In this episode we rank the four worst bank accounts in the UK - accounts marketed at people who think a high street bank won't take them, then quietly charged for almost everything. We break down CardOneMoney, Monese, Pockit and Suits Me, from £1.49 just to receive your wages to a £5 fee that only fires when your account is empty. Then we get to the part almost nobody knows: everything these accounts charge for, you're legally entitled to for free. Why "no monthly fee" is doing a lot of heavy lifting - and which accounts cost more the less money you have The £5 penalty for a bounced direct debit, the 4% foreign spending fee, and the £1-a-month charge for doing nothing Who these accounts are really aimed at, and why the fee structure targets people at their most desperate The fee-free basic bank account nine major UK banks must offer you by law - even with bad credit or no proof of address How to open one (and what to do if you've already been refused) Join the new Banking Without Borders Discord community https://link.bankingwithoutborders.co.uk/discord Subscribe on YouTube https://link.technicallymoney.com/oy8e Check out our website DepositScout.com for the latest savings rates. Connect with us (via LinkedIn) Jan: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jan-watermann/ Jonny: http://www.linkedin.com/in/jonny-pease Got a question or topic you want us to cover? Drop us a message at jonny@technicallymoney.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Okay, welcome back to another episode of Banking Without Borders. So, how does a fee of£1.49 sound to receive your own wages? Or a 2% fee to take your own money out of a cash machine and no that's not abroad? Or my personal favourite, 50 pence to check your own balance. These are real fees on real UK accounts, and today we're gonna rank the four worst offenders. But there's something quite unsettling that they all share in common. These accounts are marketed at people who think a normal bank won't take them. So they come with no credit checks, no proof of address requirements, and you can sign up in minutes.
SPEAKER_01They are basically pitching accessibility for people who can't get an account. But there's a price for that inclusion. You get charged to be paid, you get charged to pay a bill. One of them even takes a percentage of your money every time it leaves the account. So basically, they the less you have, the bigger slice they take. And here's the part that genuinely got us to make this episode. Most people using these accounts think that this is their only option. This is all they have. But it isn't. Everything these providers are charging for, you are entitled to for free by law.
SPEAKER_01The nine biggest banking groups in the country have to offer it. And bad credit cannot be used to turn you away. So stay to the end because we're going to show you exactly how to use this. But before we get there, Yan, four accounts, ranks least bad to genuinely staggering. Where do we even begin?
SPEAKER_00Let's start with Card One Money, Johnny, which is arguably the least bad of these four, um, which is quite fascinating because the only one with a monthly fee of£12.50, but at least everything is straightforward. They're selling uh transparency here, which you know is definitely a good thing if you compare that to all of these hidden charges these other accounts have. Doesn't mean it's cheap though. To close your account, and that's my personal favorite, um, to close your account, they charge 10 pounds, um, which to be fair, um only occurs if there's still a balance on the account.
SPEAKER_00But now imagine you don't know of this charge. You want to close your account because you're fed up with all of these other fees, which I'm gonna talk about very shortly. Um, they'll they'll be deducting 10 pounds off your balance uh just to refund you your money. I think that's that's harsh, that's just not right. Um, and then have an additional card holder that's also a very fascinating charge. They charge five pounds for that every single month, right? That's 60 pounds a year on top of the 12 pounds fifty that you're already paying on a as a monthly fee. Um, absolutely fascinating.
SPEAKER_00Um, it's not all bad though.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00A few of these other fees are somewhat reasonable, in my opinion. Um, receiving money from the UK is free. Who would have thought? Um it's free here, and that's also one of the reasons why this account is uh is not ranked worse, because all of these other providers do charge for this to withdraw money from a UK ATM costs£1.50. Um to withdraw money abroad is expensive,£3 plus 2.75% on top of that. That is no surprise though, because all of these accounts are terrible travel cards.
SPEAKER_00So if you're thinking about using them abroad, uh better don't. Just don't think about that. Direct debits are free, it's in that's included. Standing orders as well. And um yeah, I think it's fair, somewhat fair. Why is it fair? Because it doesn't charge you to receive money. Um, that's at least somewhat good. This is an account. If I look at the website, it's targeted towards people who have been, yeah, who've had bad financial experiences in the past. Let's call it like that. You know, they might have bad credit, they might get refused by other accounts, but um, yeah.
