ball5podcast/**Drafted Four Times: The Mailgrams, the Money & the Decisions**
50 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail What’s it like to be drafted four different times by four different Major League organizations - and turn down the first three? In this special Ball5 episode, Emily takes over the questions as Scott shares the stories behind each of his four MLB Draft experiences: the Toronto Blue Jays in 1984, the New York Yankees in 1986, the Oakland A’s in 1987, and finally the Detroit Tigers in 1988. Scott explains how players found out they had been drafted before cell phones, social media, and live draft coverage - through Western Union mailgrams delivered to the house. He also shares the offers, the negotiations, why he chose Texas A&M over professional baseball three different times, and what ultimately made Detroit the right decision. Scott and Emily also compare the draft process then to the way players experience it today, while sharing plenty of laughs, memories, and good-natured husband-and-wife banter along the way. Four drafts. Four organizations. Three times saying no - and one decision that launched Scott’s eight-year Major League career. Pull up a chair and join us in the Ball5 Clubhouse!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Hey everybody, thanks for joining the Ball 5 Podcast. I'm your host, Scott Livingstone. So for this episode, we did it just a little bit different. This episode is the audio portion of a video hosted by my wife Emily and features our banter back and forth that we filmed as the Major League Baseball Draft was wrapping up this summer to put on our Ball 5 Clubhouse YouTube channel. It's part of a new series that we're calling Time Capsule. So on YouTube, it is actually a four-part series that you can watch anytime, detailing stories from my draft experiences.
SPEAKER_02As many of you know, I was drafted four times, and each part is unique in of itself. So we carved it out for a series. You can listen here or view it on Ball 5 Clubhouse YouTube. Enjoy. Hey everybody, welcome to the Ball 5 Clubhouse. I'm Scott Livingstone here with my wonderful wife, Emily. And we were just kind of talking about, she was asking me questions about the Major League Baseball draft and different aspects of it and stuff like that. And she heard through the grapevine that I was drafted four times.
SPEAKER_02And so she had a you know a couple questions about how I found out since we watched the boys, you know, they find out now they uh show them on TV, they can get them see it, everybody sees it on social media, and everybody finds out everything about the draft. So she was curious about back in our day, uh how it all transpired. So she actually did a little digging, didn't you?
SPEAKER_00Well, yes. So what I decided was to pull out our little time capsule that we have, and let's look at how you got drafted. So I have a question. Was it on TV?
SPEAKER_02Can we go back that far?
SPEAKER_00I don't know. Well, it is a time capsule. It is a time capsule, it's pretty old. So what? So my question is was it aired on TV like it is today?
SPEAKER_02Really?
SPEAKER_00The TV where you had to get obviously I know there's no social media, but was there TV?
SPEAKER_02Well, we had TV, but you had to get up and change the channel. You didn't have remote control.
SPEAKER_00So it wasn't on TV, it wasn't broadcast, nothing like that. So in the time capsule, let's find out how you got drafted the first time. So the first time you got drafted. How do you know that's in there? Because it's a time capsule, and all your stuff in the time capsule is in there.
SPEAKER_02All of them are in there. Okay, cool.
SPEAKER_00So the first time you got drafted was out of high school, correct?
SPEAKER_02Yes, I was 18 years old.
SPEAKER_0018 years old. And this is how you were notified. This piece of paper right here.
SPEAKER_02Oh, what is that?
SPEAKER_00Can you see this? It says mailgram, Western Union. I don't even know what that is, honestly. What's a mailgram? I don't know what a mailgram is. No. That was it's a mailgram, Western Union. That's how they notify. So is this in a printer because of all the holes on here? Like that paper you roll it through.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I was 18. I don't know how all that stuff worked. Okay. What does it matter?
SPEAKER_00So it says U.S. Post Office on here, U.S. mail, Western Union mailgram. So you got this in the mail?
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_00That's how Did you have to sign for it? Like a certified mail letter? Or they just randomly sent you a letter and said, Hey, we drafted you.
SPEAKER_02So I knew I was going to be going in the draft. I I knew, I didn't know where. So it's just a situation where it's like, you know, I I I don't really don't remember how. I don't think they called us. They may have called my parents, but I don't remember. But this is what I remember is getting a mail gram that I had been drafted. I wasn't notified like through text message because we didn't have well, you didn't have text message, but anybody call you. Not that you call your home. Not that I remember.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so can I read what this says? Oh, sure. It says, Dear Scott, congratulations. You are hereby notified that the Toronto Blue Jays. Oh, so you were your first out of high school, you were drafted by the Blue Jays?
SPEAKER_02Sixth round.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So you notify the Toronto Blue Jays baseball club selected your name in the regular phase of the Rule Four summer free agent selection meeting for the purpose of negotiating a professional baseball contract. Okay, so I don't understand what the regular phase of rule four. So is it different? The draft was different back then than it is today.
SPEAKER_02Well, so basically what you had was you had the summer draft, it comes that they have now, but then they had a rule five draft that you could be drafted during the winter. So basically, any big league club that did not have somebody on their roster, they were free to be drafted or moved to another team by another team and could sign with them at that situation at that point. So, yes, there were two. There's one during the summer, one during the winter, but the summer one is the big one.
SPEAKER_00And that was that was called the rule four.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So then it says by baseball rules, this club has selection rights to negotiate with you, and it must initiate negotiations with you within 15 days after the conclusion of the free agent meeting. We trust you will give serious consideration to a career in professional baseball. You can expect to be hearing from our scout shortly. Okay, so now you've gotten this letter in the mail. They're telling you you've got to negotiate within 15 days. So within 15 days, that negotiation is done with who?
