Spirit, Land, People: The Growth of Mezcal Craft Chocolate
1 hr 24 minAudio
It’s appropriate we call alcoholic drinks spirits. Fermented beverages carry with them the traditions of their homelands and the essence of their agricultural ingredients, and they’ve been used for millennia to both grieve and celebrate, to ease tensions, to bond relationships, to preserve the bounty of a harvest, to mark our hopes for the same next year. Bean to Barstool has been covering the intersections of craft chocolate with artisan drinks for about six years now. We’ve looked at countless chocolate makers who have used alcoholic drinks to infuse flavor into their bars. By far the most common drinks used for this are beer and whiskey, with many substyles of each represented. Over the last couple years however, I’ve noticed a somewhat unexpected spirit growing more and more common. Mezcal. Mexican craft chocolate makers like Cuna de Piedra, Metiche, and others have led the way in this, and an increasing number of American craft makers have caught on. Mezcal bars are no longer a curiosity. They’re a way of carrying the flavors of this traditional Mexican spirit to new audiences, and a way of telling stories that might get missed otherwise. Today, we’re going to talk all about the growing segment of mezcal-infused craft chocolate. I reached out to Cuna de Piedra for this episode, and unfortunately, their production schedule did not allow time for an interview before this episode needed to be assembled. I want to apologize that I wasn’t able to get a Mexican craft maker lined up for this episode, as it’s difficult to tell the story of mezcal chocolate without them. I will continue working to get something scheduled, and hopefully we’ll be able to learn from these makers in future episodes. Today, we’re talking all things Mezcal in craft chocolate! Let's introduce our guests: Lou Bank, host of the Agave Road Trip podcast, and the founder of S.A.C.R.E.D. Agave, an organization that works to improve lives in the rural Mexican communities where heritage agave spirits are made. Kelly Campos, director of quality control at Chicago’s popular Dark Matter Coffee, and their craft chocolate spinoff, Sleep Walk Chocolate. Eric Parkes, owner and chocolate maker at Somerville Chocolate. You can listen to a previous episode with Eric here to hear her talk about his collabs with Aeronaut Brewing. Caroline Houghton, owner and chocolate maker at Carobeans. Hans Westerink, owner at Violet Sky Chocolate. You can listen to a previous episode with Hans here to hear him talk about roasting cacao and coffee. Shay Pal, craft chocolate and spirits enthusiast. You can listen to a previous episode with Shay here to hear her talk about pairing chocolate and spirits. Check out David's book Pairing Beer & Chocolate: A Guide to Bringing the Flavors of Craft Beer and Craft Chocolate Together. Follow Bean to Barstool on social media! Instagram Facebook Pinterest Sign up for host David Nilsen's beer newsletter for regular beer musings, and the Bean to Barstool newsletter for pairings, collaborations, and maker profiles.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_05It's appropriate we call alcoholic drinks spirits. Fermented beverages carry with them the traditions of their homeland and the essence of their agricultural ingredients, and they've been used for millennia to both grieve and celebrate, to ease tensions, to bond relationships, to preserve the bounty of a harvest, to mark our hopes for the same the next year. Bean to Barstool has been covering the intersections of craft chocolate with artisan drinks for about six years now. We've looked at countless chocolate makers who have used alcoholic drinks to infuse flavor into their bars.
SPEAKER_05In my own extensive but unofficial record keeping, by far the most common drinks used for this are beer and whiskey, with many substyles of each represented. Over the last couple of years, however, I've noticed a somewhat unexpected spirit growing more and more common for these bars, mezcal. Mexican craft chocolate makers like Cuna de Piedra, Metiche, and others have led the way in this, and an increasing number of American craft makers have caught on. Mezcal bars are no longer a curiosity.
SPEAKER_05They're a way of carrying the flavors of this traditional Mexican spirit to new audiences, and a way of telling stories that might get missed otherwise. And today we're going to talk all about this growing segment of spirits-infused craft chocolate. I reached out to Cuna de Piedra for this episode, and unfortunately, their production schedule did not allow time for an interview before this episode needed to be assembled. I want to apologize that I wasn't able to get a Mexican craft maker lined up for this episode, as it's difficult to tell the story of Mezcal chocolate without them.
SPEAKER_05I will continue working to get something scheduled and hopefully we'll be able to learn from these makers in future episodes. Today we're going to speak with some American makers catching on to what these Mexican craft chocolate makers have been doing for some time. But before we discuss Mezcal chocolate, we need to better understand Mezcal itself. To do that, I want to introduce you to a vibrant personality who is working to celebrate agave-based spirits, educate Americans on their flavors and varieties, and advocate for the hardworking growers and distillers who have been producing them for generations.
SPEAKER_05Let's talk now with Lou Bank, the host of the Agave Road Trip Podcast and the founder of Sacred Agave, an organization that works to improve lives in the rural Mexican communities where heritage agave spirits are made. As soon as I hopped on the call with Lou, I knew we would get along great. Here's Lou. Lou, welcome to Bean to Barstool. Appreciate you taking some time to talk with us today. At the outset, tell us a little bit about Sacred. What is this project all about?
SPEAKER_04Before I even start that, I gotta tell you how much I love the name Bean to Barstool and how honestly embarrassed, David, I am that I've never heard of your I had never heard of your podcast before until we were connected by our mutual friend. Um, because you're talking about two things that I love. Right? Yeah, no, are the beans hang on, are the beans always chocolate or are they sometimes coffee and are they sometimes like frijoles?
SPEAKER_05So when it started out, it was exclusively chocolate, and that's primarily still the concept, but we do occasionally bring in some coffee experts as well. But honestly, I was toying around with the idea of this combination of craft chocolate and beverage alcohol, and I thought of the name Bean to Barstool, and when I thought of it, I was like, I I have to do it now. That sealed the deal.
SPEAKER_04I love that. I love that. Yeah, so you know, I've been officially running nonprofits since about 1999. And and one of the things that I have found over the decades is uh that most nonprofits do one of two things or both things, uh, which is you're either trying to preserve an at-risk resource or helping to leverage an underutilized resource. And, you know, for me, it was trips down to Mexico. I became uh obsessed with uh with Mescal, uh enough so that I kept going back to Mexico because I couldn't believe what I was seeing with clay pot stills, um, Filipino-style clay pot stills and wood fire, and it just didn't make sense to me, open air fermentation.
SPEAKER_04So I started going back and looking at this and trying to look at it through that lens of those two things, like what's going on here, why does this still exist? And I thought that it was an at-risk resource, and then uh after uh several years of visiting there, and very specifically visiting uh Mescalero Eduardo Anales, Lalo Anales from Lalo Cura, he's he's a really good teacher. He slowly peels back the onion and helped me understand that yeah, the there's this at-risk resource, but also there is this underutilized resource at the same time, this this sort of multi-generational wisdom, a different way to look at the world than we look at it in the places where you and I live.
SPEAKER_04You're it looks like you're in Ohio. Are you in Ohio, Dayton?
SPEAKER_05Yes, yeah, near Dayton.
SPEAKER_04But yeah, okay. So, you know, we've we've got this uh somewhat more efficient view, we think more efficient view of how the world works, and then and these communities they're so focused on best results in a way that I think if if we have more robust conversations with these communities with that different viewpoint, I think the end result will be more robust solutions to the problems that we face. But as we drink more tequila and more mascal, we are putting these very same communities in that very same wealth of knowledge at risk of disappearing and just becoming essentially um a sourcing mechanism for this casual thing that we drink.
SPEAKER_04So as soon as as soon as I started getting requests from people who recognize that I work in the nonprofit world, the people down in these communities to help, um, that's yeah, I think yes, I'm I'm in. What can I do to help?
SPEAKER_05Yeah. I think that's really interesting, especially under a a Western capitalistic mindset that we kind of feel like the best way we can support and endorse a thing is by consuming it more. The more we can consume, the better we're doing for that thing.
SPEAKER_04You know, I actually wouldn't even disagree necessarily with that. Like, you know, there there are there are caveats to that, but you know, I actually do think that our consumption patterns, right? Like so one of one of the things that I preach about uh uh when I pe people think they're coming to a tasting, but inevitably they get uh like a a lecture or even they get lectured too, is that we do all of this mindly cons mindless consumption, and I do this myself, right? Like so many of the things that I eat in a given day, um, I I'm not mindful of exactly where they came from and how my my consumption is affecting the places that they come from.
