Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Becker’s Payer Issues Podcast

Becker’s Payer Issues Podcast artwork

Rob Andrews, Chief Executive Officer of the Health Transformation Alliance

Apr 27, 202620 minAudio

In this episode, Rob Andrews, Chief Executive Officer of the Health Transformation Alliance, joins the podcast to discuss the ongoing pressures and competition within Medicare Advantage. He shares insights on chronic care initiatives and the importance of collaboration and compromise between carriers and providers to improve outcomes and control costs.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hi, everyone. This is Elizabeth Caslow with the Becker's Payer Issues podcast. I'm thrilled today to be joined by Rob Andrews, chief executive officer of the Health Transformation Alliance. Rob, thank you so much for joining us today. Thank you, Elizabeth. It's good to be with you again. Yeah. So before we jump in, can you just fill in our audience, tell us a little bit more about yourself, your career background, and your role at the Health Transformation Alliance? I've been really fortunate to have a chance to see health care from a lot of perspectives.

I served in the US House of Representatives for twenty four years and was very much involved in helping to write and implement the Affordable Care Act. So I saw the problem through the eyes of, my constituents and a policymaker. I was helped to form the HTA eleven years ago. The HTA is a coop that's owned by more than 80 large US employers, and we bargain collectively in the marketplace to try to get better outcomes and better value,

better consumer experiences. So I've gotten a chance to understand health care from the point of view of the players in that ecosystem. I think most importantly, I've gotten a chance to understand health care as a dad and a spouse and, father of a internal medicine doctor. My older daughter is a physician, practicing physician. And I've certainly understood the highs and the lows. The the the wonderful feeling of having a healthy grandson born,

this terror terror of having a scary diagnosis for a member of your family, the frustration of having to struggle to get a $12 co pay adjusted because it's wrong. I mean, I've experienced it all, and I try to bring all of those experiences to the work that we do here at the HCA. Considering all of those angles that you're approaching these issues from, what's the single biggest misconception for payer executives right now? The single biggest, misconception for payer executives is that the fight

in Medicare Advantage will always be over how much the annual bump is. We are headed toward today when the fight is going to be how quickly and how effectively people produce high value outcomes for getting paid. And you might say, well, the system's never really gonna evolve to that. Well, that's what people who support regular Medicare said when Medicare Advantage was first enacted in the first decade of this millennium. It was a sort of exotic.

It was called Medicare plus choice. It was an exotic program that people said, oh, not many people will sign up. We know now that what's happened is a significant majority of new enrollees every year go for Medicare Advantage over regular Medicare. And I think we're approaching the point, if we haven't already reached it, where a majority of Medicare recipients are MA patients. I think the main reason we've seen the growth in MA, and this is

I almost chuckle when I say this. Dealing with MA providers is less frustrating for a consumer than dealing with regular Medicare. It's it's people are voting with their feet for convenience. The next step, I think, where they will vote with their feet is where do I get a better outcome for myself and a better experience? Who makes me feel better? Who solves my problems? Who's more accessible to me? So I think the competition in the future

among the MA providers will be about that, not over whether we have a 2.8 bump or a 0.9% bump. And, you know, for our listeners, the time that we're recording this was right after that increase was finalized. So very timely for you to bring that up. You know, focus in the call I read it in Becker's today, so that's how it goes. Well, I'm so glad to hear that you read the story that I actually wrote. So, but I would love to talk about self

funding a bit considering HTA's focus. So there are a lot of carriers that are offering self funding solutions and also other alternative solutions. I know we've talked about this in previous interviews that are trying to challenge traditional carriers, and their models. So in what scenarios do employers look to go around big legacy players in this space? Employers look to go around the big legacy players when when they hear no too often

from a big carrier. So if an employer says, look, we're not getting the kind of early cancer screenings that we wanna get. We're not getting as many as we wanna get. And, therefore, we wanna bring in a point solution. And, therefore, they get eighteen months worth of negotiation with the carryover data sharing with the point solution. Or when they say, look, we we have a problem with, preterm birth. Too many of our moms are giving birth early in the pregnancy. It's problems

for the baby, problems for the mom. We know that there are successful interventions would help prevent that and make the baby and the mom healthier. You know, we we want you, carrier, to pay attention to which providers and which OB practices are better at preventing preterm births than those are not. And you get a year and a half of, well, we really can't do that because that's tearing and steering, and we don't really get involved in the business of helping degrade providers.

When the no's outweigh the reasons to stay, the members are inclined to move. And so I would say to the carriers that they're either gonna have to start to say yes more often or be more susceptible to competition from, the TPAs and the smaller organizations out there. So you brought up the maternal health example. Just as a follow-up, you know, I've been tracking a couple of insurers of different sizes rolling out more specialized programs, whether that's with maternal health or chronic conditions,

other things like that. When are those initiatives actually effective versus more of just saying we're covering our bases here? Those initiatives are effective when you get the chance to look at data that tells you whether they're effective. One of the assets of the HPA is a data platform that has 5,300,000 lives in it going back fifty one months. And we generally have enough data for different solutions to see whether they work

or not. Just talking to one of our team members today about one of our large manufacturing members that is operating on the assumption that the, the maternal care program prenatal care program of their carrier is good, so they wanna steer more people toward it. Well, we said, is it really good? Well, the carrier says it. Of course, the carrier says it is. We wanna approach this with an open mind.