SPEAKER_00Do you have an agent at this point?
SPEAKER_02No, you can't. So back then you couldn't have an agent like you can now. If you had an agent, I actually have a letter from an agency that uh or from Major League Baseball that they send to you after the draft that says if you sign with an agent, you have to go pro. You cannot, you cannot sign. You can be advised.
SPEAKER_00Can you renege on it?
SPEAKER_02I don't know. That's for the lawyers to handle. So, but the fact of the matter is, is I don't remember they thought I was gonna, I'd already committed AM, and I wanted to go to AM, but then I knew I was gonna be drafted. But they you know, you know, like I always tell you, there's draft rankings, right? They always talk about that, and I'll tell you they don't mean anything. I was supposed to go close to the first round, but I'd committed AM, and so I dropped, but that was neither here nor there. But the thing about it is they actually told me, said, Hey, we're gonna come in and play the Rangers, and we want you to come to the ballpark because I was in Dallas.
SPEAKER_02We want you to come to the ballpark, dress with us, take some BP, take some infield. You know, I'm I'm 18 years old, so I'm like, okay, but it was their way of trying to change my feeling about, hey, if he gets a taste of this.
SPEAKER_00So see if you get enamored by the big leagues.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, is this wow, this is what I want to do, right? So they had made an offer, and their offer was sixty thousand dollars, which back then was was still, I mean, it's good money, it's good money now. Um and they asked me to come to the ballpark. So I get to the ballpark, the Rangers, and it's funny because I sit in the in the locker next to Dennis Lamp, who was a pitcher back in the day, which you know a lot of you guys don't know who Dennis Lamp is, but uh they had two third basemen that were platooning, a left-handed hitter and a right-handed hitter, and it was uh Lance Mullinix and um oh, was it Garth or something like that?
SPEAKER_02But anyway, they let me use their bats. So I sat in there, I dressed with them, and I mean I was like a kid among men. I mean, it was like, and so I took batting practice, hit a couple home runs, ballpark, uh, the old ballpark, and took some ground balls and went back in the clubhouse and they said, Hey, we're gonna be here tomorrow. We want you to come back and have a good, you know, just let's do this again. We enjoyed having you out, you know, they they did the whole spiel, and I didn't go back.
SPEAKER_02And the reason I didn't go back was I was so intimidated because I think kind of them having me there kind of backfired a little bit because I was just intimidated. I mean, there was grown men in there, there was just you know, just all sorts of just stuff that was that I was not used to and and just all this stuff, and so it's just crazy. And so it actually made my decision really easy to go back, go to school.
SPEAKER_00So, how do you think these guys today that are coming out of high school, getting drafted, how is it different for them today compared to when you were drafted out of high school?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think they're exposed to a lot more stuff a lot earlier. I mean, they're all in these travel baseball groups. You can play on the USA team, you can go to, you know, perfect game, you can go to all these tournaments, area code games, you can go to all this different stuff. And, you know, social media is a big deal, and people can see you and know you, and and I and I just think I think they have to mature a lot quicker than we had to back then.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so you got drafted out of high school. Sure, you can pull that out of there. You go off to Texas AM, you decide you forego the 60 grand that they offered you, which what year was that? 88, 89? No, no, it's when you graduate from high school. Oops.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, that's right. 88, 89. So I was in the 70s instead of 60s.
SPEAKER_00You turned down 60 grand, which I cannot believe you turned down$60,000 at that time. I mean, that's crazy to me at that at that time of the world.
SPEAKER_0260 grand, hold on, 60 grand or Texas AM. I think I won.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Well, well, we know that. So now you go off to Texas AM, you're playing a Texas AM, um, and now the rules back then, when could you draft a player back then? Once they've gone off to college.
SPEAKER_02Because I know the rules all are kind of if you go to a four-year school, you can be drafted after your third year. Okay. Or when you're 21. If you go to a JUCO, you can be drafted after year one or year two. But there's also a rule, like I said, if you're almost if you're 21, 45 days after the draft, you're eligible. July 15th birthday. Draft back then was the first week of June, somewhere around there. So I just made the cutoff. And yeah.
SPEAKER_00So this would have been at the end of your sophomore year?
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so end of your sophomore year. Let's go into the time capsule and see what we got.
SPEAKER_02We gotta go way back.
SPEAKER_00Wow. Oh my gosh, it's another mailgram. What are these freaking mailgrams? I really don't know what a mailgram is. I never received a mailgram ever in my life. I don't know who I'd received one from. Okay, so this mailgram. So this point, oh, okay, can I put the tell you the date? I have a date on here.
SPEAKER_01Sure, go ahead.
SPEAKER_006-4, 1986. So you're saying that this is 45 days prior to your 21st birthday.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so that was that had to be the day of the draft or the next day. Okay. I mean, or the day before, June 3rd, because if that says June 4th, okay.
SPEAKER_00Western Union was quick. Guess who really liked Western Union? George Steinbrenner. Oh my gosh, I can't believe this from George Steinbrenner. Reminds me of Seinfeld. Seinfeld? Yeah. Okay. So this says, Dear Scott, congratulations on your selection by the New York Yankees. Whoa, you could have been a Yankee. Yankee. We are looking forward to you becoming a member of the Yankee family, and our scouts will be in touch with you in the near future. Sincerely, George M. Steinbrenner III.
SPEAKER_00New York Yankees. Okay. So this came in the mail. I mean, I mean, does it come in the mail or do you have to? Because I remember there used to be Western Union stores or storefronts. Did you have to go to a Western Union and pick it up? Or it literally came in the mail? In an envelope. You don't know. Because your mom probably opened up the envelope. Probably. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Okay. I'm just these mailgrams cracking me up, people. I was probably outside practicing working on my craft. Okay. So this is now, you're now drafted by the Yankees. And what did they offer you? Did they offer you anything?
