Ian Cundall, Geoff Pontes and JJ Cooper are here on the Prospect Podcast to analyze all of the 40-man roster protection deadline moves. Who got added? Who got left out? Why is the 2022 MLB Draft A Disaster? (01:40) Did Teams Treat This Deadline Like It Was Normal? (12:40) Protection Decisions That Stood Out (26:15) Big Name Unprotected Prospects (38:00) Sneak Peek At The Rule 5 Preview
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hello, everybody. J.J. Cooper, Jeff Bontz, Ian Cundall. Happy 40-Man Roster Protection Day. Okay, I know that by the time you're seeing this or listening to this, it'll be the day after. It'll be, you know, Boxing Day for the Rule 5 protection deadline. But that being said, we're going to get all into it tonight. We are recording this right after the 40-Man Roster deadline. The 40-Man Roster deadline has passed. So now we know. Who's rule five eligible.
Speaker 1Who's not at least major league. We'll get to the minor league phase, but we're going to focus on the major league phase tonight. We're going to start by acknowledging, and we're going to start by talking about the fact that as we've talked about before, we don't know when, or even if there'll be a major league rule five draft this year, we know that there's about a 99.9999999. I could keep going for sense certainty that there'll be a lockout in December, you know, start of December. CBA is going to expire. When it expires, no one, I mean,
Speaker 1I'm talking literally no one who we've talked to, players, owners, anyone, does not expect there to be a lockout. And that means that when the lockout happens, the Rule 5 draft, which involves 40-man roster players, involves the major league roster, which means it cannot be executed without an agreement of some sort. So it'll be delayed. Whether it happens or not is to be determined. But that's a great way to start this, which is, Jeff, I'm going to you because as much as Ian's part of our Rule 5
Speaker 1fever now, you're our Rule 5 fever vet. So I'm going to ask you first, do you think looking at the protections, did teams treat this deadline like it was a normal deadline? Or did they go, nope, I'm going to leave these guys. I don't think there's going to be a Rule 5 draft. I'm going to leave these guys unprotected.
Speaker 2I thought it was kind of a mixed bag.
Speaker 3I think like you can probably look at the greater picture and say that maybe I'd have to pull a number specifically, but maybe less guys were protected than would have been if it's a normal year without any sort of ambiguity around the rule five draft.
Speaker 2But I think it was a team by team thing.
Speaker 3I felt like the Milwaukee Brewers protected way more players than I expected them to protect. And there were a couple of names on there, like a Dylan O'Reek, that I was a little surprised by.
Speaker 2They're the Brewers. They're very smart.
Speaker 3They probably know more than I do, so I'm not going to say that it was a bad protection, but I thought that it was a little aggressive in terms of protecting six or seven players. We saw some teams do that where I felt like they were more aggressive in kind of filling the 40 man. There were a lot of other teams that didn't protect anybody or Maybe some guys that would have been protected, I think, in a normal year were left unprotected. Just to kind of go into why that is, and we can all expand
Speaker 3on this, but I do think that there are some benefits. If there is no Rule 5 draft or there's some sort of a supplemental protection period, what it could allow is for these teams to have contact and work with these players throughout the offseason, spring training, and if we do miss any time, they can be assigned to a minor league affiliate and then play games. So it, it, it has a lot of benefits for why a team with a player who's kind of fringy in a year
Speaker 3where there's more likely than not going to be a rule five draft. There's some benefits to maybe keeping some of these guys off. And I think from team to team, it depended on how they approached it. The Marlins, I believe had the most available players to protect and, And they have the least amount of players that they protected in terms of the most players available for the Rule 5 draft based on post-protection deadline, at least when looking at my numbers. So they really didn't get aggressive in
Speaker 3terms of adding a lot of names. Even some players that they made some trades for during the season that you would anticipate they would get protected. The Mets in the same division kind of followed suit. Gary Gil Hill not getting protected, I thought, was interesting considering he's one of these guys that they acquired. But they and the Marlins sort of treated it as if there won't be any Rule 5 draft. You could maybe throw the Red Sox in there, but I think Ian, you'd probably back me on this. They didn't have a ton of guys that were like definite protects.
Speaker 4No, they traded the one who was the most likely to the Royals, who then added him to the 40.
Speaker 2And a former Rule 5 pick.
Speaker 5Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 4So yeah, no, I think the Red Sox... there were four teams as Jeff alluded to that did not add anyone. I checked last year. That was, there were only two teams who did that. So an increase, but I mean, I don't know if that means a lot, you know, because I do think like in the Red Sox case and the twins case, which are two of the orgs that I have, I don't think there was anyone that was a surefire lock to be added from either of those orgs. And if you look at, you know, The best available list, I don't know if a twin will make it. When we drop Rule 5, Version 1.0, there will be one Red Sox on it, and it's Blake Weehan. But I think for the reasons that Jeff described earlier, where.
Speaker 5The Red Sox, I think, want him starting next season.
Speaker 4They want him to be able to go out and pitch in AAA next year because he's probably their best depth starter right now outside of the guys with that major league experience. And to them, I think it was more beneficial to you know, take the risk that there is a rule five draft without a second supplemental or without a supplemental protection deadline, then to leave him unprotected and it'll be allowed to have a normal spring training, normal buildup. So that when, you know, eventually major league camp does get going, he's going to have a pretty big leg up when it comes to being a depth starter, because he's going to be, you know, who knows how
Speaker 4long into the season, but have had a normal spring training and a normal, normal buildup. So I think that they just decided ultimately that that was worth more than the risk of losing him, especially since there's just so much uncertainty. Um, but at the end, again, you know, you look at some other teams and like the Orioles, they added what, seven guys, Diamondbacks added six guys. You know, there were a bunch of teams that added kind of the guys that you would have expected. And there were even some surprises, I think with some teams, like there are a few guys that I was not expecting it added. I think the Marlins, it was weird because they didn't protect some guys we were expecting, but did protect some
Speaker 4guys that I don't think were long.
Speaker 1We'll get into that more in a moment. Yeah.
