Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Beyond Our Walls

Beyond Our Walls artwork

Episode 4: Exhausted by Choices

Nov 24, 202426 minAudioEpisode 4
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this week’s episode of Beyond Our Walls, Tim dives into the reality of decision fatigue - a challenge that affects all of us, whether you are in a formal leadership position or not, because we all end up navigating endless choices and conflicts in our daily lives. Tim reflects on the toll of constant decision-making, sharing candid stories from his own experience, like the split-second choice of whether to be honest about feeling overwhelmed or putting on a brave face. Backed by research on the physical and mental impacts of decision fatigue, this episode explores why exhaustion sets in and how it affects our ability to lead effectively. With practical strategies, relatable anecdotes, and a dose of pop culture wisdom from Parks and Recreation’s Leslie Knope, Tim offers actionable advice for simplifying decisions, delegating tasks, and reconnecting with core values. Find more about the research around decision fatigue mentioned in the episode here and here. If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe to Beyond Our Walls wherever you get your podcasts, consider sharing it with a friend, and check out the newsletter at beyondourwalls.substack.com. Your support means everything! Like what you hear? Maybe buy me a coffee? Find more from Tim at bio.link/timothy. Get full access to Beyond Our Walls at beyondourwalls.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Some days it feels like the choices never stop coming. Big ones, small ones, probably ones I wasn't even expecting. And if I'm honest lately, it's been a lot. Exhaustion sets in and it's the kind that makes you question if you've got anything left to give. But what if we don't have to do it all? What if showing up with intention is enough? This is Tim Dawkins.

SPEAKER_01We're going to talk about that more today on Beyond Our Walls. Welcome back to Beyond Our Walls, where we explore the day-to-day realities of leadership, mental health, and personal growth as we navigate the ups and downs of life.

SPEAKER_01I'm Tim Dawkins, coming to you once again from my podcasting studio home office here in upstate New York. And today's episode, you may have guessed, is one I think many of you might relate to, whether you've found yourself in a formal leadership position or have ever been put in charge of something, and that really can be anything, whether you've been asked to be or not. And a lot of times we're not asked to be put in charge of things, we just happen to find ourselves there.

SPEAKER_01And especially, this is for you, if you've ever found yourself at the end of your energy, staring at a pile of decisions that you still need to make and you're not really sure how you're going to do it. Lately, I've been feeling drained, if I'm being honest. And what's a podcast for if not to be honest? And it's not just the kind of tired you fixed with a snack and a nap, but the deep emotional exhaustion that comes from conflict and decision-making day

SPEAKER_01after day. It feels like every choice, every interaction is pulling from a well that truthfully is kind of running low. Feels maybe like we're approaching a drought here. The other day at work, someone walked into my office as I was sitting behind my computer typing away, probably at the 50th email of the day. I'm not really exactly sure what I was doing at the time, but whenever somebody comes into my office, it's not surprising that they would casually ask me,

SPEAKER_01hey, how are you doing? And at that moment, in that split second, I had to decide. And I think probably we've all been here. Do I tell the truth? Do I say, honestly, I'm barely keeping it together. I've been bouncing from meeting to meeting, solving problems, juggling conflicts, and oh yeah, trying not to crawl under my desk right now. Or do I slap on a smile to make them feel better and say, everything's good. The universe is as it should be.

SPEAKER_01Spoiler alert, I went with option two, but that little moment has definitely stayed with me because it reminded me how much we hold on to often without letting anyone see what's really going on. We tell ourselves a story that people don't really want to know when we're struggling, and sometimes that can get us into a bind. As leaders, we're often in the business of solving problems, putting out fires,

SPEAKER_01and making decisions that affect others' lives. But here's the thing, none of us were designed to be mired in conflict or endless decision-making every single day of our lives. It's overwhelming, it's tiring, and if we're not careful, it can really take a serious toll on us mentally, emotionally, and even physically. So today I want to talk about decision fatigue, what it is, why it happens, and how we can manage it before it manages us.

