Prove Design Value to Win Better Clients with Clive Grinyer Clive Grinyer joins the Authority Builder podcast to unpack why design must prove its value, not just claim it, and how the DBA Design Effectiveness Awards help agencies and in-house teams do exactly that. We explore what judges really look for, how to link outcomes back to the original brief, and why “effectiveness” beats subjective taste when you want credibility with decision makers. Clive also shares why anonymity and declaring other influencing factors strengthens the process, plus how long-term results can matter more than a short sales spike. We also zoom out into service design and the future of design leadership, including how AI may increase the need for design evidence, ambition, and customer-centred strategy. Key topics covered: - Proving design value through clear objectives and metrics - What makes a strong DBA effectiveness entry (and common pitfalls) - Service design, UX, and research as a combined force - AI, design intelligence, and earning a seat at the board table Resources: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Redesigning-Thinking-Service-Solving-Challenges/dp/3111392821 https://www.audible.co.uk/pd/Redesigning-Thinking-Audiobook/B0G6GM7NMQ Entering the DBA Design Effectiveness Awards? Good to know: DBA members get their first entry free, and it can’t be carried over to next year. Pay your entry fee by 23 October to save £100+VAT, even if you submit later. Entries close 1 Dec I’ve written DEA entries for 16 years, with a 95%+ win rate. Not sure if your project is a contender? Get a free verdict. Tell me about your project in a short form. Within 24 hours, I’ll send you a personal verdict covering: whether it’s a contender what evidence you’d need whether 1 December is realistic 👉 Submit your project: https://airtable.com/app8LMAyKzDMkh7mZ/pagvVTcsBugtWN7Eu/form Already have a strong contender in mind? If you know you’ve got a serious project, or you want to re-enter something that didn’t win last time, skip the form and book a quick call with me. 👉 Book a call: https://calendly.com/kaffeen/quick-collab-call Entering the DBA Design Effectiveness Awards? I’ve written DEA entries for 16 years, with a 95%+ win rate. Not sure your project is a contender? Tell me about it and get a free verdict Got a serious contender, or re-entering? Book a call
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Audio Only - All Participantshi, and welcome to the Authority Builder podcast. Today I'm joined by Clive Grinia. Clive is a designer, educator, and author. He has set up and led influential design teams for Barclays Bank, Cisco, Samsung, and Teleco- telecoms company Orange. That was my first mobile network, actually. a way back when. He started his career with innovation a- agency, consultancy rather, IDEO, in the US, and was co-founder and partner of design consultancy Tangerine, later joined by Apple and OpenAI Design Chief Sir Johnny Ive, who we all know.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsClive was head of service design at the RCA, and now advises and trains organizations in service, digital, and transformation design through his company now+next, and we'll put the link in the show notes, and ESTU Global. He works with US AI startup Primitive and is an advisor to Bosch, trustee of the Design and Technology Association, and, our focus today is around his role chairing the DBA Design Effectiveness Awards, and he is also a trustee of the RSA.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsHis book, and you know we're a big believer in writing books around here, Redesigning Thinking, was published in June 2025 and was nominated for American Best Book, Goody Business Book Awards, and the UK Business Book Awards, and is available in audio form on Audible, one of my favorite ways to, to access books. Creative Review placed Clive in their top 50 and described him as a passionate advocate for the transformational potential of design for some three decades. Today's focus on design's value and leading customer experience in the UK is in large part due to his work.
Audio Only - All Participantswhat a bio, Clive. I am Thank you so much for joining us. I was just saying o- off camera, I really need to rework my bio because that is just phenomenal. I feel like we could record about, an entire season of podcast episodes talking about- the different stages of your career and everyone you've worked with. I want a, a purely Johnny Ive episode, to be honest with you. But anyhow, like That's not what we're here for today. Thank you for joining us. Oh, no, great pleasure. thanks for hunting me down and getting me on. Thank you. as I mentioned, we're coming up to, Design Effectiveness Award- season, and a lot of my clients are, asking about whether they should enter, how they should enter, et cetera.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsAnd I... That's the focus of what I wanna talk about today. So I know you've seen design from every side. You've been- a designer, you've been client side design leader, running the world's leading design course, and now you're chair of judges. What first convinced you that design has to prove its value, not just claim it? Oh, great statement,'cause you're right. It does. I suppose, right from the very beginning, I started life as a physical product designer, and I- it occurred to me... first of all, it was obvious to me that people had lots of opinions about how things look, for example.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsOh, yeah. When you're designing a product, CEOs would come in and say, my partner's done a sketch." oh, really?" Oh, great. On the back of a napkin. Over cocktails. we think it should look like this." So you begin very early on in my career, and I think it's true for most designers, you begin to craft ways of counteracting that, and having sometimes what I call the science of design, having reasons. I remember doing my first two by two. Would you want it trendy or do you want it conservative? do you want it to look like a BMW or a Fiat? And everyone went,"Wow," And you start making better decisions that way.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsYeah. But also, you start understanding where the value really is and what they want to get out of this design. And I suppose what I'm really saying, it's all down to the brief and what is your metric for success? And the, the, the basic metric of just about every single thing, not everything, but most things I've ever been involved in the design of, is a business objective to be more successful, and that generally leads to, profit, more sales. but then when you use the word effectiveness, it can, as you go through your career, you realize that embraces a lot more metrics.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsSo for example, working at somewhere like Barclays Bank, raising net promoter score, raising customer satisfaction- Oh, yeah. -was really important. Yeah. Reducing complaints, massively important. they probably make money anyway, but making sure their customers actually liked- Yeah in fact, loved them- Yeah was the task, was the effective task we had to do. So it seemed very obvious to me that when I was a product designer, I was making things, making people feel good about buying it because it was beautiful or it was well designed, it was ergonomic, those kinds of things that design would make a better sale.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsMake sure- Yeah people would choose it above all others. When you get into digital design and service design, it gets a bit different, but still understanding your objective, understanding your metrics very early on before you even start designing, actually, is something I really believe in, so that you can always measure the value of your design against what you're trying to achieve, and then you can measure its effectiveness right away It's so interesting. Yesterday, I, I'm working with a client in Singapore at the moment on a, Design Effectiveness Award entry, and- I'd written the second draft, and then yesterday said,"Oh, we realize that we have a document with all the client's commercial objectives in it.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsIs that gonna be useful?" And then I reworked it this morning- Yeah basically. I was like,"This is an entirely different entry now." And of course, that is what the DBA are measuring against. That's what the judges are looking for. Yeah. Did it achieve and supersede the commercial objectives of- Yeah of the project at the beginning of the brief? I love the stories where Okay, I've had many conversations with a, with creative directors who say,"No, our clients want t- us to make them look prettier, look more beautiful." no, your clients wanna sell more.