If it's if it really is good, more power to the carrier, and we wanna help the employer steer more pregnant moms toward that program. But if it isn't, we want the employer to know that as well. So much of this is about being able to keep score by having access to data. And, so we believe that partners that are willing to share that data, that if the carrier would say, yeah, we 10,000 women participated in this program.

And when they're measured against the control group of women who didn't participate in the program, here's why we're better. That's the kind of questions employers are asking. When payers and providers are fighting over contracts, employers are stuck in the middle very often. So what would better alignment look like? And, you know, can you touch a little bit more on that data driven focus and how that might play into contracting arrangements? Alignment comes when there's compromise on both sides.

And the compromise we'd like to see from providers is that they are more sensitive to the overhead costs and site of care costs that drive things up. That that someone I was talking to yesterday told me that he had a member of his family who needed a surgical procedure, and there were three different prices for the same doctor in the same health system depending upon the site of care. It was $3,500

at one site, $7,500 at another site, and $13,000 at a third site. Same same surgeon, same procedure. Hospitals need to do a better job of eliminating the cross subsidy that raises prices. Carriers need to do a better job of not burdening providers with too much slow pay, which is like an interest free loan from the provider to the carrier, and then too much bureaucracy to determine,

you know, whether the procedure is approved. I noticed today, again, probably in one of your articles, that prior auth is down 11% versus before the before the commitment was made to reduce it. So, look, good compromises or good agreements are made when both sides compromise, and we think those are compromises that both carriers and and, providers could make. I was actually interviewing someone a few weeks ago about,

a self funding model that they were focused on and how they're trying to shift a lot of people or a lot of employers who work with health systems normally to independent providers and communities. How feasible do you think that is, to execute something like that? It's not easy to do, but it's worth doing, and therefore, it is feasible if the results are better. The the again, I find that,

a lot of the health care debate is whether Kmart is better than Target. The real question is, is Amazon better than Kmart and Target? Who's gonna build a system that is consumer driven, consumer friendly, less expensive, and more convenient? And if it's in if it's an independent player, I think that player is gonna win. If it's a player that's embedded in big providers or big carriers, I think that system is gonna win. It's less about

what the ownership structure looks like and more about what the objectives of the organization are. And, you know, we're looking for organizations that wanna say, we want consumers to feel a lot better about their experience. We want them healthier as a result of the experience. And we understand it will cost maybe a little more at the beginning, but it'll save a lot in the end. I would use as an example, who really gets up every morning and worries about medication adherence?

We it's it's a it's a fact of life like the sun rises in the East that a diabetic who stays current with their metformin is gonna have a better result than one who doesn't. Who's doing something about that? And it doesn't really matter so much to us if the if the someone is owned by private equity or is a five zero one three owned by a hospital or whether it is a carrier or a PBM. Who's getting the job done? And,

I think the biggest disease in US health care is the repetition disease. Probably most of the problems I've mentioned here in our discussion have been around for thirty or forty years. There's nothing new about any of these problems. What I hope will be new is that new players will come into the market or old players will solve these problems in the market. In an economy where more and more consumers are more and more result driven,

I want what I want delivered to my doorstep at a price that I think is right by this afternoon at 04:00. That's the opposite of health care. Whomever can make that happen for consumers in health care is gonna be the winner, And we think there should be a robust competitive market to see who wins. Are there any concerns you're hearing from employers in your recent discussions with them that you wanna bring up, whether it's about, you know, kind of that consumer push for more direct access?

Anything similar to that that has kind of been dominating your conversations lately. The great hockey player Wayne Gretzky said infamously that great players are not where the puck is. They're where the puck's going. Where we think the puck is going is a tsunami of gene therapy and cell therapy claims. Today, gene therapy is for extremely rare and exotic diseases like sickle cell anemia or horrible respiratory diseases for infants.

Thank God there are solutions happening right now saving people's lives. We think there's gonna be an evolution of gene therapy away from exotic to just exotic diseases to more common ones like type one diabetes or skin cancer or alcoholism. When that occurs, and I think it's when, not if, we see a tsunami of high cost claims that are gonna have to be paid by someone because I don't see a society I don't wanna live in a society when someone says,

yeah, We could cure your son of type one diabetes, but we're not covering it. I don't think that should happen or is gonna happen. But the cost of these therapies is gonna be monstrous compared to the present spend. Where we think the market will eventually go is a hybrid model where very high cost claimants are dealt within a fully insured product that is capped by a premium, where the risk bearing entity has both the expertise and the incentive to get a great

outcome for the patient, and where the sprained ankles and normal pregnancies and knee operations are left in the are the normal knee operations are left in the the fully the self insured model. That company doesn't exist yet. I bet it does in five years or less. And, it it could be the big three. It it, it could be the buccas. It could be a new player. It could be someone not in health care right now.