SPEAKER_01If you're feeling stretched too thin, you need to know you are not alone and we'll explore some ways to create space for clarity and calm. So stick around and, uh, maybe come up with some solutions for how we can make this better. So what is decision fatigue and why does it hit people in leadership positions so hard? Decision fatigue is exactly what it sounds like,

SPEAKER_01the mental and emotional exhaustion that comes from making too many decisions. We're fatigued by the decisions we have to make. It's what happens when your brain, like any muscle, becomes worn out from overuse and And here's the kicker. It doesn't matter if those decisions are big, like resolving a major conflict at work, or small, like choosing what to eat for lunch. In my world, a very important decision nonetheless. Every decision pulls from the same mental energy, and eventually we hit a wall.

SPEAKER_01So as leaders, this can feel especially overwhelming. We're not just making decisions for ourselves. We're often responsible for guiding others, solving problems, and and putting out fires. And over time, this constant decision-making takes a toll on our bodies as well as our minds. There's research that actually has shown that decision fatigue affects more than just our ability to think clearly, although that's what we think of the most when we think of decision fatigue. We think of cloudy thoughts and tired eyes and

SPEAKER_01stress headaches and things like that, but it definitely has measurable impacts on our physical well-being. A study published in the Journal of Consumer Research found that people experiencing decision fatigue were more likely to make impulsive choices or avoid decisions altogether. This happens because the prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain responsible for logical thinking and self-control, becomes depleted with overuse.

SPEAKER_01Another study from the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences It's a mouthful for a journal highlighted the connection between decision fatigue and glucose levels in the body. The researchers found that making decisions actually depletes glucose in the brain. Obviously, we know we need glucose for energy and making decisions uses energy. So that glucose gets depleted by making those decisions, which is why decision fatigue often leads to feelings of exhaustion and irritability.

SPEAKER_01This is one reason why you might find yourself craving sugary snacks or caffeine after a particularly grueling day of decision making. For me, it's like 2, 3 o'clock in the afternoon. Your body is trying to replenish all of those depleted energy reserves, and it's looking for a quick fix. So physically, decision fatigue can also manifest as stress. Obviously, that's what we think of probably most readily. Cortisol, which is the body's primary stress hormone,

SPEAKER_01spikes when we're overwhelmed by constant decision-making. That pressure to make the right decision, make the decision quickly, and make sure everybody is taken care of definitely contributes to spiking cortisol in the body. None of us should be surprised by that. Over time, elevated cortisol levels can lead to headaches, disrupted sleep, and even long-term weakened immune function. On the cognitive side of things, decision fatigue makes it harder to process complex information or think creatively.

SPEAKER_01So if you're somebody who turns to creative outlets to relax or calm yourself, you might find that when you're being fatigued by all the decisions you have to make, the last thing you want to do is sit down and take care of yourself by writing in your journal or doing some crafting, whatever that might look like for you. When we're drained, we're more likely to fall back on habits or routines, even if they're not the best choices, just to conserve energy. So this is why,

SPEAKER_01for example, someone might avoid making an important decision altogether or impulsively agree to something just to move on because we don't have the energy to deal with it. So we just decide this is what's going to be and we move forward as quickly as possible. Um, you know, when you talk about routines and falling into habits, even though they're not the best choices, I think about eating for me, that's definitely a routine or a habit that I can get into. I sometimes find myself looking for food when I know I'm really not hungry and, and

SPEAKER_01It would be really nice for me to say that I'm looking for food to fill up my energy reserves because my glucose is low. But the reality is it's a habit that I fall back on. And I'm only kidding myself if I don't admit that. So what are some practical strategies that we can do to combat decision fatigue? And I think, you know, that's kind of the main thing that I wanted to talk about today is We're all experiencing it at some point. So what are some things we can do to interrupt that cycle?

SPEAKER_01And the first one is we really need to simplify routine decisions. of the best ways to preserve your energy is to automate the small decisions in your day think about things like meal planning or your morning routine or what you're going to wear so a good example of that is someone like steve jobs who wore the same outfit every day actually i was just talking to people about this the other day because steve jobs is the example that comes to mind but there are definitely other people who have been in the spotlight that talk about really simplifying their clothing choices.

