Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Being an Engineer

Being an Engineer artwork

Lucas Pianegonda | How to Choose Sustainable Materials for Medical Devices

Nov 20, 202642 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Lucas R. Pianegonda is the founder of Gradical, a Switzerland-based consultancy focused on helping medical technology companies make better and more sustainable decisions about plastics. Over the course of his career, Lucas has developed expertise spanning polymer science, material testing, product development, regulatory compliance, manufacturing, and sustainability, and he has now supported more than 40 MedTech companies in improving how they use plastics. Lucas earned both his bachelor’s and master’s degrees in Materials Science and Engineering from ETH Zürich. His graduate work included research into 3D-printed soft robotics, and he later built his career around the evaluation and selection of polymer materials, including roles involving material characterization, international material-change projects, processing, compliance, and supply-chain considerations. His work gives him a particularly broad view of material selection - not simply as a question of mechanical properties, but as a decision that can affect manufacturing, validation, regulatory risk, cost, sourcing, and the environmental footprint of a product. Through Gradical, Lucas advocates for a more structured approach to plastics selection in MedTech. Rather than defaulting to familiar materials or choosing a resin based on a single requirement, he encourages engineering teams to evaluate the complete set of technical, processing, regulatory, commercial, and sustainability requirements before committing to a material. He is also a board member of the European Medical Polymer Division of the Society of Plastics Engineers, serves on the VDI technical committee for plastics in medical technology, and lectures at ETH Zürich. Lucas is also the host of MedTech Sustainability by Design, where he speaks with experts working across medical devices, plastics, regulatory affairs, product development, and sustainability. Across his consulting, education, and industry work, his broader mission is to challenge conventional thinking about plastics and help engineers build medical products that perform well for patients while making smarter use of materials and resources. LINKS: Lucas R. Pianegonda LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/lucas-r-pianegonda-81142b110/ MedTech Sustainability by Design Podcast: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UChPQB4eXQz3c_U2zZXAmEuQ Gradical GmbH Website: https://gradical.ch/ Get in contact: https://calendly.com/lucas-pianegonda-gradical/discovery-call-gradical Subscribe to the show to get notified so you don't miss new episodes every Friday. The Being An Engineer podcast is brought to you by Pipeline Design & Engineering. Pipeline partners with medical & other device engineering teams who need turnkey equipment like cycle test machines, custom test fixtures, automation equipment, assembly jigs, inspection stations and more. You can find us at www.teampipeline.us Watch the show on YouTube: www.youtube.com/@TeamPipelineus

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Lucas PianegondaSo people think, you know, greener, better for the planet is what more sustainable mean, means. But to me it means, you know, to be carried on into the future without detriment, you know? And that means not only environmental sustainability, but also economic sustainability and, you know, also social sustainability, which I, in med tech, translate as patient outcome, you know?

Aaron MoncurHello, and welcome to another exciting episode of the Being an Engineer podcast. Today we've got Lucas Pianegonda, founder of Gratical, which is a globally recognized company, and Lucas himself is an expert in the sustainable plastics for medical technology space. Lucas has helped over 40 med tech companies use plastics more sustainably. He's also developing AI for plastic selection and building his own database to make material selection faster and easier for all you engineers out there.

Aaron MoncurLucas hosts the podcast Med Tech Sustainability by Design, exploring the intersection of med tech, sustainability, and plastics, and he was kind enough to have me on his podcast recently. That episode should be coming out at some point in the near-ish future, so keep an eye out for that one. And also gracious enough to agree to be a guest here on the Being an Engineer podcast. So Lucas, welcome, and thank you so much for spending some time with me today to educate engineers on sustainability.

Lucas PianegondaYeah. Hello and welcome. I'm super happy to be here

Aaron MoncurOkay, well le- let's dig into this. What, what pulled you into material science, you know, back towards the beginning of your career and, and then into sustainability?

Lucas PianegondaI mean, you know, when I was like seven, you know, I don't know if you had this in the US, but we had this like friendship booklets, and I usually wanted to write in there, you know, either inventor or then later I wrote in engineer. And, um, you know, my dad then told me, you know, "If you wanna be an engineer, you have to go to basically university." And I was like, "Yeah, sure, I'm gonna do that then." then he told me, "But yeah, then, then you have to do gymnasium," you know, which, which is like kind of sets you up to the path of higher education.