SPEAKER_00It's it's it's even more fascinating that the only account with a base fee um targets the people who probably have the least amount of money available, isn't it, Johnny?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the the highlight of their website is that this is a banking alternative that leaves no one behind. Or at least you're gonna be left behind if you don't have£12.50 to pay the base fee. I mean, come on, like you are leaving people behind immediately when you have a base fee. It's a significant amount of money as well, Jan. Let's have a look at comparatively to like a Monzo or a Revolu account that's rich with features and products that's less than£12.50. This is a fee for apparent accessibility or inclusion or opportunity to get a banking account, which I think to many people is a desperate moment when you don't have a bank account.
SPEAKER_01Possibly you've been debanked or you're trying to get one for the first time, but you're struggling. That is a desperate time for many people, and they're putting a fee or they're taking advantage of that desperation by charging£12.50 and then pretending that they don't leave anyone behind. It ruffles my feathers. I'm trying to play devil's advocate like we always do, to have a balanced opinion, Jan. I'm looking at this website, card won money, but I'm I'm seeing nothing very good, to be honest. Have you got anything positive to say about this lot?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, like really positive? Not really, to be honest, Johnny. But the the the things I've mentioned that were included, like receiving money, like direct debits, like standing orders, that's somewhat positive, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01But as we'll but yeah, but as yeah, but somewhat, mate. But as we're gonna get to, we're gonna discover later in the episode that those things are free. Those things aren't£12.50. So are they truly positive, or is it like trying to polish a turd?
SPEAKER_00In relation to these four providers that we're comparing here today, I think this is positive. Obviously, if you compare it to the rest of the market, it's um I mean should should be taken. We should take that for granted that this is included because there are many free accounts that provide this free of charge, um, plus several other features. Um, but yeah, in relation, this is rather good. It's not the worst one. Um, there's one that's that's fascinatingly worse.
SPEAKER_01Yes, this next one is quite surprising. I think those that may have followed the channel for a while now, back when we were called Monito, you would have heard, at least you would have heard me talk about this provider. Jan, you've probably written about this provider. Monies, or I think I've called them Monis previously, started by a Romanian gentleman who had the experience of coming across to the UK and struggling to open a bank account. He lived the problem that he was going to solve through Monies. This account, the philosophy is it's built for someone that may have arrived in Britain with a foreign passport, no credit file, no proof of address, and they can have a working account in minutes.
SPEAKER_01That still holds with this account, Jan, but the fee structure is despicable? Maybe that's a bit harsh. I don't know. Would you what word would you use to describe their fee structure?
SPEAKER_00Ridiculous, Johnny. Ridiculous, which is quite sad because initially when this account first launched, I found it quite promising. I believe um I also signed up for it like many, many years ago. Um was rather satisfied, actually. I think it was was quite fine. Um, but now it just it just yeah, it's terrible. Let's start with uh uh yeah, my my favorite bad aspects about this account, um, paying in cash, 3.5% and a minimum of three pounds. So every time just imagine, like you you arrive in the UK, you know, you might might engage in the yeah informal economy or in other ways, just just trying to survive, you know, getting paid in cash.
SPEAKER_00Want to deposit that into your account, you know. Getting paid in cash, by the way, doesn't mean it needs to be illegal. You can also get paid in cash with a legal business, but you're trying to deposit that into this account 3.5% you take off that. Ooh. Yep. Fascinatingly bad.
SPEAKER_01That is, that is, and we're gonna talk a bit more about paying cash fees with the other providers, and we'll use this example throughout. But if we recall, Revolute used to have cash deposits, yeah, and they were charging 1.5%. That was the one. I think we made fun of that, Johnny. Yeah, we did, mate, we did. I think the first£100 was free, which I recall saying I feel like it should be the first thousand if you want to be fair. But I appreciate that there is a cost to using paypoint, for example, because there is a human interaction, typically, I believe. Um, so there is a cost to this, but it's not 3.5% or a minimum of three pounds.
