Revolut has just had the worst month in its history: two customer data breaches, one of them a months-long con run from a hijacked Italian government email account, and a facial-recognition payments launch in the middle of it all. Jonny was caught up in one of the breaches himself, so this one's personal. In this episode: How hackers used a stolen Ministry of the Interior email account and forged European Investigation Orders to get Revolut to hand over passports, selfies and home addresses Why the targets weren't random: blockchain analysis, the richest crypto wallets, and what a "wrench attack" is The victims, including the former Mt. Gox CEO who's moved his family into a hotel The moment Revolut corrected the hackers' paperwork for them Revolut's response, and why "no funds were affected" misses the point The DriveWealth breach: Jonny's own data, Revolut's chatbot reply, and who's actually responsible Pay With Smile: what it is, why it's really a merchant acquisition play, and whether there's any upside Why data breaches have become background noise, and what, if anything, you can do about it Join the new Banking Without Borders Discord community https://link.bankingwithoutborders.co.uk/discord Subscribe on YouTube https://link.technicallymoney.com/oy8e Check out our website DepositScout.com for the latest savings rates. Connect with us (via LinkedIn) Jan: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jan-watermann/ Jonny: http://www.linkedin.com/in/jonny-pease Got a question or topic you want us to cover? Drop us a message at jonny@technicallymoney.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so Revolut just had the worst month in its history. So someone spent months pretending to be a government official and asked Revolute for its customers' most sensitive data, passports, selfies. They even asked who the owners of specific crypto wallets were and where they lived. And Revolut handed it over. But in their defense, as we'll discuss, this was a very convincing con. And it's not victimless either. Some of the people whose data was leaked now fear for their safety. One of them has moved their family into a hotel. And Revolute's response, nothing, really, just a shrug.
SPEAKER_00You know, a short statement, their systems were unaffected, there were a limited number of customers affected, and their funds were untouched. Which might all be true, but it misses the point entirely because the hackers weren't after the funds in their Revolut accounts. They were after their personal information. So who they are, where they live, what they look like. And this stuff is becoming so common that only two weeks later, I got an email from Revolut telling me I'd been caught in a leak as well. So I contacted Revolute to ask what I was supposed to do about it, and I'll share their response shortly.
SPEAKER_00So that's two customer data breaches in one month. And in the same month, Revolut also chose to launch Pay with Smile, where you pay for your coffee with your face. Now that raises a few obvious concerns, which we can get into, and as always, please get in the comments and let us know your thoughts. But first, Jan, we have to talk about this data breach and exactly how they pulled it off. Because Revolut is a company worth over a hundred billion dollars with a pending US banking license, and they were tricked by a stolen email account.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, Johnny, reading through the story, I think it's it's kind of shocking. How can that even happen? Um, that's the first thing I asked myself. And I think they're it's maybe not purely their fault. Um the regulators for uh is as much if fault, in my opinion, um, due to the fact that they lost access to the email. We'll go into that detail in that detail later. What really angers me is their response. They really shrugged it off, basically. Um, didn't really admit much, just inform people that there was a data breach. And I think this is sad because this data breach has led to actual consequences.
SPEAKER_01We know that for a fact. Um, and just feel sorry about the people affected in it. It's uh it's a disaster, actually.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. So there is a certain level of incompetence here at play from both sides, not only Revolute, but also the Italian Ministry of Interior. They've had their account or their email address accessed by a party called I Am Not a Villain. This is like a hacking group, I believe, who have essentially bought access. And that's where the story begins, Jan. Inside this Italian email account, essentially, that's being used to contact Revolute. And this is an account that is also being used by the Ministry of Interior.
SPEAKER_00It's also an active account. But the hackers are able to stay silent, stay hidden by deleting any correspondence that would be for them immediately when it's received. So they just download it as a.eml attachment and delete it. And then the the the authorities, the Italian authorities, are none the wiser. I actually hate to say this, but it's quite genius, really. You know, they they created like a recovery email address so if they lost access, they could get access again. This episode is sponsored by no one, really, just Jan and I and our website, depositscout.com.