SPEAKER_04And I think that's the problem, not consumption per se, but mindless consumption. Because like all you really what I want people to do, my my the big takeaway from my tastings is uh instead of 96 and a half times out of a hundred just ordering a margarita and not thinking about that tequila and the blue weber and how something like 90% of that comes from Jalisco and has created this monoculture that's putting the biodiversity and therefore the food and the the medicinal sources at risk in this place.
SPEAKER_04You know, like instead of doing that 96 and a half times out of a hundred, why don't you do it 86 and a half times out of a hundred? And then, right, and then those other 10 times, if you're consuming ricea is a great example, right? Here's another spirit made from agave that comes almost exclusively from Jalisco, same place that can be made from almost any agave except blue Weber, right? The one agave you can use to make tequila. Like suddenly, every every time you drink a margarita, another blue Weber is killed.
SPEAKER_04And and it's killed in your honor, and they're gonna they're gonna plant a new one to replace it, and you've just contributed to the monoculture. But every single time you say, hey, give me a uh Ricea topper on that margarita, now suddenly it's a Maximiliana. And Maximiliana, you know, like unlike, sorry, I'm going in the weeds here, literally, so unlike uh blue Weber agave, uh, Maximiliana doesn't have iwelos, doesn't have those little clones that come off of the mother root. So if you want more Maximiliana, if you're gonna replace that Maximiliana that I just consumed as the topper on my margarita, you have to literally let a Maximiliana agave go to seed.
SPEAKER_04And when you do that, you have created a food source for migratory bats. And then once you've done that, you've helped to um uh stabilize, uh maybe even help flourish the bat population. So you're helping all of this biodiversity by just like I'm not saying stop drinking tequila, but I'm saying like if we just change our consumption patterns by by 10 degrees, by 20 degrees, not 180 degrees, using capitalism, I guess that's the point. Using capitalism, we can actually we can make the world better.
SPEAKER_04I don't I think capitalism is just kind of a neutral thing that we can make good or bad. I think we should try to make it more good. More good.
SPEAKER_05I think yes, I think we should make it good. Uh you alluded to this a little bit. Can you very briefly summarize and condense for people what the concerns are around agave right now and and how this is being grown and harvested?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, like the concerns I'd say are very different given where you are, what you you know, the place that you're looking at. So if you're talking just the agave plants, there's there's this whole movement of uh stop drinking wild agave because there's there's the the wild populations of agave are at risk. But if you look at the IUCN red list, that's the gold standard really for gauging how at risk any species plant or animal is of becoming extinct.
SPEAKER_04If you look at the IUCN red list, they consider something like uh a hundred and fifty-eight species of agave. And of those hundred and fifty-eight species, um they say that something like seventy-nine of them, and I'm you know, I'm I'm pulling these numbers out of my memory. They're not exact, but they're gonna be approximately correct. They consider 79 of them at some level of risk. And of those 79, 12 of them are noted as being at risk uh at least partially because of uh the production of spirits.
SPEAKER_04And if you look at those 12, two of them, potatorum and cupriata. Cupriata, people who regularly drink mascal might recognize that as one of the predominant uh agave, used to make uh agave spirits or certified mascal in places like Michoacan and uh Guerrero. Um so cupriata and then potatorum, like if you've seen Tobila, like Tobola is a variety, a common name of a variety of potatorum.
SPEAKER_04So of those 12, two of them are names that you'd recognize, the other ten you wouldn't. And those two that you'd recognize are actually considered at risk because of farming of those specific species. Farming those specific species on land that had been land where the wild multiple varieties of those species were growing, and now there's one variety that's grown there. So, you know, my my my point is that it's not easy to say what the exact problem is because it's so different in different regions.
SPEAKER_04And if if you look at what is putting wild agave most at risk, it's actually uh uh urban sprawl, it's the building of more uh highways, it is the the grazing of cattle in service of our meat consumption, it's these things. It's climate change, it's not really our consumption of the agave spirits. There's the sort of the flip side of if if we start varying, if we start varying uh to a greater degree the agave spirits that we're drinking, you know, like there's there's sort of this this this false narrative of preserving wild agave is preserving biodiversity.
SPEAKER_04And that's just not true. The two actually kind of work at odds with each other or could. Because really, if what you want to do is preserve varieties and species of agave, farming them might be your best bet. Reclaiming land and making sure that these plants continue to exist might be your best bet, which is the opposite of preserving wild lands. Uh so you know, so it's it's that, but I think it's also, you know, like the it's funny, I have this nonprofit that's called sacred, and that's an acronym that stands for saving agave for culture, recreation, education, and development.
SPEAKER_04And um, and I like I really regret that that is the name I chose because it's not about the agave for me. It's really it's about these communities and that multi-generational wisdom. And I think when I think about the things that are at risk, like that to me is the thing that's at risk. Um, and I think until we embrace that different worldview, until we recognize how that worldview is of value to us, that we can't afford to lose it, because there's gonna come a time when when we've burned off our ozone and we need to figure out how to live in this world.
SPEAKER_04And I think that's the mind view that we're gonna need to get through tougher times.
SPEAKER_05We're gonna talk in just a moment about the collaboration project you did with three different craft chocolate makers to make chocolate bars using Mezcal. Can you briefly explain what Mezcal is? Because there's some confusion around what that term actually refers to.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, no, there even is amongst the people who who love it, amongst the people who bottle it and sell it. So, you know, I I think in order to understand what mezcal is today, it's helpful to understand what it was in 1993. Um, and in 1993, if you said mezcal, you really were saying you were referring to any spirit distilled from fermented agave. You'd go all over Mexico and they would refer to uh vino de mezcal, vino mezcal, vino mexcal, but it all essentially boiled down to that word uh mezcal.
SPEAKER_04And mezcal was a category at that point, kind of in the same way that whiskey is a category. But you know, tequila had been had been exported uh from Mexico since the at least the 1850s, if you're looking at California, and was such a success, uh especially as you're looking at the 1950s, uh 1960s, 1970s, was such a success the Mexican government said, hey, uh, you know, this we kind of like this this tax income. How do we get some more of this stuff?
SPEAKER_04And started looking around at what else they could have. They they set up the denomination of origin for tequila. They said, What else do we have that can be a denomination of origin? And they said, Well, we got this thing called mezcal. And at that point, they took the word from the people. And as a result, the vast majority of people who can use the word mezcal in commerce, and this is the confusion part, the vast majority who can use that word mascal in commerce look a lot more like me than they do my friend Lalo, who actually makes these beautiful agave spirits and who has this tradition of using this word.
SPEAKER_04And now for him to use that word in commerce, he would have to change his traditions. So, you know, I if I'm saying mescal, I'm always referring to certified mascal because I don't want how to put this, I don't want somebody like Zygnum, and no, you know, I I I don't mean to be throwing one particular brand under the bus, but they're the best example.
SPEAKER_04I don't want someone like Zygnum, it's a corporation that came in and set up a distillery and then and makes certified mascal. I don't want them to get the credit for the thing that Lalo is doing, which is making these beautiful spirits, adhering to his cultural heritage, which is what a denomination of origin is meant to protect. He's adhering to his cultural heritage, and in so doing, can't use that word. So I'm not gonna call what he he's gonna call it mascal. And if I'm down there drinking with Lalo, you know, I'm gonna call it mascal. But when I'm talking to you and in so doing, talking to your listeners, I'm gonna call that an agave spirit so that nobody walks into a liquor store, sees Zygnum, sees that it's a mezcal, sees Lalo Cura, sees that it's labeled Agave Spirit, and then says, Well, I want the Mescal and grabs Zygnum.
SPEAKER_05So I think most of us, when we think of mezcal abstractly, without all of the backstory that you've just provided, when we think about it abstractly, we think about this smoky spirit. Is all mezcal smoky?
SPEAKER_04Well, uh no, it's not, you know, and like you you kind of have me at a disadvantage because even before I was drinking these beautiful agave spirits, I was uh barbecuing a lot of pork in my backyard. It's hard for me to taste smoke anymore, honestly. Oh, wow. It yeah, I know it's weird. Um, and I'll be sitting around with friends and sharing spirits like, oh, that's that's smoky. I'm like, I like it's not hitting my palate as smoky whatsoever. So I'm like, I'm really kind of at a disadvantage.