SPEAKER_01It's an easy decision that they don't have to worry about and they just pick the same thing out of their closet day in and day out. Boring, yeah, but it's certainly a way that you can reduce some of the energy that you use making the same decisions every day it's less time thinking about clothes more energy for big decisions so think about your own routines and think about your own day what's one recurring decision in your life that you can simplify or automate this week in

SPEAKER_01my house we do a lot of meal planning as best we can And so usually Sundays are a day spent getting food for the week ready so that we know that when my wife and I come home at the end of a long day, we've already got dinner taken care of. And that's been really helpful for us. Another thing that you can do is create boundaries for decision making. So give yourself permission to say this decision doesn't need to be made right now. And that can feel hard because sometimes when you're a leader,

SPEAKER_01it feels like every decision is important because a lot of people are depending on particular decisions and they're not afraid to tell you that. But not every choice is urgent and not every conflict needs immediate resolution, nor do we always need to be the ones to fix it. So creating time blocks for decision-making can be helpful. For example, maybe you set aside 30 minutes in the afternoon to review emails or make decisions instead of tackling them throughout the day. And the email one is huge for me because I really could spend a lot of my day

SPEAKER_01sitting at my desk responding to emails. They really come in fast and furious and it can be overwhelming when you let it sit for a while and then you come back and there's 20 new emails staring you in the face. The reality of the situation is we probably all have unspoken rules for ourselves where we know it's going to take 24 to 48 hours for people to really get a response. And that's what people should expect. So why are we always feeling like we need to respond right away? So maybe that's an area where you could set up a positive routine.

SPEAKER_01You pick a time in the morning and a time in the afternoon that is just for emails. And then you don't sit there and keep checking throughout the day. So ask yourself, how can I create space to focus on what matters most, whether it's in your workday or in your personal life? Something else you can do is delegate. Some of us are better at that than others. And as leaders, we sometimes feel like we need to do it all, but delegation isn't a weakness. It's a strategy. And I think I need to say that again.

SPEAKER_01Delegation isn't a weakness. It's a strategy. Trusting others to take on tasks not only lightens your load, but it also empowers them to grow. I can talk from an education perspective. There are a number of administrators who have different responsibilities in our school district. And I rely on them to take care of things. And I don't need to micromanage them. In fact, sometimes micromanaging them makes their job more difficult because now they start to question,

SPEAKER_01what actually is my role here? So delegation is definitely important. It's a skill. It's something that I have learned over time and I still fail at it. But it definitely helps with decision fatigue when you can turn to somebody else and say, hey, I need you to take this thing off my plate, as long as it actually falls under their column. So think about what's a decision that you can delegate this week. Something else you can do, and this sounds kind of hokey, but I think it's important.

SPEAKER_01Focus on your core values. When decision fatigue sets in, reconnecting with your values, the things that you hold close can provide clarity. So ask yourself, does this decision align with what matters most to me and what matters most to my teams? And your values can act as a filter. If it doesn't align with what matters most to you, then maybe it's something that needs to be put on the back burner. These filters help us prioritize and cut through the noise.

SPEAKER_01So really asking yourself what matters most can help you cut through a lot of the stuff that maybe doesn't need as much time as we think it does. And then finally, and I think probably most importantly, something that we could all do better is take breaks to recharge. Step away, no matter how brief it is, and you get that reset for your mind. I'm not talking about necessarily taking a nap, although if you have that opportunity, absolutely go for it. But a walk or a quick conversation with somebody you trust is

SPEAKER_01whether that's to brainstorm or even if it's a conversation about something not related to work just to clear your head. And then, you know, we've done some mindfulness stuff in this podcast before, and even five minutes of deep breathing, even honestly, one minute of deep breathing can make a difference. And they're actually a science to show that Any amount of time spent focused on, you know, breathing, meditation, mindfulness can really make a difference.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, it's not rocket science, but there are five strategies right there for you to think about and maybe try this week when you are feeling a little tired and overwhelmed from all the decisions that you have to make.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01For this episode's pop culture segment, I want to turn to one of my favorite shows, Parks and Recreation. If you have not seen Parks and Recreation, I highly, highly recommend it. It's been off the air for a number of years now, but it is about one of the most perfect sitcoms ever created. And if you've seen the show, you know that Amy Poehler plays a character named Leslie Knope. who is the epitome of enthusiasm and ambition.

SPEAKER_01Her energy and commitment to doing good for her community in Pawnee, Indiana, are unmatched. But even Leslie, driven, dedicated, endlessly optimistic, faces decision fatigue, and it often leads to Usually funny and often relatable chaos. One of the best examples of this comes when Leslie is planning the Harvest Festival. So she's juggling a million decisions at once.

SPEAKER_01She's securing funding, coordinating vendors, managing the media and solving crises like cursed land and missing mini horses. And the mini horse, as a side note, is a big part of this episode and definitely shows up later. As the decisions start to pile up, her stress level skyrockets, and it definitely becomes clear that perfectionism is fueling this exhaustion. So that's usually a theme in the show for Leslie.

SPEAKER_01Her perfectionism often gets in the way. She micromanages every detail. She refuses to delegate and ends up running herself ragged trying to make the festival flawless and And by the time the festival opens, Leslie is so drained that she can't even enjoy the fruits of her labor. Then there's the time that Leslie tries to plan the perfect anniversary dinner for Ben, another character in the show,

SPEAKER_01and her boyfriend. She agonizes over every single detail, where to go, what to eat, what gifts to give. until she's so overwhelmed that she considers scrapping the entire plan. And honestly, how many of us have ever been in that situation? You're really excited about something. You start planning it. You spend so much time trying to make it perfect that finally you're so tired you don't even want to do it anymore. These moments of decision fatigue in the show show us that even the most capable

SPEAKER_01and passionate leaders, and if you watch Parks and Recreation, you know Leslie is nothing if not passionate, Even passionate leaders can hit a wall when they try to do too much. So what can we learn from our friend Leslie Knope? Well, first, perfectionism definitely fuels decision fatigue. Leslie's need to have everything be perfect often adds unnecessary weight to her choices. It's a reminder that sometimes good enough really is good enough. I often say to folks, don't let perfect get in the way of good.

SPEAKER_01Delegation is key. When Leslie eventually starts trusting her team, whether it's Ben, Ron, or her beloved Jerry, she finds that sharing the load not only reduces her stress, but also strengthens her relationship. And finally, perspective matters. When Leslie steps back and remembers why she's doing the work, whether it's building a park or celebrating her relationships, it helps her focus on what really matters.

SPEAKER_01and let go of the rest. So take a step back, take some breaths, and get some perspective, which even a perfectionist like Leslie is able to do. Leslie Knope is a fantastic example of the pitfalls of decision fatigue and the power of leaning on others. Her story reminds us that leadership doesn't mean solving every problem on your own. It means trusting your team,

SPEAKER_01focusing on your purpose, and knowing when to let go of the things that don't matter as much. So the next time you're overwhelmed by decisions, ask yourself, WWLKD, what would Leslie Knope do? And then maybe skip the part where she stays up on like color coding binders. Now we have your leadership challenge for the week, and that challenge is take one small step to simplify your decision-making process

SPEAKER_01and create space for clarity. Start by identifying a recurring decision, and we talked about this previously, so start by identifying a recurring decision or task in your day-to-day life that consistently drains your energy. So for me, I talked about email, so that would be that would be my task under this challenge. Maybe it's planning meals, scheduling meetings. figuring out what needs to be done first in a long list of priorities. Whatever it is, choose one area where you can streamline, delegate, or let go entirely.

SPEAKER_01And yes, I truly mean let go. So here are some examples. Streamline. Plan meals or outfits for the week ahead of time so it's one less thing to think about each day. Delegate, trust a team member or colleague to make a decision you'd normally take on yourself and trust them to do it. Maybe start with something small and build up from there. And then finally, let go. Identify a decision or task that's less urgent than it feels.