Speaker 5It was a very interesting deadline.
Speaker 4And I think it's pretty clear that teams did approach it with very different ideas. Like some teams just acted as it was a normal deadline. Others, I think, you know, we're added the obvious guys, but we're more cautious with guys and then adding guys that are kind of fringy. And then some teams, as we said, you know, four teams just didn't add anyone. And whether that is because of the, they don't think there'll be a draft or because they just didn't think they had anyone who was worth.
Speaker 5We'll see.
Speaker 4So, yeah, I think it was, it was a very interesting deadline and it was a, It was a lot of fun to cover though. That was a, that was, it was, it came fast and furious around six o'clock and it is fun.
Speaker 1And yeah, but it's my favorite day.
Speaker 5Well, it's cause moves actually happen.
Speaker 4It's the only, like it's the only, it's the only time in the baseball calendar really where you get trades, you get transactions and you get them from all teams. And you know, you look at the other sports, they all have that defined period around the draft with the trading or, whether it be right when free agency opens where everything happens, baseball doesn't really have anything like that.
Speaker 5Like you need forced deadlines to get action. And this is really the only one during the off season that forces anything. So definitely was excited.
Speaker 1That's one of the things I always love to talk. I, when people say, why do you love the rule of five draft? I love the rule five draft for a variety of reasons. There's more than I can probably count, but one of the, Probably one of the most important is, is that exactly it is truth serum for teams.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 1Everyone loves their guys. Everyone loves their guys. They're all great. And they're all going to be great. But then you come to a point where it's like, you get the, you get the sodium pentothal, you know, like injected and it's like, Hey, do you really like this guy? No, not really. We'll leave them unprotected.
Speaker 5Do you like them enough to tie a 40 man roster spot with them?
Speaker 1No, no, no, no. They're not that good.
Speaker 5And that's where you find out.
Speaker 1And also, For other guys, look, we try to stay on top of everybody, right? At the same time, it is always fun. Every year, there will be at least a guy for a team that I don't do. Thankfully, not for a team I do, but for a team that I'm not in charge of doing our rankings, where I have a correspondent do it or whatever. And a guy will get added, and I'll have to start digging on him. And I'll start by this, but I'm like, who is this guy? You know, like I've heard the name,
Speaker 1but I don't really know much about him. And by the time I'm done with him, well, I really like this guy. I can see why they added him. That's a fun part of this too. I did want to go back to one thing that Jeff said. Yes, I know Chris Cotillo, I think tweeted out about saying like that there is at least rumors of the possibility that there could be a supplemental chance for if there is a rule five draft for teams to add players. I will say, this is not my reporting, but as someone who's probably spent as much time thinking about the rule
Speaker 1five draft or the last 20 years as anyone in the world. And I would say like, cause I've had teams tell me you think about it more than we do with that being the case. I will say this, the only logic because teams were sent instructions that said operate as if we are not telling you, there's not going to be a 40, a rule five draft. So don't tell us the dog ate my homework. Don't say we didn't protect guys. And then if there's a rule five draft, say, hey, we didn't know. It's like, no, we told you, prepare as if there is. The only
Speaker 1reason that I can think of where there would be a supplemental protection deadline when there's a Rule 5 draft is if they adopt the rules that they did propose, which is if you change the rules for the Rule 5 draft, Major League Baseball's owners have proposed that teams would be allowed to option Rule 5 players to the minors. Major League Rule 5 players. Now, again, the minor league phase, you just get those guys. There's no roster restrictions. But obviously the major league phase, you have to carry that
Speaker 1player on your roster, your major league roster, without sending them to the minors for the entire next season. That's a huge reason to leave some guys unprotected, like he's not going to stick. Now, if all of a sudden, take a guy like, and we'll get into some of these big name prospects in a moment, but take an Arun Escobar with the Phillies, right? Who I'm not even saying like, he didn't hit in AA this year. He's not a good defensive second baseman. I'm not saying he's going to get picked. But if I'm the Phillies, my
Speaker 1logic is no one's carrying that dude all year. There's no chance this guy's not going to be worth a 26-man roster spot in 2027 as it currently stands. However, if you say, hey, all of a sudden, we're now saying that you can option these guys to the minors, that changes the equation. Then you would need to have a supplemental protection decision. And again, that's the one that came off the top of my head. I can come up, there are better names than that that would fit for
Speaker 1like the guy who is left unprotected. He hasn't played even in AA yet. He's far away. But all of a sudden, if you say, oh, you know, Ian and I like to talk about, you know, I'll tee you up. The Rays lost him last year and then got him back. But who would be the perfect example of a guy who would have been protected last year?
Speaker 4Alexander Alberto, our good friend who was protected this year. He was protected right after the season because I believe he's a minor league free agent. But yeah, I mean, he, you know, when you have it, just that would completely change the dynamics of the rule five draft. And you would have to allow that because I think, you know, Carson Milbrand will be discussing shortly. Like, I don't think the Marlins leave him unprotected if teams can option him. I just had a hard time believing that. I think they're betting in this current market, maybe he can't stick on an MLB roster, especially given the trouble he had
Speaker 4this year in AAA after getting promoted with the Major League Ball.
Speaker 5Things like that, I think.
Speaker 4Is why that would make sense to why you would allow a second window. Otherwise, yeah, if I'm a team that operated normally and they gave just a random second exception, I would be furious. I'd be like, we just had to carry these guys through the lockout and through the last couple of weeks.
Speaker 5There's no logic to it. Yeah, it just doesn't make sense to me.
Speaker 1Okay, speaking of that. After the break, we're going to talk about the protection decisions first that stood out. And then we'll get into some of the names who are left unprotected that stood out right after this. We're back. And let's talk about, so let's start with the guys who were at it. You already kind of, you all kind of jumped in a little bit and started talking about them already. But Ian, I'll start with you. As we said, there were teams who, did very aggressively protected.
