My own kid has told me for years that talking to people online is just easier than talking to them in person. I used to wonder if that was a red flag. Andrew Fishman helped me understand that it actually might be the opposite. Andrew is a licensed clinical social worker and author of “Parenting a Gamer” who specializes in the impact of video games on mental health. He spent years running group therapy for autistic kids, teens, and adults before focusing his practice on adolescent gamers, many of them neurodivergent. In this episode, we get into why gaming can feel like the safest, most predictable place in a kid's whole day, especially for a kid whose brain works differently than the world around them expects. Andrew breaks down why success in a game is actually guaranteed in a way it almost never is in real life, why that fairness matters so much to a kid who's used to things not going their way, and how the social rules inside a game, like no eye contact required, no reading of body language, can strip away exhausting layers of decoding for an autistic or ADHD kid. We also talk honestly about safety, the parental controls that actually work, what to do when your kid gets pulled into online conflict because their sense of justice won't let something slide, and why the meltdown at transition time usually isn't really about the game at all. Andrew shares the question that changes everything when your kid won't log off, and a handful of specific games worth knowing about, including one built specifically to help autistic kids practice social skills. If gaming has ever felt like a battlefield in your house, this conversation will change how you see it. Listen to the full episode now. You can find additional resources at parentingadhdandautism.com and Regulated Kids.com - because it's not just about the struggles, it's about progress, one step at a time. Show notes and more resources at parentingadhdandautism.com/377 Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/beautifully-complex--6137613/support. You can find additional resources at parentingadhdandautism.com. It's not just about the struggles, it’s about progress, one step at a time.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Your kid is three hours deep into a game, and when you finally say it's time to stop, it's not a small no, it's a full nervous system event. You've probably wondered if that reaction means that gaming is the problem. Today, I'm talking with Andrew Fishman, author of Parenting a Gamer and a therapist who specializes in gaming and mental health. We discuss what's actually happening in those moments, and why gaming might be doing more for your neurodivergent kid than
Speaker 1you realize. I'm Penny Williams, and this is Beautifully Complex. Welcome back, everyone. I am really excited to have this conversation around parenting a gamer because I am a parent of gamers, and I know that a lot of parents really struggle with this. How much is too much? How much is just right? Should they be online? Should they not be online? All of these questions because we worry
Speaker 1about our kids and their health and their safety. And Andrew Fishman is here to help us kind of untangle all of this and figure out safety, figure out benefits, all that good stuff. So, Andrew, will you start by letting everybody know who you are and what you do?
Speaker 2Thank you for having me. I'm happy to be here. I'm a social worker. I specialize in the impacts of video games on mental health. I've been a therapist for about nine years. I worked at a therapeutic school while getting my master's degree. I spent three-ish years running group therapy for autistic kids, teens, and adults. Right now, I mostly work with adolescents, especially autistic people, and a lot of gamers, a lot of nerds. For a lot of my clients, they come in with their parents, and their parents' main concern is, my kids spend so much time
Speaker 2playing video games that I think they're addicted. Can you help us?
Speaker 1Can you talk to us a little bit about that? I think people are really confused about where the line is for addiction.
Speaker 2So there is a thing called gaming disorder. Right now, if you're familiar, there's a book called The DSM, which is sort of the big tome that has every mental disorder that we're aware of in it and how do you diagnose it. And gaming disorder is in there as sort of a provisional, we're not sure if this exists, diagnosis in the back. This has some evidence. We're continuing to study. It might be in the next edition. And when they're talking about gaming disorder, they're talking about tolerance, feeling like you need to spend more and more time
Speaker 2gaming to get the same feeling, giving up other activities, loss of interest in things you used to enjoy, continuing to play video games, even though it's causing you problems, lying to family members, and then you know, risking other aspects of your life to game more. A classic example, I see it pretty regularly, is people who couldn't pull themselves away from video games in college, ended up not going to class because they needed to play World of Warcraft or ended up not doing their homework and they just, and they flunked out.
