Send us Fan Mail You're the responsible one. The strong one. The one who knows better. But who takes care of the first daughter? In many immigrant families, being the first daughter isn't just a birth order. It's an unpaid, lifelong position you never applied for. In this episode of Between Two Worlds with Dr. Phebe, Dr. Phebe sits down with a fellow first daughter and therapist - Khadijah Layne, LMFT, to unpack the invisible expectations placed on eldest daughters, from becoming the family's second parent to learning that obedience, sacrifice, and silence are the ingredients for being a "good daughter." But what happens when being obedient means abandoning yourself? When setting boundaries feels like disrespect? And when you've been taught that your blessings depend on how well you please everyone else? Together, they explore the emotional cost of being the dependable daughter, the complicated relationship between cultural expectations and self-worth, and how these childhood roles follow us into adulthood, relationships, and motherhood. Because maybe the greatest blessing isn't being the daughter everyone approves of. Maybe it's finally becoming the woman you were always meant to be. If you've ever been called "so mature for your age" while quietly carrying everyone else's responsibilities, this episode is for you. Learn more about Khadijah, who is Licensed Marriage & Family Therapist and a part of a group practice; Create a Mindful Moment LLC. Send your questions, topic ideas, and sponsorship requests to consult@phebebrakolmft.com or slide in my DM's on Instagram @drphebebrako Remember we can only grow our audience with your support. Please share with your community!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03I feel like even as a first daughter, I think there's also a way in which that uh you're also expressed to be seen, not heard.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03So you're supposed to, when someone comes over, you're in the back with your mom, getting all the stuff, getting the drinks, getting knowing the things to put out for someone to come. But then there's also a part of you that is also invisible at the same time, right?
SPEAKER_02And so I think if you are the first daughter in an immigrant family, I have a question, just a quick question for you, right? When exactly were you hired? When do when did you get the the memo, the the offer letter, you know, from from gusto or ADP or whoever? Because I don't remember personally filling out an application.
SPEAKER_02Seriously. I I don't. But somehow we became the babysitter, we became the translator, we became the example, the responsible one. We became the the person who knows where everything is. And when I say everything, every nook and cranny, okay? Where where grandma's pictures are, where you know, the needle that we use to sew, you know, Auntie's wedding gown is, the pins that are required to tie somebody's ghilly, you know, all those things. The the person that everybody calls when somebody some when somebody goes missing, they haven't been heard from, or something goes wrong, right?
SPEAKER_02And somehow we're also the child who should not give anybody too much trouble. We're supposed to be these perfect little people, and you learn very, very early you have to be respectful, you have to be responsible, you have to help your mother, you have to set a good example, right? Because you have all of these siblings after you. I know I heard that a lot. And also, you shouldn't embarrass the family. Listen, I got stories on stories like for days about embarrassing the family, and you're also not supposed to talk back, right?
SPEAKER_02And if you do all of these things, you will be blessed, right? But today I wanted to ask a different question. Are you ready for this question? What if becoming the good daughter required you to become a smaller version of yourself? Let's talk about it. Let's get into that. Welcome back to Between Two Worlds with Dr. Phoebe, where we talk about the complicated, we talk about the funny, the beautiful, and sometimes painful experiences of building a life between two cultures.
SPEAKER_02And today's episode is called the first daughter experience. And if you knew, you know. There's there's being the oldest child, and then there's also being the first daughter. Two very different experiences, right? And those can be two very different job descriptions, right? And and when we first started talking about this episode, you you said something that immediately caught my attention, right? And you wanted to talk about how first daughters are sometimes taught to to shrink, right?
SPEAKER_02How how obedience becomes part of being considered a quote unquote good daughter, right? And you know, all of a sudden, how all of these things can be tied to this idea of of blessings, right? If you're obedient, you'll be blessed. If you respect your parents, you'll be blessed. Like, don't be Christian, because then they will bring in Ephesians 6, 1 and 2. Children, obey your parents and the Lord, for this is right. Honor your father and Maga. Okay, right? If you sacrifice, you'll be blessed.
SPEAKER_02And and it sounds so beautiful, it's such a beautiful thing until you start asking yourself, what happens when obedience requires you to betray yourself? So we're going there today, okay? Today I have a very special guest with me, right? And she's someone that I've known for over a decade. I think we just put together that it's been 13 years since we saw each other, like physically face to face. Yes. So, Khadija, how about I let you introduce yourself?
SPEAKER_03Thank you. I am Khadija Lane. I am a firstborn daughter. I am first generation. My mother is Sierra Leonean and my dad is Trinidadian. And I have firsthand experience of what it feels like to be a firstborn daughter and the expectations that are placed on you. And just like a firstborn daughter, I also became a licensed clinician. What? So let me take my family stuff and help people and kill people as well.
SPEAKER_02Why not, right? Why not? Why not? Because we have to do some good in the world and and prove our worth in some way, shape, or form. I've actually been been working on my memoir, and I'm at that point in my in my writing where I talk about that, about meet meeting Mark. So so for context, we also went to the same grad school as we had the same professors and we also went to college together. He did. Well, together? Yeah, because similar times, yeah. Similar times, because I still remember the very first day when you came to Salem College and your mother meeting me. I think I was your RA or something like that.
SPEAKER_03You were N R A, but you were in the same vicinity. Yeah. And when she found out you were African, then it was over. This is your sister.
SPEAKER_02Please stick your of your younger sister. And so so even if you're not biologically connected, there is still that expectation that you are supposed to be the big sister. Exactly. Right. And so I'm in in writing, I've I've gotten to that point where, you know, Mark, Dr. Demarcus Clark. Bless. Bless him. Bless him. Bless him. Bless him. He he's asking me about, or he's, you know, I think we were talking, he's asking the class why we want to become therapists. And all of us have come in with this like superiority complex of, well, I'm here to help people.
SPEAKER_02And we got knocked off that pedestal very early in the program. Very quick. In the program. But yeah, you're right. We we come into this profession with our family experiences and we want to help people. Yes. Not realizing, at least some of us not realizing, yo, you got some work to do. Right, right.