SPEAKER_02You got time for a story, young lady.
SPEAKER_00I guess we got time for a story. Do y'all want to hear a story about this?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, my pups are laying here on the floor. I think they want to hear one. Um, so 45 days after the draft, I was 21. Yankees were one of the teams that knew about it. And so they took a shot. 26th round. And I didn't think I had a good year at AM that year, but some people said yes, no, blah, blah, blah. But the junior year is really your bread and butter year back then because however you you still have leverage. When you're eligible at your junior year, you still have leverage to go back to school.
SPEAKER_02So when you negotiate, so I had some leverage, but so they came to watch me uh in Alaska. They approached me in Alaska. I was playing summer ball in Alaska. Um, they approached me at a game, and then you know, I was thinking they were there to see me, you know, like, oh, they're in Alaska to come, you know, to come try and sign me. Well, come to find out, a lot of you Yankee fans remember Kevin Moss, I think he was their 22nd round pick, a left-handed hitting first baseman. He was in the league as well in Alaska, and they were actually there to see him.
SPEAKER_02And we weren't playing each other, but so they came to our field in Alaska, pulled me aside after the game, and said, Hey Scott, what's it gonna take to sign you? So remember this back then, what was that date? 86? It was 1986. I put it away already. 1986. I think the first round pick maybe got 150 grand, 160, somewhere around there.
SPEAKER_00Oh, and what did first round get this year? Over 10 million?
SPEAKER_02Maybe probably nine? Maybe only nine. Only nine.
SPEAKER_00Only nine.
SPEAKER_02But uh nine million. But anyway, nine million dollars. But uh, so I just I would knew I I knew I was going back to AM, no deep, no big deal. So I told him. I said, five hundred thousand dollars. It's exactly what I said to those guys there behind the first space dugout in Alaska, and I never heard from them again.
SPEAKER_00So you had a little cockiness in you.
SPEAKER_02No, I just knew I knew I wasn't going there.
SPEAKER_00And why not? Because you wanted to go back to AM? Or because were you still intimidated to go to the big leagues?
SPEAKER_02I wasn't as intimidated then. I asked the Yankees for$500,000.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_02I wasn't astimidated.
SPEAKER_00So they didn't want you then. Uh uh George Steinbrenner said uh negative. Move on.
SPEAKER_02He he wasn't there.
SPEAKER_00All right, so let's move on to the next one.
SPEAKER_02What what how do you know how many times I've been drafted?
SPEAKER_00What you've been digging in the time capsule or something? I know that you have been drafted, you were drafted four times total.
SPEAKER_02Good job.
SPEAKER_00Okay, okay, so now you you turn down well, you didn't turn down, I guess you did turn down the Yankees, but they basically turned down your$500,000 counteroffer, if that's what you want to call it, right? Mutual. Mutual. Okay, so you didn't go to play for the Yankees. You went back to Texas AM. So this is now Serenity now.
SPEAKER_02This is now.
SPEAKER_00This is now gonna, golly. Uh this is now gonna be your junior year at Texas AM.
SPEAKER_02What are you talking about, Willis? Throwing you off.
SPEAKER_00This is now gonna be your junior year at Texas AM. So you play the junior year and you get drafted again. Third time. Right? So now this one, let's go see who drafted you the third time. What do you got in there? Oh my gosh, it's another mailgram. I have no other way to communicate with you besides a mailgram. When did mailgrams go away?
SPEAKER_02I really after the 12th time I was drafted.
SPEAKER_00Okay, yeah. All right, so this one is dated June 2nd, 1987. So that other one with the Yankees was June 4th. Okay, so this is interesting. I do want to point this out to those of you that are listening or watching us. Um, the draft now is in July. Because we're in the well, I guess June 2nd or June 4th, we'd be in regionals, right? Um, or we're using super regionals. Supers. Okay, so was that the same timeline and time frame for you back then?
SPEAKER_00So June 2nd, could you have been in the regionals?
SPEAKER_02No, we're in the college world series.
SPEAKER_00Wait, the college world series was June 2nd?
SPEAKER_02Well, that week or 10 days, because that's how a lot of guys found out. They found out while they were in the college world series.
SPEAKER_00So there was no supers, you just had regionals and then you went to the college.
SPEAKER_02We just had regionals, you had more teams in it. More, okay. You may have had six.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so I think that's an interesting point here to make is that you're being drafted, the draft is going on. So still at this point, it's at 1987. This is your third year, third, not third year, but third time to be drafted since high school, which we said you got drafted in 1984.
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_00So now it's three years later. So now it's three years later, still not televised.
SPEAKER_02No.
SPEAKER_00Is the NFL draft at this time televised?
SPEAKER_02I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Oh, I'm just curious because it's you know how the football queen. And that's just true. Fantasy football is about to start, people. All right. So you're so if you did AM, were you in the College World Series at this point? What? No, y'all weren't. Okay. So it didn't end it. You were home. So baseball season was over. So June 2nd.
SPEAKER_02Well, it wasn't over. We just weren't in the college world series. You just weren't in the college series. My season was over.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that season was over for you guys. So, but any other player out there painful questions. Okay, but any other player out there, June 2nd, could possibly be playing in the College World Series, and they get this mailgram that they've been drafted. So I send it to their house, not to Omaha. Gotta, well, yeah, but I gotta think that that's gotta be a factor in your mindset, wondering, Am I getting drafted? Especially those guys who were going in the first round. You're trying to concentrate on playing in the College World Series, yet in the back of your mind, you might be getting a mail gram in the mail saying, Hey, the Yankees have selected you.