Lucas Pianegonda"Yeah, then I'm gonna do that." And so I did. And, uh, with, what was it? 26, I was inventor. You know, I invented, um, you know, 3D printing, uh, silicone ink. So, you know, I, I kind of always knew that I wanted to be an engineer. And materials, uh, I found it very interesting. I think in school I really loved chemistry. I didn't wanna study chemistry, but I wanted to have it, you know, applicable. I wanna, I wanna touch what I, what I do.

Lucas PianegondaSo yeah, this is, this is how I, I went an engineer. I think I, I was born, I was born an engineer, and I always knew

Aaron MoncurW- was there ever a moment, um, during your upbringing or maybe during your formal education when you learned something that was so intriguing to you about materials and you thought, "Okay, this is it. This is, this is what I want"? Um, or did you have an experience or anything like that, or was it more of a gradual realization?

Lucas PianegondaOh, uh, oh, I really loved my, like, my first class in chemistry. That, that was basically it. Like, I loved chemistry. I was-- It just made sense to me, and I really, really loved that in, you know, high school, gymnasium. and then I, I went to u- you know, kind of look into some classes for chemistry university, and it was just, like, so far detached from any real application. I think it was, like, photosensitive, um, complex building or whatever it was that they were studying, and it was like n-n-no one is ever gonna use this.

Lucas PianegondaI, I'd rather have something that is in between physics and chemistry, and there was material science at ETH, which is very close to me and a very, very good uni-university. So this is why I decided to, to go there. Like, I wanted something to, that has to do with physics and chemistry you know, was applicable and therefore I, I then did, uh, material science and engineering at ETH

Aaron MoncurTerrific. Terrific. Um, uh, you, you are an expert in sustainability now. How did you, uh, how did you get there from, you know, an interest in materials? Was it just a natural evolution to sustainability?

Lucas PianegondaUm, so I did went into plastic industry and that may be just caused by, uh, vicinity. So, you know, it's basically I, I grew up in Rytins and then, you know, it's like two villages, uh, further apart there is a big plastic manufacturer. I had an internship with them and, and you know, uh, I, I-- at the end of my studies I, I started there. And so I got into plastics and after that I started with a legal manufacturer of medical devices/CDMO kind of thing.

Lucas PianegondaThey're kind of in between. And there the management was, was in 2020 they were like, "Yeah, you need to, you need to do sustainability." So it's-- it was basically like on the job I got in touch with it and, you know, uh, gradually I think I fell in love with the, with the topic. You know, I always in my studies I was interested in, you know, making the world better and, and you know, more sustainable. And now that I have kids I want my, my kids to have a planet too. So it-- this is, this is how I got into it.

Lucas PianegondaAnd then, you know, at the point that I founded my own company, I really found that meta companies actually it-- this is what they're very interested in, you know? What, what can we do in terms of sustainability and, you know, how can we comply to regulations? Those are the two topics that, that tended to stick so, you know, I went with it

Aaron MoncurYeah, that's, that's wonderful. Um, oh darn, I had a great question for you. Oh yeah, that's what it was. So the word sustainability, I think pretty much any engineer out there will hear that word and be like, "Yeah, I know what sustainability is." But how do you think about sustainability? Do you have like a concise definition that, that you like to use? Or like what does that word really mean to you?

Lucas PianegondaOh, I mean, that word, uh, that word has been abused in the past. I, I think it degraded some… It, like, sustainability meant one thing when it was invented, and then it degraded into just ecology. So people think, you know, greener, better for the planet is what more sustainable mean, means. But to me it means, you know, to be carried on into the future without detriment, you know? And that means not only environmental sustainability, but also economic sustainability and, you know, also social sustainability, which I, in med tech, translate as patient outcome, you know?

Lucas PianegondaLike patient safety, patient outcome. And you'll have to achieve all three of them to make a truly sustainable, you know, medical device. Or to make a truly sustainable choice, you have to hit all three of the KPIs. So you have to be better in all of, all of them and, you know, to be-- can be carried on into the future without detriment

Aaron MoncurAnd be carried to the future without detriment. That's a great concise definition. Okay, so let's, let's talk practical applications here for sustainability. One of the phrases that you might hear often from your customers when, when selecting a material for a device, medical device, is, "Well, we're just gonna use ABC because we've always used that material." How, how common do you hear that? How commonly do you hear that, and wh-wh-what are some of the, um, uh… Should that be a red flag to, to engineering teams if they're hearing that phrase pop up?

