than 30 years. So can we start our chat today by talking about Bob as a person? I met him when I was a PhD student, and I was always kind of intimidated by him because so much of what I did as
SPEAKER_02an early scientist was a direct extension of reading his papers. And now that I'm older, I know that fear was more about my imposter syndrome than anything else. He was well known as a warm and thoughtful and funny guy. So Suzanne, how did you meet Bob and come to get married if you're willing to get that personal?
SPEAKER_01Yes, we met at a conference on biodiversity in Copenhagen where he had been invited at my instigations.
SPEAKER_02Did he give a talk there or was this... Of
SPEAKER_01course he gave a talk and it was fabulous. And I sat there and I was really done for. I have to say, physically it was just so attractive to me. And then the talk was also good.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So like Marty, I can say really without any hesitation that there hasn't been a single person that's been more influential in shaping my scientific thinking than Bob. He really was this larger than life figure for me. And I remember early conversation I had with him when he asked me, so where do you think avian life history theory is going? Where should it go? And my first reaction was, Wow. I was so humbled that Bob would care to know my opinion on this.
SPEAKER_03And then my feelings went to sheer terror because then I had to give an answer. And I was like, oh boy, I hope I don't embarrass myself. So Alan, you earned your PhD with Bob and you recently led this team of 77 of his former students and collaborators in writing this memorial piece for him that's going to be coming out soon in The American Naturalist. And you opened the writing piece by saying that, quote,
SPEAKER_03Bob was not only one of the greatest ecologists of the last century, but also A thoughtful and inspiring mentor and role model for a large cohort of successful scientists. So what was it like working with him? What was it like having him as a mentor and a role model?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, this summer since he passed has been so moving and important for me because I've gone back and I've reflected and I kind of Re-understand now in a very different way what he gave me, even like the memorial that I attended just Monday and then got to hear stories from students who'd been there 30 years before me. Like I'm starting to see many things that I got from him that I didn't even know that that came from him, right? Sometimes we're not aware of what we're picking up from someone. And I was coming in. I had finished my undergrad.
SPEAKER_00I didn't do a master's, and I went straight into a PhD with him. It was very warm and welcoming. I think at that time, I didn't really have a sense of how important he was. And so it was just kind of natural for me to be in conversation with him. And the first thing I remember really from the lab is I went to lab meeting, which we had roughly every two weeks. There were maybe 10 of us in the lab at that point. And we went around the table and said what we did. And that set the stage for that year of every single person in the lab was working
SPEAKER_00on a completely different subject. So every conversation in the lab meeting every two weeks was a conversation between Bob and the one student who knew that subject, right? And so, you know, just to give you a few examples, we had Shinkan Huang, who was working on tree species distributions in Asia and North America. We had Erper Hansen, who was working on seabird diving energetics. We had Juan Martinez, who was trying to breed finches and see how far out you could breed different species and get them to successfully hybridize. We had Dave Zielkowski, who was working on warbler speciation.
SPEAKER_00We had Kevin Mattson, who was working on avian immunology on islands versus mainlands. The only two people who were working on the same subject were me and Alex Scheuerlein. We were both working on aging, and he was a postdoc at the time. And Sylvia Fallon was working on avian malaria in the Caribbean, right? And so we've just touched on not even all of the subjects that Bob works on. That was what our lab meetings were like. That gives you a sense of the breadth of his interests.
SPEAKER_00I think we're going to talk maybe more on his science later, but one point to make is that in my mind at that moment, these were just different interests he had. But in his mind, these were all part of a big hole. He saw how it all fit into a big picture. It took me a long time to really fully understand how that all came together.
SPEAKER_02Well, so that's something, I mean, you did say, we'll get into some of those details, but let's go with that big picture. Suzanne, I mean, how did Bob see these as a collective? Because Cam and I have talked a lot about that. I mean, was there some unified vision for all of these things that he did? What was that? How did he see that?
SPEAKER_01As far as I understand or see it, one unifying thread was how species came to coexist with And how their history makes it possible for them to coexist. But he had, like you say, bird physiology, aging. But I think the coexistence of species and how it is shaped by their history was one unifying threat to me.
SPEAKER_02Well, it's so impressive because it's sort of like you're alluding to the levels of organization. I mean, to work on so many of them and I guess have a vision of how the integration It all feeds together into this idea of coexistence. I mean, that's exceptional.
SPEAKER_00And I think he saw a lot of it early on, right? So he had this kind of intuition for it very early in his career. And then he spent the rest of his career basically showing what he had intuited early on that wasn't obvious to anyone else.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. I wonder how much writing the ecology textbook maybe had a lot of that intuition in it.
SPEAKER_01Right, because he wrote that when he was 28. And part of it was an anti-MacArthur worldview, okay? His first advisor was Robert MacArthur, who was not impressed with Bob. And when Robert MacArthur went from Penn to Princeton, he didn't take Bob as a PhD student, so Bob had to switch advisors. So I think he had in the back of his mind a deep desire to show that MacArthur was wrong. Okay? Because MacArthur had an ahistoric worldview that things were fitting like they did,
SPEAKER_01you know, everybody eating the right stuff, local competition. And to Bob, that wasn't the explanation or only a small part of the explanation.
SPEAKER_00I was just going to say that I think that sense that things are interconnected was maybe the central theme. If you look at one of his subjects, it will always link to two or three or four of the other subjects that he works on. The sense that was maybe there before that you could look at one or two factors and understand something in ecology. In a bigger sense, you know, his central contribution is to show that anything you look at is the result of many other processes that are all interrelated and all working together to shape
SPEAKER_00the large scale patterns that we see. And, you know, it could be large scale patterns in avian physiology, but that's also shaped by the community ecology, for example.