SPEAKER_00So what that's what's interesting to me that people might not realize is that now this draft, what this year the draft was three weeks after the College World Series.
SPEAKER_02After my birthday now, or right around my birthday, July 13th.
SPEAKER_00And it's on TV now.
SPEAKER_02It's on TV, of course, all through social media. The reason they do that is because you know, Major League Baseball made the decision. They thought it'd be a great idea to have the Major League Baseball draft and all that stuff during all the all-star activities for Major League Baseball and kind of make a big deal about it and stuff. And yeah, they bring the cameras into some of the first, you know, potential first-round picks and stuff like that. So it's just like anything else. It's a big hoop law and a big deal, but it's cool for the players.
SPEAKER_00And you know, well, you think that they probably took a page from the NFL because the NFL makes their draft such a big deal. Will you stop with the football stuff? I know, but I'm comparing. This is the clubhouse, baseball. I get it, but I'm comparing. They probably took notes and realized they could grow up, grow viewership, grow, even though we know baseball is America's game. Pastime. Or pastime. Yeah. So anyway, let's get back to what we're talking about here. So you got a third mailgram. You just finished your junior year at Texane M.
SPEAKER_00This is, like I said, this is dated 6th to 1987. And this one says, Congratulations. You are hereby notified that the Oakland Athletics. Who? I know. Sacramento.
SPEAKER_02Aren't they going to Vegas?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, they're in Vegas now, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00How long have they been in Vegas?
SPEAKER_02No, they're building a stadium there. So are they still gonna be called they're in Sacramento right now?
SPEAKER_00Are they called the Sacramento Athletics?
SPEAKER_02Oakland slash Sacramento Athletics.
SPEAKER_00Oh, really? That's what they're calling them?
SPEAKER_02I think so.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So they have selected you and named the rule. Oh, this is back to that rule four summer free agent selection. Well, I don't know.
SPEAKER_02They didn't upgrade you. So they're linguals either.
SPEAKER_00So this basically says the same thing that they'll negotiate, they have to negotiate with you within 15 days. And this says, We trust you will give serious consideration to career in professional baseball. And you'll be hearing from our scout. So this was signed by their director of scouting, Dick Bogard. Do you know who that guy was? Okay. All right. So now tell me, did they offer you anything? Can it be story time? Oh my gosh, yeah. Let's put that mailgram away.
SPEAKER_02Well, don't get it lost with all those other draft things in there. You know, they're not drafted 12 times, so it could get lost.
SPEAKER_00You did not get drafted 12 times. Well, four.
SPEAKER_02Okay. All right. Uh so Oakland drafts me. I get a mailgram, and it's third round. So again, kind of weird is I was supposed to go in the first or second round, and I ended up going to the third round, dropped to the third round. But Oakland had Oakland did not have a second round pick. Don't know why. Don't know why. Must be money thing. But they had a first round pick and a second round pick. I mean, I'm sorry, first round, and then next was third round. So they picked first round.
SPEAKER_02It actually is, I think it's an outfielder named Lee Tinsley. Uh, I think he made it to the big leagues for a little bit. And so then I found out Melgram that I was drafted in the third round.
SPEAKER_00We need to bring Mailgram back.
SPEAKER_02And they reached out to me. And so I think Lee, sorry, Lee, I think he got maybe 140 grand for the first round. So I was a second round pick. And so, you know, I'm not thinking that I'm gonna far fall much from that number. And I was ready to go. I was ready. I mean, it's junior year. I had, I can't, if I go my senior year, I got no leverage, right? So, like you can't have now five years and all that stuff. But they offered me$35,000.
SPEAKER_00So you turned down 60 out of high school three years later. Now they're only offering you 35.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I don't know why, I don't know how it was, what the deal was, but I mean I had a great year at AM. It's my best year at AM. And so, you know, I'm thinking, hey, here we go, good deal. You know, I'm gonna get six figures, something like that, just you know, because that's where everything was at that time. And they offered me 35,000. And at the time, I had an offer to play for the USA team, and this is back when the USA team used college players against the other guys' professionals.
SPEAKER_00So we would do the prof the other countries were using professionals.
SPEAKER_02We played Dominican Republic, Cuba. They were basically professional players. They were 26, 27, 30.
SPEAKER_00Oh, and you guys were all 19, 20, 21. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Okay. And so um, and we were very competitive. But anyway, we had the chance to, I had the chance to go play with them. So I told Oakland I was gonna play with the USA team. They said, okay, that's great. We're gonna watch you over the summer, and we'll try and you know figure out if we want to adjust the amount or whatever. And we said, okay, so fast forward, went to the USA team. Uh, I mean, I think I hit like 345, 360, something like that. Had a great summer, won the silver medal, uh, hit for the cycle against Canada, one of the medal games.
SPEAKER_02And so I mean, I had a great summer. And we get back home, and um Oakland reaches back out, and they go, Well, after watching everything and seeing all the stuff and so on and so forth, we decided we're gonna go with$30,000.
SPEAKER_00So why did they knock five grand off?
SPEAKER_02I have no idea. So I don't know if you know, now it's like you save money here to maybe draft a kid later, maybe their money went somewhere else. I mean, you gotta remember it's Oakland. They didn't have a lot of money, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I mean, isn't that what those movies are about?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, why, you know, the biggest thing is like, why do I like this player? Because he gets on base. You know, Brad Pitt. Yeah, and so it's like, okay, well, all the guys get on base too. So they went back, we're like, what's the deal? Because I'm expecting it, I mean, minimum 90, I'll go. And I still had the leverage to go back to AM. And I mean, you know, we had good teams, and so I was like, okay.