Audio Only - All Participantsand like- trying to, you know- Productive can we all just get on the same page around that? Yeah. But of course, it doesn't always look like just selling more. I love when, I've worked on case studies where it's allowed a brand to expand into different territories, where it's allowed them to move into a much bigger premises. They've been able to hire more people and put more money back into the economy. They can measure the export value to the UK. there's so many things that are less tangible than just purely sales, and I love that the, the awards cover that off.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsAnd, yeah. And I just think that makes such a difference. so just then thinking about, what, in terms of why somebody should be interested in proving effectiveness, what does winning a Design Effectiveness Award or just doing an effectiveness study tell a client- Yeah that a creative award can't? that's a brilliant question. Again, thank you. I was just thinking as you were talking then, one of the great enemies of design is marketing and advertising. I've said that- Yeah a few times and got in trouble for it. But, it... You c- you can sell a crock of stuff by a lot of marketing, a lot of advertising, and the pain of that is it's almost immediate.
Audio Only - All Participantsyou can measure the impact of it. It's got a sort of unfair advantage. Yeah. Design takes a bit longer, And- Yeah but it's a much more long-lasting effect. Yeah. And if you get design right, you don't need marketing and, advertising to the same extent. You can really optimize that side of things. Design sells itself, because it's there to completely fulfill what the business and the customer need. Yeah. and, and the problem we have with, businesses is they're often very inwardly looking.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsThey're not looking at customers that much. They know they want more sales, so they just throw advertising in. What I love about effectiveness is, and the DBA Effectiveness Awards are the award, I'm, I believe- Yeah is that it really shows that incontrovertible evidence that it is down to design. And they bring these amazing judges in who absolutely don't care how beautiful something is or not, right? Yeah. It's completely off the table, that aspect- Yeah which other design competitions are all about.
Audio Only - All Participantspeople stroking their skin, chins, sorry, arguing about whether it's beautiful or not. it's purely about can you show that you redesigned something or designed something and design was the component that led to that overachievement- When this happens, and I actually funnily enough wrote an article about this just a few days ago for the DBA, you actually make the case. You bring the evidence to the discussion. You make a bit of history. When you enter this award, the DBA want every single person to win.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsYeah. And they will help you win. Yeah. They will help you remove the bullshit from your entry. Yeah. They will help you find the stuff that incontrovertibly proves that it's a design impact that has... sorry, has created that impact, a design action, if you like. And that, that becomes a historically important thing. I love looking at the archive of the design- Yeah, me too Association. And it's available, right? Because you can take it to your clients. You can look at the... Yeah. I take it to students and say,"Look," right? this is not..." And then you look at things that, are perhaps fast.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsYou repackage coffee or a whiskey bottle or something. It's really easy to see a boom. You- Yeah have something you invented and you tried to sell, and then you designed it and boom. these are great stories, and they're quite easy. But then you get the other more interesting and difficult ones like services, DBA getting banks, and libraries, and, third world, action, charitable, services. Yeah, really diverse range of stuff coming in and winning. Yeah. Because it doesn't matter what it is, you can prove it's been effect- if you can prove it's been effective.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsSo all you have to do, I think, is to look at your work and say,"Are we proud of it? Has it achieved for our clients what they needed and more?" And enter. And if you are honest and authentic about that, about- Yeah the provenance of your data, you're gonna get a brilliant dinner. actually, I don't know if they do the dinners anymore, but you're gonna get a good time. And you get something for your- I don't know what the format's this year, actually. No, I can't remember. But you get- Can't wait to find out you get the pride and the ability to say to your existing customers and your next clients,"Look what we did by design.