SPEAKER_01It's just not. It's just not. It's profiteering. I appreciate we live in a capitalistic market or economy, people are out to make money, businesses should make money. I get that. On the back of customers that don't have very much money, and your ethos is about opportunity and inclusion. You know, these aren't wealthy clientele, this isn't a wealthy client base that monies have, I imagine, Yan. But still, these fees certainly look like they have money. I mean, let's talk about let's talk about the litany of fees.
SPEAKER_01I mean, this is an international account essentially, it's for an international user, but receiving money costs from abroad. Correct me if I'm wrong, Jan, because I struggle to get my head around the fee structure here, but I'm looking at£10 a year for an annual subscription alone just to receive money. That is right. And 2% per transfer. So an international product is charging a£10 fee to be international. Um a recurring fee. Uh there's a weekend currency surcharge as well.
SPEAKER_01Hello, Revolute. You're not the only one doing this. And I get that, because you know, currency markets, they're volatile and they'd have to hedge because they're not open during the weekend. But this is not a good fee structure. And again, it just highlights this opportunity that they are taking to take advantage of their clientele under the guise of being inclusive. Jan, what is your take on the future of monies? Because realistically, if we look at the history of monies in 2022, they were bought, they were HSBC essentially propped them up with$35 million.
SPEAKER_01That then fell through and they were bought out. With a fee structure like this, mate, do you do you see any future in this business model?
SPEAKER_00No, I think the main problem is that people who sign up for monies think they have no other choice. That's why they are willing to accept such bad fees, and then as soon as they, you know, maybe have improved their opportunities slightly by getting a better form of identification, for example, or proof of address, they would obviously switch ahead to the uh switch to the next next best bank. You know, any bank available in the UK offers better fees than this. So if you can access a regular bank account, you just go ahead and sign up for one.
SPEAKER_00You don't have to stick with monies. And I think that's their core problem. And honestly, that's not sustainable if you think about it. Um to be fair, they have some some paid tiers available, Johnny, that do drop the fees a little bit, but um here we're looking at the the base tier of each of these providers, and yeah, they're just terrible. And hey, uh, you didn't mention the one pound inactivity fee at the course of the money. I was just about to get to that because I was gonna say inactivity fee.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was gonna say to counter your comment about how that you know people will just leave as soon as they have the ability to open a bank account uh with a say one of the high street banks. Well, don't worry, monies are hedging against that because they're hoping people will go inactive and they can then charge one pound a month if you stop using their account. What are we charging for here? What are you charging people for? You know, just to hold an account on your books? Arguably that's an opportunity to market. They're still in your funnel. You know, you can still try to return that customer with r some sort of offer.
SPEAKER_01Let them pay in cash for free. I don't know, but there's opportunity there. They haven't gone forever, but still they have the audacity to charge a one-pound fee. This, to me, without hanging on this for too long, Yang, strikes me as a company that is on the cliff edge.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it seems like it.
SPEAKER_01This is not a sustainable fee model, it's not competitive.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, the fee model is yeah, extraordinarily bad. But it's not to worse in this comparison. It definitely isn't. Monise is owned by Pocket. Pocket does have a fascinatingly worse fee model, and you you think you read through the Monise's fee model, you think it can't get any worse, you're wrong. Um, it can definitely get worse. Let's start with receiving money in the UK. That costs£1.49, which is how much is that? 50-50 pence more than what Moniz was charging. Direct debits are£1.49 each. ATM withdrawals within the UK cost two pounds, at least a flat fee.
SPEAKER_00And now it comes card spending abroad, 4%.
SPEAKER_01Oh. £4? I don't think I've ever heard a 4% fixed fee. No. Wow, that's a new number.
SPEAKER_00That's definitely the highest here.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's diabolical.
SPEAKER_00Hey, it gets worse though. Go on, go on, go on. If you decide to withdraw cash while abroad, you pay these 4% plus£2.25 as a fixed fee. Plus whatever the ATM provider is charging. So now imagine you withdraw money in Thailand. Maybe you're a um a Thai migrant who gave everything up in Thailand, moved to the UK, now just, you know, earned, saved up funds to travel back to his family, visit them. You have to take out money from an ATM. I know this is a very fictional scenario, but it could be. And I'm just bringing up that scenario because I know the ATM fee in Thailand is fixed at 220 baht per withdrawal, then you're paying these 220 baht, which is in today's money, probably£5.50 or so, something like that.