Lucas PianegondaI, I, I, yeah, it's definitely a red flag to me, but, you know, I hear it a lot. You know, the two, the two most common, uh, defaults in, in med tech, in choosing a med tech material, any material, but also plastics, is have always used this material and our supplier recommended it. Like, those two are the, the two defaults, and I would say it's like 80% of the materials is like we have always used th-this material, so we're going to use that material. No matter if it's a good choice or not, it's like the, th-everybody uses this or we have always used it, so we, we will continue to be using this.

Lucas PianegondaI think it comes down to change is pain in med tech. You know, it's difficult to change a material. It's you need to do all the biocomp, sometimes you need to do clinical. It's hard to change a material, and it is one of the most fundamental things there is to a device, you know, the material and the matter it is made of. So, you know, changing the process, changing the design, the engineers are usually much more open to that, but a material is such a, you know, a fundamental change that they're usually very averse to it.

Lucas PianegondaBut, you know, changing the material also has a huge lever, uh, lever. It, it has the lever of cost and it has the lever of, you know, environmental sustainability and also has the lever of, um, you know, patient outcome. So if you choose the right material, you can do a lot better than, you know, just the defaults. You know, what is the chance that we have always used this material and our supplier recommended it is the optimal choice? It's very, very, uh, small that, that probability

Aaron MoncurWhen I choose a, a component, for example, in an assembly that I'm working on, it's usually pretty straightforward, right? Like I need a M4 screw or a, an M5 screw, or I need a camera with this particular resolution and it has to see in color, something like that. When it comes to materials, I mean, if it's, if, uh, some of the common materials are fairly straightforward, right? Like stainless steel or Delrin or aluminum, right? Kinda the standard choices that a lot of engineers work on, at least in my space, space, which is mostly machine design and fixturing and things like that.

Aaron MoncurBut when it comes to a mass-produced device and you're dealing with plastic, there are so many choices out there, it can feel very overwhelming. What, what's a, a process that you've used to help engineers go through what can feel like a very overwhelming decision matrix?

Lucas PianegondaYeah. So it's as with everything in life, um, you know, figure out what you want and then figure out how to get there and, and, uh, then do a lot of volume so that it's unprobable that you don't find something. that's a general good advice in life. However, you know, over the last five years I've developed this framework. We, we call it the Great Match Framework because, you know, everything has to have a good, good marketing

Aaron MoncurGood branding. Yep, that's right

Lucas Pianegondabr- good branding. But it basically comes down to, you know, figure out what your device needs to do In, you know, what, what kind of price can you charge for this? You know, what kind of, uh, application is it in? You know, what kind of biocomp? What kind of risk class? What markets? And with that you can understand, you know, the regulatory, uh, for that, you know. And then, uh, what is also important is, you know, what, what, what do you wanna do in terms of sustainability? Do you wanna reduce your carbon footprint? Do you wanna make this, you know, reusable?

Lucas PianegondaWhat, what kind of things do you wanna do with it? then you derive what the device has to do. From, from that you can derive the properties and the requirements that you have for your material. So that's the technical, the economical, the processability, the regulatory, and the sustainability requirements. Those five categories of requirements. And how we do this, we have, we have this Excel sheet, um, where we go through basically a questionnaire and say, you know, "What do you wanna do in terms of price? What do you not wanna do in terms of modulus? What do you wanna do in terms of strength?" So you have these requirements that always come up, and then you assign to them a certain weight.

Lucas PianegondaSo how important is this to, to you? For a mass-produced consumable, very price sensitive, price is the most important physical property of a plastic. Now that's a joke in, in plastic study. It's the most important property or physical property of a plastic. And then, you know, what kind of processes do you wanna apply to this? You know, do you wanna laser weld it? Do you wanna, you know, pad print on it? Whatever you wanna do, and how important is this? you go through that list. So you have a requirement, then you have a weight to it.

Lucas PianegondaAnd then you have to go out to, you know, the many thousands and thousands of grade of plastics there are and look for the ones who fit in this, you know, profile roughly. then what you do is you take every requirement, and that's painstakingly judge them on that requirement. So you give it points and then, you know, weight times points gives, you know, weight times judgment gives your total amount of points. And if you basically then sum up all the requirements, you get a total score.

