Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Beautifully Complex

Beautifully Complex artwork

345: We Need to Talk About Dignity and Humanity, with Penny Williams

Feb 12, 202622 minAudio

Somewhere along the way, we started normalizing things that should never be normal for kids. Public behavior charts. Compliance scripts delivered to dysregulated nervous systems. Support that’s only available if a child behaves “well enough.” And the cost of all of it is dignity. In this episode, I’m naming what so many parents feel in their gut but struggle to articulate: too many systems prioritize compliance over humanity, especially for neurodivergent kids. When behavior is treated like a moral failure instead of a nervous system signal, children learn that their bodies are a problem, their needs are inconvenient, and their voices don’t matter. I walk through real, everyday examples, like classroom behavior charts, IEP meetings where kids disappear in plain sight, “calm down” spaces that feel more like exile than support, and the familiar phrase “they know better.” These practices don’t teach skills. They teach fear, shame, and self-abandonment. Dignity isn’t something kids earn through good behavior. It’s a basic human right. And regulation isn’t a choice - it’s biology. When we ask kids to perform regulation on demand, we’re asking them to do something their nervous system literally cannot do in that moment. This episode isn’t about being permissive or coddling kids who struggle. It’s about being humane. It’s about choosing nervous-system-first support, privacy, co-regulation, and repair over punishment. It’s about asking one simple question before we respond: Does this preserve this child’s humanity? I’m not neutral on this. I’m choosing dignity above all, and I’m inviting you to do the same. 🎧 Listen now and join me in changing the story for our beautifully complex kids. [JOLIE - ADD the below at the end of the description only in Spreaker, not in Wordpress] You can find additional resources at parentingadhdandautism.com and Regulated Kids.com - because it’s not just about the struggles, it’s about progress, one step at a time. Show notes and more resources at parentingadhdandautism.com/345 Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/beautifully-complex--6137613/support. You can find additional resources at parentingadhdandautism.com. It's not just about the struggles, it’s about progress, one step at a time.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Systems claim to teach skills, but they actually rely on fear, shame, and withdrawal of connection and affection. Welcome to Beautifully Complex, where we unpack what it really means to parent neurodivergent kids with dignity and clarity. I'm Penny Williams, and I know firsthand how tough and transformative this journey can be. Let's dive in and discover how to raise regulated, resilient, beautifully complex kids together. Oh and if you want more support,

Speaker 1join our free community at hub dot beautifully complex dot life. Welcome back, folks. We need to have a conversation about dignity and humanity. I'm going to first walk you through a few examples before we jump into the meat of this discussion. But we have crossed a line and started calling things normal that are not or should not be normal.

Speaker 1Example number one, the behavior chart on the wall in your kid's school classroom. It's laminated. It's up near the teacher's desk. Everybody can see it, teachers and kids alike. There's green, there's yellow, there's red, and each child has a clip or a card with their name on it when they get overwhelmed. Not disruptive they're just overwhelmed. The clip has to get moved, the card has to be turned.

Speaker 1There's no explanation, no conversation, and by lunch that kid knows exactly where they stand, and so does everyone else. This strips their dignity. Think about an IEP meeting where a kid completely disappears. You're in the conference room, there's like six adults, the IEPs up on the screen. Your kid is sitting at the table, or maybe they're just outside the door. While all of the adults are talking

Speaker 1about their deficits, their behavior, challenges, and any other concerns. They're using words like non compliant, avoidant, refuses, disrespectful. No one's asking your kid how they feel in their body. No one notices them disappearing and folding into themselves. Their dignity has been stripped. Another example, the calm down room

Speaker 1that really isn't about calm your kids. Support plan says quote sensory break. It sounds really thoughtful, it sounds really trauma informed and safe, but in practice it looks like this. A child escalates, the adult escorts them out of the room, the door closes, and the message to that kid is very clear. Even if nobody ever says it out loud. Come back when you can be easier to be around.