SPEAKER_03When the people who needed help was actually our family. So there's that.
SPEAKER_02Oh, okay. I felt like a tightness in my chest when you said when you say that. Oh, my, my, yeah. Okay. Okay. You know, so, so, so you you just identified yourself as a first daughter, right? You're also first generation. Yeah. And and you are a a therapist as well. I am. And, you know, surprise, surprise, we we mostly go into the helping professions. You know, it we're either therapists, social workers, nurses, right?
SPEAKER_02Those are some of the professions that we end up going into. So Khadija, let's start with with childhood, right? Let's start, let's start there. Let's go all the way back. And I love that, you know, if you're watching, you can see these beautiful pictures of of Khadija as as a child. And I'm wondering for you, when did you first realize that being the first daughter meant something? You know, like not that you just happened to be born first in the family, but when did you realize that there was a role attached to it?
SPEAKER_03So I think it became a bigger concept was me and my brother one year apart. So, you know, my brother is older, and then there's me. And we're one year apart, so we were kind of always together. And there were nuances when we went to my uncle's house, and he'd be, you know, oh, what are you cooking for us? You know, and I'm like five or six. Like, what are you cooking for? I have rice. I I got rice under my belt. And at five or six, really, like, you know, that's the first thing, that's the first dish you make is learn how to make rice. And at that time, I wasn't really trying to do that.
SPEAKER_03And rice would burn. No, it is what it is. I didn't care that much. However, that was like the common, like, catty, you know, is gonna cook rice for us and she's gonna learn how to make these stews, cassava leaf, okra, whatever. But I think it came more into play when my sister was born because now I had another gender person that was dictating what my role was as an older sister. And when I was younger, I was very much a tomboy. So I was outside, I was sneaking outside, I was not trying to help my mom in the kitchen or anything like that.
SPEAKER_03If you didn't watch me enough, I'd be outside. So like I would slip out, I'd be gone. Yeah. My sister was very much more girly. So then there was that still that comparison of like, yeah, you need to be like her. See, she likes her nails painted, she doesn't like to riff raff, all that other stuff.
SPEAKER_02So she probably learned to cook really good rice, you know, pretty early on or something along those lines.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and she stayed with it. It didn't burn as often. Because you probably put it on fire and you just walked away. I sure did and forgot about it. I was in front of the TV. They'll tell me to make rice. If we all want to eat tonight, maybe someone else should be responsible because it's not me.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02No, that that is so interesting. But also, I'm thinking about the fact that, you know, when we're younger, we didn't necessarily have rice cookers and how how much work it was just to cook rice. Yeah. But also the fact that rice is such a staple in in our cultures, you know, like we think about African families, Asian families, Caribbean families, it's just it's it's what we eat. Yes. As a combination of, you know, stew, pepper, I don't know, something.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02So it sounds like there were some expectations that were placed on you that were not necessarily placed on, for example, your brother. No, no.
SPEAKER_03My brother was allowed to exist authentically the way that he wanted to. Like, even growing up, it's like my mom would give us a list before she left, and he's on his PlayStation. And I was responsible for yelling at everyone to say, like, my mommy's coming home. Like, we need to get it together because when she yelled, it wasn't that she was yelling at you didn't do your thing. She didn't separate it. When she yelled, she yelled at everyone. And I personally learned very early that I really didn't need that kind of negativity in my life. And so I really was like, and at some point it just became this idea that I was just gonna take over because I didn't want to hear it.
SPEAKER_03So, you know, my brother was more concerned with playing his game. Yeah, but I didn't want to get yelled at. My sister, she's the baby. No one's yelling at her. Right. So, like, there was just like a lot of pressure to accomplish this list. But then it was like the people that I was supposed to be managing as a first daughter were not actually wanting to be managed. I learned that very quickly too, that yelling and like I was just managing them like my mom managed us, but it wasn't working because I was still their sister and they didn't care that much about me, like at all managing them.
SPEAKER_02That is that is something to have to learn so so quickly, you know, and so early. Also, because I remember my brothers, I have two younger brothers and they didn't always listen to me. Yeah, right. And I I would yell at them just like my mom would would yell at me. And you're right, they never listened. No, they never listened. And so you ended up carrying everything. Yeah. You ended up doing all the things, and we'll talk about that a little later because it definitely impacts how we function as adults, yeah. And even in like romantic relationships and things like that. So, did you hear things like, you know, you should know better, right?
SPEAKER_02You are you're the oldest. Yeah, you should you should set a good example always.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. And I didn't even know what that even meant. Like, I was the oldest in comparison to my one-year-old brother, like older than me. We both didn't know better. Right. We're both following each other. My mom would always say, like, you're gonna follow, follow makata. So she would always say, follow makata, but we would be following each other to hell in a handbasket. Like, right, why do why should we know what to do?
SPEAKER_02Like, we just got here. We were just bored. We just got here. We're still trying to figure out, figure it out. Because at the same time, you know, that with that phrase, you know, you know, you should know better. Like better than who. Right. Right? Better, like we're we're just like you said, we're just trying to figure it out. We're both, I don't know, under five. And you know, we're supposed to we're supposed to know it all and and know how to do some of these things. It that that is just a lot of pressure. That is that is a lot, a lot of pressure. So, so let's let's have a little bit of fun here, right? So I'm gonna name something and you can tell me whether it's part of, you know, your first daughter startup hack.
SPEAKER_02Okay. Okay, we're we're gonna think about that, right? So babysitting siblings. Yes. Being responsible for chores before everybody else. Yes. Uh-huh. Yeah. I I because then if the chores aren't done, then you have to, if even if it's divvied up, you have to go pick up the slack from everybody else's. If they didn't do it right. If they didn't do it, right. If they didn't do it right. Knowing family information that children probably should not know. Yeah. You know, being the cultural translator and also the interpreter.
SPEAKER_03The interpreter, yeah. Because of my mom's accent, people couldn't understand her often. But Sierra Leone was taken by a British colony, but people still had an you know an influx. And then she's like, I'm speaking English. It's like what is the problem?