Speaker 1And then there were other teams who did not. I mean, obviously I would say that we had a lot of guys who, okay, you know, Christians has a way to get protected. Wow. You know, like there's no one. I'll say this. I'll start with saying this. There is no one left unprotected who you go, okay, that team absolutely 100% is certain there will not be a rule five draft. There was no Zazue does. Jesus Baez is not good. You know, the Cardinals are not like, oh, can play shortstop,
Speaker 1can play second, can play third, hit 30, you know, second in the minors and homers. Was it double A? Yeah, let's leave them unprotected and see if, you know, someone decides to bite. No one like that was left unprotected. But so we can, you know, we're not going to cover that. Like, yep, these top hundred prospects were left unprotected, were protected. But what stood out to you among the players who were protected? Was there any surprises there? either like, oh, that's a little more aggressive than I thought, or, you know, or guys that you're like, oh, that team really, you know, left,
Speaker 1you know, kind of put a lot of guys on.
Speaker 4I mean, I think the Orioles stood out because they had, I was talking to someone yesterday about this and we came up with nine names that they would have to sift through and eight, seven of them got protected. One of them got traded and one of them got left unprotected. And the one who got left unprotected is Creed Williams, who kind of fits in an archetype of player that really didn't get protected at all which is power first guys who don't really have a position um he's not alone in that you know tony blanco is another one who comes to mind like that and there's a bunch of guys who kind of have half power um don't
Speaker 4ryan clifford who have power and don't really project to add a ton of other value uh who left unprotected but the orioles making seven moves is interesting because like they're really going to be hamstrung on their 40 for the foreseeable future and so they really need a lot of these arms to turn into major league relievers soon or major league depth in some capacity. And it was interesting when writing them up though, I, you realize that they had a lot of guys who spent the entire season in AAA and never debuted. So it seems like they've kind of been preparing for this for a while. They obviously have plenty of room on their 40 to add them. And so I think just first off is
Speaker 4the Orioles are going to need, like, they're going to have a very homegrown pitching staff next year. They're going to need some combination of Levi Wells, Patrick Riley, Nestor Herman to take a step forward and be a viable major league bullpen arm next year, because they're, I mean, just the math game. Assuming we stay at 40-man rosters, they have seven spots tied up with guys they just added. After injuries, you're not going to have a lot of depth off of your 40-man roster. So I think the Orioles, it's going to be very interesting to watch when things get going, how many of these guys are in competition for the major league team out of camp. Because if you look at the names they added, the only one
Speaker 4I don't think who has any AAA experience is Braxton Bragg.
Speaker 5No, Aaron Estrada got there in a year. Yes.
Speaker 4So the only one who didn't have any AAA experience is Braxton Bragg, and that's because he was hurt all season. and he's came back in the AFL, and his stuff isn't all the way back, but he looked pretty good when talking to people who saw him out there. And he was obviously one of their better pitching prospects before they made all those trades this year. So I think that what they did is really interesting, and I think just kind of following how they map out having all of these guys, these optionable pieces now, is going to be fascinating to watch going forward because, yeah, I think there's a lot of intrigue there with that group. Another
Speaker 4group that stood out to me was the Diamondbacks. I thought the dimebacks actually, they did protect someone. I was not certain they were going to protect Spencer Geisling, but he, or excuse me, G Sting, I pronounced it wrong.
Speaker 5That might be wrong too. I'll be honest.
Speaker 4That's a tricky one for me. But he, he converted to reliever this year and he came back from it. He missed a couple of months with an oblique injury. And when he got back, his VLO was up and he's dominant against lefties.
Speaker 5Like it's a low.
Speaker 4Slot fastball sweeper type. And he, I wasn't sure he would get protected, but he also does seem like someone who could get popped in rule five. Cause we've seen that, you know, lefty specialist type of left. He's at one 77 average against them this year that really plays. And, um, to see him get protected, I think is, you know, a good sign for how they view him. And I think it makes sense. You know, they've had a really good track record with developing relievers. I look at Brandon Garcia last year. Um, uh, Juan Maria was another one. Like they, they do a really good job with relievers. So I think he's an interesting one to watch. And
Speaker 4then obviously, um, they did do something that I know made you very happy in protecting Drew Jones, who as, as, as you know, as frustrating as he is as a player to watch, he will just show those flashes that this is a major leaguer and his defense is that good that I think you had to.
Speaker 1That's the thing is that, and this is, I'm going to, I'm just going to put it on the tee for you here, Jeff. I'm throwing meatballs here. I think that we're understandably not knocking it. The average fan looking at the rule five, even the, a lot of people writing about the Rule 5, where they get it wrong is pure prospect status and who you protect for the Rule 5 draft are not the same thing. Because there is a subset of players who just don't fit and don't stick.
Speaker 1And then there's the subsets of players who you're like, that guy's not as good a prospect. It's like, yeah, but that guy can stick. Drew Jones is a guy who left unprotected, even if you do not believe in the bat at all.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1And again, we see the flashes Ian and I've talked about, like there's been about three times in his life that it's all synced up and he has lifted a ball to the pole side. And I do mean, it's 460 feet when he does it. And the two times he did it this year, he did it twice this year. And those two times for two of the longer home runs we saw this year, And then he did not do it at all. Those are the only two home runs. He has hit to the pole side in his name is minor league career. I believe. And though he's a
Speaker 170 defender in center, he can run, he can do the things that give you like, look at what Bateman, Brett Bateman did for the blue Jays.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 1They just drafted him. They just traded for him. I should say at the deadline, basically like this guy's really good in center. That's enough for us. Let's just put them out there.
Speaker 5Eli white.
Speaker 4Like he's, been on multiple playoff teams and been traded multiple times to play an exact role that someone like Drew Jones projects as.
Speaker 1So to kind of put it on T for you, Jeff, how would you explain it to what, what is a rule five protection decision versus, Oh, this guy's a much more known prospect, but that's not the type of guy who's going to get picked.