SPEAKER_02So the trick with integrative biology, if we want to call it that, is that, you know, there's at every level of organization an unbelievable diversity of things wood could work on. And though Bob obviously wove together these levels and ideas and different elements of ecology and evolution, he picked the subset, right? Because how else do you do it? Why did he pick the subset that he did? Why is there both sort of diversity and aging and growth rates of birds early?
SPEAKER_02I mean, how did he view that sort of set of sub-disciplines?
SPEAKER_01It's a very good question. And not all his picks were successful. One pick that was less successful than others is the parasites. He thought that parasites that are species specific, of course, most are, would contribute to the shaping of the community. And he tried that very hard with various students. But at the time, the molecular tools were really So difficult to handle and it was so hard that, for example, Sylvia Fallon, but also others, had a hard time getting the data.
SPEAKER_01You know, the system was the birds in the Caribbean and how different islands have different species or subspecies of birds, bird species, and how parasites might influence that. But it didn't pan out the way he saw it in his big picture.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I wonder, because a lot of that work, if I remember correctly, Suzanne, a lot of that is avian malaria.
SPEAKER_01Yes, yes.
SPEAKER_02And at the time, Sylvia and others were working, there was only so much we could see about avian malaria. So even if the ideas work, the tools, now I think it would be possible to dig into that. But at the time, it wouldn't really. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yes. That's exactly right. The guy in Lithuania who was looking through the microscope, the only person apparently who could.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Belkionis probably, yeah.
SPEAKER_01We visited him. We had three days in his house there in Vilnius. It was wonderful. But that's not the way to go.
SPEAKER_02A microscope only gets you so far for certain things. Yeah, for sure.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, I think, you know, my sense of it too, is that he just started early on, like he was, you know, he was working on avian growth rates and like in thrashers, right? And he would just start pulling on threads, right? And maybe Suzanne, you know, I don't, I don't know why he started working on Caribbean birds, but I think, you know, that island system then became something that, that led, you know, specifically to many other things. So it's kind of.
SPEAKER_01Yes. I think it's because of his early visits to the Smithsonian, the tropical ecology group there and With Birmingham and others, that's how he came to the Caribbean. That's my feeling. I really don't know. The Caribbean as a system to work in is a brilliant system, okay? But the tools just weren't available for Sylvia Fallon and others to get anywhere. I mean, he had gone to Barrow, Colorado Island in the 70s, very early on. He was familiar with the Panamanian, the lab there, and of course the Caribbean being next door.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so Marty and I were talking about this earlier, and one of the things that I think really has struck me about Bob's research in terms of marching to his own drummer, I think was a way that he was described. But unlike most biologists, he didn't work only on one species. He didn't have a single study site that he only worked at. He worked in the Caribbean. He worked on songbirds.
SPEAKER_03He worked on seabirds. Obviously, he was interested in many other kinds of questions. And I'm curious, did he ever talk about how the diversity of systems, like working in the tropics versus the temperate zone? Asian mangroves. Yes, that's right. Yeah. Asian deciduous forests. Did he ever talk about how all those systems kind of informed him?
SPEAKER_01No, he did not. No, he was question-driven. Okay, clearly question-driven, not system-driven, but he didn't talk about that, no.
SPEAKER_02Well, question-driven, but he did like birds. Is that fair? That's very fair.
SPEAKER_01He also liked plants a lot, actually, thinking about all the work he did with Hong Kien, who was at the memorial. Diversity in North America versus Asia, that's all on plants because they're sedentary. You get distribution data more easily than they do for birds, often migrate. All our papers together are on plants and daisian plants.
SPEAKER_03Maybe that's a good transition, Suzanne, to talk about your collaborations with Bob. I mean, you published many papers together. And so, you know, there are many sort of academic couples out there that collaborate and work together. You know, you were this power couple. How did you work together? You know, did you have a particular project that you worked on that was sort of one of your favorite projects or any stories that you'd like to share?
SPEAKER_01From the beginning, he provided the quantitative aspects of our collaborations because I didn't bring that at all. He had this gift, as Alan already said, of explaining things so clearly and so beautifully. I felt I understood multivariate statistics, which is a basic thing in ecology, but I had never heard about it. And he just brought that to our collaborations.
SPEAKER_02So let's, Alan, maybe talk a little bit more about Bob as a mentor to a lot of our listeners, our graduate students. And some have referred to Bob as a sort of sink or swim kind of mentor, but the weekly or biweekly lab meetings that you mentioned sort of suggest something different. And I thought one of the things that was really neat to hear is the sort of champagne cork Maybe I was inspired by Bob to do that, but I've been doing that in my lab, and I don't know why. Maybe I just did that because I knew that Bob did it.
SPEAKER_02I don't know. But maybe talk about Bob a little bit more as a mentor, how he dealt with students one-on-one.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. I think it's true to say that he was sink or swim. And I think some people might have perceived that as just a lack of interest or something, but I don't think that's true at all. I think it's actually the opposite. I think he very clearly had a philosophy where a PhD was a big deal. And if you got a PhD, it had to mean something, it had to matter. And the way that you showed that you earned it was to do the work yourself. And so you had to figure out your own question. If you couldn't understand what an interesting question was,
SPEAKER_00then you probably shouldn't have a PhD. And so maybe you needed a little help in getting there. But I think there's a lot of evidence that, from my perspective, that he really did care a lot. I mean, at a personal level, I was sick during my PhD. I was in the hospital for a couple of weeks. He visited me three times, more than anybody but my wife. So he really cared. He was always warm and welcoming. And we were over to his house frequently. But beyond that, his door was open.