SPEAKER_00And so at this point, though, you still can't have an agent because if there's a possibility of you going back, if I sign, I'm gone. So who's your negotiator? Mr. Livingstone, the uh lawyer dad?
SPEAKER_02My lawyer dad. Maybe that's why they went back five grand.
SPEAKER_00But your dad's negotiating skills weren't very good.
SPEAKER_02No, I'm not saying that. I'm saying he might have been he might have lawyered on him, lawyered up on him.
SPEAKER_00Um no, not Poppy.
SPEAKER_02No, he doesn't, he doesn't do that. He doesn't get upset, he doesn't get the red ass. But uh yeah, so they went back and we were just kind of like, okay, whatever. And funny thing is, Coach Johnson at AM had already kind of allocated my scholarship to other guys.
SPEAKER_00Because you can only have a certain number of scholarships.
SPEAKER_02It was like 11.7 scholarship total. That was it. So you had to divide roughly 25, 28 players between 11.7 scholarships. So I think back then I was on a full ride, Chuck Knobloch's on a full ride, probably Byington and probably a couple other guys. So you had all you had that other money to allocate amongst everybody else. So it was a situation where uh I actually went back to college station, did not tell Coach Johnson.
SPEAKER_02I was in Kane Hall. If somebody remember Kane Hall, the athletic dorm, it's not there anymore. There's a big hotel right across from baseball, I mean the football field now. But I called Coach Johnson. Our phone back then was on the wall with the long cord that could stretch to the living room. Yeah, but we didn't have kitchens and living rooms. We had a dorm room with two beds in it.
SPEAKER_00Oh, you're that's right.
SPEAKER_02I'm in the dorm room. So I have the long cord and the phone, and I call Coach Johnson at the office, at the baseball office, and I said, Hey coach. And he goes, Hey, how you doing? I said, right, coach, here he is right here. Yeah. And I said, I said, hey coach, uh, I'm coming back. And you know, like guys, he already allocated these scholarships. So guys actually post pictures now that say, hey, let's run it back. Well, I was running it back. And uh I mean they still had some money left because you know, it's for guys that they might get late or you know, show up at campus, or they sign during the fall.
SPEAKER_02You can sign guys during the fall, just there were so many different rules back then. But he ended up, we did not want to put a strain on the program, and so no a lot of people don't know this. My dad paid for, we paid for half the scholarship. So we took 50% from the AM piece and paid the other half.
SPEAKER_00I didn't know that.
SPEAKER_02I said a lot of people didn't know because most people don't know. And we paid for half of it, and he covered the other half. So you could say it was a full scholarship, but it really wasn't. It was a half scholarship because we paid for the other half.
SPEAKER_00But now today, that's different. A lot more scholarships are available, full ride scholarships. They're all full rides.
SPEAKER_02Every player is on a full ride now.
SPEAKER_00So, how many players on the team? Like 40?
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, I think you can, I don't know how many you can do.
SPEAKER_0035 changing all the time. So But you just the athletic budgets were different back then. You couldn't think you couldn't allocate that money to baseballs athletics. I know you're a buck.
SPEAKER_02I know you're a buckeye, and your your budgets are you know, AM's budget's pretty high now, too. Well, yours is higher, and it's even higher here at home, too.
SPEAKER_00Um yeah, so you decided to go back, and your dad paid for half. And nobody knows that. I'm sure Coach Johnson was happy to have you back because this is now gonna be your senior year, right? Right? Okay, so before we move on to your senior year at Texas AM, I do have one question because I this is something you've mentioned to me before about being drafted by Oakland. That the story was among the Oakland, either it was it people in the clubhouse or stories outside the club, maybe fans or whatever, were saying that Oakland actually offered you a hundred grand.
SPEAKER_00But you're telling me that it went from 35 to 30 after you had an amazing season with the USA baseball team. Well, where's the other 70 grand? So is that not true?
SPEAKER_02So the negotiations were as I said, they went down to 30. We said no, thank you, went back to school, and fast forward 1992. Fast forward, it's not of course it's way back. I was a starting third baseman for Detroit. And um we opened the season in Oakland, and I'm playing third base, and Oakland's uh coaching staff, which I think is Tony LaRusse at the time, maybe Dave McKay was at first base, coaching first base.
SPEAKER_02But our first baseman is uh Cecil Fielder. And I had already I got called up in '91, so I played with him at that time, but I started the opening day third baseman in 1992. And if you know that, that's if you're the starting, if you start opening day, you're on the all-star ballot. So that's why my name is on the all-star ballot.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that makes sense. Okay.
SPEAKER_02And so um I was starting, I was playing third base, and I I don't know what inning it was, but we came in. I sat down on the bench or whatever in Oakland, and and Cecil Fielder goes, he's like four people down from me. We're all just kind of sitting there, you know, in between innings. And he leans over and he goes, Stoney, he goes, What are you thinking, my man? And I go, What are you talking about? He goes, he told me over there at first base that you turned down a hundred grand.
SPEAKER_02Wait, who's he? Their third base? Oh, their first base coach. So and he he he did that, he said it after I had made a play actually on Ricky Henderson, who was their leadoff hitter. So Ricky had hit it to me, I fielded it, threw him out to end the inning, and we're running off field or whatever. And the next inning, their first base coach had said something to Cecil about that they had offered you a hundred grand. That's your rookie, that's Scott Livingstone. Yeah, we offered him a hundred grand out of Texas AM.