SPEAKER_00We built a savings comparison website basically because we couldn't find a website or a resource that we thought was good enough for what we wanted. Now we've built a database full of pretty much every account in the UK. We have easy access, fixed accounts, notice accounts, regular savers, even junior iters if you have children or if you're a grandparent. Some of my favorite features amongst many have to be the rate alerts. With Deposit Scout, you can track any account type that you want and we'll automatically email you if a new rate becomes available. We can also send you a weekly roundup.
SPEAKER_00We send it out every Monday so you can see the latest accounts and you can track specific accounts if you're only interested in, say, fixing your money or keeping up with the latest and greatest easy access account. Jan, do you want to share a favorite feature as well?
SPEAKER_01Johnny, I really love these account pages that we've set up because they provide a level of detail on each account that's available in our database that has uh yeah not been accessible before. So you can quickly look at an account, get an idea whether it's competitive or not compared to other accounts out there, and then also draw a conclusion from that, whether it's an account worth signing up for, or whether you should rather go with a different alternative, really makes the whole account choosing process more seamless, right? And at the end, I believe, I really do, that you end up with a better product, which can make a huge difference in terms of interest that you receive at the end of the year.
SPEAKER_01Take a look at the website, it's something that Johnny and I have built. It is the best way to give back to the channel, to the podcast, and to us personally. Um, it's depositscout.com, everyone. We'll show a QR code on the screen. Feel free to sign up and let us know what you think about it.
SPEAKER_00So they begin inside this official verified Italian email account and they start to send messages to Revolut, specifically the UAB, Revolut UAB Bank Entity. They send them forged documents that look like European investigation order documents. I'll put it on the screen for those who are watching. I think it looks pretty solid. They start to send these across and they're saying, hey, we've got these transaction IDs and we want to know who's responsible for them. And they start to send these forged documents to Revolut and they are requesting the profile of crypto transaction IDs, but these aren't random accounts or transactions.
SPEAKER_00The attackers have already performed blockchain analysis to identify the richest wallets they could find, and it's the identities of those wallets, those transactions that they are trying to extract from Revolut. Crypto is meant to be anonymous. That was all what it was always about, you know, anonymity. And Revolut are just revealing the people behind these. This goes on for months, Yan, and they continue to give more and more data across to this email inbox. File after file, profile after profile, we're talking names, phone numbers, selfies so they can identify the people, addresses, which is important here.
SPEAKER_00There's something in crypto, Yan called a wrench attack. It's where someone will attack someone physically, in person, in order to extract their seed phrase, their secret passwords, maybe get access to a hardware wallet. And that's what this information could be used to do. And these were celebrities, there's allegedly a tennis player called Chevchenko. We have the founder, CEO of an online gambling company called Felix Roma.
SPEAKER_00He's been quite outspoken about this on Twitter. Um he has been potentially extorted. I don't think he has necessarily paid up, but they are trying to extort him, or people are trying to extort him by saying, hey, if you don't pay or if you don't act on this, we will expose your data online, which is quite frightening. There's another guy called, I believe, Mark Carpellis. He was like the CEO of a Bitcoin exchange and um obviously has some wealth. You would assume he would have a large crypto holding. He was targeted, he was the person that's had to move out of his home and into a hotel.
SPEAKER_00And I mean, this is something, Jan. It's important to know for context. Kidnapping is becoming rife inside of the Bitcoin world, so to speak. There was the founder of Ledger, the hardware wallet, that was kidnapped him and his wife, and they were brutalized. Apparently, I think he may have had his finger chopped off before the French counter-terrorist police found him. So this is happening. This is rife inside of this world, and that's why this data is very valuable. And it might not be the hacking group, I am not a villain, that are planning on robbing these people.
SPEAKER_00I'm not suggesting that for a moment. They might sell this information to the highest bidder who then, like a nefarious actor who then wants to go and rob them. Yeah. So can you I hope the severity of this incident is coming along, coming across here. The cleverness, I think, of it is also very important. I don't want to gratify illegal behavior by saying it was so smart and so innovative. And I think there's a lot of stupidity behind this. But the fact they were able to gain access to these accounts, send these requests, and Revolute were complicit. They just happily just passed them across.