SPEAKER_00It's so different from today's world of science where everybody has meetings all the time, our schedules are booked. You could just wander over and pop into his office and chat for an hour. And we did, right? But you also learn to be wary of doing that because when you went in, you had this thing you're struggling with, you want to get this solved, and you'd go in there and you would not end up solving the thing that you wanted to solve. But you would realize that, wow, it's way harder than I thought. And here's these other things that I need to think about for that. I don't know if this was his protection mechanism
SPEAKER_00against everyone just taking his time all the time. But I think it was just this honest scientific curiosity that when you presented him with that question, you came out realizing that it was a much harder question than you thought. And so he was really there for us in that sense. But then it was on us to figure out our question and to execute and to Even once we'd figured out our question, we'd executed, it was on us to write it up, to have the self-discipline to push through to the end. These are all things that I think in his worldview,
SPEAKER_00that was what a PhD meant is that you can do that. So it wouldn't be a PhD if he was helping you too much. And nowadays, I think we sometimes, some of the universities I've had would not let me have his approach to mentorship, right? Because you're supposed to make sure that everybody's doing fine and you don't want anyone to drop out.
SPEAKER_02What about this champagne cork? I just want to make sure that we tie the thread on that story.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So when we, you know, when you graduate, when you finish your PhD, then I think the tradition evolved over time because in like the early students, it was a cork. When I was there, it was the bottle, but you know, you would write your name like with a Sharpie or something on cork or the bottle, and then those would go on the top of a shelf in his office. So there's this collection and you could see like his former PhD students each had, you know, their signature on one. Right.
SPEAKER_01And I have a photo even of that wall of bottles.
SPEAKER_02You know, we talked just a minute ago about Bob's fondness for birds, at least in the extent that, you know, there's a, as we see behind you, Suzanne, there's quite the library. And a lot of those books are on birds. One of his students recently told me something. So he's my colleague across the way in the biology department, Diego Santiago Alicone. And so he was telling me a story when he was a graduate student with Bob. That involves reading, but not about birds. He says that he was studying in Bob's library and he was particularly reading
SPEAKER_02a physics book because at the time, and actually right now, he's really interested in the sort of influence of quantum phenomena on genetic variation. I'm not going to go into those details right now, but when he was reading the book and Bob came in to see him, he thought, oh no, I'm going to get in trouble because I'm not reading anything that really directly applies to my research. And so he says, I thought Bob was going to be surprised or upset about wasting my time. But to his surprise, what Bob said is, oh, it's a good thing you're a generalist thinker. Focus on reading what's of interest to you.
SPEAKER_02So how does that resonate with you? Did Bob read theoretical physics often?
SPEAKER_00I mean, it's certainly like that attitude is very consistent with the advisor that I knew. He was encouraging us to do our own thing, think our own way. And Our research projects also didn't need to tie that directly into what he was doing.
SPEAKER_01And important is that he didn't have funding for each student. Today you have a grant and a student or several students are in that grant and you have to produce on the topic of the grant. And since Bob didn't have grants for his various students, they were relatively free to do what they wanted to do.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. I mean, that's interesting that you mentioned Bob not having a lot of grants historically. And I think that probably would be a surprise to most people, given his influence and how that really contrasts with the way that science is really being done today. Yeah. And so I think it was maybe Brian McGill that had a piece recently, kind of a memoriam for Bob, and he referred to Bob's science as slow science.
SPEAKER_03And, you know, in a way, kind of a way of doing science of slowly, thoughtfully And kind of in contrast to the get the grant, publish as many papers as you can, move to the next grant, get as many students out as quickly as you can. And this sort of maybe, I guess, fast science in comparison. So yeah, did he ever reflect on the sort of changing nature of academia?
SPEAKER_03And I think in the Amnat piece, you write a little bit about Bob's style of doing science is also one that's based on scholarship and thoughtfulness rather than how much money he could bring in. Did he ever comment or see where he fit in?
SPEAKER_01No, he did not. He was, of course, disappointed when another NSF proposal was being turned down. But no, he did not. He was a very positive person. He did not go around complaining about the nature of science funding. Not to me, ever.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's my impression as well is like, you know, well, that's how things are. We'll deal with it. We'll find a way through. We'll just, you know, it was very kind of matter of fact. And if this one doesn't work, we'll try another one. We'll make things work. It was never something to worry about. But at the same time, when I look at it, what I'm seeing is one of the greatest scientists, period, I think, of the last century or so. And the way that he did things was kind of like this classic image we have of
SPEAKER_00a scientist sitting alone in his office, Producing great theory, running data analysis, just thinking and writing. That's why he was always there so that when we popped our head in, we could have a conversation. And he would just produce so much that way. He has so many papers where he's sole author on, there's another science paper. So it's amazing how much he could produce that way. And he didn't need a grant to get that done. That doesn't mean he didn't go out and get grants when the funding could be useful
SPEAKER_00to pursue the question that he was working on. He really did, right?
SPEAKER_01He had these research collaborative networks. NSF had a special category of funding, which was relatively easy to get as long as you had a Lithuanian in there or a Norwegian or something. And he did get two of those. And we had meetings in Front Royal. This is near Washington, D.C., I'd say. And those networks, which were helping to train students in methods, he did get, I think, two.
SPEAKER_00And I mean, Marty, you and I met through one of these grants, right?
SPEAKER_02I was going to say one of the life history physiology nexus grant is how we met 200 years ago.
SPEAKER_00Right. So, I mean, Bob at that, like, you know, to tell the story of that grant a little bit, my understanding of it is that, you know, Bob was interested in why the tropical and temperate birds have different life histories. Tropical birds tend to live longer, have smaller clutch sizes. And so how can we link that to the physiology? So that was based on a couple of important papers that he'd, you know, review papers he'd published with Martin Wichelski from Princeton at the time, looking at the physiology life history nexus. And so, you know, Marty was studying at Princeton. I was studying with Bob and Bob got this grant where he pulled together A bunch of the main people you would need to do that work.