Speaker 1Yeah, we hear those stories a lot. It's really tough. And I want to kind of backtrack a little bit, I think, and talk about your perspective on gaming. Are there benefits? What are the drawbacks? What are the pitfalls? You know, thinking as a parent myself, how do we navigate this thing that is here? Our technology is here. It's not going anywhere. Our kids are exposed to it now at school, everywhere. So how do we help them learn how to find that balance that you were just
Speaker 1talking about?
Speaker 2So the first thing I would say is that video games are an art form like any other. It's like TV. It's like books. It's like movies. It's like going to a museum sometimes. There are trashy games that I think are kind of meaningless. And then there are really beautiful games that are as impactful and wonderful as any TV show I've ever seen or any book I've ever read. The narratives are amazing. The gameplay is fun and exciting. There's a lot of social benefits. We can get into all of these things. I think... One of the things
Speaker 2that draws most of my clients to video games, and I think this will resonate with a lot of your listeners, is that video games are fair. That more than any other part of your life, if you practice and work really hard and you follow the rules and you adapt, you're going to win. You can succeed in this game. where success is not guaranteed in any other part of your life for the rest of your life. You could do everything right and not get a job. You could do everything right and flunk out of college because it wasn't right for you. There are aspects of interpersonal relationships
Speaker 2that are just beyond your control. And video games are uniquely safe in that way, that it's predictable and it's fun and it's accepting.
Speaker 1So many good things in there, right? That predictability for a lot of our neurodivergent kids, they crave that. but also the social aspect. My own son, who's about to turn 24, he talks all the time, and he has since he was little, about the fact that interacting with people is so much easier online than it is in person. And so that pulls our kids in that direction. How do we help them sort of throttle that maybe like
Speaker 1you know learn where boundaries should be where time frames should.
Speaker 2Be so I think what a lot of people find reassuring is that most people never develop like a true problem with video games there's a sort of push and pull sometimes I spend more if I'm really into a game sometimes I spend less because there's nothing hooking me at the moment and most people it doesn't really impact their well-being one way or the other it's just another fact of life I think the last statistic I read was that something like 91% of teen boys play video games regularly. And 91% of boys are not being impacted
Speaker 2negatively by this activity. For most people, it's just fun. And so I always encourage people to look at the other parts of their life also. Does your kid have other interests? Does your kid have a social life? Is your kid doing well at school? Are they doing extracurricular activities? Are they learning a musical instrument? If this is not the only thing they're doing and they have a well-rounded life, their use of video games is probably fine. It's probably just a harmless way to relax after a long day.
Speaker 1Yeah. I'm just thinking about how much of a struggle that still is for a lot of parents. And I think, and you can tell me if I'm wrong, but it feels like it's a generational difference also. And that's how I think a lot of parents are getting caught up. We older parents who didn't grow up with gaming, didn't grow up with cell phones and computers in our hands, and it feels so different that it feels sort of threatening.
Speaker 1That's kind of where my head is going as we're talking. I think younger parents who've grown up with it maybe don't worry as much about it. Do you sense that too?
Speaker 2Yeah. Oh, absolutely. And there's actually some evidence that even scientists are subject to that kind of bias, that scientists who don't like video games or didn't grow up with them are more likely to criticize and see them as harmful than people who grew up with them themselves and know more about the games.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And so I think there's absolutely a stigma.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah. So we've established that they're most often not harmful. I think there's two directions to go now. One is about safety, because that's definitely a concern. and also about benefits. So what makes more sense first?
Speaker 2So to talk to your viewers for a second, I wrote a book about this subject. And the first subject, the first topic of the book, the first third is sort of a primer 101. And then also what are the benefits? So from that perspective, I think that makes sense.
Speaker 1Yeah, absolutely. And we'll link the book up for everyone too.