SPEAKER_00In one case, Jan, they sent an email, the hackers from this Italian account, incorrectly formatted the document, requested the wrong information, or the way they phrased it. And I can put it on the screen, it's in Italian, but Revolute responded in Italian and said, Hey, this is wrong. You need to change this. And I've I've had it translated. They essentially just told them, hey, you need to do this differently and then re-request and we'll send you the information you want. So at the same time, they are just willingly handing over this data without double-checking it.
SPEAKER_00Because I think if someone makes a mistake like that, yeah, and you think, okay, there seems something wrong with this. They've made a mistake. Maybe we should investigate this now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, Johnny, let me let me quickly interject here. I mean, I totally get your point. This was um yeah, not right what Revolute did here. Obviously, um not supposed to hand out customer data to um malicious groups, but speaking in their defense, if an official government email emails you or emails any bank, I'm sure this would get some sort of attention within that entity, right? And um we should start at the beginning. How did they get access to this email in the first place when looking for someone to blame? Um obviously Revolute is also to blame because they actually handed over the data, but um, I think the the Italian, um, the Italian Ministry of Interior, you know, losing access of that email address.
SPEAKER_01That's the start of it, right? So they're as much asked for it as Revolute, in my opinion.
SPEAKER_00I believe it was obtained through an info stealer. So, like there was some malicious software on a computer somewhere that stole and scraped a number of passwords that were then it was established that these passwords belong to these accounts and then they were sold online. According to Hudson Rock, which is like an Israeli cybersecurity firm, there's like 300 at one point of these Italian Ministry of Interior email accounts available to buy. I mean, that is unbelievable. And how they weren't aware that these were even available in the first place. You know, they're not they're not scanning for these things, they're not looking out for these things, they're not aware that they've had like a breach, and just so brazen as well, just to get into the accounts and whenever an email came in, just deleting it immediately and then just continuing on.
SPEAKER_00I really want to hear from people in the comments section because there is a big part of me that that says at some point we have to have a real conversation about the data that we're handing over to banks and how it's been stored. And possibly there needs to be some type of third-party, hyper-secure method of storing our data. It's not stored with the banks, it's stored with an independent authority that's located on Mars, so it's in pr it so it cannot be accessed. I don't know, that sounds ridiculous. But I'd like to hear from people about this one because our KYC data, it's very valuable and it's very dangerous.
SPEAKER_00And I personally can relate to this, Jan, because I have been a victim of this as well. Right. I have an email from Revolut to tell me that Drive Wealth, the brokerage firm that I was essentially signed up to when I signed up for trading equities, US equities with Revolut, I think back in 2023, were breached. And that includes my name, my postal address, my occupation, my the aggregate value yan of my trading account. So hey, let's just say that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's the same thing. I know exactly. Imagine you if you were really wealthy, Johnny. I mean, I know for a fact you're not, um, but if you were just kidding, if you were really wealthy, um it's the same thing, right? Um now there's data about where you live somewhere available. What a disaster. Um it's it's yeah, someone with mean and ten could buy the data and uh yeah, harm the person. I mean it's an it's a data breach of equal um severity, weight. It's a data breach of equal severity.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you're right.
SPEAKER_00May may maybe though I I mean I'm gonna sleep fine tonight as a result of this, but I think these people with the crypto wealth, because of what's been going on in the in the in the crypto world, these wrench attacks, I think these people won't sleep as well at night. And they might have hardware wallets at home. Yes, you can see how much my equities account is worth, but that doesn't mean I have any value in my house at all. And again, Revolut's response to me, hey, we're not responsible. They basically just said, hey, this is a drive wealth issue, you've got to take it up with them. Interestingly though, Jan, I did ask them to write me an email.