SPEAKER_00So he got an avian immunologist and people working on metabolism and the demography of birds and so forth. So you could put all these folks together to do the work you needed to get that question answered. And this was an important grant. It's not that he didn't get grants. And I was able to tap into that, not for funding so much, but to leverage the fact that there was this network to get my PhD work done better. But he didn't need that grant to be doing the theoretical work,
SPEAKER_00and he didn't need that grant to fund his students. So the grant was a plus, not a necessity. So a university looking to hire somebody who's going to bring in lots of indirects Bob is not the person they want to hire. And think about what that says about our world. The person who can actually do the cheapest, best work is the one you don't hire, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's a pretty sobering perspective, I think.
SPEAKER_02Strange situation we're in now. Maybe we can circle back to some of these things. There are a couple of questions of this sort that Cam and I wanted to wrap with. I want to sort of raise the issue of Bob being known as an iconoclast, because that kind of conflicts with what we've been talking about. He's generally a positive person. He didn't hesitate to challenge commonly held views. So he claimed that communities don't exist as integrated Clementian units. He was one of the first to seriously critique Hubble's neutral theory. Suzanne, you worked on that with him.
SPEAKER_02So How did he square these really strong feelings about ideas with never being antagonistic of people?
SPEAKER_01Right. It's from his childhood. He was the second child. He was always the first child is held up as the example. He is not taken on, as I said before, to go to Princeton with his advisor, MacArthur. He had an itch, a desire, challenge theory. He really did. He really did. It comes from his childhood. I do think so.
SPEAKER_02I mean, one of the things that makes, there's a lot of things that make that difficult, but maybe among them is the aptitude and like the competence to talk thoughtfully about these things. And it wasn't just that he was, these are wrong. I mean, he was incredibly articulate and often right that, you know, something else had to be understood.
SPEAKER_01And mathematically gifted. He had a deep understanding of mathematics. I mean, incredible.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I think if you ever attended a seminar where he was in the audience, right? First of all, he was always going to be in the front row. And he was always going to ask the first question afterwards. And that first question was often going to be something completely surprising from a different perspective that made the whole audience see the whole talk in a new light, right? And maybe even made the speaker see their own talk in a new light, right? And so, but it was never like challenging in an aggressive sense.
SPEAKER_00And so he just had this gift for like, because he was just curious, he was just like genuinely curious. And so, you know, he would ask this question kind of with the respect for the speaker to say, you might be able to tell me that I'm wrong here because I'm just asking this question, right? And so that attitude of genuine curiosity was infectious. And I think that's why there was no personal antagonism because for him, it was about the ideas. And I think there were cases where other people were antagonistic to him because he had challenged them, but it was never reciprocated, right?
SPEAKER_01And I witnessed such cases. I witnessed several such cases, exactly. It's exactly true. And of course, his impeccable manners, again, come from his upbringing, having been the headmaster's son, okay? His father was the headmaster of a private school. So he had to be on his Sunday best every single day, from the table manners to the manners of interacting with people. He just had these impeccable manners. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_02Well, let's sort of touch through a bunch of Bob's contributions. We would have to do an entire series of episodes to hit everything, and we won't do that. You know, just as the laundry list of things that he did work in, like history theory, speciation, island biogeography, community ecology, host parasite co-evolution, and of course, avian physiology, as we've alluded to a few times, and I'm sure I left a few out. Alan, you came to work with Bob on something like avian physiology. I don't know if you'd exactly give it that label, but what was it that sort of led you to pick Bob as a mentor?
SPEAKER_02And how did you come to work on the things that you started working on that has sort of expanded into what you're up to now?
SPEAKER_00Yes. I mean, as an undergrad, I remember even my biology 101 class, like learning about plants that have hormones that cause them to senesce in the fall and they kill themselves. What would be the selection pressure to kill yourself, right? And so from that moment on, the evolution of aging was an interest for me. And so at the end of undergrad, I wanted to find an advisor who could be a good advisor for that subject. And some of my undergrad advisors pointed me to various people, including Bob. And so I ended up, you know, interviewing places,
SPEAKER_00really liked him and the department there at the University of Missouri, St. Louis and chose to go there. And so, you know, he was, you know, his work on avian physiology was like, that was actually not the main question I came for. Like, I knew he was interested in aging. And then I ended up working on birds. I like birds too. And then, you know, the birds were a good subject for that. In terms of his contributions, he was looking at the altricial precocial spectrum.
SPEAKER_00And I think he was the one who said, this is not just two ways of doing it. There's actually a full gradient here from altricial to precocial development in birds. So that was a major contribution there. As I mentioned, Kevin Mattson at the time was working on the immune system. But you can see already that he was doing it On islands versus the mainland, right? So we're also looking at these kind of island questions were already coming in there a bit, right? But certainly the aging side of it, I mean, he'd already, before I got there, done work on the demography of aging,
SPEAKER_00showing that Even in the wild, in captivity and in the wild, you can see aging related mortality demographically in many, many species, birds and mammals. And, you know, but I think he wanted to start to tie that into the physiology, which is, you know, this kind of physiology life history nexus that he was working on. And so my work then was on antioxidants in birds and whether, you know, at the time, I look back, it seems so naive now, but the idea that maybe, you know, birds are long lived because they have higher antioxidant levels than mammals, right? And that seems so naive, but in any case, that was my PhD question.
SPEAKER_00And so, you know, we went out and sampled Blood from many different bird species to quantify antioxidant levels at the same time that Marty and other colleagues were looking at the immune systems of birds. And so then we started to try to put some of that together. And I think looking back, I don't know that we got a fully clear answer to that. I think in the end, the answer is that the physiology is more complicated. Not that the physiology is unrelated to the life histories, but there's not as simple a story as anyone had hoped.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So Alan, if I can kind of follow up on that. Aging and lifespan are sort of part of the organism's life history. And one of the areas that I was very influenced by Bob's research was not so much on the physiology side, but from more of the ecology side, the importance of density dependence. And density dependence was this idea that was very influential, I think, in the early days of life history theory of R versus K selection.