SPEAKER_02And then in some ways, you know, become her, you become her unofficial assistant, her unpaid intern.
SPEAKER_03Never got paid. I am owed a lot of money.
SPEAKER_02It it's just it's just wild. And you would also know everybody's business before knowing, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Like, I was also already trained to be a mini therapist. I'm sitting in spaces conversing with aunts about business that I don't even know about, but I just happen to be there because I was told to sit close, right? And so my brother was okay to go and play with our cousins and stuff like that, which a majority of our cousins were boys, but I was told to just sit in the corner because girls stay. And now I'm listening to information that I probably shouldn't be privy to. Like a family tea. Yeah. You know. That I'm like, what? What happened?
SPEAKER_03Who's this? Who's that?
SPEAKER_02This person's kid is not this person. Like, we're what? Yeah. Yeah. And and and you know, you talked about being a tumble, and that's something that I can definitely relate to. Because I, if given a chance, I would be outside. We had a mango tree outside of the one of the houses that we grew up in, and I would I would be on that tree. And, you know, I didn't want to wear the skirts because I didn't want anybody looking up my skirt. Exactly. It wasn't it was inconvenient. A skirt is actually very inconvenient. It's very because I now have to like figure out how to like tie it and you know, make sure I'm hiding like all of my parts. And yeah, it was just too much work.
SPEAKER_02And and I remember going through that for so many years and having that sort of experience to where like I wasn't even wearing earrings. I also had cropped hair, haircut. Like my I had my head shaved, and I remember one of my aunts like coming to our home for the very first time, and she was meeting me for the first time, and she was like, Are you a boy or a girl?
unknownI'll beg.
SPEAKER_02I was like, you know, and my mom scolded me after that. She was like, you know, see, this is why I've been telling you, you know, put on more girly clothes and put on earrings. But then there was, I think there was this moment there also as the first daughter where I grew up and I became I started hitting like puberty. And then even though I'll be outside with my dad, it felt like one day he just woke up and realized, oh no, that's a daughter. Because I think maybe secretly he wanted me to be a son. Yeah. Also, because you know how like parents are, African parents are, with like the first child being the male and and all that. And then all of a sudden I was kicked back inside.
SPEAKER_02Yes, yes. I was supposed to go learn how to be a woman, exactly. And learn how to cook. I remember my feelings being so hurt. Yeah. You know, because it was like it felt like rejection.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. Because I've been by your side this whole time. But until the development of who I was, did you recognize that there was like there's like a gap, like the day that you grow up, the day that a girl grows, everyone starts acting a little bit different. Now you can't rough house with your cousins because they might get a different and it was just like, I just want to actually just play. Yeah. I'm I'm just 12. I'm still playing with my Barbies. I'm literally still in like fifth grade. Like everyone relax. Like lucky for even having Barbies.
SPEAKER_02They wouldn't let me have barbies. My dad will not let me have Barbies because he said that it would promote teenage pregnancy. Because apparently that was a huge thing back in the day. Yeah. And so the correlations. He would never he wouldn't let me have dolls. So you know what I did when I became older and I had my own money? I started, I started buying barbies. I have a Barbie doll collection. Good for you. Black Barbies specifically. I'm always on Facebook market trying to find the next one. So I have like a little collection. I don't know what I'm gonna do with it, also, because like now I have three sons and they haven't necessarily expressed any interest in dolls.
SPEAKER_02Right. So now I have this bin full of like Barbies, and every now and then I'll open it and look at it, like, oh, you're cute, you're cute, you know what I'm saying? Good for you, though. You know what I'm saying? Yeah, I had to reclaim that. So anyway, so so back to our conversation, right? What you said something when we're planning this episode and like talking about it that really, really stuck with me. And you talked about how first daughters have been taught to to shrink. Yes, right. And I'm wondering for you, like, what does shrinking mean?
SPEAKER_03I think they're, and I think I'm still working on this, honestly, because I think there's a way in which that I feel like even as a first daughter, I think there's also a way in which that uh you're also expressed to be seen, not heard.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03So you're supposed to, when someone comes over, you're in the back with your mom, getting all the stuff, getting the drinks, getting, knowing the things to put out for someone to come. But then there's also a part of you that is also invisible at the same time, right? And so I think from the moment I was born, I've been giving my mom issues. I'm gonna be very honest with you. And I think she should have known because I'm also a namesake as well. So my grandmother's name is Khadija. And so, and she's fiery and passionate. So I don't know why everyone just thought it was just gonna skip a generation.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So I I was I came into the world, two pounds, two ounces. I was very small. Wow, was fighting for life, right? But then I also think that I was also very loud, very about like I was gonna tell somebody about something, even if there was a way that I couldn't understand the rules uh that were placed on me, and I fought against it a lot. Okay. But I feel like my mom really worked hard to beat it out of me. She was like, you need to get it together. And my brother's a little bit quieter. So I think for me, I was always just next to him, just standing up for him because he was so quiet and people would like bully him or mess with him.
SPEAKER_03And I was kind of standing in his, in his in his care. But I also think that there was a part of me that was also very loud and very like, let's go do something, let's climb trees. I was in everything. And so I think there was a part of me that was split in two growing up. So when I was home, I was really quiet and obedient. But when I was at school, I was like a different version. Nice. I was more loud. I would people, people, my teachers, friends, they love that version of me. So it was almost like I was celebrated for being all of that.
SPEAKER_03But like when I was home, that wasn't necessarily the case. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02You're and you're saying something that touches on a lot of immigrant child experiences too, because how our parents experience that at home is not going to be is hardly ever the same. Yeah. When when people like when they experience us outside, right? You're you're right. You know, we're we're loud, we're boisterous, we're fun, we're funny, like all of those things. And and I remember having to like do that because, like you, I also got that message of you're supposed to be seen and not heard, right? And so my parents, for example, were shocked.
