Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Before You Cut Bangs

Before You Cut Bangs artwork

3.29 Natalee Holloway, with Claire Fierman Part 1

Nov 13, 202634 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

A story can be world-famous and still deeply personal. Netflix’s new Natalee Holloway documentary brings the case back into the spotlight, but for our own Claire Fierman, it reopens memories of being a teenager caught in a tragedy that became public property. Claire shares why she stayed silent for years, what convinced her to participate in the documentary, and how Beth Holloway’s relentless pursuit of answers made the decision an easy one. We also discuss the darker side of true crime culture, including online harassment, anonymous trolls, and the pressure to defend yourself against strangers. More than anything, this conversation is about remembering Natalee as a person, not a headline. Claire takes us back to eighth grade, high school, and the 2005 Aruba senior trip, sharing what she remembers, what she witnessed, and the terrifying moment when Natalee’s disappearance became real. We also explore how trauma can reshape memory and how healing sometimes means allowing yourself to remember the good times. Subscribe, share, and leave a five-star review to help more people discover the show.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Before You Cut Bangs. I'm Laura Quick.

SPEAKER_02I'm a professional storyteller and I'm writing my first book. And I'm Claire Fearman. I'm a therapist, but I'm your therapist. Full disclaimer: take what you like, leave the rest.

SPEAKER_00Claire, what's been going on?

SPEAKER_01Start. You page. What has been going on? I went crazy. Laura went back to her roots.

SPEAKER_02Let's just back up. Let's just back up.

SPEAKER_00I was kidding. Yeah, obviously.

SPEAKER_02Just do a better intro, Will. Well, that was the point of it.

SPEAKER_00It was supposed to be uh ridiculous.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So there's a Netflix special out now, a three-part documentary. Um, and it is about Natalie Holloway and her disappearance and subsequent murder, that we are somewhat familiar with, just a little bit because we live in Birmingham and Natalie grew up in Mountain Brook, which is a suburb. Um, you are a big part of the story, Claire, and we have not talked about this much. We hinted at it once on the show, but we haven't talked about it. And uh we feel like maybe it's time to talk about it.

SPEAKER_01And also just backing up, we had Matthew Gawkin on and we two years ago two years ago, and we alluded that there was something. And the reason he was here and on the podcast is because we had just filmed, yeah, the first time.

SPEAKER_00Um, so let's I I want to kind of start back in the beginning, right? Um, and just talk about you when you were growing up uh and became friends with Natalie.

SPEAKER_02I can I say one thing before and then I'll answer that exactly. There were a couple reasons why I didn't talk about it on here, even prior to the documentary coming out or being filmed. Um first it was this like private tragedy that had become so public, and I won't say too much in case you are gonna ask me stuff, but um from 18 on, the media wasn't really kind, and some people were, um but lots of victim blaming, and you can kind of watch the progression of where we were all, we mean in Natalie's friends were really involved and sharing her story and um really getting the message out there, you know, when prior to like understanding that she had been murdered, and um you can see that number like really dwindle because of how horrible the media, well, I shouldn't even just say the media, people watching the media could be.

SPEAKER_02So we just kind of started like trickling out. And um a couple years ago, Beth, her mother, who if you've seen the documentary, you can just see how amazing, amazing she is.

SPEAKER_01So much to say about that. I literally text Claire and was like, Beth mothered me. Yes, just watching her pursue her daughter relentlessly for decades and justice for her, like actually changed something inside me. I was like, Yes, that's what it looks like to be a mom.

SPEAKER_02So she asked if I would do this special with her. And if Beth asked me to do something to show up for her and show up for Natalie, the answer's yes. Yeah, 100%. And I uh assume there'd be some backlash because everybody has something to say about literally everything. Um, and we'll save the fallout for later. Uh, I'm gonna stick to the positives for right now. Um, Beth asked uh my friend Madison and I to do it. Immediate yes, like we will walk you, like walk with you through this.