SPEAKER_02So throughout the organization, they didn't weren't telling the truth because I can tell you what. If they'd offered me a hundred grand, you would have been gone. He gone.
SPEAKER_00So, I mean so, but these negotiations they were all done over the phone.
SPEAKER_02Most of them, yeah.
SPEAKER_00They're calling your home phone, because they didn't travel that much back then. And did you always have them talking with your father? Oh, yeah, I didn't talk to him. You never talked to him. Your dad did all the so did your dad maybe not tell you? Oh no, because he wanted you to go back to AM, because I know how much your dad liked Coach Johnson.
SPEAKER_02Oh, that's true. But no, he wouldn't have done that. Okay.
SPEAKER_00All right, well, let's move on.
SPEAKER_02Would you?
SPEAKER_00All right, so let's move on. And so now you're in your senior year at Texas AM. This is your last year. It's either do or die. If you're gonna go on a play, what you talking about, Willis? Professional baseball. So you finish the year, you get drafted for a fourth time. You gotta go, right? So let's see who drafted you. Well, I think we already know. Which oh my, it's another mailgram. It's another mailgram.
SPEAKER_02The hand, I mean, it hasn't evolved.
SPEAKER_00Four years later. They hadn't evolved. Four years later, and you can't send like a certified letter, it's still a mailgram. Mailgram. All right, so this is dated oh, 62, 1988. So still we're in the midst of the World Series. I'm seeing it's still at that time, right?
SPEAKER_02I was at home. So I wasn't in Omaha. You weren't in Omaha. I still wasn't.
SPEAKER_00All right, so now this one is from Detroit, which we all know that obviously that's so yeah. Um, this came from director of scouting, Jax Robertson. So it says, Congratulations. You're hereby notified the Detroit Baseball Club selected your name, and the same thing. It's the rule for summer free agent selection. So now, in the same uh terms, you have 15 days for the negotiation at the conclusion of the free agent meeting. Um, they were one of like I I it must be just like a template they all use because it's all saying the same thing year after year.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's like anything else somebody gets, they just put your name in and then they just yeah, it's probably just a standard letter.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so now you this it's your senior year. You can't, it's not like today we're well. I guess that rule is new this year now that you've got five years of eligibility. Now I don't know anymore. You're well, it changes every year, the eligibility. So now it's your senior year, you have no eligibility left, you've got to go. Detroit Tigers selected.
SPEAKER_02That sounds kind of mean.
SPEAKER_00Well, you don't, you're senior. I know, but you didn't have to say it like that. Well Okay. So you are getting what round were you dropped it by the Tigers? Second, second round by the Tigers. Let me tell you something about that.
SPEAKER_02Senior, no leverage to still go in the second round. Is that pretty good? Come on now. Okay. But the the problem was when we started to negotiate, they basically could give me a six-pack of Dr. Pepper and say, see you in spring training. Because you had no leverage.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Had no leverage. Did they give you a six-pack of Dr. Pepper?
SPEAKER_02Well, they might have given my parents. My dad's a big Dr. Pepper.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So you're you're now you're going to Detroit. What'd they offer you? 50. So you went from in four years, four different ball clubs. You went from 60 to 500. Well, zero from the Yankees, because they didn't take your five, your offer of 500, to 35, which got knocked down to 30, supposedly was 100, but that was hearsay.
SPEAKER_00And now you're at$50,000. Take it. You gotta take it. So now you've taken it. Well, how do you know? Well, because I know you played for the situation. I see it all over our walls in here.
SPEAKER_02So at least it's not a state.
SPEAKER_00Not in this room, it's not. So you're now going to be able to do that.
SPEAKER_02So just to let you know, when they offered me 50, there was no counter. There was no negotiation. Yeah. It was either 50s on the table.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Thank you. So you couldn't have. You couldn't have come back and said, no, I want a hundred. Well, I could have. But they would have said they would have been the Yankees. Yeah. And said, bye-bye. See ya. Yeah. Right. Okay, so this was June 2nd. When did you accept their offer? June 2nd. You accepted it that day. Probably. Okay, well, so wait, I have a question though. Even though this is dated June 2nd and it's a mail gram, I don't know. You don't know if you actually got it on June 2nd. Probably not. Okay, because we just don't know how.
SPEAKER_02Hey, put it in the comments.
SPEAKER_00It knows Western Union. Yeah, your parents uh opened all this stuff up.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so you get$50,000, you say yes. Now what? Like, because you tell me about how these guys now they're getting drafted and they're getting you know flown out to those ball clubs right away to sign their contract. Were you flown out to Detroit from Dallas to sign your contract? Or how'd that happen?
SPEAKER_02I know there was planes. No. And I mean now they even fly, you know, the 20th round guy. Whatever. Right. We've seen it all over social media. And it's I think it's really cool though, because it is a big deal to be drafted. Because there's a lot of players that don't get drafted, you know? And uh I feel very fortunate about being drafted four times, very blessed. And you know, they just basically I signed the contract and they said I went to I didn't even go I went to a fallball thing.
SPEAKER_02I had like a something I had to go to down in Lakeland, Florida, which is where their spring training site is. I don't know if it still is, it might be. But uh I went there for a little little tune-up, if you will, baseball stuff. And then they said we'll see you in spring training.
SPEAKER_00So it's not like today where these guys sign and like you've always tell me, sign and get going. Like go join up with the club.
SPEAKER_02Because a rookie league. There's the rookie league. There's this Arizona League and a Florida League, and I think it's called like AF ACL, not your knee and FCL leagues or something like that. They're called complex leagues. That's what they are. And these guys go there after they sign. You know, if somebody's thrown a lot, like for example, Ryan Prager threw a lot during his senior year, he probably didn't, you know, throw at all. So he's, you know, because he rests. There's no reason for him to keep throwing. And then, you know, they might run some guys out there to play.
