A missing person poster looks simple until you realize it’s someone’s whole life frozen in a single photo. We talk with Renee Nelson, the voice behind Unsolved Wyoming, about why she chose to focus on unsolved cases and what changes when families are invited into the process instead of being treated like “content.” Renee shares how teaching true crime literature led her to compare books, documentaries, and podcasts, and how the spotlight from the Gabby Petito case pushed her to build a platform centered on Wyoming cold cases, missing persons, and unsolved homicides. We get into the parts of true crime people don’t always talk about: the emotional cost of living in heavy stories, the burnout that can sneak up fast, and the ethics of not retraumatizing loved ones. Renee explains her commitment to working only with families who want their stories told, and how that choice builds trust even if it slows down production. We also explore how rumors spread in small communities, how internet “detectives” can help or hurt, and why it’s so important to protect real people who are grieving. Then we go practical. Renee breaks down how reporting can get messy when “last seen” locations and jurisdiction don’t line up, why the 24-hour waiting rule is a myth, and how anonymous tips and updated technology can reopen doors that felt sealed for decades. She also shares behind-the-scenes details on recording, release schedules, and why spooky-season episodes give her a little room to breathe. If you care about ethical true crime, Wyoming history, missing persons awareness, or cold case investigation, hit play and share this conversation with someone who needs it. Subscribe, leave a review, and tell us in the comments: what do you think responsible true crime should always do?
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03Awesome. Are you ready? I am. Yes. Perfect. Okay. Welcome everybody to Beyond the Front Door Podcast with Lindy and Rhea. We are thrilled to have joining us today a fellow podcaster. Yay! Have we had that just one other time or two other times? Toby was one. And then everybody else. Anyway, uh Renee Nelson with Unsolved Wyoming. Thank you so much for joining us.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, thank you for having me. This is really exciting to be here. Yeah, it's fun to talk with other people that like to talk. Also, also that.
SPEAKER_01Also that's okay. So if you just yeah, what I'll I could do is go ahead. We're so yeah, why don't you just start by telling us a little bit about yourself, like how you got started, you know, anything personal you want to share in the paper? Whatever you did to get started with unsolved Wyoming.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, definitely. So I am from Cheyenne. I grew up here and uh, you know, so pretty much born and raised. We moved here when I was one, so I just say I'm I'm from Cheyenne. And so went to Central High School and actually did my two years at LCC and loved it so much. I was like, this is where I want to come back to. And so um went to UW, Go Pokes. Um, and then I took some time off and then decided that I wanted to go back and get my master's degree in English.
SPEAKER_02And I didn't know I was gonna love teaching, but I got a grad assistantship where I was teaching and I fell in love with teaching. And so when I was trying to think of where I wanted to be, I wanted to come back to Cheyenne and work for Laramie County Community College, soon to be Wyoming State College. And that's kind of where things started for the podcast. So we have this really cool opportunity where we get to teach a special topics class. And anyone who knows me well, I I say I'm your your sparkly weird friend.
SPEAKER_02And so because I I love the you know true crime, horror stories, you know, scary movies, all of that stuff, but I'm I'm really a happy person and I love rainbows and butterflies and and pink. And so, but when I had the opportunity to pick a class, I decided I was going to dive into true crime literature and specifically look at a case from the perspective of the book, the documentary, and the podcast, and how those three different mediums change maybe a listener, reader, or viewer's perspective of the case.
SPEAKER_02And it was actually 2019, I was teaching the true crime literature class and the Gappy Petito case broke. And obviously, with that, some really important information came forward about all of the missing and murdered indigenous people in in Wyoming, but more specifically, too, that we have a ton of missing person cases. And I don't I don't know how to say this without sounding a little out there, but as I'm having this conversation with my students and they're really emotional, you know, this is a big deal, and putting a spotlight on our on our state, you know, on our community.
SPEAKER_03The Gabby Petito story.
SPEAKER_02The Gabby Petito story, and and talking about it, I had this voice in my head, not not my own voice, but my voice saying you can start a podcast. And I was like, no, I can't. We're familiar with that voice. Yeah, I'm like, no, I won't. And so I had a six-month-old son and a barely two-year-old daughter. It's like, I do not have time to start a podcast. And then that next summer I started a podcast. So that's how that went. And so yeah, yeah, it was definitely not something I had, you know, in my life planned, but here we are.
SPEAKER_03That is a very interesting story. I I do have kind of an interest in true crime as well.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think a lot of people do, especially women, right?
SPEAKER_03We tend to I the only thing I'll say is that sometimes it can get dark. Oh, for sure.
SPEAKER_01Right. And so you have to take a break. So that's what I would think. And you said that. You said kind of like you're the sparkly, but you it's kind of like intriguing to look at that kind of stuff. But how do you um how do you like separate, you know what I mean? Like not get too into it or have you. Oh, definitely. Yeah. Like, you know how people just go down these rabbit holes and they can't get out. Right.
SPEAKER_02I definitely would say if I have a superpower, my superpower probably is being able to sit with people and listen to these really heavy stories. And I'm pretty comfortable in that arena, but that doesn't mean that I don't come away from it feeling like, you know, gosh, that was, yeah, that was hard, you know, or cry or, you know, have to put on bluey in the background, you know, to kind of come back down. And so because it it is tough. It's a, it's a, it's um, I always say it's weird to say, oh, you know, my podcast, you know, I have so much fun doing it because I don't necessarily have fun doing it, but I find enjoyment in the work.
SPEAKER_02And so because there's not really a lot of fun in in talking about it.
SPEAKER_01No, but you are doing something good. Yeah, definitely. Information out and sharing stories. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely.