SPEAKER_01Ask yourself, what would happen if I didn't make this decision right now? Then give yourself permission to let it sit for later or not at all. Then take a moment to reflect on your core values. What matters most to you as a leader? Let those values guide how you prioritize your choices. And decision fatigue often comes from trying to do it all. But when we focus on what aligns with our purpose, the noise starts to clear. So you may need to find some time to do a little quiet reflection.

SPEAKER_01I've talked about journaling before. Journaling for this reason can be really helpful. Just spending some time with yourself, writing, what are the things that are most important to me? Journaling is an act of mindfulness as well, so I highly recommend writing to clear your head. And then finally, make space to check in with yourself. Block out 10 minutes at the end of the day to pause, breathe, and ask, what decisions felt good today? Where did I feel stuck or overwhelmed?

SPEAKER_01And how can I approach tomorrow differently? And I think it's really important for us to remember that every moment is an opportunity to do things differently than we did them before. Whether it's the next day, the next hour, the next week, whatever it is, we always have moments to start over. Our day isn't completely ruined because we made a poor decision in the morning. We still have the afternoon to turn things around. The goal is not to eliminate every decision, which that would be impossible.

SPEAKER_01It's to notice where you can create room to breathe and move forward with intention. Small steps can definitely make a big difference. And each choice you simplify is one less thing weighing you down. Share your experience with someone you trust or write it down for yourself. It might be the beginning of a healthier approach to decision making. And here's some closing thoughts for today.

SPEAKER_01Leadership is hard and decision fatigue is real. Don't let anybody tell you any differently. But even when we're exhausted, we have the power to create space, lean into our values and show up with intention. In fact, that is when it's most important to do just that. Create the space to, as Stephen Covey said in his book, The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People, seek first to understand, then to be understood. If we all could do that, the world would surely be a much more agreeable place.

SPEAKER_01And that's all I have time for this week. Thank you, as always, for spending time with me here at Beyond Our Walls. If this episode resonated with you, please subscribe here on Substack or wherever you listen to your podcasts. Share with someone who you think may benefit. And I would love it if you sent me a message with feedback, critiques. or thoughts you have after listening. Let me know how you're navigating decision fatigue. And if you need someone to bounce ideas off of, I'm definitely here to help.

SPEAKER_01We've been sold a vision of rugged individualism here in the United States. And as romanticized as that vision or narrative may be, that's all that it is. It's a story. Because in the end, we all need a little help from our friends. as both the Beatles and Joe Cocker sang so eloquently. Thanks again for hanging out with me for a bit. Take care of yourself. Stay hydrated, stay grounded, and let's keep moving forward.

SPEAKER_01One choice, one step, one moment at a time. I'll see you again soon. Take care.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 11: Surviving Navigating Feedback

    Nov 16, 202642 minAudio

    How can leaders receive hard feedback, recognize their blind spots, and keep growing without losing sight of the people they serve? On this episode of Beyond Our Walls, Tim sits down with educator and longtime friend...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 10: Connection Changes Everything ft. Ian Knox

    Jul 3, 202634 minAudio

    🌟 Ever felt isolated as a leader, even when you're surrounded by dozens of people? You're not alone! In the first video episode of the Beyond Our Walls podcast, Tim Dawkins and Ian Knox dive into the paradox of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 9: Can everyone hear me?

    May 12, 202623 minAudio

    We all make assumptions about how we communicate. One of the most common those of us who find ourselves speaking often to groups of people make is that the audience can always hear us because they are like us. However,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 8: For the Love of Dogs (with Henny Hiemenz)

    Mar 17, 202539 minAudio

    What is it about dogs that makes it so easy for us to open up, be vulnerable, and express emotions we sometimes struggle to share with other people? Why do we grieve them so deeply, and what can our relationships with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 7: Valentine's Shmalentine's (with Jerilyn Stellato)

    Feb 14, 202530 minAudio

    Welcome to Beyond Our Walls! This tim, we’re expanding the conversation - bringing in more voices, deeper discussions, and new perspectives on leadership, vulnerability, empathy, and the connections that sustain our...

    Credit the people on this episode