Audio Only - All Participantsdon't doubt it anymore. this is evidence. This is provenance of the impact of design." And that's why I love this award so much. The only frustrating thing is I don't get a say in it. I just have to chair it. I have to sort out the arguments and the different viewpoints- Ah and the different experiences. So it's... And I have, I have up here my gavel- that they gave me. I'm jealous of that. So when it get, when it gets really heavy, I say,"Okay, this is the decision." 12 every night. It works. yeah, there's a few points that you raised there which I think are really worth drawing attention to,'cause I think if it's, if you've not entered before or- Maybe you've not entered that frequently.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsThere are some things that people don't necessarily know. Like I, I was mentioning before we started, my background is majority FMCG brand and packaging design agencies. So of course, if you're entering, for example, Twinings Tea, three months of data versus, the same three months the year prior, it's still a huge volume because the amount of, tea we get through. But for example, I was speaking to somebody the other day about the, poppy, the, Remember Us poppy redesign- British Legion poppy, yeah yeah, which was a, a winner I believe last year or the year prior. I think it was, yeah. And, there's such a huge difference, firstly in terms of availability- and the volume of sales, and also in terms of the impact that has.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsLike what, you know- a, listed company's, shareholder profit versus the Royal British Legion and the, Interesting, isn't it? Yeah. So it's- Yeah fascinating just the, the breadth of, projects that can enter, but also the fact that as long... You can enter an old project. I don't know, I haven't double-checked the entry pack this year to see h- if there is a timeframe on it, but my understanding there's no end timeframe previously- No on how long a project has, since it was launched. As long as you've got some new results from within a specific period that's just note- noted in the entry pack, it's normally, the last six months or last year.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsI love that the longevity of really good design is rewarded because as you say, there are many disciplines of design where the best results come over time, right? It's about proving, it's about the maturity. It's about proving the lon- the value is the longevity. Yeah. It's not the fact that you have to redesign a year, 18 months from now. It's the fact that it's here to stay. I love that. Yeah. And I'd actually say the, some of the judges are quite keen that there is a length of data,'cause sometimes- you get a quick splash just'cause- Yeah something's different.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsAnd the judges like to see a little bit more of that longevity actually. So you know, you don't need to worry if it's, if it's over the 12-month period. I think- Yeah if it happened a very long time ago, then you'd have to, you'd have a job to show that it was still, going up at that same kind of rate. But- Yeah sometimes things like three months aren't quite enough data for judges to be entirely convinced that this is gonna get the Grand Prix or the Gold Prize or whatever it is. Yeah, no, ab- almost any, any, impact beyond what people were expecting, where- Yeah where they can quite clearly show design, you will get a mention.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsYou'll get a prize. Yeah. You get an award. and then you get those top three and then the Grand Prix, and that's where- the w- when the judging panel for the final Grand Prix is quite interesting actually,'cause it's different. It's proper CEOs. it's some really big hitters come in and say- Yeah we're really gonna kick the tires on this." So to win- Yeah the big prize is, again, it's that, the authenticity of that process means you can really be proud of that. But you can be proud of any level of the awards, I think. And it, because it's a collaborative thing between the client and the agent, I like that very much as well.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsIt's not just the agency saying,"Look how brilliant we are." Yeah. Oh, God. No. You- Client has to provide the data. Yeah. You don't have your client on board, it's almost impossible. Yeah, it's not gonna happen. yeah. Yeah. It has to be... I love the, that collaboration is noted, because we know the alchemy of that, the creative process only works if both sides are aligned. Yeah. it's- Yeah it's hugely important. Yeah your project's not gonna do as well if you're not working in tandem with your client, and that is effectively being rewarded as well. And, Yeah, absolutely and I, there's, a couple of other things I wanted to mention about that.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsI don't think a lot of people appreciate versus other awards that there is no limit on winners, and sometimes there are no gold winners. Sometimes there are no... like- That's true there's, the, it is, it's not like you're entering a done deal already. as you say, the DBA really want to reward design has been effective, and there are no, there are metrics around how that's measured, but there are no metrics around how many people are awarded. So it's important- No to know, I think. yeah, and I love the fact that the other influencing factors is a section that you must complete, noting the difference, noting the additional promotion, noting the additional- Yeah support that something might have received.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsBecause to me, it's frustrating sometimes when you're writing it, but to me it's so worthwhile because it eliminates subjectivity that is rife in the world of design. You said at the beginning, Something like looking pretty, looking aesthetically pleasing, that isn't, that, that's one aspect of design in some cases, but it m- by no means ends there. And I love that they, there is a way of a l- a listing, like separating that down, breaking it down into its parts so that the effectiveness can be fully judged. Yeah. of course a lot of the winners are supremely well designed.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsOf course they are. Yeah. but we're not letting that affect our judgment of the numbers of the data. Yeah. I think that's the important point, because fantastic, you can go and win all the other design awards for beautiful app, for beautiful what it, whatever it is, but we are only concerned with making that case to bus- business and other broader organizations about the true value of the impact- Yeah and the effectiveness. I like, I love that they own the word effectiveness. It's better than impact in a way. yeah. Completely. And you measure it however you want. There, a couple other things I was gonna mention.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsI c- I also like the fact that the agencies are anonymous. Yeah. So there's no kind of favoritism creeping in. No. you could argue that, if it's an in-house team, we probably do know it's an in-house team. I can't remember whether they, they know that or not. But it shouldn't really make a difference, of course. So you are, y- you really are paring everything down so you can be 100%. And you mentioned there about the end of the application, talking about mitigating, other factors rather. That is the bit where the judges spend most time. they, they need to see, and they are very good at probing and saying,"Hang on a minute.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsWhat's missing here? Are we missing some-" and that's why I make the plea to everybody, for goodness sake, enter. It's gonna be fantastic for you, and for goodness sake, don't massage those figures. Be 100% honest. if there is marketing and advertising, then you have to put it in, but explain why design is, is the big thing. The things that change the, Obviously, a massive advertising and marketing campaign means that it's probably that, certainly for the first part. But if you can prove you've got the sales after that, great.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsOr- if that marketing and advertising was at the same level in the year prior, right? Yeah. it's about proving that it is- That's good. Yeah. That's absolutely right. The- That's absolutely right. And the other thing is if you were in three stores and now you're in 300, it's- Yeah channel extension, or whatever it might be. Yeah. But- But again, I would challenge, if the ob- one of the commercial objectives was more listings or, like- Yeah moving from independence into- Fine major multiples, like, that is a- So say that. Say that. Yeah. you define the metrics, not- Yeah the D&B. So- Completely that's your brief, and you say you achieved it.