SPEAKER_02Um, the series came out last Wednesday, and all I cared about was that it was meaningful to Beth.

SPEAKER_01And that's exactly what it was. And as your friend who walked with you through making this decision, which you grappled with, even though you wanted to say yes for Beth, because of how bad the media has been for so long. I remember you like grilled Matthew, who was the original producer. I'm talking like full on. I remember you being like, I asked every question. I wanted to know exactly what angle they're taking. I want to make sure this is to tell a cohesive story, and you felt really good about it.

SPEAKER_01I did.

SPEAKER_02Is it okay that we're going here first?

SPEAKER_00It's great. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Dad. Um, yeah, dad, tell us what to do. Um yeah. So when Matthew came, he flew to Birmingham to talk to me. And I was like, put your phone on the table where I can see it. Like I was like really paranoid that he was gonna be like recording me to like catch me in something. Cause that was, if you've watched the documentary, you can see like Nancy Grace like hammering us at 18 for a question that really actually made no sense at all. Um, and so like just not a ton of trust for the media.

SPEAKER_02And his big thing was like he wanted to tell Natalie's story through the eyes of Beth. How beautiful. Um, so we did that, and then um and you were excited. I mean, you were really after I recorded that interview, I was excited. I know I keep pausing, I'm like really anxious today. We're just gonna own that. Do you have questions about recording the documentary or just Natalie questions?

SPEAKER_00Oh, all of it. Yeah, we're gonna go.

SPEAKER_02We want to start from the beginning.

SPEAKER_01Okay, I'm like disclaimer, disclaimer, and this is what happened. It's okay because he'll edit this, so don't worry about that. Just let's feel worried. Don't I don't think you should. Here's a big reliance, but I do want listeners to realize this.

SPEAKER_00So not only have we not really gone into this much at all here on this podcast, as friends, we haven't really gone into this as well much, right? There's been some stuff with the documentary coming out that we've talked about.

SPEAKER_01I probably know more because of how long we've been friends, and literally been in group therapy together, literally group therapy.

SPEAKER_00Right. We met through this podcast, and so it was like the second or third recording session when I think uh there were plans for Jordan Vandersloot to come to Birmingham, and that was in the news, and you said, hey, and this was before this was when you were supposed to go on my birthday trip, and I had big feelings because you weren't leaving the country.

SPEAKER_01I canceled the flight. That she literally canceled her flight to go on my 40th birthday trip, and I was devastated and very selfishly was like, You bitch, but this is before she had left the country since this happened because she couldn't.

SPEAKER_00Right, right. But you like you said you just said to me, like, I don't know if you know this, but I was friends of Natalie Holloway and I was on that trip, and I was like, And Will's like, boom, boom, because because it was something that I followed very closely, it was close to us, right? It was in the town, and so like I was like, Oh my gosh, I know you from the news. And I'd already become friends with you, but had not realized that was there was that connection. And I I talked to you about like, hey, are are we gonna ever talk about this? And you said, Yeah, one at some point, and I was like, Well, I'm gonna save all the stuff I want to talk to you about for three long years, literally he's held it in.

SPEAKER_02You really do have the patience of a saint, Will. It's amazing. Well, yeah, I mean, a couple reasons I didn't talk about it on here. Well, like my life is built around other stuff now. Like in it was like I didn't start a podcast to talk about that thing um or that part of my story necessarily, and now naturally has come up. Um, and you probably didn't recognize me, Will, because like according to um Facebook and stuff, I have not aged well. That is what the big thing is. People are I'm old and ugly, but it's so no.

SPEAKER_00Here's the crazy, here's one of the many reasons I can tell you that those are just like crazy faceless trolls is you look the exact same. Yeah, you really do. Like, honestly, the exact same.