SPEAKER_00And on top of that,£2.25 for pocket, and then 4% of whatever you're withdrawing.
SPEAKER_01Whew. What shocks me here, and people may have picked up on this, the fees are fixed. These fees are entirely fixed, and they are layered on top of ordinary banking activities. Withdrawing money, direct debits, receiving money, spending money abroad. These fees, you know, would just be would never exist in a normal bank account. In a regular high street bank, it just doesn't exist because they they wouldn't they wouldn't get away with that type of behavior.
SPEAKER_01But if you were new to the UK, perhaps English isn't your first language, perhaps you would get a little bit caught up in the terms and conditions or the plans. You might not understand it, you might not understand how it works here. Based on where you're coming from, these things might, there might be a fixed fee on these things, Jan. I I don't know. But this feels quite this is like trickery.
SPEAKER_00It's very, very fascinatingly bad.
SPEAKER_01Early wage access at£1.49 is an interesting offer. I suppose you are being loaned money. Yeah. So charging a fee for that's somewhat justified. And I I know there's plenty of other providers that offer the product, but most of the time it's free, right? Most of the time this is a free product.
SPEAKER_00I think I think so.
SPEAKER_01Pocket's founder, Jan, has described their target market as the bottom half of UK adults. 20 to 22 million people is their sort of target audience. That's his framing. Um it's not a very nice way to state that um socio economic uh population of the United Kingdom, bottom to call them the bottom half. But he's essentially saying, I think, at least, that they are targeting poor people. People that aren't very well off. So we're we're targeting poor people.
SPEAKER_00And those are paying the highest fees.
SPEAKER_01For those that are listening, uh I apologize, but I'm gonna show up for those that are watching some visuals of their website, and I'll try to describe them. But you've got a lot of visuals of the same woman. I think she's real, she may be AI generated. She looks extremely happy. She's holding a phone, she's holding a card. It's the most staged photo shoot in in the history of the world.
SPEAKER_00She hasn't seen the fee schedule, Johnny. I can I'm I'm sure. She hasn't.
SPEAKER_01There's no way. Uh they've got some cashback offers. Is it worth mentioning? You can get up to 5% on top brands, 1% cash back on all other spending and direct debits. Maybe that's a way to offset the cost of the plans. Just trying. I mean, we always try to be balanced on this show. How can you be balanced reading these fees? Let's look at their trust pilot. 24,000 reviews from put 4.3 stars. So some people are satisfied. What does that tell you? That either tells you that maybe a proportion of those people don't know how this works, and they are satisfied because the alternative might not be that good anyway.
SPEAKER_01Um, there are some credit building opportunities here. You know, what's the general consensus? The user experience, payment, customer service are all quite good at pocket. It does worry me when you see this kind of positivity and you see those types of fees, Jan. Can someone explain to me if, you know, do they not correlate necessarily and why is that? You know, high fees doesn't necessarily impact a trust pilot score, because if the service is good, then that's okay. But I would argue that this service can't be any better than a free account, so you can't really justify the fees.
SPEAKER_01Maybe someone with experience of pocket is watching this right now and could jump in. And I'd say the same for any of the other accounts that we've talked about thus far.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, Johnny, let's talk about one provider that's even worse, in my opinion at least. That suits me. Suits me. Looking at the fee schedule, get the assumption that it only suits them. Outgoing bank transfers, fascinatingly expensive, Johnny. Fascinatingly expensive. They charge 2.5% of whatever you're trying to transfer out. But it's kept at four pounds at least. Oh, just imagine. Like you're trying trying to initiate a transfer, trying to get money out of the account, they're charging you for it. Wow. So the only way to get rid of it essentially is prending it with your card.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01Oh god. Okay, so you can open the account in three minutes with no minimum deposits, but rewards as standard. What is this marketing jumbo? So it it's saying that the account rewards you as standard. Right, okay. Let's see. Where are these rewards then? What are these rewards, Jan? The rewards are, oh, okay, they reward you with a five-pound fee if you don't pay a direct debit. I thought we'd got past direct debit fees, but we we apparently have.