SPEAKER_03And then it seems like it sort of fell out of fashion, but he always seemed to emphasize the importance of that. And I know because of collaborators and colleagues that I have here, the importance of density as a sort of both an ecological factor and an evolutionary factor seems to be kind of coming back again. And I think there's a A new appreciation for a lot of the work that he's done. Did that influence you at all?
SPEAKER_03Or did he talk about that a lot in your time as a
SPEAKER_00graduate student? I'm not sure that he and I talked about it that much. It certainly came up like he taught an amazing class in population biology. So density dependence was part of that class. And again, he communicated so clearly. It was a very mathematical class that nonetheless was easy to follow. And so yes, density dependence was very much in his thinking. And I mean, he's got a great paper from 2000 on that, that I think about a lot. And just to give you an example of how this applies, we often think about this trade-off between reproduction and lifespan.
SPEAKER_00And so if you look, is there kind of this aging versus reproduction trade-off going on? A lot of people use comparative evidence to say, yes, you can go look across species and long-lived species have lower reproductive rates and find this very broadly. But I think Bob's answer to that was basically, well, duh, because unless the population is kind of growing exponentially or declining exponentially, You have to maintain something relatively stable. So if you have a high reproductive rate, you're not gonna be able to live very long.
SPEAKER_00Some other force, like the forces of density dependence are gonna come in and cause that correlation to appear regardless of whatever else is going on. So this kind of inner specific comparisons don't really say that much about that question.
SPEAKER_02We could, like I said, talk about all of Bob's contributions forever, but because we have the chance to hear it from you, what was Bob's favorite? Or what did Bob consider to be his sort of greatest contribution or the mystery that he sort of couldn't crack?
SPEAKER_01Yes. I don't know that he had a favorite contribution because he would still go on about bird physiology late in life. I mean, which was in fact early research interest. Alan, what do you think? I don't think he had a favorite contribution either.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I also have the impression that he saw it as integrated enough that he would not have chosen one subject or one paper. He was very known for his work in community ecology, but I don't think he would have said, Community ecology is my favorite thing that I've done. I think he would have just seen it as part of this interwoven network of interest. But I mean, there's an interesting anecdote on this as well that came out from the memorial on Monday. So Don Miles, former PhD student I was there,
SPEAKER_00told us this great story about they'd submitted a manuscript to ecology on like ecomorphology and how that could structure community ecology. And they got the manuscript back and said, congratulations, it's accepted. But then the wrong manuscript was in the envelope. So they had to write back. And, you know, this is back in the days when everything was by paper and mail, right? And this was like, you know, maybe early 80s, right? And then the manuscript was actually rejected. So then they get like, you know, a couple weeks later, they get this back, it was actually rejected. And, you know, so Don Miles is very frustrated,
SPEAKER_00like pulling out his hair, like, what are we going to do? And Bob's like, don't worry about it, we'll sort it out. Very typical Bob, just kind of like so laid back, relaxed, it will all be okay, right? And the reason for the rejection was because Bob should stay in his lane. He was not a community ecologist at this point, right? And so, you know, go work on avian growth and development. That's your thing. But do not come into our territory of community ecology here, right? Wow. So Bob's rebuttal was then to say, you know, fine if you want to criticize our science.
SPEAKER_00That's fair game. But, you know, don't... Rejected because of who I am, right? And so then it went through and got accepted, right? And now we see him as a major community college.
SPEAKER_03So maybe we should also talk a little bit about Bob's writing and writing style. He did write a lot of papers also just on his own. Marty and I were talking about this. I think one of the reasons why Bob's research was so influential wasn't only the ideas, but also the way he communicated. We were commenting that we remember the papers that he wrote.
SPEAKER_03They stick with you in a way that a lot of other, you know, even very good papers with, you know, high profile results don't necessarily stick with you in the same way. And so did he ever talk about like, you know, tips on how to be a good writer and how to be a good communicator that way? Was that, did he just have natural talent that way? Or did he have a sort of a formula that he followed?
SPEAKER_00So, okay, so yeah, I mean, I, he didn't say, like, this is again, something that's very different from how things work today. Like today, I can see like a lab meeting that we might have in my lab about how do we communicate well in science? And let's talk about that for an hour and a half, right? Bob would never do this. Like Bob would, you know, you would come to him with your draft, it would come back dripping in red. I mean, like red is the color that I associate with going into his office, right? Like you were lucky if one word of your original manuscript made it through, right?
SPEAKER_00So it was up to you to infer from where the red was, which was everywhere, how to be a better communicator. And we were talking about how he made very good figures. But I think all of the things we're saying come down to clarity of thought. His ability to ask the right question in a seminar, his ability to teach a hard Subject well, to create a network of collaborators and pull them together, and also to communicate in the right way in his papers to make that impact was
SPEAKER_00because he saw things so clearly. And when you see things that clearly, it just kind of comes naturally. So I think in that sense, it would have been hard for him to say, here's the secret sauce. It was just like, that's how he saw it. And hopefully the rest of us were going to see what he was doing and kind of copy that to some extent. But there wasn't anything more than that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. I mean, that's both sobering and inspiring. I mean, it's sobering in the sense that there is no secret formula and that I think it also speaks to that what made him such a great scientist was this ability to think so clearly.
SPEAKER_02There's so many different questions to ask. All right, I'm going to ask about taxon cycles. And the reason I want to ask about taxon cycles is that I think I still don't quite understand it. Now, it may be too much to ask you to sort of channel Bob on this, but why did he think this was so important? What does taxon cycle mean? And I think he, I know once I heard him in a plenary give a talk and it involved the banana quit. One of his examples is banana quit. So can you share with us what was so important about taxon cycles to Bob?