Speaker 3Yeah. I mean, I think that there is sort of like a subsect of, of prospect status players, right. That don't get protected. That's not to say if you're a good, good prospect, you're going to get protected. Even if you're years away and you know, you signed at 16 and you're in double a for a week, you're probably going to get hired. If you're a legitimately good prospect, you're going to get protected. Um, That said, I do think
Speaker 3that there are a lot of, and I'll put it this way, corner outfield prospects, corner infield prospects that generally don't get protected because they don't get picked. If you look historically, there's just so few corner guys who do get picked And if they do get picked, very few of them stick. Even less of them have any impact down the road. And we've studied this historically. Those sort of positions don't project well. But that said, some of
Speaker 3the guys who have been left unprotected from those positional groups have turned out to be MLB all-stars. Max Muncy was a guy that is an example of this.
Speaker 1There's a better example.
Speaker 3Yeah, there's a whole list of guys that have been unprotected over the last few years that maybe become protected next year when they're a little bit closer. Matthew Wood of the Brewers is an older catching prospect. That first guy had a great season this year, kind of married all the skills together. He was unprotected last year, was written up in our Rule 5 preview. I think it was a very low probability that he would get picked, but he was interesting enough to write up. That guy this year is protected. So I think there's sort of this... weird middle ground between guys who maybe have some prospect
Speaker 3status and they are, if they are good, they're going to get protected. If a team spent a lot of money on them and they're good, they're going to get protected. If they're Tamar Johnson and there are major question marks about how good that player is, those guys aren't going to get protected. And I think that is a reflection on their prospect status, frankly, but there's other guys that maybe didn't sign for as much money fit into some of these awkward positional players. Typically those guys probably aren't going to get taken or really young pitchers that don't have any experience above high a, you can be a
Speaker 3legitimate prospect, have pretty good stuff. And often those guys maybe won't get picked because it's just the chances of them sticking or zero.
Speaker 2It's, it's a waste of $ 50, 000.
Speaker 1I would say also kind of along those lines, we saw a number of these. If you were like, we mentioned Arun Esquire, I mentioned Tamar Johnson, a second base only profile. Now I say this, Dan Ugla is a second base only profile who ended up being one of the best Rule 5 picks of the 21st century. I'm not saying it never happens, although that's a long time ago. Dan Ugla's peak was a while ago now. I mean, I could talk about Johan Santana as the class A pitcher who gets picked and then it turns into everything.
Speaker 1Great pick. It's a long time ago now. But what I would say with this is that if the less defensive versatility you have, if you are a liability defensively, it's really hard as a Rule 5 pick for your bat to be good enough because you are going to go to spring training if there is a spring training this year. If there is a Rule 5 draft and there is a spring training, you're going to go to spring training and you're going to have about a three to four week window to essentially make the case, this
Speaker 1is how I can be on this roster. And that's not the kind of guy who is going to generally make that case. Now, if you have this guy who can play shortstop, and then you say like, oh, he can play shortstop. He can play second. He can play third. He could run the bases. Maybe even if you don't hit all that great, you're at least then you're like, well, he's better than our other utility infielders. That guy has a chance. The center fielder who you're like, we can put them in center. We can put them in right.
Speaker 1We can put them left. That's a role player. But as you like to say, Jeff, At the end of the day, it's really about the pitchers. The position players, that's like this small little subset of Major League Rule 5 picks. The pitchers, that's where you spend. That's where we spend the majority of the time of our focus because you're in and you're out. Those are the guys who you can see get picked. They get picked. They get picked a lot.
Speaker 5They also stick more. Look at Spencer Miles this year.
Speaker 3Yeah, and I think there's even ways to finesse them because they're pitchers too, that it's probably easier. And I'm not saying that there are phantom injuries, but I do think that there are times when wear and tear can be perceived as a risk. And there are times where those guys get slowed down and put onto the injured list and There's a whole process with rehab that kind of allots them a couple of games here and there
Speaker 3as they're working their way back to maybe pitch in the minor leagues for a game or two. So I also think there's just a lot more flexibility that you can sort of have with some of these arms too and end up keeping those guys. And I think the other part of it too is when we talk about the best Rule 5 picks, the majority of them are relievers. A majority of them are guys that were left unprotected, and they had the stuff to certainly be in a
Speaker 3big league bullpen. And they get protected, they get kept, or they get traded the day of the Rule 5 draft. And those guys can be in their team's bullpens for years. I mean, I believe the Red Sox have, what, two or three guys right.
Speaker 1Now in their pen that were.
Speaker 2Top yeah and then they had watson.
Speaker 4Who was really good with the angels after they got him yeah but i mean whitlock's what a top five reliever in baseball and they got him as a rule five pick so.
Speaker 3Yeah i can remember the cardinals making a couple of moves and adding guys to their bullpen too like ryan fernandez was a rule five from the red socks and he's been he's been with them now for what two years and you know it's been a pretty valuable player so i think there's a lot of those types um And even some of the guys that don't stick, you can look back years later and say, oh, wow, this guy has developed into something that was pretty good.
Speaker 1Jose Soriano.
Speaker 5I was about to bring him up. There you go.
Speaker 1That's right. I was going to move us on to tie into this. Let's now flip it to the unprotected, the guys who were left unprotected. So I'm going to start this one. So there's a piece up at BaseballAmerica.com. It's eyeopening for me. I try to look, I have been studying first round picks and for this look, there was a first round pick last year. It was pick 39, which was after like 10 non first round picks little just insight to make it simple. I just treat it
Speaker 1as the top 30 picks. There are 30 teams. The top 30 picks is what we're looking at.
Speaker 5Right?
Speaker 1So, but first round every year, I look at what are the players who are unprotected in their first year of eligibility. who are first-round picks. Because if you don't protect a fourth-rounder, okay, if you don't protect a first-rounder, you want to do over. No one drafts a guy in the first round, four or five years later says, nah, we don't need to add him to the 40 and goes, it was a good pick. We really liked the pick in hindsight. You may have liked it at the time,
Speaker 1but when we say that this is truth serum, this is your truth serum moment. And let me just say, I mean, I always talk about the 2016 draft and how bad the 2016 draft was at the top. This 2022 draft is an all-time stinker. Like this is, it is shocking. Like when you look, I'll just try to pretty quickly, you know, like, okay, here's, let me just
Speaker 1call up the draft from that year. So sorry, this is good. Not, this is great podcasting here, but I do want to have it up. So just rattled through. Okay. First pick Jackson holiday, big leaguer. Hasn't really come together yet for him, but still young and a big leaguer. Let's just say by what we're going to come to, that's going to be good. Second pick drew Jones added to the 40. We just said, I'm not saying that this is a pick you would want to do over at two, but Hey, added to the play, the big leagues Kumar rocker is in the Rangers rotation, bit up and down. Hasn't been dominant or anything, third pick, but okay.