SPEAKER_01It is alarming how similar you look as the little girl version of you on that, on Nancy Grace. Thank you, we all. Yeah, but like I um okay, before we go back in time, I do want to say Claire started getting some random trolls reaching directly out to her, and she looking for support from me, sent me a screenshot, which wasn't your mistake because honestly, it was my mistake. When the number was involved, I was like, oh, well, don't tempt me with a good time.

SPEAKER_01I the unhealed version of me showed up, but uh the fierceness in me is more about protecting my people. Like, I don't like when people are main, especially when they're hiding behind a keyboard and being the worst. And that's what all those people are doing, and it's it's just to get a reaction.

SPEAKER_00Which I told Laura, I believe that this is a game for these people, right? Like they live in this dark part of Reddit where they're like, Did you so much you found her number? Great, let's all text, whatever. And I was like, This is a stupid game for these people. And uh-oh, Laura, you've just become a player.

SPEAKER_01And let me tell you, put me in, coach. Well, Claire texts me and was like, does Zagne to take your phone? Because I was sending her screenshots. And I was like, he is threatening to do so, and I'm not letting him, but I'm I'm I'm wrapping it up. I'm finishing. And I did finish, but then what I didn't tell you, so I blocked that person and I started getting text again the next day from a different number. It's okay.

SPEAKER_00Because it's just Google numbers that they don't care, they can just yeah, pick up a new one and yeah, but I think my concern was that they enjoy it, right? Obviously, any kind of response, especially a negative response.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, totally.

SPEAKER_00Especially a negative response is why they're doing it. That's what they enjoy. They enjoy the back and forth and the yeah.

SPEAKER_02What a waste of time, man.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_02What a waste of time and like really missing the point, which I know we'll get to this. Like um, at 18, we encountered a murderer, like a sociopath. And all of you did. All of us did. And that is not the focus for some people. I think for the majority of people, it is. Like, I'm focusing on the negative because you know, our brains wired for it, and it was fucking mean, by the way. So mean. Um I've gotten the like loveliest texts.

SPEAKER_02I mean, from you and Danielle watching it, like from people that like I peripherally know, just like deep understanding and really got to see Natalie. That's what I loved about it, is that showed her. Like it that got me good, and it showed Beth. And so there have been far more like beautiful messages sent to us. Those are what I'm like holding on to.

SPEAKER_00So, what was your first memory of Natalie when you guys were young, when you met her? What's your when you go back? What's the first thing you remember about her?

SPEAKER_02Uh a pool party to like welcome the new girl. That's like pretty fuzzy.

SPEAKER_00Um what she was the new girl coming in? Or you were? Yes. She was.

SPEAKER_02She was me. Born and raised ZB, baby. Um so Natalie was new. She was moving from Mississippi, and I do say this in the documentary. Let me, this is a funny thing. Um, are y'all familiar with the movie You've Got Mail? Yeah, of course. Do y'all remember when Joe Fox is interviewed and they like clip it and all he's shown saying is, I sell cheap books, so sue me. That's like kind of what I felt like happened on the documentary. They'd like, you can tell I'm like cut off mid-sentence, probably because I was like, and the emotional part of that is, and Netflix don't care about that.

SPEAKER_02Um, but moving into Mountain Brook, because like you're usually not like first generation, like you're my parents met at Mount Brook Junior High. That's wild. So it was like amazing that she like came in, but she wasn't really scared of anything socially, and she just joined our friend group. Um, the memories that really stand out, um, she went on most uh family trips, a ton of family trips with us.

SPEAKER_02And like I can like see her um, like at the beach.

SPEAKER_01Like to Grayton, where y'all always go?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, or we'd go, like my grandparents had this condo, and we did a lot of Grayton trips, um, and a lot of condo trips, and she was just really like neat and tidy. I was not, and I remember wearing one of her bikinis, and she was like, Don't sit on the ground in that. And I was like, Okay. And like she just kept everything like orderly and nice and neat. And she was worried that if I sat on the ground by the pool, it would cause pilling in the J. Crew sometimes.

