Cash ISAs Explained: eToro, XTB, Bonus Rate Traps & How to Pick the Right One
15 minAudio
It's a new financial year, which means a fresh £20,000 ISA allowance - and a market that looks more competitive than ever. But several of the headline rates are not quite what they seem. In this episode: • Why eToro's 4.78% works differently to a standard Cash ISA • What XTB's 6% actually means over 12 months • The bonus rate traps - and which accounts drop by up to 2% after year one • Flexible vs non-flexible ISAs explained clearly • How ISA transfers work - and the one mistake that kills your tax-free wrapper Rates sourced from DepositScout.com - check the link for the latest figures before you act. Join the new Banking Without Borders Discord community https://link.bankingwithoutborders.co.uk/discord Subscribe on YouTube https://link.technicallymoney.com/oy8e Check out our website DepositScout.com for the latest savings rates. Connect with us (via LinkedIn) Jan: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jan-watermann/ Jonny: http://www.linkedin.com/in/jonny-pease Got a question or topic you want us to cover? Drop us a message at jonny@technicallymoney.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Okay, welcome back to another episode of Banking Without Borders. So today we're going to do a full Cash ICE deep dive, dedicating the whole episode to ICEs for the tax year 2026-27. And rates are so competitive right now. But there's also some headline numbers that I think look better than they actually are, especially when you read the small print. So we want to make sure that you know the differences and the details before moving your money. And we're going to cover the best easy access cash ICEs, the best fix rates, how transfers actually work, and we'll spend some proper time on two accounts, eToro and XTB, because these are generating a lot of attention right now.
SPEAKER_01All the rates we discuss in this episode are correct as of today, April the 13th. And if you want the latest, most up-to-date numbers, head to depositscout.com, just filter for Cash ISA, and everything is right there. So yeah, some of the ICEs that we're going to talk about today are flexible and some are non-flexible. So should we begin with just clarifying what that means?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, Johnny, so the difference is really simple. A non-flexible ISA would consume your allowance if you withdraw money from it. Um let's say you put 20,000 pounds in, take 5,000 pounds out. Uh you cannot put that 5,000 pounds back uh in the same tax year and uh benefit from that allowance. And a flexible ISA doesn't have that restriction. You know, it's flexible, it can move money in and out. Uh, you'll keep your 20,000 pound allowance.
SPEAKER_01The headline rate is flexible, and that's eToro at 4.78%. Now this works differently to a typical cash Icer, and I'll get into the nuances shortly. But there's also another rate on our table, which is 6%. That's XTB. And I know a lot of people have mentioned this to us in the comment section. It's a very popular headline rate at the moment, but we haven't put it at the top, and for a special reason, which I'll discuss with you shortly. But first, eToro. Now, this is very interesting because it works differently to a normal cash ICE. With a cash ICE, the bank is essentially paying you. You deposit money, they lend it out at a higher rate and pass a slice of that back to you as interest.
SPEAKER_01It's just pretty simple. With eToro, your money is actually invested into a qualifying money market fund. Now think of this like a very boring, very cautious investment fund that gets lent out to governments or to large financial institutions on extremely short term. So I'm talking days, maybe weeks, but not years. And now those borrowers, so those governments, for example, they have to pay a return. And that return on that loan is passed back to you. These track the Bank of England base rate. So in practice, they behave a lot like interest, but technically you're receiving investment returns rather than bank interest.
SPEAKER_01And I think, Jan, for most people, this distinction doesn't really matter at all. Um, these funds are tightly regulated and the risk is genuinely very low. And the the difference is only really in how deposit protection works or FSCS protection works, I should say. Because with a bank, when you're depositing money into a bank account, you're treated as a depositor and you get£120,000 protection. With eToro, you're treated as an investor. So you receive just£85,000. I think that one catches people out. It's not going to be hugely impactful because a cash ICER is, of course, limited to 20k.
SPEAKER_01Now, the 4.78% rate, Yan, this is quite interesting. There are essentially two layers to this. One is the underlying rate of roughly 3.75%, and also a eToro bonus, which they've added on top as a promotional offer. Now, what's important to know with that bonus rate of roughly 1%, that could change at any point. And I think that's the real rate risk here, Jan. It's worth saying that this is just like any in in in some ways, any bank product, right? It's variable. Those rates can change at any point. And um so could this eToro rate. And also, I should probably mention, Jan, the last thing to flag, I promise I'll stop talking.