Speaker 1We just said Tamar Johnson left unprotected. Unfortunately, blew out his ACL, which does not... I've had people ask, does that make it more likely he gets picked? I would say no in this case because the medical is one of the things I've been told by multiple front office officials over the years. The medical, and we write up guys. There are guys we write up, and it's like, I like that guy too. Our medical department is never going to let us pick him because if you draft a guy... You also take on the medical liability, right? So if he has to have further surgery, there are costs involved
Speaker 1in all these things. But most importantly, Tamar Johnson did not hit 200 in AAA last year in most of a full season. That's not going to get you picked. Elijah Green, five. We didn't even really talk. No one expected Elijah Green. He struck out just too much throughout his career for the Nationals. Jacob Berry was left unprotected last year for the Marlins. That's number six. So we are already top six picks. Three of them went unprotected. Just to be clear, I've studied the last 10 Rule 5 drafts for this. There is no other year where
Speaker 1there were two unprotected top 10 picks, three of the top six. Cade Horton, good pick. I know he's been hurt, but that's one where the Cubs, if they had to do over, I think they're like, yep, let's roll the dice again. Let's do it again with Kate Horton in his elbow. Brooks Lee at eight. Again, he's a big leaguer.
Speaker 5He's good this year. Three war this year.
Speaker 3Yep.
Speaker 1That's the guy they do again. Okay. Gavin Cross was less than protected last year. Royals pick at nine. Gabriel Hughes, big leaguer. Close to a six ERA, I believe. Maybe above six ERA, but big leaguer. It's Rocky Soto. Kevin Perotta, 11th overall, left unprotected last year. So now if you're scoring at home, that's four of our top 10 and five of our top 11. And then Jace Young was 12.
Speaker 1And Jace Young is a big leaguer who was on the 40-man roster, but he was also designated for assignment today, having never really established himself with Detroit. Okay. Hey, we're at pick 13. Zach Netta. Great pick. In a redraft of the first round, he goes 1-1, and it's not a question. I don't think that you could make an argument for someone else, maybe down the road. Okay, I'll ask y'all. Chase DeLotto or Zach Netto? I'm taking Zach Netto. He's already got four years of track record in his
Speaker 1back pocket. Fair?
Speaker 4He's also premium position, whereas DeLotto is going to corner guy. So, yeah, you probably take Netto, even with his swing and miss issues. But, I mean, I think it shows how weak this class is, that someone like Netto, who does have a pretty– big hole in their game is the clear cut.
Speaker 1Number one guy, Jet Williams, pick 14 out of the 40 thing. Bad year, you know, injury plagued year this year, but out of the 40 Dylan, let's go at 15. This one makes it sad to me. Cause I, I will tell you right now, a lot of people can say this watched one of the best pitch performances. I have ever seen a high school pitcher throw NHSI that draft year. It was also the last pitch he threw that year. Cause he blew out his elbow in that game. And we have never seen the same Dylan Lesko since. Yeah.
Speaker 5I saw him this year and it was, it was, it was rough.
Speaker 1So I'm, I'm protected. Chase DeLauder again, guardians do that a hundred times out of a hundred. Again, Justin Crawford is a big leaguer with the Phillies. I'm not going to do all of these. I'm going to stop at 20, but Cam Collier was left unprotected. Jeff, I will say you were, you were ahead of the curve on that one. Jeff basically on draft day was like, I really don't think that's going to work out. I think that his, I think I don't want to, I'll let you, I don't cause I.
Speaker 5Don't want to.
Speaker 3So he was being, he was being rumored as a top 10 pick at the time. And I was on the ground at Katuit at every single one of his games with the exception of one. I saw every play he made in the cake, right? Which I thought was probably the best sample. I saw all the Cubs guys roll in. I saw all the Cubs guys be disappointed and roll out and move on to other players.
Speaker 2All right.
Speaker 3And he was rumored to the Cubs. He was rumored to the Cubs, rumored to the Cubs. I think there was a huge disconnect between how he was reported.
Speaker 2And I don't think it was by Carlos.
Speaker 3He did a good job, but generally out in the public, there were a lot of irresponsible opinions on Collier and the type of player that he was. I remember seeing that he was a plus runner and then going and watching him and being like, he's four years younger than the first baseman on this team.
Speaker 2And the first baseman.
Speaker 3On every kick team runs better than Kim Collier does at 22, you know? So it was one of those where it was always kind of clear and it never really clicked.
Speaker 2That's not to say that it won't. I think there's always been talent here.
Speaker 3I mean, he's an immensely talented hitter, but the approach and it's just, it's a tough profile too. I mean, to be a first baseman, you have to be, one of the 60 best hitters in the world has cut out. Maybe not totally, but it's hard to not be a top 100 hitter in the world and be an everyday first baseman in the big leagues.
Speaker 1And I want to say what that is. The Reds did protect a first baseman today. They added Carter Graham.
Speaker 5I think that's the telling thing.