SPEAKER_02Which is probably true.

SPEAKER_01It was true, but I've never thought like that far ahead of any scenario. I was like, You're like, and then I'll ask my mom and dad to buy me a new one.

unknownOkay, fine.

SPEAKER_02Um, so like I can just like see her on all of those trips, and it has been really nice to like think about that and remember those pieces.

SPEAKER_00How old were were you guys when she moved to Mountain Brook?

SPEAKER_02I think eighth grade.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_0113. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Some formative years.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. Describe your personality versus her personality when y'all get to high school.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it seems a yin-yang kind of.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_02So I was really lucky in my friend group. It really became my group in ninth grade. And um, it was kind of a mix of like a couple cheerleaders, couple dance teamers. Um, everyone pretty much made good grades. I was truly masking my ADHD at that time. Um, like pretty good kids. Um like I mean, we did stuff like um, like we were still like dressing up as like Hanson and making videos.

SPEAKER_01Like not TikToks, though, because that didn't work.

SPEAKER_02No, like on a camcorder, like recording ourselves singing mm bop. Like, of course. Um, lots of Yahtzee, like we were just still like had this like innocence and fun. And these were the funniest people I had ever come in contact, contact with. Um, cute, but not super worried about like being the most popular or the best dressed. Um, I was like entering, like, here comes like the full hippie coming out. Um, and Natalie was very reserved in those ways, like definitely a rule follower.

SPEAKER_02Um, always, I mean, you can see in every picture, like never really a hair out of place, like really beautiful, um, honor roll student. Um, but she a youth group kid. Funny. No? Oh, well, and I mean, I know you were Jewish. I mean, you obviously. I mean, maybe she was into Bible study. I don't know. I wasn't included in this thing. So as a Jewish girl, you were an episode of how I was excluded. Um so, anyways, just like a solid, solid group of girls.

SPEAKER_02And I think like if I could say anything like nice, like just nice people. It was like where I learned like good friendship was from them. Like, if you see their face on Netflix in those pictures, like those, like I can cry about it. I mean, I still talk to some of them almost every day. I love them so much, and every one of them had their lives changed. And it's been really hard to talk about it. And so, I mean, it was even hard in our friend group, like it was hard to talk about Natalie for a long time, um, for lots of different reasons.

SPEAKER_02Um, but there's just been a ton of pain, a ton of pain in those like precious, precious people.

SPEAKER_00So, when the trip was coming together, how how did that happen? Was it a school sanctioned trip? It was a friend trip.

SPEAKER_02What was the So the school had nothing to do with it, and that was always super clear. Like any planning meetings were not at the school. Do you remember Mountain Brook Swim and Tennis? Yeah. Yeah, it was like a tennis club. I don't remember. Anyways, like I remember a meeting being there. I think that's what it was.

SPEAKER_00Um which I told like my daughter she watched, and we were she was like, So it wasn't a school trip. I was like, that's very normal. Like my I didn't go on it, but like my senior, they all went to Cancun and I didn't decide to school and do that.

SPEAKER_01It was a known thing at our high school that you take a take a senior trip. But it was what was really interesting is the same thing happened at our school where there would be like a senior cruise, which sounds terrible to me, but a senior cruise, and then there would be teachers that the parents would kind of say, Will you go on this cruise? We'll pay for it, just so there would be chaperones there. So same thing.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, people are like a school trip for seniors. Like, this is not unheard of for seniors to go on a trip to celebrate graduation. So, like, let's normalize that. Yeah, it is very common. Um, not a school sanctioned trip. I like I wish I had more clear memories of the chaperones. I really don't. Like, I remember some of them. Um, some of them were teachers. I think that was just like, I assume, like a parent must have like asked.