SPEAKER_00Let me let me just interject here. That's for every try. So you know sometimes when you cannot pay a direct debit. I've had that happen actually in the past because I forgot to update my banking details and the account was empty, that was tried to be charged. Um so when when you uh when when they uh when when when you can't pay it, when you can't pay it, they try multiple times. So every single try is being charged at five pounds. They make that clear in their fee schedule. Um that's fascinating. Now imagine the provider trying three or four times, and that's when you you notice it. Wow, you might owe them for 20 pounds.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, why couldn't you pay your direct debit? Maybe you just don't have enough money. You know, maybe you just skin so you're being charged a five pound fee for being broke. When you're arguably at your most vulnerable financially, um you're probably financially vulnerable before. That's why you signed up for Suits Me in the first place, because their philosophy is that it's built specifically for migrant workers. So there's no credit check. Again, I said this already with the other accounts, there's no proof of address needed. You know, they publish this website in 14 languages.
SPEAKER_01So what does that tell you? It tells you that they are just spreading an extremely wide net to capture as many foreigners or or people that are foreign to the UK as possible. And any money moving through your account, it looks like they're taking a percentage for it. Balance inquiry, 50 pence card spending abroad, 3.47%. What are these figures? 3.47% for spending abroad plus£1.97. Where are these numbers coming from?
SPEAKER_00From their website.
SPEAKER_01You know, yeah, from their website. Someone's spitting them out in the accounting accounting department. Paying in cash. Okay, this one got me as well. Paying in cash. Again, I said I'd return to this. They want two pounds plus 1.5% to pay in cash at pay point. That is expensive. Every time you're getting, say, your salary paid in cash because perhaps you're working a car wash, perhaps you're you're younger and you're, I don't know, mowing lawns, doing landscaping, uh, getting cash from customers.
SPEAKER_01You are getting a two pound plus or plus 1.5% fee every time. What bothers me the most about this is that people in this position are typically at their most desperate and they may think that this is their only option. And is it time, Yan, to maybe talk about the fact that this isn't their only option? And the UK mandates that the biggest banks have to give people, have to provide people accessibility to a current account, albeit basic.
SPEAKER_00I think now is a good time to move on, Johnny. Let's talk about that.
SPEAKER_01Under the payment accounts regulation of 2015, we have the likes of Barclays, the Cooperative, HSBC, Lloyd's Banking, Santander, TSB, Virgin. These are apparently nine of the largest, biggest nine of the largest banks in the UK, but you know, Monzo should probably be on this list as well. They have to provide you with a current account. And that's where you can have your wages or your benefits paid into. You can get cash in and out at a branch, you know, you can use the post office, direct debits and standing orders must exist, a debit card, online and mobile banking, everything you would expect.
SPEAKER_01Now, you should be able to open one of these accounts with no credit or poor credit. But I do wonder, Jan, maybe you can confirm this. A legal resident of the UK can open one of these. But can you confirm if someone who's come to the UK and isn't fully into the system yet?
SPEAKER_00Well, not necessarily. So the FCA um is quite broad with the criteria they apply here, but they do say um that they have to make it easy and have to be flexible with the terms of identification that they accept. So there could be um, and I assume that official certificates, maybe a birth certificate that you bring with you, um, certain state letters, could be a letter from the job center, um, from the uh financial institutions, could be um maybe confirmation letter from a homeless shelter, potentially, you know, whatever whatever you have available.
SPEAKER_00I'll say bring that to the bank, mention the situation that you're in, and then you should be able to to get this account opened. And if you don't with one bank, try with all of the eight others before you choose one of the options that we just discussed.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well that's it. That's what I was about to say. This is genuinely one of the harder requirements, isn't it? Just proving who you are so you can get past anti-money laundering checks. A bank as well is compelled to give you an answer within 10 days. So there might be a period of time where you could still be unbanked, shall we say, which is, I think, important to say that one of these providers that we've mentioned today could fill that void.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, they're relatively fast, I think. Um suits me as an example. They do mention all kinds of ID forms that they accept on the website. Um it's a complete list. I would assume that these forms of identification are also accepted within a within a legacy bank. I would assume that. Um, but they do take much longer to decide whether they want to accept your application or not. But you know, that doesn't prevent you from from just applying with several different entities and just taking whatever uh the account that that gets approved.