SPEAKER_04But, you know, I think sometimes when people say smoky, there's a conflation of uh the taste of smoke and caramelized sugars sometimes. And again, sometimes it might just be that I just don't taste smoke. But I've had people tell me, like, here's a great example, right? There's this beautiful mezcal certified, right? Beautiful mezcal that comes out of um uh guanajuato, San Felipe Guanajuato. The same family makes two brands. Uh, one is Mescal Villa Suso, and the other brand is Mescal Lucy Pistolas.
SPEAKER_04And it's delicious. And it's a family that's been making spirits from Magave for seven generations, calling them Mescal, certifying them as mascal as soon as that became a thing. They do not have a bit of smoke anywhere in the process. So they're utilizing a Salmiana agave and they're steam cooking it, uh, and then they're grinding it, and they've got the only certified distillery for making artisanal mascow that does not have fire anywhere in it.
SPEAKER_04And they got literally grandfathered in because Milena's grandfather had been using these uh these steam-jacketed stills since the 1950s. So there's not a single bit of smoke involved in the process. And yet, when I've poured it for friends, they go, Oh, that's so good, it's smoky. So, you know, I think part of it's in our heads, part of it might be that that uh caramelization. Yeah. So it's it's not all smoky, but you know, the the the the thing, if you look at the actual uh normas, the rules that surround mezcal and tequila, you'll see that production-wise, with a couple of you know major exceptions, and you know, geography is a big piece of it, uh, the fact that tequila can only be made from one variety of one species of agave, whereas mezcal can be made from any agave.
SPEAKER_04Like putting those things aside, if you just look at the actual processes, you can do with one what you can do with the other. It's just tequila is 33 times the size of Mescal, so trying to do things in that um we're not focused on efficiency uh approach is really hard.
SPEAKER_05Tell us how this project came together where you partnered with these craft chocolate makers. What was the idea like where did the idea come from? How did that get started?
SPEAKER_04Well, let me ask you a question first, David. Uh, do you like chocolate?
SPEAKER_05Of course.
SPEAKER_04Well, yeah, me too. That's how the project got started. So, so I've got these great, great, like if a company can be your friend, you know, the Supreme Court tells us that uh corporations are people. Well, if that is true, Supreme Court, then one of my best friends is Dark Matter Coffee, this beautiful coffee roastery that's just down the street from me here in Chicago. Uh the the whole team there have become great friends over the last decade and change that we've been interacting. And and I'll I'll I'll say right at the outset, I don't drink coffee.
SPEAKER_04Uh, I tried drinking coffee when I started hanging out with them because they make what I'm told is amazing coffee. I just don't like coffee. I don't I don't know. I don't understand why. Anyway, so these guys started a chocolateria down in Pilson on the south side of Chicago, sourcing initially all of their cacao from from Mexico and just making beautiful bars. And I like and I'm like I'm a I'm a an agave geek and I'm a chocolate geek, but they invited me to join them at the DC Chocolate Fest that happens annually at the end of April in Washington, DC, at the French Embassy.
SPEAKER_04They invited me to join them and pour spirits at their table. And I thought that's well, hey, you know, anytime I get to hang out with Jesse and Aaron and the crew, I'm I'm in, Kelly. Like they're they're all just poor hey Fabian, they're all just great. But getting to go there and eat chocolate from all these different chocolaterias around the country, I'm in, not even around like around the world, I'm in, right? So um I did it and I fell in love, and I was the prettiest girl in the room because I was the only person pouring spirits and uh and And so I went back with them I I want to say three times doing this before I realized like everybody's walking around eating chocolate.
SPEAKER_04They're coming to me, I'm pouring spirits, they're buying chocolate, I could sell them chocolate. And I'd made all these friends. So I got I there's a Mescalero in Puebla, in San Luis Atoletitla in Puebla, uh Il Defonso Mercedes Inez. And uh I have liters and liters and liters of his his spirits, and so I gave two liters each to three of my chocolateteer friends. So that's you know, my friends at uh Sleepwalk, that's the chocolate division of dark matter.
SPEAKER_04So, you know, my my friend uh Jorge Fieros, uh, you know, over at Sleepwalk, I gave him uh two liters of Ildefonso's Papalo Metal, and then I gave two liters to Eric Parks over at Somerville Chocolate in Massachusetts, and uh two liters to Carolyn Houghton over in St. Paul at Caro Beans. And and I just told them, do whatever, like drink the spirit and do whatever this however the here the spirit hits you, like follow that uh follow that inspiration. And they all ended up sourcing different cacao from Mexico.
SPEAKER_04And you know, for me, this like A, it was an excuse to buy a lot of chocolate, and then B offer the chocolate for sale at the festival. But also, you know, like I love the fact that your your podcast speaks to bars and speaks to chocolate bars and and and bars where we go to drink. Um because when I think of bars, I mean obviously you go and you have fun and you just drink. But I think that there is some really interesting tastings that you can do as flights.
SPEAKER_04And I think chocolate is the exact same thing. We can learn so much about the things that we consume and the places where they come from and the similarities and the differences by doing flights. And like why it's just struck me, why aren't there more flights of chocolate offered at these bars? And why aren't and why aren't there more flights actually of spirits offered at these bars? I think it becomes a conversation piece, if you will, um, to be able to offer that. So that's what I wanted to create was this flight where there's one common ingredient and you think, well, the cacao and the sugar.
SPEAKER_04Definitely different cacao, but that one common ingredient, and you have the three bars. You got the bars, yes?
SPEAKER_05Yes, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04They taste so each of them is delicious, but delicious in its own way.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Yeah, I love getting to taste those side by side and just it highlights the uniqueness because you're tasting them together. Whereas if you tasted them spread out over time, they might all kind of sit together in your mind. But ironically, having them at the same time, you can really see the sharp contrast there. Tell us just a little bit more about this Mezcal from Puebla. What's unique about it? Give us a little information about it.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, okay. So Ildefonso is in this region called the the Tehuacan Kulican Biosphere. And it was recognized by UNESCO as a World Heritage Site uh years ago. And once it received that uh recognition, that designation, uh, the Mexican government put in place all these regulations, and Ildefonso and his 37,999 neighbors are no longer allowed to harvest off of the wildlands.
SPEAKER_04This is how they had been eating and how they've been making their living. So you know what we do at Sacred is we ask uh these Mescaleres what their problems are, what solutions they imagine are the problems, and what resources they need to implement those solutions. And um and he uh Ildefonso came and said, Hey, uh we need a greenhouse, we need a nursery, we need some way to germinate seeds so we can start farming because we can no longer just farm from the wild. Um so uh uh so we we did the fundraising uh and uh and now he's got this project that takes care of you know the immediate community.
SPEAKER_04Um and so to me, like it there's this irony in there's this irony in the idea that UNESCO recognized this place as a World Heritage Site, and that cuts off the people who are part of the biodiversity of a place, cuts them off from access to their food, puts them immediately at risk of of food insecurity. And it was recognized by UNESCO as a World Heritage Site because there's evidence that this is where corn, bean, squash, chiles were first farmed in the Americas.
SPEAKER_04And so now uh they're finding and they haven't done that for hundreds of years. So the Mexican government has these rules in place that are trying to preserve it so it looks like the place that was recognized by UNESCO, even though it's not being recognized for what it is now but what it used to be. Um and now it's forced these families to start farming. There's like this really weird backwards way of looking at things. So, you know, I I I say that to say um I think the most important piece of Il Defonso's spirit is Il Defonso.
SPEAKER_04Right? The the the person who makes it, his process is he's cooking underground in the stone lined earth and oven. That's where that smokiness might come from. He's milling by hand using wooden hammers. He's fermenting open air primarily in plastic barrels. Why plastic barrels? Are those traditional? No, but when you're in the middle of nowhere, it's hard to get replacement equipment. If that equipment breaks, you're gonna lose all that ferment, so plastic barrels, safer. Um, and then distills first in wood-fired steel stills. There again, super safe equipment, and then refines it in wood-fired copper pot stills.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, sounds amazing. Is that a mezcal that is available to us here in North America, or do you have uh do you have a special direct source?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I like I've got I've got a bunch of it here in my basement as I speak to you. And then my friends at Malort in Chicago in their warehouse, they hold a bunch for me so I can use it for these tastings, so it's brought in legally. He's he's not uh exported to any degree right now. I think maybe the guys at uh McGame Latte might every once in a while have some of his stuff available for mail order. But yeah, it's it's you know, it's it's funny. People they they taste something and then they want more of it.