SPEAKER_02Okay, like their flappers were agasted whenever they would see me on stage. Yeah. Because we went to church and and I was a performer. I've always been a performer. I love being on stage, you know. And I think that's why people find it hard to believe that I'm an introvert, you know, because they're like, but you're so badly, yeah, I'm a performative extrovert, you know. And they would be shocked to see me on stage. And I would always play these different characters, right? And like little skits and things like that. Like I had one skit that I did one Christmas where I was I was the pilot and then I was several passengers in there too.
SPEAKER_02Wow. And I was voicing every one of them in different like voices, accents the whole night. And my parents were just shocked because they didn't see that version of me there at home. But that was also because I was shrinking, exactly, you know, while I was home. And I know that so many people can relate to that. Yeah, you know, and and also when I think about shrinking, I don't necessarily picture someone saying explicitly, like, you know, make yourself smaller, right? It's very subtle, subtle, right? It's not, it's not too in your face, but then it's always this thing of like, don't be too loud.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. Like, don't challenge adults, right? Don't talk back, don't be difficult, don't be selfish. Yes, right. And and you know, think about everybody else. You should be grateful, you know. Yes, like that, like things like that. And I I just I think I learned that maybe that's what being a girl meant, or being the daughter, like that's what it meant. Like being loved and being easy to deal with might might be connected.
SPEAKER_03Right, right.
SPEAKER_02And I don't know if you ever experienced that or ever felt that way.
SPEAKER_03I think I did, because I think I didn't get in as much trouble when I was following the rules and following what the rules were. And I think for me, I recognized how to play both very quickly, you know? And I think a story that I have is that my mom would actually come to my classroom and watch me on her lunch break because she was like, Did she work in the building? No, she left her job on her lunch break to like be in the bushes of my classroom.
SPEAKER_03But like I remember the fear when I came home one day and she was like, I saw you in class. And I'm like, what did I do in class? Like I'm going through, like, what did I do? What did I do? What did I do? And she was like, and you were just out of control. Like, I don't know what happened. I don't know who that person is. So there was just like so much where it's like, okay, am I being watched today? Am I being what will I be watched tomorrow? So, like, there was always a way in which that it was always reinforced that I needed to follow a specific guy because at some point my mom might show up at my my classroom and watch me from the door.
SPEAKER_03And it was like, it was like the scariest thing ever because she wasn't watching my brother, but she was definitely watching me and making sure that I was staying in line and that I wasn't doing too much. Um so it was definitely, it was definitely a funny thing now that I've grown up. Like, oh my gosh, like you could have been eating your lunch. However, you know, watching me in my class, I guess.
SPEAKER_02Or or running errands, yeah. You know, or going anything else, doing something else for yourself. Doing something that adults do, yeah, you know, for themselves. Yeah. So so let's, while we're on that topic, let's talk about obedience, right? Because sometimes respect and obedience get used interchangeably. Yeah. And I think it gets confusing for us, especially those of us who grew up in African households. And I'm speaking for as African households as somebody who grew up in one. Yeah. But in your home, what did obedience mean?
SPEAKER_03I think that there was a blind sense of obedience, right? My mom still scares me. And because we my big age. At my big age, yes, I am still afraid of my mom. And we'll always have a healthy affair of my mom. Um and we didn't live with my dad. So like it was very clear that my mom was like, You're you're not, you can't go anywhere, right? Like, this is the only house you've got, right? And so my dad wasn't like, I'll save you guys. He was afraid of everyone is afraid of my mom. You know what I mean? She is just, she is fiery.
SPEAKER_03And so, and she's the she's like the last of six, and yet she is the scariest out of all of them. Ain't that something? Yeah. Especially as a woman, too. Yeah, yeah. And there's three boys, three girls, and she's the last of six, and she's apparently very scared of everyone's scared of her in the family, in her family. So I think that like my mom, from the time that we could understand, she knew that there was a boundary and she said, I am your mom. And so, whatever your when you come into this house, whatever your friends do with their mom, that has nothing to do with me. You shake that off.
SPEAKER_03But when you're in this house, these are the expectations that I have for you. Don't do that over here. We don't do that over here. You know, and they always have like that one name that they can't quite get my my Michael. Like it's just like, okay, Michael's mom. I can't, I can't talk to her like Michael's mom, right? But I think it's I think it was just the foundation of obedience, yeah, and the idea that however she runs it is how she runs it. Even if she's wrong in running it, she's not apologizing for her wrongness. Apologize for what's because of what's you know, like there's grace for her, but there's not grace for us to make mistakes.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely not. Absolutely not. Now, were you allowed to disagree respectfully?
SPEAKER_03Disrespectfully, no. Okay. Yeah, never, never. I was never allowed to disagree. I could disagree in my head. Of course. Yeah, I was really good at disagreeing in my head, or like she would see the wheels turning when like things didn't quite make sense. But like, yeah, I was I was shadow boxing in my room, closing the door really hard, but then stopping it right before it closes.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, because how dare you try to like slam a door in her house? Yeah, in her house?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. So the door is coming off the hinges. Hinges? I I don't I think my mom was like, I could just create another person. I don't I you're gone out, you're gone.
SPEAKER_02Out, out, out, out. And and this is what I find fascinating because we spend so many years like teaching girls, especially, you know, listen to authority, you know, don't be disrespectful, be agreeable, don't make people uncomfortable, you know, like don't speak your mind and all that. And then we become older, we grow up, we become adults, we're in the workplace, and then all of a sudden they're telling us, well, why aren't you speaking out for yourself? Right? Like if your boss said something you didn't like it, why didn't you say something? Right? We're being taught to like set or or being expected, I should say, to set boundaries and speak our minds and advocate for ourselves.
SPEAKER_02And then I think about it, what like when did when did y'all teach me how to do that? You know, they didn't. You didn't teach me how to do that. And so how am I supposed to go into the workforce and then all of a sudden tell my boss, well, actually, I don't agree with you on that. Right. Because I there was never a foundation of self-advocacy, and there wasn't anything about even uh apologizing, owning up to anything, accountability, like all of those things. And and yet we're we're expected to do that as adults.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, we're supposed to switch. Like at some point, when we get to 25, I guess, we're supposed to switch and say, Oh yeah, like I taught you all of these things to like be obedient, but now I need you to actually advocate for yourself. And it's like, well, when does this the light switch on for us? When do we know? Because still, even with my mom, there are things that I can and can't say. There's still that level of you're, and she's always said this you can grow old every year, but you'll never be as old as me. So that's it. Oh, that's a bar.