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsGreat. That's what we wanna hear. It's that alignment that we're looking for, I think, or the judges are looking for, and I'm just trying to check that they're doing a good job. Yeah. Completely. And there's a couple of other things you didn't mention there. I'm just like, I- I promise I'm not being paid by the D&B in any way, shape, or form. And I don't believe you are as well, quite honestly. Me neither. But just, I just think it's really important'cause I do, I am very passionate about proving the effectiveness of design. 'Cause I think it's so empowering for agencies in order for them to, incredibly go after new business and feel proud about what they've achieved.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsBut what, there's a couple of other things. if you're a DBA member, I th- I don't know if everybody knows this, but you get a free entry. So you're only gonna let it- Yeah go to waste if you don't, if you don't use it. So DBA members, that is a call to action for you. but also- Okay. when I first started writing these entries like, oh gosh, like 2011, so 15 years ago- Okay at that time you had to design the entry in order to submit it, and this was- Yeah a big barrier to entry for a lot of- Yeah smaller agencies and, one man and his Mac kind of scenarios. and frankly, the agencies, the design agencies who were not graphic design agencies.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsI work with product design agencies who are like- Yeah. we need to off- outsource all the graphic design. We don't do that." that was a barrier to entry for some people. I love that now it's like- Go on it has to be an Arial. It has to be, like, maximum this point or minimum this point font size, and don't let your margins go any further than this, And it has to be like- 12 pages or less or whatever it is. It's like- Yeah it really levels the playing field, beyond, as you mentioned, taking out those agency names, restrictions around how you can identify who was involved, espe- Yeah especially in that first stage.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsI think these are all things that's really worth people knowing about. So you mentioned the judges there, and especially when it comes to the Grand Prix and, the really big hitters, the CEOs. Your judges on the panel commission design for a living, so how does effectiveness shape, effectiveness evidence shape the way they choose and keep an agency? What is your understanding of that? Yeah, so just worth just mentioning some of, the, the kind of people who are judges. Yeah. You're right, they are very often commissioners. They can be working for big brands, from car brands to perfume brands to, to drinks brands.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsW- uh, incred- and of course it's a quite a large number of judges on every session, so you really get a cross-section. And you'll have perhaps some founders, some entrepreneurs, and you'll have previous winners. Yeah. a terrific mix of people who all bring a little bit of different expertise to the, to the job of appraising that, that entry. And then, I... You're right. There, the real prize is that relationship, isn't it? And of course, because we don't know who's entering, we don't know whether that represents, a long-term.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsBut of course, when everything is revealed at the awards ceremony, ritual, whatever it's gonna be- the same names do come up, and the same clients come up, and that, that's a triumph, I think. yeah, I've spent a lot of my life as a consultant and you know that the value of the relationship you start building over time can just be so impactful, and you become part of the company, really. I've also spent half my life actually being inside companies.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsSo I've done, poacher turned gamekeeper quite a few times in life. And, Bo- both times it's because you want to have that long-term relationship. You want to feel you're able to influence those strategic decisions that, that sometimes can be detrimental to effectiveness- Yes without them realizing it. Yeah. I always describe des- any kind of designer as a, as zoomers. we're looking at the strategy or the policy, and then what does that do to the detail, and how do you represent that and turn that into something that does become effective? That is design- Yeah isn't it?
Audio Only - All ParticipantsYeah. it's not prettying it at the end. So I think... And that's also, you mentioned the, the way you enter and the application process has got better over the years. I think the, the spread of different kinds of organizations and what they do has got much broader, and more strategic. and I think that's where design needs to be right now. Less- I l- Yeah I love that a few years ago they took out the categories. Oh, yes. I was gonna- Which was a, was an interesting movement at the time- Yeah I think through quite a few of us. But I think it was needed and warranted, and it can be too constraining.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsThe whole, you know, definition of design is uncategorizable, right? It's about improving, through engineering- Yeah creativity, regardless of what, what output, or what category that falls into, what discipline, industry, format. So I love that was removed'cause I think it's removed some of the barriers to entry for people who don't feel like they're the typical design agency. That's right. That, I'm so glad you mentioned that because th- there's some things that you don't wanna change, and that has been a really important thing. And I think if you started having best packaging, best, I don't know, healthcare, campaign, you'd just be all over the place.
Audio Only - All Participantsno, I totally agree with you, and I think Deborah and the team at the DBA are very resolute about that. They are not gonna have categories, and it, that's what makes the judging so interesting. You are, you absolutely are judging apples and pears. Yeah. But you're judging the same impact of the apple and the pear. Yeah. And that, what you're judging is still identical and, that's the powerful, important bit. And it also allows people to understand what effectiveness means for all these different examples. So you instantly get a spread.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsIt's, we said at the beginning, it's a sort of historical record of business success through design in so many different ways because of that open category. And you don't have to search through packaging, you don't have to search through drink sprout. it's all there. Which I imagine, I never thought about... I love reading through the effectiveness case studies- the winner case studies, but probably because I'm a geek on that front. But I never thought about it before- I said, these are great examples to share with your students and influence- And I know that's not maybe the main objective of the people who are entering and putting money and effort and time behind this, but this idea that actually having removed those categories, they're then seeing case studies- Yeah on how design can impact- Yeah.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsYeah without any, yeah, without any kind of like genres around it, without any limitations- Yeah like forcing them to think more broadly, like a, an art foundation course, in, in terms of- yeah the many applications. And we know how clients are terribly bad at only measuring themselves against other people in their industry. Oh, my goodness. Yeah. this forces them... at the RCA, I was teaching students, and I would talk to them about the DBA. They had never heard of it, but n- it was really interesting. Now, Anya Klopper and I in Now Next, we teach businesses, and then with S2Global, we do apprenticeships with businesses.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsAnd it's mind-blowing for them when they see it, because it's not been in their remit perhaps. It's not been in their worldview, and they begin to see the power of what we're teaching- how it eventually, has the impact on their organizations, whatever it is. And there's, it's an incredibly powerful thing. We should probably talk to Deborah about making more of it, publishing a book or something. I don't know. Look, I'm always for publishing a book or so- Yeah something. Yeah. Yeah, I have a lot of thoughts and we've actually interviewed Deborah in the past- Oh, yeah on the podcast- Yeah a, a way back, actually. I think it was during COVID, but- yeah, always, I think...