SPEAKER_04And really what I want is for people to taste something like that and go, oh, that's so good. I want to see the place, I want to meet the people. Instead of just go to the the the corner liquor store and get the bottle, because to me, the value, the flavor is literally the the people in the place distilled.
SPEAKER_05Appropriately, my own sharpest memories of mezcal come from the times I've had it in its homeland. I haven't traveled anywhere near as extensively in Mexico as Lou has, but my annual trips to Mexico to judge the Copa Cerveza MX beer competition every fall have led to some memorable moments. There was a late night on the rooftop of Cuka's brewery in Malinalco sipping Mezcal alongside their excellent porter late into the night with the other judges, while the band played and everyone sang along. Just last year my wife Melinda and I were walking down a side street in Mexico City on our way back from Taut Chocolate and Dechoso Chocolate, and we wandered by a tiny open storefront.
SPEAKER_05Above the door was the name Blah Blah Blah Salude, which we instantly fell in love with. The owner, a tattooed woman who we quickly discovered was a punk rock evangelist for Mezcal, spoke no English, but with Melinda's Spanish and my sort of kind of Spanish, we were able to follow along as she walked us through a tasting of bottles we'd never seen before, each flavor expression different from the last. It was eleven in the morning. The three makers who worked with Lou at Sacred to create these Mezcal chocolate bars also created completely unique expressions.
SPEAKER_05I want to thank my friend Barb Genuario, Choco Chaser on Instagram, for sending these bars my way. I had the Somerville bar before, but not the ones from Sleepwalk or Caribbean, so getting to taste them all side by side was a treat. We're gonna hear now from these three makers. The first is Kelly Compos, director of quality control at Chicago's popular dark matter coffee and their craft chocolate spinoff, Sleepwalk Chocolate. At the beginning, I asked Kelly how she got connected with Lou at Sacred.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so we've been working with Lou for a very, very long time. He's a good friend of ours here in Chicago. We've done a lot of different projects over the years, whether it's coffee collaborations or chocolate collaborations. Um he's a great connector for people. He loves to connect different people into different industries and merge together our worlds. So he's been an amazing person to work with. Gosh, I mean, it's been probably over a decade that we've known Lou and maybe even before my time at Dark Matter.
SPEAKER_03Um, but uh we've we've traveled with him quite a bit. We've gone down to Oaxaca to visit uh Mescal producers and farmers with him. He's been on trips with us to see cacao producers and the whole process. So uh we we always love exchanging information and uh learning about each other's industries. And so it's just a natural fit when you have uh an agave spirit like that and then uh cacao from you know the same country.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, no, that's really cool. So have you done a mezcal infused bar or other projects like this prior to this one?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so we we have done some mezcal infused bars in the past. Uh one of the bars that we regularly have available is a collaboration we did with Chef Rick Bayless here in Chicago. Uh, we did a flight of four different inspired bars from different parts of Mexico and different um like regional flavors with chilies and spices. And so one of those is a Oaxaca inspired bar in which we use mezcal to infuse the spirits into the nibs.
SPEAKER_03Um, so we we have played with it before. It's fun to see how different expressions create a different outcome in the chocolate. Uh, we like to use the same base cacao when we're doing stuff like that so that we have like a control. And then we can um, you know, infuse those nibs. We pressure infuse them in stainless steel kegs um and then uh process them like we do with all of our other chocolate, crushing them for 48 hours till they're a really silky, smooth, finished chocolate bar.
SPEAKER_05That's really cool. Let's talk about that base cacao. Uh, the one that I that I see for this particular collaboration with Sacred was the Salva Zoque. Is it am I saying that right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Tell me a little bit about that origin and why you use that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so that that is a cacao that's um it's a community cacao. So what that means is it's from a lot of small producers that work together to pool their cacao. And the reason they do that is because one person might have one or two kilos, another person might have three or four kilos. And the ideal uh size for fermentation of cacao is to have, you know, up to 500 kilos in a wooden box to ferment. And um, I compare it a lot to actually compost because you want to have a large enough size that it's uh creating a nice warm environment for that activity and that fermentation to be successful.
SPEAKER_03If you try fermenting cacao and you only have a couple of kilos bunched up uh altogether, it's not going to be as successful because it just can't get the right combination of temperature and microbial activity to ferment. Um, so this cacao is a lot of small producers that work together. Um, it's uh from a group called Agrofloresto. Um they we've worked with them for about five or six years. Um, they're in Tabasco and Teapa. Um, and we've gone to visit them several times, see their operation. It's really exciting to see uh what they're what they're doing down there.
SPEAKER_03Cacao is fermented for anywhere from five to seven days in these wooden boxes and then dried under uh like covered shade patios.
SPEAKER_05In the fact sheet that I saw from Sacred, they said that your bar was a 50-50 blend of washed and fermented. That didn't that didn't quite make sense to me because uh my understanding is that it would all be fermented. Uh, what am I misunderstanding?
SPEAKER_03So, yeah, so this one, yeah, this was was all all fermented. Yeah. So there was no washed cacao in this one. It was all fermented, but uh, that is another type of processing that cacao producers will use. Um, and this is where, like, on our end of things, we have a lot of experience in coffee. So we start to see some overlap in how coffee is processed and cacao is processed. Uh, and the washed process is in similar way to coffee. You're using water to remove as much of that mucilage and reduce the fermentation time, and it changes the overall outcome and flavor profile of that chocolate.
SPEAKER_03For us, like we love like the ferment on it because it gets like nice and fruity and a little funky, and you get a lot more complexity out of a fermented cacao uh versus a washed cacao. So, yeah, this one was really cool. Project for us to work with on the Salvisoque where it's fermented. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Tell me a little bit about the mezcal that you used for this bar.
SPEAKER_03With any of the projects we do with Lou, he's always really amazing about sourcing awesome mezcals. Um, you know, one thing that we really loved about this specific spirit was the flavor profile, had a lot of like, and this is a compliment. Um, it had like a barnyardy kind of like funky, you know, you get a little bit of like earthiness. Um, and you feel like you're you're like there on the property with these producers with their animals crushing a gun base. Um, and so that was something that uh we when we tasted the finished bar and we tasted that mezcal in there, you know, you really got a lot of that origin coming through and uh, you know, a lot of that that funk, you know, not just like everybody always says mezcal, oh, it's smoky, you know, oh, the roastiness of the smokiness of the roastiness and all that.
SPEAKER_03But like I think there was a lot of nuance here with like some of the terroir and the surrounding region. And yeah, I mean, Puebla is a beautiful place. We've we've started getting some coffee from those folks down there uh in that area, and we're excited to also be working with a cooperative that's starting to grow cacao. So we're hoping to get some cacao from from Puebla, which would be really cool because then we could use cacao from the same place that the mezcal is coming from. So that would be really awesome.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Uh I understand this bar was made by Jorge Fieros. Is he your main chocolate maker or was this just kind of his project?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so he's our main chocolate maker. So he's been with us for several years now. Um, he is from uh Guadalajara originally in Mexico, and uh he moved here, gosh, over 20 years ago now, but he started with us several years ago and he's been managing our chocolate program. Um, and that's been really, really awesome for him. I feel like it connects him back to some of his roots and you know, some of these cacao's we were able to find through family members and connections that he had back home. So I think there's like a really awesome connection that he has with this, with this product.
SPEAKER_03And, you know, it's been really exciting to see him like learn and grow. And uh, you know, he gets the the lucky, you know, the fortune of being able to go back to Mexico and work on some of these projects and visit producers as well. So um, you know, he's had a couple of visits down there where we've gone to visit farms and participated in cacao festivals. And, you know, it's it's always great to have a you know native Spanish speaker with us as well. Um and he really flourishes and and gets excited about the product.
SPEAKER_03So yeah, he's been a strong piece in our chocolate team.
SPEAKER_05We're gonna come back to Sleepwalk in just a little bit to talk about their process for using Mezcal because they're actually using a really unique method for spirits infusion. I haven't seen any other makers doing. So we'll hear from Kelly more in just a bit. For now, I want to bring on an old friend of Bean to Barstool, Eric Parks at Somerville Chocolate in Massachusetts, has been on here several times. He operates Somerville out of Aeronaut Brewing, and his proximity to the brewers there has led to numerous collaborations utilizing beer and beer ingredients.