Lucas PianegondaAnd with that total score you can rank order alternatives. So if you have 20 alternatives, you can run it through that system and it'll rank order that list. And the best one, that is usually the one that I recommend because that is the best trade-off. That's the best bang for your buck material. And, um, you know, we, we have built a database with currently 33,000 materials, uh, plastics in there, and we can basically run all of them so we know the best plastic there is for, for whatever you are trying to achieve given that you understand your requirements

Aaron MoncurVery logical workflow to back into materials that are the right choice because I could see a lot of us just being like,"All right, uh, huh, nylon. Eh, no, it didn't quite work. Okay, uh, how about polypropylene? Eh, no." But your workflow, your process makes a lot of sense. Start with the end in mind, define your requirements, and then back into the available options that support those requirements

Lucas PianegondaAnd, and coming to, to your camera, to your screw, to your tubing, whatever, you can apply the same system. It does, it does work very well. You know, you have to understand what it has to do. You know, it has to have a certain res- resolution, has to have a certain price, uh, or fit within my budget, has to, you know, have color or not. How important is color to me? Um, you know, what does the camera has to be mounted to? And then you go and look on the market, okay, what kind of cameras are there that can fit to these requirements, and you rate them all, and it's basically… It is a system of choosing, you know.

Lucas PianegondaIt-- this is not limited to plastics. It's, it's called value analysis, this, the, the method. And you, you can apply it to any sort of alternative, search that you're looking for. So it, it, it is very widely applicable

Aaron MoncurMy next question was gonna be once you have these technical requirements defined, is there a database that you can go to, to, you know, down select, put those requirements in and, like, use that as a tool to down select, uh, your available plastics? But it sounds like you have already built that database, and I promise Lucas did not pay me to say this or even ask me to say this, but where, where can engineers find that database? Because it seems like a really useful tool.

Lucas PianegondaYeah. So we're, we're currently in basically, uh, what, what an engineer would call, you know, beta testing. So we rolled it out to our, uh, program members. So I have this online learning program where people can learn about plastics and sustainability and, you know, how to choose them, material compliance, and all of this stuff. And we're rolling it out to them and, you know, we- I'll, I'll see where, where I can take this. You know, there are commercially available databases. The problem with those is, you know, the data that is in there, that tends to be in there forever.

Lucas PianegondaYou know, the plastics industry is kind of mobile. You know, companies get bought and sold and, you know, rebranded and whatnot, and grades get disc- discontinued, so you need to keep it up to date. And, uh, you know, if, if you want to have access to the database, just g- shoot, shoot me a message on LinkedIn and, and we can help you-- hook you up

Aaron MoncurAmazing. All right. Let's talk a little bit more about sustainability and the, specifically the economics of sustainability. Is it, is it true or is it a myth that if you use a sustainable material, it's gonna cost more?

Lucas PianegondaSo the-- what traditionally would be defined as sustainable plastics would be either recycled or, uh, bio-based plastics. And, you know, we, we can go into, you know, bio-plastics and whatnot, you know, because there's also a distinction between, you know, bio-based and biodegradable, let's leave that out the window. If you use a different feedstock create your plastic than fossil, fossil has the advantage of economy of scale.

Lucas PianegondaYou know, we have taken, you know, the last hundred years, we have dug up oil and gas and made out of it, also plastic, but, you know, also fuel, and it has the econom-e-economics and the process efficiency behind it of a hundred years of development. So if you use a bio-based or if you use a recycled content material or chemical recycled content material, it's gonna be more expensive. However, material is not the only lever you can play.

Lucas PianegondaYou can play a lot of levers. You know, to make a good product, you need process, you need design, and you need the material. And all of that-- those together, and if you optimize them the right way, usually you can take out also cost out of your device. If you have… take this example. You know, this, these auto-injectors or, you know, this is an injector pen. Auto-injectors and injector pens, you know, they have-- they've taken off the last few years. You know, GLP-1 antagonist drugs have catapulted them into the stratosphere.

Lucas Pianegondain the hundred millions and billions. And this quite a complex device, you know. Such a m-injector pen has, like, ten to fifteen components. Now, if you have something like this, you can rec-reduce component count, you can reduce the matur-- uh, amount of material that is used, you can play around how the stresses are distributed. So maybe you, like, if you have a, a, a metal component in there, you know, to take a lot of the stress, you can downgrade some of the materials that it w-would be usually made from, know, your engineering plastics.

Lucas PianegondaAnd like this, if you play these, what we call eco design, w-was-- used to be called, you know, optimizing your product, that can then lead to not only ecological gain, you know, better environmental footprint, but also, you know, cost, um, i-implications, so, you know, cost savings and easier processes. So, you know, it's not true that environmental sustainability always costs you. Uh, like, if you play the green advocate, you know, if you're causing environmental damage and not paying for it, you know, that's, that's also, like, a thing that is going on, you know.