Audio Only - All Participantsanyhow, that's a topic for another day, but people who are passionate about this area need to come together and put their brains together how we can make it go further. 'cause I think, if nothing else, it's such a huge export for the UK is design. we are, one of the foremost design- Yeah centers in the world and, if nothing else, like it's a, it's a very valuable, revenue-wise, industry for this country, and that is one of the reasons that- Yes we should be focusing on, growing it for everybody's benefit- Well- For business benefit- And- for consumer benefit, for on a national level.
Audio Only - All Participants100%. Can you tell I'm very passionate about this? Good. Good. and we, the Design Council just produced their latest, design economy report, which is, really incredible, showing the impact of design being greater than retail and hospitality. It's got a really interesting definition of design and- Slightly unfortunately non-designers, but what it means is design activity that's going on inside organizations rather than- Yeah the agencies and consultancies. And suddenly you see the impact of that. And it's great actually to see...
Audio Only - All Participantswhen I was at Tangerine with Jony Ive and Martin Derbyshire, we didn't have any UK clients after a while. We were all only working internationally, and it's probably why Jony Ive went off to California and had a much better time than the rest of us. Yeah. But- Yeah but it's actually really nice to see the impact of design on the UK now and the way the Design Council's going, and the DBA working very closely with the Design Council now, which is really great to see. I, I totally applaud what you're saying. I think the impact of design on UK businesses and organizations, so many of my graduates are now in the NHS, financial services.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsThe spread of- Yeah design both at a delivery craft level and in a strategy service level is incredibly impressive, though people aren't always that aware of it. no, and I'm learning all the time. And we share someone in common, who I'm working very closely with right now, and the fact that she de- she comes from a design background and the concept of service design and currently working- in a strategy role. But I'm like,"What? This isn't design as I know it. what the heck is this?" And I've had to educate myself this, I'm not saying- Of course the full bearer of design, but, this is a whole area of design that I didn't even know existed.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsI d- and isn't that funny how you can exist in this industry for that long and not know? so- It's, it's quite a new discipline, to be fair. Yeah. yeah. In these 12, 13, 14 years at the RCA. But I will hijack your podcast for this reason. Yeah, go for it. That very few of the graduates from service design at the Royal College of Art, in fact possibly none, work for design agencies. They work for management consultancies. Come on, designers. Get a... Get on board here. Yeah. Get some service designers in. They're gonna really help you sell your business and be much more strategic.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsOkay. Yeah. Ad banner. And it's But I- I think... Oh, gosh, I don't know. That I... This might be a rabbit warren its own right. But how many... Okay, let's take it this way. how many service design effectiveness award entries have you seen? Because- There are some Sorry, what's that? Sorry, there are some. There have been some There are some yeah Because I, I think this is what I couldn't understand when I was first understanding this definition of service design, and I do understand it's a relatively new discipline, but, is how, just how wide-ranging that is.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsAt what point you involve that person and really it's at the get-go. it is... And this is why perhaps it's known more as strategy, or in terms of how- what the output is- or what the, w- what you bill as on an invoice. It comes under strategy rather than service design. In some of the areas I've seen it, and I don't know if I'm misspeaking here, but, yeah, I think it's... But, more service design people need to enter, and then we'll- Yeah, no understand the value. 100% agree. I think the problem with service design is the impact is much less tangible than a whiskey bottle label.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsYeah. Yeah And it's much more spread. It's very holistic. But funny enough, Annie and I did a workshop yesterday with a well-known fashion brand, who, who were looking at, so what's UX, or what's service design, what's research? Mm-hmm. And actually bolting those together was a really meaningful activity. And I think the, the, the, the methods of service design and UX design, for example, are pretty much identical. They just have a slightly different canvas size. UX are obviously concerned with what's through the glass. Service designers are using the same techniques to look at the broader experience and touchpoints, and dig down into the system and try and get the system to work.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsAnd researchers are bringing us the data of, and bringing the CEO data of what's not working and what they should be doing. So it's the research, UX, and service design is incredibly powerful combination. And I- I do think the outcome of that, the effectiveness of it, is usually greater innovation. greater longevity of customer loyalty. fixing problems that are really hurting your business. those are the sort of metrics that you get from things like service design. But it is a much more collaborative thing and a bit more strategic, you're right.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsBut I think there's still a bit of, just not knowing each other. Like you say, people don't... And sometimes- Yeah craft side of design is at the forefront of agencies, for example. Yeah. they sometimes criticize service designers or make the comment rather, that service designers aren't so much about the craft. I'm not sure that's really true, actually. I think they're using exactly the same craft skills, just on a slightly more broader, in other parts of the experience. there's still a lot of crafting and beauty and simplicity and accessibility and inclusivity.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsEverything you might have, let's say, in a digital project. Yeah just And so many of those are measurable, of course. like- It- I don't know. When- When somebody says to me,"It's intangible, it's hard to prove," I'm like,"Give me it. Let me see it." I wanna- Give it. Like- Yeah. Yeah. So maybe, yeah, maybe I need to find somebody that I can do a- I remember a big bank, I just mentioned accessibility, inclusivity there. I mentioned a big, one of the big five banks came to the RCA and said they just realized 20% of the people couldn't use their app'cause they were neurodiverse. Yeah. But there was a massive business case yeah for sorting that one out, And they did, which was great.