SPEAKER_05Lou had been buying bars from Eric for years before the pair finally met in person. Eric was walking back to his shop from his storage space, and a gentleman was checking out his bars. Lou introduced himself and they started chatting. Lou had been traveling between events on the East Coast, and before Eric knew it, they were tasting Mezcal.
SPEAKER_00He's talking about Mizcal and he's off in his car coming back with bottles of Mizcal to try out, and it's, I don't know, way too early to be drinking anything, but it was like 10.30 on a Tuesday or something. It was an eye-opening experience for me with him because um I'd never really known Mescal to be anything other than basically glorified moonshine that I encountered when I was living in Mexico back in the 80s. So this is this cool thing. Like, this is this one farmer, and it's this one Erla Magave type, and this one was buried underground for a year in a bin, and this one was allowed to sit in the open air.
SPEAKER_00And it was really kind of cool. And um, I began to understand some of the nuance behind it, even though it's kind of hidden behind quite a lot of alcohol, uninitiated like me. It's hard to cut through that initially. But that's how I came to know him. And then out of that discussion, we had this idea of coming up with an all-mascal, like a Mexico bar that Mexican cacao, Mexican miscalcul. And it was sort of a fun way to promote his efforts and for me to push my boundaries a little bit. And he put me in touch with Monica, who has uh a company in Mexico selling assorted Mexican products, and she sent me some cacao from um cooperative in Tabasco that goes cacao, a collection of cacao's different strains.
SPEAKER_00I got a couple bags of that from her and away we went.
SPEAKER_05So uh tell me a little bit about the cacao from Tabasco. What was the profile you were working with on that?
SPEAKER_00I found it, it's funny, I've been working with it infused for so long. I've sort of begun to forget what it tastes like uninfused. But it to me, it has a very crisp uh stone fruit feel to it. I wouldn't say it's super acidic, but it has definitely some punch that way, the way apricot would would have, um, with some underlying berry. It's not one of those really earthy, leathery, tobacco-y kind of nutty cacao. It's more in the front of the mouth feel to it, like to me. So it has a lot of that ripeness, that berry feel to it.
SPEAKER_05So, what was the process like for actually developing the bar? You've obviously done infusion bars before. Uh, was that a pretty direct translation over to working with the mezcal, or was there more of an RD process?
SPEAKER_00Pretty much, because I've been familiar with the beer bar I do where that one is nibs that have been fermented for a week or two. In the case of infusions like this, it's more a matter of pouring something over nibs and deciding how much to put in. Because you don't want to, especially something that's pricey like Mescal, you don't want to overdo it and you don't want to underdo it. So I just kind of jumped right in and said, Lou, how about two liters? And you sent me that. I pour it in typically with a nibs, I'll pour it in there in a in a bin and I'll saturate it to the point where it's just beginning to pool up in the bottom, but I don't really want to soak it in a bunch of liquid.
SPEAKER_00So that's the same thing I've done with beer in the past and once in a while with coffee or other liquids, but there's no point to having a lot extra there. So you want to put it in there to the point where it's just not going to soak in much. And cacao isn't gonna soak it in like a sponge because it is ultimately a fat. You know, you're trying to get water into a fat, but it will expand and swell. And um, so you do get some of it absorbing. I would pour it in until it stops soaking in, really. And I've I've learned through trial and error that it's usually about a liter and a half or so.
SPEAKER_0015 pounds of nibs, I think, is what I would do after roasting. And it sets the point where it's going to pool a little bit, but not a whole lot. What I then do is I let it sit there and percolate for maybe an hour or two until I know that all the all the mescal is in the beans, and then I set it out onto trays. And the more laborious part of the process is drying it. And I have been tinkering around with different processes for drying. And sometimes I when I do uh I have a way of using my convection oven in which I do my cacao roasts, I can turn it into basically a glorified dehydrator where I put trays in there that have perforated bottoms, and I have a thing that sucks out of the top, and I leave the door cracked just a little bit and it's over overheat.
SPEAKER_00It helps dehydrate it that way. With the mascal, I've decided to let it do uh room temperature drying and just not subject it to any additional heat or being in an oven, which in theory might have other flavors going on or aromas. So for the mascal, I tend to put it onto a bunch of solid trays, have a fan blowing over it, and just let it dry. And I come by every uh couple times a day, and I'll give it a stirring just to make sure everything's done, and I have a fan blowing over it, and I might shift things around. And it could take two or three days of that.
SPEAKER_00And the way you know when it's reached your target is you weigh it before and after. So periodically you'll you'll dump them in and see how much the the net differences and whatever that is, is is gonna be liquid. So I go until it's down to the last few ounces and then decide it's dry enough.
SPEAKER_05Texturally, is it basically feel dried at the end or is it still kind of tacky?
SPEAKER_00Uh it feels dry, it actually feels dry before it's done, because it's for a while it you have liquid, especially when you go and stir it around. And then after a while you feel like this surely must be dry, and you weigh it and it's has an extra eight or ten ounces in there, and you think, well, let's I wouldn't go and put a cup of water in my. Refiners, so let's keep going with it. But on the flip side, since I'm not dehydrating it overheat, I I think this it's close to theoretically impossible to dry it fully to the complete extent that it was before. And the thing with chocolate is it all the ingredients we put in the refiner have some amount of residual moisture in there even after roasting it.
SPEAKER_00So it's not a perfectly dry process. So but the general the more moisture that's in there, just residually, the gummier it gets, and it makes it a little bit thicker and it's a little harder to mold and stuff like that. So you just have to kind of balance it off with the need for speed to get done with the thing versus texture when you're refining it.
SPEAKER_05So you do notice a little bit of a difference in that refining process after this from a standpoint of the behavior of the cacao.
SPEAKER_00It can, more so with well, the beer bar that you're familiar with, that one has so many other things going on that'll actually add a little bit of cocoa butter to it. I don't usually add cocoa butter, but something with a lot of carbohydrates or other starchy things in there. I I loosen it up a little bit. But I don't know that I put any cocoa butter in my skull there. Because I I did a pretty good job of drying that, uh, actually. I think I got down to the last eighth of a cup of water. People have been adoring that bar, I think. Well, there's it it is uh it's one of the ones I describe as being a little bit polarizing. So there are people out there who are gonna loathe it, but generally the people who like it really like it.
SPEAKER_00And so since the alcohol is gone, it's they don't have that initial, like, well, that's too strong. They're just getting in the chocolate, as you might have noticed, you get, I think what's forward from the skull is the smoke and the sort of a leathery, burlapy canvas flavor. That's that's to me what really jumps forward in the drink into the cacao. And people like it a lot. So it's one of these ones where I can't really make enough of it, um, even though I mark it up a bit at the shop because it's just a pain to make it. The drying process just adds a few days.
SPEAKER_05Now that you've done this, do you have any other plans or experiments you want to take up with Mezcal?
SPEAKER_00There's always the discussion of putting things into white chocolates, but that's really difficult because you have to infuse the sugar. And I've done that once or twice with bourbon and things like that. And unlike cacao, it the sugar will actually go into a solution if you put too much in there. So you have to put just enough in there that you can saturate the sugar, but not quite just make a puddle of liquid. And then what happens is it starts to crust over pretty quickly when you're drying it, and so it protects the inside from drying out. So you have to get in there and constantly break it up and spread it out in the tray.
SPEAKER_00And then at some point you'll throw it in a Veg Vitamix thing and powder it again. And the drying sugar is there's no way I could charge enough to make that worth it. But that would be fun to try in a white chocolate to see what comes through.
SPEAKER_05I know when I talked to Tandy out at Ember's chocolate, she had done some of the same stuff with sugar, but she had also infused milk powder as well as an option.
SPEAKER_00Oh. Oh, I never thought of that. Infuse the milk powder, and then well, milk will dissolve. So does she I wonder if she uses just not quite enough to get it to fully dissolve? All right. That's one of the reasons with white chocolates. I got into an air infusions because it's it's a fun way to do stuff when you don't have the solid of cacao in there. I do a white with nibs. Rather than infuse the chocolate, I'll infuse the nibs so you have that flavor in something solid that belongs in there. And that one I do, um, I've done nibs that are set infused with chai, and I think I did one with the bourbon and the nibs and things.
SPEAKER_00It's a way to get something in there without the pain and suffering of that. It's not going to be a strong.