SPEAKER_02Um, I don't know if they got paid or the trip was paid for. Like, I don't know. Like, because I didn't care. Like, I don't mean that. Well, you were a kid. You're a kid. You get signed up for stuff. You know what I mean? Like, I didn't fill out paperwork. Parents do that. Well, you were excited about the trip, and that's all you cared about. Like, we had made little t-shirts, like, I think with puffy paint, um, super big deal. And it was light at the end of a K through 12 tunnel.

SPEAKER_02Yes. Um, what is not talked about that just came to my mind is our grade lost one of our very dear um guy friends um in a car accident right before that. And I mean, that wouldn't have been a part of the story, but it just kind of that's something I've had to work through in therapy is we were coming off of a horrible loss, like in our core group, lose a friend, and that's not a common occurrence for a teen.

SPEAKER_02Um, and so we're finishing school, lose a friend in a car accident, and it was like a break, right? Like just get to this trip, go start life.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So there's nothing but excitement really for this. How many people was it like a huge group, like half the senior class, or was it like, no, this is more of a small like couple of friends?

SPEAKER_01One small. No, it looks sure that number is out there, like a hundred.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's what I think. My senior class, again, I didn't go, I went somewhere else to my small group, but I think it was like 100, 150 or something, went to Cancun. So it's a large group of people.

SPEAKER_02It was big. Yeah. What's the drinking age in Mexico?

SPEAKER_00I think it was 18, which is why.

SPEAKER_02So, again, not uncommon.

SPEAKER_00Correct.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, definitely. This is what you're looking for. Where can we go drink legally? Can't you drink in France too? Like none of this was like that crazy sounding to be like incredibly clear.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so you're excited about the trip? The trip starts. What do you remember about the how long we were there? Do you remember?

SPEAKER_02Um, so the I have the first part of that trip like seared in my brain. So we were staggered in flights to get there and to get home. You cannot fit all the people on the plane. Um, I think I was the first group to arrive and the first group to leave, which I know we'll get to of like kind of the disconnect there and me leaving. Um, and I can remember who I was sitting with. Like, I don't remember if we like checked, put our bags in our room or anything like that, but um going to this like beachside bar, and I'm gonna, I'm not using names specifically today, so I'll be like a friend, this friend.

SPEAKER_02Um they like a lot of people also don't want emails and texts and things. So friends. So I I'm gonna tell like some endearing stories too. Like I had like maybe had like a bud light before, like at like a bonfire or like um tasted Kahlua or something, or vodka and propel, like grody drinks that you like, or you know, trying out senior year. Um, so I didn't know how to order a drink or what to order.

SPEAKER_02And um, I just remember like hearing the name fuzzy navel, and I don't even know what that is, but or and I was like, I'll have one. Um, it just tastes like juice.

SPEAKER_01I immediately thought of um what were those things that you drank in a bottle, but they were the fuzzy navel uh boons wine cooler, boons. Wine coolers, yeah.

SPEAKER_02I feel like maybe fuzzy navel's like peach.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it has vodka or something like that.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so um we did drink on that trip, but like I can see it so like I can like feel it. It was like humid and hot and beautiful, and I'd never seen water like that before. Um, and I was like astounded, and I'd never really understood all inclusive. Like this is like really feeling like a grown-up for the first time. And like the how you think grown-up life is gonna go. Like, you can do whatever you want, whenever you want, you know? All in. And you know, my parents had taught to me before I'd had lots of safety talks before because like I'd gone to see like lots of live music leading up to this.

SPEAKER_02So, like, I had had tons of like don't do drugs and things, and all if you've listened to this podcast, like we know what the Feremans had already gone through with addiction. So I was like pretty boundaried in drinking, like didn't really ever like to feel out of control. Um, and I don't know where I was going with that.

SPEAKER_01Well, you got your first drink, fuzzy navel. You heard somebody order it and we were like pump off to the races. Here we are.