Audio Only - All Participantsyeah. Also, not just for business reasons, but for- You know, legisla- ne... Oh, I can't say it. Legisla- fle- oh yes. Legislation Legal reasons. Legal reasons, yes. I can't say it today, apparently. I haven't had enough coffee. So there's, you, we touched on something there that I think is really, is really important to address, is when I've worked in brand and packaging design agencies in-house there, there was a lot of bitching about we don't have, People aren't valuing design enough.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsThey're using us too late, they're involving us too late, they're being led by, y- the bigger advertising campaign. and that isn't the way to address design. If we think about, how consumers make decisions at the point of purchase, then retrofitting an out-of-home campaign on a pack is not the way to do it. And there was a lot of bitterness about m- design not having a seat at the board table, and not getting enough, a, a big enough slice of the marketing budget pie, so to speak.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsSo what... I feel quite passionately about this. I'm interested in your take on where does proving effectiveness fit into design earning that seat at the board table? Yeah, that's interesting. the board table one has always been difficult. However, I went to... I've been to a few kind of design leadership things over the last few years- Yeah and noticed how the table gets bigger and bigger with here's the chief of, chief design officer of something, chief design officer. And 10 years ago, there were none of these people existed.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsSo I think they are getting there actually, and they all complain, say life's terrible, but they are there Yeah. and it's happening more and more, which is great. But I think the real answer to your question is that it's actually why I like service design. It's why I went into that, because you start talking about the whole experience. And when you talk- Yeah about the whole experience, you realize design is there in every single part of it. Whereas- Yeah and when you present, when you present the customer experience as a journey to any organization, it usually blows their mind. 'Cause they usually think it's just marketing over here, a bit of product or, you know, graphics or design here, and then after sales, customers, customer service will be after, That's such a horrible view of the world.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsWe all have something to give, but design is an orchestrating thing. It's a visualizing thing. If you have a strategy, it can visualize it for you to check it out, Is that really what you think you're gonna get? Unifies the company around visions. Of course, you design the actual product touch point, whatever it is, to be successful according to your business objectives, hence effectiveness, and you carry on. You build that relationship. what are you gonna do after you've sold something? How are you gonna build that ongoing brand connection for the rest of that customer's life?
Audio Only - All Participantsthat's- Yeah our real objective, isn't it? So- Yeah I think you're very right. I think the perception of design is a constant problem for everyone in design, to the point where some people try to stop using the word design. I don't agree with that. I really don't. I think design just needs to be explained and made much more important. The final thing I might say here- Which is a naked segue into the book I'm writing next Love it is that, I actually do believe, and I think I've got quite a lot of evidence for this, having worked with some... in the AI world for the last, a few months of this year quite intensely, and seen the kind of cultural change that happens as AI is integrated and takes away a lot of the processing and boring work that people have apparently been happy to do for most of their lives.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsI'm gonna... at Barclays, 99% were there to stop any innovation and just answer emails, frankly. But they don't have to do that anymore, maybe. Yeah. Yep. And I was- In this day quite triggered when, a, senior manager in a big organization that we were training through Now Next said to us,"Our business analysts are gonna have about 30 to 40% of their work taken away by AI. Could you please retrain them as service designers?" I thought,"Ooh, that's interesting." And I've seen that happen more and more, and I do think that design as a skill that everyone needs to know about- need to probably understand and even be more of a designer themselves in terms of problem-solving, allowing creativity to happen in organizations, and work with designers to come in and understand their much more strategic value.
Audio Only - All Participantsone of the great fears of AI is that basically everyone can be the same. AI will turn a small bank into the same as a big bank, Yeah. So how are you gonna differentiate? How are you gonna- Yeah talk to customers? How is your brand gonna be more than a logo? I think this is a really interesting opportunity for design. Yeah. And I know everyone's worrying about losing their jobs, but I think we have to be really proactive here and say, you don't have to worry about all that." stuff anymore. Let's start working with you on understanding your customers. Let's create some, some possible strategies to differentiate yourself from everyone who's the same.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsBut we have to be, we have to go out there and be proactive about that, I think. So that's where I am on design. I think it's gonna save the world. Good. Good. But we have to get in there- and explain this, hence me- thank- writing my book. Who wants to... no, very, that's, yeah, completely whet my appetite. but who wants to, that business leader, the CEO I think you mentioned, who had that initiative, when you said it was triggering, I thought,"Oh my goodness, what's, what has this person gonna have done?" But that is just such a wonderful- and human way of- viewing the possibility, right?
Audio Only - All ParticipantsI am completely obsessed with efficiency and fulfillment of potential, probably to an unhealthy level. so the fact that, people in positions of power are seeing the opportunity that, rather than just the cost savings that AI is going to bring is- Yeah is marvelous to hear. I, it was marvelous to hear that, and I think we're at a fork in the road. There are certainly some business leaders who think it's clever to fire 50% of their workforce. I think- it's not very clever, and wherever we've seen that hasn't always worked. It hasn't worked out ever, actually.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsYeah. But I think the idea... On the other hand, we're clearly gonna be through a transition. Clearly, people are gonna have to find new roles from the ones they did before. but I think there are absolutely, as you said, human capacity is there. and I was invited, actually, the reason I got into the book was that I was invited to, apply for a research grant, which I didn't get, but never mind. it, it put me on a good path- Yeah on what's the future of intelligence, human intelligence- Yeah if we have artificial intelligence.