SPEAKER_03I think the thing that the Gabby Potato case brought forward for me that I hadn't really articulated is how many really dead bodies are out there and people we just haven't found them. Oh, definitely. Right. Like they talked a lot. I remember that. Like they found several bodies when they were looking for Gabby Potito. Am I correct? I think that if I remember correctly, there was at least two more. Yes. And so you just don't know. That would be the, you know, um, and Wyoming is so vast, right? It would be impossible to know all the time if, you know, where somebody has died and be able to locate them, and then they're just out there.
SPEAKER_02Right. Well, what was it? The dating game killer, you know, he came through Wyoming and he had murdered somebody here in the state and you know, was, you know, charged with that. But I mean, where she was located, nobody would have ever found her. Nobody. And so, yeah, I think that's definitely an aspect of our our state that is has a little creepiness to it for sure.
SPEAKER_01They put it in Yellowstone. Like Yellowstone made me think about it even more. The TV show, you know? Yeah. Where they just were like dumping people over the edge. Oh, in the show Yellowstone. That's uh that's a real thing. Yeah, so then like so then you like watch that and you're like, that could be real. That's what I'm thinking. I mean, do we have a dead spot in Wyoming? We do.
SPEAKER_02Okay. We do. We actually have this really weird um territory or like area where there's like technically like nobody governs it. And so I mean, in theory, could be a dumping ground. And so it was really interesting. I had a producer call me about a year into podcasting, and they're like, Can you tell us more about this? I was like, Well, yes, I guess, but I'm like, for what we know, um, people have gone through there to look, they're not finding anything.
SPEAKER_02It does exist, it's this, you know, very strange area. But um, it was it was something where people all of a sudden Yellowstone got really popular and people were looking at Wyoming in this new interesting way. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03That's where they went and disposed of the body and then. Because as though you're not gonna probably still get charged with murder before they did.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Where do you want to go next?
SPEAKER_03Um so when we're talking about true crime, why did you choose to focus on unsolved cases?
SPEAKER_02So I decided to focus on unsolved cases specifically because we had we have a lot of cases that are going on 40 plus years of being unsolved. And, you know, so getting to the point where family members are starting to pass away. Um giving people a platform to share this pain, this share, you know, this personal tragedy that they have and to get the word back out there, I think is really important.
SPEAKER_02And so I I do things a little differently. I work specifically with families that want to be worked with. And so not everybody who has a missing loved one or an unsolved homicide, because I also cover unsolved homicides as well, wants to necessarily relive, you know, that and retell their story. Yeah. And I do think that is an issue with the true crime community and that difference between entertainment and real life, you know, and yeah, in real life.
SPEAKER_02It is family's lives, and how horrible would it be to be telling sharing somebody's story and then for them to tune in and it's their story, and they had no idea that this was going to happen. You're re-traumatizing that person, and I don't want to participate in that. So, you know, it does kind of put a damper on, you know, churning out content all the time. But at the same time, I know that the content I'm putting out is, you know, with the family involved or, you know, a friend that is involved that, you know, they want this case out there and they want that, you know, platform to be able to talk about their loved one.
SPEAKER_01It's a really good point. I'm glad you brought that up because I it's it's really interesting that you're here today because I don't schedule these, so I don't know who's coming on the podcast. I'm like, but it's today. Well, I kind of know once she puts it in the calendar, but I clicked on someone in Gillette this this week. It was someone missing, and they because I grew up there and it was probably it was around the time I was probably like, I think I'm like her age, so I was like, Oh, I don't remember this. And I was trying to kick click on the case, and then I didn't couldn't find like anything about it. I couldn't, I kept trying to search and I'm like, it seems like so long ago, but then you're saying I can see where a family would maybe just be like clo done, and maybe they've moved on.
SPEAKER_01Like that's a really long time, like 40 years. 30 years, it was a long time when I looked at it, and I was like, Oh, but you're right, people do family members start passing away, and then what happens? These people just are like forgotten. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_02It was the Amanda Gallian case. I think it was. Yeah, yeah, because I think her missing anniversary was just this past week. Yeah, that's kind of and I think it was 30 years. Yeah. And so that that's a huge amount of time.
SPEAKER_01So then I was looking to see if there was a Facebook page for her, or like you know how there's you can find and so you can find out more information. Are they still searching? What happened? I couldn't, I was like having a really hard time.
SPEAKER_03I'm like, that's so sad. It's a tough one. It really is. Well, and what makes it hard too is you know, we say all the time on this podcast that in Wyoming, we're just really one step removed from everybody. We you can probably find any Wyomingite on the street and find a connection to somebody else, you know, just by starting up the conversation. So I could see what you're saying in that if you have you do got to be really careful because everybody knows everybody. Yeah. You know, and you do want to make sure that um you're being safe for the family.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_02Definitely. Yeah, for and for myself too. Yeah. Definitely one or two cases that are a little too close to home that I haven't that I've stayed away from just because you you have certain information or you know, people tell you things and you know, you gotta stay safe. So yeah, definitely. I think that is a huge part. And Wyoming, as though is we're we're very big, we're also we're crazy, right? And we will drive three hours to go shopping, or right?
SPEAKER_02To to and so, you know, so it's one of those things distance doesn't necessarily matter for us. We're like road trip it is. Yeah. So yes.
SPEAKER_03Um, how do you decide which stories to cover? Like, well, you've I guess you've answered it in that they're unsolved stories and then families that want to tell their story. Are you searching them out or are they searching you out? Both.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, both. And so it's always really interesting when families reach out to me and you know are ready to go because sometimes that's not the case. And so other times, you know, uh I I'll go through social media. And so I specifically work with the group Missing People Wyoming, which is this amazing Facebook group that was started by Desiree Tonoko and is about 40,000 strong. And people will connect with her all the time, you know, and say, hey, we're looking for some media coverage.
SPEAKER_02Do you have anybody? And so she'll connect with me and then I'll connect with the family members that way. Or, you know, seeing a missing person poster, I'll do I do a series on social media called On This Day. And so I covered Amanda's case this week. And so, you know, just to put out the information, when was she last seen, how old she was, what did she look like, and then you know, where to submit tips. So rather calling the Gillette PD or Division of Criminal Investigation, and if people wish to remain anonymous, they can submit tips anonymously on DCI's website.