SPEAKER_01Well, you saw that, as you know, in taxon cycles, the young species is not adapted yet to It's interacting parasites and over time it will adapt to them. That is basically the taxon cycle. The time comes into the way species interact with their environment. That is the taxon cycle. Why he was so fascinated with that I think it comes from his early interaction with Biff Birmingham and the work in the Caribbean versus Central America.
SPEAKER_01And taxon cycles were always attacked, right? They were never made it into becoming an accepted explanation in ecology.
SPEAKER_02And so how the idea, I mean, the motivation was something about understanding community assembly. And diversity on islands, right? So the parasites as the sort of enduring and evolving force that as co-adaptation between host and parasite sort of takes its form, then speciation is enabled because these relationships kind of go off into different directions. Is that? Yeah. Okay. Maybe I do understand it a little bit better than I thought, but I know as a graduate student, it always seemed a mystery.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I'm the same way. Like, I think I didn't understand it until we put this piece together. And, you know, now it's like it seems to make sense to me that like a species will go through different phases as it kind of, you know, over a long course of evolution, as it adapts to and, you know, Antagonists, maybe not just pathogens, but more broadly. And this, I think he saw as key to explaining distributional anomalies. Bananiquet, for example, is not found in Cuba, but it's found on many islands around it. It can certainly get there, right? So why isn't it established in Cuba?
SPEAKER_00It seems like it should be, right? And so if you want to explain this, then you need to go to other types of explanations, such as potentially the taxon cycles. And so I think Early on, he was poo-pooed. I don't know where the consensus is now, but I think it's less negative than it was for sure. But I think this was a critical part of the overall picture of why would you have the communities that you do?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's interesting. If we're going to stick with thinking about communities, one topic that Bob got involved in relates to Steve Hubbell's ideas of neutral theory in community ecology. And I remember lots Papers and debates going back and forth. So, Suzanne, you were involved, I think, in a lot of that research. So, can you talk a little bit about,
SPEAKER_03you know, what were the main arguments against neutral theory?
SPEAKER_01Oh, exactly. The effect of local history that we have already touched upon several times in this conversation. If you have a different history in Southeast Asian mangroves, say, than in New World mangroves, You will have a different diversity. Yes, Hubble's worldview was completely ahistoric to me.
SPEAKER_03And I think that point about history and evolution is something that does permeate a lot of Bob's perspective. And maybe, you know, I think some of this does come through in the MNAP piece, but, you know, like today we think about evolutionary ecology and the The sort of, you know, unification as a very natural thing.
SPEAKER_01Yes, and yeah, he didn't exist when Bob started writing his textbook. This didn't exist.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that ecology and evolution were sort of separate. And so like, yeah, maybe the MacArthurian view was you could understand ecology without evolution. And Bob really, you know, argued against that. And not only that, not only... Evolution from the perspective of the evolutionary history of the individual species, but also at a regional level, thinking about the biogeographic history and the larger pool of species.
SPEAKER_01Exactly, exactly. The ice ages in Europe have had a terrible effect on the tree diversity, and less so in North America and Asia. This is a prime example, of course, that many people have discussed.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so the sort of ahistorical view would be like, I can just go into this forest and I can measure physiology and ecology and I can understand the patterns of diversity and coexistence. And that was sort of Bob saying, no, no, no, you cannot do that. You will not get the same answer.
SPEAKER_02Well, so one more question and then we'll sort of zoom back out and ask some sort of wrap up kinds of things. We have alluded to it a little bit. So, you know, indulge me if this one seems similar. Was there any revision to his thinking? So, you know, Suzanne, as you said, he wrote those textbooks in ecology so early in his career and then he had a very long career. So was there some idea that he sort of circled back to and said, oh, that wasn't what I originally thought is not how it goes?
SPEAKER_01Not that I know of. It's an excellent question.
SPEAKER_02Alan, any thoughts? Any thoughts there?
SPEAKER_00I don't remember specifically what the ideas were, but I remember there's a couple of cases, and I know we've actually cited it in the Mnet piece, but I can't off the top of my head say what the question was, but where he would publish a paper and then come back later and say, I was wrong about that. And so to me, the lesson is not so much what he was wrong about, it's that his approach to science was one where It was not about the ego of getting it right and having like my paper was the one that said the right thing. It's just the curiosity to get it right and to acknowledge that we all make mistakes.
SPEAKER_00Right. And again, like this is to me how science should be done.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. I think that's a really such an important message to get across. Yeah, and I think along those lines, I'm feeling really motivated to go back and read Bob's ecology textbook because I think that was the ecology book that I had as an undergrad and it was extremely influential in getting me interested in studying ecology.
SPEAKER_03And I feel like if I go back and read it now, I might get a better appreciation for Bob's worldview and these connections that I probably completely missed, you know, when I read it as a naive undergrad.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Which one was that, Cam? Because he did write two, right?
SPEAKER_03Well, it was the one that had the, I mean, it's the striking Rousseau.
SPEAKER_02The Economy of Nature, right? The original ecology one.
SPEAKER_01The sole cover is Economy of Nature.
SPEAKER_03Oh, it is. Okay. Let me see. Hold on a second.
SPEAKER_01He's going to look for it.
SPEAKER_03I lost the cover for this. So I don't know. Which one is this?
SPEAKER_01First one. Yes. Ecology.
SPEAKER_03This is the first one. Okay. This is the second edition. Yeah. Because this one was 1979 was the edition. So it's a bit kind of dated now.
SPEAKER_01We got royalties for years and years and years. I think my apartment here is bought on the royalties of that book.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. I heard the book came out of his basically preparation for his PhD comprehensive exam, that he wrote all of these notes to prepare for his exam. And they were so thorough that other people asked him if they could borrow his notes. And then he said, well, you know, maybe I should just package this and put it into and make it into a book. I read that same story.
SPEAKER_00There's an interesting story about the textbook that came out by email from one of the former students, which is that, you know, he had a copy in his car and he was driving across the country. He was in Colorado and he stopped at an overlook and, you know, got out of the car, he's looking around. Somebody came and rear-ended him. Push the car off the cliff, right? And the car had a copy, you know, this is like 1972 or something. So the car had a copy of the manuscript in it before it was published. And this is the only copy. And so Bob scrambles down the cliff, much more worried about the manuscript than the car, right?
SPEAKER_00And comes back up, you know, with the manuscript.
SPEAKER_01It's very plausible. He was a good salesman. He was definitely interested in publishing. He really was. He wrote a guide to the exits from the highway, which I have, okay? The exits from the highway, because oftentimes he would drive to visit his parents in Monterey, California from Penn, right? Across the country. And at that time, there was no easy, I mean, you had to get off the highway to get gas and food, right? And he published, it didn't make much money. I have copies of this thing, exits from the highway.
SPEAKER_02So he wrote, I mean, The Economy of Nature, like you say, is the shorter version of the ecology book, but the ecology was published in the 70s. Did he ever talk about writing? Why didn't he write sort of a brand new modern ecology book?
SPEAKER_01Ah, and they even wanted him to do that. I think it was too late in his life.
SPEAKER_02I would like to hear Suzanne, you know, I guess maybe this is a crazy question, but what would Bob think about the opportunities with artificial intelligence now? The opportunities or the frustrations, the challenges, you know, pick your descriptor, but how would he see that?
SPEAKER_01Large data sets was a major issue for him. The North American tree distributions in Canada, he worked on this with various collaborators at University of Missouri St. Louis, Bob Marquess and John Lill. So to get large data sets also on bird life history, which he had these data sets, which he tried to analyze with Scheuerlein, he was a German collaborator. To use artificial intelligence to analyze large data sets, it would have been wonderful for him because he was interested in large data sets.
SPEAKER_01He was. And he even deposited some of these data in the appropriate depositories late in life. I mean, he had a life history of God knows how many bird species.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Well, that's a good intro to my kind of one of the last questions I wanted to ask is, you know, one of my interests when I started graduate school was why Temperate and tropical bird species had different life histories. And this is where Bob's thinking was so important. And so I'm curious, again, Alan, if you had to articulate Bob's perspective on how he saw,
SPEAKER_03what were the reasons that he viewed temperate and tropical bird species as having these different life histories? And how that fit into his interconnected view of things.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm not sure that he ever published a summary view of that. And so all I can say is that what I believe, and after having had a lot of conversations with him, and so I don't want to fully attribute this as his view, but I think it's my view probably heavily influenced by him. And I think what I would say is that there are many factors. And if you look at tropical birds, they don't all have long life histories. Some of them do, right?
SPEAKER_00And if you look at temperate birds, most temperate birds either have to deal with winter or migration. And these are hard things to survive. They are hard things to deal with physiologically. And this probably puts some constraints on the life histories in ways that make it much harder to evolve a very slow, long life history. Tropical birds will have the full range of options. Temperate birds don't as much.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. And I think that largely squares with how I view things as well. So that, I guess, yeah, shaped by a lot of that same thinking.
SPEAKER_02Well, this is a similar kind of question. In the Memorial in MNAT, you all write that Bob's most general contribution was Was to show how almost any phenomenon in ecology or evolution is shaped by a wide array of factors not always considered. We've talked about parasites. We've talked about evolutionary history shaping ecological communities. I mean, that concept is inspiring and, I mean, just beautiful. Why? I mean, where does that kind of come from? We keep alluding to this curiosity, but why keep looking for the other?
SPEAKER_02Why, when he sits in the front of the seminars and hears a question, why take something into another direction? I mean, how does that come to be?
SPEAKER_01Part of it is his contrarian. Part of it comes out as a young man having experienced what he experienced and wanting to establish himself. I know this goes against this view that Bob is this sweet, nice, positive man he is, but he also was ambitious and he wanted to be seen as having contributed importantly.
SPEAKER_02Well, the way that we've talked about the contrarianism, I mean, I sort of see that as the quintessential scientist where, like Alan, you referred to the multiple times that Bob writes to journals and says, look, I got that wrong. Because it's not about being first or best. It's about just progressing the ideas. So I don't know. I think that might be indirectly one of the biggest lessons that I took from what I read from Bob and my conversations with him is that And contrarianism is kind of the fuel of how science progresses.
SPEAKER_02And it doesn't have to be at the expense of the other scientists. But if you're not coming in and innovating and asking about how these disciplines contribute to mine, I mean, it just sort of things get all gummed up and progress might not happen.
SPEAKER_00And curiosity and clarity of thought, like if you put those two things together, then you often end up with like, oh, could we see it this other way? And then you get to what looks contrarian, but it's not necessarily coming out of a place of I'd like to be contrarian. It's coming out of a place of like, and possibly the ambition could be part of that too. Like I see how I can make a unique contribution here, right? By seeing something differently.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I think to reach his level of stature may not be possible without some degree of ambition. But I think also, just to kind of follow up on your point, Alan, that it's one thing to be contrarian. But just for the sake of being so. But it's another to really come at it from the perspective of trying to make things better and be constructive. It's not just to tear things down, but it's to build something that is better.
SPEAKER_03And maybe there's ambition in that your views you think are correct. And you're trying to share them or at least reconcile how your perspective could influence somebody else's. But obviously he was open to changing his own views as well. So he never got stuck into a single lane.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Would he go for science today if he was starting as an assistant professor, given, Alan, what you've been alluding to about what it means to be an assistant professor in the US these days? Would he do this? And if not, what would he do?
SPEAKER_00My take on it is that he would not sweat the fact that the system is imperfect. He would just follow his curiosity and Do what needed to be done to do the science he wanted to do. I don't think he could have done anything else. I think his natural curiosity and interest would have pushed him into science no matter what. I don't necessarily think he would If you were to put the question to him, should we have the kind of graduate supervision systems we do now where it's not
SPEAKER_00as much sink or swim, I think he probably would have argued if you asked him directly for the way that he did it, but I don't think he would have spent his energy fighting that.
SPEAKER_03So, you know, we've talked a lot about Bob's curiosity and, you know, his vast knowledge of, you know, avian life histories and natural history. But so was Bob as a child, I mean, you mentioned that he was the headmaster's son, but was he a naturalist from an early age?
SPEAKER_01Yes, he often told me that he would escape into the woods also to be alone, probably away from his father and mother. Mother was also a teacher at that same private school and would study the birds there, the local birds in Monterey. Absolutely. He was apparently interested in birds like from when he was 10 or 12. And he knew every bird, every bird that occurs there.
SPEAKER_00Most of the birds in the world, too. We alluded to it, but he had this whole room at the University of Missouri St. Louis that was his personal library of bird books. It was immense.
SPEAKER_03And he'd read them all.
SPEAKER_02Well, this has really been a lot of fun. We always want to sort of make sure that we give you space to talk about things that we haven't prompted you for, especially here because there's so many personal stories and just Bob as a human instead of just as a scientist. So is there anything else that you wanted to make sure to leave listeners with?
SPEAKER_00From my end, there's one other thing I'd like to share, which I know was not just in my case. I know many other students had similar experiences. When I first arrived, I wanted to work on aging, and Bob sat down with me and said, why don't you look at this whole evolution of menopause thing? I think there's something to do there, right? And this was not a question I'd really considered. The grandmother hypothesis was out there. And I spent the first couple years of my PhD working on a subject that was not part of my dissertation. It was just a side project that he'd kind of launched with this question.
SPEAKER_00And to this day, it's one of the papers that I'm most fond of, where basically I make the argument that most mammals have something approaching a post-reproductive lifespan in the females, and that therefore the physiology of post-reproductive lifespan is general in mammals, even if the length of that is, let's say, much longer in humans and a few whale species and so forth. So that whole project and that paper, which means a lot to me, I wrote it all up and it came from the question that he asked. And I think he had some intuition of where I was going to get with it,
SPEAKER_00but he never really told me that. And his red markings were on many drafts of this paper and he helped me shape it. This is my first time writing a paper. And then I came to him when I was about ready to submit and I said, so authorship, I'll be first author, you'll be second author. How do we do this? Oh, no, no, no. You publish that alone. And he was not an author on that paper. And, you know, he fully deserved it, but he was not an author on that paper. And I didn't know, you know, enough to say, to insist, right?
SPEAKER_01I could add, and I'm not going to be specific here. I could add several highly cited papers where he should have been an author. And he stepped back. I really could be specific here. Incredible. Very generous. Yes.
SPEAKER_03Well, I think in the AMNAAP piece, you mentioned that despite his extremely impressive sort of list of publications, in many ways, it's sort of like a shadow CV and that it should be a much longer list, but he chose not to be a co-author on so many papers.
SPEAKER_01Yes. And also that he reviewed because his reviews were also super insightful.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I would imagine. Not necessarily the person you'd want as your reviewer.
SPEAKER_02It's going to be a lot of work afterwards for sure. Yeah. Well, Suzanne and Alan, we really appreciate this. It's been great to get to know more about Bob, especially as a person. Like we said, his science has influenced us a ton and a lot of the community. It's a huge loss, but what an incredible inspiration. And it's great that we get to talk about this for the next generation of graduate students and such.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. I feel like, you know, if Bob's ambition was to make a difference and be noticed and be regarded, you know, his legacy will live on, I think, you know, for many generations. So yeah, thank you for taking time to talk to us.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. You were so well prepared, both of you. Incredible.
SPEAKER_00It means a lot to have this chance to go over his legacy. And I think it's really important to do this. So I really appreciate this opportunity.
SPEAKER_02Thanks for listening to this episode. If you like what you hear, let us know via Blue Sky, Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, or leave a review wherever you get your podcasts. And if you don't like something, let us know that too. All feedback is good feedback.
SPEAKER_03Thanks to Steve Lane, who manages the website, and Molly McGidd for producing the episode.
SPEAKER_02Thanks also to Carolyn Merriman and Cass Biles for help with social media, Brianna Longo, who produces our awesome cover images, and Clayton Klauskow, who blogs about topics covered in the main show. Check out his work on our Substack page.
SPEAKER_03And thank you to our Substack and Patreon subscribers and the National Science Foundation for support.
SPEAKER_02Music on the episode is from Pottington Bear and Taryn Costello.
Why do we age? What can long-lived animals teach us about healthy aging? Can treatments extend life without costly trade-offs? In this episode, we talk with Steve Austad, a distinguished professor and chair in the...
How can organismal choices drive adaptive evolution? Can plasticity act as a kind of selection? In this episode, we talk with Pim Edelaar, a professor in the Department of Molecular Biology and Biochemical Engineering...
How do you find an invasive species that no net can catch? What happens to the scientist whose research samples end up in federal court? In this episode, we talk with David Lodge, a freshwater ecologist at Cornell...
How have flowers shaped the modern world? Why do we and many other species have such intimate and long-term relationships with them? On this special episode, we talk with David George Haskell, a writer and biologist. We...
When a bee visits a flower, what decides the match? How can a neutral model explain community assemblages? Why are long-term ecological studies so important? In this episode, we talk with Diego Vázquez, a community...