SPEAKER_02We're on our this is we're grown ups now. Let's go. Yeah. And I remember my parents like they gave me cash to be able to tip because they're like, just because it's all inclusive doesn't mean it's not. For you, like you really, and so I'm just like pew pew pew. It was probably like a dollar, like a dollar for you. Um, and you get a dollar, and you get a dollar. We had like our outfits picked out and our bathing suits picked out and magazines because, like, to be clear, this is important. There were no iPhones, there were no iPhones.

SPEAKER_01Yes, so I'm sure I you had your razor, your razor cell phone.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, barely. All right. Like, I don't even know what I had. I feel it was a little clunky. You know it was like a Nokia for sure. No, no, a Nokia. Um, I actually think it was. It was silver. Um, remember when you could change the faces on the 100%. Um, so we did not have international cell phone service. Also, or maybe some people did. I absolutely didn't. Um, I don't even know if I called my parents at all from that trip. But um, so yeah, like we just get down there ready to go with like cameras, you know.

SPEAKER_02I'm sure I had a disposable, yeah, or digital. Yeah. Yeah, I'm sure we had digital cameras. When we got back, the FBI kind of took everything. Like, I'm missing like FBI, I'm missing a lot of my. We're gonna need those bombs. Yeah, like I don't have anything at all from that trip.

SPEAKER_00Remind me what year it was.

SPEAKER_012005.

SPEAKER_002005. Okay, yeah.

SPEAKER_01And in 2005, because I did see, and I will say this about the documentary. I feel like you and I have had conversations, and I've literally been in therapy with you and heard you talk about these things. Um I learned so much that I did not know. Like, so much. I feel like I was like, damn, this is like revealing a lot. But I also seeing the pictures of you guys on the trip and just from memories, you know, like way before the trip of little Claire, like physically little, but also because you are a very tiny person.

SPEAKER_01I'm so young. Yes, but very young. And all I wanted to do was hug her. Oh, same. That version of you. Like, I remember Zach and I were watching it, and I'm like, oh my god, I just wanted to rescue you.

SPEAKER_02Who didn't? My mom was had a hard time watching that. She was like, I'm gonna email them. And I'm like, Well, it's been so long, I don't think Nancy Grace or Fox News really cares.

SPEAKER_00But um so on the were there like planned of activities on the trip, or was it just like you just guys went to the beach every day?

SPEAKER_02Okay, so I have been asked these questions always, always, always. And what is so weird, like I can remember really specific things, and then a lot was I don't know if it was, it was like I didn't my brain didn't want to keep the information because it ended in death, right? So it was like the rest is in these like kind of vignettes in my head. It reminds me of like being a little kid. Remember those things you could hold up to your eyes and like press down, it would change the picture. That's how Aruba feels to me.

SPEAKER_02So when people ask me like in interviews these questions, I'm like, you should really ask somebody else. I am sure there are more things. I remember you could do things like scuba diving and stuff, and at night there were these like um events like for the whole hotel, like think like cruise line type events. Like bonfire. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I was really never into that kind of stuff. I came into my grandma's hobby uh hobbies much later in life, but like I just wanted to like hang out. I mean, 18-year-olds want to hang out with their friends, they don't want scheduled events.

SPEAKER_02We've just finished high school. I don't need to be signed up for nothing. Um, and so I didn't, maybe somebody else did, but um, I remember every day you'd wake up, get your breakfast, go to the beach, go to the pool, and that was the whole day. Come back in, get ready to like go out. Um, I went out one time, so I was not at Carlos and Charlie's the night of Natalie's disappearance. I was there the night before. And like this is not new information to y'all or anyone that's my friend.

SPEAKER_02I was just never like a good late night hang. It was just never for me. Um the glasses come off. It's time to go to bed. Like one night, I've just never been that way. You know, like this wasn't like a oh, she like because this happened, she does these things. Like, I have never liked late nights. I don't like big crowds, never have, but I'm sure I had some FOMO. Go to Carlos and Charlie's really typical, like um islandy hole in the wall.