SPEAKER_02And so, but people will comment. And so sometimes you'll get family members who comment. And so then that I have an opening to reach out to them and say, hey, if you're ever filling up for it, I would love just to chat. And then usually when I can get them to chat, then I'll talk to them about potentially doing an episode and we'll then set up an episode for them and we'll do that. Very interesting.
SPEAKER_01Okay, we're gonna do a little segment called behind the scenes though. Oh, behind the stories. Okay, is there like a particular case that's really like stayed with you?
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah. I I would say all of them, honestly. Sure, sure. And so all of them definitely stay with me. And so, and having some really interesting stuff that has happened, right? So this past weekend, for example, I I got to go to the Wyoming Historical Society Awards luncheon. I was nominated for an award, which was very exciting.
SPEAKER_03Congratulations.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. And so, but that's where Amy Robectel went missing, right? And so I haven't covered her case personally, but I I know the case really well. And so traveling across Wyoming and you see these places where you know this is a family behind this case, it definitely will give you goosebumps. And so the but the one that I will always say, if you, especially right now with it being spooky season, if you want a really great listen, the case that sticks with me that I always think about because just it happened to be so awesome that all of us came together that the way that it did, is Kimberly K Novak.
SPEAKER_02And so she went missing and is is presumed dead. And her sister and her niece worked with me to do the case, and it's it's a really hard case to listen to. And but I'm sure you can remember back in you know the the 90s and the early 2000s, especially during Halloween, radio stations would have uh people call in to talk to a psychic, right? And so the sister just so happened to get on on Halloween, called in and talked to the psychic, and the psychic connected with Kimberley, and she has the recording.
SPEAKER_02And so she passed the recording on to me. And so that recording is part of the episode, and it will give you full body chills listening to especially legit. If it does, yeah, just the things that this woman says to um, I believe her, I can't remember her name off the top of my head, Rebecca. I think it's Rebecca, um, is just wild. Yes. And so highly recommend that episode. It's just one that is so different from all the others because of having access to that recording after all of these years was pretty phenomenal.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. That's um how many missing people are there or unsolved cases? I know that's probably two different answers.
SPEAKER_02There are. So yeah, technically, so cold cases are unsolved homicides, and then you have your missing persons. And so when you get after a certain amount of time, then that missing person, you know, they're all entered into DCI's database. And so the last I checked, we were over 80 in terms of the missing persons. And cold cases, we don't have quite an accurate number quite yet. There was legislation that was just passed recently that all of the uh law enforcement agencies in the state needed to submit their cool cases to Division of Criminal Investigation to be reported, and that's still in process.
SPEAKER_03Oh, very interesting.
SPEAKER_02And so I would say well over 20 in terms of the the uh unsolved homicides in the cool that cool case arena.
SPEAKER_03And what's the oldest one that you've looked at or aware of or that I'm aware of? Oh, what is her name?
SPEAKER_02I think it's Olga, and she I think like went missing in 1936, something crazy like that. And so that's a really interesting one. And I I should dig into that one. And so because she was on a honeymoon with her husband and they went hunting, oh and she didn't come back. Yeah, she still fishing back, right? Yeah, and so uh so I know who it was. It's always the husband, right?
SPEAKER_01Spoiler alert song. But where she is, I'm not sure. Right.
SPEAKER_02And so so yeah, I would say that's probably the most the oldest documented missing persons case that we have in the state, I believe, is 1930s area. The oldest that I have covered, I just covered uh Belinda Mae Grantham's case, and she is an unsolved homicide from the 80s, and so she's going on 45. She just it's her 45th anniversary of being an unsolved homicide.
SPEAKER_03So she was found, but it's unsolved. If they don't know who killed her, correct.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and so and that's a that's a really hard case to listen to. Um, I interviewed her sister and Belinda's best friend's daughter has been helping with this as well. And so she's been really instrumental in getting a Facebook up, getting, you know, information out there, people can you know connecting with her for information. And so she's connected with the Division of Criminal Investigation. And so I just released that case in September. And so the official statement is that DCI is working on some pretty legitimate leads.
SPEAKER_02And now because of technology advancing testing, they're retesting some of the items that they have in that case. So we could see that case solved soon, and that'd be pretty incredible.
SPEAKER_01That is awesome. That's where I that's where my next question was going, was gonna say, like, um, obviously you're doing like amazing work helping get the name these stories out so maybe they can be solved or found, or somebody have some kind of closure. But what um have you had any other cases where something big has happened that's changed it?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So I've had three cases that I have covered that actually remains have been found. And so Rocky Nahara, which was an incredible case, uh, where I, you know, did the original interview and then I had the opportunity to do a follow-up with the family about him, his remains being found. But that was a really fun one, you know, to obviously have a found situation because it was this woman in Canada where this is her hobby, where she just does genetic stuff on the side, and she saw Rocky's missing poster in a group, and she decided that she was going to start running some names, and she found his death certificate in Seattle, all the way out in the Washington area, and so then you know, was able to connect with the the family and then the police and you know close the case.
SPEAKER_03And close it essentially. She does like genealogy, yes, yes.
SPEAKER_02So yeah, great episode, right? Amazing episode. So highly recommend that one too. So Rocky Nahara is found, and then the uh the first part where it was missing, because that's what's really interesting about these cases is that, you know, when you know, originally listening to her story sounded, you know, like maybe there was some foul foul play involved. And so, but unfortunately, you know, Rocky died in a warehouse fire, and so you know, not what they were expecting and and across the country, and so nowhere near here.
SPEAKER_03So he went missing first, and well, yeah, I just went missing first, but then so my question Well, that's the hardest part.