SPEAKER_05Let's hear now from Caroline Houghton, owner of Caro Beans in St. Paul, Minnesota. I've admired caro beans from afar for many years, but I confess this was my first opportunity to taste any of her bars. I caught up with her recently and she explained how she first met Lou.
SPEAKER_02I met Lou when he happened to be in Minneapolis for um an agave tasting and at Mexican restaurant, and he just I think he said he w every time he goes to a city, he googles like who makes bean to bar chocolate there, and I was one of the only ones that popped up. So he sent me a a quick note just inviting me to this agave tasting. And yeah, I met him there.
SPEAKER_05So did you have any background with mezcal or agave drinks before that?
SPEAKER_02Not really. My husband is from Mexico, so we've always enjoyed mezcal or tequila. Um, so we were familiar with like how it's made and you know, like how to taste it and stuff, but we had never been to like an official tasting like that.
SPEAKER_05Well, let's talk a little bit about the bar that you made. So my notes show that you it was a 65% bar made with cacao from Cooperativa Ryan in Chiapas. What made you select that specific origin and tell us a little bit about it?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, I mean, first and foremost, I wanted to use an origin from Mexico because I didn't I I that was the only way I could justify making a bar with a spirit from Mexico as well. So yeah, I I really like Ryan because of their like sustainable farming practices. Um, it's a much smaller co-op, so farmers are getting paid fairly, you know, working conditions are good. But also that specific cacao has already some like smoky notes to it that are not very commonly found in in cacao that I felt like would pair with really well with the agave spirit.
SPEAKER_05So are those smoky notes process related at the farm, or is that just something is that just a note that you kind of pick up in it?
SPEAKER_02It's just a note I pick up in it, and you know, it could be something from the farm, it could be, you know, even the beans were fermented and there were like fires nearby and and it picked up that smoke. So, you know, it could technically be a defect even in the bean. However, it's a bean I really like making chocolate with because it has those, and it's not smoky like like wildfire smoke, it's more like a like a black tea kind of smokiness to it, if that makes sense.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, that's interesting. Well, tell us a little bit about the process for making the bar. How did you go about infusing the mezcal?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so as you know, you can't just add liquid to chocolate, so you can't just like straight up add the mezcal. So what I do um is I I roast the beans, winnow them down to nibs, and then add the mascal to the nibs. And then I let that I let those ones soak for three to four days. Sometimes I'll do up to a week for, you know, like I've done like a red wine bar and I'll let them soak for like a week. But because the mascal itself has such a strong flavor profile, I didn't want to let them soak as long.
SPEAKER_02Um, so it's three to four days, and then I strain them um and then run all the nibs through a dehydrator so they get really completely dried out before I put them in the melanger. So it is it's quite a process to make an infused bar like that.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. And 100% of the beans that went into the bar were infused in this way.
SPEAKER_02Correct, yeah.
SPEAKER_05Very cool. Um, so obviously you you got to taste the mezcal during this process. What were your thoughts on the specific mezcal that Lou uh was using for this collab?
SPEAKER_02We loved it. It was very like vegetable, pretty smoky, but not as smoky as like some more commercially produced mezcals. Um but yeah, just a really unique like vegetable kind of taste that I I wasn't a hundred percent sure how well it was gonna pair with chocol like with any cocoa bean, but I actually I really like how it turned out. I feel like it paired really well with that cacao.
SPEAKER_05What has the response been like from your fans and customers? Was there a kind of an education curve to this, or did people resonate with it right away?
SPEAKER_02People that are familiar with like agave spirits were the ones that really wanted to try it right away. And unfortunately, because Lou purchased most of these bars to sell at that chocolate festival, I didn't get to talk to most of the recipients of the bars. So, but I've had so I I do still have a few bars left that I've had on my website. So I've heard feedback that people and I actually, it's funny because I just got an email from someone yesterday that had tried the bar and they were blown away by how it really captured like the essence of, you know, if you had like a little shot or little cup of mascal.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I've gotten really good feedback on it.
SPEAKER_05I'm going to share a short bite-sized episode soon in which Caroline talks about her very important ice melter bar she created earlier this year to raise awareness and funds for immigrant justice. So keep an eye and ear out for that. Let's circle back now to Sleepwalk as Kelly explains how they infuse alcoholic beverages like Mezcal into their cacao. So a lot of chocolate makers are soaking beans in different spirits. I think you're the first one I've heard about doing that under pressure.
SPEAKER_05Can you expound a little bit on that process?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so the pressure infusing, that's something that we've done quite a bit with uh with coffee. Um, and part of the reason for that is because uh, you know, we like to remove any outside variables that might be going on in that um in that tank. We like to we we sanitize everything. So everything we're using, like the kegs themselves are completely uh like sanitized and sterile. You put those nibs in there, and then the pressure um just helps give it that extra push to really infuse that spirit into the beans.
SPEAKER_03Um and it also purges out any oxygen that might be in that keg. So um, you know, you don't want we'll we'll use either spirits or we'll use beer sometimes. Um we've done all kinds of weird conditions. We've conditioned in Coca-Cola, we've conditioned coffee with coffee, like all kinds of stuff like that. But you know, most of the time uh oxygen is not a friend of many liquids. So uh we like to get that oxygen out. So we will top off uh these kegs with nitrogen, kind of forcing out any oxygen that's in there uh and really infusing that spirit into the nibs.
SPEAKER_05How long does that process typically take? Is that shortened the time period from what normally would it would take?
SPEAKER_03We've been infusing under pressure for uh, I don't know, yeah, a long, long time. I don't even know the last time anything was was infused that wasn't pressurized for us on the coffee side or the cacao side. So honestly, we haven't done infusions that were not under pressure. So I wouldn't be able to tell you timeline if it was faster or not. Um, but we do uh typically infuse the the cacao nibs for about 48 hours with quite a bit of agitation as well. And that's just to make sure that all of the nibs are getting that experience so that there's not one pocket in it that's you know more uh infused than another.
SPEAKER_03But yeah, about 48 hours is typical for an infusion. Uh, we've played around with timing a bit, but um that's a nice sweet spot.
SPEAKER_05Beyond just obviously being a delicious bar, what is the the story that a bar like this is telling? What is the significance of a project like this?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think like a big piece, and for really a lot of the chocolate, a big piece of it is about education and like informing people and our customers and people interested in chocolate about other projects and other things happening out there. We're totally on board and and love to support Sacred and their mission. And so I think this chocolate, uh, if people are drawn to sleepwalk or chocolate, it also attracts them to hey, what is this other thing that's happening here? What's sacred? Let me look them up. How are they influencing um producers and agave uh farmers and all of that, you know, and looking into more of the story behind what Lou is doing.
SPEAKER_03And so I think like these collaborations are a great way to connect people to multiple aspects of uh places that need help and bringing attention to that uh because a lot of people don't know, they don't, they're not educated on that, you know, they don't know what happens, the the background of how Mezcal is produced and where it's grown and um, you know, all the agave spirits. So just kind of bringing some awareness is really huge.
SPEAKER_05I'd love to hear if you know of any other makers who are using pressurized CO2 for an infusion environment. So drop me a line if you have any leads there. Just a relatively short drive from Chicago, Hans Westerink is making excellent craft chocolate at Violet Sky Chocolate in South Bend, Indiana. Hans has been on the show a few times previously, and I reached out to him this time because he recently made a Mezcal bar that is one of my favorites I've tried. Last year, before the Midwest Craft Chocolate Festival, I reached out to him to see which of his Spirits-infused bars he had available for wholesale so I could table them at the festival.
SPEAKER_05And he mentioned he was planning a small batch of a mezcal bar. I ended up with 15 of the 16 bars from that test batch, and they sold out quickly at the festival. Here Hans begins by talking about why he thinks dark chocolate and mezcal work so well together.
SPEAKER_06They're both so complex and bold, like a really strong dark chocolate and a mezcal, just they can stand up to each other because they have so much depth.
SPEAKER_05So this is a 77% dark chocolate, which that's kind of your standard percentage for most of your bars. And this is made with uh Haiti cacao. What made you go with that origin for this?
SPEAKER_06Just the really nice, like earthy notes in that chocolate. Just the like I love some chocolates that kind of have like they taste like the forest smells, you know, like it has this just like rich, loamy kind of note to it. And I thought, you know, with the smokiness and like the vegetalness of the mezcal, it makes sense. I just got two Mexican cacao. Um I'm really excited to do more, do another round of mezcal with those. And they're like drastically different from each other.