Audio Only - All Participantslet's grasp that nettle. And I thought,"Wow, this is great." And somebody encouraged me to, to enter this and talk about design intelligence rather than artificial intelligence. I thought that, this is it, isn't it? Our ability to create, to consider, to understand future consequences by modeling scenarios and designing the future. We're really not very good at it. Sorry. There's lots of people who are good at it, but they're called designers. yeah. And we always struggle to get in upstream. yeah. So how c- so really this is our big challenge now. and that's why I called it design intelligence, because I think it's a massive part of human life that we've tended to avoid.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsYeah. Put off. 'Cause we've gotta go and monitor a process or yeah. Yeah, and you know- Optimize something. Yeah. and use brains, right? I know that sounds- Use brains, yeah it's, we will naturally find as humans the point of least re- lowest resistance, right? And if we're taking up our time with answering emails, as you said, then it becomes easy to tick off those easy checkboxes on a to-do list- Yeah and not do the harder but more rewarding thing. AI eliminating that is encouraging us to...
Audio Only - All ParticipantsYeah. It, it should do. I feel like it all fits that together, right? Like I- We need to paint that picture. Come on. But I think it does, I could say a very provocative thing, which would be in the age of AI we will all be designers, and designers will get upset about that. Oh, they already are. Trust me, I'm having a lot of those conversations. Yeah, but I don't mean, I don't mean that everyone's gonna stop using designers. In fact- Yeah I think the opposite of that. But I think we have to accept that there are, that people need to think about design, realize that when they make decisions they are designing. that was what my first book was about, Redesigning Thinking, was saying, you, normal person, you're actually being a designer, you just don't realize it.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsAnd you're making a bad decision. Yeah. So the, there is a Thinking more like a designer I think is or using the tools, for example, to map a journey and realize it's terrible- Yeah. Yeah I think has to be good for designers too. Absolutely. I really believe, and I'm not speaking about design here, but I think people who are scared about AI, I suspect they are, they've been enjoying coasting in whatever role they're in. And- the ones who love what they do, are really passionate about it, see the opportunity to spend more time pushing the boundaries of what they enjoy- Yeah and satiating their curiosity.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsAnd I, yeah, I just think that's a, a huge enabler, if you view it the right way. But it's hard not to get defensive, I understand, for people who feel like- Oh, of course. Of course their bread and butter, the, the stuff that literally pays to keep the lights on is now more easily, outsourced elsewhere and they have to have the energy to think and innovate beyond what their current product offering is- Yeah in order to stay viable. I think designers are actually in a positive position. I think our creativity and problem-solving will be our salvation.
Audio Only - All Participantsand, and it's great. I do s- see quite a lot of optimism in design, more than perhaps I might expect. there's loads of people pointing out how crap AI is- and using their design skills. So great, go for that. We are using AI in design a lot to help us get the more aware of customers faster and make better decisions, and then prototype things faster. Yeah. Our clients, our training clients are coming to Anu and myself now and saying things like,"AI has, is making so many mistakes.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsPeople are launching an AI prototype thinking it's the real thing.""And we're realizing we still need to go through the design process because it's hurting our business." bring it on. That's what I wanna hear, yeah. and that's the message- And also the self-reflection to realize that and know that you need to course-correct rather than double down on it. yeah. Perhaps we just have good clients, I don't know. but that we are talking to people who are thinking that way and getting that- Yeah it's not the panacea for everything, and they don't just stop using design. Very good to know. I'm conscious of time and being respectful of yours. and I was gonna come onto that topic which we about looking ahead, how is AI changing how design gets made, et cetera.
Audio Only - All Participantsbut do you, just on that note perhaps, does proving its effectiveness become more important or less in the world of AI, AI changing how design gets used? Oh, much more important I think, because we will... Be interesting to see this year and in future years whether we're seeing AI- And how it's being integrated into the business success of design. But I'm 100% confident that we're going to see more creativity from humans, more...
Audio Only - All Participantsfaster and more effective creativity enabled by AI. I've had some interesting quotes recently'cause I'm interviewing people- so many people for the book. But somebody in an insurance company said to me the other day, we're using AI to do stupid things," right? We could us- use AI to do much more important things, but there is no doubt that what will keep us alive will be our creativity, our imagination. That will be our domain, and AI will be swarmed around us, helping us achieve that and have impact with it.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsAnd I think that's right. I hope that's right. Mm. Yeah. I believe that's right. But- but it's up to us. We don't just give up. We've got to show our clients the level of creativ- creativity we can bring and why AI will never beat that. And AI is just a copycat, really. It either copycats- Yeah or hallucinates. Yeah. Yeah. yeah. I'd rather have a human hallucinating than AI. Absolutely. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. It's m- one of my favorite things at the moment is demonstrating how we can make our clients' marketing and new business processes more efficient using AI with the same output, and then saying,"This is what you should be doing with that spare time, with that spare money." Because it's not a,"Okay, that's it.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsFull stop. Move on. Do client work." It's like a,"Now think of the potential of what you're able to do with that space created." You remind me of something I've always said, that I said, that I think design, the real value of design is raising people's ambition. Pe- people naturally don't have much ambition. Yeah. They react to a competitor. "Oh, look what they've done. Quick." No. You can do better than that right now, So I think design envisions ambition, and it won't stop doing that, and AI will help us achieve that ambition, I hope.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsYeah. yeah. end of statement. It gives us something to live up to. Yeah, I went through a rebrand a couple of years ago now, which was a deeply uncomfortable process for me. But it, b- going, leveling up in terms of visual identity and the expression of that across lots of formats, and it being more... Yeah, just y- regardless of what you think about it, it w- it was a step up, and it was then uniform and consistent. And what that unlocked in me in terms of how I think about my business and what I will allow myself to hope and dream for, and my ambitions, did change.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsI think that it requires external objectivity of a design expert to look at a problem, provide a solution that requires you to step up and meet it, and grow your own kind of hopes, dreams, vision for your brand, for your business, whatever it is. yeah, it's like a str- I always think of it as like a stretching the stomach at Christmas kind of thing. You know when you eat so much, and then in January you're just, so much more hungry- yeah because you've, yeah, you've been eating such a volume of food. It's a bit like that, but on a business level.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsNever thought of that way, putting it there. And I don't mean greedy, I mean, it's a good thing, right? yeah. it's a, it- Yeah ambition- You can do more. Yeah. Yeah, you can do more. Yeah, you can always do more. It's the journey, it's not the destination, right? Yeah. so okay. I, finishing off, just one final question. If somebody has, somebody listening in has a project in mind right now that they want to, they think is a great effect in a s- study, what should they do before the 1st of December? Well- Deadline day, by the way. you're proud of your work and you know you've done something special for your client, you need to go and tell them straightaway you're gonna enter it, right?