SPEAKER_02Hole in the wall club. Like it was loud, dark lights. Um, and I did not stay very long, then I went back. Um, so I was not there Sunday night. I was only there Saturday night.

SPEAKER_01Okay, and talk about getting back. How did you get back? Because there's so much controversy.

SPEAKER_02Like super, super hooked on this. Um, and again, I just want to be really clear. You're not in Manhattan with like marked yellow cabs, and there was no such thing as Uber or Lyft. So cars would just wait out front, and you would just you know pop in a car. And they might say, like, where are you going? This is holiday in. We're going to the holiday in. Hello. Um, so again, super normal. Uh, I was never scared, never worried.

SPEAKER_01Um when you left Saturday night, was it like you and another friend, a couple of friends? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So then that Sunday, you just don't like you're just not going out because you're leaving the next morning.

SPEAKER_02Like it's because I was an old soul, Will. I'm like, I'm sure I've got to fold the clothes and get some sleep. Like, I just had no interest. What I do remember You went hard during the day. Yes, Claire.

SPEAKER_01Claire's like, I'll go hard with you guys.

SPEAKER_02Daytime. I love light. Um, so that day, hung out with everyone all day. The clear memory I have of that night, and I can like see who I was with too. We went to the hotel lobby. A lot of it felt like very like open air. And I was sitting on a bench and we knew um Carlos and Charlie's was closing and everyone would be coming in. And we kind of just like sat there, watched everyone come in, chatted with some people. Sure, when my friends came in, just walked off, went to bed. But think like let's say 80 people out of a hundred went.

SPEAKER_02That's like a lot of people. So I didn't have like a notebook, like, oh, checked in with you. And this to be really clear, we all had lots of roommates. So Natalie was not my roommate. Um, so when I went to bed, like I was just kind of like with the people, but also like you might sleep in so-and-so's room or whatever, because you're still having spent the night parties. Like you're 18.

SPEAKER_01And so it wasn't um well, and and aloneness does not exist when you're a teenager. No, there's no such thing, especially for girls. Like you just pile in wherever. And I know I mean, you've always been like kind of a girl's girl. Like you, your book club is insane. You just went to New York with your book club, but like that idea of just like bebopping from room to room. Exactly. It's very normal, extremely normal.

SPEAKER_02I mean, it's the girls. Well, you go to the bathroom with me, like always together, kind of moving around. And then so I wake up the next morning and I was rooming with people that I was on the earlier flight. So we get ready, go to the airport, and I do remember this. Like, I was super hungry. I and I remember getting brie. Like, it was like all they had in the airport. And I was just like eating cheese because I was like, I can't make it to Miami without food. I mean, again, 18, all I'm worried about is like, well, remember, this like logic part of the brain has not formed yet.

SPEAKER_02So I'm surviving on avoid harm, seek reward. So I'm like gonna get a snack and a Mountain Dew and wait for my flight. In the airport, two of my girlfriends came up to me. I can see this, and they're like, we can't find Natalie, she's not getting on the flight. And my immediate response was very adolescent, and it was she's gonna be in trouble, slash Beth's gonna be mad. And I probably would have said, Miss Beth, like is gonna be mad. Did not occur to me what had happened, would have been.

SPEAKER_02Or to even worry. No, I got worried by the time we landed in Miami. So I was on the longest way to get back. We had to do Aruba to Miami, Miami to Atlanta, and then get on a bus. So uh what a miserable experience as you're going through this. It was just like so much time, so much time, and I'm sure my parents were trying to be protective. So, but I can still see like next little snippet is Miami Airport, and um I was on the phone with my dad, and he said, Bear, this isn't looking good, and I was furious because like what did he mean?

SPEAKER_02And she's just somewhere else, and I remember being like, Don't say that. Get to Atlanta, we get on the bus to Birmingham, we got picked up, um, and then my house was like my parents' house was like the hub that night. Everyone just trying to remember this happened, this happened, this happened, this happened. Uh, we're on and off the phone with Beth. Um, and still like scared, but like adrenaline of like, let's just figure this out.