Speaker 1We don't want you here if you're a problem. That strips their dignity, folks. Another example the gentle compliance script. An adult kneels and uses a calm voice. I need you to make a good choice, use your words. We don't do that here. The child's body is shaking, They're breathing is shallow. They're so disregulated, but the expectation always stays the same, perform regulation on demand. You've shown me

Speaker 1you're disregulated, But I'm going to tell you that you need to be regulated, and then I'm gonna expect then it just magically happens. This strips dignity, folks. How about those data points in our IEPs that end up just replacing a child. The report says, meltdown's reduced by forty percent. What it's not saying is the child stopped asking for help, The child learned to freeze, the child learned it was safer to disappear. That strips dignity, folks. How about that

Speaker 1he knows better moment. We've almost all had these conversations with our kids' schools. A child does something impulsive, they blurt something out, they might swing at someone when they said something mean. Then the adult size and says he knows better. But knowing isn't the same as being able, and shame does not build skills, folks. It erases safety,

Speaker 1It strips the feeling of safety. It can't happen under shame, and so what happens? It strips dignity. You guessed it. When someone tells you to just do it already and stop asking questions. I'm sure at some point in your life somebody has said that to you. Just do it already and stop asking questions. How does that feel? On the receiving end? It feels like you don't matter, doesn't it?

Speaker 1It erases your dignity and humanity. Somewhere along the way, we decided that compliance actually matters more than humanity. Do you hear how ridiculous that sounds? We have decided that compliance matters more than humanity? No? Absolutely, not, no way. So this episode is going to be about strategies, It's going to be about doing, and I am not neutral on this. I will warn you right now I'm not

Speaker 1going to be neutral. And remember that if a strategy wouldn't be acceptable for an adult. It's not suddenly humane because the person is a child. Kids are people too. I've said this before on the podcast, but when I was four or five years old, I had a T shirt and it said kids are people too, right on the front, and I wanted to wear that shirt every moment of every day. So it started very young for me to see kids as people. They're not things that

Speaker 1we need to control. They are people that we need to help along the way to finding themselves and doing it with dignity and humanity. Let's define dignity in plain language. It is being treated as a full human, even when struggling, even when different. When someone is different from you and you treat them like a full human, you are treating

Speaker 1them with dignity. It is not earning respect through behavior. No one should earn respect in my opinion. It's not proving worth by performing, and it's not losing rights because regulation is hard. Regulation is hard for so many of our kids. They are on the cusp of that activated state of dysregulation. So very often that is high alert. That is where's the stress. I know there's stress coming.

Speaker 1Where is it? Oh my gosh, I can't do this and then we tack on to that, we approach that without any dignity. We strip the dignity right out of it by asking for compliance. We feel like kids need to earn humane treatment by behaving appropriately using my air quotes. Again, no one, no human being, should have to earn humane treatment. Ever,

Speaker 1we also work from this place of thinking that support is conditional. If we can have unconditional love for another human little or not, we can have unconditional support. We can unconditionally treat them with dignity. The hard truth is that our nerd divergent kids are asked to sacrifice dignity for access. You can have support, but only if you comply.

Speaker 1So we've talked about a lot of examples of where dignity gets lost in school, those public behavior charts, those clip systems, forced eye contact isolation so that they can calm adults talking about a child while they're right there, present in the room, talking about them, and for them taking away recess because a kid does their work more slowly, taking away movement, taking away autonomy. Hello, we need autonomy

Speaker 1to feel safe, folks. He knows better language. Well, I'm sorry, miss Williams, but your son knows better than to lash out when another kid is unkind, what are you going to do about this? Come on? Knowing better and being able to do better depend on the state of the nervous system. They are two totally different things. These practices that I was just talking about teach kids that their body is a problem, that their needs are inconvenient, and

Speaker 1that their voice does not matter. Wow. I mean this is making me, honestly feel a little sick to talk about right now. This is not what we want for our kids. Folks and teachers don't want this for our kids either. They are practicing traditional methods and following traditional ideals about education that just fly in the face of neuroscience. It's not about educating, it's about conditioning. But it should

Speaker 1be about educating right, and it should be about dignity for all. When regulation is treated like a moral failing, dignity is going to be the first casualty. Regulation is not a moral failing. Regulation is a human biological thing

Speaker 1that happens, and some people struggle more than others with dysregulation. Regulation is not a moral failing. Regulation is a person's biology. Would you punish someone for having diabetes? Would you tell someone they know better than to use a wheelchair and they need to walk. I mean, these things sound absolutely ridiculous, right, but that is what we are doing to neurodivergent kids.