Lucas PianegondaY-you just leave the bill for someone else to pay.

Aaron MoncurYeah

Lucas Pianegondaso that's, that's also an argument that can be made.

Aaron MoncurSo companies who are using sustainable materials, is it generally the case that the CEO or someone of great influence at the company just has this almost altruistic desire to do the right thing and keep our planet healthy and clean, and, and that's why they go into sustainability? Or are there other commercial-based, more economic reasons that would motivate a company to use sustainable materials?

Lucas PianegondaYeah, I mean, overall, I think there are-- I, I have found four motivational, ground motivational forces there are for, uh, sustainability in, especially in med tech. You know, the first one you mentioned is basically intrinsic motivation. So, you know, the CEO, the founder, the, the family that owns the company is convinced that this is the right step, and therefore they have an intrinsic motivation to do, uh, you know, to be more sustainable.

Lucas PianegondaThat's one, um, let's say motivational force and I, I usually I tend to find this is the weakest one. You know, the, the… not, not because I think that founders and, and owners cannot move stuff, but it's usually, you know, companies exist to serve their customers, and if good companies exist to serve their customers. And that means, you know, customers are a really strong force. so your customers as a med tech usually is like hospitals and, you know, healthcare providers, and if those, you know, have tender questions that ask about sustainability, that's a very strong moving force.

Lucas PianegondaSo, you know, you see, for example, the NHS, uh, in the UK that has put out some requirements for their, you know, for their tenders. For example, if middle of next year, uh, I think it's like Q- Q1, Q2, uh, 2027, if you do not have a net zero roadmap, so like how do we get to net zero in our, in, in your company? If you're a supplier above a certain, you know, threshold like 5 million, you're no longer going to be a supplier. So either you do it or you're no longer a supplier.

Lucas PianegondaSo that is a very strong motivational force. then it is, uh, competition. So i- if you're a healthcare provider, you're always being told by med tech, you know, "Oh, we can't do that more sustainably because, you know, patient safety." And then there comes, uh, around the company who may be doing, you know… Uh, let, let's take, let's take the injector pen. So, um- I was at Pharmapack this year, January 2026. There was a company called EcoInject, and they launched their new sustainable, um, Uh, less components, better footprint, a lot better footprint, and, uh, costing less, you know?

Lucas Pianegondathey're better in economics, they're better in ecology, and they basically proved everybody wrong who, who said they, they couldn't do it. So what happened after their five-minute TED Talk where they presented this, the-- a huge bubble of, of comp-- of, uh, people formed around their booth, and 80% were, were their competitors. They were just trying to figure out like,"What the hell are they doing?" Like,"How are they doing this?" You know? It's like they were just, "Ah, geez, I think we need to do this too." So, know, competition is a very strong moving force towards, you know, any innovation, but also sustainability.

Lucas PianegondaSo if your competition is doing something that has a green stamp on it, just to put it like bluntly, then everybody else thinks, "Okay, we need to do this too," because if they sell it, you know, the probability that I can sell it is pretty high. And the last one is, you know, obviously regulations. In Europe, we have a, a bunch of regulations lined up that are forcing companies to be more sustainable. those are the four forces. It's internal motivation, customers, competition, and, and then the regulations

Aaron MoncurAnd I, I imagine without some level of regulatory requirement, the innovation required to produce these sustainable materials economically may not happen. So that's probably a good thing

Lucas PianegondaYeah, I mean, th-that is the case. However, Europe and, uh, you know, I'm Swiss, so just that I, I mention this to everybody who's very ignorant about Switzerland. Switzerland is not Europe. Switzerland does not belong to the European Union. No. Um, so we're a third world country. Uh,

Aaron MoncurYeah, you're, you're the neutral ground, right?

Lucas Pianegondayes, yes, yes. Uh, so Europe, uh, tends to make regulations that are very complicated and, and, um, I-I'd say optimizing for micromanagement. So I think they could be doing a better job on, you know, making it easy to implement because they tend to do a lot of, "Oh, you need to register here, you need to register there, and I need a bunch of information that nobody really has." So yeah, I think regulations can be a force for good, but they need to make it such that it's also, you know, kind of feasible, especially for SMEs, you know.