SPEAKER_01We don't know why people are becoming missing. So someone goes missing and you don't know, did they want to purposefully missing? Yes, or are did someone just snatch you off the street in your life? Or did your spouse take you hunting and you didn't come back? Exactly. I think that's why we're intrigued by it. Also, because we want to know like, are people just getting snatched off the road? You know what I mean? But that's usually not the or are they trying to disappear, or are they just trying to disappear? And do people actually do that?
SPEAKER_02People really just disappear and never Yeah, it definitely, I definitely think there's an aspect to that, right? And so, and that's why it can be so hard. Wyoming is getting better and Wyoming. We and does you know, Desiree Tinoko, who I mentioned from The Missing People of Wyoming, one of the amazing things that she has done, she's helped get you know DCI's database streamlined, but also you know, seeing some issues too. So Gabby Petito, going back to her, she's a great example as to what was kind of flawed with the system in the first place.
SPEAKER_02So Gabby was last seen in Wyoming. However, she lived in Florida and her parents were in New York, right? And so it was this crazy trifecta.
SPEAKER_01And they were traveling, so exactly. And so in some places.
SPEAKER_02Wyoming said that she had to be reported missing in Florida.
unknownOh, it just points at it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. That's so that doesn't make any sense. And so now with the current legislation, it doesn't matter if you're a Wyoming resident or if you are visiting Wyoming, if you are a last scene in Wyoming, and they have to take your your um This it's so weird you're bringing this up.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay, so my husband's a police officer. He doesn't listen to this, and I don't know if any other police officers. Anyways, there was something with a person missing recently and or supposedly missing, or they were thinking the person was missing, but they didn't go missing from here. And they were trying to report it here because that's where they were from. And he was like, They're not missing you. We need to call where they were, where where was the person? Right. I think that's probably maybe like a question, you know what I mean? Like you're saying it went the other way. So maybe there is a confusion with the system and how that how you report it and where you report it.
SPEAKER_01Why can't you report it everywhere? Right. Can't you report it everywhere?
SPEAKER_02Well, and that's the jurisdiction issues, right? That's why last week I with my with my day job, and so I hosted a miss not a missing persons, um, indigenous persons panel, right? And so we had some incredible folks who are working within, you know, the systems come and talk about the issues that are facing, you know, missing murdered indigenous people and specifically the jurisdiction issue, right? And so if if they go missing on the reservation versus if they go if but they live on the reservation and they go missing outside of the reservation or are harmed outside of the reservation and who harms them and what's their jurisdiction.
SPEAKER_02And so it becomes so incredibly complicated and messy, right? And that's problematic because then you have a delay of justice, slow it down, yeah, and reporting and and investigation, and because it's basically who does it belong to.
SPEAKER_01Well, and it just looks like nobody wants to take the liability telling you it's yours.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And so same thing with the missing person's issue. And so is depending on where do they go missing or were they last seen, that's probably where it should be. And then hopefully they would communicate then to their home, you know, base or whatever and say, hey.
SPEAKER_01Well, and that's what I was thinking. Then they went and looked, like in this case, they went and looked at his house. He's not there, like where he okay, well, then he didn't come back. Right. Right. But he didn't l go missing from that place.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. And and that's the issue.
SPEAKER_01You don't want him looking somewhere in Florida for the Abbey when she wasn't in Florida.
SPEAKER_02Like, clearly. And and that's the thing, is that it's not a crime to go missing as an adult, right? If you want to disappear, you have every right to disappear. However, it's the concern when it is out of character, you know, and out of behavior. And and then the other problem along with this, too, is and this and a lot of the reason why I decided to start the podcast is that you have people who maybe have addiction issues, um, you know, history of doing certain work that can be high risk, uh, mental health issues.
SPEAKER_02And so, and maybe they have a a pattern of disappearing for periods of time. And so then maybe then the report isn't taken as seriously as it should be. And so, and that can cause some issues as well when maybe we should be looking for people within the first 24 to 48 hours and and we don't like I don't know.
SPEAKER_01My husband always when we watch TV shows and it's always like you can't report them till they're missing for 24 hours, he's always like, That is not true. It's not true, that's not true, and people really think that, and that's really sad because if you wait 24 hours, then that's a lot of time has passed, especially with younger people.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, oh yes, absolutely. Yes, and so yes, 24 hours is not a real thing. If if somebody is, you know, legitimately missing, you know, you should report them as soon as you feel something is is off and or wrong.
SPEAKER_03Um in the time that you've been studying this and doing the podcast, is there any patterns that have arisen for you?
SPEAKER_02Ooh, that's a good question.
SPEAKER_03I'm putting you on the spot. Yes, I love patterns.
SPEAKER_02Yes and no. And I would say probably every missing person's case is unique and so really unique circumstances. However, I would say, and it depends on the year. I would say if we're looking 20 plus a year ago, years ago, you see an interesting pattern with law enforcement.
SPEAKER_04Okay.
SPEAKER_02I would say now law enforcement has changed so much and they're much more responsive and are more educated and aware that you see a lot more and technology with that. Absolutely. And they're they're so vested in, you know, getting people home and and closing these cases that you know they're using social media and they're using all of those resources as well. And so, you know, I'll share flyers all the time, and half the I would say 50% of the time they're coming from the law enforcement agency's social media page.
SPEAKER_02And so they see the value in that. So I would say 20 years ago plus, absolutely you would see a pattern within how the case was handled, but now I would say it's very different.
SPEAKER_03Would you say more women than men or more men than women? Is that or is it pretty equal, or do you know?
SPEAKER_02No, that's a good question. I don't think I've ever, because I would say a lot of my missing cases that I've covered are men, honestly.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think I would have thought that it would be women. Maybe because we are women, we're paying more attention to the city.
SPEAKER_02No, absolutely. And we're a little more cautious, maybe.
SPEAKER_01Why did that why did she disappear?