Speaker 1And I would also say, though, other than the fact that Cam Collier went first round and Carter Graham was a later round pick, This isn't a question. Carter Graham was on the same team, outperformed Cam Collier. He's much older. I will say this. Much older. Everyone's older than Cam Collier. That's one thing. Cam Collier is still very young. That's why you hope that it does develop. But Carter Graham was an incredible development success story this year. And again, give him all the credit in the world. Utterly remade
Speaker 1himself from being an org player. He managed to cut his chase rate, make more contact, swing the bat harder, hit the ball harder and hit the ball more effectively. Other than that, he didn't do a whole lot, you know, offensively better, but like, like three and a half miles an hour at jump in average EV, like two plus miles an hour jump in 90th EV while making more contact while cutting his K rate, while better, you know, better pitch swinging at better pitches. There's almost nothing he didn't do better this year. And he gets rewarded with
Speaker 140 man roster spot to wrap up though. Daniel Suzak left unprotected last year, picked by the giants made, you know, stuck as a rule five pick. and then Owen Murphy. So that's all together in that first round, 12 players from the top 30 picks from that first round were left unprotected your last year or this year. That's the most in any draft of the last 10 rule five drafts. And there's only been one other where there was more than six left unprotected. And by the way, we already have almost as many big leaguers from the 2024 first
Speaker 1round as we do from 22. even though 24 is two years later, including high school players. So that was just a kind of a wow moment to me. We obviously, so we did see a lot of first rounders left unprotected. I would say, to be honest, one of the things that we've seen with this is if you are an unprotected first round pick, you don't get picked and you don't end up having significant big league success as a general rule. I think there are now 63 players left
Speaker 1who fit in that last 10 draft study before this year. And Cole Reagan's has been a success. Now Cole Reagan's is weird because he was hurt in 2018, hurt in 2019. And then he was rule five eligible after the 2020 season. And there was no season in 2020 because of COVID. So yes, he went unpicked because no one had seen him pitch in three years. Other than him, Only other success story I can find, which is more than three
Speaker 1career war, is Foster Griffin, who went to Japan for three years and kind of remade himself.
Speaker 3And I think you look at both of those examples, and you can't really view those as a typical Rule 5 situation.
Speaker 5You can't compare anything to those.
Speaker 1No.
Speaker 5It's unlikely that anyone will have a similar path.
Speaker 1Yeah. So that's, to me, kind of a look at, that's where we're looking at kind of some of the big name unprotected. We'll have more about that over at Baseball America as well. But we're going to save the best for last. When we get back after one more break, we're going to give you a little sneak peek at Rule 5 Preview Version 1.0. We'll make a case, we'll each make a case for one guy who we think could get picked if there is a Rule 5 draft right after this. Okay, we're back. Each of us gets to make the case for one. There's going to be
Speaker 1more over at BaseballAmerican.com.
Speaker 5Do check it out.
Speaker 1We'll be up by the time you're listening to this. Well, if you're listening to this and you are, I tip my cap, if you are hardcore and you're listening to this at 6 a.m., you might beat us. But if you listen to this in the morning, I think we'll already have Rule 5 draft preview version 1.0 up. So, Ian, we'll start out with you. Who is someone who is unprotected who you think and you can make a case for why they could be picked?
Speaker 4Ooh.
Speaker 5That's a tricky one.
Speaker 1Cause you're, if you don't know yet, I'll go to Jeff. Jeff's got one on his top. You're ready to go. And I've got like one that I really want to tell you about.
Speaker 5Well, I don't want to take yours.
Speaker 1So I'll let you go.
Speaker 4Don't worry. I, the world is my oyster. So I'll, I guess I'll just go with, I'll go with Carson Moe brand. Cause I thought him being unprotected was the most interesting case of the entire time, because this is a guy who was in the top 100 at one point this season. And, I don't think the process that got him there was wrong. Maybe he ended up a little high in the list, but in hindsight. In hindsight, it was wrong.
Speaker 5We screwed up.
Speaker 4Well, in hindsight, it was wrong, but I think he did show some traits that were interesting enough to warrant at least consideration.
Speaker 5And granted, it completely fell apart in AAA. And I don't think we maybe took into account the level that it fell apart in AAA.
Speaker 4He had an 8.39 ERA with 52 walks and 64 in a third innings. I think that the baseball really bothered him. I think that he just could not grab a breaking ball. And like Jeff and I saw him in AAA and it was bad. He was, Velo was down. He just could not find any, just spin feel of his feel for spin was gone at just everything was gone. It was, it was really, it was a rough outing and you know, it was one of his first, it was one of his early outings. So it was maybe this was just an outlier and it's like, well, no, this kind of held the entire time. And yeah, I
Speaker 4think that still there's enough talent that a team will be willing to take a chance here because this is a guy with pedigree. This is a guy who at his best will show, you know, big stuff. It's really interesting shapes. And, you know, I mean, you know, mid to 90s upper fastball, you probably cut down the arsenal if you draft him because you're moving the bullpen. You're not letting him start if you're rule fiving him. And so I think there's a pathway that a team will at least take a look out of spring training to see what it looks like, especially if, I, and I think this could be a, it's kind of an interesting
Speaker 4gamble by the Marlins is if the minor league season starts and he goes out there and he's thrown all winter with an, with, you know, with the major league baseball and comes out and kind of looks more like the guy we saw in the first half teams are going to get a long look at him before the rule five draft could take place.
Speaker 5And so I think.
Speaker 4That we'll have a really good idea of how he's adjusted after an offseason of kind of having to reinvent himself after the struggles he had. But I think that the talent is enough that I could see a team taking a chance on him. And he was definitely one of the bigger names unprotected, someone who is inside the Marlins top 10.
Speaker 5Okay.
Speaker 1Jeff, what about you?
Speaker 3So I think there's a few. I need some more time to really dig in. pick my guys apart, but the, the name that stuck out to me kind of immediately, it jumped on my model that I've been kind of messing with, um, is Owen wilds, uh, from the rays. It's a big fastball, good angles, seven feet of extension, mid nineties, velocity, uh, cut ride shape, lower spin, high spin efficiency. Um, so it did lose a little ride in triple a, but not a substantial amount. Um, A
Speaker 3lot of swings and misses against that pitch. Really good expected outcomes in terms of his ex-Woba against that. Has a kind of like mid-80s gyro cut kind of a slider. It's an interesting shape that got less whiffs than the fastball, but had like a sub-200 ex-Woba.
Speaker 2So it is a good pitch. He's a two-pitch guy. Kind of look.