SPEAKER_01This is essentially a marketing funnel, right, buddy? They are trying to push people into their investment app because this is an investment platform. And this Cash ISA exists inside this investment platform app. I went through the process of signing up, Jan. It was a really interesting sign-up flow. For those that are watching, I'll pop it on the screen. There are questions around what sort of investments do you want to do. I think I had to I think I had to fill out our W8 hyphen B E N form, I believe they're called, the tax treaty form here in the UK with the US. Um, and that's typically something you fill out when you're signing up for investing. I think what you've got to be careful is when you go through this process is A, getting frightened because you you feel like you're going down the road of investing.
SPEAKER_01Well, you're not, you're just signing up for e-Toro and eventually you can find the option for cash ISA. And two, don't make the mistake that I've seen some people make, Jan, where they're signing up for stocks and shares ISAs accidentally instead of cash ICEs. So if you're signing up for your cash ISA and you see like crypto or trading or CFD options, you probably are amongst stocks and shares. So just double check where you are and where you land and make sure that you're you're signing up for the cash ISA. And of course, I think Jan, you say this all the time. You just got to be wary that you don't end up investing all of your money, right?
SPEAKER_01Because you're on this investment platform.
SPEAKER_00Exactly, Johnny. And that's where the risk is. You know what I find fascinating personally? Um if you look at this table of the top rate, the top three, we know already those are investment platforms.
unknownYes.
SPEAKER_00Quite surprising that they have flexible allowances, right? Yeah. So it's it's in their interest, it's in their interest that users put money there, you know, let's say they deposit the 20,000 pounds thinking they will accumulate some savings and then it works really well, right? They might get the taste of it and then start using these other investment products that these platforms obviously have to offer. And that's the whole point of why they're offering that in the first place. And you don't have that with normal, uh, normal bank institutions. These are typically non-flexible because they they want the money to be to be kept, right, in the account.
SPEAKER_00They don't want you to to move move it there and then move it away once you get a better rate.
SPEAKER_01And that's what we've got at the top. Trading 212 at 4.62%. That's a tracker rate which moves with the Bank of England and it has a bonus of 1.08%. Then eToro at 4.78%. That's a triple access. So that rate I've just been talking about. Take money out more than three times. And if you do, the rate will drop to 3.48%. I think that's fine for most people, but it's worth knowing. And then XTB, that trading platformer. Six percent. But that six percent will only last for 90 days because it's a 2% bonus. But it is worth knowing about this account, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I'll go into a little bit of a detail now because I think this is important because there are a couple of nuances. So after 90 days, important to note that rate will drop to 4%. And if you do the mass across a full year, you're looking at a blended rate of 4.5%, which is still very competitive, but that's a long way from the headline of 6%. XDB is also for new customers only, and you need to open the account before the 30th of April 2026 to qualify for the boost. So that window is closing. Structurally, though, this is closer to a traditional cash ice than something like eToro because your money sits in segregated accounts at class one or tier one banks.
SPEAKER_01I should say, if you're wondering what a tier one bank is. Think Santander, Unicredit, um, pretty safe financial institutions where in theory your money would be held and be safe. And as a result, you also get FSCS protection up to 120,000. What I think is happening here, Jan, XTB is passing on the interest that they're earning from the deposits inside those bank accounts. And I think they're passing that on to the user. And I think the promotional rate of 2% is a cost that they're absorbing to use as a marketing vehicle.
SPEAKER_01Neither Jan and I have this account. I did sign up for eToro. I haven't signed up for XTB, so I'd love to hear from anyone that has if you can share any insight into how it works. Neither one of us are big fans of the marketing around this. I do think that it's quite clearly a vehicle to push people into investing. And that's fine. That's fine. But as Jan mentioned, you've got to be cautious about this. But do please share with us if you have any insight or any any feedback of XDB.
SPEAKER_00I'd like to add a note here, Johnny, as well. Uh looking at their website, I get mixed feelings, you know. You have Slatan Ibrahimovic holding a um a trading app into the camera. Um it's it it all feels a little sketchy to me, you know. And you have all these all these sports athletes, you know, these uh, you know, um professional athletes that are world famous, obviously, and they're just uh a way they're trying to win trust. Um and it's I think it's for me, this causes the exact opposite, to be honest. But maybe I'm too rational for this.