SPEAKER_02Like a lot of let's just figure this out um energy.

SPEAKER_01And we'll trace it together. We're gonna put place it together, we're gonna figure it out, we're gonna find her. Beth's there because Beth rolled out quick, right?

SPEAKER_02I mean, she talks about it, about calling the police and driving, what'd you say, 120 down the interstate and saying, like, don't pull me over because I'm not gonna stop. She's not stopping.

SPEAKER_00Do you remember the last time you'd seen Natalie?

SPEAKER_02At the pool, uh, I think at the pool, I have this memory of like having magazines at the pool and being with her. But again, it's not like all day I was like, and then I was with Jane, and then I was with Susie. Like I was just hanging out with literally all of my best friends. Yeah, that was it. Um, and like I wished I had more. Like, that's been super painful. Like when people have asked me questions, I'm like, I don't know.

SPEAKER_01I don't know. And I mean, not to it's not your job to be the therapist in this moment, but I mean, like the body, the body protects us. And so when something really painful happens, like the way that your body will lock out anything that could harm you.

SPEAKER_02I wish I remembered that whole trip. I wish I remembered where she like. I wish that I remembered more. Yeah. For like me and my friend, like, I wish. And to be honest, I really thought about a lot of high school memories with her. It was like I wasn't like allowed to go there. And this documentary did gift me that. Like, golly, like, I love the videos of her in high school, like hearing her voice were just so good. And it like gave me permission of like, oh my god, like, oh my gosh, all of that existed too.

SPEAKER_02All of that existed. Before you cut bangs is hosted by Lara Quick and Claire Fearman and produced by Will Lockamy.

SPEAKER_01Follow along with us everywhere. Please subscribe to the podcast, find us on Instagram. We're constantly doing polls. We want to know what you think. And I know that you probably know this, but reviewing us and giving us five stars matters more than anything, and we are so grateful to have you here.

SPEAKER_02We talk so much on the podcast about seeking therapy, getting help, finding resources. I would love to be able to help you with that. My website is up and running and beautiful. It is goodgrowthwithclaire.com. So, whether you're in the state of Alabama or not, I want to be able to help direct you to the right resources. Goodgrowthwithclaire.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 3.28 Mushrooms saved his life… Meet our friend Joe

    Oct 30, 202641 minAudio

    Psilocybin is often labeled a trend, but for many, it is a last resort after years of therapy, sobriety, and unanswered struggles. In this candid episode, we sit down with Joe - 28 years sober and a survivor of deep...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 3.27 Why Don’t We Talk About This (naked chores and losing it on customer service)

    Oct 16, 202630 minAudio

    What do you do when nobody’s watching? And we’re not talking about your skincare routine. This week on Before You Cut Bangs, we’re confessing the weird, embarrassing, and occasionally unhinged things we do behind closed...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 3.26 Are You Accidentally Ruining Your Life? When good habits, healthy routines, and self-improvement go too far.

    Oct 2, 202627 minAudio

    Optimization is having a moment, though not always in a good way. What starts as a simple Botox touch-up or a timed calendar can quickly devolve into a life that feels like a spreadsheet with a pulse. In this episode,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 3.25 Apparently, We Have To Rescue Ourselves

    Sep 18, 202640 minAudio

    A possum walks into a house at 2 a.m., and somehow it turns into one of the clearest lessons we’ve had about mental health, self-reliance, and what it actually means to grow up emotionally. We start with Claire’s very...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 3.24 Is Addiction Really A Disease??? w/ Keith Fierman (Claire’s Dad) Part 2

    Sep 4, 202636 minAudio

    Waiting on someone you love to “finally be ready” for addiction help can quietly take over your whole life. Today we sit down with someone who’s lived both sides of it: Keith Fierman, Claire’s dad, who got sober and...

    Credit the people on this episode