SPEAKER_02Like right now, this year, Grahovac, he's with the Angels, right? He's I think in Arizona, and he'll probably they might send him out for the rest of the summer, maybe fall. I don't know how how they do it, but to get some at bats and just kind of see how he does. And then when he comes to spring training, then they try and figure out what what level do we want to start him at?
SPEAKER_00That you're and you're me saying level, you're saying like low A, high A, or double A, triple A. Or he could even go, yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I mean, look at Braden Montgomery. He flew through the system. Right.
SPEAKER_00You know, so uh because the reason why I'm asking about that is because so you didn't do that back then because they didn't have that rookie league, those Arizona leagues, what have you. Because I've heard you talk about some of these guys, especially for us, we always reference the AM players because that's the obviously where you played in the program that we're closest to and know those players. You referenced this last year, I remember, about Caden Kent. You played with his dad, well, not with his dad, but his dad played in the big leagues. Obviously, you guys were in the big leagues at the same time.
SPEAKER_00And you said I'm the Hall of Fame, by the way. I know he just went into the Hall of Fame. Amazing.
SPEAKER_02Deserving, very deserves it.
SPEAKER_00You mentioned to me when Caden got drafted, you were like, he's gonna be gone. He's gonna sign and he's gonna go because his dad's gonna say, get in that organization, get to know all those people, because his dad knows, right? He's been at what he played 20 years in the big leagues, yeah. So so that's and you say you've said that to me before, too. You're like, man, just sign and go. Get playing, get going. So but you didn't have that opportunity because those leagues weren't around then.
SPEAKER_02Well, I think they had some sort of like fall, kind of maybe be called like instructional league, but it wasn't until the fall.
SPEAKER_00So And where was that? Where did you go for that? At the spring training site.
SPEAKER_02Okay, I would so all the other spring prank spring training teams in Florida and probably in Arizona had prospects and people come in during the fall, and probably some people, I mean, it might be three or four weeks, I don't know how long it was. But now the draft is so late that a lot of the guys, you know, they'll go to the complex for a little bit but may not go anywhere. Some people may just sign and go to the lake and they say we'll see you in spring training, however, it is. But in the Kent situation, I figured Jeff would be like, dude, get going, get noticed, get recognized, get to know the people in the organization.
SPEAKER_02The more they get to know you, the sooner they get to know you, the better. And I mean, Caden's a great player, and I think he's got a great chance to make it. And uh, I just think getting in it sooner, and that's why I was a little bit, God, why is the draft so late? Because now these guys don't do anything during the fall, as far as like with these teams, and maybe they do. I don't know all the ins and outs, but a lot of times it's usually bringing in the prospects and not the other guys. But the draft is so you know, squeezed now to 20 rounds, and they might go to 10, which is crazy.
SPEAKER_02Um, how are you gonna fill all those rosters of those minor league teams? But yeah, to me, it's the sooner the better to get in there. And so when I saw when I was with Detroit, I went to that instructional league, and then I didn't see them till spring training. I mean, that's just the way it was.
SPEAKER_00And you know and what time of does what was spring training time? Was that like the end of February?
SPEAKER_02It was the middle of February for the big league club, and it was somewhere in March for the minor league group. So I went to the minor league camp first. Bo Schimbeckler was our GM. Ha ha, Michigan. Michigan. Uh-oh, go blue.
SPEAKER_00Did you really just say that?
SPEAKER_02Did I come out in my mind?
SPEAKER_00I cannot believe you just said that. No, it does not work in our household. I don't say anything about the horns.
SPEAKER_02That's true. You don't ever. I take it back.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. So I guess to kind of wrap this up, I think hopefully you've enjoyed us kind of going through our time capsule and pulling out all these mailgrams. I mean, these are cracking me up because I guess I've never seen one before.
SPEAKER_02I guess you got anything else in there?
SPEAKER_00There's nothing else in there, just the mailgrams. Oh, there's more stuff in there. Well, yeah, eventually they will be down the road. So just to kind of recap this, so you were an 18-year-old kid. You got drafted, you got drafted four times. So the first time was when you're 18, coming right out of high school uh by the Toronto Blue Jays. And then, of course, you had to wait for the rule, the rules were until you were 21 or 45 days, you know, but after the draft, if you were 21, which at that point you were just sophomore year, you got drafted by the Yankees.
SPEAKER_00They did not take your$500,000. They thought about it offer. And but then um, and then of course, then it's the Oakland A's, we got some conflict on what was actually offered to you. And then you settle with Detroit. I think actually you probably went to the the best place you could have gone to with Detroit and started your career there.
SPEAKER_02Well, I'd say that it was a it was it worked out good because even though it was Sparky Anderson and he liked having older players around him, so you know he always had the big red machine, so he didn't really have to manage. He just filled out the lineup card and everybody ran out there and did their job, Joe Morgan and all those guys. I just uh it was a good time for a young player to be in that organization because as the guys were getting older, you could replace them or or just fill in somewhere and they started to mix in some youth.
SPEAKER_02And you see a lot of that now. Where if the big league club is not playing as well or not doing as well, you see the younger guys can get up that level pretty quick. And I see a You know, a lot of the guys that you just we d talked about earlier and that we watch all the time at AM, I I see some of them going pretty, pretty quick, not like this year, next year, but maybe within a year and a half, two years, could be in the big leagues. Just depends on the organization that they're with.