Speaker 1Behavior is not the opposite of dignity. Control is Control is the opposite of dignity. Asking for compliance for compliance's sake is the opposite of dignity. When we look at things through the brain based lens and we reframe behavior as communication, not character, then we start to treat those who are neurodivergent with dignity. It's not about character and

Speaker 1morals and personality. It is their biology. When the nervous system is under threat, whether it senses an actual threat or it senses a perceived possible threat, it cannot perform appropriate behavior. I'm using air quotes again, folks. Appropriate behavior. It cannot because when we are just regulated thinking, brain access dims or is completely cut off, so we cannot

Speaker 1access skills, we cannot process language, we cannot rationalize or use logic. But yet we want to tell a kid, but I just need you to do this, or I just need you to act this way, and there's suddenly supposed to be able to do that. No, it is outside of their biology. In that moment. You cannot discipline a nervous system into safety. You cannot instruct a nervous system into safety. You cannot. Systems claim to teach skills,

Speaker 1but they actually rely on fear, shame, and withdraw of connection and affection, withdrawal of even compassion and empathy. This is not okay. I know you know this, but we need to be talking about it. This is not okay. If a child has to abandon their nervous system to survive school, the school system is broken. The kid isn't broken, the school system is broken. And by the way, they

Speaker 1can't abandon their nervous system. It controls staying alive. So what do we do? How do we take a more humanistic approach? What does dignity centered support actually look like. It doesn't mean that we're permissive. So many people are going to make that argument that we are just letting kids get away with air quotes again bad behavior, But we are not. We are honoring where the nervous system

Speaker 1is in that moment, knowing that we cannot teach or correct when they are disregulated. It is nervous system first, parenting, nervous system first educating. Because a nervous system governs our behavior, so it is that important. Dignity centered actually means privacy, choice, coregulation, before correction, before correction, assuming stress before we assume that

Speaker 1they're being defiant. When the nervous system goes into fight, flight or freeze, that is a biological stress response. So we have to assume stress before we assume intentional bad behavior because we are going nervous system first. Dignity centered is repair over punishment and seeing the child, not just their behavior, seeing that human being in front of you

Speaker 1and what they need. Accountability with dignity is possible. Again, we're not being permissive, We're not letting go of expectations. We're not letting kids make their own decisions and run amok in whatever way they want. Accountability with dignity is possible. Accountability without that dignity is harming kids, period. It is harming Kidsture without humanity is just control. It is just

Speaker 1simply trying to control that person, that child. Humanity without structure is abandonment. Structure without humanity is control. Kids deserve the humanity first, dignity first, So what are the long term costs of ignoring dignity of not treating our neurodiversent kids, teens,

Speaker 1young adults, adults with dignity. Let's zoom out. When kids grow up without dignity, they mask. Almost every parent I coach now talks about how their kid masks, they have anxiety or increased in escalating anxiety. When kids grow up without dignity, they have a shame based identity. That little voice inside of them has a story of shame. They

Speaker 1also learn helplessness, They learn that they cannot win, and they often learn a distrust of authority because they don't feel seen, heard, and understood by that authority if they are not treated with dignity. We're not just looking to shape behavior. We are shaping safe nervous systems. We are shaping self worth and future relationships. So I am going