SPEAKER_03That's a bar.
SPEAKER_02I might have to borrow that for one day. Okay. Maybe not say it in that way because you know, like I'm raising kids who will speak up and you know, you know, my I apologize to my kids. Yes, right? Like very important. And I allow them for them to disagree. And I always see my mother cringe whenever we have those like moments, but I want them to have a different kind of experience and to be able to like self-advocate and things like that. But I might have to put that in my back pocket, you know. Yeah, and and as we're talking about this, you know, I can't help but wonder like, how does a woman learn to trust her own voice after you have been rewarded for ignoring it?
SPEAKER_02Because then if you know you're you're compliant, you you you are quiet, you're agreeable, it's like, oh, Kadija is such a good girl. Such a good girl, you know. One day she'll find a fine horse band. You know, like still, still there.
SPEAKER_03You know, try to find and and actually, like, I think my mom's super like, how did I raise this girl? Because I am actually gay, so I am not finding a husband. Um, but yeah, I don't know, because I I do feel like that's also still where I'm working on like actively using my voice. Because again, when I was younger, I would use my voice, but then it felt like in order to survive my childhood, I had to like kind of dismiss it. So I feel like when I get into really close relationships, I question the impact of my voice, or it takes me a really long time to ruminate, process.
SPEAKER_03And then I asked, I have to talk to myself. Yeah, am I feeling the way that I'm feeling? Because and I I do everyone's side, right? Yeah. So it's like, oh, okay, so what did they say? What did I hear? Right. Was I because you're a you are a therapist, and so you know how to hold space for all of the parts. Yes, yes. And I have a lot of conversations with other people and how I want them to be that exist in my head. And then when I have a conversation with them, I'm so surprised that they don't say what I had practiced for them to say. I'm like, oh my gosh, like you're just going off script. That's so weird. Like, I really need you to conform to what's in my head.
SPEAKER_03Like the the scripts that I had in my head that you weren't privy to, that I was talking to myself at 2 a.m. and I couldn't go to bed because I was so like, like all of the stuff, all of this interaction that I had is now seeping in me. And it's also affecting my sleep. And then I'm like filled with guilt and shame. And like, why do I feel that way? I should be grateful that I even have a friend, right? Right. I should be grateful that like they love me or they care about me. I shouldn't be that mad or that angry instead of I actually have a visceral reaction to what was said or what was done to me.
SPEAKER_03And this is actually me letting them know how to care and love for me even more. I make it like I I pull in and I and I and I shrink and I'm like, I should just, I should just be grateful.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. Oh that that that in itself is a loaded conversation and like a whole episode on its own. And I'm just like thinking about the anxiety of that and having to hold all of those things, especially in the middle of the night. And I know I've been called into that sort of thing where I have the conversations in my head. And in my mind, I've had the conversation with the other person, and then I bring it up and they're looking at me like, what are you talking about? You know, and and I I even had that experience with my assistant a couple of times, and you know, she was blunt with me.
SPEAKER_02I was like, Phoebe, you be having those conversations with your head. And in your mind, you think that we've talked about this. No, I don't know about this project that you thought about and you're working on all of a sudden, and now I'm supposed to be, you know, producing some deliverables. And I just have to like sit back and be like, oh, you know what, you're right. Because, like you, in my mind, I've I've played out the whole episode. Right? Like the end credits have already rolled. Yeah. And they weren't even in the beginning credits. Now, now let's get into one thing that, you know, you you mentioned that I speaking of things that we can't stop thinking about or or the things that are in our heads, like blessings, right?
SPEAKER_02Talk to me about the connection that you see between obedience and and blessings.
SPEAKER_03So I think growing up and even at this age, I was so confused about blessings, mainly due to the flat fact that it's not quantified. So, like with most stuff in our world, it's like, okay, like you go to school, you get a job. There's some quantification of that. You know, I'm putting in work and I get something. But when my mom and my like aunts and uncles were talking about blessings, it just felt like there was a lot of gaps, and it also felt like it was on the backs of sacrifice of women. So my uncle didn't have to sacrifice as much as my aunts and my mom was.
SPEAKER_03Yet somehow the fruits of his labor of being at MIT and retiring early somehow quantified him as being blessed. Whereas my mom and my aunt had to work really long and kind of retire. Yeah. So there was like a way that I couldn't understand what exactly that meant, but I knew that there was something as far as the sacrificial part of being a girl and that my blessings would come someday at some point, somewhere, but you don't know when.
SPEAKER_03So then it's almost like you almost have to continue to keep that strive. Yeah. Because one day it will. It will come. But you don't know when. You don't know when. But you got to put in a lot of work in the back end. And I just felt like it was like, well, I just need to know when. So then maybe I can prep like two years before. Maybe I can do whatever I want to do for 10 years, and then two years I can really own in roots to the ground and receive my blessings. I just, I just couldn't get it. I couldn't get it.
SPEAKER_02Oh, because like so many of us heard some sort of version of that too, right? Yeah. Respect your parents and you'll be blessed. If you sacrifice for your parents, there's going to be a blessing. If you obey, you know, things will go well for you. If you honor your parents, you're going to live long. Right. And I couldn't help but wonder like, what happens, right, when inside a child, when when goodness and and obedience and parental approval and all of those things they come and blessings all come like tangled together, right? Like to me, it just felt like this complex, I don't know, vague, like you said, you know, thing mess.
SPEAKER_03It's like a uh I don't even know what it is. And it's like, okay, so if I get a new car, is that my blessings? Okay, but if I get in an accident, okay, I gotta get myself back on track. It's like, how do I even quantify what is actuality of like the pros? And when I'm listing all the blessings of my life, what does that even mean? But then also it's weird because there are people that are not doing what they're supposed to, and they're and they're still getting blessed. Like my uncle did not turn and give money back like he's supposed to. My mom and my aunts did sent money back all the time and got these people through college, and uncles and cousins and and their nephews, and my uncle didn't do that.