SPEAKER_00And Revolut's chatbot, weirdly, does anyone have any experience with this? It kind of acts like ChatGPT. Probably it's powered by ChatGPT or Claude. Possibly, and it gave me an email address. It drafted an email for me to send to them, which by the way, they haven't replied yet. It's been a while. Uh, seven days, I'm still waiting. It requested whether my full or partial account numbers were included. And this is what's most interesting, Jan. Third point, what measures DriveWealth is offering affected customers, such as credit monitoring or identity protection services, and whether any compensation is available for costs I may incur.
SPEAKER_00So, this partner of Revolut, you know, DriveWealth, Revolut in itself are trying to throw them under the bus, aren't they? Yeah, it's a good way to phrase it. They are throwing them under the bus.
SPEAKER_01They picked them as a as a partner in the first place. So, in my opinion, at least from my perspective, um they're equally at fault here.
SPEAKER_00Why do they get to abscond responsibility? I I don't get that as well. Like, why are they not culpable? They they partnered with them.
SPEAKER_01Did you know about DriveWorth in the first place before before this data breach? You probably never heard it the name.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. Embarrassingly, no, I haven't been curious to hear from people in the comments if you were affected by this. But no one, no one had any idea who DriveWealth was. There's a terms, you know, of course, and it would have been clear to me if I'd have read the terms, I'm sure.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_00That's what I'm saying, Jan. Like, I I don't remember partnering with Drive Wealth or agreeing to this. I I I partnered with Revolut to help me trade stocks and shares, but they're not responsible.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's not right, Johnny. That's not right. And I think I have a feeling that these large corporations, they're not really prioritizing data safety as much as they should be, right? Especially nowadays where where data is so important. Um why are there not more severe fines? I believe the maximum fine they could be getting is 20 million euros, if I'm not wrong.
SPEAKER_00I think that might be the GDPR ceiling. Yeah, I think so. I think so. Right. Um, or 4% of total revenue. So for Revolution that yeah, it's 20 million euros.
SPEAKER_01Dent in a balance sheet. There's nothing, literally nothing.
SPEAKER_00I suppose there is a brand equity perspective here. Like, what is the damage to the brand? I know that doesn't really make a huge dent in any sort of cost because they're so significant. But do you think people are put off by this as a result? Like, get in the comments, let us know. Like, how does this make you feel about it? It's not like it's the first time this has happened to Revolut either. I wish it doesn't seem to make a difference, does it?
SPEAKER_01I wish this would repel people, but I don't think it's going to repel anyone. I think people will just forget about this, just as they have with any other data breach in the past. This is something that's occurring so regularly nowadays that it's it's not even making news. And I think if if we check on YouTube, I I'm not even sure if there are many other videos talking about this incident. Um, although it has been, I mean, it's been fascinating, right? So there's certainly something to report. You would think that there's a public interest in this. Um, I just found a few newspaper articles, but that's pretty much it.
SPEAKER_01And then then, like five days afterwards, after there was in the news, it was done, right? People forgot about it. Next topic. Some AI chatbot hacking, some other large corporation, you know, some some rogue AI um going crazy. It's just feels like this is data.
SPEAKER_00Until there is a victim, until there is a victim, Yan, and someone is harmed as a result of this, someone is kidnapped. You know, that's when it gets back into the news. But then again, at the same time, I don't I don't think Revolute are gonna come out and you know take responsibility for it. They've not taken responsibility at this point. Um, you know, they've they've confirmed something's happened.
SPEAKER_01Isn't it? I mean, it's it's kind of making me angry as well. It's not it's not the fact that they lose the data in the first place, it's the fact that they they react like that, you know, like they couldn't care less.
SPEAKER_00Ooh. Puts me off. Let's be real, it's something that they don't want to talk about. They want to talk about it as little as possible. They want to brush it under the carpet, and at the same time, you know, they want to roll out new products, new features. They don't want anything to stain or interrupt or get in the way of their rapid, fast growth, which is arguably potentially one of the reasons why this is happening in the first place. You know, there is certainly an argument for why we're allowing fintech or we're allowing any organization to act hard and fast, you know, with with our data as a you know, and while they grow as quickly as possible to maximize revenue and profit.