Lucas PianegondaLot of Metag is SME, uh, based and, and you, you-- if you have too many regulations that nobody really understands and reads, y-you will make it very difficult to do the right thing. Um, think it comes down a lot to, you know, the materials and how they are produced. So I think you wanna solve the sustainability problem, you need to start with the chemical sector. You need to, you need to start with how your materials are even produced there is where the challenge really is.

Lucas PianegondaIf you can't get the feedstock to be cheaper somehow, it's going to be very, very difficult to, to, to make it economically viable. And, and there is really where, where a lot of the challenges are

Aaron MoncurBeyond the pure economics of sustainable materials, how close or dissimilar are material properties between your, your historical fossil-based materials and the sustainable materials?

Lucas PianegondaWell, I mean, it depends on which sustainable materials you mean. You know, the-- go bioplastics because they are the most, uh, you know, talked about. There are bio-based plastics and there are biodegradable plastics. The biodegradable plastics have vastly different properties, you know, in terms of shelf life, in terms of chemical resistance, but also processability, shrinkage and, you know, stiffness and all of that stuff. So it's a different plastic. And then you have the bio-based ones that can sometimes overlap with biodegradable, so some of them are bio-based and biodegradable, and others are just bio-based.

Lucas PianegondaSo for example, let's take polyethylene. Polyethylene can be made from sugarcane. So the company, company Braskem in Brazil, they have a functioning, um, bioethanol industry. So what they do is they cultivate sugarcane, they make it into ethanol, uh, with, you know, fermentation, then you can dehydrate that ethanol and make ethylene out of it. That's the, the monomer of polyethylene. You can polymerize it, and it's chemically completely identical to normal polyethylene. So not so different at all.

Lucas PianegondaSo the very, very, s- much the same properties as conventional plastics have. and this is where I see, you know, a lot of meta companies going because this is what, what they're used to, and it is like a small enough change so that they will dare to do it. are also other plastics, you know, the biodegradables such as PLA, polylactic acid, which you can also, uh, uh, do from sugarcane. And they, they have different properties.

Lucas PianegondaSo, you know, temperature resistance can sometimes be a topic. Um, it is pretty stiff, it is pretty brittle. So if you need like a plunger or whatever, that is a good thing. if you need it to be very tough because, you know, the, the surgical device might fall, that can be a problem. And then you always have to see, you know, is this a trade-off I can make in that clinical setting?

Aaron MoncurSo for engineers who have to specify one of these materials and they're working with their contract manufacturer, and you mentioned that one of the most common ways that they fall into using, you know, whatever material it is, is the contract manufacturer says, "We recommend this one," you know,"ABC, XYZ." But for an engineer who doesn't really have that material science background, are, are there some questions that, that we can ask our contract manufacturer to, like, kinda make sure that the recommendation they're giving us is actually a, a good recommendation?

Lucas PianegondaYeah. So, I mean, there's-- Like, I, I will explain the motivation first for, of the contract manufacturers just to, just to, like, protect them. So contract manufacturer has certain grades that they're already using in-house, and to set up a new grade under a quality management system can be a little bit of a hassle. You have to do a incoming goods ex- inspection. You'll have to understand the material. Sometimes it's not even a, a, a supplier that we already have onboarded, so you need to onboard a new supplier.

Lucas PianegondaSo that's, that's all a hassle, one. Number two, if you have a plastic, plastic very much depends-- You know, the price of a plastic very much depends on the volume that you're buying. If you're buying 25 kilos, you're gonna get a much different price than if you buy, m- you know, 250 tons. uh, the prices go down significantly until, like, a full truck, which is, like, 23 tons-ish. Um, meaning if you're just using, like, five tons a year, and you have another plastic that you're using 100 tons of, you know, the price is gonna be a lot better on, on the one that I already am using.

Lucas PianegondaSo if you can make it work with something that you already have in your repertoire, you try to do that because of just economics. And what I would do in order to challenge them is, first of all, as said, figure out what you want. You know, figure out what requirements you have, and then figure out if that plastic fits these requirements. And then maybe can also go ahead and see if there would be something different that could be, um, fitting these requirements. Because what I often see is, you know, we, we have sampled it, we have tested it, it works.

Lucas PianegondaYes. So that is good. So you know it works, but do you know if it is, if it is over-engineered or not? You don't know. You don't know if you're, if you're shooting with cannons on, on, uh… Jeez, do you say that? Like, there, there's a saying in German that you-- with, uh, mit Kanonen auf Spatzen schießen, which is basically you shoot with cannons to, uh, sparrows. Uh, I don't know i-i-if there's an equivalent saying in English.