SPEAKER_06So that'll be fun.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, for sure. So when you were making that selection for Haiti, was that just kind of something you were thinking in your mind would work? Was there a taste testing process to figure that out?
SPEAKER_06Yeah, tasting things side by side, just seeing how it interacts. And just I like to just like even just smelling, you know, just using like aroma notes and then try some of the nibs. We didn't really do a test batch.
SPEAKER_05Tell me a little bit about this mezcal that you worked with. This was Las Nahuales, Nahual de Coyote Joven Mezcal. What made you select that? And tell me a little bit about the mezcal itself.
SPEAKER_06Well, that I had tried out a mezcal tasting, um, and just kind of blew me away. So it's one of the ones that we carry regularly and make cocktails with. I know it's uh a woman-produced brand, which is not super common there, but it just has a nice vibrancy, really clean, not too smoky. It's not like the overly, overly smoky, which I don't mind, but you know, it's just a little more balanced than some of them.
SPEAKER_05More approachable too, especially if you're if this is the first time somebody's encountering Mezcal in a chocolate bar.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. And it's interesting how how you know, once you the alcohol dissipates, it kind of it has a softer edge because part of the intensity of those liquors is like the alcohol carrying everything, you know, carrying the aroma and the intensity. So in the chocolate, it's like much more muted, just rich, you know, all the fats instead of the alcohol, kind of like mute mute the flavors or just balance it out in a different way.
SPEAKER_05Sure. Tell me a little bit about your process or how you infuse this.
SPEAKER_06Roast the cocoa beans, winnow them, get the nibs, and then just soak it, basically. Soak it for a week or so, and then kind of dry it out enough that it can be ground. Because if it's too wet, it won't liquefy. Sure.
SPEAKER_05So you mentioned the two Mexican cacao origins that you got in that you want to work with. Uh, what are those origins? And would you do something differently with this process with those?
SPEAKER_06I mean, I think the process worked well. So I'd probably use the same process. The cacao is there's Camino cacao for us, Osito is the importer. And then the other one's almendra blanca, so like uh more of like an heirloom, lighter color cacao.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I think I've had your Almendra Blanca bar before. Did you do that with like gin or another spirit?
SPEAKER_06Perhaps probably yeah, I did a barrel-aged one. Okay, it's probably like the rye barrel aged. Yeah, that sounds right.
SPEAKER_05Okay, cool. Uh, what was the response like to this bar? Was there any kind of learning curve for people encountering something like this for the first time?
SPEAKER_06I mean, I think a lot of the people that I work with and my customers really like mezcal. Um, so it's something we had talked about for a while. So I feel like in our in our group, it was like just made sense. And we like chili chocolate and you know, just the intense flavors. We do a lot of mezcal cocktails. So it it's you know, it went over well, and definitely people are asking for more of it.
SPEAKER_05So yeah, like I said, it was very popular when I had it at my table, and people, I'm not even sure people had a huge familiarity with Mezcal, they just love the idea of something unique that they hadn't seen before.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, that's always exciting when you, you know, get to learn something.
SPEAKER_05One of my best friends I've made since launching Bean to Barstool is Shay Pal. Most of you will know her on Instagram as Chock Coffee Wine. Shea is an energetic enthusiast of flavor. That enthusiasm is agnostic of food and beverage segments. She wants to taste everything. And when she and I get together, we always end up in a bit of a frenzy of tasting different things and trying them together. I approached Shay a while back about writing a Mezcal and chocolate pairing guide for the Bean to Barstool site, and she is working on that.
SPEAKER_05Cross your fingers. Hopefully, we'll have that up soon. But in the meantime, I just wanted to talk with her about Mezcal as a taster and discuss some of the Mezcal infused chocolate bars we've both been enjoying. So, Shay, I know that you are an adventurer and you go all over the world tasting all sorts of chocolate and spirits and everything. Tell me about your relationship to Mezcal specifically.
SPEAKER_01Well, Mezcal first came into my life, you know, I kid you not, it was the George Clooney's Mezcal. I kind of sort of liked it. But then I was like all about tequila at that time, you know. And then once I tasted that, I quite liked the smoky spirit, too. I went to Beni's and sought out mescal, looking for mezcal. And lo and behold, I chanced upon this guy, and he was like telling me that you shouldn't be trying more of the wide agave and look out for the wine agile's because a lot of the mescals back in the day that Benese carried were made from the Espadine.
SPEAKER_01Nothing against Espadine, but there was like a lot of them available because that was probably the most cultivated agave. So I started with tasting the Del Vida line of agave spirits, which mostly concentrated on Espadine. But what they did was they did espadine from different producers all over Wahuka or you know, Durango, or I think they have like a bottle from Pueblo or all the S club producing states.
SPEAKER_01So then I started tasting a few of them and I started speaking with people, and then that's when Lou came into my life and I was talking with him, and I also reached out to Kikini of the Cuna di Pietra, you know, and um, you know, I have to jump right into the Metcal bars that he makes. Well, long story short, mezcal has been in my life, you know, the the smoky white spirit that I totally fell in love with. The world of mezcal, or rather the world of agave spirits, has always been blown my mind.
SPEAKER_05Well, one of the areas of growth that I'm seeing within craft chocolate in in terms of like spirits and alcohol collaborations is with mezcal. And I think for a lot of people, if they haven't tasted any of these bars, mezcal might not sound like it would go with chocolate, whether in as an ingredient or as a pairing, but uh these bars can be amazing. So let's talk about some of the mezcal-infused chocolate bars that you've had. You mentioned cuna de piedra, they are unique because they're actually releasing a an agave spirit alongside their bars, right?
SPEAKER_01They have a agave spirit. Um, but that's not technically mezcal because they it is made from a different part of the agave than what is used to make mezcal. So I think you and I have tasted it together. And I remember from my perspective or from my database of memories, uh flavor notes, for me it's very rum like or rather agricole rum like. Um, you know, it has a very sugar clean forward note, and it's amazing.
SPEAKER_01The they call it, they don't I don't think they call it Metcalf. I don't think they do, yeah. they call it agave spirit because it is a it is a agave spirit and technically not a mezcal from the true sense of well they've they've made a variety of bars using different mezcals do you want to talk about those a little bit yeah exactly so what they do is they make two bars i think they're like both 73 from the same coco but they use a joven and a reposado of the same espadine mezcal and i think they're from santiago matatlan and they just soak the nibs in the mescanal and these are great gateway starting bars to mescamel for people who have never tried mescanel so if you taste a bar without the mescamel and you taste the bar with the mescanel it's so different from each other even though the cocoa is the same the percent of cocoa is the same it gives you a note that is not like nothing other it gives you a note like a little smoky a little clean a little fresh it's completely different from their actual bars with only cocoa so I think that's a great getaway bar and that is actually a bar which introduced me to mezcal and chocolate together.
SPEAKER_05I think that's probably true for a lot of people they were kind of at the forefront of that I think one thing that I love about mezcal bars is that when you taste bars that are made with some kind of whiskey or a rum, those flavors are largely playing off of the base notes of the chocolate. So like going down to those foundational flavors whereas mezcal is usually pulling up on those high notes and kind of lightening some of those flavors so you're getting more contrast.
SPEAKER_01Exactly and I love the fact that they do pairing with um their own cocoa meaning Mexican cocoa like five out of the six or seven bars that I have tasted which have mezcal are all made with Mexican cocoa. The only one I think that I've tasted were actually one that you gave me was the one from Valescale where he did like a Haiti uh cocoa with Mescal. And I don't know what mascal he used we're gonna have to ask Hans about it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah so that was a very different bar because of the fudgy notes of the fruity notes of the Haiti cacao and the mascal that he used to pair with it was so different from all the other bars. They were like contrasting each other and totally balanced.
SPEAKER_05And he also does a little bit higher percentage and he typically his house flavor usually is like a little bit less refined. He usually leaves a little bit more acidity a little bit more of a and I don't mean this in a bad way but a little bit more of like a roughness to the flavor profile to get it maybe closer to origin in in his mind. Exactly so yeah you do get a little bit more of that earthiness and you get a really fun pull on like the blueberry notes of that cacao with the smokiness of the mezcal exactly the fruitiness and the tartness at the back of your mouth really balances out the flavor profile of that the mezcal that he has used to put in the nib.