Speaker 3At the traits of like power, slider that gets, you know, bad contact. consistently, um, release traits, movement, kind of that cut ride shape that team seemed to like, and the ability to miss some bats.
Speaker 2I think he's interesting.
Speaker 3I don't, I don't think he's a slam dunk by any means. Um, but certainly an interesting one. And, uh, I think some of the other guys that I'll say, like, if I can pick a secondary honorable mention, because I don't think this is going to be your guy, JJ, but Derek diamond from.
Speaker 2Pirates looks kind of interesting.
Speaker 3There's Velo there had only a 39, excuse me, 39, 3.9% walk rate this year, which is, which is obviously excellent. Strikes in AAA for pitchers are paramount in terms of those guys going in the rule five draft. There's a threshold that kind of have to be under. We've studied that historically. I think it's also in line with something that a scout told me a long time ago when I was feeding them names for the rule five draft. And he's kind of like, Jeff, the biggest thing is
Speaker 3you can't take on guys that are going to go into the big leagues and embarrass you. And that's, you know, guys that as far as pitchers, that's going to be guys that are going to walk the house. So, you know, it looked like an Andrew Baker or Will Bednar or someone like that, whose stuff might be good, might've missed some bats, but ultimately they walk too many guys to probably be high probability five picks.
Speaker 4Okay.
Speaker 1I said, I agree. I've got about five pictures that I could rattle off here because that's where most of the guys last year, there was one position player taken in the entire major league rule five draft. That was a Daniel Suzak who did stick, you know, Spencer miles, best pick from last year's draft. Spencer miles was very good pick by the blue Jays. But, but I would say I'm going to still go with position player despite that, because I'll tell you right now, when I saw, and I'm going to tee up Ian on this because we've
Speaker 1talked about it because when I saw Noah Miller, the Dodgers is on this list. That dude is, if you asked me, who's the best present defender, middle infielder in the minors, if you want to tell me that Starling Cava down the road might be better. Okay. You can probably come up a couple other guys who might down the road be better, but I'll tell you this right now, Noah Miller, I've watched, A ton of him playing defense
Speaker 1at short. And by the way, they played him at third some, and it translates right over to third. At third, it's like, wow, he made a play there. But he makes plays at short that very few short stops can make. He's reliable. He's rangy. He's got the hands. He's got the actions. He's got the feet. He's got the arm. The key thing that he has that most of these guys who are these light hitting guys like this don't have is they can make the flashy play to their left. They can make the play coming in. But if you have to go back in the hole, they just don't have the arm to make that play. That's where I'd
Speaker 1say Starling Cop. Starling Cop does not make that play that Noah Miller does not. But Noah Miller does. Is he going to hit?
Speaker 4No.
Speaker 1He had a 42, I think it was, off the top of my head, when he runs created plus in AAA in 25. He improved to like 80 this year. But he doesn't hit the ball hard. Doesn't make a ton of contact. Strikes out a good bit. Doesn't hit the ball in the air. He doesn't. doesn't really do anything offensively great. He is not someone you want as a regular, but he was a former twin. And let me just tell you, because we talked about this on the podcast in the off season, we said going into the season, it's like the twins do not have an
Speaker 1actual shortstop on their roster. And I think it proved to be true, right? They started playing Brooks Lee. Brooks Lee was not a shortstop. Nope. They played a variety of players, none of whom were actually shortstops. Nope. Noah Miller's actually a shortstop. Now, I wouldn't want to play him every day. Nope. But if you said, make the case to go with the Jeff thing, don't embarrass me. If you recommend Noah Miller and he goes out, that guy's going to go to spring training and the big
Speaker 1league manager, the big league coaching staff is going to be like, yep, I see exactly why he's here. And then it's going to come a question. Is it important to us? And again, only fits for certain teams, right? If you have a plus defensive shortstop at the big league level, you don't need to.
Speaker 5Draft Noah Miller.
Speaker 1But if you're going into it and you're like, we're a little shaky there defensively. We got a guy we believe can hit, but we don't know how good he is defensively. You could absolutely carry this guy to come in in the seventh, eighth, ninth inning of games that you're ahead. And by the way, he does have some contact skills. I don't want to make it sound like if you have him bat, that it's going to be like that there's a pitcher at the plate or anything like that. That's not what I'm saying. But so I would say like he, to me, I'll just tell you,
Speaker 1he's got two years of AAA experience too. He's the best infield prospect available in the rule five draft defensively that I can think of in years. There are guys who, Kyle Holder was available years ago.
Speaker 5He was picked, too, I believe, yeah.
Speaker 1He was picked and did not stick.
Speaker 5Christian Cairo was picked in it, too, who could really pick it at shortstop, right?
Speaker 1Right. There are a couple guys who've been taken. But what I would say is usually those guys, their bats are even worse than Noah Miller's. Noah Miller, again, Noah Miller hit 10 homers in AAA last year. Oklahoma City. He's not a good hitter. I'm not saying he is. I'm not selling that. But what I'm saying, Lewis, is like, but if you said to me, like, I remember 2018, I think it was, the Astros left, but Richie Martin
Speaker 1was left unprotected. And I remember thinking at the time, and Richie Martin is not a great defensive shortstop, but that was one time where I was like, that guy's going to get picked. There is no chance. That's one of the few exceptions where the whole, the first rounders don't get picked. This guy had had a decent year the year before in the upper levels of the minors. And actually A's, I think Richie Martin was. Yeah, A's, A's. And it's like, and the Orioles are picking one, one, and they don't have a shortstop. And they did. They drafted him. He wasn't good for them, but they did draft him. I feel like I'm not going to say
Speaker 1that we don't even know if we're going to have a real five draft this year. But I will say this. If someone takes Noah Miller, I have very little question about that he's going to show up and it's going to be like, whether he makes the team or not, it'll be like, yep, that made sense because he's going to be the best, one of the best defenders in that camp.