Speaker 1to make a commitment right now, out loud to all of you that I will always choose dignity over compliance. I invite you to choose the same stance, the same perspective, the same commitment. Choose dignity over compliance. Folks, Compliance doesn't teach kid's skills. Compliance robs them of dignity. Compliance makes

Speaker 1their nervous system more disregulated and success less possible. When you are coming up to a struggle with a student, a struggle with your kid, a struggle with anyone else, any other human, really ask yourself, does this preserve this person's humanity? Does this preserve this kid's humanity? Does this

Speaker 1preserve this teen's humanity? Does this preserve my child's humanity? That should always be our first question, not why did you do that? What's wrong with you? But my response is it going to preserve this child's humanity? Am I going to treat them with dignity if I do this thing? If the answer is no, you need to pivot. If the answer is no, and you continue with that thing

Speaker 1that is robbing that child of dignity, you are going to harm them. Maybe not right in that moment, but probably, but you are going to harm them. And when we continue to rob them of dignity, guess what happens. Their mental and emotional health as adults is far worse. It is far worse. We are robbing them of joy and happiness and a sense of belonging. I know that some of you are thinking that I'm hysterical and I've lost

Speaker 1my mind and I'm going over the edge, But I'm telling you this matters more than anything. We have to start treating each other with dignity always, always is, always, always always. Please, I'm begging. Can you tell I'm begging. I just want every human to treat every other human with dignity and humanity. That is how we raise kids who are happy and fulfilled. That's how we help our

Speaker 1friends and our neighbors and our fellow man when they're having a hard time. We don't need to fix neurodiversion kids neudiversent adults, but when they are kids, we do need to protect them from systems that forget they are a human being. They are a unique individual human being. Parents didn't create the system, this educational system. Educators, most of them, didn't create the system. The system was created,

Speaker 1you know, decades and decades and decades ago. But those educators are often trapped inside of that antiquated system that does see kids as individuals that only ask for compliance. Above all, we can hold compassion for the adults in the school, the educators, the teachers, the administrators, and still refuse to rob them of dignity and harm them. Please, I hope you'll just make this really simple commitment with

Speaker 1me that we will always choose dignity over compliance. This is how we change the experience for the better for our kids at school, out of school, and beyond for a lifetime. For a lifetime, folks, I will see you on the next episode. Please take good care. I see you. You're doing hard and meaningful work and you don't have to do it alone. If you found this episode helpful,

Speaker 1share it with someone who needs it and leave a quick review so other can find this support too. When you're ready for next steps, the Regulated Kids Project is here with the tools, coaching, and community to help you raise a more regulated, resilient child. Get more info at regulated kids dot com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 384: Managing Holiday Dysregulation, with Penny Williams

    Nov 19, 202625 minAudio

    The holidays aren't the most wonderful time of the year for a lot of our families. For many of us raising neurodivergent kids, they're the most dysregulating time. And if you're already dreading the holidays, that's not...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 383: The Nervous System Budget, with Laura Petix

    Nov 12, 202635 minAudio

    Your child's nervous system is running on a budget, and some mornings it's already overdrawn before the bus arrives. Socks with seams, overhead lights, a barking dog, wet grass on the hem of their pants. For...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 382: How Cognitive Load Can Show Up as Big Emotions and Behavior, with Dr. Amy Moore

    Nov 5, 202631 minAudio

    A meltdown over homework is rarely just about the homework. When our neurodivergent kids fall apart over one worksheet, one chore, or one simple request, there's almost always more happening beneath the surface than we...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 381 How Worrying Less Helps Children More

    Oct 29, 202635 minAudio

    Worry can feel like love. When you're raising neurodivergent kids, worry can even feel like the responsible thing to do. But worry quietly pulls our attention inward, and our kids' nervous systems notice. In this...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 380: When You're the Dysregulated One, with Penny Williams

    Oct 22, 202622 minAudio

    Some mornings, the most dysregulated person in the room isn't your child. It's you. And that doesn't make you a bad parent. It makes you human, with a nervous system that's been hypervigilant for a long time. In this...

    Credit the people on this episode