SPEAKER_03And yet, and yet MIT blessings have early returned. I I don't know. Just I think we were lied to. I I I think we were lied to. I think that blessings doesn't make sense, and I think it's a way to ensure whoever buys it, I think buys into it. I the idea is that you sacrifice your life or something. I think it's also in hopes that someone will turn and come and help you, but I don't think that that ever happens. Like, my mom has helped a lot of people, and my aunt has helped a lot of people, and yet our nephews are still on WhatsApp asking us, hey, I bet.
SPEAKER_03Hey, hey, hey. Like, why is your WhatsApp picture changing, but you're asking me for money? You you got a free college. My mom paid for you for free call. I didn't get free college for my mom. You got free college, and you're you're you have not turned back around. You're still reaching out, you're still asking, you're still saying, keep sending, keep sending.
SPEAKER_02You know, it's it's wild that you bring up this like this this WhatsApp thing and and people asking for for different things. And and I think about some of the people that our parents have invested in over the years. And sometimes I ask myself, what was the return on that?
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_02Right. But I'm sure they will convince themselves that the return on that is our success, our well-being, because this is what what it is. And and if you're a person of faith like me, you're also thinking in the back of your mind, well, we say that we trust in God and and God's will is going to be done. So is it really tied to you sending home money when I needed shoes? Right. Or or I needed, I wanted to go on vacation. Right. And you're like, no, vacation is a luxury. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02You know, we need to take care of our people back home. Right. Right. That is such a hot button like issue. And some some episodes ago, we had a conversation about like finances and things like that. And I think we might need to have another conversation about that, you know, and about these investments that we make in in our family members and the ways in which we kind of reinforce, you know, this this dependence as a culture.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Right. And I I know that, you know, we we have been trained to take care of each other and all of those things, but it's like, can we even like respect our parents and also like disagree with some of the choices that they're making and how they impact us? Right. Can we honor our culture and and choose something that our families wouldn't choose? Right. Right. Could we be the ones to like set the limits around how much money we're sending home every month? Right.
SPEAKER_03And and saying no to people, you know, the ex the excess of people that I've never met but somehow know me and my WhatsApp.
SPEAKER_02Listen, we we've had conversations about that where like I've had to set some limits around that. I'm like, you know, you never give my my number to any family members without asking me. Yeah. You don't, we don't do any of those things. And my friends have been very, you know, respectful with me around that. But I think also because, you know, like um I'm older now and there's a different level of like connection that we have. But it took a while to even get there. Yeah. Like it's in even thinking about that still scares me. Yeah. You know, like I'll I'll still at this point, like I'll go out and maybe like it's in the evening and my heart is still racing, like, ooh, I need to wrap higher up and get back back home.
SPEAKER_02But it's not even like getting back home to my children because I know they're taken care of, they're protected, they're fine. But it's this idea of my mother.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Yep. Right?
SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm. Yep. Yep. So so I even have to like ask you, like, can you can you love your mother and still tell her no?
SPEAKER_03That's a loaded question. I don't think I've ever said no. I think I've said a softer, like, I don't know. Let me think about that. I can't make the decision right now. Yeah. Um, I don't think I've ever said no. I think I've I've softened it. But I think there's also a part of me that my mom doesn't really ask for a lot right now. So there's not really much that, you know, that's going on. I think, I think the last conversation we had is I I I didn't agree with how she felt like she was disrespectful.
SPEAKER_03And I I was she was like, well, you know, in our culture, we don't apologize because family's family. And I said, and I don't agree with that. And so when you're ready to apologize, I will be here, but I'm not gonna continue with this. Wow. And and then the conversation was done. But you know, my mom's good at you know, hanging up about people. She's really good about hitting the N button. Even though, even though as siblings, we all pay for her phone. But I can't say, like, well, we pay for your phone like she used to, but we definitely pay for her phone.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02But so can you be a good daughter and still disappoint your parents? Absolutely.
SPEAKER_03And I have learned how to disappoint my mom a lot, a lot, because I think it's at a risk of me. If I continue to placate and I continue to get small, it's at risk to me. And I think I initially I think I was like, you know, I moved down to the Charlotte area. I want to create a home. I know that's very important for my mom. I want to at least have like a bedroom or so she can live with me. Like the honorable things, all of the things. Like, I'm gonna move her down here, it's gonna be great.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03She she just doesn't follow roles either. So, like, I we haven't gotten her here. But how however, I felt like there was so much, but I feel like there was a way in which like there was also a conversation where that comparison, and it's so hard being African because you're compared to other Africans doing other things or Caribbeans. Like my mom was comparing me to Rihanna. Oh, my mom said, you know, Rihanna, Rihanna, Rihanna got her mom a house. I said, Rihanna.
SPEAKER_02Also, do we know what Rihanna sacrificed to be able to get to where she's at to be able to get the house?
SPEAKER_03I said, wow. I was okay with being compared to someone at my church, but now Rihanna is like, I'm not the bar, the bar is the bar is too high. The bar is too high.
SPEAKER_02Yikes.
SPEAKER_03So I do think that there was a way that I recognized that I would have to disappoint my mom. And I also think me being gay was very disappointing to my mom. And I was okay with that. I feel like I'm by, but like when I had the conversation with my mom, I specifically didn't tell her because I didn't want, I wanted her to sit with the uncomfortability that I might marry a woman instead of marrying a man. And so, you know, two can play that game. And I wanted her to sit in that.
SPEAKER_02I I just wanted to like know how amazing it is and how much strength it must have also taken for you to like allow for her to sit in that discomfort. Because I can imagine you trying to maybe like placate, right? And and trying not to disappoint her either by playing small or minimizing this part of your identity, and just, you know, well, I mean, I I could still end up with a man, you know, and and just kind of rolling with that, but you didn't do that. And and and I imagine that for people who are watching or listening, like that in itself is such an inspiration too, because a lot of us have hidden all of these different parts of ourselves in order to keep the peace, in order to not not disappoint them and all those things.