SPEAKER_00But at the same time, yeah, that this has all been going on, Jan, while they while they launch pay. I keep wanting to call it pay by smile, but it's not, is it? It's pay with smile, which I think is an awful name. I don't know what you make of this.
SPEAKER_01I think it's ridiculous, you know. Um definitely could have could have thought of a better name, but the timing, that's even more ridiculous. The timing is just, I mean, could not have imagined any worse timing that there's two data breaches in a month, and that's the same month they're launching this feature that lets you pay with your biometric data.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so we should explain what pay with smile is for those that aren't aware. If you went into, I think it was Kiss the Hippo, it's a coffee chain in London, there were three chains that were selected for this across a two-day period where they had a Revolute terminal where you pay and you could look at the terminal to process the payment. But I believe you had to scan a QR code to accept that you were gonna do the payment in the first place, choose it as an option, so it's quite convoluted. It might not be like that in the future, but for this one it was a bit convoluted, and then you would look into the terminal and pay. I don't believe it's like um using telemetry data or trying to um extract as much data about you as possible from your face.
SPEAKER_00The merchant doesn't store any of it either, Yan, it's gone immediately. Revolute will, however, I believe, according to the privacy policy, at least be storing that data. I guess some people would argue, mate, you know, this could, once they iron out a few things, could be a quicker way to pay for smaller purchases, just grab your coffee and go.
SPEAKER_01It feels kind of unnecessary to me personally. You know, I'm happy paying with my phone. It's it's never been something that uh I found disturbing at all. You know, you when you have an iPhone, you just press the power button twice, I believe, Apple Pay opens up, or the home button, sorry, it's a home button on the side. You press it, press it twice, Apple Pay opens up, you look into the camera, and then you consciously tap your card against the card reader, right? You make a a conscious decision to pay at that moment. I don't like the idea of having to look into a into a camera, potentially smile, and then pay that way.
SPEAKER_01You know, feels like there's there's something, yeah, not nothing conscious about that. You know, what if you accidentally look into the wrong direction? Oh, you've just paid. At least that's what I'm imagining from hearing this, these kind of details. It's it feels kind of kind of funny. Feels like something something useless I would not really want to use, feels like it comes out of a Black Mirror episode.
SPEAKER_00It really does. And I don't think it's really meant to be for the customer. I don't think they're trying to innovate anything. I mean, it might appear like that, it might be dressed up like that. Please again get in the comments. Let us know if you think this is useful. But I don't really see the use case for it, and I can tell what this is. This is just an opportunity for Revolut to capture more merchants. You know, it might make payments faster, but they can offer this as a 0% acquisition. So if a merchant uses this payment method, they won't charge, Revolut won't charge them a fee for the transaction.
SPEAKER_00Whereas, you know, if it's a card, for example, they might charge 1.5 or 2% per transaction. This will be free. So that'll get people to sign up for Revolut. That'll get people to pay the£350 plus VAT for their terminal to install it into their business, and then obviously Revolut can start to charge or or generate revenue from non-pay with smile transactions like cards, credit cards, etc. etc. So it's a it's a really clever way, Jan, to come up with something quite unique and innovative. So people talk about it, people like us, so like the sun reports on it, people go in there purposely just to use it, talk about it.
SPEAKER_00That gets people in the merchant, that gets people in the business, that'll attract people to getting this product, and as a result, Revolute get their terminal inside these companies so they can generate revenue from those checkout conversions. And this is so this is not for the customer.
SPEAKER_01So once they control the checkout, you you're suggesting that it would start implementing fees because it's then too difficult to switch back?
SPEAKER_00They they might not start implementing fees on pay with smile, but they will immediately have fees on any other transaction. Fair enough. Um pay with smile would be 0%, but they'll immediately so they they just use pay with smile as a quirky way to get merchants to to buy into this idea. Because it you you you you can see why it could arguably be convenient, I would say it's not. But it it it's it's a merchant acquisition play, not like a customer innovation play, is what I'm trying to say. I want to try to see an upside though. I I I think it feels dystopian, I think it feels weird, but let's talk about what it could be.