SPEAKER_02Why no? That's why we literally watch true crime. Women watch true crime substantially more. So my husband hates true crime. He he he he hates that I do this podcast. He's super supportive. And so he'll he's my number one cheerleader, but he does not listen to the episodes unless I tell him specifically to listen to a certain part or anything like that, because he does not want this living in his head. And so, but what's really interesting is that they are consuming true crime, they're just consuming different genres of true crime, and so you know, like anything gang-related or cartel or anything like that, that's considered true.
SPEAKER_03Exactly, exactly.
SPEAKER_02And so, or or anything with like war or POWs, or uh we watch the Untold series on Netflix, which is sports, but it tends to have a true crime flair to it. And he's like, it's not true crime, it's sports. I'm like, Okay, okay. And so, but you know, women specifically look at true crime almost as an educational resource. What did they miss? What's the red flags that I should avoid? And you know, and then how would I get out of the situation?
SPEAKER_02And so we absolutely do consume true crime for those reasons. And so, but if I'm yeah, if I would look at my my list of individuals that I have covered, I would say most of them are probably men.
SPEAKER_01A lot of them are men. Well, and that's hard because we just think like women would become missing because somebody would take them or be able to take them or yeah, you know, do something to them. But when men disappear like that, um like um oh god, his name was just in my head. Um, I'll think of it. But you wonder, you're like, who's taking men? Like who's grabbing a big old giant guy and taking him down the road? Or I don't know, you know what I mean? Why are they definitely, definitely?
SPEAKER_01Well, and chance. Oh, chance Inglebert. Yes, yeah, yeah. And that's an interesting one. Like when that happened, that one that is an interesting one. But you know what I mean? You like start to think like, and maybe that's why we go towards like someone they know has to have done it, because how would they do this? And do you think that most people assume it's somebody that they know, or is it about half and half, or it's just like you said, all unique?
SPEAKER_02Right. So thinking of the cases that that I have covered, it's usually my my gut is is that it's somebody that they that they know. And so, for example, um John Hammond, I think it was George John Hammond is his name, and his remains have been found. And so, but and they have uh closed the case and said that he succumbed to the elements. He went camping with his buddies in November, right?
SPEAKER_02Interesting time to go camping, you know. And so hunting.
SPEAKER_03I mean you could if you call it hunting, yeah. Exactly.
SPEAKER_02And he who wandered off, allegedly, and they the the the story that they gave the sister was well, we thought he got in that truck, and they thought he got into my truck, and then when we got home, he just wasn't with us. Hmm. And then didn't say anything for five days, you know, so just kind of a strange situation when you're what happened, what something happened, right? And so, you know, so I would say a lot of the male cases that I cover most of the time have some element of they were with somebody else, you know.
SPEAKER_01Um like willingly with them at least. Yeah, to you know, and and they're you know, somebody I don't know if that makes us feel better or not to know it's somebody you know or some random person, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02Like yeah, a random act of violence, right? And so most of the time I would say just just like women, it's most likely going to be for a male, somebody that they are with, and you know, who knows that they were drinking, who knows, you know, what something got out of transpired, but yeah, typically it it it's definitely a situation where and I never saw them again, and it's you were the you were the last person to see them, and so yeah, just super interesting.
SPEAKER_03That would feel very frustrating, incredibly frustrating, yeah.
SPEAKER_02And in and I know it is for uh his sister, and so who I you know kept in contact with quite a bit afterwards, and so you know, to hopefully do a found kind of portion, but I think she's just so frustrated that there's no real resolution outside of that. Now she knows or she has her brother's remains, but what happens.
SPEAKER_03No, and that's a hard one. And so many people, I mean, rumors start to spread everywhere, and people think it's fishy or that you know the remains were planted, or you know, and I I don't remember all of it with that particular case, but I do think those sorts of things happen where the rumor meal starts to grow large and you don't really know exactly where the facts are.
SPEAKER_02Right. Well, and that's a that's a that's an intense one because the rumor meal tends to focus obviously on Bailey. And, you know, she won't do interviews, she gets death threats all the time. And so, which is incredibly unfortunate because here's a person who, you know, was not around chance when this happened. She was she, you know, was accounted for, but you know, is raising their son and you know, is trying. I I just it's just really unfortunate where sometimes the rumor mill will go, you know, and so not remembering that this is a whole real person on the other end and this was her her husband, this was the father of her child, and you know, not allowing her to be able to grieve in peace, I think is just really tragic.
SPEAKER_02And so death threats.
SPEAKER_03I never understand why people like even this week and even now when there's trending stories or things happening online, and all of a sudden, for example, the story with um Kelly Clarkson and the art store. The art store is getting death threats from Kelly Clarkson fans. Really? Because you care this much about the fact that she got denied to purchasing a bird. Yeah, like I can't, like, what is it with that? Yeah, you know, and all across the spectrum that that happens.
SPEAKER_01Well, because it's so easy because of social media and the internet, we can just they can do it and hide behind everything. Exactly. Exactly. But also, social media has allowed us to now have all this information at our fingertips and like podcasts like yours that can help get the information out and a lot more. Because you know, I'm sure people back in the, you know, before the internet were like, How did you even know about all these things? You really didn't. America's most wanted. Yes. Oh my god. I hope that you've got something on you. Yeah, you're like, you didn't get it in your face like every day.
SPEAKER_01No. Like I'm looking at this person missing person so that I could actually maybe help, because you can be aware of people around you and try to help with tips if you have any, or definitely.
SPEAKER_02And and I think that's the really interesting thing is that sort of, you know, you know, we talk about, oh, you know, I didn't know it was this bad. Well, I think the reason why we know it's so it's always been this bad, but it's just now we we have it in our face more often that we're more aware of it. Absolutely. And so, and and the social media aspect too is is really fascinating because I'll have family members who will comment on like, oh, that's my mom, you know, that's missing. And or, you know, oh, like uh that and that's how I got one of my cases that it's gonna come out in November, um, you know, through TikTok, where they're like, oh my gosh, that's my what did they say?