Aaron MoncurNot exactly, but I think people get the, get the gist of it

Lucas PianegondaYeah, yeah, just you're just completely over en- engineering the thing. So a, a very good example is PEEK. If you can't do it with PEEK, you have to use steel. It's like there's no plastic that's better than PEEK. It's the pinnacle of the plastic pyramid. It is the best plastic there is, the best high-performance plastic there is. it doesn't mean that if it works with PEEK, this is the optimal solution. You might be overpaying, you might be using a lot too much footprint you are using PEEK for, you know, any mechanical part that you, that you have in your device.

Lucas PianegondaUm, you know, it is known, it is a known material, and people use PEEK where they could have used PA six. Um, yeah

Aaron MoncurWhat degree is AI becoming a useful tool for material selection? I mean, if, if we use your process, which I think is a great one, start with the end in mind, define the technical requirements, what you need to do with that material, and then work backwards. Uh, at this point, can you just plug that into ChatGPT or, or Claude and will the answers be good, or is it still… Are, are the models still working that out?

Lucas PianegondaYeah. So What will not work is, "Dear ChatGPT, I need the med tech material. Needs to be good. Thank you." That, that doesn't work, you know? Uh, what you… And I have this, you know, I have this framework. You need to understand your skill, so you need to understand your engineering, your med tech, your plastics. You, you need to have the background to understand and the expertise to understand what the AI should be doing and to fact-check it if it, you know, does hallu- hallucinate.

Lucas PianegondaThen you'll have to have your process in place. You, you have to have a process, a structured material selection process that is data-driven, that yields a result, and has a very logical step-by-step instruction. So if I can teach it an int- to an intern, if I can teach it to, you know, uh, a new employee, you can also teach it to AI. And then the furth- th- third and very clit- critical component that we need to have, and this is where, you know, this is why I built the database, you need to have the data.

Lucas Pianegondaif you just let it out on the internet and you say, you know, "It, it's on the internet, it must be true," like, you know, we all know that things that are on the internet are not true. But if you just let an AI agent say,"Okay," like, "Go find me a material," it's gonna find whatever data there is on the internet and assume it's true. So you need to have a verified and basically fact-checked database you know these grades exist, they have these properties, we have the data sheets from the supplier, and this is to the best of the knowledge of the industry what is true.

Lucas PianegondaYou know, data sheets, you know, they don't tell you e- everything, so there's still some limits to what the data says or, or can tell you. But the best we can do, we need to have the data. And if you have those three things, you know, the process, the skill, and the data, then AI can accelerate by many folds. You kn- you know, we did this experiment. We started in February, March this year. We built this database and, like, by now, what used to take six weeks to a recommendation, I can do basically in a day.

Lucas PianegondaYou know, it's like I have 20 minutes of agent runtime, and if it's like first time right, I'll have to review it for maybe an hour, and then I'm done. So, you know, you can accelerate by manyfold, but you need to have the expertise, you need to have the right process in place, you need to have the data. Otherwise, it doesn't work. Um, so I, I have this picture that I like to paint. It's like bamboo. Like, bamboo grows underground for like five years, and then it starts to shoot up at 90 centimeters a, a day, which is, you know, for the freedom folks is, uh, like three foot a day.

Aaron MoncurThe freedom folks?

Lucas Pianegondath- freedom folks. Yeah, you. You guys. The, the, the ones that are using the, the, the, the weird, the

Aaron MoncurYeah.

Lucas Pianegondalike

Aaron Moncurthat's us.

Lucas Pianegondaand inches. Yes Um, yeah, if you, if you say like 90 centimeters, they won't get it. So it's like three, three foot or, um, that would be a yard then in that, in that case. Uh, I have my, I have my imperial units down. No. So have to basically build a lot of underground stuff that you don't see that is hard work, that nobody really, you know, doesn't really get you results, you figure that out, and if you have that figured out, you can do it extremely fast. If you figure out your process, you have the skill to fact check it you know how it works, and then have the, all the data necessary, that's applicable to any appli- application of AI, then you can do things a lot faster.

Lucas PianegondaBut yeah, you need to give it very straight guidelines on how to do it

Aaron MoncurYeah. For engineers who are listening to this and thinking to themselves,"You know, I know my company has a new sustainability initiative. They wanna get more into this. I don't know much about it, but I, I need to learn. I need to get up to speed on this stuff," what are some resources that engineers can use to just start learning the basics? Or, are there some, some websites or companies out there?