SPEAKER_02And you talked about even like moving to Charlotte and all the things. And here's a problem like first daughters or oldest daughters, we we end up leaving home, right? But then that job description that we talked about earlier in the episode, it still comes with us. Yeah, it still follows us, right? And and I have to think to myself, like, how does this first daughter role like even show up in in my adult life? I moved across the ocean and it was still following me. Yeah, right. I still had to do all the things, right? And and so so even for you, like even after moving out, like now you're paying her a phone bill, like you're doing all of these things and still showing up and carrying on these responsibilities, but like for you, how has that role showed up as an adult?
SPEAKER_02Like now in your adult life, right? How is it showing up in your relationships and in your friendships and at work?
SPEAKER_03I think it's there's a lot of doing that I had to learn to unlearn, right? I think even when I moved, when I was in grad school, like you know, we're in Greensburg, Pennsylvania, but my mom was still, there was stuff happening at home, and she's like, bless. My mom's like, hey, I sent you text. I need you to put this, and this was before AI. Now, if AI existed, I would have been great. But like, she's like, I need you to put put this letter into something, some kind of form. I called your brother, he doesn't answer. He's at work, right? And like, and you know, and she's like, I need you to draft this, and then I need you to print all of this out, and I need you to send it to me overnight.
SPEAKER_03And it was just like, and then I would, again, she'd be like, uh, show me what you got. And it was like, I don't like the wording of that. Let's redo this. And it was just like, I am this far away, and I'm yet, I have to still draft stuff and go to, you know, Kinko's to print something out and then overnight it because it's it's a crisis that's happening in her world. But I think as I've gotten older, I've recognized that one, there's gonna be times she's gonna call that I'm not going to answer because I am doing something. Because you're busy, you're an adult. I'm busy and I'm an adult and I have my own things that I have to do.
SPEAKER_03Right. And I think now that I'm older and we're a little apart in our connection and our relationship, I think there's a part of me that recognizes, okay, what kinds of relationships do I want to have, platonically and romantically, where I am not always doing. Yeah. I'm in this era of soft life because it's working for me. Go you. Thank you. And so I think the friends I'm making now understand that my worth is not attached to what I do. Yeah. If I can come, I come. If I can't, I can't. But they don't require me to always be on.
SPEAKER_03They allow me to just exist authentically. And so I think I have stepped back in feeling like I have to manage everything or be the best friend or be the good person and always, you know, always calling to check in, but never really wanting to be checked in with because I'm fine, I'm good, I'm good. But how are you? How are you doing? What's going on? I know I know I saw this post, it looked a little weird. How you doing? Right. So I've realized that like there's just stuff that I'm gonna miss. But my friends, I think, have done a really good job. In the new friends that I'm making, I'm very clear about like aligning with people that you know can do the same thing and can reciprocate that same energy.
SPEAKER_02I love that. I really I love that. I love that for you. And and I imagine like over time you've gotten better and better with like being more comfortable, you know, like receiving care rather than giving it, you know, because like there's a very interesting paradox there for for us as, you know, first daughters and women, because sometimes that the woman that everybody is describing as so strong, so resilient, so reliable, like you know, all those things privately we're thinking, I I wish somebody could hold me, right?
SPEAKER_02Do do you notice how exhausted I am? And I think in some ways we train people to not even check in on us because they think that we've got it.
unknownYeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02You know, they think we've got it and and we're good. Yeah. We could have a whole conversation about that, you know, a whole conversation. But I I just I I just want to say that I appreciate your your honesty around. This is because a lot of this, too, that that is really important for this podcast, you know, as we're talking about between two worlds, is that we don't want to throw these parts of our culture away, right? But we also want to name the problematic parts and how it's showing up for us as adults, right? Because it's not like we don't want, we don't want the takeaway for those who are watching or listening.
SPEAKER_02We don't want people to think, oh, our culture is bad, or we're bashing our culture, or individualism is good, or you know, you have to have boundaries, boundaries, boundaries, boundaries, or like move away and block everybody on WhatsApp. No, that's not that's not what we're saying. There's parts of our culture that are absolutely beautiful. There's the family, there's the language, there's the food, there's the responsibility, there's community, right? I'm always telling people like I'm not self-made, I am community made, right? Because Phoebe is who she is and she's functioning in all these ways and she seems so like resilient and doing all those because I have a whole system, a whole network, a whole village that like holds me together and holds me.
SPEAKER_02I'm about to like be outside doing all these things because I have a mother, for example, who is going to help me with my boys and like and like still show up. Yeah. So then there's all these things, and at the same time, you know, we are able to like hold on to it, all of it. Right. And so, so for for us, you know, how do we keep these values without erasing ourselves, right? Especially as as first daughters, what what's that gonna look like, right?
SPEAKER_03And I think I think one of the biggest things that I know is that, you know, even being Sierra Leonean, we we get agile. Like we we have such such so much, you know. Right, like you can you can meet someone that's Sierra Leonean and like you can feel it. You can feel you can feel the culture. Like even if you're not Sierra Leonean, yes, African, like you can feel the culture, you can feel like when you eat food, when you eat fufu, like there's just there's just like I feel like I like expand when I eat our food again and and then I add being Caribbean on top of that.
SPEAKER_03So I feel like there's so much, there's so much. And I think again, I have the honor to have this kind of conversation, to have some awareness about it, right? In a way that I'm having conversations with my brothers and sisters and my cousins in ways that our parents didn't have the opportunity because they were also surviving. Like, even when I'm thinking about having kids, like I don't think my mom had that conversation about having kids and what that looked like. So I recognize there's some privilege in my ability to have conversations like this.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, but I think our culture is phenomenal. Like I just, I don't know, there's just so much. There's food and community, and you can meet someone and you're connected.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that you can just see on their face on their face, yeah. Right. That like they're they're getting like I just rented somebody at Costco a couple of months ago, and I could just see on her face. I was like, and then she heard me say something to my my one of my kids in in Chi. Yeah, and she was like, Oh, you're from Ghana too. I was like, you know, you can change numbers, okay. I see you see. You know, I I just love that for us. And and I appreciate you like, you know, saying that too and and naming it because again, I don't want people to to hear us having these conversations and think that we are, you know, way too advanced, or we think that we're better than our culture or anything like that.