SPEAKER_02Because if you're with an organization that already has a lot of young players and they're really high on them and they're paying them a lot of money, you could be stuck. And I did get stuck in Detroit a little bit, uh, just because the older players, like you know, Alan Trammell and you know, Travis Freyman was there. He's a superstar, he's younger than me, but great shortstop. Ended up playing third base for him for a long time, and I played a little bit of third after when Trammell got hurt, and Travis moved to short, which was his natural position. And thank goodness, because that's where I kind of made my hay with doing well at third base.
SPEAKER_02You know, I made CNN play the day. They had that back in the day.
SPEAKER_00You did?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Detroit third base against Oakland of all teams. Remember the$5,000 they didn't offer, they took away, took it off the table. Diving play, man, like parallel to the ground, stole a line drive, come down. So it was pretty cool, even though I don't watch CNN, but I got CNN play of the day.
SPEAKER_00But did CNN cover sports back then?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, they actually, yeah, they had a little blurb about that. So, hey, one little thing that I wanted to say about the athletics and the kind of the 30,000 and the 35,000 turned out kind of funny because the GM that was with Oakland at that time, he they asked him why they didn't, how come they weren't able to sign me? And I got a little blurb. My mom's got it in the paper. She cut it out in the paper.
SPEAKER_00Now the Dallas Morning News.
SPEAKER_02Or Dallas Times Herald, whichever one. Okay. And it it said, he was quoted as saying, Well, we had two scouts go and watch him play during the summer, and one liked him and one didn't. So I was like, that the people in the front office at at Oakland actually went and became the front office in St. Louis. Same people, same guys. And so and they ended up trading for me.
SPEAKER_02Trading for me from San Diego to St. Louis, the same group that said, ah, he was okay when they watched. So I guess I got better. But the funny thing is, I was playing on the end of a two-year contract, and if I had a third year, and if they didn't pick it up, there was a buyout. The buyout was 60,000. So that group that was in Oakland, now in St. Louis, didn't pick up my third year, but still had to pay me 60.
SPEAKER_00So you got some money out of them.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, more than five.
SPEAKER_00More than five. Well, one more thing I do want to bring up just before we wrap our whole draft your draft series up, is that um you were drafted in the second round to Detroit. That's when you finally went after your fourth time. And one point that I want to make is that this year, Caden Sorrell from Texas AM went in the second round to the Cubs. So you signed for$50,000 with Detroit second round.
SPEAKER_02Where are you going with this?
SPEAKER_00Well, what number were you picked?
SPEAKER_02Uh like 45th, 46th.
SPEAKER_00Okay, what was Sorrell? 68. 60 or something, maybe 60, something like that. Okay. 38 years later.
SPEAKER_02Why do you have to keep saying it like that? You like emphasize 38.
SPEAKER_00It's 38 years later. Caden Sorrell by saying that. Now, granted, he plays a different position. He's an outfielder, but he's also a hitter. You both are hitters.
SPEAKER_02He's really good.
SPEAKER_00And he's extremely good. Looking forward to his career. He signed. Do you know what you signed for in the second round?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, like 1.6, 1.7, somewhere around.
SPEAKER_00$1.6 million. And you signed for$50,000 38 years ago. But it's just the contrast, right? I mean, think of that. Just the contrast of where this game has gone and with the money that's tied to it. Plus, you know, Caden also has some NIL money that you didn't get the chance to have either.
SPEAKER_02Well, you know, and I went back to school without getting NL NIL money. True. This is but I mean, the the difference in the money, it is what it is. It's it's just times have changed. It's evolved. You know, and you can look back at, you know, I'd be curious to know what the the guy at the at uh the 40th or my pick, my slot, 45th or 46th, whatever I was.
SPEAKER_00Oh god, this year.
SPEAKER_02What did they get? I don't know. I mean, I hadn't looked at it, but uh I I would probably bet it was more than 50,000.
SPEAKER_00Uh yeah, I'm sure it's probably more than 50,000. And he wasn't told via mailgram either. It was televised on TV.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, I've really enjoyed this episode.
SPEAKER_00Oh, I have too. Are you gonna have me back?
SPEAKER_02Uh well, I mean, it's gonna be up to them. Let's see what the comments say.
SPEAKER_00Vote for me to be back. We got more things coming in this time capsule. We've got a lot of things to share with you that we have discovered and all of his immemorabilia that he has saved over the years. So stay tuned. We've got a lot of great more stories to bring you out of our time capsule.
SPEAKER_02I hope you guys have enjoyed it. Thanks, guys. All right, folks. Thanks for listening. Hope you enjoyed it. Be sure to check out our Ball Five Clubhouse YouTube channel and subscribe for notifications. Thanks again.
Send us Fan Mail After the World Series, somebody asked me, “Scott, do you think small ball is coming back?” That got me thinking about what we mean when we tell a hitter to “do damage.” A home run can change a game in...
Send us Fan Mail Before the big leagues, there was a summer wearing USA across his chest. Scott Livingstone and Emily open the Ball5 Time Capsule to revisit his experience with the 1987 USA Baseball team - from sharing...
Send us Fan Mail My parents told me choosing a college was my decision. Then an Oklahoma State recruiting visit took an unexpected turn over a piece of chocolate cake. In this Time Capsule episode, Emily joins me as we...
Send us Fan Mail Being prepared. Observing. Executing. Sometimes staying ready starts with watching closely. In this episode of Ball5 Clubhouse, Scott Livingstone shares how watching pitchers for a “tell” helped him...
Send us Fan Mail Former Texas A&M standout and Major League outfielder Tyler Naquin joins the Ball5 Podcast to talk about his Aggie career, his journey through professional baseball and what it means to be inducted into...