Speaker 2Thank you. So the benefits of gaming, it's, I think, first off, the same benefits that you would experience from any work of art. It increases your experience of the world. It just makes your world bigger. The more stories you are exposed to, I think the better person you end up being, the more empathy you have. And it's hard to describe what art does to you, but I think it just makes you a more whole person. There's also social benefits, as we talked about, any time that you can connect with other people, even if it's over a
Speaker 2shared game, especially if it's over a shared game. It's just a nice way to spend time and just become a more interesting, well-rounded person. Social time is always good. For autistic people, I think you alluded to this earlier, where it feels like a safer, easier place to socialize. One of the ways that I think about that is that there's a lot that neurotypical people take for granted in social settings. How much eye contact is too much? How do I know if this person is really interested in what I have to say? Can I talk about
Speaker 2my special interest? Have I said too much about it? Has this person's body language indicated that they want to end this conversation? What are their facial expressions telling me? And although autistic people can often do a lot of those things, it's a lot of juggling in your head. It's a lot of trying to remember, wait, shoot, their feet are pointed toward the door and they said this one thing. And so now I have to figure out, well, okay, shoot, do I pivot then the conversation? Have I said too much about myself? And a lot of those barriers go away in a game. Yeah. Where if your special interest
Speaker 2is Minecraft and you are playing Minecraft, everyone in that room has self-selected to hear about Minecraft. Everyone is interested about it. You don't have to worry about it. You don't have to worry about eye contact. You can't even make eye contact in this space. You don't have to worry about body language. It's... easier to script socially. And so it's both its own good thing and also a good stepping stone, a place to practice social relationships that you can then take out into the real world.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah. And talk to us a little bit about the safety around that, because I know a lot of parents worry, and this was a huge concern of mine, Two is we don't know the other people that they're interacting with in that space. And some of them are predators. There's no dancing around that. Most of them, I think, are not, right? It's not the majority. But how do we keep our kids safe in those spaces? Do we have to be there with them to do that?
Speaker 2So there's two pieces to this that I would bring up. One of them is there are parental controls in most, if not all, games or settings within the menu if it's not a direct parental control. And that's to limit who's allowed to talk to your kid. So in Fortnite, just as an example that I think does it really well, there's a sliding bar in the settings menu if you go to communications or connections, I forget what it's called. But you go to this one area and then there's a sliding bar that says everyone can talk to me. Or if you slide it a little less, it's only
Speaker 2my friends and the people I'm currently on a team with can talk to me. If you slide it a little further, then it's only my friends can talk to me. And then if you slide it further, no one can talk to me. And so again, there's options in all these games from I just want to play this game and I don't want anyone to hear what I'm saying and I don't want to hear what anybody else is saying. And then it goes all the way up to anyone, including those predators, can talk to me. I think that option, that most extreme anyone can talk to me, should be off in every game that kids are playing.
Speaker 1For sure.
Speaker 2And the problem with Roblox in particular, as the most notorious example, is that although they changed it recently, I've heard mixed reviews, it used to at least be that you could only set it to everyone can talk to me or nobody can talk to me. There was no friends only option. And so if your 10-year-old kid wants to talk to other 10-year-olds from his class and they're all talking in Roblox, There was no way to also disallow 50-year-olds from another state to talk to them. And so if you have the option, and I would go
Speaker 2into the game settings, the kids' favorite games, and just turn that option off for strangers to talk to them. And then I think to your second point, I think that the best thing that parents can do is to play with their kids just to see what's going on, to spend some positive time with them, to get a good bonding experience. There's a lot of benefits to playing with your kids. And one of them is to passively monitor You know, I keep hearing my kid talking on his headset. Are they talking to other kids that I would approve of or are they talking to people that I wouldn't? And you can't make good decisions if you
Speaker 2don't have enough information. Yeah.
Speaker 1We really need to engage with them about what they're doing online, have those conversations and know what's going on. Yeah. It's so good to hear about those parental controls because when my kid was 10, those didn't exist. We were just trying to figure out how, like, how do we limit I guess, who they're with and what's going on. And it was much, much more difficult then. So I know parental controls have come a long way now.