Speaker 5I have a team for you also.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 4This team currently has Jim Jarvis projected as their starting shortstop. They didn't really have a shortstop at all last season and they have an excellent lineup that can afford to have a nine hitter who adds nothing but defense. That team is the Atlanta Braves. I think he would be a great fit there. They've run out Nick Allen in the past before. They know that type. I just think that that is like a match made in heaven for the Rule 5 draft.
Speaker 5Assuming the Braves don't address the position elsewhere.
Speaker 1Especially even if they do, right? To me, that's the perfect combo. To me, I'm not Noah Miller's agent, but I just gave a sales pitch. I'm like, you got to take this guy. I am not saying that anyone should take this guy and say, that's our shortstop. You should never take a rule five draft pick as a shortstop and be like, that's our guy. That is, that is rolling a level of dice that you should not go to. But if you said we want him to be part of our mix, absolutely. Cause of what you just said, like the Braves were a team last year
Speaker 1who had injuries at times where it was like, we don't really have a shortstop. Okay. Now you have a guy who, The same way that we talk about backup catchers. What is the most important thing for a backup catcher? You've got to be able to do the job defensively. And that's the Braves are a perfect example of this, right? Like the funny thing is, is now the twins aren't. The twins were at this time last year. Now they got Kellen Culpepper and they got Mary Houston. No, not them. But they're covering other teams too. But I will say, that's one that I'm kind of excited, again, seeing him. Yes, Ian.
Speaker 5Can I jump in, too?
Speaker 4I didn't realize we could do multiple like Jeff did. I'm fascinated to see what happens to some of the Rays' arms because they left three unprotected that are pretty interesting. I've just been in a Rays' mindset this week as I've worked on their top 10 and top 30s. Jackson Bowmister, Santiago Suarez, and TJ Nichols, all for very different reasons, are all really interesting to me. I think Bowmister is someone who I think could go really early. This guy who's close to big league ready. He's got good pitches. I was talking to some teams that have him well
Speaker 4inside their top 20. So I think that he's a pretty interesting one that they left unprotected. But at the same time, it actually fits with the Rays because the Rays just have a plethora of these guys who are probably not starters and who are just like relievers, but they're like, it's not a leverage reliever. It's probably more like a middle relief profile. And they just have so many of them that at some point you just have to make a decision. And I think they're kind of hedging their bets that there might not be a rule five draft. or if there is, it's okay. We lost, you know, a sixth inning reliever. It's not the end of the world, but I think, yeah, cause Bowmister. And
Speaker 4then Suarez, you know, he throws a ton of strikes. His curve ball kind of was weird this year. He wasn't able to use it a ton. And then Nichols kind of regressed this year. He was better last season. I think he was in the brace or he was one of their top 10 prospects entering the season, but he kind of had a down year. It's kind of a two pitch guy now. So I think that they're, they're a team that they did add Xavier Isaac, but it was interesting to me that they left three pitchers who, Working on the rough draft, at least two of those guys were probably going to be ahead of Isaac, but they didn't get protected and he did. So I think that was an interesting one to me and some names
Speaker 4I would be watching that will be added to version 1.0 shortly.
Speaker 1Okay, I'll also say with that, and then we'll wrap this up, but this will not happen. But if you somehow happen to be the team where you're like, hey, we've got a great first baseman who's absolutely a nightmare defensively at first base is a danger to himself and everyone else. So we need, we need a premium defensive first baseman to be his, you know, his caddy. Well, then Trey Morganger, man, because that guy is an incredible
Speaker 1first baseman. Didn't hit a triple A at all this year. Doesn't have power. The power has never developed.
Speaker 2I did.
Speaker 5Yeah. He hit a little better when you're trying for injury.
Speaker 1I will say he was like 260, 270, but I will say, Like if, again, I, and I, I, if you ask me, give me an example of a guy who fits that there is none, you know, like there is not the example of the guy where you're like, Oh, it was the great defensive first base when it got drafted for his glove. Nope. That hadn't happened. You know, but, but that is a interesting one, but we have so much more about the rule five draft. We're going to preview it until it's postponed. And then we'll flip into
Speaker 1minor league rule five preview mode. We did it before Jeff and I did. And by the way, we hit some of the picks, you know.
Speaker 2I think we hit like 12 or 13.
Speaker 1We had a bunch of, you know, we're, so we're going to do that. And by the way, a lot of those guys did make the majors. I am not going to tell you that they've had dramatic, significant big league careers, but they made the majors. And if you get a minor league rule five pick to make the majors, you've done well, you know, I mean, they're not all going to be Justin Moore. They're not all going to be what was the catcher for the Omar Navarez for the White Sox. Those are some premium minor league.
Speaker 5Role play picks.
Speaker 1But if you enjoyed this, you will definitely enjoy all the stuff. We wrote up every player was added to the 40-man roster at the deadline. That's over at BaseballAmerica.com. We have a full explanation of how bad the 2022 first round was over at BaseballAmerica.com. And by the time you are listening or viewing this, you will probably be time that we will have up rule five preview version 1.0. So check that out or baseballamerica.com for Ian and Jeff. I'm JJ. So long, everybody.
JJ and Carlos continue to review the 2020s draft results of NL teams - this time with the NL West. How has each team in the division drafted, who has done well and who might want more picks back? - Time stamps: (0:00)...
There might be no position as loaded as shortstop year after year with many of the games biggest stars amongst the ranks. This week on the Baseball America fantasy podcast hosts James Anderson and Geoff Pontes dive into...
On this week's Hot Sheet Show, J.J. Cooper, Carlos Collazo and Ben Badler The Hot Sheet Show airs live on the BA YouTube channel every Tuesday at 3 p.m. Give us a sub, and we'll see you then! Time Stamps (00:00)...
JJ and Carlos continue their divisional draft reviews with a rock solid NL Central division. How have teams drafted, who has had the biggest wins and who has picks they would like back? - Time stamps: (0:00) Intro...
This week on the Baseball America Fantasy Podcast our lead fantasy analyst James Anderson is joined by Geoff Pontes to break down the 2027 second base and third base dynasty rankings. While neither of these are deep...