SPEAKER_00You know, just take that instead. Um, but in the meantime, maybe if you need an account within these first 10 days, maybe then suits me as a good option, or one of these other providers, but just don't stick with them for a long term. It's it's not worth it at all. And um, there's so yeah, way better options out there. This base account or basic account that's available to everyone within the UK, even my asylum seekers, right? Um, not just settled residents. Um good good alternative.
SPEAKER_01So do let us know what you think of any of the accounts we've talked about. Do you have any experience using them? And also which of their fees were most shocking to you? I don't know, Jan, if people will find it that shocking that there is a fee attached to depositing cash, for example, because cash is becoming somewhat redundant. And as a result of like the opposite of economies of scale, right? It's gonna get more and more expensive to pay in cash the less people do it. So that's a fee I could necessarily accept, but when it comes to fees like closing accounts or an activity fee, or five pounds if a direct debit is missed, I have a real hard time accepting that.
SPEAKER_01And Jan, I wanted to ask you a question. As someone who's lived an expat migrant life, do you have some do you relate to this kind of desperation in any way to open an account? Because you've moved internationally, surely, and you've been unbanked for a period of time. Can you relate to why some people would accept paying these types of fees?
SPEAKER_00I've not been unbanked, Johnny. Let's make that clear. But I do kind of relate to um to this situation. I understand why it can happen. Um, I think the main problem is people losing access to accounts before they get to open another one. Um, and that's exactly the situation you don't want to be in. So um, if there's that's a risk that could potentially happen to you, just make sure to to have at least two or three different accounts available before uh you move abroad or so. Um, and then also, you know, I know it's not right, but let's say you're planning to move abroad, you're planning to move to a different country.
SPEAKER_00Move there first, then open up a local bank account, and then go ahead and potentially update the address with your old bank accounts. Don't do that beforehand because else there might be a period where you don't have access to any bank account and you see that's that's not right, and then there are different institutions potentially trying to take advantage from for of you. Um so don't let that happen at all. Yeah, try to be clever about it, plan ahead, and I think that's all I can say about this.
SPEAKER_01If you do have questions about this, if this is something that's actually bothering you, jump in our Discord. I'll put a QR code up on the screen, I'll put a link in the description box and message us, reach out to Jan, reach out to me. You can reach out to anyone in the server. We've got over a hundred founding members now, and lots of people are living an international lifestyle using various accounts with multi-currency capabilities, possibly accounts that are easier to access because they have various passports and live in different regions of the world. So, this is definitely something that I think, Jan, a lot of people on our Discord server could help those in need or those seeking advice around the idea of trying to find more inclusive, accessible bank accounts.
SPEAKER_01Everybody, thank you for watching. Thank you for listening. Please do consider subscribing to the YouTube channel. I'll put a link in the description box below. And as always, if you've enjoyed the show, give the video a like, rate us on Apple Podcasts, rate us on Spotify, however you get your podcast, we'd really appreciate it. Five stars. And we'll see you in the next episode.
Amex Platinum is cutting lounge visits but still charging the same fee, so is it still worth it? Jonny and Jan break down what’s changing, then build cheaper stacks that cover lounges, travel insurance and everyday...
Jonny and Jan rank the ten best UK credit cards that pay you in points, covering Avios, Virgin Points, Amex Membership Rewards, Nectar and more. Every card is scored on the same model: £1,000 a month of spending over...
Trading 212 is ending its card cashback on 3 December, and Jan and I dig into why, what the card is still good for, and which UK and EU alternatives are actually worth switching to. Why Trading 212 pulled it: what the...
In this episode, we run through the best UK savings rates for November 2026. What we cover: • The Budget - tax on savings interest outside an ISA rises by four percentage points from April 2027, and the Cash ISA cut is...
In this episode, Jonny and Jan ask whether you should ever take out a personal loan. We checked 22 UK lenders and found advertised rates that only just over half of borrowers have to get, price lists that reward...