Lucas PianegondaOh, I would start with my YouTube channel, you know, just a, a very, very, uh, plain self-advertisement here. You know, uh, my YouTube channel has the, you know, it's MedTech Sustainability by Design podcast, plus I have a lot of YouTube videos on this. Um, there is a good place to start, I would say. You know, there, there are a few other podcasts that I could recommend. You know, if you're in, in sustainable healthcare, you could go to the Sustainable Healthcare podcast. Um, what, what would be a few good other ones?

Lucas PianegondaYeah, that, and, you know, you can always reach out to me. I always give away, uh, like an hour or so for free so that you can ask a bunch of questions. So I, I'd, I'd be happy to chat. tho- those are resources that you would, that you would usually go to

Aaron MoncurTerrific. Okay. Well, um One of the things that I like to do on this podcast is, is make connections with people. So you've been very generous in sharing all this information about, uh, sustainability and material selections, and I'm wondering what, what kind of things are, are you trying to learn right now? What kind of people are you trying to connect with? And, and is it possible that perhaps our audience could do a solid for you and make a connection or, or help you with something? Is, is there anything in particular that, uh, you're looking for right now that an audience member might be able to connect with you

Lucas PianegondaYeah. So, I mean, we're always looking for good people who are, you know, interested in plastics and, and med tech. Um, I wanna just connect with people who want to make the world better, you know. My, my motto is ma- form a better world with plastics. You know, if you need to select a plastic, you know, come to me and, and, uh, and we can, we can connect. know, in general, whoever can teach me a lot about, you know, like the medicine, you know, the procedures, you know, what, what, what the devices actually should be doing, I'm very much interested in that.

Lucas PianegondaSo if you have good podcast guests that you can recommend, that. Or, you know, if you have projects where you, where you need help with plastic selection, uh, or, you know, you wanna do training on sustainable plastics or stuff like this, uh, um, you know, I'm a business owner, always looking for customers.

Aaron MoncurOkay, great. Well, Lucas, thank you so much for, uh, for spending some time with me today and, and sharing all the experiences and expertise you have. I really appreciate it. I know that the audience does as well. So, uh, thank you again for, for being with us today. And how can people connect with you?

Lucas PianegondaOh, I live on LinkedIn. You can, you can basically shoot me a LinkedIn message at any time of the day. I'll, I'll answer. Uh, LinkedIn is a very good place to start. Uh, we have a website, uh, or-- and we have a YouTube channel, so you can just Lucas Pianegonda and, and you'll find me on the internet. Uh, Pianegonda is not that, uh, common of a name. There's one jewelry, uh, maker in Italy. Uh, uh, so I don't make jewelry. Uh, I- I'm the plastic

Aaron MoncurThe other pianigonda

Lucas PianegondaHe has the other Pianegonda.

Aaron MoncurOkay. Terrific. All right, Lucas, thank you again for spending some time with me today. I really appreciate it

Lucas PianegondaYeah, yeah, I

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ryan Pickens | AI Tools You Can Use Today for Hardware Development

    Nov 13, 202653 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What if AI could help you take a hardware product from concept to production in a fraction of the time? In this episode of Being an Engineer, Aaron Moncur sits down with Ryan Pickens, founder of Pickens...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Mark Blakey & Ruben Inzunza | Behind The Scenes: How Pipeline Developed EZ Motion

    Nov 6, 202653 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What if mechanical engineers could automate motors, pneumatic actuators, and testing equipment without needing to write complex code or rely on a dedicated controls engineer? In this episode of Being An...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ghulam Murtaza | Overcoming Adversity: An Inspiring Tale of Perseverance

    Oct 30, 202642 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Ghulam Murtaza is a Controls Project Engineer at Vanderlande with a background spanning industrial automation, robotics, controls, data science, cloud computing, and artificial intelligence. Before...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Eron Flory | Toastmasters for Engineers, and FIRST Robotics

    Oct 23, 202653 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Eron Flory has built a career around turning difficult engineering problems into real products - and, increasingly, around helping other engineers learn how to do the same. His background crosses custom...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. James Bryant | A Process For Engineers to Succeed at Home & at Work

    Oct 16, 202643 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Dr. James Bryant, Ph.D., P.E., is a dynamic force in the engineering and leadership development arenas. With a robust background in civil engineering, James has spent over 20 years leading...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode