"You just cannot comprehend that." These words from Angie Smith barely scratch the surface of the unfathomable tragedy that befell her family during COVID lockdown in 2021. What begins as the story of an "average mom and nan" quickly unfolds into one of the most devastating accounts of domestic violence in recent UK history. When Angie's daughter Terri ended a 14-year relationship just before national lockdown, she turned to online dating for connection. The man she met, initially charming but quickly controlling, moved into her home with alarming speed. Isolated by COVID restrictions, Terri's contact with her mother dwindled as red flags multiplied. Angie recalls the moment that sent chills down her spine - her daughter's new boyfriend wrapping Terri in his dressing gown, tying the belt around her, and declaring "she's not coming out with you, she's staying with me." In September 2021, Angie learned through social media about police activity on her daughter's street. What followed was every parent's worst nightmare - the discovery that her daughter, two grandchildren, and their friend had been brutally murdered. The killer's calculated actions afterward - staying in the home overnight, watching TV among the bodies, even calling a taxi to sell her grandson's Xbox for drug money - reveal a level of depravity that defies comprehension. Angie recounts the painful aftermath: identifying unrecognizable bodies, learning her daughter was pregnant, enduring court proceedings where the killer attempted to evade responsibility, and ultimately witnessing him receive four life sentences. "He's got the life sentence, but so have we," Angie observes, noting how the trauma continues years later as new headlines about the perpetrator's prison violence emerge. This powerful testimony serves as both a memorial to Terri, John, Lacey, and their friend, and a crucial warning about recognizing early signs of controlling behavior. Listen to part one of this two-part conversation to understand the devastating reality of domestic violence, then join us next week to hear how Angie transformed her grief into activism that have already saved other families from similar tragedy. View Angie's 1in3 profile here: https://www.beyondthestatisticspodcast.com/guests/angela-smith/ This podcast is intended for mature audiences. Some listeners may find the content distressing as episodes may include discussions of violence, human trafficking, and other forms of abuse, including emotional, psychological, sexual, financial, and physical. In many cases, names have been changed to protect those involved. Please note that the statements and opinions expressed by guests do not necessarily reflect my own. Support the show If you are in the United States and need immediate support, contact the National Domestic Violence Hotline by calling 800-799-SAFE (7233) or texting START to 88788. If you're outside the United States, crisis resources are available at BeyondTheStatisticsPodcast.com/GetHelp. Connect with Beyond the Statistics: 🌐 Website: https://www.BeyondTheStatisticsPodcast.com 💜 Join the Beyond the Statistics Community: https://www.patreon.com/BeyondTheStatisticsPodcast 📧 Email: BeyondTheStatisticsPodcast@gmail.com 📱 Follow on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, and X: @BeyondStatsPod If today’s conversation meant something to you, subscribe, leave a review, and share this episode. And if you’d like to continue the conversation beyond the episode, I’d love to have you join us in the Beyond the Statistics Community. Every story shared helps another survivor know they are not alone. Music: Tim Crowe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hi, angie, thank you for joining me today on One in Three. How are you doing? Yeah, okay, thank you, okay. So we are actually planning on recording two episodes with you, and the first one you're gracious enough to talk about why you're here, what circumstances led you to where you are. So, if you don't mind, go ahead and introduce yourself and give a little bit of background.
Speaker 2Yeah, I'm Angie Smith. I'm from Derbyshire, south Yorkshire in the UK. I'm just an average mom, an average nan, an average everyday person. Really, really, yeah, but unfortunately.
Speaker 1Yeah, I've got a tragic tale to tell. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And these tragic tales they happen to average everyday moms and nans which is a grandma here? But do you want to go ahead and tell a bit of that tragic tale that brought you to where you are today?
Speaker 2Well, it was my daughter. She had a long-term relationship, 14 years. She had a son, john. A couple of years later Lacey came along, her daughter and you know. They was quite an happy, loving family. Her kids meant the world to her. And then her and her long-term partner, they broke up and we was about to go into national lockdown in the UK.
Speaker 2Um, and that was pretty hard for her. Um, you know where she'd had this long-term relationship and she came out of it and then she were there on her own. So she started. She joined a dating website and she matched with a man called Damien Bendel. Things progressed really quickly too quickly for my liking and I wasn't allowed to see her because we were in national lockdown.
Speaker 2So everything was done on FaceTime, telephone, which was really hard because we'd see quite a lot of one another. She told me over FaceTime that she'd met this guy and he was coming up for the weekend, which then I questioned, because we were all in national lockdown and he lived quite about two hours away from where we actually live in Derbyshire.
Speaker 2The children were staying with their dad up that weekend and he came down. I told her to keep in touch with me. I wanted to know how it was progressing because you know, we never really knew this guy. She did. After the weekend he went home. He then came back the following weekend. Then we were starting to come out of a little bit of a lockdown so we could see I think it was five other people from our households.
Speaker 2Then we were starting to come out of a little bit of a lockdown, so we could see I think it was five other people from our households. I went to meet him at her house, I'd say the first couple of hours he seemed quite charming and I was thinking, oh, maybe she really has got something here. Um, and then after that it just went really downhill the conversation. Um, he'd mentioned that he I was talking about my family dog that I had to have put to sleep because he was quite ill and how much the vet's bills were.
Speaker 2And he told me his friend had a dog and he couldn't afford the vet's bills. So he hit it over the head with an aspirin. That was my wall wall. No, no, no. I'd had the conversation with Terry and said I I'm not sure about him and she said it was all like front provado. He likes to play the big man, the and I wasn't.
Speaker 2Then I was really on my guard with him. Um, and then again it was the national lockdown again. We kept going in and out of lockdowns and you know how it went all over the world, um, and then, next thing, I know, every time I rang he were always there. You could hear him in the background. She was less where we'd facetime. A couple of times a day I would chat over the phone. That all stopped, um, and then we was out again for a little while.
Speaker 2When I went back round and I was going out and asked her if she wanted to come with me and he had a dressing gown on and he wrapped her in the dressing gown, tied the belt around her and said no, she's not coming out with you, she's staying with me. All these shocking little things. And I'd said to her why is he always here? You know, why has he not gone home? And she was like he's just not gone home anymore.
Speaker 2Mum and I said well, this is a bit too soon for my liking, um, and then, as I said, contact became less and less. Until then I was really quite concerned for her. Um, I saw a program which was about Claire's Law, which is a disclosure scheme in the UK, and I downloaded the form to fill that in to see if I could find out his criminal background.
Speaker 2It was very difficult to do and it wouldn't have gone to me. It would very difficult to do and it wouldn't have gone to me. It would have gone to her and knowing he was always there, I didn't think that was the right thing to do, so I stopped it. So therefore I didn't find out which criminal background were. Time went on and on and there was a few little things were coming out about him and I said to her I don't like what I'm hearing.
Speaker 2He's been in prison before. He had a drug habit and she'd said, yeah, but he's changed now. Mum, you know he loves me, he loves the children. He's never had anybody to change for and so he's changed for me. She started to ask me to borrow money all the time and that was another big concern because she wasn't like that. It was sort of every other day and it was a certain amount of money late into the night and I just said, just said, no, I'm not doing this, because this money's not for you, it's for him.
Speaker 2Um, he were quiet. He'd come down to me and said you've got me all wrong. And so therefore, it was like I don't know, I'm gonna have to try to get on with this guy because otherwise, if I don't, I'm going to lose her. And so I tried my best to get on with him. And then on the morning of Sunday, the 19th of September 2021, I was quite busy throughout the day and hadn't heard from her or the children, and so we'd seen on a local Facebook page of our community, our little village, that something really bad had happened in Killamarsh.
Speaker 2It's a little village we live in and there was a lot of police presence. And it got to about 3 o'clock and I just thought I haven't heard from her today. So I rang, it went into voicemail. I rang again, it went into voicemail. I tried texting her Nothing. I tried texting her nothing. So then my husband had said oh, it's just come up over the Facebook page that whatever has happened today has gone off on your Terry Street.
Speaker 2And I said right, I've got this really bad feeling. We need to go down. And I went down and what met me was a sea of police. The road was cordoned off. I jumped out the car, I ran to the policeman and said what's happened? That is my daughter's house, please, I need to get down there. And he said no, no, no, no, you can't, you can't, you need to get back in the car. We'll take your name and address and we'll send officers out to you, which, within 10 minutes of me arriving home, they came out.
Speaker 2I don't remember much really about that day. They proceeded to go on and said they'd found a body and we think that this may be your daughter. And I remember saying no, no, no, you've got this wrong. This can't be no. And then they went on to say and then there was another body, and then another. And then they reckoned that there was someone staying over for a sleepover, which I knew was my granddaughter's little friend because she's always sleeping over, and I called out her name and said oh no, not her as well.
Speaker 2And I just said he did this, didn't he? I just knew, I knew it was him. I was waiting to find out who our parents were, because Damien Bendel had smashed her phone and they couldn't find anything. Obviously, they couldn't get into her phone to find out any phone numbers. So that was, yeah, it just went absolutely crazy.
Speaker 2As soon as they'd contacted us. Then they released it on every TV programme. Who she were. I mean sitting there on that Sunday night watching the news and watching my daughter, my grandchildren, all come up on the news. It was just unreal. It didn't seem to. It was like I was asleep and I was in some kind of nightmare and I've got to wake up from this. Our village it was a big part of it.
Speaker 2There were so many tributes left flowers, teddy bears, candles. People are utterly shocked and yeah it, it was hard. Um, I don't know how I mean people say to me how do you keep going? I keep going now because of what I do. Um, the first couple of weeks I just didn't. I think it was just a case of getting up in the morning and trying to focus what I had to do.
Speaker 2Um, because about four days after we had to go and identify her, which was I can't even describe what that was like. It was behind her face, she was beyond recognition and also she had the defence wounds on her hands, so she'd fought for her life.
Speaker 2A few days after that, we actually went to see my granddaughter and my grandson. They were in the same room. Same applies to what he did to them. I can remember standing in the middle of them both and I could hear this screaming, and I didn't know who this screaming was, and then I realised it was me and I fell to my knees. My husband picked me up and said we need to go.
Speaker 2This is not good for you. Yeah, so that was you know, I'm a man, and I mean. They fought for their lives as well. Children he was quite'm a man and I mean they fought for their lives as well. Children he was quite a big man. Used to do cage fighting, so they never stood a chance and then it went. And I just think every week there was something different. And they said that obviously she was eight weeks pregnant with his baby and decided to tell the police it wasn't his baby.
Speaker 2So then we had the task of having to have the baby taken out of her to have a DNA test, and then we had the task of saying whether we had the baby put back in Terry or whether we'd give that baby a funeral. And first of all I'd said no, I don't want any of think of ease near my daughter.
Speaker 2And then my husband had a word with me and said you know how much she loved children. Um, you know she should have the baby back with her. So that's what I decided. Um, and then it was you know, and I'm I can't say, I'm not comfortable, but it doesn't sit well with me, or I don't try to think about it. But then we found out that he'd also why, lazy as I die, and he then raped her at least twice.
Speaker 2What kind of man does that? How can you call him a man? I tried to not refer to him by name. If I speak about him now, I call him the monster. I'm just thinking. What they went through that night. They just don't bear thinking about it. It came out afterwards because we weren't told exactly how they died for a few weeks, and it came out that he'd killed them and he'd hit them at least nine times around the head with a claw hammer.
Speaker 2So, yeah, can you even? You just cannot comprehend that. It was just absolutely yeah, you just open every day that you'd wake up. Yeah, you just open every day that you'd wake up. The court, you know he decided, you know I killed them, but I didn't really kill them. You know I was.
Speaker 2You know I don't remember. You know the last thing I remember was sitting on the stairs, came to, went upstairs, seen my daughter and my missus dead no, I don't think that you did, because you went on to cover your own tracks. You smashed up a phone. You knew exactly what you were doing. He sat in court with us there. First couple of times he actually stared me out, actually turned around and looked at me and stared me out, which was really hard to keep a lid on things.
Speaker 2And then he went along the route that he said he was asked to give a plea. He went along the route. You know he's got a mass in his brain, so he wasn't that really guilty of killing him. It was this mass in his brain. And I'd said all along, I'd said to the police, our barrister, I'd said he's lying. So they'd done extensive brain tests on him which lasted near enough a year.
Speaker 2So his back was always to call all this time, listening to how he was suffering, which sometimes you don't even want to know. And then he stood up at one time and said you know, he's not guilty of murder, but he's guilty of manslaughter. And I wanted to jump home and shout out are you kidding us? You know, really. And so then it went.
Speaker 2It just kept going on and on and on. And then, in December 2022, we got a phone call from the police that said well, I've got another court date. Phone call from the police that said, well, I've got another court date. It was the 21st of December 2022. We went back into court and he pleaded guilty to all charges and then the judge had said he said he was sorry, you know he realised that he'd have to get a full life term, which is he will die in prison.
Speaker 2The judge gave him four life terms one for 15 years for ages of murders and a full life term for what he did to Lacey alone and a full life term for what he did to Lacey alone, he'd said, because Lacey were killed in the living room, my daughter were killed in her bedroom, my grandson was killed in the bathroom and my daughter's little friend was killed in my granddaughter's room. He'd said he'd carried Lacey, which is my granddaughter, upstairs to be with her mum, when all he did was carry her upstairs to do what he did to her.
Speaker 2Yeah, so he was sentenced to a full life order, which is very rare in this country. There's only about I think there's about 27 people in this country that's got a full life order. So he will die in prison and that's. You know, that's all we could have wished for. You know he'd never come out to be able to hurt anybody else again, and it's just he's still carrying on in prison.
Speaker 2I mean, you know, last year we got a telephone call from the National Preparation Service that said he's attacked an inmate in prison with a chlorammer. Unbelievable, why would you let someone like him in a workshop with a chlorammer? So now he's in the news again because he's up for attempted murder, though he cannot get anything else on his sentence.
Speaker 2So, yeah, everything just keeps coming and coming, even though now you know we're nearly four years on and you think that you're never going to hear about this person again, but he's still controlling everything. You know he's got the life sentence, but so have we got life sentence? He's never going away.
Speaker 1I'm kind of speechless. I mean, I'm familiar with the story, but to hear it from you is just so much more emotional, in a full range of emotions, and I absolutely would refer to him as the monster as well, because there's truly no other word. You could call him um. Had he, was he still there, or how did they arrest him?
Speaker 1Um?
Speaker 2what happened was yeah, that's a statistic from war over. Yeah, he'd, he'd stayed with them. Um, he did what he did to them. He stayed with them all night in the property, apart from one time he called a taxi. I don't know what you do call a taxi. Yeah, he called a taxi and he went and sold my grandson's xbox in the middle of the night to a drug dealer to get drugs.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's someone that didn't know what he was doing and he told the taxi driver. The taxi driver made a conversation with him and he said how's your weekend been? And he went. Yeah, bit of a mad one. I've been chilling with my family. He watched TV during the night while they were all laying there yeah, so that is.
Speaker 2And the next morning he went out. He was caught on CCTV, I think about 10 past 7 in the morning, buying cigarettes. He had blood all on his hands. And then he went back to the property and phoned his mum to say that he had stabbed himself with a bread knife. She had then called the police for a concern for him. She didn't know anything about what happened.
Speaker 2While she went phoning the police, he was on the phone to the police at the same time and then, basically, the telephone call goes to I need police and I need an ambulance because I've killed four people. And then the officers came out. He decided to tell them you know, I've cut myself so many centimetres in with a bread knife and the policeman says, all right, right, let me have a look.
Speaker 2Um. And then he says and the policeman says, oh well, nothing's going to happen to you now. And he went yeah, I'm going back to prison. So the policeman says um why, have you done anything to anyone else? And and he says, yeah, I've killed four of my family. I don't think the police actually believed him at that point. And why really would you? I don't think you would. The police went in.
Speaker 2I mean, the whole of the general public didn't see the footage. We saw the footage of when the policeman went in and he was quite utterly shocked. There was a female officer there. She was quite upset. He told her to leave because she was getting that upset. Yes, and the way he told the policeman I've just killed, it was like nothing. Oh, I've just killed, it was like nothing. You know, I've just killed four people. I'm going back to prison.
Speaker 2So they had to take him to the emergency department because he had. They were just like nothing. He just nicked himself. You know, he obviously didn't have the will with all to kill himself. So that's how he handed himself in. Yeah.
Speaker 1It's just a disgusting story. I mean, like you said, when you think it can't get any worse, then there's this other part of the story where he just proves that he is a monster. You mentioned Claire's Law, and I actually did do an episode in the past on Claire and I've explained what that was. But I think let's cut this episode here and then next week we'll go into what you're doing in terms of activism and then maybe we can discuss a little bit more of what Claire's Law entails, so that those who don't know will understand what you were attempting to do.
Speaker 1Okay, okay, all right.
Speaker 2Thank you.
Speaker 1Saying that was a tragic tale doesn't begin to do it justice. I'm truly honored and humbled that Angie shared her story with us. Even now, days later, as I edit this episode, I find myself at a loss for words. The ripple effect of such a senseless, despicable act is devastating. The heartbreak it leaves behind for the family, the loved ones, is immeasurable. As Angie so powerfully said, they're all serving a life sentence.
Speaker 1So, angie, thank you for joining me today and thank all of you for listening. You for joining me today and thank all of you for listening. I've included the link to Angie's one in three profile in the show notes. Angie and I will be back next week for part two, where she shares the incredible, tireless work she continues to do in honor of Terry, john and Lacey. Until then, stay strong and wherever you are in your journey, always remember you are not alone.
How do you learn to trust yourself again after emotional abuse? When you've spent years having your feelings dismissed, questioned, or minimized, even the simplest decisions can leave you second-guessing yourself. In...
Leaving an abusive relationship doesn't mean the abuse's impact ends. For many survivors, life after domestic violence brings new challenges: custody battles, financial struggles, emotional trauma, and the difficult...
Why do survivors of narcissistic abuse still feel unsafe long after leaving an abusive relationship? And can clinical hypnotherapy help the nervous system recover from trauma? Barbara Duchnowski, LCSW, joins Ingrid...
What happens when a military spouse experiencing domestic violence turns to the very systems meant to protect her - and those systems fail? Cynthya Pagan-Hale joins Ingrid Dutton on Beyond the Statistics to share her...
A relationship can look calm from the outside while quietly teaching you to ask permission for your own life. In this episode of Beyond the Statistics, Ingrid Dutton sits down with author Eva Levina to explore coercive...