SPEAKER_00I mean, from a technical What was the upside here, Jan? Is there anything positive?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, from a technological perspective, I think it's quite fascinating that this is possible nowadays, right? Think back two decades or so. You know, if you would have told that someone in 2020 uh 2006, they would have thought you were crazy, honestly.
SPEAKER_00I I do agree that the technological innovation side of this is is is is fascinating and impressive. At the same time, it's creating more opportunities to gather data, which, again, we know now is far more valuable than the money in our wallets. So there's more value being put on this data. The more data that's collected, the more that's accessible, the more hackers can try to get hold of. It creates more and more risk for further data breaches. You know, if I'm paying with SMALE every time, I'm constantly sharing an updated selfie video of myself.
SPEAKER_00So no longer is it the old dated one from like five years ago when I was a little less grey and a little less wrinkly. You get the latest image that you could then use if you were a nefarious actor to, if you are able to get hold of it at least, open an account, mimicking me, or maybe even work it out how you could use it to gain access to an account. I don't know. The bigger picture here for me is Jan that this innovation creates more value or it makes this KYC data, this data that we share with these banks, more valuable, more compelling, and this underbelly economy that goes on in the world of criminal organization just gets more opportunities to steal more things.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I wish people were more conscious about when they hand data over to large corporations. I wish they were more conscious about it, maybe um a bit skeptical, you know, here and there. And it's just unfortunate. Because data breaches nowadays, they're part of day-to-day lives, unfortunately. Um, and this, you know, might not change anytime soon, given how fast AI is developing. I don't think this will change anytime soon. I think this might even become more common, right? Because with the help of AI, you know, actual hacks could happen.
SPEAKER_01Um, and more actual hacks could happen. It's it's much easier to hack something, I assume. Yeah, be skeptical when you when you hand over your data, you know, be be cautious about it.
SPEAKER_00Skepticism is important, Jan. But what were you supposed to do if you just wanted to use Revolute to trade crypto?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, can't do much.
SPEAKER_00Like it could have happened to any platform. We should be in you know, should we should mention that, of course. You know, this can happen anywhere and it happens all the time. But you know, you you just basically, I think we're all just better off offline, aren't we? Just not using the internet, because essentially, like, you know, you your data is necessary to gain access to most things, most things are gated. And you know, what are you supposed to do?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, what are you gonna do?
SPEAKER_00Get in the comments, let us know your thoughts. Come join the Discord, we'll stick a QR code on the screen now if you want to come and further the conversation.
SPEAKER_01I'd like to ask you, Johnny, are you intending to inform the Discord community as soon as a drivework response comes in? Is that where they will they will learn about it?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah. I'll keep everyone up to date on Discord. Yeah, that's a good point. I haven't had a response yet. I ha they have to respond, right, at some point, I would expect so. Otherwise I'll contact Revolute again and see what they have to say. Hopefully. Or I should say what the the the chat bot has to say.
SPEAKER_01Try to escalate that a bit.
SPEAKER_00Okay, thanks everyone. We'll see you in the next one.
Amex Platinum is cutting lounge visits but still charging the same fee, so is it still worth it? Jonny and Jan break down what’s changing, then build cheaper stacks that cover lounges, travel insurance and everyday...
Jonny and Jan rank the ten best UK credit cards that pay you in points, covering Avios, Virgin Points, Amex Membership Rewards, Nectar and more. Every card is scored on the same model: £1,000 a month of spending over...
Trading 212 is ending its card cashback on 3 December, and Jan and I dig into why, what the card is still good for, and which UK and EU alternatives are actually worth switching to. Why Trading 212 pulled it: what the...
In this episode, we run through the best UK savings rates for November 2026. What we cover: • The Budget - tax on savings interest outside an ISA rises by four percentage points from April 2027, and the Cash ISA cut is...
In this episode, Jonny and Jan ask whether you should ever take out a personal loan. We checked 22 UK lenders and found advertised rates that only just over half of borrowers have to get, price lists that reward...