SPEAKER_02That's my son's father-in-law or something to that effect. It was really strange. And then the daughter got in contact with me, and and then we were able to, you know, connect and talk that way. So it's been super helpful, I think, in terms of getting tips, but then as well getting awareness out, but then connecting with those family members. And that was a really tough one because I said nobody has ever talked about our father's case before, ever. And so uh it has since I connected them with a journalist who who I I think is incredible at reporting true crime, and so there's not been a news story out, but then when my case comes out or my episode of Over There Your Father comes out will be the first, one of the first media coverage that they've received in 20 plus years.
SPEAKER_02Wow, yeah. So it's it's good. It's the social media can be an incredible tool as much as it can be incredibly scary.
SPEAKER_03So do you have a studio?
SPEAKER_02I don't have a studio.
SPEAKER_03So what do you do? Tell us your setup.
SPEAKER_02I mean, it's sort of similar to this, but I'm just in my office. So I'm really lucky I have a downstairs office in my home, and so and a you know, a a mic and a uh headphones, and then like we just go for it.
SPEAKER_01And so they have to come to you, no. See, and that's where we we like went back and forth when we were setting this up because we wanted people in the community to come, right? Yeah, but now we don't really I mean we could figure out and record something like with some microphones and a phone and stuff somewhere else, and go somewhere else, but we just do it here, so yeah, it kind of limits sometimes who we could have on if we wanted somebody who is not in Cheyenne.
SPEAKER_02Definitely, yeah. I use Riverside, which is which is a great tool, and so essentially it's a really nice Zoom call, and you know, and you do it that way.
SPEAKER_01And so we did one on Zoom once.
SPEAKER_02We didn't try it out, yeah, yeah, yeah. And so it's definitely interesting, but I only do audio, I don't do video, and so uh Rebecca Belinda's sister, bless her heart. She was like, Will you please give me the video? I was like, You don't want the video. It's it's not flattering on anybody, Rebecca. And she's like, Please, no, I really want it. And I was like, Okay, I will post it on YouTube, but I am not putting it anywhere else. And so it is on YouTube for just her, and so, but yeah, I only use audio.
SPEAKER_03You record because you see each other, yep, we see each other. Uh-huh. So you record that, but you don't release that. I don't release the audio.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, every once in a while I'll, you know, when I'm, you know, plugging, oh, you know, in this video today, and you know, like I'll do the Riverside will do these really cool magic clips where they take, you know, a really cool yeah, a chunk of it. And so I'll post that, but I'm not posting, no. You half the time I look a hot mess. I'm not putting that out there.
SPEAKER_03Okay. That's kind of nice. Working in your pajamas. Yeah, pretty much. So, how often do you release episodes? Like, yeah. Do you have is there a routine to that or what does that look like?
SPEAKER_02No, there isn't. No. And so, along with um, you know, being a full-time college instructor, so I, you know, teach English out at the college, I have two young children, five and seven now. And then uh my husband is a firefighter with the city, and so you know, 48 hours on uh, you know, I'm solo parenting. And then I also run Airbnbs. And then when I'm not doing that, he also farms and ranches. And so we we stay pretty busy. And so, and like I said, you know, when I have families that want to be worked with, I'm definitely working with them.
SPEAKER_02It can take a little while for them to get comfortable to the idea, and so there's sometimes I am not kidding, I will be talking to a family for years, you know, wow, one to two years before they finally like, okay, we're ready, Renee, let's do this. I'm like, okay, and I drop everything to make sure that I can, you know, get them on. And so, but uh, I'm in a really good routine right now where I'm having episodes come out every two weeks, so that's been really great. And so, but it really just depends on what's happening to the families that I'm working with and how they're feeling, if they're ready to record, law enforcement too.
SPEAKER_02And so I can run into snags with law enforcement. And so most of the time, law enforcement is super happy to work with me, which is very exciting when they are. Uh, other times, you know, I'll get the the go-around, like, oh, call us back next week. We'll have something for you. And, you know, I'm chasing them down for a month, and we're finally like, okay, I just need to get the episode out. I'll just say that, you know, it was a no comment, yeah situation. And so it can kind of just depend. And so, but they're right now every two weeks, which is really fantastic, but that is not the norm.
SPEAKER_02Okay. Not the norm.
SPEAKER_03That's awesome. So I will let me like how many per year do you have an average there?
SPEAKER_02Uh I would say probably four a year. Yeah, four a year. And so, and then I try to do spooky episodes because that is fun for me. So that's where I get my fun in. And so the, you know, the actual the whole title is Unsolved Wyoming, Cold Cases, Haunted Places. And so, so right now for October, I'm doing spooky episodes. And so I did a crossover episode with Buried by the Back Roads, which is another Wyoming podcaster who's out of Rock Springs, but she covers international history as well.
SPEAKER_02So she covers everything from you know Wyoming history to you know across the United States over the pond and everything. And so, and she told me this really great story about Jibo, Wyoming. I don't know if you've ever heard of Jibo, Wyoming. It's it's a ghost town now, so it's sure it's gone.
SPEAKER_03And so maybe a few of those.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, we do. We have quite a few of them. And so she told me the history of Jibo, Wyoming, and some of the hauntings. I recently just had a grave robbing situation, which is just crazy. Right. It was like we're still grave robbing in 2026 and what's and so so yeah, so so right now I have some spooky episodes coming out, and then I try to do them like a spring-o-wing type situation. So I'll have some really excited, I have a really cool guest coming on that I'll put out for for in April.
SPEAKER_03So that sounds fun. Yeah. Sounds interesting.