Audio Only - All ParticipantsAnd there's gonna be glory and hallelujahs spread on you. you're gonna tell them it's free, you're gonna tell them there's a team there to help you get that, submission correct. Yeah. And that you have a really great chance. If you know in your heart that you have created something amazing, then for goodness sake, express it. For history, we need to record it, right? yeah. We need to make the case, especially in the age of AI, about the impact of design. There's no reason to hold back. There's no benefit in holding back. It- there's people there to help you.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsIt's free. Your relationship with your client will be improved whatever the outcome, right? Absolutely. And I think it's such a healthy thing to do. it, and it helps people articulate perhaps stuff that you've felt you've done but not said, and not measured more important- importantly, and not communicated to others. I think that whole process is such a positive process. And at the end of the day, you might get a prize. yeah, yeah. A honorable mention. You might win the whole thing.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsBut you'll just feel better about yourselves. Don't hold back. I, and on that note, I, the last... I think it's the, gonna be, when I publish this, the pod- podcast that came out, the episode that came out before this one. But I just did one about why it's not just about winning, what to do once you've won. What- Yeah how else that helps you. Good point. And I think it's really worth looking through,'cause there's a lot of awards where you think- Oh, w- we get a trophy, we get a nice meal, a bit of a piss up kind of thing, you know, team event, and the client might be happy. But then it's like, there's nothing else, whereas this is the beginning of that journey.
Audio Only - All Participantsand in that episode we talk about all the different ways that you can apply this and bring it to life in your business, with your clients, with your prospective clients, to make sure that you're putting it to use. There is never a downside to even if you don't win, the fact that you've pulled together that data, then even then use it, Like there is no- Yeah you, there is no situation where you can go pitch for a project, put a proposal together, include data and it not be more persuasive to the- Exactly decision-maker that's reading it, right? this is the thing that's gonna propel you forward.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsYeah and remove your fear of subjected judgment of your peers, and focus on the people who are paying you. Yeah. I think the final thing I'd add to that, actually- Yeah I forgot, of course, they have this fantastic conference now, the Effectiveness Conference. Yeah. When you become part of actually a network and a cohort of people who are- Yeah talking about that, I think that's tremendous as well, that they've taken it up a level. So yeah, but everything you've just said, completely agree. I think it's just such a good thing to do for your relationships with your clients. Absolutely. Clive, thank you so much for your time. So can you tell us just before we finish, when is the book coming out?
Audio Only - All Participantsyou know- Can you share a link or anything that we can pass on? please continue to buy Redesigning Thinking, which is We'll put the link in the show notes yeah. and that's gone really well, and I'm really grateful for that. In fact, this fashion brand yesterday, she said she had, done one course on blueprinting and then read my book, and she's now got a brilliant service design team, so it obviously works. Brilliant. The next book, Design, Design Intelligence, the deadline for me to write it is April. Okay. it's probably gonna I think the idea is we're gonna try and get it out for Christmas next year. Okay. Yeah. Okay, so way off, but I'm sure we'll be speaking to you before then.
Audio Only - All ParticipantsI wanna know about the book. meanwhile, it's being translated into Chinese, my first book. So if you wanna do a, episode in Chinese, we could try that. Oh, I will be using Google Translate to do that. That is not one of my skills. But yeah. Great. Clive, an absolute pleasure to have you today. Thank you so much. Thanks for asking me. Great to speak to you. Thank you.
Violet Lange, Harvard MBA and former management consultant, shares how she transitioned from executive coaching into love, dating and intimacy coaching, and what it really takes to build a credible, results-driven...
Wondering what entering the DBA Design Effectiveness Awards really takes? This episode breaks it down with real numbers and realistic time commitments, so you can decide without guesswork. Key topics covered 2027 entry...
Win Better Clients Using Effectiveness Awards Every autumn, Charlotte gets the same question: should you enter the DBA Design Effectiveness Awards, and what do you actually get out of it? The honest truth: if you win...
## Nadine Nethery Customer experience and retention strategist Nadine Nethery shares how she evolved from copywriting into connecting the full customer journey, so business owners stop chasing leads and start maximising...
Why do so many LinkedIn outreach campaigns fail even when the brief sounds “perfect”? This episode breaks down a surprising pattern found after building seven prospect lists for seven very different businesses, and...