SPEAKER_01Something that I think might put people off as well is that they don't offer transfers in. I think they have a stocks and shares ISO which you can transfer into, but the cash ISE you cannot transfer into. If a trading platform puts you off, we have other options available for you. Plum are offering 4.61% with a pretty hefty bonus for 12 months. We'll talk about that in a moment. Tembo are offering 4.3%. They don't offer transfers in, which might put people off. Um, and that rate does drop down as well as a result of a bonus. Moneybox are offering 4.3% with up to three withdrawals per year.
SPEAKER_01That is a 0.85% bonus. Hargreaves Lansdown, another trading platform. Apologies. I said that that was done. Uh, 4.26%. If you open the stocks and shares ICER, I believe, Yan, you can get up to 4,000 pound cash back. Is that right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a current promotion, so that can be insanely attractive. And that would be a very large deposit, I imagine. That's not going to be 20k.
SPEAKER_01Then Atom have an easy access ISA, 4.25%. You don't get transfers in with this one, but I do like it, Yan, because it's just very simple. There's no catches, nothing really to flag on that one. Um, but that's from Atom. Just quickly want to talk about bonus rates, Yan, if that's okay, because I think this does catch people out. These are obviously artificially boosted rates that usually fall within, you know, after 12 months. And, you know, the industry uh counting on people not realizing that the rate has fallen and then locking in and keeping your money, your deposit. Plum, for example, offering 4.61%, that's essentially a headline rate.
SPEAKER_01That's really good. We know it's better than XTB across a year, and that includes a 2.54% bonus for a year. So that falls, that falls quite significantly. Yeah, and I just really want to stress to people that if you have got a bonus rate, set a reminder in your calendar for 11 months, not 12 months, 11 months. So you can spend some time looking for the next product, the next investment, and then have it ready to go as soon as that bonus ends.
SPEAKER_00If you use a deposits card, you you you do that in a few minutes. That's the beauty of it. But you know, it's another sorry. So we have a few interesting fixed rate uh cash ISAs as well. HSBC with a one-year fixed cash ISA at 4.5%. Pretty attractive, you ask me. That requires the HSBC current account though. Um nationwide offers a 4.35% fixed ISA for a year. Um tandem 4.3%. Looking at two years, and above it gets actually slightly more attractive, which is fascinating. Uh, you got Shetwood Bank uh via Hagrid's Landsdown, uh 4.55%, nationwide 4.4%.
SPEAKER_00Three years you get Shetwood Bank also via Hagrid's Landsdown, 4.5%. And um, if you're willing to commit your money for five years, um Shetwood Bank also offers 4.55% and nationwide 4.5%. And that's that's pretty attractive. I know it's you know it's a long it's a long time, right? Five years committing your money for five years is a is a um yeah a decision that should not come lightly. That's of course, but getting four point five five percent each year guaranteed for five years, I think that's quite quite privileged, especially if you think think a decade back.
SPEAKER_00You know, we had super low interest rates. And people would have dreamed of something like that.
SPEAKER_01Do you believe though that now is the right time to be fixing? Let's have a quick conversation about the base rate and what the future looks like. Do you think fixing at this period of time would be would be wise?
SPEAKER_00I think absolutely, because you you don't really know what's to come. And um, do you expect the interest rates to rise even further? We have economic um yeah, economic instability. Uh maybe that's a little little harsh way to call it, but there's some some issues in the economy, right? It's not going as well as as the politicians wanted. Yeah. It's unlikely that that base rates will, you know, go go up much further. You know, if you're getting if you're getting 4.55%, that's something that's already almost a percent above the current base rate. Yes. It's typically there would be uh four interest rate rate hikes, right?
SPEAKER_00In order to reach that one percent, because they're typically uh raised by 0.25 base points. And um therefore, I think it's a good good good good decision. You know, it's something I would I would personally um be intrigued doing if I had obviously if I had this much of a of a if I would be willing to to take this much of a of a commitment with my my fixed savings.
SPEAKER_01I think investors and economists are predicting potentially one rate raise this year. My approach would be probably to have half of my savings in an easy access and half in a fixed, and then only fix the money that I'm I genuinely am okay with not being able to access. I think that's pretty obvious. Some of the fixed accounts that Jan's just talked about, like that HSBC fixed account. I mean, that is ultimately also a funnel into their into their bank, right? Just like XTB and Fitario, because you've got to get the current account. But you've got to get the current account. With nationwide, I don't think you have to get a current account.