But you you would have, I'm I this is literally true, I think, that, people came into Blockbuster Video in the eighties. And so now we really ought to think about a product where people can watch movies on their home computer. And they said, that's a really stupid idea. We're not gonna do that. Well, hello, Netflix. I'm sure it seemed bizarre the first time the creators of Uber got together and said, you know, if ordinary citizens just made themselves

available as temporary drivers and picked people up at their house and dropped them off where they wanna go and have their credit card information on file. And that seems like a really bizarre thought that who would really do that? Hello, Uber. That health care is going there. And the reason it's going there is, I think, closely tied to the tsunami of gene and cell, gene and cell, therapies that are coming in the very near future.

How do you recommend these new entrants or even, you know, current players that are going into that space with the more segmented pharmacy approach? How do you recommend they build trust with employers as employers are used to more traditional models? Step one is know your customer. It's not the CEO of the company. It's probably not the CHRO or the CFO. It is a benefit lead who is three or four steps down the ladder from the very top of the company, but whose job it is to make the

plan work every day. And she or he, it's usually a she. You have to earn that trust. She's heard a million times that all I can save you 15% on your medical spend. Some of our members whimsically say to me, you know, tomorrow I'm gonna have six meetings with Point Solutions, and I'm gonna hire them all, and I'll save 90% of my medical spend, six times 15. I mean, they they know that that's not true. The way that you earn their trust is to show them the data,

give them references of people you've done good work for, tell them the truth. Your product isn't always perfect. It's not always gonna work. It's not easy to implement. And let them know that when all hell is breaking loose, she'll be there as their partner. I mean, this is the person who if 90 people show up at a radiology lab today and all of them get their appointments canceled because there's some administrative glitch, it's that problem lands in their lap. That's what they're worried about today.

If you help them solve that problem, you earn their trust. If you tell them that, no. No. They need to take an hour and read your pitch deck about how they're gonna say 15%, you're slamming the door in their fingers. Do you have any final thoughts or advice for industry leaders as we wrap up our conversation today? Be proud of the industry that you are in. Naturally, people in health care gravitate to what's wrong and how to fix it. That's our job. But what isn't wrong, what's right, and how

to sustain it is this is an amazing place to get care. Sovereign potentates come here to get their care for a reason. Because there are heart transplants happening today in small hospitals that would have been unimaginable forty years ago. There are children who will be born today who weigh a pound and a half, who will survive to be full, thriving, healthy adults. There are cancer survivors who would have never

survived, ten years ago, fifteen years ago because the advances that have been made in detection and surgery and chemotherapy. We should be proud of this system. We should be concerned about its inequities, its inefficiencies, its shortcomings, but let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater. Now I in our own families, we can I can? I think we all can point to some story that is miraculous about something that was

done to help someone we love. That didn't happen by accident. It happened because we have a lot of good people in the health care system who can do great things. Let's try to unleash their talents so they could do more. I guess I'd put it to you this way. I would hope that the most valuable player in the health care system would be a maternity health nurse who helps convince, a mom to take better care of herself so the baby's healthier than she is, not someone who's great at upcoding

so the hospital can collect more revenue. That's what we need to do is fix a system where that maternal nose nurse is the rock star, and the upcoder is shows some value, but is not the rock star of the team. Well, Rob, thank you so much for joining us today, and I'm looking forward to continuing this conversation going forward.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Payment Integrity Can Protect Savings Without Creating More Friction

    Nov 20, 202619 minAudio

    In this episode, Jon Grandstaff, Senior Vice President of Payment Integrity at Zelis, discusses how payers can reduce payment friction, use AI to support more accurate claims reviews and improve payer-provider...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. From Learning Collaborative to Gap Closure: How Wisconsin Medicaid Is Telethinking Colorectal Cancer Screening

    Nov 19, 202612 minAudio

    In this episode, Amy Conlon, MPH, Population Health Sr. Manager at Exact Sciences, and Jeff Huebner, MD, FAAFP, Executive Medical Officer, Division of Medicaid Services, Wisconsin Department of Health Services, discuss...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. What Health Plans Miss When They Look at Markets in Isolation

    Nov 18, 202617 minAudio

    In this episode, Denis Mrkva, Senior Vice President of Analytics Solutions at Data Axle, discusses how health plans can combine consumer, employer, geographic and healthcare data to identify growth opportunities, reduce...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Strengthening Provider Networks Through AI, Data and Strategic Partnerships

    Nov 17, 20268 minAudio

    In this episode, Bob Tavernier, Solutions Executive at Quest Analytics®, discusses how health plans can leverage AI, provider data and strategic partnerships to improve network accuracy, strengthen regulatory compliance...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Martina Lee Strickland, Head of Marketing, PR and Brand at Clever Care Health Plan

    Nov 16, 202617 minAudio

    In this episode, Martina Lee Strickland, Head of Marketing, PR and Brand at Clever Care Health Plan, joins the podcast to discuss the importance of building trust when serving underserved communities. She also shares...

    Credit the people on this episode