Speaker 2They also make for a more pleasant experience generally. I still turn on some of those settings myself. Grand Theft Auto has an online version where you're playing with other people. I played it for maybe three minutes before I heard, you know, it sounded like elementary school children yelling racial slurs. And I thought to myself, I just don't want any of that in my life. I'm done. I just went to the setting right away, turned it off, Much more pleasant experience. I'd turn it off at any age. I think it's generally a bad idea.
Speaker 1A lot of our neurodivergent kids have this really strong sense of justice. This was a big thing with my own kid, gaming and online, is when people weren't behaving themselves, he wanted to fix it. He would engage to try to get them to be better, to do better. And it was a real battle to get him to not engage in that stuff, to just let it go, move on. I don't know if you have any words of wisdom
Speaker 1around that, but I found that to be, and so many parents that I talk to in coaching and stuff are like, this sense of justice just kills us. It takes us into places that we just don't need to go all the time.
Speaker 2What you're describing is very real. This sense of justice, this sort of, there is a right way to do things. And often they're right. Those people shouldn't be acting that way. And it's not fair. And it's wrong. And you want them to stop. And you can't. And that's the hardest part for a lot of people is that the people online who are saying the worst things are doing it for fun. They're doing it because they enjoy the fight. They enjoy the attention that it gives them. And so the only way to really stop them is to just not give them that attention. It's just report them, block them,
Speaker 2move on. And that feels like not enough. It feels like you should convince them otherwise. It feels like you should just show them the error of their ways. And the reality is that that doesn't change anybody's mind ever, especially on the internet. It's just telling them that they're wrong and yelling at them. And it doesn't do anything if that person is not acting in good faith. This is not a debate. This is a troll on the internet. And so the best tool that you have as someone who cares about justice and cares about people acting right,
Speaker 2block them and move on. And if enough people do that, it stops being fun for them and they stop.
Speaker 1Yeah. So eventually that can work.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1That I need a resolution right now thing gets you stuck. It's so real. It's hard to get at least my kid to move on from that. I was like, no, I'm going to make sure they know that they're being hateful. Yeah. Can we talk a little bit about that power struggle around gaming? This is something I think every parent probably knows at this point if your kid's old enough to be gaming, especially like when we're asking them to stop.
Speaker 1When it's time to transition to do something else, sometimes we see the most surprising and challenging behavior out of our kids when And I think we interpret that as, well, then gaming isn't a good thing for them. If they can't transition, then we just need to not do it at all. Where do you fall in that debate? What is the evidence kind of telling you about what's going on there?
Speaker 2Well, first, I'd say that transitions are hard and have always been hard. And games are no exception. If your kid is really into music, maybe playing the saxophone is their thing and transitioning them away from that and toward bedtime or toward a shower at the end of the day or toward homework is going to be a struggle too. Games are no exception to that. And so I don't think that they are uniquely bad in that way, in that transitions are just hard. The other thing that I would encourage parents to look for and to listen for is when you say it's time to go to bed,
Speaker 2time to turn the games off for the night. what do they say is the reason that they want to keep playing? Because there are different categories and different ways that you can respond as a parent based on what they identify as the problem. So if it's, but my, you know, we're in the middle of a round, my friends are going to lose. That's different. That's a different problem, a different kid and a different solution that you can implement. Then I just need one more minute. Then I'm going to finish. And then I'm almost there. I'm almost at the end of the level versus I need to finish, or I'm not gonna be able to do this thing anymore. Or,
Speaker 2One of the harder reasons is if they're playing to sort of dull emotional pain and the rest of the world is just more difficult and they don't want to go back to the real world. But the point is that each of those categories requires a different response from you and you can't know how to respond if you don't know what the problem is. And so I think that for most parents, the first step, first and most important step is stay curious, stay calm and talk to the kid about what was actually happening in that moment. What made it so hard for you? on top of
Speaker 2it just being a transition.
Speaker 1And they're not always going to be able to have that conversation in that moment.
Speaker 2Very good point.