SPEAKER_01I definitely probably think I've probably listened because I listen and I like stuff, I like the Wyoming stuff because I mean I do like stuff a big case for the whole nation, but it is kind of interesting to hear things that happen in your state.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, definitely. And especially spanning, you know, so much time and just how different it was. And so, like I said, Kimberly's uh Kimberly Knobacks' episode is just so nostalgic to me because of that radio piece. You know, my kids don't even know what the radio is. And so I was actually on the Glenwood show last week and I was like, I'm gonna be on the radio. And they're like, What's that? I was like, Oh, you don't you don't actually know what a radio is. That's okay. So yeah, he's been doing that forever. For a long time, yes. Awesome.
SPEAKER_01Okay, we want to do our lightning rounds. Okay, we've been trying this new thing as overrated, underrated, or appropriately rated. Oh, okay. Okay, first one true crime documentaries. Appropriately rated.
SPEAKER_03Yes, good. You want me to go? Sure. Um, amateur internet detectives. Oh, that's a good one.
SPEAKER_02Oh, because there's so many good ones out there. I will say appropriately rated, but maybe slightly overrated.
SPEAKER_03So somewhere in between there. There might be some um wannabe ones out there. Oh, definitely.
SPEAKER_02There's ones, oh, there's there's for sure. And there's some that cause a lot of damage. Yes. And so that's that's part of the issue. And so the ones that know what they're doing, yes, we need them. But the ones that are getting in over their heads and are, you know, spouting things on TikTok that are Potentially hurting a case. No.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02It makes sense. Small town gossip. Ooh. Uh appropriately rated. And so because you know, so there's probably some truth to that. So depending on what it is, right? Especially if it's true crime related, I think they can be really beneficial.
SPEAKER_03That's really hard. Yeah, because I'm thinking of a couple where there's probably a lot of small town gossip and it's for good reason. Definitely. Because we know each other. Yeah. Definitely. Um, crime scene TV shows. Ooh, like, I don't know. What would be a good crime scene TV show? The thing that I struggle with a little bit are like serial killer documentaries. Oh, yeah, definitely. Those are those are dark, underrated, or overrated. Overrated.
SPEAKER_03Overrated for sure. Just do that one because I've watched a few.
SPEAKER_01Also, because we just keep making them famous and them famous, and they did terrible things too. Horrible things. Yes. Instead we could what listen to a story, a documentary on somebody who's missing or went missing and learn how to not be missing ourselves. Definitely. Yeah. Or help them.
SPEAKER_02Or not make it worse for them. Yeah. I do think, you know, for example, like the Ted Bundy situation is really fascinating because uh Bundy really relied on women's politeness and, you know, kindness and our natural ability just to want to be helpful. And so that's I think that's a that's a huge that's a it's a good tale to teach women to not to trust your instincts and to that you don't always need to be the nice girl.
SPEAKER_03You don't owe it to anybody.
SPEAKER_02You don't need to be the nice girl. And I think that's really important. And so, but I do think what's problematic with Bundy is that you know he has exploded into this realm of infamy that is really toxic and unhealthy. And so there's people who wear t-shirts that say Ted Bundy's hot or Ted Bundy's my boyfriend. It's like, what is wrong with you?
SPEAKER_03And so that's really problematic. I was just saying this the other day that um the one guy recently um Wade uh he's got tattoos Oh um the Deadpool killer.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, um the the handsome one that was in the thought he was I think it's Wade Wilson is his name, and that's why they call him Deadpool.
SPEAKER_03Like the fan mail that he's getting is often. People like in love with him, and you just getting married or one of them is getting married.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, oh Chris Watts, yes, Chris Watts.
SPEAKER_03I didn't even know that they could really communicate with technology from jail, but there's some states that it appears like allows.
SPEAKER_01I know in jail right now that posts.
SPEAKER_03So so if you have access to internet and technology in a jail cell, why would you ever even want to leave? Right? You've got a roof over your head and three meals a day, and you get to just interact online.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I and I and again, I think it depends on on the pen the the institution itself. Sure. And so, but I um I think most of them don't have that. And so I don't know if we're gonna Well what about like jail? Yeah, I don't know how Chris Watts is getting married. I think it's just through fan mail legitimately. Oh, I think so.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and so then she could start doing visits, all you have to just do is get approved.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and then she can do business.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and then is it conjugal visits, and then pretty soon she's having his baby horribly, but you probably can they probably can hug and things.
SPEAKER_02I yeah, it it gets into a real, a real weird situation in the way that um people idolize these, you know, these horrible people. And I I talked about it actually in my last episode with Sammy, you know, from from Buried by the Back Roads, is that you can't really name victims of some of these cases because the focus is so heavily. Well, yeah, we just named a bunch of people tell you the person that you ironically, I did cover Chris I know I'll I usually say Shannon's case.
SPEAKER_02And so Shannon is is the wife of Chris Watson, and so Shannon CC and Bella. And so I did cover their case in the class. I did, and it was hard. It was a hard one to get through because you know, here you have this, you know, perfect little family, or at least you think it is. And the difference between the book and the documentary and in the and the podcast are really fascinating because I think a lot of these women think that this was a crime of passion, spirit of the moment. You know, he went into a rage and blacked out and did something really horrible.
SPEAKER_02You read the book, you can you have the details in there that let you know that if this was he he attempted a couple of times to harm Shannon. And so, yeah, and so he he did. He, you know, tried giving her um hydrocodone in her smoothies when she was pregnant with the therapy. I good research. And so, yeah, good research. And so the um, so the that's why I do that this class like I do, because I think that changes a ton to go from oh he just you know, he just lost it, he just went crazy to then realizing right now saying she killed the kids and he killed like there's oh and people do believe that they do, they're like, no way, he's there's no way he did it, she did it, and then he No, absolutely not.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely not.
SPEAKER_03I mean, all you gotta do is watch the video footage of him and know that he was fully so guilty, so guilty. Yeah, so yeah, it's really tragic. Oh my gosh, boy, I could spend forever talking to you. Okay, yes, anonymous tips.