SPEAKER_00Um then you want to get the credit card, and then you want to get the asset management offering, and then you want to get this and that, and then at some point you're within the whole HSBC ecosystem and you're fully invested.
SPEAKER_01But that that fixed ISA could be a good place to put money that you you know you can afford to not have access to, um, and then have the remainder of your savings put into like um an easy access savings account. That's the approach that I would take. I think we should quickly have a conversation about ISA transfers because I appreciate that this can be a little bit confusing. Some of the providers we've talked about offer transfers and then the likes of tandem on this account that we've talked about, and Atom and XTB aren't allowing transfers. So you can essentially transfer old ICEs into a new cash ICE without it counting against your current£20,000 allowance.
SPEAKER_01One thing to note though, these transfer rates, so when you transfer to a new provider, sometimes the rate can be less. So for example, Plum, the new money rate is 4.61%. But if you transfer in, it's 4.08%. So yeah, and which product would you choose, mate, from all of the rates we've talked about?
SPEAKER_00ETORO, 100%. Okay. Not the highest rate, right? That's that seems to be XTB at 6%, but 90-day boost expires, and then you're down to 4%. And to be honest, I feel much more comfortable um using eToro at 4.78%. As long as you can stay within the 85,000 pound limit and you're, you know, you can you can control your decisions, let's call it like that. It's probably the best option here. And it's flexible, so why would you care? You know, you uh go in and then you can just just withdraw your money if if you have to.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay, so what cash ISO are you guys gonna choose? Let us know in the comments. What do you think about some of the accounts you we've talked about today? I'd love to hear your thoughts on these trading platforms as well, just owning the headline rates, XTB, trading 212, and eToro. And a quick note on trading 212, if you go directly to their website, Jan, I should have mentioned this earlier, it might only say 3.6%, but you have to do some Google searches to try and dig out like the promo rate. So if you're struggling to find that headline trading 212 rate, go to deposit scout.com. I've made sure that the table links to the landing page for the 4.62% rate.
SPEAKER_01Or just don't.
SPEAKER_00Just use Itaoro. It's easier. Really? I I mean I I don't I don't like this. You know, offering two different rates, I'm not a fan of that personally. And uh we've advertised trading two on two in the past. We're we're you know, we're we're a fan of the product in general, but um yeah, I just don't like this. And um Yeah, I think it's right to call this out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well let us know what you think of that as well. We'd love to hear from you in the comments. And as always, if you enjoyed the video, if you're listening and watching, please do if you want to support us, like it, like the video on YouTube, rate us on Apple, Spotify, give us five stars if you're feeling generous. We'd love your support. And I have nothing else to say, Jan, on that matter.
SPEAKER_00Johnny, should we mention that if people wanted to sign up with eToro or XTB, they can just use the link in the in the description.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I didn't want to yeah, okay, I don't want to be salesy, but yeah, no, I agree. He's right. If you want to support us and you do want to take out these accounts, um, we do have affiliate links for them in the description box. We really appreciate your support. If you if you want, you don't have to, but that is one way you could support us by going through the link in the description box to sign up for eToro XDB. Well done, Jan, for mentioning that.
SPEAKER_00Thanks everyone for listening. It's been a pleasure as always, and uh see you in the next episode. Goodbye. Goodbye.
Amex Platinum is cutting lounge visits but still charging the same fee, so is it still worth it? Jonny and Jan break down what’s changing, then build cheaper stacks that cover lounges, travel insurance and everyday...
Jonny and Jan rank the ten best UK credit cards that pay you in points, covering Avios, Virgin Points, Amex Membership Rewards, Nectar and more. Every card is scored on the same model: £1,000 a month of spending over...
Trading 212 is ending its card cashback on 3 December, and Jan and I dig into why, what the card is still good for, and which UK and EU alternatives are actually worth switching to. Why Trading 212 pulled it: what the...
In this episode, we run through the best UK savings rates for November 2026. What we cover: • The Budget - tax on savings interest outside an ISA rises by four percentage points from April 2027, and the Cash ISA cut is...
In this episode, Jonny and Jan ask whether you should ever take out a personal loan. We checked 22 UK lenders and found advertised rates that only just over half of borrowers have to get, price lists that reward...