Speaker 1Sometimes we, you know, a lot of times I think we have to wait. I remember realizing that for my own kid, it was like, I'm at a point where I can't save. Everything I've been doing all this time is going to be lost if I don't have five more minutes so I can save. And I, you know, I started talking to parents about like, imagine you're watching this mystery, this whodunit movie, and somebody right when they're about to tell you who actually did it, they turn it off and they say, sorry, we got to go do something else. Like you would be upset too.
Speaker 2Yes. And it's truly like, all right, if I needed five more minutes and then I would happily turn it off because then I will have all the ends will be tied up and I will know who did it and I can move on.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And the saving is a big one too, where if I had been working on a proposal for work or something for an hour, And for whatever reason, I couldn't save my progress until I finished this paragraph. Oh, you couldn't stop me from finishing that paragraph. That's a tremendous amount of work and effort put in. And it's the same thing for a lot of games. Sometimes you have to reach a checkpoint to save it.
Speaker 1So for the kids who you give them five more minutes and now they want another five minutes, they want another 10 minutes, they want just one more minute. Is that where we're starting to see more of a problem that we need to address maybe?
Speaker 2I think that's certainly one sign. There are some games that just work against you in that way. Some games are designed to be, you're always five minutes away from something. And they overlap all these goals so that as soon as you finish one, you think, all right, well, I'm going to, as soon as I reach the town, Then I'm going to turn it off. And then you get to the town and somebody goes, oh, can you do this one more thing for me? We're five minutes. And you're like, okay, well, surely now that I can do this, I can five more minutes. I wrote about this in the book. I've fallen into this trap too. There's a
Speaker 2game called Skyrim where they give you, you know, there's 300 different quests and all of them are, they only take a couple of minutes each and they overlap. So when you're just finished one, you're also almost finished with the next one. And three hours went by without realizing it. It's now two in the morning. And I thought, shoot, I was supposed to go to bed. How did that happen? Yeah. And so it's an easy trap to fall into, even as adults, even as people who know better. Some of the games just work against you. And so if that's your kid, maybe talking to them about maybe that specific game is causing more problems than it's helping for you.
Speaker 1That segues right into the next thing I wanted to ask you, which is, can you list some specific games that you find... help to build skills, have benefits? Do you have some favorites?
Speaker 2Oh gosh, I like so many games. The first one that comes to my mind is Minecraft. The single player or co-op version of it as a way to practice planning ahead, as a way to be creative and I'm not sure how much you and your listeners know about Minecraft, so I'll back up a second. Minecraft is an extraordinarily popular game, and it's very creative, where you're dropped in what's called a sandbox world, where you can do whatever you want. You can create and destroy parts of the environment,
Speaker 2you can raise animals, you can go hunt monsters, you can go build a building, and you have a tremendous amount of creative power over this world. And so people use it to recreate buildings from their neighborhood. They use it to build their dream mansion. They use it to raise livestock and create a little farm to gather resources. And some of them want to gather the best things and then delve into the mines and figure out what's down there. And there's a lot of forethought and planning that is just naturally built into this game, where if
Speaker 2I want to build this mansion of my dreams... I need to not only figure out what I want it to look like and then execute, I need to gather those resources that will allow me to... I need to go get wood if I want to go build a log cabin. And so there's a lot of creative potential in this game. I think most directly, that's a game that I would suggest has benefits. Yeah. There's a game, another one that I mentioned in the book, it's called Balotro, but people pronounce it Balotro, where it looks like poker, it looks like gambling, but it's all statistics and numbers
Speaker 2and probabilities. And you're trying to get the highest score by, gosh, it's complicated and hard to describe. It's a lot of math. And so it's the Fibonacci sequence and it's multipliers on multipliers on exponents and repeated exponents. It gets really complicated really fast.
Speaker 1Wow.