SPEAKER_01So it's it's fantastic.
SPEAKER_05Well we're talking about chocolate and mezcal going together in bar form, but what about in pairing form? You do a lot of spirit pairings what thoughts do you have on pairing mezcal with chocolate?
SPEAKER_01I have mostly paired Mexican cocoa with Mexican mezcal uh what I also like is not just pairing the single origins with a mezcal and you know playing around with different kinds of mascales and different kinds of agave to go with those I also like those bars which are made I've only done Mexican makers for these experimentations you know because the world is so big I never got a chance to do others.
SPEAKER_01But what I also like is the Mexican makers like jangala and reina negro these guys what they've done is put ingredients which are very common to the Mexican palate or which is very easily available like flor de jamaica or hangibre's or you know my my Spanish is pretty messed up. Or you know the Jangala has a Samaligusano bar which is so fantastic with like a clean mascal you know a very starter mascal like an espadin would go fantastic with this bar.
SPEAKER_01So that's the playground you know what I've I've been doing is mess Mexican cacao with an ingredient which has Mexican born origins and then you know play with the mascales of different types and just play with it. There can be several mezcales maybe they're from the same producer like a teobala or a tapestate and then you don't just play around with it.
SPEAKER_05It seems surprisingly a fairly forgiving pairing. Right right yeah if somebody were to come to you and say all right I want to try a mezcal and chocolate pairing but I'm not sold on the idea what is like one pairing that you would give them to try to change their mind and make them fall in love with this?
SPEAKER_01Yeah I I would first ask him what kind of spirit the person likes and depending on what he says if he likes a smoky spirit then I will definitely go with the depestate and if he likes cleaner spirits I would do a simple espadin I don't say simple by you know in any derogatory means or whatever. But and then what I will do is do like a clean um alamandra blanca kind of Mexican cocoa which has this peanut fudgy note you know the one that good now produces for instance or even the one from uh cuna de piedra or the one from Etiche you know she has a fantastic 70% or 73% bar like clean notes of the Mexican cacao but I because I want them to taste it and then bring bring um uh uh agave spirit to go along with it and I'm sure they will be sold.
SPEAKER_01I have a feeling that Madagascar cacao would go well with a mescal which is especially very very smoky because of those fruity notes from the Madagascar cacao maybe you and I can try this next time I see you and we'll talk about it. Um I have a feeling it would really go well.
SPEAKER_05Yeah that would be similar somewhat to like what we were talking about with Haiti but even bolder. Exactly honestly I I kind of now want to try all sorts of origins because I'm I'm struggling to think of something where I feel like no that would definitely not work.
SPEAKER_01Right. I know what you mean yeah mezcal is really so forgiving.
SPEAKER_05Yeah which is surprising I think people think of it as a challenging spirit if they're not used to it because that smoke can be if you're not used to it or you're yeah it can be divisive but it's honestly not it's pretty light on its feet. Exactly exactly if you've only ever had mezcal once or twice it can be easy to think of this spirit as a single flavor concept and that's really true of any food or beverage that we don't have a lot of experience with what I love about the mezcal chocolate bars I've been tasting is that they are all so unique from each other.
SPEAKER_05Ember's chocolates esfuerzo tabala mezcal dark with orange and bay is like a mezcal margarita with notes of pine and floral lavender. Metice mezcal legendario starts out earthy like dry soil that quickly warms into soft berry notes. Violet skies mezcal Haiti bars bright and sunny with notes of juniper and salted grapefruit. We could go on through these but the whole point is that every one of them is so different. I spoke with a brewer years ago who said what he's going for with every beer he brews was the tilt of the head when someone tastes it for the first time because it's made them pause to pay attention.
SPEAKER_05The flavors of Mezcal do this they make us stop and pay attention. The two guideposts of the tasting experience for me are comfort and provocation. A chocolate or an artisan drink can succeed by offering nostalgia and familiarity or by offering challenge and excitement and the most intriguing tasting experiences can find ways to satisfy these seemingly opposite experiences simultaneously like watching a storm roll in from the warmth and safety of your living room.
SPEAKER_05That's what I'm continually discovering with these Mezcal bars and I encourage you to seek them out and see if they stimulate this for you as well. To wrap up I'll share Lou Banks answer to a question I ask almost all of my guests what story is their work telling I put this to Lou in reference to his collaboration with these three chocolate makers and his answer was kind of perfect Lou you know I I I could I could make up a fancy story for you David but the the truth is the story that it's telling is I Lou Bank love chocolate and love agave spirits and love to find ways to um uh to initiate conversations around that right and so for me this gives me the opportunity to talk about biodiversity through the lens of these different cacao the one same ingredient that's consistent through the three chocolate bars um like I get to talk about biodiversity.
SPEAKER_04I get to talk about all of these beautiful handmade chocolates that we can access and you know most people what I ask them do you do you like chocolate? Oh I love chocolate they'll say and then I'll ask them well what's your favorite cacao and they don't know and so there again you can start talking about biodiversity and then talking about these people who are in places like St. Paul, Minnesota uh like Somerville, Massachusetts, like Pilson in Chicago, um, who are trying to preserve that biodiversity by giving us more delicious chocolates.
SPEAKER_04And then it allows me to talk about this this Il Dafonso this this man who's making these beautiful spirits in a traditional way in a place who is at threat his traditions his his livelihood his food security is at threat because we think we're actually trying to preserve something and in that attempt to preserve something that isn't the thing we're actually putting at risk something that is worth preserving. So stories. It's about me telling stories and it's about me having chocolate to eat that cannot be overlooked.
SPEAKER_05Having chocolate to eat is always going to be foundational what's next are we going to see a collaboration like this again? Oh yeah are you doing this project again?
SPEAKER_04Oh yeah yeah I still have some of these uh bars left like with the I'm not gonna ship anything during the summer it's just not worth it. So some of these bars assuming that I don't eat them all will last until uh fall comes um but yeah no I'll definitely be doing this every year. I just I love the results so much uh I can't not and then I'll just have them for offer when I show up at events mainly or if people come through Chicago if they want to just reach out through the Instagrams or the Facebooks you know want to meet me at uh Dark Matter Star Lounge I'll just slip them a few bars.
SPEAKER_05Lou thank you so much for your time and expertise today I've certainly learned a lot.
SPEAKER_04Well thank you David I appreciate the opportunity to uh to uh uh walk into your church and speak to your congregation That closing is kind of perfect for a conversation about spirits is it not?
SPEAKER_05Thanks so much to all my guests on today's episode and thanks again for bearing with me as I was not able to get any Mexican chocolate makers on the show but I will continue to prioritize that. I'll be writing an article about Mezcal chocolate for the Bean to Barstool blog that will be available a couple weeks after this comes out. If you've tasted any Mezcal bars, I'd love to hear your thoughts on your favorites and if you're a maker who has worked with Mezcal, definitely reach out and share your experience. Some quick news changing the subject I recently got Creo Chocolate's newsletter and they had a call for collab partners in there.
SPEAKER_05Many of you will recall I did a full collaboration for Craft Chocolate Makers series earlier this year so this warmed my heart to see they said if any local business studio or maker would like to collab to email them at info at creo chocolate.com. They're in Portland, Oregon. Creo, if you're listening let me know what comes of that. I always like to see collaborations happening. And finally I will be attending the Northwest Chocolate festival this year so let me know if you'll be there and we can say hello in person.
SPEAKER_05Thank you all so much for listening today. I hope you enjoyed this episode of Bean to Barstool
Bean to Barstool Redux: Vintage but still relevant conversations from the archives without all the extra narration. Just classic interviews from really cool people in craft chocolate, craft beer, and other food and...
Today, we’re talking with a chocolate maker in Belgium, a country still struggling with some baggage around the idea of craft chocolate. Mike & Becky is owned and operated by a couple whose names are not, in fact, Mike...
Here's the entire Media Relations for Craft Chocolate Makers series in one place! Media Relations is a critical component of your marketing strategy as a small business, but it often gets overlooked. Maybe you don't...
One of my favorite memories of my trip to Quito, Ecuador, in 2024 was a night spent at Bandido Brewing’s cozy taproom, just a short walk from the historic district. Founder Nathan Keffer played host and invited some off...
Bean to Barstool Redux: Vintage but still relevant conversations from the archives without all the extra narration. Just classic interviews from really cool people in craft chocolate, craft beer, and other food and...