SPEAKER_02Yes. Have I underrated? Over there, they're appropriately rated, please. Any anything, you know, little small, it could be that you you you don't remember it quite correctly because time has passed, submit them. And so rather they come to me, and I have had tips come to me, and I turn them over to law enforcement or DCI has a you know, again, anonymous tip that you want to be anonymous, you can submit tips anonymously on their website. But yes, they are appropriately rated. Please make sure that you are submitting tips no matter how big or small.
SPEAKER_02Awesome. Um, cold case reopening. Appropriately uh underrated. Yes, we need more of that. Um and so because I think as time passes, people who maybe were involved or know something, hopefully they grew a conscience.
SPEAKER_01You know, hopefully, they grew a conscience or they became a little laxadaisy because they thought they got away with it.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. And so, yes, I think we shouldn't be opening more coal cases 100% because time passes, things change, people aren't the same. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Can go ahead. No, you go. I it was your turn. Conspiracy theories.
SPEAKER_02Oh, so back in the day I would say overrated, and now I say underrated. There's just too many good ones. Okay, lizard people. Come on. I'm like lizard people.
SPEAKER_01Oh my god, I don't even know. I like things like that that are funny. I also be like, what is a lizard person?
SPEAKER_02Oh TikTok will take you, we'll take you to it. But sometimes I think we do need to let go of reality just like a little bit to dive into some of these things to be like, this is nuts. But then, you know, you get into it and you're like, maybe it's not that nuts. So yeah, I'm I'm for it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Okay, the power of a good podcast.
SPEAKER_02Oh appropriately rated. I definitely think a power of the good podcast can be so instrumental. And so, you know, rather it's true crime or it's self-help or it's comedy. I think, you know, having a good podcast in your back pocket can do some real good.
SPEAKER_03I agree. I like them just when I'm out walking my dog and be out listening, you know, you learn something new or you get a spiritual uplift for the day. Yeah, sweetly, whatever. And so definitely. Yeah. So how can people find you?
SPEAKER_02So I am on every major listening platform. And so go to your favorite podcast app and then just type in Unsolved Wyoming, and so you'll see Unsolved Wyoming and Renee Nelson, and that's me. And then you can also follow me on social media. My handle is Unsolved Wyoming Podcasts, and so and I also you can email me and I have a website, unsolved Wyoming Podcast.com.
SPEAKER_03I love it. Um, what do you hope listeners take away from your podcast? I hope that they take away that hope is real.
SPEAKER_02Hope is real. And so, and for a lot of these people who come on to my show and you know, I'm giving them a platform, they have real hope that maybe somebody listening is going to remember something or think about something, or the person may be responsible, or the person who saw, you know, that you know, something, you know, is going to say something. They have real hope. And so I think that's probably the thing that I want people to remember when they're listening to these stories is that the people who are coming on are they taking a chance to share their story that maybe something is going to change with their story.
SPEAKER_03I can't imagine a worse. I could, I mean, they're maybe they're I shouldn't quite say it like that. I think having somebody that you deeply love and care about and not know where they are, right? Like there's no closure, like the Savannah Guthrie, her mom, right? There are they ever gonna know where she's at or what happened. And the the agony that comes from not knowing um where your loved one is, you'd almost rather be like, okay, tell me they're dead and bring them to me so that I can at least lay them to rest and be comfortable and know where they are.
SPEAKER_03I just think it would be, especially if it was one of your children that went missing. I just I don't even know how you'd function every day, honestly. So my heart goes out to all the families that have a missing loved one because it has to be a very cruel form of torture.
SPEAKER_02It is my opinion. It is. And the world doesn't stop for them, right? And so they have to make space for this pain and agony and still show up to work, or if they have other kids that they had to take care of, or you know, they still have to pick up the pieces and move on with forward with their lives, even though you know part of them is stuck back on that day.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I think I wouldn't even want to leave the place where they went missing. I think that would be very hard for me. Like Gabby Petito's parents, for example, you know, I the first thing I would want to do is go to Wyoming, come to Wyoming and go right to wherever they thought she was. Like, and it would be really hard for me. I don't know, maybe I got attachment issues, but it would be very hard, I think. Yeah, especially as a parent. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02I can't as a parent and you would have to pull, you would have to drug me and pull me away.
SPEAKER_01Well, like you said, you would never want to give up hope, but the world goes on and then you're the only one like living in it, you know?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, because things move on. Yep. Well, awesome. Thank you so much for coming on. That was super having me. And we love that you're doing that. Yeah, we're gonna have to listen. Yeah, thank you. Of course. Uh, and for all of our listeners, as you know, Lindy and I are realtors here at Pig Properties. So if you're looking to buy your sell, which um uh if you're looking to buy your sell, we'd love to help you with that. Uh, you can find us at sellsyenne.com as well as all of our social media channels and be on the front of our podcast on YouTube and all of your major podcast platforms.
Holiday magic can feel like a high bar until you hear how real people actually do it. We sit down with fellow Realtors Mike Hoppe (Coldwell Banker) and Krista Boyer (Peak Properties) to talk about Christmas traditions...
Your house isn’t messy because you’re failing, it’s messy because you’re human and time is limited. We talk with Jamie Avent, owner of Summerset Concierge in Cheyenne, Wyoming, about what happens when you stop treating...
You can spend all day fighting algorithms and still never reach the people who actually live down the street. Wendy and Rhea sit down with Tosca Ball of The Prairie Peddler to talk about a marketing channel most...
A third grader who “hates running” signs up anyway, finds her people, and suddenly has a place to belong after school. That’s the quiet magic behind Girls on the Run, and it’s why we invited Cindy Bradley and Kate...
Dropped keys, a heavy door, a transfer out of bed, a crowded store aisle, these are tiny moments that can become daily barriers when you live with a mobility disability. We talk with Michelle Warner from K9s for...