SPEAKER_02I think it's more about like how do we bridge the gap, right? How do we how do we bridge that? And so speak speaking of bridging the gap, you know, and on every episode, I have a bridge the gap tip. And and this one is for the first daughters, you know, for for us, right? And so before automatically saying yes, we have to like ask ourselves, right? If nobody was disappointed by my decision, and I'm saying this for all of us too, right? If nobody was disappointed, what would I choose? What would I actually choose, right? Because it's not, it's not, you know, like our families' needs don't matter, or or not not because like our culture doesn't matter, like all of those things matter, right?
SPEAKER_02But our needs also have to be in the equation. Yes. We weren't taught that. And now we're starting to learn how to also prioritize ourselves to things that we're needing because we have to build some sustainability. Yes, right? We have to, we have to to build something that we can keep going with, not just for ourselves, but also for the generations behind us, because we also want them to do something differently while still maintaining all of these values and these pieces of our culture, right? And so you don't have to stop loving your parents if you disagree with them.
SPEAKER_02You can love them and disagree with them, you know. Maybe the N in your no might not be as strong and solid, but you know what I'm saying, like a little subtle, like you know what I'm saying? So, so you can you don't have to be selfish, right? Because you know, you're you're choosing yourself, right? And and and perhaps what it means to be a good daughter is not that we have to be invisible.
SPEAKER_01No, right?
SPEAKER_02We can be good daughters and be visible and be ourselves, and and there's so much beauty in the first daughter experience. I I I wouldn't trade that for the world, right? Right, we're we're the leaders, we're caretakers, we're resourceful, we make things happen. Yeah, and and some of us even make things happen in our sleep. We should do when we're coming up with our different scenarios, we are and and and we also carry stories, we carry recipes, we carry traditions. I'm like the unofficial family historian because I I have all of the pictures, like all the aunties, uncles, yeah, all of the things.
SPEAKER_02I have a little folder, I have it backed up on a drive, and then also like an online drive because those are the things that really matter to me. I'm big about like history and memories and things like that. And so it's not maybe that we want to be less caring or we want the generation after us to be less caring, but it's like it's it's realizing that care does not have to flow only in one direction. Yes, right? The care can go back and forth. Yes, right? We can be loving and we can also allow people to love us because that's one of the things that some of us are still learning how to do, right?
SPEAKER_02And that maybe our strength is not going to disappear just because we asked for help. Yes, right? We're not less than because we we disagree, right? Or we we decided to say, I can't do it today. Right. You know, and and in so many ways we're still learning how to function in these ways. And it's it's a work in progress. Yeah, it's a work in progress, and there's room for us to be loved. Yes. As as who we are. That's who we are. You know, so as so as so, as so, as so, right? So, so for for every first daughter who is listening or or watching, what do you want to tell them?
SPEAKER_02What do you want to say? What's the takeaway?
SPEAKER_03I think the one thing that I want to say is that one, you matter and you're the backbone of the family. You you you are, right? And you're also very important to yourself, and you have to come home to yourself at the end of the day. So, regardless, even being the backbone as the family grows, you have to know who you are. Yeah. Because we can't have another generation where the first daughter loses herself.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And then she's just a watery version for the next ver. And then every first daughter is taught that I get watered down while the family continues on, even though it's on the backs of me and even it's on my sacrifice. So I think you have to come home to yourself and find your voice.
SPEAKER_02You have to come home to yourself and find your voice. I love that. I think we deserve a support group as first daughters. I I I you know, yeah, I'm gonna do that. I'm I'm gonna I'm gonna start a little support group for us, you know, like a little four-week little group or something. Yeah. So if you're watching or you're listening, make sure that you follow at Dr. Phoebe Brackel on TikTok, on Instagram, Facebook, I think Facebook, I'm like sit with sit with Phoebe or something like that. I don't use Facebook that much, but but yeah, first daughters, we're we're going to get we're going to get a support group very soon.
SPEAKER_02And so be on the lookout. So thank you so much, Khadijah, for for having this conversation with me, for naming some of these things that I know are not easy to talk about. So for you to come on here and say all of these things and speak your truth and be so funny while doing it, also. I I appreciate it so much. Thank you. Thank you for having me. Yeah, this it's been such a pleasure. And and if you're looking for for Khadija and where to find her, I'll put that information in the show notes. And so we'll be we'll be in touch. Yes.
SPEAKER_02We'll we'll be back for for more. We'll have some more of these conversations. And I also appreciate you all for watching and listening this this season. I think it's been such a blessing just to hear the feedback, to talk about some of these difficult topics, and I don't take it for granted at all. So thank you so much for for listening. Thank you for being here, and I will see you at the bridge.
Send us Fan Mail What happens when the version of you everyone rewards is the version you can’t sustainably keep being? For doctors, lawyers, therapists, engineers, and academics, competence can lead to more...
Send us Fan Mail What happens when the language you speak, the accent you have, or the culture you come from becomes the very thing someone uses to make you feel different? In this special episode of Between Two Worlds...
Send us Fan Mail I’m 37, have three kids, a mortgage, a PhD, and a whole therapy practice. Yet somehow, I’m still not grown enough to leave the house without explaining where I’m going. 😂 If you grew up in an immigrant...
Send us Fan Mail What happens when the person who is right for you isn't the person your family imagined for you?In this episode of Between Two Worlds with Dr. Phebe, Dr. Phebe sits down with psychologist Dr. Yuxin Sun...
Send us Fan Mail Our parents spent years asking, “What will happen to my children?” But eventually, many of us start asking a different question: What will happen to my parents? In this episode of Between Two Worlds...