Speaker 2I can go on, but I think you get the point. There's a lot of games and ways to view them as beneficial in that way. Actually, sorry, there's one more game that just came to mind. I'm not sure if this is actually released yet or not, but I was given early access to a game called AVA, A-V-A, which is designed for autistic kids to practice social skills. Oh, wow. And so you're this little girl named Ava, and you're flying around this world, and you're talking to people, and... You're sort of guided through social scripts and conversations where
Speaker 2you talk to someone and then you have multiple choice. What do you want to say to them next? And then if you say something that's rude, then the person reacts poorly. And Ava thinks to herself, oh, gosh, I really said that was too much too soon, wasn't it? I should probably try again. And it goes through some of the really easy mistakes that we all fall into and gently guides you into what are some other ways that you could handle various interactions. It was designed by autistic people for autistic people. Very cool.
Speaker 1Sounds amazing. Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Really amazing. Because they're getting that feedback in real time without maybe that social danger. Not danger, but like, you know.
Speaker 2The stakes are low in this game.
Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Amazing. There are a million more things we could talk about, and we're already running short on time. Is there anything that we haven't talked about that you feel like is really, really important for parents to hear right now?
Speaker 2Yeah, I think that the biggest takeaway I really want people to have is to play alongside your kids. And this is probably going to be uncomfortable for a lot of people, especially if you didn't grow up with the games. It's going to be strange to play with your kid in a way that you're going to be bad at it for a while. You might want to just watch. You might want to just sit next to them while they show you all around their virtual world. But it's such a good way to bond, to connect, to learn more, to learn what the language is that you can use.
Speaker 2Where if you know, for example, that your kid does these things called raids and, you know, maybe you don't really know what they are, but you know that they take 30 minutes each and that you can't save until the end of it. That informs a lot of your parental decisions and gives you the language to communicate more effectively with your kid. You can say, look, I know you're in the middle of a raid, but we need to turn this right off right now because grandma's coming over in three minutes. That's more effective communication than just you need to turn it off. Just acknowledging that there's a problem and using the kid's language helps bridge those gaps.
Speaker 1For sure. Yeah, absolutely. My kids wanted me to play and wanted me to play. And then they're like, you're really holding me back. Maybe I don't need you here.
Speaker 2Yeah. I bet that was a really fun day for them.
Speaker 1Because I'm not a gamer.
Speaker 2I bet that was so fun.
Speaker 1For them, though. Yeah, to be the authority and the one who knows how to do something better than mom. Absolutely. Completely.
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 1Tell everybody where they can find you online and where they can find The Buck Parenting a Gamer.
Speaker 2So my website is videogamehealth.com. You can see a lot of articles and things that I've written there. You could find the book anywhere books are sold. It's called Parenting a Gamer. Help your child build healthy habits, make positive choices, and find balance in virtual worlds.
Speaker 1And thank you for focusing on this. Thank you for helping us to navigate this. It is a challenge for so, so many families. And I think understanding what are the benefits? Are there problem areas what can we do to make sure this is healthy that's how we alleviate some of the worry and the anxiety that we have around it and our kids can then have a better experience so i really appreciate that um this is some of the
Speaker 1world that you're doing your work in and i was just so happy to talk to you and happy to have you here i really appreciate.
Speaker 2It thank you so much let's do it again sometime yeah i.
Speaker 1Will put all of andrew's links in the show notes for everyone And I hope to see you next time. Take good care. Visit beautifully-complex.com for more resources, coaching, and parent training. And help another kid by sharing this with someone who could benefit from listening.
The holidays aren't the most wonderful time of the year for a lot of our families. For many of us raising neurodivergent kids, they're the most dysregulating time. And if you're already dreading the holidays, that's not...
Your child's nervous system is running on a budget, and some mornings it's already overdrawn before the bus arrives. Socks with seams, overhead lights, a barking dog, wet grass on the hem of their pants. For...
A meltdown over homework is rarely just about the homework. When our neurodivergent kids fall apart over one worksheet, one chore, or one simple request, there's almost always more happening beneath the surface than we...
Worry can feel like love. When you're raising neurodivergent kids, worry can even feel like the responsible thing to do. But worry quietly pulls our attention inward, and our kids' nervous systems notice. In this...
Some mornings, the most dysregulated person in the room isn't your child. It's you. And that doesn't make you a bad parent. It makes you human, with a nervous system that's been hypervigilant for a long time. In this...